A R GPI

0000 OOLV LAW ^{' o—O G}S P6PPC 2AV cesc, 3 ~Po 0100 SV S i stow /t We/f0 th 3~ e4s r7 n d4 ⁰²⁰⁰ v,>'t P r 4914 Au;* SIN' A4,ekeEv Y4 t_{ad O}c .._ .. ⁰³⁰⁰

r,q

r'e ~ (~aRl Jiro V~ y 4 ~a ~a ilAsJ G7'rtUc, S

Na wwE

0400 OP.S' or c-Co t tav A&4rA d-S a zo ^Cif' rOp 0500

oe)o k GS'

⁵

^~r Ik

C P's ~,, )c la" A 9~ ` 5' S. s

148° .13 . VS ~

(5)00 CRS F(x

^/.X

/,ZS - 9Z `-6 . .

s 47E

0d-( s 47E

,. ~~ i_ ' _- c..~,-~ s 47E

G~4fiJ 4

tie

~PA _ z a Z~ 2-12r 1Z~' 3~ 9 1 `3 I

Oltwl A1 c,: > (

_d,GQ

Fix 4-n

n

l ~' :?~; , i U ._ L',3° ; k - 7t _{1 ~ _}

c~6~ca 1d~/~c~ I CiCi --

~3'Z. ~~x ~(~' 72°`~~'~~- ~ 11 s 1~-g° ~f2 • `7th _ ---

C -10 t kA X, L 5e I_ S 5-'~ MLI- NIL- LA-) (U I)

LL-

n3c>o GPs V- I X 12f 2-S ' 01 5

~ 2~Sa 3'7 •• ~ Z ~

(..7X---~...•V~S:"7

51.1 6~~c.C.-"P2oPi'Ir~ Wuaa,2`il~,5in3

Qua( L~-u-~• t.~ •~i~ 5 .

1600 1600 1700 1800 1900 - 2000 2100 2200 2300 2400

z6a4cti•a 4--~

)x,29 hy-_

0700

0000. ~4• +

7~ . .

0900

2 ,

1000 _ q , 0 1100

1200

1300_ _%,Ojl dP 'IT c ~ k

1400

C.3. ~

O' p

c..

~Z ~-r-1

tag ct5~ - _1-200 j.

Time ,pjStanc~.:

LAMAS -~ Day ( Dated Q~} Zoe E

Passage from Passage to

TI .. a n g Dlst r c

DI j2

^Vccb

_'7-156

⁰¹⁰⁰ _-

IG4

- - 0200

0300

s 47E ₀₄₀₀

s 47E _

s E 0500

0600 0700 0800 0900 ---

1000 -- -

- '. ^~'.a; F ~+

_r/~ at :~: f.r ✓ G ,

— — ... 1100

--- 1200

300

G ~~C`Y1 t 1X CtY=` 1© ~t C31 l~. p `~~ 1500

1600 _

Gtr ( 1700

Sn.~ 4~~~' SAS ' 12~a ~~+ C37:7,~ 1800 --- -

1900

~ ~ ~ r ~ w..~ „~•~ ~ s, .`a 02, 2000

-V)AC... C 1 2100 _.

2200

v 2300

2400 ILL

PraOre ssiue igtal

L Vr,~rr A09A'A

s 47E.. Tfine/

it e

5j Lon d ; From

47~

^{s 47E}

(OI bore i-r, ^{9f -7y✓t}^- f v R o PYrd 1~la"lA+C 200{2), s 47E --

19 r 2,1

Contains deletions under FOI

Day Date Zon t

Passage to

~Tirne

n J

— ---- ` ¢~..i' ( I tJ

417

1

^€mot~

-WOMI

D Wt-4M

CFQ T' 2' AYN" t)

I.' Ste• q'f(.S NT2 "S1 -7+2f-.

l•~~G7 ~~aNW ti~ N~ ~"~ rasa ea~'~1+~.~1 _

a~® WK" he

v..t ~7

Q S Nip .~a►tia~_9.2 Q- --

^---

-

s 47E

eo i1

anv

ISO

₍. _..~i~~f T S airAc>N VO'•A rw +

1 8 "'?7 1 c- ,2'33. X40

_GP _ k- r-ps _Fr

52 • gc 12_ 3c4. Z t `i e ^z

Ul-F -

^{s 47E}

tdoo

170(9 1$45

0100

Lafilutle ; ~;oCi9ltuda~.

`Previous #04c.;

Prbg resslve:to#ai `~.

HMAS

Passage from S

0200 0300 0400 0500 0600 0700 0800 0900 1000 1100 1200 1300 1400 1500 1600 _1700_

1800 1900 2000 2100

2200,

2300 2400 -

0 oa(z}

12 33.7.►5 072•~i~b

`1Ccc ~~j 662 ~ AK=Q

r-1111:

U11 Ic

Contains deletions under FOI

HMAS

041

⁽^, 1 ON&Oi ~ ^Day

Date

1 7 1-AM _'l i

^Zone

1~ I~~

Passage from Passage to

.m` .:.:,':.::.ti.::: ::•..:, :.:;r::..; ,. •.i

is p

YY. :4: :. m~

0100

,.. o _.4ⁿⁿ Distance:

'.:run'.

?•4.rvs'47E gmcA ~6Si 0200

47Er 0300

0400 0500 0600

_... :a;. .. t`rl $1 ltyi

1~1; 6700

-U01'.1-. 0800 ^—

- -I

b m `: w-i l):.1 wf') i N —(J-11W) . s t Ft' 1 M b(,- .._.. t~`~"_ . ` 1.~ ►~"1~1.t_ `(.F'r4•~.._l.Lt~i.~lC:l}kJt.

OC.{,lt`!C+ ~j.a. t~2._~.~v-...~.~r~.._._..__

1000

1100

0500.--

1200

- -- - ~ A 3`)+.3E,

1300.--

1400

1600 _..

-= --

r 1600 - -

1700

?~ lS .. ~►t~ f Si'~r~ <-~ t ...3r~ _ ': ~i'{~ iii ~,~'

1800...

--190Q.._ _.._

',1 1111--..~.,~~---. Il ?t•1~ - -- 2000 I .

-3- ----s 47E --2100

2200 --

2900 2400

"' zTofal

`'`'`' ~ Previous,aotal,

;: Progreselve total:

[at(tude Ungitude`=

~0001(Z)

moo(Z) .`

_ 1200(2) "

4•

'asp*k

1.2000).

Date

A - S

Day Passage to

Zone

l Vf

L

^ql^'1~~

Passage from WAS

~► J .,

~__l~►`~.~ ~..1~L _.C?a t~•'~ tN>;~ {'fin-~i 6_~t~-- i)~_lC,d~.f~~t'a

..Gf0ITt~N u9r•.;' 1?J11_Ei.

N1V1G~1?.~J 11~..1t; _i_qt7.f'~fi

j.L„UlNt~'~ ~~itj~

'^~?t'•.t_~Ftt £ ? i.~d~

i.. tAfw 462 \SO

~Ob"! ~.~!(1..q C4R.R~t'"~1 ~ t''+~► J~G;Kr ----

Mrs-~NSt'T

¹¹⁰⁰

1200 0400

0600 0700 0800 0900

1300 1400

oat CxFu 3:.

¹⁵⁰⁰

14O (s_'-vn!oe- E. ks

¹⁶⁰⁰

1700 _c.a rt kP ~ (q ~ ; . i rk ~ s ~ `"~ 1800 1900 t tf 11?Ml N ^fi ! =' "fir lcc „•a~t~ e ~~ ²⁰⁰⁰

6,6 I CJ 2100

2200 2300 t~l4~ ~ fr `ice (~c t 2"'~ l• `a~FS._ 1 ~°~~~ (1

C'J-- i~ .vts ~ ~~•~,'L 3oa~t~?~F4~(~.-1„wttJC} ~j~

s 47E

__...

s 47E

2400

Pogresslve

trtaJr

s 47E

ilk)

019

^{cn A}

F?w i --

'P. IN, A1 ,70

5~

11t' . 17~~f~tz~:t~~.%i /tt% iv

✓ c),# e , ,r` t

wov,4 A7 at`?

ybt _{. l.•}

~~It~

1 w —

11.14

,19 LAMAS

Passage From

Day

IMORWR4 Passage to

Date

N AW 20/3

^{Zone t}

/4 /2c/q 6-5

0100

IfT) (D A410 vt5 ,

0200 0300 0400 0500 0600 0700 0800

~liG~n -F/11. GPs' l j'z~?,

an. ,$ S

lz.s-"

^{-q~) .}

(-M

c. - f^7G~' tt1,? ;. r1C., r•~R" t t~1.1_r ,~. ~ ~tZ:. -- c^`,t 7 ~ ~'JG III ;;f•! L~~e~,._~s_ _~,~' D7r _Z1al; _ >t VIS ^1U81'E ^dil'JU~

0 090 - - n-746_._._ .~Tfl,2rGr~ lH IN_6 ~Ear~~ tcyAfi ~~'c 1000

L•:'j i~: ,~4 Y,r~~Jli'✓";ri~t'L":.r. _'•'~°i~~ .."'~~'..~'r#~!•''r is .rises i~lt3~B a ~f~, F'^`:?~'rr• 1100

< ri 1200

OR5

0 r1?t CPS ^{1 ° ga}^{e7 5} h?~`'Er~l, ~ISg~'._ 1300 s 47E

s 47E

%t<?Cil`)_1

vsrr, e C~~ c,cn:E I _cif ~ ~t 2 tN A&YA

.

^r4 _t_t

- S kS

C? Z 'y t. s. ribs

mot

Fly

^c,

C~ a ,:®

~Se

Z-9--j

)

^fo '33

Iti+r.vR4 t l +c, s S th : V's" ~ . U""&%, C~ >:,ff . t ,~ . _ _ i~Ssc.2€ IE~tI•llpsrl~2r..~~4~r Ic.?~^'~~'~ ~\'`~~. ~Ft f~~`~~

or)w

9

^{s 47E}

1400 1600 1600 1700 1800 1900 2000

2400 2100 2200 2300

tCa®

s 47E

1~oa(z~

oso.(zy

'beat

?ostign;'

t~~' ~tL•5tt;

.Longitude. {

*066 tote[::

rogressivg:tatoi:'

°Time! LatiEUde

HMAS

CHTtbCt~-

day

-f /-/OR

^pate ^Zone

Passage from Passage to

y: :e.

T : i•• . ~.';:~,:.'•

v Tim to

~v-iv c7 Y afar. P.s~ ,~.0 ...~L~~'idr~!...~' _...

0200..

0600 0400 0500 0600 0700 0800

---... ~n

--- _

._ _.. _... ...._.._ ...y _... 0900 I

~ . ~. 3 • ~~~ s ^loon

1100 I .

M C, /9 ~, ! ~ ~ ~ ~ , ~ .~ ~ ~ ¹²⁰⁰ ⁱ

42.~ J ~{. .C.r

1300 1400 1500 1600 1700 lsoo _ 1900

2000 _

2100 --

S 47E

s 47E 22 00

2300 2400

~- LIZ s 47E

61 12

~zz

- — 006 f'rQvious fot L

i°•f.•r1f, 1)0IV 1If7 rr•k , C I\- 1 fJif ' E~~ aA1~.:t~. C~ .~ ;. ...:.::...:~...,-

15V

3'06~ _ iQQO.jZ)i

_ t~/sr•'4 i.~-r~~7' ~~ l ~ ' ~ '+•':~6Q,0(Z) °. 1 ~;`` tf (7`(i 7-

MO

A /cam AI5T ^.19 4'.7:.₁_n:_'_')'>₍:_~: :; _

-~.::_••

~~,

I'll

_{s 47E}

—,,In-AA

s 47E

---s 47E s 41t --- ---

I qID 19 6A4 r--314-

Contains deletions under FOI

HMAS Day Date done

Passage to

Passage front

OO.w

1 t~

isiancs ;

rail

! s 47F=

_ 1100

1200

P-'4

DMI& 1300

? u 2s«_ _.. .

0200 0300

A/ ICJ o z's S

1.

T--Ix P.^hr^.^— Fa, 4-T . 4.S.Y`r1k.

i`4r _ C _~-" o

_ ^.0800_{0900 .--} :ir'~ 1 ~-,, "! 34.-7 1000

~- 1 5

^{0400 —}

0 0500

0000 0700

1- 7

CO ^CE~% 005

1 P-1 68

V:Ut)a 44e~ . r.`'Cy-VE

1400

1-701 .10 vNOis

1' (oB

^c3

;

5 ~ 1 'eut a _f' 1600 1700

~~)~ _ ..._

1800

C-Ioav,~.V 1x S 1 ¹⁹⁰⁰

2000 2100

``ICJ

}~' i" f 2200

2300

" z`; ~~ i (• 2400

1500

t` , mil"

.f. t.~j ~..._. ~~.l,~SA 1 "9""_~' , _ft's } ^~~Y'}~! .~M~ric..11,~1r~ •_

;Preytous,tot~t'

±Pro~ressye~;totial..'

;Longitude°;:

PV i 12

541t

.. _. l,:P.~_:.p~ ~1

p~~~ /(, °. ~~ —LL~~_ ~r '~ _~~G / ,t' ~~✓ r~Y'Z~ ~ljU~1,~G S ~_

V(9 Y.1) .1~q.

1 qra

CAL

s

Plotting Coordinates of HMAS Childers Method

The documentation of coordinates in the log book from HMAS Childers was written In 'Degrees, Minutes and Seconds' form. I had to convert this to 'Decimal Degrees' in order to plot the location of HMAS Childers with the use of certain Internet software.

The software was based on Google Maps, with the following add-ons:

* http://netvicious.com/gps/, to convert locations from 'Degrees, Minutes and Seconds' to 'Decimal Degrees'

* http://www.darrinward.com/lat-long/, to plot the coordinates.

Conversion of coordinate samples from 'Degrees, Minutes and Seconds'to'Decimal Degrees' Coordinates were regularly recorded, including during periods of little movement. I Identified a selection of coordinates that would demonstrate the vicinity of HMAS Childers for a period before, during and after the interception of SIEV Lambeth. My reference is written on a copy of the log book pages.

Time Log Coordinates Watts Ref

Decimal Coordinates 17 April

0300 S12 25 01, E128 3712 4 -12.416944444444444, 128.62 0400 S12 28 212, E128 33 999 5 -12.4702, 128.56665

0620 S12 33 834, E128 27 281 10 -12.5639,128.45468333333332 0714 512 33 693, E128 26 756 13 -12.56155, 128.44593333333333

0930 S12 29 521, E128 29 503 16 -12.492016666666666,128.49171666666666 1200 S12 34 358, E128 31639 19 -12.572633333333334,128.52731666666668 1500 S12 33 582, E128 31983 23 -12.5597,128.53305

1900 S12 32 828, E128 35 401 27 -12.547133333333333, 128.59001666666666 18 April

0001 S12 32 3, E128 38 6 32 -12.534166666666665, 128.635 0700 S12 30156, E128 40 072 39 -12.5026, 128.66786666666667 1119 S12 31151, E128 41850 44 -12.519183333333334, 128.6975

1130 S12 29 809, E128 46 550 45 -12.496816666666667, 128.77583333333334 1200 S12 28 406, E128 58 353 46 -12.473433333333332,128.97255

1230 S12 26 960, E129 11456 47 -12.449333333333333,129.19093333333333 1300 512 25 418, E129 24 366 48 -12.423633333333333, 129.4061

1330 S12 23 922, E129 37 224 49 -12.3987,129.6204

1400 S12 22 221, E129 51748 50 -12.37035, 129.86246666666668

1500 S12 19 498, E130 15 062 51 -12.324966666666666, 130.25103333333334 1515 S12 19 091, E130 20 040 52 -12.318183333333333, 130.334

After this point, HMAS Childers reached the vicinity of Darwin.

Page 1 of 3

Location of Ashmore Reef

Ashmore Reef is located due south of Pulau Rote, at -12.2404778123.0417056 (marked on the below map).

Ashmore Reef was one of several 'excised offshore places' regularly visited by Australian

Government vessels, resulting in certain Illegal Maritime Arrivals being considered 'offshore entry persons'.

Page 2 of 3

Location of HMAS Childers

The abbreviated plotting of the location of HMAS Childers is shown on the below map. It is nowhere near Ashmore Reef (which can be seen as the slightly lighter blue, due south of Pulau Rote).

HMAS Childers was on the open sea and according to the log book, for the time period considered, did not visit any location other than Darwin.

Conclusion

HMAS Childers did not travel to Ashmore Reef, or any other 'excised offshore place', over the course of 17 —18 April 2013.

s 47E

Manager, External Accountability Section

Risk and Assurance Branch

I

Integrity, Security and Assurance Division Corporate Group

11 April 2016

Page 3 of 3

From:

Cc:

subject;

Data:

Attachments:

s 47E

Eiza.e 11 .0 esor; iatban Ca ieron External Accountability; s 47E

Roberts

Lambeth and S 47F- Email 2 of 3 [SEC=UNCLASSIFIED]

Tuesday, 19 April 2016 2:01:52 PM

Darwin Boat Arrivals 13-08-2012 to 20-05-13 (Arrlvao,docx Darwin Boat Arrivals 13-08-2012 to 20-05-13 (ArrivaD.Ddf Darwin Boat Arrivals 13-08-2012 to 20-05-13 (Interceatio ),docK parwln Boat Arrivals 13-08-2012 to 20-05-13 (Intercentlon),pdt tMB012 Detention Notice.pdf

LMB075 Detention Notice.pdf

SIEV Lambeth - DIBP Response -16-00014 (2015-101553),do"

Immloration Ombudsman; Christopher

UNCLASSIFIED Good afternoon,

Please note the attached documents in support of questions asked in January 2016 regarding SIBV Lambeth (DIBP Reference: OHR-16-00014; 00 Reference: 2015-101553). Happyto discuss.

Regards,

s 47E

Accountability Section

Risk and Assurance Branch I Integrity, Security and Assurance Division Corporate Group

De.artment of Immi.ration and Border Protection Ms47E

UNCLASSIFIED

Important Notice: The content of this email is intended only for use by the individual or entity to whom it is addressed. If you have received this email by mistake, please advise the sender and delete the message and attachments immediately. This email, including attachments, may contain confidential, sensitive, legally privileged and/or copyright information,

Any review, retransmission, dissemination or other use of this information by persons or entities other than the intended recipient is prohibited. DIBP respects your privacy and has obligations under the Privacy Act 1988.

Unsolicited commercial emails MUST NOT be sent to the originator of this ernail.

Australian

Dalam dokumen Contains deletions under FOI (Halaman 95-107)

r,q

Na wwE

oe)o k GS'

~r Ik

C P's ~,, )c la" A 9~ ` 5' S. s

(5)00 CRS F(x

/,ZS - 9Z `-6 . .

0d-( s 47E

G~4fiJ 4

~PA _ z a Z~ 2-12r 1Z~' 3~ 9 1 `3 I

Oltwl A1 c,: > (

Fix 4-n

n

l ~' :?~; , i U ._ L',3° ; k - 7t 1 ~ _

C -10 t kA X, L 5e I_ S 5-'~ MLI- NIL- LA-) (U I)

LL-

51.1 6~~c.C.-"P2oPi'Ir~ Wuaa,2`il~,5in3

Qua( L~-u-~• t.~ •~i~ 5 .

2 ,

~Z ~-r-1

DI j2

'7-156

_r/~ at :~: f.r ✓ G ,

47~

Contains deletions under FOI

417

1

-WOMI

CFQ T' 2' AYN" t)

I.' Ste• q'f(.S NT2 "S1 -7+2f-.

v..t ~7

Q S Nip .~a►tia~_9.2 Q- --

-

ISO

1 8 "'?7 1 c- ,2'33. X40

_GP _ k- r-ps _Fr

Ul-F -

tdoo

0 oa(z}

U11 Ic

Contains deletions under FOI

041

1 7 1-AM 'l i

1~ I~~

'asp*k

Date

A - S

L

~__l~►`~.~ ~..1~L~~ _.C?a~~ t~•'~ tN>;~ {'fin-~i 6_~t~-- i)~_lC,d~.f~~t'a

j.~~L„Ul~~Nt~'~ ~~itj~

~Ob"! ~.~!(1..q C4R.R~t'"~1 ~~~ t''+~~~► J~G;Kr ----

Mrs-~NSt'T

oat CxFu 3:.

14O (s_'-vn!oe- E. ks

6,6 I CJ 2100

C'J-- i~~~ ~~ .vts ~ ~~•~,'L 3oa~t~?~F4~(~.-1„wttJC} ~j~

s 47E

Pogresslve

trtaJr

019

F?w i --

5~

✓ c),# e , ,r` t

ybt . l.•

~~It~

11.14

N AW 20/3

lz.s-"

(-M

OR5

.

- S kS

mot

Fly

C~ a ,:®

Z-9--j

fo '33

9

1~oa(z~

^~r Ik

l ~' :?~; , i U ._ L',3° ; k - 7t _{1 ~ _}

_'7-156

1 7 1-AM _'l i

~__l~►`~.~ ~..1~L _.C?a t~•'~ tN>;~ {'fin-~i 6_~t~-- i)~_lC,d~.f~~t'a

j.L„UlNt~'~ ~~itj~

~Ob"! ~.~!(1..q C4R.R~t'"~1 ~ t''+~► J~G;Kr ----

C'J-- i~ .vts ~ ~~•~,'L 3oa~t~?~F4~(~.-1„wttJC} ~j~

ybt _{. l.•}

^fo '33