^TREM CHAND Kl GHAIR AFSANWITAHRIRON
KA TAHQIQIWA TANQIDIMUTALA^^
ABSTRACT
T H E S I S
SUBMITTED FOR THE AWARD OF THE DEGREE OF
inctnr nf pijtl050p%
IN
URDU
BY
MINHAJUDDIN
Under the Supervision of
DR. M. SAGHIR BEG
(Pen Name : SAGHIR AFRAHEIM)
Department of Urdu
ALIGARH MUSLIM UNIVERSITY ALIGARH (INDIA)
^ik^d^~>J^^U>y/dyi^iMj>/-y
Jl/
' • / • »(r^'/'ye":rt/)
j>J><;: - ^/J^'J'.^yf^^/J'
N»1ciY^^^T
wT/t^.r-CJllfiL/j>Vk_^^l>/i v^yi^viUlT^vlj^v^ ^'l^^iii'r-Lf>^iiLr'>j(tr>ii<:7 ( j / - ) ^ ; jiJir c^i;/5>r(j/*)<y
i/lvj^iAf^v^M^y/r^
M>^
J . r , r , r ^<a _1 , z . - A «<1 ^(^ - I I - i r•ir
jr*
(j:t c.lv i'-y j M i ^ ^ ^ l ^ / y ^ j l j C/l W y l IJU^^I. b f v / ^
-.i::^ >i»(Ji^l^^C^L>£c/lt/(/L'jl^^^(^y''^(:/ii^(^(>r^l
J>2^1|j^y/ycr^,L?^^^^'c:-ti<^l^*)£>^f^y(^f->l^^l
YREM CHAND Kl GHAIR AFSANWITAHRIRON
KA TAHQIQi WA TANQIOIMUTALA^^
T H E S I S
SUBMITTED FOR THE AWARD OF THE DEGREE OF
IN
URDU
BY
MINHAJUDDIN
Under the Supervision of
DR. M. SAGHIR BEG
(Pen Name : SAGHIR AFRAHEIM)
Department of Urdu
ALIGARH MUSLIM UNIVERSITY ALIGARH (INDIA)
^ It'J>s;
CFVJ
vA^y LJ f i (/>;> ,^y
J^
ivj\)iSLpi}Uy.
Jl/
' • / • •(^(/(ye^i^t/)
^ft
2),
epanmen of ijrau
'P h
ALIGARII MUSLIM UNIVERSITY, ALIGARII-202002 (India) Tel.: {700920,921
{Extn. 1631
Dated:30;.4'><^6
Certificate
This is to certify that this thesis entitled ''Prem
Chanel Ki Ghair Afsanavi Tahriron Ka Tahqiqi-wa-Tanqidi
Mutala'' being submitted by Mr. Minhajuddin under my
supervision and guidance. It is an original research work and it has not been submitted to any other University for any other degree.
This thesis is forwarded for the first time for the award of Ph.D. degree in Urdu. Counter i^Afzaiptfsain) "tjhairiTUHf (Dr. Saghir Afiahcim) Supervisor D f p . 1 1 ' . J ' . * .•! I ; a
iJlali)
( i M U I • j l )
c.<y(|jf^ icy)
>2r (c:;j))
c;:ri> (C7)
^ ; (d)
/ J L k u A C t t t t ^ t jLiL:k Aj u •i^'^h^I
l^lil^U^ : ^ ^ l
Aju\Sh\
iS^J^i ^yjc^ ^[^L i/t-; jSiiJi^ r(iv»;4>i J / ^ ± £ (jViii: of l:>b
Zl(Long Short Story)ii7Ai^>l^ J l i J ^ i ^ i ^ / J t ^ < C / t ^ '
^ ' k , t>?7 tij, jt^ y^*zl
J i ^ ; i ^ J ^ t y ^ t r > r A 3 j . ^ u r ^ / u ^ j 7 i r - ^ f e j ^ i i ^ £ £
• i/!^/<)(/'^(jyi:>bj>^)7ij Ji>ki^J^t X
O M / U ^ ^ ^ / ^
t>r(>^y^u L^^y(ui::/^c;^zl c.t^Lr>:>|^y
(f)
irA , ( / -w^tv^cJVt^/'wjijJv't^Jvt^L/rd:
• • • ' ^ • • * «
w^v
j^ ^ trif l/t^fU/^l^/i wr^v^l c/t^in j y ^ ^ C ^
:4x5L5u) ( a i l )
: 6 j L ; ^ ( r )
• • * • •
l/' i^ (/I >r / c i ) (/ / / \:(j
£^/U>^LifiJ^l^L/>^jyuJUiL:Jl;V^t^Vl^'-^"^'^^*^^^^
: <^U (u)
• • * •
: jLoIa.1 ())
:>- (T)
:(^jlLjljj^ (r)
iJUjjA^jSUijI^rn.A^.I. ( r )
• *
:oU5lj ( r )
:<ji5ljC)j>^4jLa.l> ( r )
:<Gjf^ ( i )
:/^^ r ^ li.::?^ U^(>L. ( / ^ ^i/^;j:r uTl^il^ T^^^
- < i ^
• • •
:jUTt>iL ( Y )
rcixklj (r)
:OLULIA ( l )
»
• • •
*
roLxlilL^obiilj ( 0
rojjLiiaild^ ( Y )
nsjdjj^j^ (r)
: o i ^ j ^ L j ( i )
yjyi^'^/^yu^'u£dU^iii^^-4J>^J>>^%Ji^L/4tJ^^^^
Lr;byvi>^c/!^^>i£^iiir!^£i^t<^v/c.jJU.^ir^^
- - If
«>/iv' 9>>4?; ^ ihj;>i (sJij^ f^^jij ijt iX^^y
-£xJui/c/!:c^i>"j>i;J^u>j/^^y£>fL/i^c:/b^j^>W^^
ji^^y:
-^>^J^uyV*>fly>ic:"j/>j/;" (II)
• •
oli;>^i;-ir.Jyj(/i>^,ir.^yii.ir.(/<(/j^«ii*l^(/l(».c>^«^.u^U(jt;^
^^ijrz^/^U^\Jiiy^"c.hjh" Or)
•(at* (S*^) c^luui^
• * *
^><>^T.J^^r<c^^v^vi^9vy.[k<v^;/^l>Ciy^r^->>'Iy^^c^^
" 0 ^ » ' (A)
* * V y y •• '^
-/x^l^L^.Hrr^vkt^^yJ^-jy^^/- („)
J^dl^(j:r.(9rA4rji;j:fy(/(J,t:ivy^,i)">J^^' (ir)
J^5l^o^.i9rr^crvk.'^yJ>>-((i>:Jj^y)'U,l^ju,/' , r
-<i7^l>(j:!.i'?nHrji.J,^iJl:>,>;^(^y)'Ju5r . r
(^^- Oi^ Jd"^ ^J^ c^b'i <r^>* t ^ ^ U^ (^"^
** * 7
r^j^t
1 *• y • • • • • • • • / • • • *• ••
a — J 4
rq_t/,i9i^iJi>..^^Ui:clJvJiJyrr*'£_'>o/^^^(v^v
: c ^ 2 ^ j ^ d A X f ^ . ( t ^ y / i
r^-L/'<>^(^y-'(ij>l>JUi/' ~ L
rr,(/^>^f^y-'Liy(^il7,>^" : ^
M
* V
• *
- • • • • * - ' • > • • • • ' • • • ' - - - H • - ^ y " ' • • ' • • I.. I — . - • i . . . — . I • —
L yj'^ bj b^/-' l/^^
A * r > '
'2L>
• •• •
• «
• • • • • j
Jjjii^ c^i/^i (^/c.if (/^ if^^. L ij\ 6^if}'\^ if^L^
JiJiJ
bc^>t^(i^^4^(j''/u>^'wf^t'ifijiy^;'7iZlJv;i^i_bc^i^
*::^ ^ Vl/'y^t*^ ^ / ( J ^ lrA>^»>i( (J^vify^c^ ^ Y'^'' '"^•^
ti'»-nAj^V>ir"Jl^^^"
nJ^,J^^/i}</J^^iyi£u^/J^yj>/-y I
• • * •
I. ^ - i
: - < ^
I
£ ( / U ^ Z->^i^(/v V'^y'-^'^-^i^ ^^^^1^^^=^ v^
j>.
r^^t
** ** ^
J
f^^i/ *(Jl/Ov^Vtv>C:l>j/vly*w^l>^Jy
( V )
^Itiu^' J^/^^/ (»)
.i2^J>r? /UiyJ/l^fX/i (r)
,\^cJ\ \S/^\^^\j)^ (r)
^ll[I.c'-»^ c.vO<l/t:/LU (r)
^lill'^V ^>tf3f^V^ii (l)
-^^(j:^ci>'i>>J^./uyirt/t?jH^^Uv-.i^^
(/LZ,(/c^JO'^y^ii./c/<w=^:^(;Ti/ijyirt/^
••(i• •• • ' ^ * *
. I ^ j j v r ?
^ii:3/^
^iJli^
f H K ^ / l fijir^vl^HiDJ^y^
^il!^^
.iV5iJ^>^ , i ^ / i ijr^Jv/eiJDtt^'
^iJlS-^llIS-/^
^ i ; I I I I I I I I I I I I I I iJjfA^y
• 1 V ' M I I ^ i ; I I I I (JJ^JL/Iyjll/Dli^ W > ) ^ juur
* c^\JiMi6hJ
{fiJI^iMf-JJMH/K^
C/'Vjit6>V(0^t
^U»(/^ t;/l6L^[^ c^lij3(^(juj^>! JCJ^,. jt^AC^^Xf^)^^ - ^ «1 ^ ^ - A - ^ « ! • ,11 «ir jr «ir - ( ^ -11 - ( ^ -lA - f * S IIIw.j(iiyi^u><fi^>^f^y(j:tJii;£t/^J/li>U9i-i^^^Ub6(i^(j:rj^
i.>i^j£^/Lfu^uJii^(£c^y^>U(/4^i>i3j>(i/(^
^
^ ^ <
« « «
• — • V
i^T^ ^Oi/ i^/y c>/^/v(r ^ 1 1 , (j/i/(/c^c/>- iT^^ f^>:
V v •» ' .Ir-r J - L ^ J ^ b / ^ . c / ! / J ^ ^ c f t / ^ ^ ( / 1 ^ . ^ / U i ^
^ i ^ j / l t j i i T ^ l i/^vilwi^y ^ l t U ^ £ U J I / 9 ^ JjL^>if d'-^i^'U'^^
brc:^uy>^jirii(j:iyuV->^6>t^'-^>itr-/(/iv^
-/^>^7y/^.vJ^iJU(^yiV^2/>4'^^^'f^^^/^^
tyl-Uif'''^/u;u-(ilJ%ii;>b(/(/i>(ji>viiij>yjv(j^
. ; i ^ ?^ t^c:>y/cii ?c^ ^ ^ c ; : ; cipc/^L^r''"'^ ^ ^ ^ f
-:^1 350 ^ V b ,1 02 ^SjJ'iS^y^ ^ r <M(/ .r••t^^^XM/^li^>c^v^l^>:>^yc.L/ i
i n05
05
01
02
02
01
53
20
03
02
05
07
09
07
22
15
02
06
06
02
01
11
J>/c/J(fU
J?UlV>^(
J3Jijj}^C[JlJ/>\r
Ji/^^^^'^\j(ivy^Oc/Ty^'
J\J^JX^.ij^i^JhiSA
iJhcr/L^h
iiiJi/ly^CjyAM
i/ti/^y^r'^cT.
^if-cf'i^
* • ^Jt'iil^yJ/) i^jh^j if }^{j/)/j^J.iJi)J/) .
i^y^6iM
^y/i\jP'\,r
^Cis\
^L ^A , 9 , ! • ,11 j r j r JC Jd ,11 j ^ -lA ,19,r»
, r i.rr
.rr
, r r
,rci
irz.27 l>iJU(/iv - r i 01 j^^JM -^^
02 (iJIr-J^l^) ^l>y/V -f'^
05 l/Z-f.^ -r<l
01 -'1^4^*' -^*
08 I'/r'^ci^ -^'
01 (il^/l>5 -rr 01 \Syy4'^i^A^ - r r 04 J f ^ / Y ' O i ^ - r r 01 yjvvt^vvAT . r ^ •* - r 02 k^>^?f'> ' ^ ^ 04, lf^Uyci->yC> - r ^ 04 ^j^jJ>^(\j -rA 01 > / L / ' Y ' ^ ^ ^ - ^ ' ' 14 'T^jy^L^^' -(^^05 iJy^iJOir -ri
06 J y i f c / ' A i ' - r r 02 ( j i l ^ ) ( i v / ^ l - r r 01 Zu<Jii^vDi - r r 01 i^'iJ/V>li<u/i -f^^ 01 y>i^t|-2-. ^(^101 ^tjyr ,rz
irA01 / L ^ / V / -rA
07 I^jk/i ^d*
08 \JMJ^^ - ^ ' 01 \/.\jiJ>.jU ^<ir01 C f ^ j l r i , ^ r
01 J>^;?Jiic/^oJ^ - ^ r
01 \:)\MAJJ:\ ^dd 01 ^ t ; j ^ , ^ 1 01 ^^/(\j ^dL 01 ( i / j j ^ v r ^ O ^iSA01
>Pi' ^^q
03 i^vUS>y^ - V 0 2 l>;,vUj-(> , 1 1 01 iL^l/l^y ,ir 01 ij^J'jijy - i r01 -'^''-2^'i^r-i -^(^
01 lvj>l/6'> -^^ 02 c/t^^*"^--^ -^^ 01 a / L j U y ^ V ) - 1 ^ 01 c://* - i A 01 (J7^U/lf>i -^^01 01 01 01 01 01 03 12 01 01 01 01
Ji>4f>J( -A.
660 58 23 07 690 ir»(ii)
• • •
i<So^ 'IfTc/f^L ( r )
.:>'.
- If
ji\S^Jjtc.\^\J^Uyji\^L(}^J^\^U'c:^\jii\/i). i :
^ \
ji?-^f^(/^Tji'(J'j>^,Lfiy^^^j(/(/^Oc^(jy^^
Message of the c^y^l^^/tvvi^jv-i^iJiC/J^U'^Tlfy
irr.(/'lt^v6:y^Ul>-f>L;iyy>d^ilZlJii^Forest
(iii)
, £ :
?wX^v^Jl ( / jtj^uA^^^U^Lor^^y^?^
(LX/l:ifi9nc^/rr:J.U(r^,^bi)r^i.t/ -<f^lrL>*
^ci>*; (j->((^ cii:>^>^ v A ^ i ^ ^ L v ; » y £ ^ T
rrr .rr^j.j^ -^a^^Lf'
^i;7i(J''^^r^^J>^^'vUij>^i/^,-i;^ircrr'(£r.
y •• ***** **
ft
i^l^'/jCly v>J^i^ i/f^i:
L C ^ V - ^ ^^ ^ ^ ^ li^^J^i/'^iL^
LT£ U ^ , ^ L/l/Cfi^i^ U/l~J(vi(.l*}iJa)£ t^Uti^^^^^
(/(Personal Essay)^( (/> l(Light Essay)*:!( .i/U £ £
> U l Oi-L^ 2£^(Essay) ^Li^/c^L^viic. lilJ^Zl ciUvi( 2^ If
LT (Essay)4iuljr: ^ ^ I r t X ^ ir^ l/^'U^^^lP^rVy/c^iy^ t-U
^ Vilest Jbi ( ^ Jjviyj>(^ J v O ^ > / y j A ^ ^ ( ^ > ) i ^ ^
^ «» y y j M * T
y
If »
^
J^JULr'L^'^Lr>^f^<4t/,-l*/^t^1880L/^(jlX]^/>£^
{^^\
jdWbMfl
• • . -A• • •
mBm mm m
^^~M^Lfri^'^^-^~u^^^J/^'^-^\>^.^ L
• A*
• V ^ ** * * •
ir»-irL^r Jiy^.t^^y.i^->lf c>c>(i/c.U^
(/U> J.I-* cTU M -t^ (S^ c ^ C/l>^ If'c^l^^jyZl >^ f^y J^'>^
r<^<i_i^
iTui/^/^iAfx J / v -f- J/(/^ if'/i^ Ji:^^>^ ^ J>^-^^f
: ^ U i | / ^ i r
^(JlfJtJfl^liu/i/^r
l^t^jj
^^J'i
/ ^ ^ ^ / ^ ^ > lir 1 ^ 1 ^ li^ • • 7 T I • t *• 11^(^rrj'yf/ir
1^1
|-tb2^Uv
c i A
I I I I 11 I I I I I I I IiT'
C J A I I I I I I I I I I I IO^'
dA
I I Cilr^Jt^L5/f>'(i(/A
( ^ y ^ ^ U j y y ^J/^t/iJi^U
jL^^i^uMu^^^ycJ^
^/.jtO^h^
\Jj'^/,
[X ^j'iJ^Oif
ii/Jr^/
c ^ / t ^ r t L . L ^
* 4 jX^^JtijjJ^Jiiijy^ iJ--3J0''')ijtj)\fir^lJj\nJl^^jli^vyiJ>-*iL
6 > l ^ j l LTV K9 bii'tc/ly ( i /
J^^
ifj/L^M
J_r
- T^r
- ^ , 1_z.
- A ,q _ ( • ^K ^ir «ir j r ja -11 - l i i : -lA - H ( ^ ^iqrr(//ir
fHrrJui^/ri
,Hrr^iA
clA
*liii^
.rA 1^1.i^rr//i/r»
d/lf
L/^ (/j^vyj;i^^(/Jl-o^^
^LvJrUVuy;icfT
^-^(i.^^
c;i1;^c.^i/'Jc//rwlet-t^^^U^j'^J^r
^^JLTLT^'iT^cCij/^Lr
4/Ju.^
u ^ ^ U c / ! ^ t / / / f j
^ ^ /f y ^ j j j / / ( i
A y J^>y JVuidVii Jy >^
Li/Jv/^iocTUi;?
i/(/<Ly(s^c^l ^)j[;^u/if)t/nCjuJvb^
(ji^i^^l^i:>yTwX(J'c/^JtULj7i^
. r r
sr
^^^ ^^d, n
.r^
.rA
.r^
- ( i * -iit^^r
,(^r
- ( i f «<S(i , ^ ^ - ( i ^ , ^ A ^^9 , 1 * - I f , i r _ i rl^r-f i 9 r r ( / ; ? ^ ^ i ( ^ i £ . U u . i / i / ( i / ^J^JiJA
"^^d^Jii
Ibji^ij^ijl/j}iXSiT'
^hyjsii^fj jljfj^ij^' — 1 » r • i f^^u^C'^
•• • Jc[^)jli)ji [JMj)^^\^\Si^ yiv^Si/h^jbi^j^ i/jjiiivjli^J > J ^
.
^ u / f / .
d^'i'f/
, i r ,i(^ ^11 -1Z. ,1A ,1<1 ^ i i » ^ ^ ( -Z.r - • ^ r-^r
,^i5 --<:i -Z,Z, --i^A -Z.q «A» ^Al - A r - A r _Ar .AtJ\^r
,\^rr}^ f\^rr)^ ^\'^roy\ f i ' i r i ^ fHr(S(j^/> fi^r^jJ^K f\'\rci[jji} \^rO){jj5} .s'irii^A fS^rdij^ ,\^rcij^ ^^^r^ijr. ^i«ir(i(jjir ,\^r&c)^. ,\^ro^^. ,iqr(i^y .i'^rdyr^j ^ ( 9 r i c ^ f H n y ' u ^ I I I I I I M I I 11 I I I I I I I I I I I I ) l I I I I I I I I I I I I 11 c/ir-^o^y jhj^tihh'/.
fj^
W^
(^Vc/yyifi^ yL^yblj/^t^c/LIf C/Jtf^^lLr •;^^6^'L/:::u^'/
(3>^<J*iC?t^
tf>Jj>>^C/iiK> ^(i|/:V(j:!Ji:l^ f^vi'^l^ 7'i>vv>v^^ji^u/i^../?
t/^^'Jl^'^y^ c/<;^U'c/i/'i/i.i^Lr^ >W!^4J_ ivv ly> k-X(< 0-' l*'<:i-1/^(J>i^iJ^>ii^uJ:?t3< - A 1 ^SL , A A -Aq -<1» -91 , 9 r ^-^r , 9 r - 9 ^ -91 - 9 ^ -9A -.99 - ! • • • ( • ( -(•r - i * r - i ^ r - i * ^ ^ M J^L \L^
fi'^r^ijj: fi'^r^ijjf: , f ^ r * ^ .i'^r^X^ ,\o>r*X^ ^- t .i9n(/* ,\^ruf\/Ci f H r r ^ / i / i r . i i r r ^ / i / i r f i 9 r r ^ / ! / n f i ^ r r ^ / i / i r f H r r ^ / i / M ^i^rryr^/iq fi'?rrJvr?/<? f i ^ r r J v ^ i . n r r J V / f r f H r r ^ v l / r » . H r r i l y f / r fi9rr^>r/ir cT^ I I I I M I I I I I I I I I I
dA
I I I I n I I I I H I I 11 I I I I I I I I ( ^ A / j l J u < i L ^ *L/>VXJ/
U^}Ajj> ^ U - V U - L M U I O ^ J L V I ^ (j:l'l(j^(j(Jitf<:_>t7 ^ ^ l ^ ( j / ^ £ -V^;>^L5''^U^tfe/l/ (i^ij(/^jXC7>b< J ( i J ^ ^ j ' u > t - ^ j ^ i /utJ^
^Jriift ^i^Soi^^i t^yvVf JVVvi^ (j"WvUtp((/!iiy'^ ( J v j i c / l f c / l f b ^ i y X y J y4K/^>^
- l » A - ( • q ,11* ^111 -iir ^iir -Mr J\Ci JS^ J\L _((A J\^ jr* - i n - i r r - i r r - i r r >(r^ - i n -(ni -irA -iM l ^ < ^fi9rrJv/(9
j r ^ l ^ l i ^ fi^r*^y fiir^^y fi^n^jp^
fi'injv
^lY2^U->'^t/
O^
I I I I I I t ^ i ^J!/it;
•• 1(/,^^y4\L(S^'
iUji-jj-h
J J - T y ^d \LS^^n^A H r f ( / ^"^Hij/: I'^n^i^ i ^ n / -i 9 r u / ( HH/:^ i^n^» i«!rr(/* \^rr{f i^rrj^ i^rryyi/d \<^n^A \^ruP^i/r i^rr^i^n \^rr/y\/r^ \'^rryy\/r'i \^rryy\/r\ \^rry^^/L (9rr^i,ir c/^ I I M I I I I I I M I I M I I I I I I I I
dA
L/^ 0 / A I I It I I I I I I I Iui/^
O/d^jii^U^-i lyL4_iJj.L/l/J'iJi^
^J^J:Z^7\SJ^/o'JivTJ^
c/V^^^xJ/
krcTt/^
^ l . l . l ^ c C ^ ^ ' ' /yi^>t;^Zlj>^yc/'l^!A^4 y
^vv^J'Jl^iiyyw-.ifr
\SMfc^j^.i)Syi ( i l d r ^ i l t T / l . ^ (j^iiji/^'ii^'^" y ^ i J t ^ i J ^ ^ O ' y _1 , ^ -A , ^ , ! • -(I -ir - i r , i r JOi J^ JL ,IA -H ,r» - n «rr «rr - r r _r^ _ n -n^: IZ.<1,i<^rry^^/r\ ^\'\rryf^/r\ ff^rr^r^ fi^rryr^/ir fHrr>r^ fi'^ri^r^ . i ^ i r r ^ fi^rryr^/ir fHrrJvK/r f»^rrJyK/rr fHrrJyj//i fi^jrrJvK/rr fi9rrJ^/?/r fi^rrJv/?/i f i 9 r r J v / r z ,\^rr'^A/rL *\'^rr^A/rL ,\<^rrif>r<^ ,\^rr^jF*/r ,\'^rr/^ fi9rrt;ii>