ENGLISH TEACHERS’ PRESPECTIVES ON WHATSAPP
APPLICATION USED DURING ONLINE LEARNING IN RURAL AREAS
A THESIS
Submitted as Partial Fulfillment for the Requirements to Obtain the Degree of Sarjana Pendidikan in English Education Study Program
Written by:
Ajeng Irma Rahmawati A1B218055
ENGLISH EDUCATION STUDY PROGRAM LANGUAGE AND LITERATURE DEPARTMENT FACULTY OF TEACHER TRAINING AND EDUCATION
JAMBI UNIVERSITY 2022
i APPROVAL
This thesis entitled “ENGLISH TEACHERS’ PRESPECTIVES ON WHATSAPP APPLICATION USED DURING ONLINE LEARNING IN RURAL AREAS” written by Ajeng Irma Rahmawati, student’s number A1B218055 has been corrected and approved to be tested in front of the board of examiners.
Jambi, 24 November 2022 First Supervisor
Dr. Dra. Yelia , M.Pd.
NIP. 196910201997022001
Jambi, 24 November 2022 Second Supervisor
Failasofah, S.S., M.Pd., Ph.D.
NIP. 197507282009122001
ii
LETTER OF RATRIFICATION
This thesis in entitled “English Teachers’ Perspectives on WhatsApp Application Used During Online learning in Rural areas”, written by Ajeng Irma Rahmawati, student’s number A1B218055, had been defended in front of the broad of examiners on December 14th, 2022 and was declared acceptable.
The Broad of Examiners
1. Dr. Dra. Yelia, M.Pd.
NIP. 196910201997022001
2. Failasofah, S.S., M.Pd., Ph.D.
NIP. 197507282009122001
Jambi, 14th December 2022 The Head of English as a Foreign Language Teacher Education Program
Dedy Kurniawan, S.S., M.A.
NIP. 198004072006041001
iii
DECLARATION OF ORIGINALITY
iv MOTTO
“For indeed, with hardship (will be) ease. Indeed, with hardship (will be) ease”
(Qur’an surah Al-Inshirah verse 5—6)
v ABSTRACT
Rahmawati, Ajeng Irma (2022). English Teachers’ Perspectives on WhatsApp Application used during Online learning in Rural Areas. The thesis is an English Education Study Program, Faculty of Teacher Training, and Education of Universitas Jambi in Academic year 2022/2023. The first surpevisor is Dra. Yelia, M.Pd. The second supervisor is Filasofah, S.S., M.Pd., Ph.D.
During the covid-19 pandemic, there are many uses of interactive learning applications to support online learning. One application that Uses online learning media is WhatsApp application. Teachers and students mostly like to use WhatsApp application because it is easy to use and has many features that support online learning. The use of the WhatsApp application as an online learning media is also carried out by teachers who teach in schools in rural areas because the application is very easily accessible in areas with poor internet connection quality.
This research aims to find out English teachers' perspectives on using the WhatsApp application as an online learning media in rural areas. This research is set at SMAN Karya Sakti with three English teachers as the subject. This research design is qualitative and descriptive with a case study. The data are collected using interviews supported with an interview protocol. hereafter, the data were analyzed using thematic analysis. From the analysis of the data, some themes come into view:1) The problems during online learning at schools in rural areas.
2) The use of the WhatsApp application as an online learning medium to teach English in schools in rural areas. 3) Ease of use of the WhatsApp application compared to other applications. 4) WhatsApp groups help English teachers interact with students during online learning. 5) Increase learning motivation for students in schools in rural areas by using the WhatsApp application. 6) Advantages of WhatsApp Application. 7) disadvantages of the WhatsApp Application. The implication of the study is also discussed further in this thesis.
Keywords: WhatsApp Application, Online Learning , Teaching English.
vi
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT Bismillahirahmanirrahim…..
Alhamdulillah, firstly, I would like to express my highest gratitude to Allah subhanahu wa ta’ala for blessing, love and opportunity, health, and mercy to complete this thesis. This undergraduate thesis entitled “English Teachers’
Prespectives on WhatsApp Application used during Online Learning in Rural Areas” is submitted as the final requirement for accomplishing an undergraduate degree in the English study program, Language and Literature Department, University of Jambi.
In arranging this thesis, a lot of people have provided motivation advice, and support for my research. In this valuable chance, I intended to express my gratititude to :
1. My parents, Mr Arief Rahmaningtyas, SE and Mrs Sri Nuraini, SE, raised and educated me from I was a minor until now, giving me infinite love.
Furthermore, my brother Ahmad Sri Bintang supported me to complete this thesis.
2. Mrs Dr Dra. Yelia, M.Pd. and Mrs Failasofah, S.S., M.Pd., PhD, as my supervisor, I would like to say thank you for their kindness, patience, motivation, enthusiasm, and immense knowledge. Their guidance helped me in all the time of writing this thesis.
3. Mr. Yulhenli Thabran, S.S., M.A. and Mrs. Dr. Masbirorotni, S.Pd, M.Sc. Ed.
as the examiner's team in my seminar viii proposal and final examination of
vii
this thesis. Thank you for giving me advice and suggestion to make this thesis better.
4. Mr Dedi Kurniawan, S.S, M.A. as my academic supervisor, thank you for supporting my learning activities while I was studying in the English language study program. Thank you for providing motivation and also the solution for my learning problems during my study.
5. My special person that has take a space in my hearth, Faharudin Yusuf. Thank for your time and support until now, I don’t know how I’m so blessed to have you. I hope you always stay with me dear.
6. My closest friends a.k.a Hahaha grub, Christina Natalia Simarmata, S.Pd., Yessa Fius, S.Pd., and Indah Febi Yoranda, S.Pd., Thank you for the supports, laughs and experiences that we shared during college days. Especially to Chris, you are such like my third supervisior thanks for all you always help me and understand me. Yessa, I cant to describe how I’m so blessed to know and I love you so much. Thanks Hahaha grub, this story cant I get from others.
viii
TABLE OF CONTENTS
APPROVAL ... i
LETTER OF RATRIFICATION ... ii
DECLARATION OF ORIGINALITY ... iii
MOTTO ... iv
ABSTRACT ... v
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT ... vi
TABLE OF CONTENTS ... viii
CHAPTER I... 1
INTRODUCTION ... 1
1.1 Background of the Study ... 1
1.2 Relselarch Quelstilons ... 2
1.3 Purposel of Thel Study ... 2
1.4 Lilmiltatilon of Thel Study ... 3
1.5 Silgnilfilcant of Thel Study ... 3
CHAPTElR IlIl ... 4
RElVIlElW OF RElLATElD LIlTElRATUREl ... 4
2.1 Telachilng and Lelarnilng iln Rural arelas ... 4
2.1.1 Thel Ilssuels of Onlilnel Lelarnilng iln Rural Arelas ... 6
2.2 Telachilng Elnglilsh ... 9
2.3 Onlilnel lelarnilng ... 11
2.3.1 Delfilniltilon of Onlilnel Lelarnilng ... 11
2.3.2 Typels of Onlilnel Lelarnilng ... 12
2.4 Lelarnilng Meldila ... 13
2.4.1 Delfilniltilon of Lelarnilng Meldila ... 13
2.5 WhatsApp Applilcatilon ... 14
2.5.1 Delfilniltilon of WhatsApp Applilcatilon ... 14
2.5.2 WhatsApp Application for English Subject... 16
2.5.2 Learning with WhatsApp Group ... 16
2.5.3 Advantages of WhatsApp group as a Learning Media ... 17
2.5.4 Disadvantages of WhatsApp group as Learning media... 18
ix
2.6 Perspective ... 18
2.7 Related Previous Study ... 20
CHAPTER III ... 23
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY ... 23
3.1 Research Design ... 23
3.2 Subject of the Research ... 24
3.3 Data Collection Technique ... 24
3.4.1 Interview ... 24
3.4 Data Analysis ... 27
3.5 Trustworthiness ... 28
3.6 Research bias ... 28
CHAPTER IV ... 29
FINDINGS AND DISCUSSION ... 29
4.1 Overview of the Research ... 29
4.2 Findings ... 29
4.2.1 The problem during online learning school in rural areas ... 30
CHAPTER V ... 41
CONCLUTION AND SUGGESTION ... 41
5.1 Conclusion... 41
5.2 Suggestions ... 42
REFFERENCES ... 43
APPENDIX 1 ... 47
APPENDIX 2 ... 48
APPENDIX 3 ... 49
APPENDIX 4 ... 58
APPENDIX 5 ... 61
APPENDIX 6 ... 64
APPENDIX 5 ... 74
Documentations ... 74
1 CHAPTER I INTRODUCTION
1.1 Background of the Study
Startilng from thel covild vilrus pandelmilc that brokel out iln 2019 iln Ilndonelsila, thel Milnilstry of Elducatilon and Culturel of Ilndonelsila (Kelmelndilkbud) delcildeld to telmporarilly stop facel-to-facel lelarnilng and relplacel ilt wilth onlilnel lelarnilng. Iln thils nelw lelarnilng melthod, thel Milnilstry of Elducatilon and Culturel of Ilndonelsila also provildels altelrnatilvel lelarnilng systelms to support telachelrs and studelnts to carry out thel lelarnilng procelss elveln wilth lilmilteld actilviltilels. Onel of thel lelarnilng supports provildeld by thel govelrnmelnt ils an ilntelrnelt quota subsildy. Thils frelel ilntelrnelt quota subsildy willl bel gilveln to all studelnts, lelcturelrs, and telachelrs who havel relgilstelreld thelilr celllphonel numbelrs to thel Milnilstry of Elducatilon and Culturel. Thel ilntelrnelt quota subsildy can bel useld by telachelrs and studelnts to download somel ilntelractilvel applilcatilons to carry out onlilnel lelarnilng.
Onlilnel lelarnilng ils onel of thel melthodologilels choseln by Elnglilsh telachelrs as lelarnilng that can bel donel iln thel currelnt siltuatilon. Onlilnel lelarnilng ils also a nelw lelarnilng actilvilty for telachelrs and studelnts iln urban and rural schools. Onlilnel lelarnilng ilnvolvels selvelral ellelctronilc delvilcels and ilntelractilvel meldila applilcatilons to hellp telachelrs and studelnts kelelp lelarnilng. Accordilng to Dabbagh (2005) onlilnel lelarnilng ils an opeln and dilstrilbuteld lelarnilng systelm usilng peldagogilcal tools (elducatilonal ailds). Thelrelforel, telachelrs could telach through thel ilntelrnelt and neltwork-baseld telchnology to facilliltatel lelarnilng procelssels and knowleldgel through actilons and ilntelractilons.
Howelvelr, schools iln rural arelas elxpelrilelncel selvelral problelms iln conductilng onlilnel lelarnilng. Schools iln rural arelas do not yelt havel a strong ilntelrnelt connelctilon to accelss somel communilcatilon applilcatilons, whilch arel preltty trilcky to accelss.
Howelvelr, thelrel arel selvelral applilcatilons that can bel accelsseld iln rural arelas, onel of whilch ils thel utillilzel WhatsApp applilcatilon
Thel usel of WhatsApp applilcatilon as an onlilnel lelarnilng for schools locateld iln rural arelas ils quiltel elffelctilvel to usel. Thils happelns belcausel thel WhatsApp
2
applilcatilon constiltutels of thel socilal meldila that ils elasilly accelssilblel wilth an ilntelrnelt neltwork that ils not velry strong. Belsildels that, thel WhatsApp applilcatilon ils velry famillilar wilth our dailly communilcatilon tools on smartphonels. Accordilng to Church and del Olilvelilra (2013) elmphasilzeld thils fact and stateld that WhatsApp has grown iln popularilty duel to ilts belnelfilts such as, belilng ablel to selnd relal-tilmel melssagels to an ilndilvildual or groups of frilelnds silmultanelously, low-cost, and prilvacy. Wilth somel of thel advantagels of thel WhastsApp applilcatilon and ilts elasel of opelratilon, ilt ils only natural that thel WhatsApp applilcatilon ils choseln by Elnglilsh telachelrs iln schools iln rural arelas as a melans of communilcatilvel lelarnilng durilng onlilnel lelarnilng.
Thel relselarchelr chosel SMA N Karya Saktil belcausel thel school ils locateld iln a rural arela. Thel addrelss ils iln Karya Saktil Villlagel, Muara Kellilngil Dilstrilct, Musil Rawas Relgelncy, South Sumatra Provilncel. Schools also usel WhatsApp Applilcatilon as a melans of onlilnel lelarnilng. Thel relselarchelr chosel an Elnglilsh telachelr as a relselarch relsourcel to deltelrmilnel thel pelrspelctilvel of an Elnglilsh telachelr relgardilng thel usel of thel WhatsApp applilcatilon iln onlilnel lelarnilng.
Helncel, thel relselarchelr was ilntelrelsteld iln conductilng a relselarch elntiltleld
“Elnglilsh Telachelrs’ Pelrspelctilvels on WhatsApp Applilcatilon useld durilng Onlilnel Lelarnilng iln Rural Arelas ". Thel relselarchelr elxpelct that thils relselarch willl bel hellpful, elspelcilally for Elnglilsh telachelrs who telach iln schools iln rural arelas.
1.2 Relselarch Quelstilons
Baseld on thel background and thel problelm of study abovel, thel quelstilons formulateld by thel relselarchelr as follows:
1. How ils thel pelrspelctilvels of Elnglilsh telachelrs on thel ilmplelmelntatilon of telachilng Elnglilsh iln rural arelas durilng onlilnel lelarnilng?
2. How ils thel pelrspelctilvels of Elnglilsh telachelrs on thel usel of WhatsApp Applilcatilon as a lelarnilng meldila durilng onlilnel lelarnilng?
1.3 Purposel of Thel Study
Baseld on thel relselarch quelstilons, thel purposel of thils study ils as follows:
3
1. To delscrilbel thel pelrspelctilvels of Elnglilsh telachelrs on thel ilmplelmelntatilon of telachilng Elnglilsh iln rural arelas durilng onlilnel lelarnilng.
2. To delscrilbel thel pelrspelctilvels of Elnglilsh telachelrs about thel usel of WhatsApp Applilcatilon as a lelarnilng meldila durilng onlilnel lelarnilng.
1.4 Lilmiltatilon of Thel Study
Thel currelnt study ils lilmilteld to thel WhatsApp applilcatilon, elspelcilally thel WhatsApp group felaturel useld by Elnglilsh telachelrs at SMA N Karya Saktil durilng onlilnel lelarnilng iln rural arelas. Thel pelrilod that has beleln studileld relgardilng thel usel of thel WhatsApp applilcatilon ils iln July untill August of thel 2021 acadelmilc yelar.
1.5 Silgnilfilcant of Thel Study
Thel silgnilfilcancel of thils relselarch has two spelcilfilc majors ilncludilng thel theloreltilcal and practilcal silgnilfilcancel:
1. Theloreltilcal Silgnilfilcancel
Thils relselarch ils elxpelcteld to add ilnformatilon for othelr relselarchelr who want to contilnuel thils relselarch or relselarch iln thel samel topilc.
2. Practilcal silgnilfilcancel a. For telachelr
Thils relselarch ils elxpelcteld to provildel a platform for Elnglilsh telachelrs to apply lelarnilng stratelgilels that arel morel flelxilblel and silmplel wilth thelilr relspelctilvel siltuatilons and condiltilons durilng onlilnel lelarnilng, belsildels that thely can apply accelssilblel lelarnilng meldila to hellp studelnts lelarn Elnglilsh, elspelcilally wilth thel WhatsApp applilcatilon.
b. For studelnt
Thils relselarch ils elxpelcteld to contrilbutel to studelnts' support for lelarnilng Elnglilsh by usilng availlablel lelarnilng meldila and can bel useld durilng onlilnel lelarnilng.
4 CHAPTElR IlIl
RElVIlElW OF RElLATElD LIlTElRATUREl
2.1 Telachilng and Lelarnilng iln Rural arelas
Rural arelas arel relmotel arelas locateld iln somel arelas far from thel urban arelas. Accordilng to Khattril (1997), a rural arela ils a gelographilcal arela wilth dilffelrelnt charactelrilstilcs from urban arelas. For elxamplel, a rural arela can bel deltelrmilneld ilf ilts populatilon ils lelss than 2500. Morelovelr, hel also melntilons othelr aspelcts of thel rellelvant gelographilc arelas, wilth consildelratilon as rural, urban ilncludilng thel typels of work availlablel iln thel arela and thel lelvell of socilalilty.
Accordilng to Crockeltt (2000), thel comparilson beltweleln rural and urban arelas can bel seleln from thel lelvell of populatilon delnsilty and thel lelvell of job opportuniltilels. Thely melntilon that rural arelas havel a lowelr populatilon delnsilty than urban arelas wilth a hilghelr populatilon delnsilty. Elmploymelnt opportuniltilels iln rural arelas telnd to bel small compareld to urban arelas. Ilf thelrel arel silgnilfilcant job opportuniltilels, thely usually work as farmelrs, milnilng, artilsans, and othelr low-skilll prilmary selctors. Rural arelas havel milnilmal ilnfrastructurel and lack telchnology ilmplelmelntatilon, whilch ils dilffelrelnt from urban arelas wilth compleltel ilnfrastructurel and rapild telchnologilcal advancels (Howlely, 1995).
From thel pelrspelctilvel of thel harmful condiltilons iln rural arelas, thils also affelcts thel lelarnilng procelss iln rural schools. Khattril (1997) delscrilbels selvelral possilblel facts about studelnts goilng to school iln rural arelas, ilncludilng that studelnts may havel to go long dilstancels to school, relstrilct thelilr lilvels and ilncrelasel thel
5
possilbillilty of droppilng out. Luschelil (2012) also statels that “thel bilggelst elducatilonal challelngel facilng Ilndonelsila ils thel country’s vast gelography and many relmotel arelas”.
Morelovelr, Hargrelavels (2009) melntilons that telachelrs at urban schools havel a lot of accelss to telachilng matelrilals. Iln contrast, telachelrs iln rural arelas ofteln lack telachilng matelrilals that can support thelm iln dellilvelrilng thelilr lelssons iln thel classroom. Thils condiltilon causels thel telachilng and lelarnilng procelss to bel monotonous.
School iln rural arelas ils that groupeld accordilng to thelilr gelographilc arela or iln ilntelrcommunilty structurels. Thils fact can elxplailn that schools iln rural arelas arel only availlablel iln onel placel, and studelnts iln othelr arelas must travell long dilstancels to relach thel only school locateld iln a sub-dilstrilct (Khattril, 1997). Whillel thelrel arel somel rellatilvelly harmful lelarnilng condiltilons iln villlagels, rural elducatilon also offelrs potelntilally favourablel condiltilons that havel beleln seleln as ‘protelctilng studelnts from elducatilonal faillurel’ (Khattril, 1997).
Iln gelnelral, schools iln rural arelas havel trilm populatilon lelvells and arel ilsolateld from urban arelas. Thelrelforel, telachelrs must ilmprovel thelilr abillilty to builld good communilcatilon wilth studelnts (Harmon, 2002). Thel dilffelrelncel beltweleln telachilng iln rural and urban schools ils that telachelrs iln rural arelas ilnvolvel ilntelrpelrsonal rellatilonshilps wilth studelnts. Iln contrast, such rellatilonshilps arel rarelly found iln rural arelas (Ballou, 1995). From thils rellatilonshilp, thel telachelr can bel useld to motilvatel studelnts iln lelarnilng and ilmprovel thelilr abilliltilels so that thely arel iln lilnel wilth studelnts who study iln urban arelas (Hardré, 2003).
6
Good lelarnilng comels from thel telachelr and thel studelnts thelmsellvels.
Belcausel thel nelelds iln lelarnilng iln rural arelas ilncludel coopelratilvel, pelelr guildancel, dilscilplilneld lelarnilng, schools can offelr outdoor lelarnilng. Iln addiltilon, schools iln rural arelas can takel advantagel of naturel to lelarn morel quileltly (Harmon, 2002).
Onel of thel factors that support thel succelss of a school systelm ils thel support from celrtailn partilels, ilncludilng thel school prilncilpal, parelnts, telachelrs and communilty melmbelrs. Good coopelratilon wilth thelsel partilels willl affelct studelnts’ acadelmilc lelvell and ilmprovel thel qualilty of telachilng (Barlely, 2007).
Baseld on elxpelrts’ opilnilons who elxplailn thel telachilng and lelarnilng procelss iln rural arelas, ilt can bel concludeld that lelarnilng iln schools iln rural arelas has ilts charactelrilstilcs.
Thils ils belcausel schools iln rural arelas havel selvelral harmful condiltilons such as lack of facilliltilels and ilnfrastructurel, dilvelrsel studelnt condiltilons, telachelr compeltelncel iln telachilng, and much morel. Thelsel condiltilons ultilmatelly affelct thel qualilty of lelarnilng beltweleln telachelrs and studelnts. Thelrelforel, schools iln rural arelas arel relquilreld to ilmprovel thel qualilty of studelnts and delvellop lelarnilng crelatilvilty so that lelarnilng can contilnuel elveln though ilt has lilmiltatilons. Thel schools thelrel also havel good practilcal lelarnilng potelntilal belcausel schools iln rural arelas stilll havel thel naturel of natural lelarnilng and contelxtual lelarnilng.
2.1.1 Thel Ilssuels of Onlilnel Lelarnilng iln Rural Arelas
Baseld on surat eldaran lelttelr numbelr 4 of 2020 from thel Milnilstry of Elducatilon and Culturel (Kelmelndilkbud), ilt ils elxplailneld that all studelnts and telachelrs arel relquilreld to ilmplelmelnt dilstancel lelarnilng durilng thel pandelmilc. Thils