• Tidak ada hasil yang ditemukan

Mathematical Model Of The Intra Venous Glucose Tolerance Test Using Modified Minimal Model

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2017

Membagikan "Mathematical Model Of The Intra Venous Glucose Tolerance Test Using Modified Minimal Model"

Copied!
7
0
0

Teks penuh

(1)
(2)

Alma and Scope: The Fer East Journal of. Methe171,atlcal Sciences (FJMS) Is devoted to publishing original re ... rdl papers and critJcal IUMIY 8111cle1 In the fteld ot Pure and App/lad Mathemetlcs, Computer App/lea/Ions and Stailatics. The FJMS /1 • lortn/ghl/y journal published In twelve 'IO/umes 811nueUy and each 'IO/ume comprises of two

I-•.

Abalnetlng, Indexing and Review•: Global Impact Factor : 0.692, Scopus, Mathematical Reviews, MathSciNet, ProQueat, lndexCopemlcua, EBSCOhoat, Zentralblatt MATH, Ulrlc:h'a web, Indian Science Abs1111cts, SCIRUS, OCLC, Google Scholar, ExceMence In Reaearch for Australia (ERA), Acedemk:Keya.

Submlulon of Manuacrlpla: Authors may submit their papers for c:onlideratlon In the Far East Journal of MathemaUcal Sclencaa (FJMS) by the followtng modes:

1. OnHna aubmlaalon: P l -vtait journal's homepage at http://www.pphmj.com/joumals/ljms.htm 2. Electronically: At the e-mall llddresa: Qmll@pphmj.com or kkazed@pphmj.com

3. Hard copln: Papers In duplicate with a letter of aubmlaaion at the llddresa ot the publisher.

The paper mual be typed only on one aide In double spacing with a generous margin all round. An effort Is made to publish a paper duly recommended by a referee within a period ot three months. One set ot galley proofs of a paper will be sent to the author aubmlttlng the paper, unless requested othefwise, without the original manuscript, for corractlona.

Abatnlct and Referencaa: Authors are requested to provide an abstract ot not more than 250 words and latest Mathematk:I Subject Classfflcatlon. Statements of Lemmas, Propoaitlona and Theorema should be aet In /la/lcs and referencet should be arranged In elpllabetJcal order by the surname ot the tlrat author.

Page Charges and Raprlnta: Authors are requested to arrange page charges of their papers @ USO 40.00 per

page ヲセ@ USA and Canada, and EUR 30.00 per page for rest ot the work! from their Institutions/research grants, If any. However, for authors In India thla charge la R1. 800.00 per page. No extra charges for colour figures . Twenty-ftve reprints In print wrslon and a copy In IOft wrslon are provided to the corresponding author ex-gratis. Addltlonal

aets of reprints may be onlered at the time of proof correction.

Copyright: It Is aaaumed that the aubmltted manuscript has not been published and will not be simultaneously aubmltted or published elHWhere, By submitting a manuscript, the authors agree that the copyright for their articles

la tranaferr'ed to the Pushpa Publlahlng Houae, Allahabad, India, If and when. the paper la accepted for publication.

The publisher cannot lake the responaibUlty of any loss of manuscript. Therefore, authors are requested to maintain a copy at their end.

Subscription Information for 2013 lnaUtutional Price for all countries exce India

Electronic SubacripUon E720.00

Print Subscription Includes Online Access E 1195.00

USS 995.00 USS 1695.00

For lnallluCionl: On MMJng • - lor """""9(1) ol the F• e .. 1 Joumel of

Me...,_--.

(FJMS), エィ・セ@ l o _

Md prinl lhe - will be 8Y8llellle lhn>IJgh lhe inltllutlonel 8 dlgff1 IP - · lo be pnwtded by 1he . _ w t e euthorily. The

f8cillly lo - will c:onlJnue 1111 lhe end ol lhe noxt Cllender yew from the lell illue ol the volume IUblalbed. For セョァ@ conllnuod ヲセ@ lo keep lhe - of the - llUbocttbed volume for onolher IWo c a - r ve-mey be had on • conoldereble

dlacounled rate.

Price In lndlan Ra. For Indian lnstltuUons In India onl

Print Subscription Only Rs. 15000.00

The IUbacrtptlon セ。イ@ runa from January 1, 2013 through December 31, 2013.

Information: The journals published by the •puahpa Publishing House· are solely distributed by the "Vljaya Booka and Joumala Dlatrtbutora•.

Contact Person: SubscripUon Manager, Vljaya Books and Journals Distributors, Vljaya Nlw81, 198 Mumfordganj, Allahabad 211002, India; aub@pphmj.com; arun@pphmj.com

Information for Special Volume 2013

Special Volume 2013 (supplementary volume) of the Far East Journal of Mathematical Sciences (FJMS) ls devoted to article• on Computer Sciences, Information Sciences, Financial Management and Biological Sciences, c:onalltlng of six laauea to appear In the month ot February, Aprlt, June, August. October and December. It la In llddltlon to Ila

regular volumes.

The special volume conaldara orlgnal reaeardl papers and crlUcat survey articles baslcatly lying In the following

area1:

1. Development of theory and methods for Computer and lnformaUon Sciences

2. lntrtllllc force bringing Mathematica and Computer Science closure for sclenUflc and engineering advancement 3. Impact ot MathemaUcal techniques In Biological Sciences

4 . Appllcallon of Mathemallca In Financial Management

5. Analylil of algorithms and Soflwara toots for computational work lnatltutional Price for all countries exce t India

Electronic Subscription

Print Sublcrtptlon Include• Online Access Price In lndl9n Rs. (For Indian lnllilutlona In India only)

I

Print Subacrtptlon 0nty

E 215.00 USS 315.00 E355.00 USS525.00

Rs. 3500.00

S

Far East Journal of Mathematic11I Sciences (FJMS) © 2013 Push pa Publishing House , Allahabad. l!1dia Available online al hnp://pphmj .com/joumalsifJms .htm

S ecial Volume 2013, Pan VI. Pages 587-5% ..

.p d I . l "o1111111 S··1 Info S<i F111an<ll1I Mana" & 111111. s,1.)

(Devote 10 an1c ..:son · · .. ·· · · "

MA TH EMA TICAL MODEL OF THE INTRA VENOUS

GLUCOSE TOLERANCE TEST USING

MODIFIED MINIMAL MODEL

Nurullaeli, Agus Kartono and Kiagus Dahlan

Laboratory for Theoretical and Computational Physics

Physics Department

Faculty of Mathematical and Natural Sciences

Bogor Agricultural University (!PB) Jalan Meranti, Building Wing S, 2nd Floor Kampus IPB Darmaga, Bogor 16680, Indonesia

e-mail: aguskartono70@yahoo.com

Abstract

The modified minimal model of glucose and insulin plasma levels .is

I セ、@ to analyze the results of glucose tolerance tests 111

common y オウセ@ · . .

humans . In this paper. a mathematical model for dcscnh111g the

lucose infusion rate is introduced . The modified minimal model was

セウ・、@

to study a few sets of published data including healthy humans

and type 2 diabetes . The gluc0se-i nsulin system is a dynamic

integrated physiological system and gcneratcs the rcal ッーエQQュセ・、@

model parameters from the experimental data using the 111od1hed

· · 1 d ·1 ·1·hc avcra,,ed rセ@ va lue between measured and

m11111na mo c . o

calculated plasma concentrations is 0.977 . which indicates excellent

agreement.

Received : October 26, 20 13 ; Accepted : Nov em her 22. 2013

2010 Mathematics Subject Classification: 37-XX. 37M05 .

Keywords and phrases: modified minimal model, intravenous glucose tolerance test.

(3)

588 Nurullaeli, Agus Kartono and Kiagus Dahlan

Introduction

Human bodies need to maintain a glucose concentration level in a narrow range (70-110 mg/di or 3.9-6.04 mmol/l after overnight fast) . lfone's glucose concentration level is significantly out of the normal range, then this person is considered to have a plasma glucose problem: hyperglycemia or hypoglycemia. Diabetes mellitus, or simply, diabetes, is characterized by high blood glucose levels resulted from defects in the glucose-insulin endocrine metabolic regulatory system, in which either the pancreas does not

イ・ャ・セウ・@ insulin or the cells do not properly use insulin to uptake glucose.

. Diabetes mellitus has become an epidemic disease in the sense of life st)rle. To diagnose whether or not an individual subject is already a diabetic or has the potential to develop such disease, the so-called metabolic portrait, including the insulin sensitivity index and glucose effectiveness, of the subject needs to be sketched. To this end, several glucose tolerance tests have been developed and applied in clinics and experiments. The fundamental idea of such tests is to examine the response of insulin, called insulin sensitivity,

after a large amount of glucose is infused into one's body . A commonly used protocol is the intravenous glucose tolerance test (IVGTT).

Type 2 diabetes (formerly called non-insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus, NIDDM, or adult-onset diabetes), a more widespread metabolic disorder, is primarily characterized by insulin resistance, relative insulin deficiency and hyperglycemia. Some cases of type 2 diabetes also appear to be an autoimmune disease where the immune system attacks the P-cells, decreasing the function of producing insulin, while other type 2 diabetes cases may simply result from excessive body weight that strains the ability of

the P-cells to produce sufficient insulin.

In the procedure of IYGTT, overnight fast is required for the subject, and then the subject is given a bolus of glucose infusion intravenously, for example, 0.33g/kg body weight or 0.5g/kg body weight of a 50% solution, and is administered into an antecubital vein in approximately 2 min. To observe the metabolic regulation between the glucose and insulin, within the next 180 min, the plasma glucose and serum insulin of the subject

Mathematical Model of the Intravenous Glucose Tolerance Test . . . 589

arc sampled frequently at the time marks 2', 4', 6', 8', JO', 12', 14', 18', 21', 24', 30', 35', 40', 45', 50', 60', 70', 80', 90', 100', 120', 140', 160' and 180'. According to the rich information constituted in the sampled data, appropriate analysis can reveal the metabolic portrait.

One popular approach of the analysis is as follows : (I) fonnulate or choose a well-formulated kinetic model based on physiology ; (2) estimate the parameters of the IVGTT model with experimental data, and then (3) the parameter values are used to obtain physiological infonnation , for example, the insulin sensitivity and glucose effectiveness.

The intravenous glucose tolerance test (IVGTT), as an important experimental procedure for the estimation of glucose effectiveness and immlin sensitivity, has been widely used, because it is relatively easy to measure, and its analysis generates a lot of information. The test includes injecting a glucose bolus and then collecting a set of plasma glucose and insulin samples over a period of 3-5 h. For diabetic patients, it is sometimes necessary to have an exogenous insulin infusion because of insufficient endogenous insulin secretion despite stimulation by the glucose injection.

The glucose-insulin system as an in\egrated dynamic system m physiology, however, should be described mathematically as a whole. When an integrated dynamic system is split into two interacting sub-systems, and then, the system parameters are optimized by fitting the measured data separately, the generated parameters cannot be thought as optimal ones for the whole system. In the glucose-insulin physiological system both glucose and insulin have feedback effects on each other via pancreatic response and stimulation. It is worth to obtain optimized model parameters from measured plasma glucose and insulin concentrations simultaneously in the time course by using the regression method. This single-step parameter-fitting process could generate a real optimal approximation to the dynamical integrated glucose-insulin system without losing the interaction infom1ation implicitly contained in the measured concentration profiles.

(4)

a measure of the dependence of fractional glucose disappearance. The latter term represents a measure of the fractional ability of glucose to lower its own concentration in plasma independent of increased insulin at basal insulin, to normalize its own concentration within the extracellular glucose pool. This normalization occurs after glucose administration and may involve glucose-mediatcd inhibition of hepatic glucose output and/or accelerated glucose disposition.

The Modified Minimal Model from the IVGTT

The dynamic insulin and glucose responses to glucose injection were analyzed as previously described lo yield the individual parameters of the minimal model. The modified minimal model, which we proposed as the simplest representation that can account for the dynamics of glucose during the IVGTT, is described by the following differential equations :

dG(t)

-;ff= P1(Gh

- G(t))- X(t)G(t), G(to)

=Go.

(1)

dX(t)

-;ff=

-p2X(t) + p3(/(t)-Jb), X(to)

=

0, (2)

dl(t)

(ff= y(G(t) - a,,)1 - k(/(1)- 1,,) if G(t) > Gb, 1(10)

=

10, (3)

、セセエI@

=

-k(J(t)-1,,) if G(t) < G,,, /(10 )

=

10 ,

(4)

n

L(Y;

-

5';)2

R2

=

l - ..:.i'--= l:...._ _ _ _

n (5)

L(Y;

-

y;)2

i =I

where G(t) and J(t) are glucose and insulin concentrations measured in

plasma. X(t), insulin action, is proportional to insulin in a compartment

remote from plasma, and Pl, P2 and p3 are model parameters. Parameter

Pi represents the fractional ability of glucose to lower its own concentration

I

,.

I

JI

I!

!;

I

I

I.

II

I

I i

I I

I

I:

i:

·I

1.

in plasma; p2 and p3 are the fractional transfer coefficients of insulin into

and out of the remote compartment where it acts to accelerate glucose uptake

or decrease glucose production. G0 is the glucose concentration one would

obtain immediately afler glucose injection if there were instantaneous mixing

of glucose in the extracellular fluid compartment. Gh and 1,, arc the

pre-injcction values of glucose and insulin. Insulin sensitivity, represented as the

insulin sensitivity index, S / is calculated as p3 / P2 . Glucose effectiveness is

the ability of glucose, at basal insulin, to normalize its own concentration.

This latter parameter is represented as SG and is equal to p1 as defined in

equation ( 1 ), where

.v

is the prediction of the non-linear least-squares fit.

The residuals between the best-fit curve and the data, Y; -

.v.

Glucose and insulin data [G(t} and /(1)) arc submitted to the program modified minimal model, which estimates the model parameters from the real data. This program is based on the non-linear least-squares estimation

method of Marquardt. /(1) is submitted to the program modified minimal

model, which predicts a glucose time course, G(t), which fits data G(t) as

closely as possible in the least-squares sense. In the course of the titting,

the model yields X(t), an estimate of X(t), as well as estimates of

parameters Pl· P2· p3 and Go. S1(P3/p2), S<;(pi). and the coefficient of

determination R2 are calculated from model parameter estimates.

Fitting the modified minimal model of glucose disappearance to standard

IVGTT data yields parameters representing glucose disappearance: S 1 and

SG. The fonncr tcnn is a measure of the effect of the dynamic insulin

response to augment glucose decline; the latter tcnn represents the ability of glucose per se (at basal insulin) to effect its own normalization . Parameter

s

1 , varied from 5.0 x QP M セ@ to 2.2 x 10-.l (µU/Lr1min 1 and Sc; averaged 1.2

x 10-3 to4 .5 x 10 2 min·1

To examine the veracity of the Sc; value obtained from analysis of the

(5)

592 Nurullaeli, Agus Kartono and Kiagus Dahlan

Sa from experiments. In accordance with the modified minimal model, the

rate constant for the decline in glucose when the dynamic insulin response is

suppressed is equal to Sa (Sa = half-time/0.693) . Numerical Results and Discussion

In order to exemplify the computation of the proposed stability criteria, we considered sets of parameter values consistent with adaptation to data

from actual IVGTT experiments. Simulations are performed by using MATLAB ordinary differential equation solver ode45 . Experimental data published in [ l]. We obtained these data by manually measuring the data in related figures in [ l].

In the original data sets, the time mark 01 is the starting time of the bolus

glucose infusion. We further depart from published work in hypothesizing that glycemia increase between the start of infusion to the first observed glycemia point follows an ascending linear ramp. Moreover, in observing

that indeed the bolus glucose infusion belongs to the initial condition of the ordinary differential equation model ( 1 )-(4) .

Subject 6 Subject 6

"'°

m '

""

...

-""'

セ@ 300 0 s

§ 1<1(1

ij 120

(>

100

IO ' -... cl U . o 0 0 ,

0

"

f ...

0 0

セ@ 200

\

..

r

- 100 100

..

0 D

"

0

.. 0

セ@ 20 .. "' .. セ@ セ@ セ@ セ@ セ@ "" 0 0

,.

.. .. ..

""'

120 140

,

..

110 200 [image:5.843.471.776.62.208.2] [image:5.843.34.789.71.546.2]

Tlmo(Mo) Tlmo(mo)

Figure 1. Profiles of subject 6 in [ l] produced by equations ( 1)-(4) with

parameters k = 0.12, y

=

0.015, Gb

=

80 [mg.dr1] , lb = 40 [µU /ml],

p2

=

0.06 [min-1

], S1

=

6.5 x 10-4 [µu -1.ml.min-1], Sa

=

0.025 [min- '],

lo = 230 [µU/ml] and G0 = 500 [mg.dr'].

Mathematical Model of the Intravenous Glucose Tolerance Test . . . 593

1 '50 ᄋ セ@

=

I セ@ ' ..

'

セ BB@

::

セ@

\

セ@ \

(; 150

100

'°•!--MNNLLLセセ@ .. - .. セセ@ .. セ QPP セQセ LNL MMGM LNL M .... ---;;o- -""'

Tlmo(mo) ,

..

,.,

"'

"

,.

;.

:.

0 Subject 7

.

\ I

I ,,

セ@ j

..

100

'"'

1 . . 160

.

..

""'

Tlmo(mo)

Figure 2. Profiles of subject 7 in f I] produced by equations (I)-( 4) with

parameters k = 0.16, y = 0.0125, G"

=

90 fmg .dl 1

]. I"

=

30 fµU /ml].

P2

=

0.06 [min-1] , S1

=

5.07 x 10-4 fµU 1.ml.min 1], Sc;

=

0.035 fmin 1].

lo

=

180 fµU /ml] and G0

=

315 fmg.dl 1 ].

""

Subject I

'""

Subl•C1.

""'

1000

I"'° \

i セ@ 000

,,

g

I i

""

I !

セ@ 1"1

\

!

,,,

0 I .s J

.,,

,. •\

\' I 1\

J

""'

'<1

セ i@

\,

·--.

..

..

セ N@

" r

I

..

0

,.

-"

..

..

...

.

,.

140

...

1!0

""

0 ;.

:.

..

..

...

,,.

.

..

...

11() _j

"'°

Time(-)

,

...

,_,

Figure 3. Profiles of subject 8 in [ 1] produced by equations ( 1)-(4) with

parameters k

=

0.35, y = 0.18, G11

=

80 !mg.di 1

1.

111

=

40 lµU /mll .

P2 = 0.65 [min-1] . S1 = 2.5x10-4 lµU 1.ml.min

' I.

Sc;= 0.08 lmin

'I.

(6)

100

..

(l v u 0

80

0 20 40 00 80 100 120 1'90 180 180 200

nN(nin)

Subject 13

セNMMMセセセセNMMM ᄋセセセセ セセセ@

()

セセ

B@

\

- u

:§ HXI c.

,; Oo I')

"

セ@

,, IJ • ᄋMセM _q セ@ 0 iJ

..

セセセセセセセセセセセセ⦅L@

0 セ@ セ@ .. .. セ@ セ@ セ@ セ@ セ@ セ@

Tlnw(mln)

Figure 4. Profiles of subject 13 in [ 1] produced by equations ( 1)-(4) with

parameters k

=

0.45, y

=

0.027, Gb

=

75 [mg.dr1], lb

=

20 [µU/ml],

p2

=

0.45 [min-1], S1

=

7.5 x 10-3 [µU-1.ml.min-1], S0

=

0.026 [min-1],

10

=

250 [µU/ml] and G0

=

185 [mg.dr1].

100

0

' -•. u

'-..0 fl .JJ ••• Q .u

0 0

80 10 100 120 140 180 180 200

Tlmo (ninl

'

1000

Figure S. Profiles of subject 27 in [ l] produced by equations ( l )-( 4) with

parameters k

=

0.345, y

=

0.037, Gb

=

75 [mg.dr1], lb

=

30 [µU/ml], p2

=

0.45 [min-1], S1

=

3 .5 x 10-4 [µU-1.ml.min-1], Sa

=

0.033 [min-1],

10 = 1080 [µU/ml] and G0 = 345 [mg.dr1].

The optimized parameters obtained by titting the modified min

model to the experimental data of the live subjects. The averaged R2 v

including glucose and insulin concentrations for these four cases is 0.

this means that the modified minimal model was excellent. This coul.

explained by the increased flexibility of the modified minimal me

because of the assumption that the insulin decay rate is not always a ·

order process .

In the standard IVGTT, alier an injection of glucose bolus, the b

glucose reaches a higher concentration and shows an apparent d

immediately to the basal line in 1 hour. The corresponding in concentration stimulated by the injected glucose raises to form a peak,

an approximate exponential decay alierwards, and finally a secondary

appears.

Conclusions

The glucose-insulin time course in IV<iTT is a very complex pre

influenced by many factors. The interaction of glucose-insulin during IV

shows a great difference between subjects. The proposed modified mi1

model combined with the single-step filling process can be used to sim

the plasma glucose and insulin profiles subjects . The R2 va lue of ( between experimental and calculated time courses indicates the si mul

results are excellent. It also indicates that the modification to the c. minimal model improves the '!lodcl's llexibility. The modifications in·

an assumption that the decay rate of the plasma insulin is not alw;

first-order process. The single-step fitting process applied to the moc

model generates a set of real optimal model parameters to the glucosc-ir

system as a whole dynamic integrated physiological system .

Acknowlcdgmcnl

The authors would like to acknowledge fonding from the DANA ;

[image:6.843.45.802.15.554.2]
(7)

596 Nurullaeli, Agus Kartono and Kiagus Dahlan

References

[I) J . Li, M. Wang, A. D. Gaetano, P. Palumbo and S. Panunzi, The range of time

delay and the global stability of the equilibrium for an IVGIT model, Math. Biosci. 235 (200 I}, 128-137.

(2) Y. Zheng and M. Zhao, Modified minimal model using a single-step fitting

process for the intravenous glucose tolerance test in type 2 diabetes and healthy humans, Comput. Meth. Prog. Biomed. 79 (2005), 73 -79.

(3

I

A. Kartono, Modified minimal model for effect of physical exercise on insulin

sensitivity and glucose effectiveness in type 2 diabetes and healthy human, Theory Biosci. 132 (2013), 195-206.

[4J A. D. Gaetano and 0. Arino, Mathematical modeling of the intravenous glucose

tolerance test, J. Math. Biol. 40 (2000), 136-146.

FAR EAST JOURNAL OF MATHEMATICAL SCIENCES (FJ

Editorial Board

Gunjan Agrawal, India Natig M. Atakishiyev, Mexico Antonio Carbone, Italy Hasan Coskun, USA Zhenlu Cui, USA Manav Das, USA Shusheng Fu, China Wei Dong Gao, China Toshio Horiuchi, Japan Lisa M. James, USA Koji Kikuchi, Japan

Victor N. Krivtsov, Russian Federation Alison Marr, USA

Jong Seo Park, South Korea Alexandre J. Santana, Brazil

A. L. Smimov, Russian Federation Chun-Lei Tang, China

Carl A. Toews, USA Vladimir Tulovsky, USA Qing-Wen Wang, China Peter Wong, USA Pu Zhang, China

George S. Androulakis, Greec Carlo Bardaro, Italy

Yong Gao Chen, China Claudio Cuevas, Brazil Masiina Daros, Malaysia Massimiliano Ferrara, Italy Salvatore Ganci, Italy

Demetris P. K. Ghikas, Greec• Jay M. Jahangiri, USA Young Bae Jun, South Korea Hideo Kojima, Japan Yangming Li, China

Manouchehr Misaghian, USA

Cheon Seoung Ryoo, South K

K. P. Shum, China

Ashish K. Srivastava. USA E. Thandapani, India B. C. Tripathy, India Mitsuru Uchiyama, Japan G. Brock Williams, USA Chaohui Zhang, USA Kewen Zhao, China

Gambar

Figure 3. Profiles of subject 8 in [ 1] produced by equations ( 1)-(4) with
Figure 4. Profiles of subject 13 in [ 1] produced by equations ( 1)-(4) with

Referensi

Dokumen terkait

[r]

Demikian Penetapan Pemenang Pelelangan ini dibuat dan ditandatangani pada hari, tanggal dan bulan sebagaimana tersebut di atas untuk dipergunakan sebagaimana mestinya.

Metode pelaksanaan mengambarkan rekanan tidak memahami pelaksanaan kegiatan, rekanan tidak menguraikan cara kerja setiap tahap pelaksanaan kegiatan dengan baik, tidak

Pemberian stimulus padaanak usia dini pada aspek fisik motorik juga dapat mempengaruhi aspek-aspek perkembangan yang lainnya, agar perkembangan anak dapat

For this coupe, it is clear that for the total extent of soil disturbance, current harvesting and regeneration practices are unlikely to meet the operating standards proposed under

Beberapa rumusan masalah yang dibahas di dalam penelitian ini adalah mengenai hak dan kewajiban pemilik tanah dan developer dalam akta perjanjian, problematika yang muncul

Model Pelatihan dengan Pembelajaran Proyek Efektif dalam Meningkatkan Kompetensi Berwirausaha Mantan Buruh Migran yang Direkomendasikan .... Keterbatasan Penelitian dan

Tabel 4.13 Ringkasan Hasil Perhitungan Uji-t Post Test Kelas Eksperimen X2 an Kelas Kontrol....