From the
clinical
standpoint, the spontaneousabortions mey be <livicled
irrto
two broad divisions:(1) r^rhere pathol-ogicaL changes indicate
the futility
of any therapeutic measures; and(2)
where investlgations,early
antonataL care and therapy may increase the chancesof
pregrlancy progressingto
termin
a proportionof
cases.The following specimens may be included
ln
thefirst division:
defective ova and trophoblast (159),stricture of
the cord(2), foetal
pathology(1)
andchorionic vascular dlsease (23), making
a
total"of
185ebortions, an incidence
of
44.4 per centof the
4L7spontaneous abortlons
ln
the presentseries.
Hertigand Llvingstone (1944) analysed 1000 spocimons
of
abortioninto
two categories, nameLy dueto
ovular factors arid naternalfactors,
and foundthat
6L.7 per cent boLongedto
the former category where no therapy could have saLvageclthe
abortions.
They inclucled specimensof vilLi
on1y,enpty chorionic sac regardless
of its
being ruptured, placenta circumvallata and Breuss molein
the group ofovular
fact,ors.
Such specimens do not necossarlly lndicate an al¡normal.ityof
the ovumor
trophobLast accordlng tothe
criteria
usedin
tire presentstutty.
Colvinot
a,1,(1950) found
tirat
72,2 per centof their
440 abortionsrepresented the so-called blighted ova, excluding malforned
foetuses. Clinicallyn
a blighted ovunslgnlfles
thatno treatnent couLd have saved the pregnancy and honce
thls
groupis
anaLogousto
tirefirst division of
spontaneousabortions suggested
above.
The high incidence ofblighted ova
in
the seriesof
Colvlnet aL.
(1950) isaccounted
for
by the iLL-deffnedcriteria
they used fromMallf
s
(1917) classification.
Sirní1arLy, Iluberet
aL.(1957) discovered 68 abnornaL foetuses, includ.ing nine macerated ones, amongst 90
lntact or
cornplete specinensout
of
atotal of
3L4abortions.
They concl-uded that an abnormal foetus was presentin
more than oneiralf
of patf-ents whoaborted.
This conclusionis
iL1-founded because1t
relates onlyto ti¡e
90lntact or
completespecinens, and does
not
takeinto
consideration theronaining
abortions.
The inclusio¡rof
nacerated foetuses amongst the abnormaLis
alsoincorrect.
The flndings of tho present series arein
disagreementwith
those ofHertig and Livingstone (1944), Colvln
et al.
(1950)and Huber e.t
al.
(1957), and emphasl'ze the necesslty of acareful
ovaluationof
the pathological- changes.The renaining about 5ó per cent
of
spontaneousabortions
ln
the present series belongto
the seconddivision.
The foetus was norrnalin aLl
cases wherepresent and the placenta
did
not denonstrate any abnornality145.
of
development.rt is
tirerefore beliovedthat
oarly antenatal care, and sonetinres pre-conceptional.investigations and treatnrent, may increase the chances
of
a successful pregnancyin
sonreof
these cases.There were 677
uterine
abortionsin
the present series andin
673 cases the maternal age was known(Table
16).
The average ageof
the ¡nother vras 27.7 yeersin
these 673cases. rn
41s spontaneous abortfon casostlre maternal age ìías known aud the average age Ì{as
27.6
years.
Tire iucidenceof
the causesof
sponteneousabortion
in
women under 27 yearsof
ageis
compared withthat ín
women who were 27 yearsof
ageor
overat
thetine of
abortion (TabLeL7),
Althougtr there appears to bca
trencl towards e higirer incidenceof
defoctive ove and trophoblast, chorioriic vascular disease and atypicalendornetriun
in
wo¡ne¡r under zT yeats, the differenco in the trvo age groupsis not statisti
caLLysignificant
at 5 per centLevol". Also,
tire differencei¡r
the incidenceof
place¡rtal. pathology iretlveen tl¡e two age groupsis
notsignificant at
5 per ceutlevel. rt is
therefore concLuéed.that
naternal age doesnot
influence the ceuse ofspontaneous at¡ortion.
The cause
of
abortion was discoveredin
52.1 per centof the
7L4 specimens 1n the present series whereuterine abortlon was diagnosed
clinlcally
(Table xg).Adequate specfunens were received
in
72.4 per cent ofceses,
of
which overtwo-thirds
(72 per cent) demonstrateda cause, thus confirning
that
the chancesof finding
aceuso
of
abortion are higherif
the specinenis
adequate.Anongst the specirnens where a pathological c&use I{Bs found,
it
was locatedin the
foetusin
29.8 percent,
in the cordin
3.8 percent, in
the placentaiu
59.6 per cent endln
the endonetriurnin
6,8 per cent (Table 19).The placenta
is
therefore the nost important organin
anabortion specinen
for
Locating a pathologfcal cause.An Ínteresting coj.ncidence
in
Tables 18 and 19 nay be poiuted outhere. 0f
the totaL specirnens of uterine abortions, irreluding rphantonr, 72 per cent were adequatefor
diagnostlc purposesof
whicir,in
72 per cent, a causeof
abortion ruas detected, andof
these, in72 per cent
it
was based on pathologicalfirtdings.
Ineffec,t,
a pathological sause was found ir:, only 37.3
per centof the
totaL uterine abortions including tpltantomr,thus enpiiasLzing once agairr
the
importanceof
aclinico-
pethological approach
to this
probl.en.L47,
ì
CHAPTER VII
CONCTUSIONS
The findings
of
the present study allow thefollowing conclusions :
(1)
A cl.assificationof
abortion specimens which isbasçd on abnormalitios
of
the foetus alone ig inconplete, sinco changesin
other portions of the gestatlon products can be responsiblefor
abortion, and these abnonnal.ities aro found norefroquently
in
the placenta thanin
the foetus.(Z)
Since abortionís
a conplex process,it is
probably notJustifíeble to classify
abortion specimens &sduo
to
ovular factors and maternal factors.(5) In
viewof
the above, a newclassification is
prcsented,which takes
into
açcount pathological changes in every abortion specinen as a whole.(4)
On tl¡c baslsof this classification,
defectlvo ovaand trophoblast constitutes the nost lnportent slngle
entity
sccountingfor
58.1 per centof
the spontancous abortion specinensín
the present study.There were 159 specinens
of
dofectivo ova and tropho-blast, of
whlch 88 were obtainedfron
women under 27 yearsof
age end 7Lfron
rfromen aged 27 years and over.,(s)
(6)
(7)
(8)
(e)
(10)
(11)
(12)
(15)
(11)
Chorionlc vascular dicease and
etypical
ondometriunare often associated
with
dofcctlve ova end.trophoblest.
Vascular disturbances probably pley e
signiflcant role ln
the csusationof
abortlon as n¡nLfested byplacental
infarctlon
and haenorrhage, cord pathology and chorionic vascular dlsease.Plecent,a1
ínsufficloncy,
whichls
char¡cterized byspeclfic
chengosin
theviLlt,
can occur durlngearly prognancy end
rcsult fn
abortion,Pathological. changes
in
the u¡nbil.ic,rl cord form adistinct
sauseof
abortlon when therois
evidonceof
obstructionof
cord circuLation.A comnon
finding in
abort,ions dueto
eccldont endtrauma
ls
placentalinfErctlon
and heenorrhsge.Approxlnetely 44 per cent
of alL thc
apontaneoutabortions
in this
scrlos hedlrreverslblo
changcswhich could not havé beon corrected by t,herapy.
Maternel age
did not
fnfluence the pat,hological sauseof
abortion.The averagc naternal ege
in a1l
casc!¡of
utcrineabortions was 27.7 years.
Inadoquete spcclnens end ldlopathlc abortLon¡ accounted
for
over 40 per centof
the uterlne abortlon spccinens.A pathoLoglcal cause was found
ln
37 per centof all
1.49.
the
clinlcally
suspecteduterine
abortLons, but reached SZ per cent when edequato materlsl wesavalleble
for
study, thuslndicating
thedtfflculties In
deterninlng the exect çauseof
abortlonin
alarge nr¡nber
of
çases.BIBtIOGR.A.PHY
ADAIR,
F. L.
(1944)|
Introductory remerksto
secondsostion.
Conference on Problcmsof
AbortLon.The Abortlon
Problen.
WlLlians and Wilkins Co., Bal.tlnore, p.
58 .rA HELPER OF NATURE' (1879)
Brit.
mcd.J.,
1:ALTMAN,
P. L,
and DITTMBR, D.S, (19ó2):
Growth, including reproduction and norphological dcvelopnent.Fcd.
of
Aner. Soc.for
BxperLmcntal Bl.o1.,Washlngton,
D.C.
Characterlzattonof
devclop-nontal
stages:
M8n.p.
273.ARIAS-STELLA,
J. (1954):
Atyplcal endonetrlel changosacsocieted
with
tho presenceof
chorlonic tLssue.Areh,
Path.,
58: Lt2-L28.AZZOPARDI,
J.
G. and ZAYID,I. (1967):
Synthetlcprogestogen-oostrogon thcrepy and uterine changes.
J. clin.
Path.,
20t 7lL-Í38.BABBAGB, N.
F. (1965):
An epldcnlcof nl¡carrlage
inhumans
porrlbly
ceuscd by Toxoplasma gondll.Med.
J. Aust., 2:
485'488.BAIIAI{TYNE,
J.
If.
(1902)¡
Manualof
Antenatal PathoLogy andHygisne:
TheFoetus. Wllllen
Green andSons, Edl,n.
BALIANTINB,
J.
W. (1904):end Hygieno:
Sons, Edin.
BALIS-HBADLEY, W.
(1884):
The naturelhlstory of
fourgagcs
of
lacerated cervixuteri,
Aust. rtod. J. ¡n.s., ó!
200-2L4.BARNBS,
R. (1852):
Anlnquiry into
someof
the rclationsbetween menstruetfon, conceptLon, and lcctatlon¡
and the lnflucnce
of lactetion ln
causlng abortl.on.Lancet,
2:
510-514.BENNBTT,
J.
H. and BRAI'JDΡJ. (1955-54):
Sone lnoreexact
tests of
glgnlflcancefor
0-A natcrnal-footal incourpatíbtlity,
Ann. Eug6n.,18:
302-310.The placenta
in
abortion.ó05.
ManuaL
of
Antenatal Pathology ThcEmbryo. tYlllian
Grcen ¡ndBERGSTRoM,
H.,
NILSSON,L. A.,
NILISoN, (1.967):
Demonstratlonof
Rtr58 day
old fetus.
Amsr. J.99:150-155.
1_51.
L.
and RYTTINGER, L.antlgens Ln e
Obstet. Gynec., BISHUN, N. P.
,
RASHAD, M. NNEELY, M. R, and BURKE, G.
ln
a caseof
repeLancet,
1:
95ó.BISHUN, N.
P.
and MORTON, W. R. M. (19ó8)¡
Chronosomestudics on wonen who heve had two or more
unsuccessful pregnencieg
, J.
Obstet. Gyneec.ßrit. cwlth.,
75: 66-70,BRADY, E.
J. (1892):
Abortion followlng endouetritisanð posslbLe cause
- wlth
notesof
caso.Med. Press.,
n.s.,
53: 500-501.BRITISH MBDICAI DICTIONARY, THB
(1961):
Ed. bySir
Arthur Salúsbury MecNaLty. Caxton Publish.Co.
Ltd.,
London,p.
521.BROWNB,
F. J. (1925):
0n the abnormalltiesof
thcunblllcal
cord which nay ceuce antonataL dceth.J.
Obstet, Gynaec.Brft.
Emp., 322 17-48.BROIV¡IING,
A. G. (1885):
Hypertrophyof rtght heart,
wlthdiletatlon - its reletions to
abortion and deeth.Mcd. Rec. (N.Y.
),
282 597.598.BUtt. WLD HLTH ORG.
(19ó6):
Standerdizatlonof
Proccdurcsfor
Chronosome Studies 1nAbortion.
Me¡norandun.342 765-782.
CARR, D.
H. (1965):
Chromosome studiesin
spontaneousabortfons.
Obstet. end Gynec., 26t 308-326.CARR, D.
H. (1967):
Chromosome anonallcs as a cause ofsponteneous
abortion.
Anor.J.
obgtet. Gynec.,g7
r
ZgS-293,CARSTAIRS, K.
C, (1965):
Theidentification of
plateletsand
pletelet
antigensln histologlcal
gcctLons.J.
Path.Bact.,
90: ZZS-ïTL.CARTER,
J. E.,
VELLIOS,F.
and HUBER, C.P.
(1963a):Clrculatory
factors
governlng thevlebtllty of
thehr¡nan plecenta, based on e norphologlc study.
Aner.
J. clin. Path.,
4Q: 363'373..,
MoRTON, W. R. M., MANNIoN, P.L., (19ó4):
Chronosomal nogeicLsnated ebortlon (Corrcspondence).
CARTER,
J. 8.,
VELLIOS,F.
8nd HUBER, C.P.
(1963b Histologleclassificatlon
and incidencecircul.atory lesfons
of
the human placenta, wlth a reviewof
theliterature.
Ançr.J. cLln.
P8th.,40:
374-578.CHARLBS,
D. (1964):
Iatrogenlc endonetrial patterns.J. clin. Peth.,
t7¿ 205-2L2.of):
CIENDENIN,
T.
M. and BBNIRSCHKB,K.
(19ó3):stud.ies on sponteneous abortLons.
LZz 1281-t292.
coLvIN, B.
FISH,
J.
ScooKE, R.
Chromosome
Lab. Invost.,
D.,
BARTHOIOMEW, R.4.,
GRINÍES,t{.
H. and. (1950):
Salvagepossibtlitíos ln
threetenedabortJ.on.
Amer.J.
Obstet. Gynec.,
59: 1208 -t224, G.(1958):
An analysisof
350 casesof
abortion.Brlt.
ued.J.¡ 1:
1045-L047,CROWDER, R.
8.,
BILLS,E.
S. and BROADBENT,J.
SThe nanagenent
of
threatened abortlon:of
100cases.
Aner.J.
Obstot. Gynec g9ó- ggg..
(1 950) :A study
.,
6o:CURTIS,
A. H. (1925):
Spontaneous recurrent abortion.An
lnquiry lnto
the causes and preventive treatnent.J.
Amer. med.Ass., 84:
L262-L264.czEIzEL,8., HANCSOK,
M.,
PALKOVICH,I.,
JANKO, M. andZOLTAI,
N. (19óó):
PosslbLe reLatlon betweonfoctal
death¡nd E.
histolytica lnfection of
the mother.Amerî
J.
Obst'et. Gynec.,9ó:
264-266.DAVIS, A.
:
2665 casesof abortfon. Brit.
med. J. ¡-150.
DAVIS, B.
P. (1909):
Motor carmiscarrlage.
Mod. Rec.(N.Y.),
752 L74-175.DBLHANTY,
J, D.4.,
BLLIS,J.
R, and ROWLEY,P. T.
(1961):Trlplold cells ln
a hr¡manenbryo.
(Corrospondonce).Lancet,
1:
L286.DOUGALL,
J, (1875):
Notes on sixteon casesof
abortlon.Lancet,
2:
587-588; 622-623.DUNCAN, W.
(1892):
Postgraduate lecture on abortion.Lencet,
2:
559-361.(les 0)
?t
123153.
EASTMAI{, N.
J, (195ó):
WllliansObstetrlcs.
11th Ed.Appleton-Century
Croft, Inc.,
Now York,p.
601.FALCONER,
B.
(1946e)l
fnvestlgations on the uterlne mucota.IL
The occurrence and slgnf.flcanceof
ectatlcand
cystic
glandsln
the uterlne mucosa.Asta
obstot.
gynec. scend.,
261 475-495.FALCONBR,
B. (1946b):
A studyof
the pethologyof
habitualabortíon.
Actaobstet.
gynoc. scend., 28¡ 49ó- s24.FALCONER,
B,
(1949a)I
fnvestigetions on tl¡e ut,crine mucoss.VI.
0bservations on the inconpletecystic
change' of
the stronalcells of
the endomstrium.Acta obsteto gynec. scÊnd., 28t 105-111.
FALCONER,
B.
(1949b)¡
Invcstigations Lnto the uterlne mucosa.VII.
The pathol,ogyof
pre-ovuLatory haemorrhage.Acta
obstet,
gynec. scand., 29: 2L0-222.FISHER,
J. J. (1955):
Mlsscdabortion:
Analysisof
50cas6s and discussion
of etiologl.
Obstet. endGynec.,
1:
529-534.FOX,
H. (1966):
Thronboslsof foetel arterls ln
thehumrn
pLecenta. J.
Obstet. Gynaec.Btit.
Cwlth., 732 961-965,FOX,
H. (1968):
Basenent menbranc changesln
the v1111 ofthc
hunenplaconta. J.
Obstet. Gynaec, BrLt.Cwlth., 7Sz 302-306,
FUJIKURA,
1.,
FROEHIICH,L. A.
end DRISCOLL, S. G. (19óó);A
sirnplified
enatomicclassification of
abortions.Amer.
J.
Obstet. Gynec.,95:
902-905.FUJIKUM,
T.
and CARLËTON,J. H. (1968):
Unllateral thlc,keningof
fetaLartcries
on the placenta resenblingarterlosclerosls.
Aner.J.
Obstet.Gynec,, 100¡ 843-845.
FURUHJBLM, M. (1949)
¡
The treatnentof
habitual abortion.Acte
obstet.
gynec. scand., 292 407-41ó.GARNETT,
A. Y. P. (1880):
Abnornel adhoslonof funis
to pLacenta,with
accidental hemorrh¡ge and abortisn,A¡ner.
J.
ned.Scf.¡ D.8.¡
7.9¿ 73-79.GORDON,
A. (1897):
Tenporarystcrility
ae ceusc of abortlonat
theflrst pregnency.
Ann. Gynec.GLASS,
B.
(1949abort 332.
and
Pedlat., 11:
20'24.The
relatlon of
Rhinconpattbilit
Amer.
J.
Obstet. Gynec., 57: 32)
i
OII . v5 toGRAI{T,
A.
(1955):
HabltualabortLon:
Prcconccptlonel investlgEtions and postconceptionel trgatncnt.(Correspondence). -
Fertll.
ándSteril., 4:
169-170.GRANVIIIE,
A. B. (1835):
Graphfcl].lustratlons of
Abortíon and the Dlseasesof MenstruatLon.
London'GRAY,
- J. D.,
pioblen TUPPBR,oi
C, spontancous and ROWSE,abortion. V. J. A. (1958):
_TheThe gcnesisóf
spont¿neou¡abortlon.
Amor.J.
Obstet.Gynec.,
75t
43'52.GRBEN,
- J. S. (1924):
Placenta praevialn
theeerller
partof pregnsncy:
Anote.
Mcd.J. Aust.,
Lt349- 350.
GRUBB, R. end SJOSTBDT, S.
abortlon and ster
18 5- 195.
Blood groups ln
Ann hun, Genet.
,
19:i
(1e55)lity.
:GRUENWALD,
P. (1961):
Abnornelitiosof
placentalvescularfty
in relation to lntra-uterlnc
deprlvatloir and retarðetionof
foetal^growth.Signtflcance
of
avescular chorlonlcvlLlí.
N.
Y. St. J,
Mcd.,É:
1508-1515.GRUENWALD,
P.
(19ó5)¡
Chronlcfoetel
dlstress and placentellnsuffislcncy.
BLol. Neonat., 5:2L5- 265.
GUILBEAU,
J. A.
and TURNBR,J. L. (1953):
Theeffcct
oftravel
uponthe
lnterrupt'lonof pregnancy.
Ananalysis-
of
1917 cases wttn ninlnum Journeys of500
hllos.
Amer.J.
Obgtet. Gynec., ó6¡ L224'1250.
HALL, B. and tr(ALLEN,
B. (1964):
Chromosome studlos inabortuges end
stillborn infants.
Lancet, 1:110-111.
155.
HENRY,
J. S, (1957):
Some bloLogical aspectsof
spontaneousabortion:
Reviêr,rof
the recentliteraturc.
Aner.
J.
Obstet. Gynec., 73t IZZ9-L237.HERROD,
J. H. (1953): Allergy - a factor
1n abortions?Report on two
ceses.
Aner.J. 0bstet.
Gynec.,66:1168-1171.
HERTIG,
A. T.
and EDM0NDS, H. W.(1940):
Genesis of hydatidifornmole.
Arch.Path.,
50¡ 260-29L,HERTIG,
A. T.
and SHEI.DON, üÍ.H. (1945):
Mininalcritoria
required
to
prove prinafacie
caseof
trar¡matlc abortionor rnlscarrisge.
An analysis of, 1000spontaneous
abortions.
Ann. Surg., LLTt 596-ó06.HERTIG,
A. T.
and ROCK,J. (1944):
On the developnentof
the early human ovum,with
speclal reference to the trophoblastof
the previll.ousstage:
Adescriptlon
of
7 nornal and 5 pathologic humen ovo./\mer.
J.
Obst,et. Gynec.,
47 z 149-184.HERTIG,
A. T.
and LIVINGSTONE, R,G. (1944):
Spontaneous,threatened and habitual
abortíon: thelr
patho-genesis and
treatnent.
New EngL.J.
Med., 2302797 - g0ó.
HERTIG,
A. T.
and ROCK,J. (1949):
A seriesof
potentÍally abortive ova recoveredfron fertile
wo¡nenprior to
thefírst
¡nissod nenstrualperlod,
Amer. J.Obstet. Gynec., 58: 9ó8-993.
HERTIG,
A. T.,
ROCK,J,,
ADAlfS,E.
C. and MENKIN, M.C.
(1959):34
fertil.ized
hr¡man ova, good, bad endindlfferent,
recovered from 210 wonen
of
knownfertility,
A study
of
biologic wastageln
early human prog-nancy. Pediatrics,
25t ZÙZ-ZLL.HBWITT,
G. (1860):
On the hydatldiformor
veslcular rnole;its
naturo and nodeof origin.
Trans. obstot.Sos. Lond.,
1:
249-266.HBWITT,
G.
(1861)z
Ílydatidiform degeneratlonof
the ovum.Trans.
obstet.
Soc. Lond,, 2z Ll2-116,HOTCHKISS,
R. (1944): Forttlity in Men.
Llppincott, Phlladelphia,p.
151.HUBBR, C.
P.,
MELIN,J.
R. and VELLIOS,F. (1957):
Changesin
chorionl.c tlssueof
aborted pregnancy.HUBBR, C,
Aner.
J.
Obstet. Gynec., 73t 569-578.P.,
CARTER,J. E.
and VBLLIOS,F. (1961):
Losionsof
thecirculatory
systenof
theplacenta.
A studyof
234 placentaswith
special referenceto
thedevelopnont
of infarcts.
Amer.J.
0bstet. Gynec.,81
¡
560-573.HUGHBS, E.
C.,
VAN NESS,A.
W. and LLOYD, C. W. (1950):The
nutrltional
valueof
the endonetríun forlnpLantetion and
in
habitualabortion.
Amer. J, Obstet. Gynoc., 59: L29Z-1303,HUNI,
A. B. (1947):
The Rhfactor in abortion.
Amer. J.Obstet. Gynec.,
55:
467-473.HUNTINGT0N,
J. L.
(1929)!
A rcviewof
the pathology ofone hundrcd
four
consccutive niscarriagesin
private obstetric practice,
Amor.J.
Obstet, Gynec.,L7: 32-4t.
INCE
(1856):
Diseaseof
the ovum and placents as a eauseof abortion.
Med. Tlmes attd, Gaz. (Lond. ),
rr.9. ¡ L2: 389-390.INHORN, S.
L.,
TI{ERMA}I,E.
and PATAU,K. (1964):
Cyto- onotic studiesin
spontaneous hunan abortlonabst.)
Am6r.J. clin. Path,,
42: 528.JAKINS, W.
V. (1884):
Mlscarrlage, andits
causes.Aust. rnod. J.
¡
Melbourne,n.s., 6:
496-498.JAVBRT,
I
(C.
T.
and BENNETT BARTONand acquired lesions o
spontaueous abortion.
65: 1065 -L077 ,