THE READABILITY LEVEL OF READING TEXTS IN ADVANCED LEARNING ENGLISH 2 TEXTBOOK
BY USING CLOZE TEST
A Thesis
Submitted in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirement for the Degree of Sarjana Pendidikan
By :
ATIKAH SARAYAH
Registration Number 2113121009
ENGLISH AND LITERATURE DEPARTEMENT
FACULTY OF LANGUAGES AND ARTS
i ABSTRACT
Sarayah, Atikah. Registration Number: 2113121009. The Readability Level of Reading Texts in Advanced Learning English 2 Textbook by Using Cloze Test. A Thesis. English Educational Program, State University of Medan, 2016.
This research dealt with the eleventh grade students’ Cloze Test in reading texts. This research used a qualitative design in which the data are taken from five reading texts in a textbook. This study was done to find out the readability level of a book undertitled Advanced Learning English 2 Textbook used in SMA Dharma Pancasila Medan. The population of this study was 125 students who were distributed into 4 classes, but the writer only took 58 students as the sample using random technique to get a representative sample. The procedures were conducted by distributing the cloze test to the students, collecting data, correcting data, calculating data, analyzing data, interpreting data and the last was concluding the result of the study. The analysis found that: 1) 4 texts get the average score above 53%; Text 1 (95%), Text 2 (56.95%), Text 3 (58.92%), and Text 4 (78.58%). Those reading texts are included into Independent Level. It means that the texts are quite easy since the students could answer the cloze test easily. Furthermore, the last text (48.73%) is included into Instructional Level because it is in the range between 44 and 53 percent. It means that the text is appropriate for students and they could understand the text but still need teacher’s instruction. From the finding result, the writer get the average score of 5 reading texts is 67.63%. It is included into Independent Level. Therefore it is concluded that the reading texts in Advanced Learning English 2 textbook are not suitable to be used by students and teacher because the texts are quite easy. The students can read the texts independently. It is expected that the finding of this research is useful for everyone who wants to study about readability level of a textbook.
ii
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
First of all, the writer would like to thank The Almighty Allah SWT for
His blessings, strength, and patience so the writer is able to accomplish her thesis
as a partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Sarjana Pendidikan at
the English Department, Faculty of Languages and Arts (FBS) in State University
of Medan (UNIMED).
The historical and meaningful process of realizing this thesis, surprisingly
has created relationship and involvement between the writer and a great number
of people who have contribution to finishing this thesis. The writer would like to
express her sincere gratitude to:
1. Prof. Dr. Syawal Gultom, M.Pd,the Rector of State University of Medan.
2. Dr. Isda Pramuniati, M.Hum., the Dean Faculty of Languages and Arts.
3. Prof. Dr. Hj. Sumarsih, M.Pd.,the Head of English Department and Nora
Ronita Dewi, S. S., M. Hum., the Head of Education Program of English
Department.
4. Dr. Anni Holila Pulungan, M.Hum and Rita Suswati, S.Pd, M.Hum., her
Thesis Supervisors.
5. Dra. Sortha Silitonga,M.Pd.,her Academic Advisor.
6. Dra. Masitowarni, M.Ed., and Prof. Amrin Saragih, M.A., Ph.D, her Thesis
Reviewers.
7. All the Lecturers of English Department who have taught and guided her
throughout the academic years that could not be mentioned one by one.
8. Gimin and Paini, her beloved parents for their unconditional love, warmth,
iii
they gave that can make the writer understands and appreciates the meaning
of struggle in life.
9. The writer’s sincere gratitude also goes to her dearest sisters and
brothersYayuk, Kak fitri, Bang Darwin, and Kak Lia, for the supports, love
and pray.
10. Ahmad, Anis, Ammar, Hana, Hanif, Aira, and Husna as her nephews and
nieces for their cheerfulness.
11. Eis Sri Wahyuni, M.Pd, and Mr. Pantes, the administration staff of English
Department, for her attention, assistance, and information
12. Headmaster, Vice Headmasters and English Teachers in SMA Dharma
Pancasila Medan for time, chance and cooperation.
13. Sri Lestari Setyawan and Chairunnisaher best friends for love, time, laugh,
happiness, supports, togetherness and everything that they experienced
together in formal and informal occasions in achieving S.Pd.
14. All Students Class B of English Education 2011 who suddenly had
interaction and helped the writer in accomplishing all requirements for
graduation.
There are many people whose names are not mentioned above, the writer
thanks them for their support in finishing her study, may Allah SWT bless you all.
Medan, February 2016 The Writer
Atikah Sarayah
ii
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
First of all, the writer would like to thank The Almighty Allah SWT for
His blessings, strength, and patience so the writer is able to accomplish her thesis
as a partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Sarjana Pendidikan at
the English Department, Faculty of Languages and Arts (FBS) in State University
of Medan (UNIMED).
The historical and meaningful process of realizing this thesis, surprisingly
has created relationship and involvement between the writer and a great number
of people who have contribution to finishing this thesis. The writer would like to
express her sincere gratitude to:
1. Prof. Dr. Syawal Gultom, M.Pd,the Rector of State University of Medan.
2. Dr. Isda Pramuniati, M.Hum., the Dean Faculty of Languages and Arts.
3. Prof. Dr. Hj. Sumarsih, M.Pd.,the Head of English Department and Nora
Ronita Dewi, S. S., M. Hum., the Head of Education Program of English
Department.
4. Dr. Anni Holila Pulungan, M.Hum and Rita Suswati, S.Pd, M.Hum., her
Thesis Supervisors.
5. Dra. Sortha Silitonga,M.Pd.,her Academic Advisor.
6. Dra. Masitowarni, M.Ed., and Prof. Amrin Saragih, M.A., Ph.D, her Thesis
Reviewers.
7. All the Lecturers of English Department who have taught and guided her
throughout the academic years that could not be mentioned one by one.
8. Gimin and Paini, her beloved parents for their unconditional love, warmth,
iii
they gave that can make the writer understands and appreciates the meaning
of struggle in life.
9. The writer’s sincere gratitude also goes to her dearest sisters and
brothersYayuk, Kak fitri, Bang Darwin, and Kak Lia, for the supports, love
and pray.
10. Ahmad, Anis, Ammar, Hana, Hanif, Aira, and Husna as her nephews and
nieces for their cheerfulness.
11. Eis Sri Wahyuni, M.Pd, and Mr. Pantes, the administration staff of English
Department, for her attention, assistance, and information
12. Headmaster, Vice Headmasters and English Teachers in SMA Dharma
Pancasila Medan for time, chance and cooperation.
13. Sri Lestari Setyawan and Chairunnisaher best friends for love, time, laugh,
happiness, supports, togetherness and everything that they experienced
together in formal and informal occasions in achieving S.Pd.
14. All Students Class B of English Education 2011 who suddenly had
interaction and helped the writer in accomplishing all requirements for
graduation.
There are many people whose names are not mentioned above, the writer
thanks them for their support in finishing her study, may Allah SWT bless you all.
Medan, February 2016 The Writer
Atikah Sarayah
iv
CHAPTER II.REVIEW OF LITERATURE ... 6
A.Theoretical Framework ... 6
d. The Factors Influencing Text... 11
e. Matching a Text to Students ... 12
3. Readability ... 12
a. Definition of Readability ... 12
b. Factors Affecting Readability ... 13
v
4. Cloze Test ... 18
a. The Concept of Cloze Test ... 18
b. Constructing the Cloze Test... 20
c. Administering the Cloze Test ... 21
d. Scoring and Interpreting Cloze Test ... 21
B.Relevant Studies ... 23
C.Conceptual Framework ... 24
CHAPTER III.RESEARCH METHOD ... 26
A.The Research Design... 26
B.Place and Time of Research ... 26
C.Population and Sample ... 27
D.Techniques of Collecting Data ... 27
E. Instrument for Collecting the Data ... 27
F. The Techniquesof Data Analysis ... 28
CHAPTER IV.DATA ANALYSIS, FINDINGS AND DISCUSSIONS
..
30A.Data Analysis ... 30
B.Findings ... 34
C.Discussions ... 36
CHAPTER V. CONCLUSIONS AND SUGGESTIONS
...
38A.Conclusions ... 38
B.Suggestions ... 39
REFERENCES ... 41
vii
LIST OF PICTURE
vi
LIST OF TABLES
Pages
Table 2.1 The percentage mark of the cloze test ... 22
Table 4.1 The Number of Data Analysis of the Deleted words ... 31
Table 4.2.The Percentage of Data Analysis of Deleted Words... 32
viii
LIST OF APPENDICES
Pages
Appendix A. John Gilbert . ... 44
Appendix B.The Ugly Duckling ... 45
Appendix C. Drinking Coffee has Health Benefit ... 46
Appendix D.The Golden Snail ... 47
Appendix E. Komodo Dragon... 48
Appendix F.The Score of Students ... 50
Appendix G.The Percentage Score of Students ... 52
Appendix H. Independent Level ... 54
Appendix I. Instructional Level ... 59
1
CHAPTER I
INTRODUCTION
A. The Background of the Study
In the present fast developing world, knowledge and information spreads
rapidly. People very easy to get knowledge and information from many
sources.Reading is one of the ways to get information about many things in this
world and it is very important to consider that reading should be encouraged to
everyone.Reading is the basis for learning different subjects in schools. Lems
(2009:170) states that reading is an envolving interaction between the text and the
background knowledge of the reader. It can be inferred that a text in reading has
correlation to the students’ background knowledge therefore the text should be
selected based on the students’ understanding.
Further, in English curriculum, Educational Unit-Oriented Curriculum
(Kurikulum Tingkat Satuan Pendidikan : KTSP) 2006, of Senior High School
level states that there are four skills should be achieved in learning process
namely, listening, speaking, reading, and writing. Reading is one of four skills
that must be mastered.
In mastering the reading skill, both the teacher and the students need some
mediums of instruction to facilitate them. One of the mediums of instruction
which is used in every level of students in the schools is a textbook. A textbook
has an important role in facilitating students studying the language, especially in
2
The English textbook which the eleventh grade students use isAdvanced
LearningEnglish 2 for Grade XI Senior High School (Nature and Social Science Programmes) published by Facil, a brand product of Grafindo Media Pratama. The textbook is based on Educational Unit-Oriented Curriculum
(Kurikulum Tingkat Satuan Pendidikan : KTSP) 2006. The genres of texts in that
book are report, narrative, exposition, and spoof. The genres are based on the
syllabus of the eleventh grade student. In doing observation, the writer also asked
the teacher about the text in that books whether they are readable for students or
not. The teacher said that some of the students still get difficulty to understand the
reading texts in the textbook, especially the vocabularies while other students get
easy of them.
From that book page 19, a text which the titled is Komodo Dragon in the
third paragraph, some students still get difficulty and others are easy to understand
about it, as follow :
The natural habitat of Komodo dragons is extremely harsh by human standards. These arid volcanic islands have step slopes and little available water most of the year. A short monsoon season often produces local flooding. The average annual temperature at sea level on Komodo island is 80 F degrees. Dragons are most abundant in the lower arid forest and savanna.
From the paragraph above, the students get difficulty in translating and
understanding some words such as harsh, monsoon, abundant, and arid.
Encouraged by this problem, the writer would like to know the readability level of
the reading texts of that textbook by using cloze test.
The process of selecting a good textbook is actually difficult. There are
3
process as well as possible to make the students easy to understand and even have
motivation in every time in learning English. Harmer (1983:153) said that it is
often difficult to convince students of English as a foreign language that texts in
English can be understood even though there are vocabulary items and structures
that students have never seen before.
A good English textbook is easy to read, easy to understand, and easy to
comprehend for students. The easier the text is, the better students can understand
and read. On the other hand, if the textbook is a difficult one, they will lose their
motivation in learning English .
It really important for teacher to knowing the students’ reading ability in
comprehending and understanding textbooks. There are some choices and ways of
selecting a good English textbook which is readable for students according to
their education levels by using readability analysis. It is used in analyzing the
readability level of texts in a textbook. To finding the result of this analysis a
readability test is needed as the tool. From its tool, an English texts provided in
English textbook is known whether it is difficult, plain or easy for students.
Neil (1992:212) stated : a text can be readable when the reader can match
the concepts of the text and has scheme for processing it. Readability of text is
very useful for students in understanding the text. Students can easily catch on the
meaning of the text when the text is readable and they can convey on its meaning.
After knowing that selecting a textbook is important, the writer tries to
make a research about it. To answer and understand about the readability of a
4
observation. After she got permission, the writer asked the teacher some questions
about the English textbook which is used by the students especially at the
eleventh grade of the school. The writer chose the eleventh grade students
because she considered if the eleventh grade students is better than the tenth and
twelfth in this research. She thought that the tenth grade still needs more
adaptation with their new school, while the twelfth grade must prepare and focus
on their final examination. So, the writer just focus on the eleventh grade students
of SMA Dharma Pancasila.
B. The Problem of the Study
Based on the background of study, the problem is formulated as follow : Is
the textbook Advanced Learning English 2 readable for the students of the
eleventh grade of SMA Dharma Pancasila Medan ?
C. The Objective of the Study
In line with what has been stated in the problem of the study, this study
tries to describe and analyze the readability level of texts in Advanced Learning
English 2 for Grade XI Senior High School (Nature and Social Science
Programmes) published by Facil, a brand product of Grafindo Media Pratama
2013.
D. The Scope of the Study
The scope of this study is describe the readability level of five reading
texts that are taken from the English Textbook Advanced Learning English 2 for
5
E. The Significance of the Study
Findings of this study are expected to provide information which may have
theoretical as well as practical values or significance.
Theoretically, the findings of the study later will add some new theories
and information in selecting the appropriate English textbook. Meanwhile
practically, the findings become source of reference for the English teachers
especially in Senior High School in their attempts to selecting the appropriate
English textbook.
The findings are also expected to pose challenges to authors and
publishers on the need to re-assess their publications and make readable texts
available to students. Finally, the findings of this study can be used by other
38 CHAPTER V
CONCLUSION AND SUGGESTION
A. Conclusions
The The problem of this study tries to observe is the readability level of
reading texts. To get the data about this, the writer distributed the cloze tests of the
eight reading texts. After analyzing and interpreting the data of the eight reading
texts in Advanced Learning English 2 textbook through cloze tests, the result
shows that there are four texts have the cloze test score above 53%. They are the
first text John Gilbert (95%), the second text The Ugly Duckling (56.95%), the
third text Dringking Coffee has Health Benefit (58.92%), the forth text the Golden
Snail (78.58%) and the fifth text so the judgment score is in the Independent level.
The texts are predicted to be quite easy. It means that the students are likely to be
able to understand the text by themselves. While the other text has the cloze test
score approximately 44%-53%. The text is Komodo Dragon (48.73%). The text is
predicted to be of appropriate difficulty. It means that the students may need some
continuing assistance with the texts.
Based on the cloze test result, the writer gets the average score of 5
reading texts is 67.63% so it can be concluded that reading texts of Advanced
Learning English 2 are in the Independent level because the reading texts are
readable and understandable to the eleventh grade students of SMA Dharma
39
writer takes a conclusion that this textbook is not appropriate to be used by the
students at the eleventh grade students of SMA Dharma Pancasila Medan because
they can read them by their own.
B. Sugestions
There are some suggestions for English teachers, the principal, the
publisher and other researchers.
1. For the English teachers
The English teachers should not depend only on one textbook in using the
instructional materials. The teachers have to select a suitable textbook for
their students which are readable, understandable and interesting.
2. For the principal
The principal should help the teachers in providing teaching materials by
supplying English textbooks adequately for all students and appropriate for
the students’ needs and level.
3. For the publishers and authors
The publishers and the authors are expected to pay attention in producing
the better textbooks which appropriate with the level of the students’
ability as the good textbook which can help both the teacher and the
40
4. For Other Researchers
There are still so many textbooks offered by other publishers. The other
researchers can use them as the subject of the research. For those
interested in studying about the readability, you can use the other
techniques besides cloze test. The writer hopes that this research can give
41
REFERENCES
Adawiyah, Tuti, 2006. An Analysis of the Readability Level of “Developing Competence in English Grade VIII” Textbook for Junior High School. Jakarta : Syarif Hidayatullah State Islamic University.
Alderson, J. Charles, 2000. Assessing Reading. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Allington, Richard and Michael Strange., 1980. Learning Through Reading in the Content Area. Lexiton : DC Health and Company.
Anderson, Mark and Kathy Anderson, 1997. Text Types in English 2. Sout Yarra: Macmillan Education Australia.
Ary, D. et al., 2002. Introduction to Research in Education. Stanford: Wadsworth/Thomson Learning
Aukeman, Robert C., 1997. Reading in The Secondary School Classroom, New York : Mc. Graw Hill Company.
Beard, Roger, 1990. Developing Reading 3-13, Second Edition, London: Hodder & Stoughton.
Biber, D., 2006. University language : A Corpus-Based Study of Spoken and Written registers. Amsterdam : John Benjamin B.V.
Browers, Rogers and CJ. Brumfit.(eds.)., 1980. Applied Linguistics and English Language Teaching .London: MacMillian Publishers.
Darwesh, Abdul-Jabbar Ali. 2010. Cloze Test : An Integrative Approach. Baghdad: University of Al-Mustansiriyah College of Basic Education.
42
Fatoba and Oba, Joseph. 2014. Readability Level of Recommended Chemistry Textbooks and Students’ Academic Performance in Senior Secondary Schools in Ekiti State. Nigeria, International Journal of Education and Research, No 9.
Guzzetti, B.J. 2002. Literacy in America: An Ensyclopedia of History, Theory and Practice : Vol. 1. California: ABC-CLIO
Harmer, Jeremy. 1983. The Practice of Language Teaching. London : Longman Group.
---. 1991. The Practice of Language Teaching. London : Longman Group UK Limited.
Heaton, J.B. 1990. Classroom Testing. London : Longman Group UK Limited.
Hughes, Arthur. 2003. Testing for Language Teachers, Second Edition, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Klare, G.R. 1982. Readability in P.D. Pearson (Ed). Handbook of reading research. New York : Longman Published Ltd.
Kolahi, Sholeh. 2012. A Comparative Study of the Readability of English Textbooks of Translation and Their Persian Translations. International Journal of Linguistics.
Lems, K. 2009. Teaching Reading to English Language Learners: Insights from Lingusitic. New York: Guilford Publication.
Nuttal, Christine. 1982. Teaching Reading Skills in a Foreign Language, Oxford: Heinemann International.
Oakland, T. and Lane, H. 2004. Language, reading, and readability formulas: Implications for developing and adapting tests. International Journal of Testing.4, 239-252.
Perekeme, B.A.D and Agbor, C.A 2012. Readability of Language Textbooks Prescribed for Junior Secondary Schools and Students’ Performance in Reading Comprehension in Bayelsa State, Nigeria. British Journal of Arts and Social Scienses. Vol. 9 No 1
Rahmat, Mulia, 2014. Readability of Texts in State Examination of Senior High School. Medan : State University of Medan.
Smith, Nila Banton, and H. Alan Robinson, 1980. Reading Instruction for Today’s Children, Second Edition, New York: Prentice-Hall, Inc.
43
Taylor, W. 1953, Cloze Procedure : A new tool for measuring readability. Journalism Quarterly
