HTS Submission 7995 – Suitable for Review

(1)

HTS Submission 7995 – Suitable for Review

1 pesan

<aosis@hts.org.za> Jum, 12 Agu 2022 pukul 22.09

Balas ke: Ms Elizna De Bod <5ts.srsupport@hts.org.za>

Kepada: Assoc. Prof. Acim <subhanacim@uinmataram.ac.id>

******************************************************************

Ref. No.: 7995

Manuscript title: Systematic, substantive, and functional comparison between the holy Qur’an and the ideology of Pancasila

Journal: HTS Teologiese Studies / Theological Studies

******************************************************************

Dear Assoc. Prof. Acim

Thank you for submitting your manuscript to the journal. All new manuscripts are given a preliminary inspection by the editorial oﬃce to assess whether the submission is complete. We are grateful for your efforts to adhere to the author guidelines of HTS Teologiese Studies / Theological Studies.

Your manuscript will now proceed to our blinded peer review process to undergo an assessment by our expert independent reviewers. Read our peer review process https://aosis.co.za/policies#peer_review.

Editor remarks:

Ensure to keep us informed if any of your credentials have changed during this time, to ease communication with you as your manuscript progresses through the different publication phases. If you need any assistance, kindly contact the Editorial Oﬃce at submissions@hts.org.za with any questions or concerns.

We remind our authors that our publisher is a member of CrossChecks plagiarism detection initiative and endorses and applies the standards of the Committee on Publication Ethics which promotes integrity in

peer-reviewed research publications. This journal also conforms to the accreditation requirements by both the Department of Higher Education and Training of South Africa and Scielo SA.

Thank you for your continued patience and support, and we hope you have joined our online community by signing up for our RSS alerts and Twitter https://twitter.com/HTS_Journal page.

Kind regards, Ms De Bod AOSIS colleague

(2)

******************************************************************

Give us feedback: Please help us to improve your experience as an author by taking a few minutes to tell us about the service that you have received. We appreciate your participation and want to make sure we meet your

expectations, which will give us the opportunity to better serve the community.

Form:

https://forms.oﬃce.com/Pages/ResponsePage.aspx?id=mXfgHQ3TR0ix-

TiElOAkzi4e5bmbrRhDux1_hEph7SZURDVSTlpEN1I0WU9JODFNR0ZPQUg1MkJRQy4u

If you are interested to receive publication notiﬁcations from the journal, follow us on Twitter (https://twitter.com/HTS_Journal) or register for the RSS feeds.

Editorial Coordinator Special Issues Unit

Scholarly Journals Department

AOSIS Publishing, Empowering Africa through access to knowledge Tel: +270219752602

URL: website url of journal

reviewing interest: AOSIS colleague

________________________________________________________________________

HTS Teologiese Studies / Theological Studies | https://hts.org.za | ISSN: 0259-9422 (PRINT) | ISSN: 2072-8050 (ONLINE)

If you require immediate assistance, please contact AOSIS Publishing | Tel: +27 21 975 2602 | Support email: publishing@aosis.co.za | Business hours are weekdays between 8:00am-16:30pm

Interested in more Theological and Religious Studies research, visit:

• HTS Teologiese Studies / Theological Studies [https://hts.org.za] |

• In die Skriﬂig/In Luce Verbi [https://indieskriﬂig.org.za] | •

Verbum et Ecclesia [https://verbumetecclesia.org.za] | • Theologia Viatorum [https://theologiaviatorum.org]

Conﬁdentiality: The information contained in and attached to this email is conﬁdential and for use of the intended recipient. This email adheres to the email disclaimer described on https://aosis.co.za

(3)

HTS Submission 7995 - Conﬁrmation and acknowledgement of receipt

1 pesan

<aosis@hts.org.za> Kam, 4 Agu 2022 pukul 22.19

Balas ke: AOSIS Publishing <submissions@hts.org.za>

Kepada: Assoc. Prof. Subhan Abdullah Acim <subhanacim@uinmataram.ac.id>

******************************************************************

Ref. No.: 7995

Manuscript title: SYSTEMATIC, SUBSTANTIVE, AND FUNCTIONAL COMPARISON BETWEEN

THE HOLY QUR’AN AND THE IDEOLOGY OF PANCASILA Journal: HTS Teologiese Studies / Theological Studies

******************************************************************

Your submission has been received by the journal and will now be processed in accordance with published timelines.

Processing time guidelines are available under the journal’s ‘About’

section, however, please note that each submission is assessed on its individual merit and in certain circumstances processing times may differ.

You can check the status of your submission in three ways:

- Journal Website: login to your account at

https://hts.org.za/index.php/hts/author/submission/7995.

- Publisher Enquiry Service: telephone numbers are +27(0)219752602 and/or 0861000381.

- Publisher FAQ and Email Service: visit the Publisher FAQ and Email service at https://publishingsupport.aosis.co.za/index.php

You will receive additional emails from the journal as your submission passes through the phases of the editorial process.

Kind regards, AOSIS Publishing

HTS Teologiese Studies / Theological Studies

________________________________________________________________________

(4)

(5)

HTS Submission 7995 - Manuscript at Desk Review

1 pesan

Kepada: Assoc. Prof. Acim <subhanacim@uinmataram.ac.id>

******************************************************************

Ref. No.: 7995

******************************************************************

Dear Subhan Acim, Lula Sumardi

Thank you for working with our Editorial Oﬃce to ensure that we have a

complete record of your manuscript and all submission's compulsory forms at HTS Teologiese Studies / Theological Studies.

All new manuscripts are presented to our Handling Editor for a preliminary Desk Review to assess whether the subject matter and general content are appropriate for this journal.

We have requested our Handling Editor to commence with this preliminary Desk Review in the upcoming week. We trust you will be receiving an outcome of this assessment before 2022-08-19.

If you do not receive the required feedback, we invite you to contact our Editorial Oﬃce to enquire the reason for the delay.

Thank you for your continued patience and support.

Kind regards, Ms De Bod AOSIS colleague

******************************************************************

Give us feedback: Please help us to improve your experience as an author by taking a few minutes to tell us about the service that you have received. We appreciate your participation and want to make sure we meet your

expectations, which will give us the opportunity to better serve the community.

Form:

TiElOAkzi4e5bmbrRhDux1_hEph7SZURDVSTlpEN1I0WU9JODFNR0ZPQUg1MkJRQy4u

(6)

If you are interested to receive publication notiﬁcations from the journal, follow us on Twitter (https://twitter.com/HTS_Journal) or register for the RSS feeds.

Editorial Coordinator Special Issues Unit

________________________________________________________________________

(7)

HTS External Review Decision 8154 - Accepted for publication

2 pesan

<aosis@hts.org.za> Kam, 13 Okt 2022 pukul 15.38

Balas ke: Dr. Annelie Botha <annelie.botha@up.ac.za>

Cc: Lalu Sumardi <lalusumardi.fkip@unram.ac.id>

******************************************************************

Ref. No.: 8154

Journal: HTS Teologiese Studies / Theological Studies ISSN: 0259-9422, E-ISSN: 2072-8050

******************************************************************

The journal has a double-blinded peer review process and your manuscript was assessed by two expert independent reviewers. Read our peer review process https://aosis.co.za/policies#peer_review.

Thank you for your revised manuscript. We have reached a decision regarding your submission. I am pleased to inform you that your manuscript has now been accepted for publication.

The Editorial Office will contact you by 20 October 2022 to finalise your manuscript for the Finalisation and Publication Office. If you need any assistance, kindly contact the Editorial Office at submissions@hts.org.za with any questions or concerns.

peer-reviewed research publications. This journal also conforms to the accreditation requirements by both the Department of Higher Education and Training of South Africa and Scielo SA. Be assured that upon publication, your manuscript will be indexed in various international research

repositories for further dissemination and reach in readership.

*******

Please help us to improve your experience as an author by taking a few minutes to tell us about the service that you have received. We appreciate your participation and want to make sure we met your expectations, which will give us the opportunity to better serve the community.

Feedback:

TiElOAkzi4e5bmbrRhDux1_hEph7SZUQVZUWDNTR0tLQTVQODVUNlJTT001SzhHSC4u

(8)

*******

Thank you for submitting your interesting and important work to the HTS Teologiese Studies / Theological Studies. We value your contribution to the journal and for the active involvement in the development of the discipline.

Your manuscript will soon form part of this open access publication and your content will be licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution License. We look forward to your future contributions.

Kind regards, Dr. Botha

Department of Practical Theology, Faculty of Theology, University of Pretoria

******************************************************************

Frequently Asked Question

What can I expect from the publication procedure?

******************************************************************

On the acceptance of a manuscript for publication by the Editor-in-Chief, the editorial staff will work towards preparing the manuscript for online publication by performing a technical review of the publication process. The accepted manuscript will be prepared and handed over from the review oﬃce to the Finalisation and Publication Oﬃce.

Dr Annelie Botha

________________________________________________________________________

Subhan Abdullah Acim <subhanacim@uinmataram.ac.id> Kam, 13 Okt 2022 pukul 15.40 Kepada: dwiwahyudiati@uinmataram.ac.id

[Kutipan teks disembunyikan]

(9)

HTS External Review Decision 7995 - Rejection

1 pesan

<aosis@hts.org.za> Jum, 23 Sep 2022 pukul 20.11

******************************************************************

Ref. No.: 7995

******************************************************************

We thank you for the submission of your revised manuscript.

Your manuscript is being declined as the review of your resubmission does not demonstrate on the marked-up track change copy that changes which the author(s) indicate in the authors' itemised feedback correlate adequately with the comments in the reviewer feedback and the explanations provided in the comments section.

I regret to inform you that the journal is unable to publish your

manuscript. We hereby release your manuscript from consideration so you may submit it elsewhere.

If you wish to revise this submission and make a new submission to the platform please do so prior to the 30th of November noting submission 7995 and the reason for the decline.

Do consider submitting future manuscripts which you believe would be suitable for the journal.

Thank you for your interest in the HTS Teologiese Studies / Theological Studies.

Kind regards, Ms De Bod AOSIS colleague Editorial Coordinator Special Issues Unit

(10)

________________________________________________________________________

(11)

HTS External Review 7995 - Review Status Update

3 pesan

Kepada: subhanacim@uinmataram.ac.id, lalusumardi.fkip@unram.ac.id

******************************************************************

Ref. No.: 7995

******************************************************************

Dear Subhan Acim, Lalu Sumardi

Your blinded manuscript moved into the peer review process on 15-Aug-22 and is still undergoing assessment by our expert independent reviewers. Read our peer review process https://aosis.co.za/policies#peer_review.

Please could you provide me with the names (full name and title, aﬃliation and email address) of 2 x suitable reviewers for your submission in order for me to contact them if needed.

We hope to receive an outcome of the ﬁnalisation of the review shortly, which will be communicated by the assigned Review Editor, as our records indicate that your manuscript has been in our review stage for 14 days.

Thank you for your continued patience and support, and we hope you have joined our online community by signing up to our RSS alerts and Twitter page.

Kind regards Ms De Bod AOSIS colleague Editorial Coordinator

(12)

Special Issues Unit

________________________________________________________________________

Subhan Abdullah Acim <subhanacim@uinmataram.ac.id> Jum, 19 Agu 2022 pukul 22.49 Kepada: Ms Elizna De Bod <5ts.srsupport@hts.org.za>

Dear editor of HTS

I sent you the name, aﬃliation, and emile of the both authors:

1. Dr. Subhan A. Acim, MA., Universitas Islam Negeri Mataram, subhanacim@uinmatram.ac.id

2. Dr. Lalu Sumardi, M.Pd., University of Mataram, lalu.unram@gmail.com Thank you

Sincerely yours SUBHAN A. ACIM

Mail Delivery Subsystem <mailer-daemon@googlemail.com> Jum, 19 Agu 2022 pukul 22.49 Kepada: subhanacim@uinmataram.ac.id

Message not delivered

(13)

There was a problem delivering your message to 5ts.srsupport@hts.org.za . See the technical details below, or try resending in a few minutes.

The response from the remote server was:

550 SPF policy prohibits sending from address 209.85.221.180

--- Forwarded message ---

From: Subhan Abdullah Acim <subhanacim@uinmataram.ac.id>

To: Ms Elizna De Bod <5ts.srsupport@hts.org.za>

Cc:

Bcc:

Date: Fri, 19 Aug 2022 22:49:19 +0800

Subject: Re: HTS External Review 7995 - Review Status Update --- Message truncated ---

(14)

HTS External Review 7995 - Review Status Update

2 pesan

<aosis@hts.org.za> Sen, 15 Agu 2022 pukul 18.14

Balas ke: Ms Michele Menezies <8ts.srsupport@hts.org.za>

******************************************************************

Ref. No.: 7995

******************************************************************

Dear Subhan Acim, Lula Sumardi

Your blinded manuscript moved into the peer review process on 15-Aug-22 and is still undergoing assessment by our expert independent reviewers. Read our peer review process https://aosis.co.za/policies#peer_review.

We hope to receive an outcome of the ﬁnalisation of the review shortly, which will be communicated by the assigned Review Editor, as our records indicate that your manuscript has been in our review stage for 10 days.

Kind regards Ms Menezies AOSIS

Editorial Coordinator

Submissions and Review Unit Scholarly Journals Department

AOSIS Publishing, Empowering Africa through access to knowledge ________________________________________________________________________

(15)

Subhan Abdullah Acim <subhanacim@uinmataram.ac.id> Sen, 15 Agu 2022 pukul 18.21 Kepada: dwiwahyudiati@uinmataram.ac.id <dwiwahyudiati@uinmataram.ac.id>

(16)

HTS External Review Decision 7995 - Revisions required

4 pesan

<aosis@hts.org.za> Jum, 16 Sep 2022 pukul 16.01

******************************************************************

Ref. No.: 7995

******************************************************************

We thank you for the submission of your manuscript. The peer review process of your manuscript has now been completed and we have reached a decision regarding your submission.

At present, your manuscript requires minor revisions to address the concerns of the reviewers. Their comments are attached to the platform for your

consideration. Please log onto your proﬁle to view the reviewers’

comments.

Please include with your revised submission an itemised, point-by-point response to the reviewers which details the changes made. The revised manuscript should be submitted by 30-Sep-22; if you anticipate that you will be unable to meet this deadline, please notify the Editorial Oﬃce.

As a member of the Committee on Publication Ethics, we encourage your participation in assessing your Similarity Check Report in your journals’

personalised manuscript section. Proceed to rewrite the paraphrased text or to introduce citations and acknowledgements as needed. Our assessment revealed:

No similarity concerns at this stage.

Below my signature, you will ﬁnd steps to resubmit your revised manuscript.

If you need any assistance, kindly contact the Editorial Oﬃce at submissions@hts.org.za with any questions or concerns.

We look forward to receiving the revised manuscript.

Yours sincerely, Ms De Bod AOSIS colleague

******************************************************************

(17)

Frequently Asked Question

How do I view the reviewer comments, after the formal peer review, if the Editor-in-Chief provided feedback regarding my article?

******************************************************************

The editor should send you an email stating all the revisions suggested during the formal peer review process. If you are advised to download the comments via your personalised journal section, follow these steps:

• Log into your personalised journal section in the journal.

• Under your ‘User Home’ click on the ‘Author’ or ‘Active’

link that will direct you to your ‘Active Submissions Table’.

• Under the ‘Status Column’, click on ‘In Review: Revisions

Required’. This link takes you to the overview of the peer review process.

• The review page of your article provides information and documentation under the heading ‘Peer Review', and will identify ﬁles by reviewers,

e.g. Reviewer B 19-123-1-RV.docx 2011-08-10. Download these documents to view the reviewer ﬁles.

******************************************************************

Frequently Asked Question: The Editor-in-Chief has requested revisions to my article. How do I submit my revised version?

******************************************************************

When the editor dealing with your submission chooses to ask for a revision, you will be notiﬁed by email. In the journal’s personalised section your submission will move in the active table from the status ‘In Review’ to

‘In Review: Revisions Required’.

When you prepare a revised version of your manuscript, it is essential that you carefully follow the instructions given in the editor’s letter. Use

the standard uploading format (as described for original submissions), but include both a clean copy of your manuscript and an annotated copy

describing the changes you have made. Failure to do so will cause a delay in the review of your revision.

If references, tables, or figures are moved, added, or deleted during the revision process, renumber them to reflect such changes so that all tables, references (Vancouver Style) and figures are cited in numeric order. Images need only be uploaded if changes have been made to the figures since the previous version.

The annotated copy should have highlights on the changes (either by using the 'Track Changes’ function in Word or by highlighting or underlining

text) with comments in the text referring to the editor or reviewer query.

Be sure when you upload your annotated version that the changes are clearly visible on the Word (.doc) ﬁle prior to resubmission.

You should create a point-by-point response letter specifying how you have addressed each of the editor’s and reviewer’s comments.

Using the review version of your manuscript, edit and revise your submission according to the reviewers' and editor's comments, and follow the steps:

(18)

• When you have addressed the comments and completed your revisions, log into your journals’ personalised section and click on ‘In Review:

Revisions Required’.

• Under the ‘Editor Decision’, click on the bubble icon to view the editor's decision letter. If needed, you may view the original editor and reviewer comments by clicking ﬁles linked under the ‘Review Round’.

• Once your revisions are correctly formatted and prepared, click on

‘Browse’ to begin uploading your revised manuscript from your desktop.

Ensure to upload a clean, annotated and point-by-point version as part of your revised manuscript submission.

Once all three documents are uploaded, you will need to inform the editor via email of your resubmission. Click on the email icon and proceed to type and email the editor. Remember to press 'Send'.

For a video detailing the uploading of your revised manuscript see here:

https://pkp.sfu.ca/ﬁles/author_submission_status_acadiau.mp4 Editorial Coordinator

Special Issues Unit

________________________________________________________________________

Subhan Abdullah Acim <subhanacim@uinmataram.ac.id> Sab, 17 Sep 2022 pukul 08.38 Kepada: Ms Elizna De Bod <5ts.srsupport@hts.org.za>

Dear HTS editor

I have revised the article according to the feedback from the reviewer and have sent it to you. Thank you.

Best regard

(19)

Subhan Acim

HTS Manuscripts <submissions@hts.org.za> Sen, 19 Sep 2022 pukul 17.50 Kepada: Subhan Abdullah Acim <subhanacim@uinmataram.ac.id>

Thank you for the attached, we will however also require an author

comments document noting in table format, the reviewer comment and how you had address the speciﬁc concern.

Please provide this document as soon as possible in order for the editor to review your submission.

Kind regards Elizna de Bod

HTS Teologiese Studies/Theological Studies

hts.org.za l Follow: @HTS_Journal l Receive email press releases and call for papers: Subscribe

Submission and Review Editorial Coordinator: Elizna de Bod, Telephone Ext: 513 l submissions@hts.org.za Finalisation and Publishing Production Coordinator: Lara Antonopoulos, Telephone Ext: 509 l

publishing@hts.org.za

Compliment or complaint: Hannelie Diedericks, Telephone Ext: 502 l publishing@aosis.co.za Tel: +27 21 975 2602 l Fax to email: 086 685 1577 l Fax: +27 21 975 4635

15 Oxford Street, Durbanville, Cape Town, 7550 l Get directions

Published by AOSIS (Pty) Ltd: aosis.co.za, Facebook, Twitter, LinkedIn,YouTube, SoundCloud, and mailing list subscription

This email adheres to the email disclaimer on www.aosis.co.za

Sent: Saturday, 17 September 2022 02:38

To: HTS Manuscripts <submissions@hts.org.za>

Subject: Re: HTS External Review Decision 7995 - Revisions required

Subhan Abdullah Acim <subhanacim@uinmataram.ac.id> Sen, 19 Sep 2022 pukul 20.44 Kepada: HTS Manuscripts <submissions@hts.org.za>

Dear editor of HTS

Below I send the corrected document to each reviewer. Thank you.

(20)

Sincerely yours Subhan A. Acim

(21)

HTS 8154: Manuscript Accepted for Publication, Sent to Editing

1 pesan

<aosis@hts.org.za> Kam, 13 Okt 2022 pukul 17.02

Balas ke: Ms Tanien Botes <6ts.srsupport@hts.org.za>

******************************************************************

Ref. No.: 8154

******************************************************************

Dear Subhan Acim, Lalu Sumardi

We are pleased to conﬁrm your manuscript's acceptance for publication on 13-Oct-22.

We can also conﬁrm that the Submission and Review Department released your manuscript to our Finalisation Department to commence the various editing processes to secure online publication within the next 90 days (if not

sooner).

Kindly note:

1. If you need to make contact with AOSIS Publishing during the ﬁnalisation stage of your manuscript, kindly contact us per email or phone.

2. The ﬁnalisation procedure works as follows: (a) The ﬁrst stage is the language editing that is returned to the corresponding Author for review.

This will be the ﬁnal opportunity for the corresponding Author to make text changes to the manuscript. (b) At a later stage, the editorial staff will send the corresponding author one set of galley proofs, at which time the Author will have two working days to mark any typographical errors.

3. Manuscript tracking is available on the submitting authors' journal proﬁle. The submitting Author could visit their home page frequently to assess the stage of the manuscript.

Kind regards, Ms Botes AOSIS

(22)

(23)

HTS Submission 8154 - Conﬁrmation and acknowledgement of receipt

1 pesan

<aosis@hts.org.za> Sen, 26 Sep 2022 pukul 13.25

******************************************************************

Ref. No.: 8154

Manuscript title: SYSTEMATIC, SUBSTANTIVE, AND FUNCTIONAL COMPARISON BETWEEN

THE HOLY QUR’AN AND THE IDEOLOGY OF PANCASILA Journal: HTS Teologiese Studies / Theological Studies

******************************************************************

Your submission has been received by the journal and will now be processed in accordance with published timelines.

Processing time guidelines are available under the journal’s ‘About’

section, however, please note that each submission is assessed on its individual merit and in certain circumstances processing times may differ.

You can check the status of your submission in three ways:

- Journal Website: login to your account at

https://hts.org.za/index.php/hts/author/submission/8154.

- Publisher Enquiry Service: telephone numbers are +27(0)219752602 and/or 0861000381.

- Publisher FAQ and Email Service: visit the Publisher FAQ and Email service at https://publishingsupport.aosis.co.za/index.php

You will receive additional emails from the journal as your submission passes through the phases of the editorial process.

________________________________________________________________________

(24)

(25)

HTS Proofreading 8154 - Thank you for reviewing your galley

1 pesan

<aosis@hts.org.za> Sel, 15 Nov 2022 pukul 14.17

Balas ke: Ms Jana Venter <4ts.fpsupport@hts.org.za>

Cc: Lara Antonopoulos <lara@aosis.co.za>

******************************************************************

Ref. No.: 8154

******************************************************************

Dear Assoc. Prof. Subhan Abdullah Acim

Thank you for proofreading the galley(s) of your manuscript.

We are looking forward to publishing your work.

Kind regards, Ms Venter AOSIS

Finalisation and Publishing Desk Editor (Supervisor) Scholarly Journals Department

(26)

HTS Proofreading 8154 - due 07 Nov 2022 - Your galley is available to be proofread prior to publication

4 pesan

<aosis@hts.org.za> Kam, 3 Nov 2022 pukul 15.50

Balas ke: Ms Jana Venter <jana@aosis.co.za>

******************************************************************

Ref. No.: 8154

******************************************************************

Dear Assoc. Prof. Subhan Abdullah Acim Your galley proofs have arrived!

We are excited to share your manuscript in your Author Centre in galley format (PDF) to proofread and review. Kindly ensure to scrutinize the galley proofs well and include any necessary changes at this point, which include, among others:

• Answer all related queries from production staff and editors.

• Pay close attention to deadlines; late submissions can delay publishing.

• Always check author order, author names and aﬃliations.

• If you introduce text, make only critical changes that might affect conclusions (e.g., data revisions).

• Update any in-press citations if published at the proof stage.

• Correct typos.

• Do not make extensive text changes or move blocks of text.

• Please do not make your changes within the PDF, as we will not be able to track the changes made.

This proof contains notes and queries from production staff and editors that need to be addressed to avoid publication delays. To ensure timely

publication of your manuscript, we ask that you do not skip a query and markup the critical and necessary changes due to errors. Your work must reach your intended readership not just as soon as possible but at a quality level that makes your scientiﬁc impact in the scholarly community.

Steps to access the galley proofs:

1. Visit the platform by following the link

https://hts.org.za/index.php/hts/author/submissionEditing/8154 2. Log in to the journal, if required.

3. Select the link labelled ‘View Proof’ under the heading ‘Layout’.

(27)

You will be able to download the PDF onto your computer or print it.

4. Add changes (typographical and format) by either adding markup and comments on the galley with a PDF viewer application using the HIGHLIGHT TOOL ('How to Use the Comment and Markup Tools in Adobe Acrobat':

https://tinyurl.com/5n7795k5) or adding your comments to the function

‘Proofreading Corrections’ on the platform.

If you struggle with this functionality, you can make your comments in a

Word Document. Upload your proofread PDF with markup comments under Step 1:

Proofreading. Ensure to upload any ﬁgures or tables that need replacing too. You will be able to upload multiple ﬁles.

5. Finally, inform me that your proofread PDF is available. In Step 1,

proceed to click the email icon under COMPLETE. You will not be able to add any more ﬁles after sending this email.

We ask that you respond to this email as an indication that you have received our request. Would you please let me know if an extension is required?

Kind regards, Ms Venter AOSIS

Finalisation and Publishing Desk Editor (Supervisor) Scholarly Journals Department

Subhan Abdullah Acim <subhanacim@uinmataram.ac.id> Jum, 4 Nov 2022 pukul 14.24 Kepada: Ms Jana Venter <jana@aosis.co.za>

Dear chief editor of HTS

(28)

Thanks for your information. I inform you that I have corrected according to the input given. I'm sorry, I'm having trouble ﬁxing it in PDF format that you sent. So I'm sending you a revision in word format. Thank you.

Best regards Subhan A. Acim

Subhan Abdullah Acim <subhanacim@uinmataram.ac.id> Sen, 14 Nov 2022 pukul 21.15 Kepada: Ms Jana Venter <jana@aosis.co.za>

Dear chief editor of HTS

I'm so sorty if I disturbe you. I would like to give you question, when my article will be published. I hope it can be published in this edition. Than you.

Subhan Acim

HTS Manuscripts <submissions@hts.org.za> Sel, 15 Nov 2022 pukul 14.19 Kepada: Subhan Abdullah Acim <subhanacim@uinmataram.ac.id>

Dear Prof. Subhan Acim

We are in the ﬁnal stages of your article's production, making sure the proofreading changes are made and your article updated, then a ﬁnal stamp of approval and hope to publish your article as soon as possible.

We will keep you posted.

Kind regards Jana Venter

HTS Teologiese Studies/Theological Studies

Submission and Review Editorial Coordinator: Elizna de Bod, Telephone Ext: 513 l submissions@hts.org.za Finalisation and Publishing Desk Editor (Supervisor): Jana Venter, Telephone Ext: 507 l publishing@hts.org.za Compliment or complaint: Trudie Retief, Telephone Ext: 500 l publishing@aosis.co.za

Tel: +27 21 975 2602 l Fax to email: 086 685 1577 l Fax: +27 21 975 4635 15 Oxford Street, Durbanville, Cape Town, 7550 l Get directions

(29)

Sent: Monday, 14 November 2022 15:15 To: Jana Venter <jana@aosis.co.za>

Subject: Re: HTS Proofreading 8154 - due 07 Nov 2022 - Your galley is available to be proofread prior to publication

(30)

HTS Proofreading 8154 - Clean Copy Ready For Signoff

6 pesan

<aosis@hts.org.za> Rab, 18 Jan 2023 pukul 22.03

Balas ke: Ms Michele Menezies <8ts.srsupport@hts.org.za>

Cc: Lara Antonopoulos <lara@aosis.co.za>

******************************************************************

Ref. No.: 8154

******************************************************************

Attached please ﬁnd the clean copy of your article after corrections

implemented. Please could you go through the article carefully and advise if there are any more changes required, if not, please could you email me stating that you are happy for article to be published.

‘Proofreading Corrections’ on the platform. We prefer markups in the PDF with a comment tool highlighting change requirement. If you struggle with this functionality, you can make your comments in a Word Document. Upload your proofread PDF with markup comments under Step 1: Proofreading. Ensure to upload any ﬁgures or tables that need replacing too. You will be able to

upload multiple ﬁles.

(31)

We ask that you respond to this email as an indication that you have received our request. Would you please let me know if an extension is required? We would like to receive your feedback within a week.

Kind regards, Ms Menezies AOSIS

Subhan Abdullah Acim <subhanacim@uinmataram.ac.id> Kam, 19 Jan 2023 pukul 04.36 Kepada: Ms Michele Menezies <8ts.srsupport@hts.org.za>

Thank you for your information. I state the article is complate. Thank you.

Subhan Abdullah Acim <subhanacim@uinmataram.ac.id> Rab, 1 Feb 2023 pukul 20.18 Kepada: Ms Michele Menezies <8ts.srsupport@hts.org.za>

Dear HTS editor

I hope you would like to tell me abaout publication of my article. Thank you.

SUBHAN ACIM

Pada tanggal Rab, 18 Jan 2023 22:03, <aosis@hts.org.za> menulis:

HTS Manuscripts <submissions@hts.org.za> Kam, 2 Feb 2023 pukul 20.53 Kepada: Subhan Abdullah Acim <subhanacim@uinmataram.ac.id>

Hi Prof

(32)

Our sincere apologies for the delay in getting your article published. Your article is not ready for publication yet, I am going to prioritise getting your article published by mid February 2023.

Kind regards

Michele Menezies

HTS Teologiese Studies/Theological Studies

Sent: Wednesday, February 1, 2023 14:18

Subject: Re: HTS Proofreading 8154 - Clean Copy Ready For Signoff

Subhan Abdullah Acim <subhanacim@uinmataram.ac.id> Kam, 2 Feb 2023 pukul 20.58 Kepada: HTS Manuscripts <submissions@hts.org.za>

Thank you for your response.

Subhan Abdullah Acim <subhanacim@uinmataram.ac.id> Jum, 3 Feb 2023 pukul 12.18 Draf

--- Forwarded message ---

Dari: HTS Manuscripts <submissions@hts.org.za>

Date: Kam, 2 Feb 2023 20:53

Subject: Re: HTS Proofreading 8154 - Clean Copy Ready For Signoff To: Subhan Abdullah Acim <subhanacim@uinmataram.ac.id>

(33)

Hi Prof

Our sincere apologies for the delay in getting your article published. Your article is not ready for publication yet, I am going to prioritise getting your article published by mid February 2023.

Kind regards

Michele Menezies

HTS Teologiese Studies/Theological Studies

Sent: Wednesday, February 1, 2023 14:18

Subject: Re: HTS Proofreading 8154 - Clean Copy Ready For Signoff

Dear HTS editor

I hope you would like to tell me abaout publication of my article. Thank you.

SUBHAN ACIM

Pada tanggal Rab, 18 Jan 2023 22:03, <aosis@hts.org.za> menulis:

******************************************************************

Ref. No.: 8154

******************************************************************

Attached please ﬁnd the clean copy of your article after corrections

implemented. Please could you go through the article carefully and advise if there are any more changes required, if not, please could you email me

(34)

stating that you are happy for article to be published.

‘Proofreading Corrections’ on the platform. We prefer markups in the PDF with a comment tool highlighting change requirement. If you struggle with this functionality, you can make your comments in a Word Document. Upload your proofread PDF with markup comments under Step 1: Proofreading. Ensure to upload any ﬁgures or tables that need replacing too. You will be able to

upload multiple ﬁles.

We ask that you respond to this email as an indication that you have received our request. Would you please let me know if an extension is required? We would like to receive your feedback within a week.

Kind regards, Ms Menezies AOSIS

(35)

(36)

RE: PAYMENT REMITTANCE FOR AOSIS (PTY) LTD

1 pesan

AOSIS Billing <billing@aosis.co.za> Sen, 24 Okt 2022 pukul 20.10 Kepada: Subhan Abdullah Acim <subhanacim@uinmataram.ac.id>

Good day,

Trust my email ﬁnds you well.

Thank you for the proof of payment, the funds have been well received.

We will keep you posted for further updates.

Kind regards,

Karen Botha

Senior Bookkeeper

AOSIS (Pty) Ltd: www.aosis.co.za l Certiﬁed Moodle Partner™ of South Africa

Tel: +27 21 975 2602 l Ext: 204 l karen@aosis.co.za Fax to email: 086 675 7317 l Fax: +27 86 675 7317

15 Oxford Street, Durbanville, Cape Town, 7550 l Get directions

Connect on: Facebook, Twitter, LinkedIn, SoundCloud and YouTube l Subscribe to our mailing list

(37)

Proof of payment_Subhan Acim

1 pesan

Subhan Abdullah Acim <subhanacim@uinmataram.ac.id> Jum, 14 Okt 2022 pukul 19.35 Kepada: BILLING@aosis.co.za

Greetings

We hereby inform you that we have completed the article payment process.

Manuscript Reference Number: 8154

Manuscript Title: Systematic, substantive, and functional comparison between the holy Qur’an and the ideology of Pancasila

Here we attach proof of payment.

Sincerely

Subhan Abdullah Acim

(38)

HTS Conﬁrm your HTS Teologiese Studies / Theological Studies registration

1 pesan

<aosis@hts.org.za> Kam, 4 Agu 2022 pukul 21.01

Dear Assoc. Prof. Subhan Abdullah Acim Thank you for registering!

Just one more step, we need to validate your email address to activate your account.

Click on the link:

https://hts.org.za/index.php/hts/user/activateUser/subhanacim_2022/s28qP9TZ Note: In most mail programms, the link should appear as a blue link which

you can just click on. If that doesn't work, then cut and paste the address into the address line at the top of your web browser window.

________________________________________________________________________

(39)

HTS Online ﬁrst publication 8154 – your article has been published

1 pesan

<aosis@hts.org.za> Rab, 15 Feb 2023 pukul 16.10

Kepada: Subhan Acim <subhanacim@uinmataram.ac.id>

Dear Subhan Acim, Lalu Sumardi, Congratulations!

Your article Systematic, substantive and functional comparison between the holy Qur’an and Pancasila has just been published and is available at the following link:

https://hts.org.za/index.php/hts/article/view/8154

Your manuscript will now form part of this open access publication and your content will be licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution License. It is freely accessible to any user and will shortly be indexed in various

international research repositories for further dissemination and reach in readership. There is no need for you to order print issues or copies.

Citation Information

As an online ﬁrst article, your paper is fully citable even before the journals full issue has been compiled. Your article can be cited by its unique Digital Object Identiﬁer (DOI),

https://doi.org/10.4102/hts.v79i2.8154. Later, after inclusion of your article in the paginated journal issue, please continue to use the DOI alongside the usual citation details to enable readers to easily ﬁnd the article in print and online.

We encourage you to mention your article and its DOI on your website or your social media proﬁles. If you are interested to receive publication

notiﬁcations from the journal, follow the journal on twitter https://twitter.com/HTS_Journal or, register for the RSS feed at

https://hts.org.za/index.php/hts/gateway/plugin/WebFeedGatewayPlugin/atom.

*******

Please help us to improve your experience as an author by taking a few minutes to tell us about the service that you have received. We appreciate your participation and want to make sure we met your expectations, which will give us the opportunity to better serve the community.

Feedback:

(40)

TiElOAkzi4e5bmbrRhDux1_hEph7SZUOUk1NERWM1hHNFAzSENIV09EQ1dUUTJUUS4u

*******

Thank you again for publishing with the HTS Teologiese Studies / Theological Studies. We look forward to your future contributions.

________________________________________________________________________

(41)

REVISION FOR REVIEWER B

No Part Reviewer Suggestion Revision

1 Abstract. In the abstract section, the

components contained are relevant to the writing guidelines, but need to be equipped with the urgency of doing research at the beginning of the paragraph.

This article presents the systematic, substantive, and functional reasons for how they could work altogether by looking at the similarities and differences in anatomy, taxonomy, substance, and function of each component of the corpus.

2 Introduction. On the background, it is very important to reveal the similarities and differences between Pancasila and the Qur'an so that it is logical to conduct a comparative study

between the two.

At the end of the introduction, it is necessary to reveal the novelty of the research conducted.

Consequently, it obtained a comprehensive picture of the systematic, substantive, and functional similarities and differences between the holy book of the Qur’an and the ideology of Pancasila. It finally revealed why the two corpora could walk side by side.

From the findings, it is hoped that it could provide

comprehensive knowledge about the similarities and differences between the Qur’an and the Pancasila and, at the same time, answer curiosity about the reasons how they can work together.

The description of the similarities and differences between the Qur'an and

Pancasila in terms of anatomy, taxonomy, substance, and function are novelty in this study.

3 Method. The research method has been explained in detail and

comprehensively to reveal research problems, and the components contained are relevant to the established journal writing guidelines.

There is no revision in this section.

4 Findings. The research results section has revealed important research findings, but it is necessary to provide specifications regarding the

All the findings of this study are important