Collaborative Writing in an EFL Context

Sri Rejeki

fld'ru!'svdsdrufu.6d

Co[laborative

Writing

in

an

EFL

Context

ABSTRAcr

wqrho lor060.0r vsry hos be6i vdel prcmoreJ

i

_edlorioi

i

rhe orco ol Eis sh oiovqse

r&.[$

dnd ]eoii lq,

s*De

ro qBohr€ry en tequedy be Eei

col0606rlely

n,rrh!r!dspopuo,6i+eolne.

;nuJlorm5baproEfie(orqborc. olo biess

rldr

rhe ddo veie.orreded rhrough odo

*,nAE o6ir inreotubd wlh qeellynedhss, vh.h o m.d ro reo.h *€tulobiedr* I vousr o vqsliolqdY16'rc]udhggro!ppoh

64nesh

4Gdwe€i

Jea

on"osrdup5rq'nipdeJ

irferlJr

rrlE.oloSqdre,rrhe

rolp po d ns o rd vd€ o rory viien i _{srolps 6ced} oo

rherp.diqs.

Ed.r

eib,olrreer.upro.rruhrrowrcthe5roqNhch@l$!ei*sonJ

po

goid eiris ro e(oyoeerhqlqors rherid*5 Il,e ddq reeedhqeJ hrcueh.loi,

o&eioroicidrud.

r€l&roirhoriossub

eJdrhaeidoJrhe*n*Eoropo ordo*

hd nude !loed smechohieslhei perlqmhs rhe b+s

rme

oddsene , nuJeit derdepidere, oid ryp6 or

*fiq,erc

qmoie ile

n!*

5tu<left rqEd,hey enofd

'he qdi'cr, one 5tuae qDe5EJ 'rd rlE.olobqdion dd

id

rc

os @lr05 she ,ode,peded

INTRODUCTION

1..trr n!

li,..t! r

r-:i)glJr

LDlulr

rLLr..ms.r.n,sr

rn.l.Ir.i]

L.N l,,rg

fl,.r{l

fn

rl,r

n.rl)*.{r(rl

Lt)lmrl,

n)nin,rg,

11,r, li,

rcrhs.Nrlc

itrnt

83

nLlJj!(whD

JrlNr

rh.lcs:on Nhil. srdenrs xs

nt

li\crci.Innris

a.0ro&h,

trh.r:

unLrlly

nxnLl

ir

ftrni.irlr!

rl:!s

tthN

trr iun.nr:

wlur

b

do wth tLc NorlLools rnd klLi,ig rh.m

dre

aNv.s.arlte

qtrr*nlrs This nat IRJ

t)

$udenti l.p.o,lcn.e to

tlt

rur.l.Fand

lc:ol

rudcnc

irdcp.

cr.enleanri'r:r I'r iLlllnion

ro dns, EngliJh

tu.hertL?!lr tl)clcs.n

urtrg

Brlu$

lndanesii, duc ro h.k olEdslish

fr.i-.icn.y. Ai drc $mc ti'nc,

mnysud..$

l.xm

E.glish _l,xsirclyrnd

lNt

Liftlc calorts to

irnfut

rlli

Enllish _Fr.liocn.r

it

rlcir own

FN,rxl

timc

Thqr!.nJ

mu.h ordcn rime J.i,)g

nri'r-s.ilu,.lon.rn'rpo(i

r E.eLish lc{niih!,

rL.h a:

r'rtJlii'!

tclAFion,

pliti.s

odLnt

q

n.i,

ornrcll,rs

rhrn nnrtphoncs. Sr\1.trN JtPenJ

ro. mu.h.n

rh.tcx.hcr

rd

$udILrt.s

rurro$

onli Tl\c r.xlLcr rnd n!L1cn. Nn.ds

rontrbuk _src{l}

dt

ruLlcnti

dc\.lq,nrtrt.r

Mrkins $n.[nts

mn i'

.NnJcnt his t

..r

x liishn,c

6rEnlhhlrnlurlc

rcr.hcr, $1..

!nl\

n,

nxric

vlu

rsdr

in tl)c rrc.

wlrs

cFe.d.rr

[rmiis

N n.t

('lnm]lf

.nur

xsed

like

l,

on.\ir. I,lxnt Enslislt icxrhcr,

r:n..i:lLy

r

rh.

l)lnhy.du-trur

lnrcYr,

Lrt

ticdr

nlng

tu use r

nut

ruJttrr..nrLJ )!"

l,n)[l

rlurs.cs

nrdu6 [rntty

t]tr!

\lgrs.J

i,)n)cirlmguigclcarnins

Arari.qoltehii!

rr.l,ri(lL'$

n,r

ir

mor!

{uJ..n..nturol

l,N

b..n cndts:ll

n

rldn!ffd

b

nnpn,rc$ud.n6' Lxnlux*

rdl.ior).

F,irriDlolt,

mary *uJcntr

r(....urrpcJ6uxLlnLrlr(n,trilrllNnh'hcir

rc$

b

s.rt.n

r

ftur.(

r\l

_r!.scni tr

nlfiitr

.ailnLrfL d

i.n.c

Arrllr!

thc $udcn.r.ntd.n

Lcrni.!

if

Enllirl,

!hs\crD

lc

rnaLrrn,ttrtNil

n

JNd.pnLlunil.,nsurg.skillr

1!{.ni'rs.

r.iJnr!,sr!rLn,!

:nd $riitrr!.

\fni'r!

hr

Leol

rlrsdud

ns

on.orrh!

nutJitlirnh

pFbLm

l,c.rtrsr "ir

rmrnr

urlsL

hoN{rJcnhi.qutrc

drc:lilll

Nl.J

t pulLnN.ilini{

firrcol

Lvnnns

li

,

n.rk,

luq

r!."

(KhDntreldr,

lol

l,

p. 'r r+) T1,us,

t

's

nnl).rrtu

tor EnrLirl' rs

)6rig.hn!trxg.(El;L)tca!l,dr.detlop

\nd.ntr'Nir

rs:h Lls ro lleh

{trJcrN'nk.cn

ln

ny

E|t

!o

cih,

w,i.n!

las

r.i

t'tur

romo,cLl,N.' rnri,ntrnLr xrnviq.ln (rltnu,

n{

,nnant, L.

Nl

l\lanJ

(1007)$

eni,twiitr!

a.nvnls

lNr

L,(n

r.uNi

on

:rhi-

nrs _sood

shd$nrdiflnrnnr

rtrl

IInmlri.rl[.n

$:

Ii

hrdon$i.,, c..nnn.n

0

tirc drx

rlcs

flk.

iLi dr. lll:l- lrlsh.r

du(fr,t nff*s

ir rltxr

dtrd.nNift

bl.J

ni

ttrnlu.crt [iJcnn.frl)cr

it rh..rJ oinrr.n.$e,.

U

.(urit.Lvnaof

rrrlics

hrtbrn

qLLirc

rclutrtn,

fnldr

ri.nlir!

r. rullents

Nrili'r!,..r.!.'rllt

dnr

ure(ilri

Ihis nnslrtLr

Ars

,Nlritnntr,

Youn!,.t,1

!l:m.(nr

(100t) xrgre, lit

F^ri.n

Lcinnrr inJ jl,i1'q iml

ellii!rt*i

oI tlrc

r!rrltr

Oir "rr

r" JN.lot

$!i.

rsnnn!rlillsLs

b

lrNt $LLlot.

N{rrlf

tirti.

I

c

r

thr

iin'

!tis.

Lcrntr,r

r(,i.i,

$LLJIr

l)t.!tLtor'tnclr

worlur!

rt)sthr\ii,

nr!ir

r.tr:

i',1,n].r k)

bctfu r i.qum n,. l{nqui!..

|r

h

n!

ruJc'tr

woltn,s

tuldr.r, i

n'!l,d

r$uil!'.nts

rhc

dr

rcDmirt r.tr

$u!].r.

$

lr,n

n.m

lrh

"n\.r(l

r*.ll& r|.m.

1007) Th!

lunnq

fivnornrnr.

1,.1r, duJuts

l\ l...,lq,u rfr

.nn,ctirhcr.ln tl,i,

, rris

nrnul

nL.a

84

Vhile it a

l.lieKl

thrt mrnr

Erlhh r.drcs

ir

rhe

l

.n.sirn hLglicr .Jrc,ni.tr

..ntc\$

hN.

Nnonnenkd ? rari..,

.I

urirnr! r{Niri.s,

h$rh

of

.,,lliLonrnt \Lrnin! ni rlntdicsan .onrcis lias Lecn s.rruclv.onnu!tcJ

th!

ol,j..li{.ol

tle snd},ls tu

nn{,sfu

ihc

d(rt

tu

*hi.h

thc

c.ll,Lro

ir

nrri.g

\orL

i|

an EIjL

THEORETICAL FRAIIEWOSK

Tlt

dr..ry dui

hJenir:

.hn $udl is s..n> .uLunl

pu$rnnts

Ir.N Vyg.trty{tr78)

h

t'tr Lro.l,

Mul

atul So.iar, Vls.GkI(19?8) mxn$i,tr

rLr.c|lLlr.n

Lcxi,r ri!n, orhr

F.rlc

trutr

tli.d,

Vhen

d\'lrrnr rlurnjs

Lmgr

i!r,

ir

!\imrl.,

dqrill

a{rrc

nrc L(onL ftom rdrlts

Nlrc

rmnnrii.r

_rvnl nidm

orli

r orL.r

aluhs.Si'niLarlf,qh.n.li1.lrdrs.r.k1.rxnds.

bs.h.ol,

dq

my

jl$

lan

r tr.n,h.gurgr

tLr

\N

bydr.

pr,rlcrou tlnii

V)xo$b (19?8) _rLo

N.i.

_{rlai humd}

d.klo|ni.nr

js

i,,hotntbr

n).irlly siruii.,1

,,(n,iti

rvhrh

nnpLcs

nu.

i: inr.N

I

rrcllnn

humxn:

bg(

tos.nu

qirh.rh.^ o

drdr:..i

ii

_so

lI

tl)r..R

ofL.rmnrgr

ri)riri

lr,$rlr

r,i,nDs Lik. Fn{lrh, tn,gus!,

tt{D.n

!xr

l.h

,nlJ.r.qr,ir. EDsliJr

ri.r

rlr l.co

t

r.nn.t

ihcm. l.imnrq inrm

rltrntui.hcr

nlLl,.n

r..n

ir r

oi

tdDr.ilcitrnnrg

iiin

rhcncNi

roumcnt P..rs

rl

rcrrhe

Lrho _r.c

rl

Ergl n) .,m

fnn

i.

rnvn.ndr.ni6r

E|!Lirtr t,tr!ua{t

l

ni.r

to

r.qui(

Enelnh

lind.

\,lL.h i,r

n'n,

q.rl.lnalulrr.cdtirl.rf!r,,1rffui.r.nr\

nl

n

t.vcd

t tL.

.nrn.nrun

nLjrrrrG

[rn-.s'

t[sn.,sc t]s

rl.rnrn., [n!!nr

r..,.]r$i

i

dsisn i,iru,,sc

l!rrldrr.nvrLc rlu

r(lrnr

itrJcnrs

r$rl

nnLrl.rxri'rlr

V1,.1<

n!

$Llln)oraiiv.lyr.uLi (!rtrn.

$uJer.

(r

!onnno-ri.rtu n,

!i.L,.atrrln

r!

t.r!(

l,isnxge. I.oLl.riIg

$+rskl,

L nn.Lr

{nl

Thont

(1007)

ik)

_{.trgu. in.tr}

s.o

_l.uguapc

lunri

l..m

dr-

t.q.r

Linsuje

tlmrlh

i'Rnulj:trnm

rnJ

nntr.ri.n

Brthis, ilr.]' nru tlurl,'L,qn.,s.

rc.frinul

ar(,m

ill.

iircrx$i{,r Nnh nr.

f..rl.

nrtrmldrenr md rLtr.

rll

lume$ soni.l

rrrt

tle Lngn.,gc

iin.

arfuk

terntrtruN. Inr.trnlr,

i.r.rLlin!'o

I

rolirndTL.ntf

(lco?),

f[r:.jn

rmllyr

r (,[ i.l.

ru

rlr

rd]L'isnnr

ii

n

inl.l!b

_{t\s,.1).lqri..n} nrJ

ru'l

_{f ro.c!!i1rd} rtJ

rntralll

ruhLr.

dt

l,i,ru:r

Thr

s.sf..,llt

truc 1'h$.r lmgugt

lurnrr ni!\

n, ijnn.

fu

r

r..,.hrntu

\|\f

k

orrr.Jrr.

r l,onl

i|

nrr

hrlrr

\(l,il.

srrxkr!

rLllI

i,a

l]i!!

L,Nn rl,rnn,n

$ili[

skilL n]r.

[

trsurg.

Lrn.rs

rn

&],

_nc

ft(D

.lllirritr

sorlnrs, nr.

.tiiq

lin!.,,!.

skrLl, n,.h is

uitmr, on

rl$.nio,.rtrc

rnlin.

tu!\

of \oll.'bf

nhl.

tr.rliI{.

tir :J!Lni(r,

.r,llal,orrm

$ridg

is trLr

"xu.[.1ijr

i(]rtr

!,.irl

.oNn,.ti.f

i$ , nn ..nn.nm

d!o1

Thet 0n,vnl.

imf.rfufi

nrrilhs nn

Lfllyldle

n*

sn,.1ir,r I'r n,.al

ronrnr

i,!N

rh.ori

nr.

.ntl]i:ii

is on

iuJrn'.'

\lireu! r

i

N.rL.f

l

nnng nJ \ririnsas a

mN|$;ii.ri .l

infuF

mL:cJ

rri.n

ii*e(i,L

Ar..nli',g n) V}?ohlr

(1978),rhilJren _l,'im

ntr

_{nleN nronlh dr.n}

!\L,L..nt.rs.

Bf$rnrg

nr

ohd

!nl,

_ra!h

.rh.r,

nn i

lnt

thcnnnr

\frxrj$Jurnr!

.l[ir

lj(r

I

i\.n*io

si1,,, tr

!c.iinr!

thNlir.t,)i

Lrrnnrq

^

rlnrl,r\i

!r

n,ro-rudntr(u!n)s

i'r ih.

iuJ.nri

7Ur

(Z.n!.af'.xh,,l DNll.p

hur)

V).ro6ky

nr

o,cJrlr|rnr

l.lrrtr.rl

,Jr

1978)

[u

hcim.(,

dlibor,lint

\r,i,]!,,11(\\:

{ud.nFrohNr

n(

f.ed6r.L,

\!l,i!L.in..rtrr

cnLcra

n

n\enrlhrrorilt

_Fr{s

rnu

ni.(

irc l.ssrouF

of*udc^ts.onFird

ni

xr

\

ii

'rJu

$uJ. i

Tllelc.dbirk is t'ln)

ft{.

ctailcd

mdroNnL.

t

to dcrr. x

b{rr

LITERATURE REVIEW

WRITINGSKILLS IN LANGUAGELEARN NG

ln r _{t,r.Linri,ury$udr} k

!N

lounJ drir

Eryhh [.gtragr{udcnh n)

],

dresivic(J

rhftsrc,,liii!

is the tilori1. rkitL

olrlLhrgusc

stilLs. 1Ln.nnig, rc.dnrs,

irirnrc,,n

sNxkiIs I.

wxs jln) re\t.,ltd ni,rwrnins

wr

ror\nh

_ro bc

tl'. nrsdillL.ulr

skiLl in

l.rni'rs,

Iuurq.

Lr.rrsc n hciuly

dq\axl

on rh.r,).danarr

mi$or

(Nmon, _{2009) ni}

lstunr

_r)

.on\tf

ni.nnr!.

ln

rl

ki.m, El.nr

rrl

o\lo:(loto)

nonk,r

rhf iniliri.r

rh*r

mlrrtcr.l]es

J6i!-n

ntr rhetrJrs\'s L.us

nu..r

_{Enqlbhs|c,rlnj:}

shlls,

ntkr

_nun

snii|s

_{slinL Thtre}

l

_trN)

r

rumLlr.axrenrFs

6 nn|n\.

snJ.nN E.slistr writrR, L

!

liy pcnormin!

liammr

..n..1nr

tnv&15nuJons

*riins.

O,,

rh..lif

h

rd,\riirDssliills

&r.nllLr

,l.p

nlell

of

n'!

rKrrDrLr

tn(nulii.nr$

(Lo

_{llllxtrJ, ?007).}

lk.ynrml h.nr

_rh,tr

dltror.c

(iirlng _ikrlls

n.ld.

r\ririri.r

r,rt{

_rd

li\

ri.hrr\,

l,nru.,s.

ii,t\r,

and p.cr

nn[1,ora-n.r

lircnr,n

ar.b^

alcr to Lr.nnc'i

^(itu(1.:,

r.^.nrl

m.ft

.,ri.r aml

lern!r\i

_{t!.r.rf h.n} on

,lt.

rrnr.s

Thb!

nroa:.nh

nrrrNi:r!c.rJr

otlu

r.r.h.$

_rLxyi

!q

i,nftrbni

tut. tn

EnsLr.l,l{nirig ILris

r(rin

to dl. fr.r dur drr

r!niri.:

th.,r )

r(rh.r

J.rsns

i{ld

LiqLn}

tuhc

b

suJ.n$

ticrnxl

nuilrnD

r \.

nrg,

lhnh\

ll LciJ

tu$

lllnNcnli$nrw

h

M(i,i!

'lhis

ir.[n.. [.ridir!

I

n.Mhrc&n-nu.n\n.rnr.rt

tu

dr. iutlons r)

rngrr

rn

L. rn.l Il),und (100?)Jc5ign.J _i

iLitns

rhrmh

nr vh'.lr rhr

w(nrr

tupi.s\rr

rhrull

trth

*(len6'.rvtrortrrrr

nnJ turl rcrd.rs

They rpf l,cd

Jis.n+i,r\

JcmonsEr..ns, anJ

cvlor.on

1o.trlaqr rlre

sn .n6li.nR

thcv

(,dcd $i)ri,,!

Attci.ondu.r.d tl). _f rc..durc

6.sx,xrsli*",

nuJons

wcr!\e,

ro

b.nnc

m.rn,firl

r\l

rnqi!.d nr

rrkilrg

Then

rcnrt.\i

..ns

*.n.

l,Is.r

a.,l

sL.\el

Lr.rNr ..nrcn6

Thri n,i!hi

i,rtir.t.hs

$trttetrrn.uLd LiL.ly

|\rro.n

Ld{

r&n

nn\,1fr pbvi.[d strh rnorf

!l,lio

r

nita

bwrirctl,rr

_mxkcssrn!.

n,'li(nl

COLLABOFAT]VEWRIT NG

T. nDrnld

d*.!trv

s trllc

vrms

rnrvi!-

!)

r

linllLshJAs n

r.nJur(l

mhvnlurlLyr

|mnrl,lr

r!

rxd.ue

ar\+

(100?)mriNrt.J

,l rtr

latrn! x.ri1i,r\,{lJ

h.nt

Nrlhl

ltrhcr

phrlc

Nli,.(1r

For.xi'nrl.j

doins

l)n,nrn nnm!$trli

!ih.F

_lcftnr!

Ic.Jh.L

arom

iriJtr:,

Lrr i tr: . on\rrnrn,r Ntrh

tn

n!ts _xnrL

r\xr.in!

rl{

n)fi( r

mlrhrr

rrc ,,Ll $itL

nll

il

.\nntr! fr,.$s.s..trntr

[!

J.

n,

nnl'r

rr .,ily

ll,$!\'i

(.LL,,tu.rnr

s

_{iitg nrhisnndl} i,o,ns

rlHrnu![n.$rh I

n'o

o.Noo

rni'l\ rft

rr.x

I

r(

rr wLnrs nis.nrd (

dL,turnc

_{lvnhns, drorlh ir s}

dor.ul

N

,n

nnl,tr,..i\l

:l,c.n

|n.rir.J

!)rmNl

tniirl,

tr.i!i,f^rnnur!lr|.w!rl,l TLo(.mm.r

r.n ,nL 5

rhr

r,lic: _rl.tr(

rou(L

rlk

.olliLoltrr.

v

iir!.trnl

rn!,tr.sk

n! nnJcn..o

J.

fN

rc! cn (Srn!1,

lnoj)

ttrtlu

r.!iL\1

i.t

virj$.

&rthorGr.nt:,\rrnrg(RolliIn,r,

_loo4).

ali;

itivtr,

tuqrircs{uncn6i,

ftflc.ton

_ttnn

Nn

l!rnn)!and,

r

fi.san,.

_m.,

*uJ.n6[r\t

rt,

rt\Le$ thc

l.$o.r

th rtr$|Ath lsr,rtr

(11005)

xr$*

_{drir rollaLoritivc}

$itnxslu,ln

L.

ntrsl,cd.j

hd.

rudrrthrn

_rfuvinnr!

Iec,ll,i.t.o

tlr.ir

!..^.

S|c _{iL.n did a}

.!|itjoittu

_wninrs

hsLi.|

sudo rsorkd,o

[rn

_furL]

rrttc

i

dr.or$ritnl:r

r)sethe. Thr rcsrt6s|orr(r

ti

_.

tlr.

!tunnrDl

_{a.{tra.y {,i tL.}

fi.nj rlkitm!

rlu

rlc $rdcnN

rdu..J

_{mre hrslj.r r|an} slicn rlc iu.tcn6 aid n,r

x

i.:iJutruirins

A1.o, r|e

|

..!s *riti,rg atum

tuJ..s,

_{.olhtr.ri_}

r*!*tisFl4

hilLcrt-rls oitinj:urlc

romJ,l.xi.l _an!

k'c

uur

!,.rit

_Thr

rNLt.

iLs.rhor.(l _dur

rl[.ollrr$rtv.rrirDjr

_{n.ri!i_}

ii,x r!.civcl

Nfnr

_ri.m

drruJ.N

_Tl)cy

cnlqd.Ik

rri\mi.s

rnrl..nsiJc(d

_rhdn

h.lfnn n,

rnfrt\r

_{tll.n wrnnipskiih}

Aroih.r

*ulfor.oltrtr,rr(r

\rnnr!

_t:

itnj

..n!1trftt

Ly Kl.trib

,nt M.iilmi

_{cot 5)}

Ih

snr!('hoqa.har,srn().f

_strdrn$

$h.

_d

r.lLnatr

^r

\r{npotrtt.c.irmcJ nrtr

$cr

$lo

Jnl wrnnu _{lcnlout it\,}

..Lhlur

_rnr

i*j,L

rl$. Thc.nhbor.rN(

rjuD,

_{rv,itntb urn,}

l,cft.r m (

'N

.f

r!nt.t,

.rg, ii:,trnn,,

!,inr.

m.tr,

hdrtrr)r

iii

_nrr.L.jii.s.

rkd!$

coot)

,rrus

,hxt _{inL Ior.rnr naiir np LiJ}

I..ur

rsL

nrd.htsnr

!.nr.,t

h.i,.\r,L

j.rrp..rIuIy.n

.\Dl.dr

nr _{rr! au'L}

.t

0rrelr

_.

i(i

t !Ilc(:,

(f

₄₎

tunr.iainr!{.rtr

bt,.

_rt,.

tu,.f,rsrh)

n'lhhofutrr Luiiu n! won]\l

t].i.rnnjr

{un.nh

n, J.

n,.

nnh6.r.rn!

uriirn!, MlLlis

rx

n

(iro

_h (l(r1I) _{t,k, Ji!t n4 (nL,rtnn}

jiilt

\

irn!

\!nhrLo.!r!l.nN :\trtrorlhi:rurs.iriincstn

i.sL

Jrnihn

_on

rn!r! rft.nc

.iu,ld

1,.

i,rJitlr.ll I\

nr!

n,rl.$,

aq.txn&d

_tltar

dl,rtro'r rNriinrs,t

|M

fdsitmnnllGn,

rA.:irsnLlLn6'urnitr!,

r

_N.ll

r

_{rh.ir s$,tirrg} s[ills They

n'gg.(d

s.\(rt{c!s

thr

_tur.h$.

.oul.l tatc

r, rxiryour.ollltlnriivc

_{\yrni,r!. TLc}

n'$, as .h$ n,s!r$.1, n _{n, Frn}

$uJo\t\.ithd

rl'.osnrs _dr.ir

].xrf.n

_{nrNms.n$ orL,rnr*} JlNcn byrhc t..,rtr.F. Moltt!an

utt;n.trt!

(:0ll)

_{susscscd tua.hus io}

(r

cp.,tucr(,

.n!

_{r) cnc.urgc $rJrnts}

nr\o*sith

Jilar

.t

p()d(

wnh dr ficr.n, _totLr

!I

_{rn ni.nrry.}

Ih.

n.onLl

n$

N n) pn^rJc lrp.rtunnics _nn rh! _Irxns nr

I

n)aon

_{rhc nrl)i.s nq, urnt to}

"ritu

ilorr

TLLs{.r.ran

rtn,h

us.J _r,

hlt

trl)oui drc _{ors.trrt:.tri.n.trtk}

\ritnrr

|,

(..

TLc

trc\r

fit

ir Lf

or!M!

i!jnn.nrs

_{tu mccr}

.rtrLJ..lN

_{tr.trr: r) Ll. tus.kLn,nLnl)on}

rLrir

nl.$

TL,:ftr

_{x nnt,Jtral}

l)rtll.fuJunr

\o.L

ng,i.lxs

bourhr,

_{t,hn, xn,t$rturh€}

li^t

dnn. Tcr.h.r: [.,y pnyrh _{{L!xcni.,)\ oD}

ihe.nni'r.Alicrrhis.{ud.i..trrior,l!nrrLc

ftn.l*i

rnJ.!nin,rJ

strh _{lonnn.n^ rnd}

\us!Nn,r\ Sn

u$1rr.nvrtu

r|.

r0

d

ii l.isc.lon rh. ..hmcnr. _{in,t nilgcnn}

\

.rrl

rc..

k.r:Iin..

Tha.)alc driy

n,rrn,c rnlr

drJcnsrsrgrrll

_io

Joiinier

_{trn$, n) rtrcy}

Whn. ..tl.i

t,.furv|vniij,s

N $cnr I tur

$trl.ns,

ioi

nln

Jrns&\rl]irrllynnolll,|lr

rhe xroviri$

s6(lr

(lo I I )

Dunhft

n

_m.r

rr

{nJ(n6lrd

|rin{.irh,L.ur

_{r.ltrs;hr ro}

.!sis.

m tollx[onrrr. \artru.

s(LJ..r

!]ktr.r.

rw

ri.n

r

mn a.

wl) rh

rilhrl)Ir

li.rnous.ll

ll'drir

|l,\D.J

Grui,rnt

qr n.nq..n,,latrr_

ddtrsrh

ut,(r

()n

nt.ir{!xnJ,Snrh

(:i]ll)

ils.

_{t)f ,nr: !ur}

n)r *,

_Llu.r

\.ifi

_t,\\

tNat

:...hd lrj:tr.,!r

_{l)rtrttri.n.r}

jnr

_nor

!(

_tln

87

piirel Nlrh sudentswi6. hLehcr

l!\!l

!lLr-suur !n,l.lctr.y. Also,

Sod

(l0ll)nrgsrY:

d,x.,.UaLofutirc wnrirx

x.tiln'$

nceJ n) L,r

monnorJt,ennh

$!

rtivitrls

trk

rII..-METHODOLOGY

This sudy is r n.it

oIi

bigs.r$dy

il

ftquird

$ud.ns to

$orl.ouabortilclf

Vi.ids

i.nvitlcs,

rrhxspanti.g,

t

nrg, atrJ

Jis

!

$uns

$r.

xlso pcdomrcd

t.

th$c _{lrarl)s i.i} rcar. a _lt.siri!. lcrnrilrs

oNnonm(

rlrt

.rgrgcd

$Jdn..

lndivnh'xl

*or\

\vrnln!

rnvi

n$

\Hr

.f odGcd rrntr ro

tlt

.othl)ontilt

sritnu .nes n, _l,r.vnlc

uftJlirls

ro

lrnriln.:.

{trdcrts*nhnt

NomrqMiliri.s

nt

coLlibontnr uri.n:i xcnvLiits

ur|

r.niu!t(l

n)r

onc meetny a; r

Prt.ls..i$

olodrcrr.ivtics

T*.

sroup\ wnl

i

nn,l.l64lrcsli'ncr cnx,lld

n r c.trisc nrre

inu,llal

i,r tlns res.rt.h rhc

.ourie rr'll.Lus sho*d

thitrh...ur!

*is

tu

tcxdr rr:rmcnhtive wtulngs. Th. dm

.6hnr.J

wcre mann, hseJ on

n,IcrrhcrhurJt.as

.brration

dnnn! tln!

ti('urh'

r.iiviq.n

sudcnb' nnerln idr wtrh

nrtnln,tll)

m.mlir^

nu.ng

rll

obsc^jtior

inM.6,

11i.

(iJr.is

nnc$;s, imonsorltrn tu Rmir)J

n(suddt"

n

r(nl)tr

ar

.mc

],

.c

r

tu

tnrnlc

nrrh.r

il\a.imriLn\vhen

citstrf An.rlis$r.inita

wx.. aln,

,.ilc.rd

tlno

qh

\tuJut'rencdnr,

whilh w.rc

nLl)ottcdftl(

urd

.t

n,. icin$ter

THETASKS

Thc

$udcnb"d.

tLN

Ji.nl*l

nm.s{rL

lrrLD

or nrtr

.r

dn(

ruJ.n.

SarLrnF

\ua

dren rkcd

t, mk. i

fur

_"t

irturl,

"hi.h

wir

tmtins

nr

!r{Lt\

\th

i,te

n,fiN

IheIwcr. al1.tr.J., nLsNs:

ri!

ron.$i olrl.,L

I.rnrri,ig lrntr tu

the!r

n! rnN't}

.r

ro rrnn

fn

r.

Ff{

rijjhr

iLvir

nl

ilsnN

rhe

ut.qrt

oi th!

wri.u

\4i[

Fnnrnq T]is Jn.usiion wrs

ii

orlcrl ro.$rblLsha

lc.nir

ctrvironmcntnn

'hc tndrtrt! r. ..ntrLLrt. li,.\ klnlg

nlrs

ior

lr.r

rtririti.s, $h,.h \

i:

.r,1Lrl..rrtnt *nrnrg Ancr

riNing,nrJcnr\rre

i'snut blritcl

jory lD$d on drc

frintug

nr$

.r.fcdr

rl

s,

th.

Firi'rr:*N

a(rlh r (isdtntutor

$oJor

6..nrtrtitI t n

()n r _rricrc offt,l).r,

sLh

Ninl,.r

oInn

grouN.r)L

i

6

ift!

I

Nnri *l),{.1$.r\

TLt.ro .rftnt*-rLJ

nntnn'.

rl,.

d.,f

[ron.

nt.

'jnrc,nitritlt

tl\ir.lrml,i

1r"uld

lo

ntr $me rs

hi'!trn..

t,n

Ai nrc dnl ol rln

u(.hg,

nr. !1..N

oi

*ririn!

tilr

fl

J.nt!' f a\hL..d

rer.

(li\flxltd on

rlk uLt rlo,s

in[

Nth d].

frinnn!.

FINDINGs

OBSERVATION

BriJ

on

n,..l.cntrtn\r,

Dr)$

itlenr

{,..1n,.niq

rLi. $nti,,q

rrr\

ri$.

S"-c

pnr$."rl.l

rcxll

".rk

t,!.nr.r r,.rotc

t

f'!(

!1{'mns

Erh

m.mL.cr

nr,!

arrrs

('

,v1itr.tr

i

ftrt.irifr

l\rnnstl,

nlLrbor*

Tim. n,rnxrcnun Th.

iultn[

ol rh.

rl].lr

m.di'rs\ri

2oo minf

i.s.rrh

A]nriLlh nrnn

olrh

lndrdi,r.

trt,c.lqnr

sLtn iL,

il.

fr.ldLs irtltnrs,.g

h.\

m!(1, nme

nir

i']F ifu

r,olLi6.ntr\.\Lnii,,{,{!J.rtssNrr

nrn

n. i,, dt. _nrntnr!

)

triti$

Ihisnrlll\l

Li\r

lrJtr,t.l rl,t

$u.l.nN cni,vd

d"

rti

r

it

rcinr

rldic

cxhrJrJ prnrnrs nm., rhr.nnl

.{cl

nmc

tu

nr

_{.olhbofu.rc uitinp ws}

r.r

tn.nrn

6r*!Je.s

_Somcgroulrs

ri,Fsrt

_tu

6.

rhir!

_{\hen t|e rijn. otrhc roursc Drlr.ns} luN orr, qhi.L _{Ld r.}

$nre$.t.n6

_Jntnot

e.ov.

c(rtr:l n'nount of opp.rurr!- nj rxfrds

shLd.ns' nt d,.1]tndcn.c.

Sai06

_Mto

'rxl.,nlysel.

.dtunxmasnnrrNNt{nigoa

n{r

io

lir

$ofle

_Th.

|aitj.rl[set!(i,m

rroress wis

ps(mtn

n) ar.nl

ju.l.nN

ro

!ho.i.thor..trnr.rrjrs

_{who L.rd I riNihr}

r.\tt

ol EnslLsh

rrftnt[rlr tn

_{(hri.n, ttr! s.lcFon}

fn,.c!s

rrr

rnro

cJ nr

ncii.

_r

nnn

rLljNrnt

ie,r.i'rstnLir.nmri

_{ntr nu.t.n$ \etrh}

i

_loLtrr

l!\tLoi

Enslnl

frofirtcn.r

lrrs.d,r rh.LnFr_

tiu), nnn!

!r.!F

troi(cd u.Lt nr

tdclq.inqthc

iory

Tl,

_{.lrtrLps, resirdle\ tL.ntrvcrs! lc\ats}

oiEnsli$

p

L.icnq,

uur

!,tNtut

b

!Lt1,or

cr.l) ncnrlier nJ

lwn

ufrtr.r{o.cs

_Frm

rlj.il

fna!.1lvriiing,

rh.ir$os.wri

!ohci$r

i

-d,ou!l' !onr. srammri.xt .rors $.tu

nr

Ar

n,ccnn.tnt! ariln''

di!{

_su,ps

\m

,,lnt

i,

pr.il!.crl{n\rly.ol.(nrr.rnsLis.Jonnt,

Ihr

otht

luDs

rrlnr.J

r,

_6.

ilt

_{N nk !cs!}

aul,NrLur

nc$

_{Wh,L. drly}

rttu

_rt,tr

6

_r.(L

do..r.umt)rrfrc\$.a\rni,r!l,a:dontll.n

rrlnugs, drc\rirnrgs

{ttu

riiurcLl t,

_orc

rHrl{r

.t

qdr _{pn{rN orly. I Lcr}

ho*du,

Jnftilft.J n,.j,,l\

qulty.nnrq

c.,.lj mcnb.r

,niLnnLlI,

ilt

_ri,l:

\rrt.

nor...!s:rtty

_rrl.r.,t

t,

..iliL,o

rir

$riufg

I,or cumnlc,

i:

ttrc

6kon

.Li'

n.rlwr

n.t 1\

trh ldr

otr funmrnrg

.fllnntro!!

urnDg, $mc _skrLps

t(i.l.J

_nl

JNri|u.

rl,r

tusli.r!Lilitt$

_h.ny!.n

uiltire

r!l

n rirtrq. tliu!, rh _N rvho hful x hi*her lckL

oiEngli\h

dnrhd

\rc:cLc(.J

b;.

_ttr! $fui,,g, ind

rlt

tu$ oi itrc

luLtr

N.i!

b

do tln,

rnN

olsri.nrg

rnl

lruir(th.

a.rivit),, n lvrs ollenrtt I trar tr.. vninr! was q r rc

!l

I.f

_s. iog

llr

ihe

s'

d.nN. This Nt!hi hxvc Lrrdr

.r,!,J

1,! tL. on. olihc.otrrsr objc.intr

tl[r

_i..trireJ

$uJuns r) bc lnrlc to dcm.ns(te rtrcir ln)itrN

o

Lvrnc

arsum.trii.k

_{csrys. Afpaktr.l,| $h.D}

(tr

$trdons

rtrc.Niin&d

b

_{Jo ire. uitnrg n,} c\Ptus

rhlir

..N,.rinr.oai[.n.1j(Nc

to\y!n.:

rjnre

oaixr nt*riiir!,

wh,.hsrstiusbr irl

drc

rr.vidN:.Drc$r. t\rnre

_rt,

r

Jqrs

upli.itlr !r[$scd rl(tr

_{.rmnm nr}

trr

.ctlcr

nrxf qriinrs

I r

'nt$Aqune$rl.

l(rsD!

6q.rN. ir

h

r dificrcnr.oh.err.attrat

oi .trgur,Br

h.

uri.n!,

whi.|

qs.,sri

_Ly

r,n.

odr.r{J.nN.

s,,m.nu(Lns

*,kd

rtDr,

'n

rrqumc'x{ir

$

i,rg. iljc,

\rr.

tuquftd to

lu'!,,n

'iiroJurb'yttn,,!rarh, t, s\.t

oii rL.tr

n].s Ntrli cvdrn.t,anLl n, u,ftc

r.on.lLrlns

I,i.,!,)dr

h,l.rtrAilc,

n{nlint

\rtur!

\t

n..

..r!srrlrr.quire'nironu&)a .r(Iklng

pir,'!rtfh:

This 11|i

.l

Nri'nrq, A

flrtrnF

rhr.d,

\n:

q,

h

_{rlrLLl.jsi,,! nn n,on}

truur!

rik\ hxJ

i.(&,n brfu.i.lrrron.lfn!

REFLECTION5

r,r rtr! r.fL!.riLm,

hurrutu$

6(!cJ

or

.hrnoil.rrn.ri.li.mp.tr!tii,

_{i,rI:,.mJljlnl}

!.rf

lnrle,ftciriln, on ni(

nnhL!nrnr

wrnDs nn]: Thq

!rrrJ

nr.it dr.n

r.,ltnr

rt,hrkifg

r

N.\nlnl l)tr.tr'\.d,crrrr.

n,!ft!(d

i..rstc

I

{.rr l)NJ.r

_tL. prtnrnrsnrcymJ. _{Al_}

nu

_rjh

trNi!

i

a.r! {rirms, rtr!

i.t$

() Nnn:

ih.

trcr ILNtJ

by ihc

pritun!

BN.J.n

(]t tuIh.i.n,

m"n

nr,l.",..iir.J

iLa

hq

d\rqtl

11!

lunnnr.n ,'.it

,ii.".

n.s Sone oI

nudut

lni

i.x!J

rnr

rL.\

l,J

n.t

.y|)c.t drit ihctr wnnns

Js\

).unL\

.nn.

t.nr

nt.irBiNi'rgs.

wth

ftsa n,thcr.lli6. r\t

wrnin!.tiei\-,

mo$ oi

drn{roro,lu,

nt\

J,J

r.t niii

wiritr!,n

sulr). HoNsar,.i.

{r-nrntcxl)li.itlr

{md

ilDt sLrc sN i.(LnL\

fiur

tr&d

$lrlr

ltr

jliouf 6.riusc dr€ othcr m.mli.rr ture slov inwrnnrsrnJ

nD.rricd

Nal Nnh

rlr&ingaml

intn g Shc

drl.d

upLvLit,ng rhe

Dtscua5to

UnlLk i

ntJr

d,r,lutrcJ l.|

Khr,lirn,l

Mc,lunri(1015)nt.(hi.harqhidc\FuinNtiL

r

tunt.lgnarp\

r

ninrlr,r.d thc rrnJs

oi

ihr

vitnrls.ftl[

ntr,.lut..idrc nn gnrN,

drnrudv Lln.i

aiienrN n,

lnfr.

nr. q1i.

n\ssoI..UiLo

iie! rnd no,MlL',1!trit(t

srirqrr$Niiiti

llrssLllrtue's .n{trJr i

r.xdor

on

..thb.ftn

r Nitnlq rn ivi,

t

ft'

nn

nniin

Lriitng

..nJntd

i,) n,c {tr(lf

\rs

onh

.onll0(nl

iii .nc

Nciirgniih

tr

lnrl.l,ch

lom rhe

lrhu

r.i'irli

.rhiJr Les

rltrtntr

Th.

Frntnr!rftlitl

tlN

ni.tJsJ

n,

hrltiud.nr:

gcncnic nlcir L,y dnn$thg n\.

..n..fr

oi

snnns

tlq

tucrdrl

tor(lur

Tl.Jisdstror

sir

6.rstu

r lci m

rs

cnvirrmcnt

tut1,.

{trJ.rr\,

r\ {rgg.$rJ

[r

v]nork\

(lr?ll),l,rlinr

rl).rrNftd rl...r "r

Tl,,

Js$snmwis

Jlo

r:d

n .nnm

n) ra.$

iuldtr:'itr!

ntrrl

.n

tL! $orl

th$\rnt(l

n.

(r(

rlnrLsh rhr

sur

Drisll.,lu.!.

wh.n rlr$

tnr.h

ilnrr

I he

nrJr

nnrlics

tLt

EU

icrLi..

n.cJ n)

rn!,r!

,1,{ 11[

..lhb.rlrir {riinr

i.ti"iti6

r.

qLkll\

\1,{ril,trrcJ

,m.n!

rk

mcml..A ofthe sbrps. TLr!,

cr$ runb.r

oi rhc grorp Lca6

'h.

$rr

rmounr

.l

r!\nr\ilLliq.

tor

dr

stuut's

nr.ss.

ALicrrn\

rh

atiihg uf snill _sroups,

.*

prks,

troru

be earcr

n\

tutclrds

b

sdrit

$

Jents _{s'nrll lr.ups} wiu aL$

rlhw$ud.trsto

onriLrt.ln

rc rolliboratn,i,

nrh

as

w.rlirs

on rh.

a.m.y

o(tl,c $rltilre.

\nodrcr

imflicltiot

.f

Ais *uJy is

d

t

fr.\dLngslrcon. thcn,cs

mil

Lc [clFri'l ior

dtrJrn.

b.rctu

adon, nrlr.r dnD nNnt!tcll

{udutr

to .hoosc ihc

!rt,i.

Khitnl

Nn.il

nr

ll0L, a:l!.Idtir

{rJ.nh

ii, _-..fue

i

fi.\!.r!riii'r!

n:i'rn tlr. rod. dicv 1,,Nid.J .a.h

scc!,{hirh

Nishtha\r

hcl$i

6.n$u,

.lrn6

r

rl,.

.rNri'n.nbl

lmup t.,

n(t..I

l'r.rkhn! n,I,iN nn

ntr,l.m

.rn

h.h

s

!*s

to

rrrN

Jo{n rl,cn nlcxs inLl ta.us thcir

ttertlon

on drt giroi

mri.

Thc

t)l,ic rc

norncicsnrily

tu

l.ruJcnn.rd

dlr$N

snJcnh

mif

rd

dlairnri.$o

!le\anr tl,(

t,Di

Toti(wth

lvl,l!h suJcnr trrc

lin,ilir

will l.romc

i

grcrt

.ontriLrti.r

n,

$urlut'

nL.rdr

coNclusloll

c.llil,omtnt

Niti,,s

[ry

h,vc L](n

p.lrlUr

n, n'my

L.in

n!

..nt!rtt

Mxrv EFL ter.l,$s otrl

l!^t

in$n.tuJ ilrln

nliLti\

to

wit.

an

r.rJcnrn 1.t'l\cr, lrtrlLcinr

i,oikl,

or

nunr.thcr

Lnr.[oIfi..r:oi{rninr: lhcrniqrtn$t,l

nris

nnhLon

l

\rnii,g r(rLry1vs

rlutth!

dhttrrnrn

Ri:

orlL.d.n

ticsrn

iml

$uauis

w.r

cn..urqcJ n)

s,t[

rl.sdywth

.n.

utlrr

Thnnqh the

t!,d,.i..|scrvfi.n.

flncnF

iNol.J

n,

dth,(nL( rrm.a

n'.ni,\

90

su.l.nts wdc x[]. r,

xrl

lollxb.ntrldy nr

turms.f\!ririn!

Mxnf $udcn6

(i.ru

rnor

rhr

menbe^ ol dre gr.urs ntrc

o

rlc

lonlol

Enllish

r,.n.i.nrrIx

(lcrnD

il$ slurJ

tlmi.n.

n'lcnrl(lr

lrrn

rcd Nhen

hdero

r

mcn'bc^

sR\t ur thr

sirinqwoi!

io

L.i

()'

rl)c oiher

snle, h.r

fru$

tion

nilhr

live

L(n

uu{i

trr.

h.r

n.i

tx,og

i6l. t.

(ork

(nlilrlr.rtnth(dr

$uJ.rFwlohrd

l.,w{ llvck oi Ershh _fnni.

REFERENCEs

Bn.hrf,J.,Y{

rs,S,6r

(imcn

,l)

(1005)

'lhr.{L(

_{oIdL*!rcr. 41,!s or nxrc.tn?}

li.d6r&.tr Esl-$d.nt\rnnis

/oin'"i ol

5..o t

L,,&re

U/,r'tra, 14, t!l-105. Eld.i. r..&

(\ti.:.A.

coto)

(i,

iLor.rc

wri.nrg, l_.nrrnr-e inogn l$gu.s. .mJ

rritins r oNann.rs

JdtLr)flnrrl

LanFdk

Ldn,r{d/

ri..JuDroc, t4

(r,

1-71

llodg.r,(i.al

(?001).

Lcunnrrrl[.rrh..UiLD

Drnt

ui1i,,s

Ltudn,

ja

(l),1-1c

Kluriir,l\'1, SL N1!,hami, H. (1015). L-tsuging

rnn wnms.liUs,

Th..ll1(,)ai)llrl,or

iv!

\rrnrne

or

EFI

{lJori

viu

ns _Nrli,,minrc

A&r&6

m Lan(!rq.aiJ Ltrdra

srdilr,6(l),

l0l.t1l

L,noll,J,

srlhom.

s

I

(lco?)

Sornuhrtl

d,eorrdiJ

slr.mlh sr,'!rl.rniru.

L, B

un

P*r$,&l

Vnl'.,ms Tl@rir! 0

lnnl

L',sric.

drrntun

(J!. 201.rr.1) Nhhrih, NJ

I.,l.

&

F\LrnJ, n (1007)

EnhridnritrJ.

i

trcrson.nr

rJ

m.rilrii.f

i,i

$nirs:T|.

ri:c oil,rinltry

*ltenri

in 1l.!rs

Kr!

nn,,

qs-o

r,^sxrlr

lvtni,r(,

16,Ilr.tl?

[(nli!r],1),

&

(irroi,lo, R.

(l0ll).

A.olhlnm-riv. writug rpDrua.h; Meilrdolog) drd

$(lent

issessmctrt. T]t l,rglla!/

]i/!lur,

JJ

oI

j.10.

N

r.r,l.(2009). Hos hlre a

{.ab

laryn

n@ied tur rtarlnrs &d lis&ningl

Cdrl'dn

MoJ.n lnastr{& nd.iru, 6 r ( _{r), 59-91}

Rollins.n, P. (2004)

Exncri.n.cs Nr.q\nrs

r

ESLrci,lcnt

with!

tocrrsaof!,

!d'rr

&nxlioi lnsLs & h Unimidd,l

Contl'n.k,

12, 79-108.

Spe.t, B

'i(

(1001). Ari[rarin

rn./(

r

@llzrDru.

ri,r

rri&'(

Sl'

lo*.y.Bis.

Sr.r.h, N. (2005).

(lolhLronri(

ritnrlr.

trod!(

Forc$,

iNln(denLi

rene.iioN.

lomd

o/

SonJ LanFkr& W,,.ins, l+ (1511?r).

Sdrh,N.

(l0ll)

CollaLromnn srnin! ln

L]

.ont xts ko.cscs, .ur.omds,

^n,l

fNfrc

dtrdions

Annkr Rd Ee oi Arr,lild L ,o,n.nx,

Vlsoisty, L S. (197!). Mini i,,ro.iE4i Ti{ JarloE

,r.tr

olLiduplr.,

osiar

prec,s

cimbridse,