• Tidak ada hasil yang ditemukan

Policy Brief Epistema Institute vol 1 2016 web

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2017

Membagikan "Policy Brief Epistema Institute vol 1 2016 web"

Copied!
8
0
0

Teks penuh

(1)

?7<58/@/<!38@38BA74

IRYNZN! V[V! `R^WNQV! XR_NYNUXN]^NUN[! `R^UNQN]! V_V_`VYNU! `N[NU![RTN^N^N(!JN[NU![RTN^N^N!_RNXN['NXN[!NQNYNU!`N[NU!dN[T! QVZVYVXV [RTN^N( IRWN`V[dN& ^NXdN` @[Q\[R_VN& _RONTNV ON[T_NYNU dN[T!ZRZVYVXV!`N[NU(!JR^R^QN]N`!_RWaZYNU!]R^_\NYN[! `R^XNV`!QR[TN[!`N[NU![RTN^N^N(!JaYV_N[!V[V!ZR[TVQR[`VSVXN_V!`VTN! QV! N[N[`N^N^N[N[dN(! GR^`NZN! NQNYNU! XRPR[QR^a[TN[! ]R[RTN^N^NN[! `N[NU'`N[NU!^NXdN`!QNYNZ!]^]^NXNX`VX!]R[QNS`S`N^N^N[!`N[NU(!BRQaN! NQNYNU!XR`VQNXWRYN_N[!_`N`a_!UNX!]NQN!cVYNdNU!]R_V_V^&!`N[NU! `VZOaY&! QN[! `N[NU! ^RXYNZN_V(! ?NY! V[V! NPNPN]! ZR[VZOaYXN[! X\[\[SYVX(! JR^R^NXUV^! `R^XNV`! QR[TN[! UNX! ]R[TRY\YNN[! _RONTNV! caWaQ ]RYNX_N[NN[ XRXRcR[N[TN[ [RTN^N N`N_ `N[NU( 8NTNVZN[N! ZRZNX[NV! UNX! ]R[TRY\YNN[! QN[! R[R[`V`N_! UaXaZ! N]N! dN[T! QN]N`! ZR[WNQV! ]RZN[TXa[a[dN! NQNYNU! ONTVN[! QN^V! ]RZONUN_N[!V[V(

EN_XNXNU V[V ZR[Ta_aYXNXN[ NTNTN^ HKK GRGR^`N[NUN[ ZR[RTN_XN[!XRZONYV!X\[_R]!_RWN`V!QN^V!`N[NU![RTN^N^N(!JN[NU! [RTN^N^N!V`a!_R_a[TTaU[dN!NQNYNU!#`#`N[NU!ON[T_N#!dN[T!ORYaZ! N`Na!`VQNX!QVYRXN`V!UNX!N`N_!`N[NU!N`Na!UNX!aYNdN`(!8R^ONTNV! XRXRXRYV^aN[! QN[! XR`VQNXWRYN_N[! ]R[TN`a^N[! `R^UNQN]! `N[NU! [RTN^N^N!]R^Ya!QVYa^a_XN[!QNYNZ!HKK!GR^`N[NUN[(!GR[QNS`S`N^N^N[! `N[NU!UNX!QR[TN[!]R[QNS`S`N^N^N[!`N[NU![RTN^N^N!UN^a_!OR^WNYN[! _RPN^N^N!OR^_NZNN[ a[a[`aX!ZR[TUV[QN^V!`V[QNXN[!]R[RTN^N^NN[! `N[NU!^NXdN`(`(

=OHK-/KPEG!<EUKLK!9WVKILIL

>GPVNKT!CFCNCJ!RGPICLCS!FK! @GMQNCJ!AKPIIK!>GSUCPCJCP! =CTKQPCN&!>GPVNKT!FCRCU! FKJVDVPIK!OGNCNVK!CNCOCU! G%OCKN-!CPCTNVUJHK/TURP&CE&KF

L\YaZR!+!JNUa[!,*+0

(2)

L\YaZR!+!JNUa[!,*+0

&

AHTFHQVWNQZE!AEQEK!<HJETE!

K[QN[T'K[QN[T! E\Z\^! /! JNUa[! +30*! `R[`N[T! GR^N`a^N[! ;N_N^! G\X\X']\X\X! 7T^N^VN! $KKG7%! `VQNX! ZR[TR[NY! V_`VYNU! #`N[NU! [RTN^N#(! KKG7!_RPN^N!`RTN_!ZR[TUN]a_!_RTNYN!]RZNX[NN[! ZR[TR[NV! ]R^[dN`NN[! XR]RZVYVXN[! `N[NU! \YRU! [RTN^N! QNYNZ! Q\X`^V[! UaXaZ! NT^N^VN! X\Y\[VNY&! FQOGKP!WGSMNCSKPI(!KKG7!ZRZ]R^XR[NYXN[!V_`VYNU! ON^a!OR^a]N!?NX!DR[TaN_NV!ERTN^N!$GN_NY!,%(!;V! QNYNZ!X\[_R]!`R^_ROa`&![RTN^N!QV]NUNZV!_RONTNV! \^TN[V_N_V! XRXaN_NN[! _RYa^aU! ^NXdN`! @[Q\[R_VN&! dN[T! ZR[a^a`! DNUXNZNU! B\[_`V`a_V&! ZRZVYVXV! XR c R [ N [ T N [ ! ] a O Y V X ! a [ ` a X ! Z R [ T R Y \ Y N ! "DGJGGSTFCCF#$!ZR^aZa_XN[! XROVWNXN[!"DGNGKF#$! ZR[TN`a^!"SGIGNGPFCCF#$!ZRYNXaXN[!]R[Ta^a_N[! "DGTUVVSFCCF#$! QN[! ZRYNXaXN[! ]R[TNcN_N[!

"UQG[KEJUJQVFGPFCCF#! UaOa[TN['UaOa[TN[!

UaXaZ! N[`N^N! \^N[T! QR[TN[! `N[NU(! @[V! a[`aX! ZR[RTN_XN[! ONUcN! UNX! ZR[TaN_NV! \YRU! [RTN^N! V`a!_RWN`V[dN!OaXN[YNU!UNX![NZa[!XRcR[N[TN[&!

+

HKK! GR^`N[NUN[ ! ZR[dN`NXN[! ONUcN! `N[NU! [RTN^N! ZR^a]NXN[! \OdRX! ]R[QNS`N^N[! `N[NU(!JN[NU![RTN^N!ZR^a]NXN[!`N[NU!dN[T!`VQNX! NQN!UNX!N`N_!`N[NU!N`Na]a[!UNX!aYNdN`!QV!N`N_[dN(! GR^N`a^N[!GRZR^V[`NU!$GG%!E\Z\^!,.!JNUa[!+331! `R[`N[T! GR[QNS`N^N[! JN[NU! ZR[dN`NXN[! ONUcN! ]R[QNS`N^N[!`N[NU![RTN^N!QVYNXaXN[!QR[TN[!PN^N! ZRZOaXaXN[! OVQN[T! `N[NU! QNYNZ! QNS`N^! `N[NU! `N[]N! QV`R^OV`XN[! _R^`V]VXN`! QVXN^R[NXN[! VN! OaXN[YNU! UNX! N`N_! `N[NU(! ;V! _V[V! `VQNX! NQN! ]R^_\NYN[! WVXN! dN[T! QVZNX_aQ! NQNYNU! `R^UNQN]! `N[NU! [RTN^N! fON^ag! dN[T! `R^OR[`aX! XN^R[N! K[QN[T'K[QN[T&! ]R[R`N]N[&! ]R^OaN`N[! UaXaZ&! N`Na!]RYR]N_N[!QN^V!`N[NU!UNX!$_R]R^`V!`N[NU!UNX! X\[bR^_V!QN^V!UNX!ON^N`&!`N[NU!]N^`VXRYV^&!QN[!`N[NU! dN[T! QVYR]N_XN[! ZR[WNQV! `N[NU! [RTN^N%(! 7XN[! `R`N]V!ZR[WNQV!`VQNX!ZaQNU!WVXN!]R[QNS`N^N[[dN! QVYNXaXN[!`R^UNQN]!XYNVZ!`N[NU!fdN[T!_RWNX!ZaYNg! ZR^a]NXN[! `N[NU! [RTN^N&! dN[T! _RWNX! OR^QV^V[dN! [RTN^N! @[Q\[R_VN! `N[NU'`N[NU! `R^_ROa`! `VQNX! QVYRXN`V!_aN`a!UNX!N]N]a[(!

GR[QNS`N^N[!`N[NU!\YRU!8NQN[!GR^`N[NUN[! EN_V\[NY!ZRYNYaV!]^\T^NZ!@[bR[`N^V_N_V!GRZVYVXN[&! GR[TaN_NN[&! GRZN[SNN`N[! QN[! GR[TTa[NN[! JN[NU! [email protected]%! _RPN^N! ^a`V[! `VN]! `NUa[)QR_N! QVYNXaXN[! QR[TN[! PN^N! ZRYNXaXN[! ]R[QNS`N^N[! `N[NU!N`N_!`N[NU'`N[NU!UNX!`R^YROVU!QNUaYa(!IV_N! QN^V! `N[NU! UNX! _R^`N! `N[NU! aYNdN`! V`aYNU! dN[T! XRZaQVN[!QV[dN`NXN[!_RONTNV!#`N[NU![RTN^N#(!

BR]N_`VN[! XROR^NQNN[! `N[NU! [RTN^N! `R^YR`NX! ]NQN! XR]N_`VN[! `N[NU! UNX! QN[! `N[NU! aYNdN`(! IR]N[WN[T! `N[NU! UNX! QN[! `N[NU! aYNdN`! ORYaZ! QVNXaV! _RPN^N! XR_RYa^aUN[! ZNXN! ORYaZ! QN]N`YNU! QVXN`NXN[! `RYNU! NQN! `N[NU! [RTN^N(! ENZa[&! XR[dN`NN[[dN! `VQNX! QRZVXVN[(! 8N[dNX! cN^TN! [RTN^N! QN[! ZN_dN^NXN`! UaXaZ! NQN`! dN[T! QVN[TTN]!`VQNX!QN]N`!ZR[a[WaXXN[!OaX`V!NYN_!UNX! N`N_! `N[NU! _RYNV[! OaX`V! ]R[TaN_NN[! SV_VX[dN&! XROR^NQNN[! UNX! QN[! UNX! aYNdN`[dN! `R^N[PNZ! _RcNX`a'cNX`a!QVZN_aXXN[!QNYNZ!XN`RT\^V!`N[NU! [RTN^N!$DGEQOG!TUCUG!NCPF!DZ!FGHCVNU%(!

;NYNZ! ] RYNX_ N[NN[ ! @G.J&! \`\^V`N_! ]R^`N[NUN[! PR[QR^a[T! a[`aX! ZR[dROa`! `N[NU' `N[NU! dN[T!`VQNX!NQN!NYN_!UNX[dN! _RONTNV! `N[NU! NQN`(! BR`VXN! NXN[! QVS\^ZNYV_N_V&! ZN_dN^NXN`! QVZV[`N! ZRYR]N_XN[! UNX[dN! _RUV[TTN! `N[NU! ZR[WNQV! `N[NU! [RTN^N! QVZN[N! XRZaQVN[! QVYNXaXN[! ]RZOR^VN[! UNX! N`N_! `N[NU(! GNQN! _NN`! V`aYNU!`R^WNQV!]R[RTN^NN[!`N[NU!$UNX!QN[!aYNdN`%(! GRZ\U\[! XRZaQVN[! cNWVO! ZRZONdN^! 8RN! GR^\YRUN[!?NX!N`N_!JN[NU!QN[!8N[Ta[N[!$8G?J8%(!

(3)

AVXN!XV`N!ZR[TNPa!]NQN!K[QN[T'K[QN[T! $ KK %! E \Z \^ ! ,1! JN Ua[ ! , **1! `R [`N [T ! GR[TRY\YNN[! MVYNdNU! GR_V_V^! QN[! GaYNa']aYNa! BRPVY!Wa[P`\!KK!E\Z\^!+!JNUa[!,*+.&!ZRZN[T! `VQNX!NQN!XRWRYN_N[!_`N`a_!`N[NU!]R_V_V^(!BRQaN! KK! V[V! _NZN! QNYNZ! ZR[QRSV[V_VXN[! cVYNdNU! ]R_V_V^&! hMVYNdNU! GR_V_V^! NQNYNU! QNR^NU! ]R^NYVUN[!N[`N^N!RX\_V_`RZ!QN^N`!QN[!YNa`!dN[T! QV]R[TN^aUV!\YRU!]R^aONUN[!QV!QN^N`!QN[!YNa`i(! ;V! QNYNZ[dN! `VQNX! QV_ROa`XN[! YaN_N[! ON`N_! cVYNdNU! ]R_V_V^! ZR[TV[TN`! _VSN`[dN! dN[T! ZR[TNYNZV!]R^aONUN[!_RPN^N!#NYNZVNU#!_R]R^`V! `R^WNQV[dN! `N[NU! `VZOaY&! NO^N_V&! `_a[NZV5! ZNa]a[! NXVON`!`V[QNXN[!ZN[a_VN(! GR^aONUN[' ]R^aONUN[! V`a! OR^]R[TN^aU! ]NQN! _`N`a_! ]R[TaN_NN[']RZVYVXN[!N`N_!cVYNdNU!]R_V_V^(!KK! E\Z\^!+!JNUa[!,*+.!`VQNX!ZR[a[WaXXN[!_`N`a_! QN[! WR[V_! UNX! N`N_! cVYNdNU! ]R_V_V^&! [NZa[! ZRZOaN`! XN`RT\^V_N_V! OR[`aX! QN[! Sa[T_V[dN4! RX\_V_`RZ&! OV\RX\^RTV\[5! XNcN_N[&! QN[! e\[N(! KK! V[V! ZRZOR^V! ]R[RXN[N[! ]NQN! cVYNdNU! ]R^NV^N[[dN! QN^V]NQN! cVYNdNU! QN^N`N[[dN(! I`N`a_!cVYNdNU!QN^N`N[!]R_V_V^!`VQNX!WRYN_(!?NY!V[V! dN[T!_RZR_`V[dN!QVN`a^!QNYNZ!HKK!GR^`N[NUN[(!

BR`VQNXWRYN_N[! ]R[TaN_NN[! `N[NU! QV! cVYNdNU! ]R_V_V^! ZRZVPa! X\[SYVX(! INYNU! _N`a[dN! NQNYNU! dN[T! `R^WNQV! QV! K^a`_Rca&! BROaZR[&! ANcN! JR[TNU(! JE@! 7[TXN`N[! ;N^N`! ZR[TaN_NV!

`N[NU! ]R_V_V^! ZaYNV! QN^V! /**! ZR`R^! QN^V! OVOV^! ]N[`NV! `N[]N! NYN_! UNX(! JN[NU! V`a! QVTa[NXN[! _RONTNV!`RZ]N`!YN`VUN[!QN[!]R[TaWVN[!_R[WN`N(! F ` \ ^ V ` N _ ! ] R ^ ` N [ N U N [ ! O R Y a Z ! ] R ^ [ N U ! ZR[TRYaN^XN[!UNX!N`N_!`N[NU!`R^UNQN]!V[_`V`a_V! JE@!7;(!IRZR[`N^N!ZN_dN^NXN`!`RYNU!ZR[TaN_NV! QN[! ZRZN[SNN`XN[[dN! OR^]aYaU']aYaU! `NUa[! _RORYaZ[dN(!8NUXN[!OVQN[T!`N[NU!]R_V_V^!dN[T! ON`N_! TN^V_[dN! YN[T_a[T!QR[TN[! YNa`&! `R^QN]N`! _R^`V]VXN`! UNX! ZVYVX! $`NUa[! +303%! QR[TN[! XR`R^N[TN[! OR^N_NY! QN^V! UCPCJ! ZCTCP! $Ca`USV! QNYNZ!9NUdN`V!,*+.%(!

JN[NU!dN[T!WaTN!NPN]!WNQV!\OdRX!_R[TXR`N! NQNYNU!`N[NU!`VZOaY!QN[!`N[NU!^RXYNZN_V(!JN[NU! `VZOaY!QN[!`N[NU!^RXYNZN_V!`VQNX!QVN`a^!QNYNZ! KKG7(!!ENZa[!Ia^N`!<QN^N[!BR]NYN!8GE!E\Z\^! .+*)+,3-! JNUa[! +330! `R[`N[T! GR[R^`VON[! I`N`a_! JN[NU! JVZOaY! QN[! JN[NU! HRXYNZN_V! ZR[dN`NXN[! ONUcN! XRQaN[dN! QV[dN`NXN[! _RONTNV! `N[NU! [RTN^N(! ;NYNZ!XN_a_!QV! 9VYNPN]&! ZN_dN^NXN`! _R`RZ]N`! dN[T! _RZaYN! ZR[WNQV! [RYNdN[! QN[! ZN_dN^NXN`! ]R[QN`N[T! ZRZOaXN! `N[NU! ]R^`N[VN[! QN[! ]R^XNZ]a[TN[! QV! N`N_! `N[NU! `VZOaY! QV! Ea_NXNZON[TN[(! CRZONTN! GR^ZN_dN^NXN`N[!Ea_N!BNZON[TN[!ZRYNXaXN[! V[`VZVQN_V!QN[!]R[Ta_V^N[!`R^UNQN]!ZN_dN^NXN`! ZR[TTa[NXN[! XYNVZ! `N[NU! [RTN^N! $BUa^VdN`V! ,**3%(!

8RQIOLN!GL!CLOEZEK!>HULULT#!

AEQEK!ALPFWO!GEQ!AEQEK!?HNOEPEUL

GR[RTN^NN[! `N[NU! V[V! WaTN! ZR[a[WaXXN[! ]^NX`VX&! V[_`V`a_V&! QN[! UaXaZ! dN[T! ZR[TUN]a_! UNX'UNX!_R^`N!XYNVZ!^NXdN`!N`N_!`N[NU(!GR[RTN^NN[! `N[NU!V[V!ZR[WNQV!PN^N!RSRX`VS!ONTV!]RZOR[`aXN[! cVYNdNU! `R^QR]N[! ON^a! $PGX! HSQPUKGST%! ONTV! XROa`aUN[!`N[NU!_XNYN!OR_N^!XN]V`NYV_`VX!$BRYYd!QN[! GRYa_\!,*+/4!,1-%(!BYNVZ!`N[NU![RTN^N!NXN[![NVX!QV! `R[TNU! ]^\_R_! ]RZON[Ta[N[! V[S^N_`^aX`a^! QN[! ]RZOaXNN[! X\[_R_V(! IRYNV[! V`a&! ]RZOR[`aXN[!

XNcN_N[! Ua`N[! dN[T! QV_NYNUN^`VXN[! UN[dN! ZR^a ]N XN[! Ua `N[ ! [ RTN^N! ZR Z] R^ `RTN_! ]R[RTN^NN[! `N[NU! V[V(! INYNU! XN]^NU! `R^UNQN]! XNcN_N[! Ua`N[! V`a! ZR[dRONOXN[! _`N`a_! `N[NU! [RTN^N&! `N[NU! UNX! QN[! `N[NU! aYNdN`! QV! QNYNZ! XNcN_N[!Ua`N[!`VQNX!WRYN_(

(4)

>=971D!

8H@<=

(

7 Q U V L V W V H

L\YaZR!+!JNUa[!,*+0

JN[NU! [RTN^N! ORXN_! UNX! `R^[dN`N! WaTN! `VQNX! ZaQNU! XRZONYV! XR]NQN! XRcR[N[TN[! [RTN^N(! IRYNZN! V[V! `R^QN]N`! XROVWNXN[! Z R [Ta `N Z N XN [! ]V UN X! ` R^ ` R[` a ! Q NY N Z ! ZRZOR^VXN[!?NX!>a[N!K_NUN!dN[T!QVQN_N^XN[! ]NQN! `NS_V^! ZR[TR[NV! #UNX! ]^V\^V`N_#(! ;R[TN[! V_`VYNU!V`a&!8GE!ZRZ]^V\^V`N_XN[!]RZRTN[T!UNX! dN[T! NQN! $GYKTUKPI%&! dNX[V! ]R^a_NUNN[&! ZRZ]R^]N[WN[T! QN[! ZRZ]R^ON^aV! UNX! `R^_ROa`(!GR^a_NUNN[!_RONTNV!_aOdRX!UNX!dN[T! `RYNU! OR^V[bR_`N_V! QV! N`N_! `N[NU! ?>K! `R^_ROa`! YROVU! QV]^V\^V`N_XN[! QN^V]NQN! $PNY\[%!

_aOdRX! UNX! dN[T! YNV[&! ZR_XV]a[! XROR^NQNN[! `N[NU! `R^_ROa`! QV`RYN[`N^XN[! N`Na! `RYNU! QV^RXYNVZ! QN[! ZR[WNQV! _ a Z O R ^ ! X \ [ S Y V X ! Q V ! Z N _ d N ^ N X N ` ( ! 8 G E ! Z R[TN[TTN]! ONUcN! `N[NU! `R^_ROa`! _aYV`! QVYR]N_XN[!_RONO!ZN_VU! ZRYRXN`! UNX! ]^V\^V`N_! O N T V ! ] R Z R T N [ T [d N ! _RZaYN(!

B R ` R [ ` a N [ ! d N [ T ! _RYNZN! V[V! QV^aWaX! a[`aX! ZR[WRYN_XN[! NQN[dN! `NS_V^! ZR[TR[NV! UNX! ]^V\^V`N_! NQNYNU! GG! E\Z\^!.*!JNUa[!+330!`R[`N[T!?NX!>a[N!

K_NUN&!?NX!>a[N!8N[Ta[N[!QN[!?NX!GNXNV!N`N_! JN [ N U & ! d N [ T ! Q V ! Q N Y N Z [d N ! Z R [ T N ` a ^ ! #]R^]N[WN[TN[! QN[! ]RZONUN^aN[#! UNX(! @[VYNU! dN[T!ZRYNUV^XN[!`NS_V^!ZR[TR[NV!UNX!]^V\^V`N_(!

G R ^ N ` a ^ N [ ! _ R O R Y a Z [ d N ! W a _ ` ^ a ! ZR[V`VXOR^N`XN[! ]NQN! #]^V\^V`N_! ONTV! ^NXdN`#(! GN_NY!.!BR]a`a_N[!G^R_VQR[!$BR]]^R_%!E\Z\^!-,! JNUa[! +313! ZR[dN`NXN[! ONUcN! hJN[NU'`N[NU! ?NX! >a[N! K_NUN! N_NY! X\[bR^_V! UNX! 8N^N`! dN[T! _aQNU! QVQaQaXV! \YRU! ^NXdN`! QN[! QV`V[WNa! QN^V! _aQa`! `N`N! Ta[N! `N[NU! QN[! XR_RYNZN`N[! YV[TXa[TN[! UVQa]! YROVU! `R]N`! QV]R^a[`aXXN[! a[`aX! ]RZaXVZN[! N`Na! XRTVN`N[! a_NUN! ]R^`N[VN[&! NXN[! QVOR^VXN[! UNX! ON^a! XR]NQN! ^NXdN`!dN[T!ZR[QaQaXV[dNi(!!

GG! E\Z\^! .*! JNUa[! +330! QN[! `NS_V^! ZR[TR[NV! UNX! ]^V\^V`N_! $]R^]N[WN[TN[!UNX%!`R^UNQN]! ]R^a_NUNN[! ?>K! `R^_ROa`! Q V ] ^ N X ` V X X N [ ! U N Z ] V ^ ! _R^a]N! QR[TN[!GSHRCEJU!

]NQN! ZN_N! X\Y\[VNY(! D\[\]\YV!`N[NU![RTN^N! O R X N _ ! U N X ! XR ] N Q N ! ]R^a_NUNN[! ZRYNYaV! ]RZNUNZN[! `R[`N[T! #UNX! ]^V\^V`N_#! ]^NX`V_! `VQNX! ZRZOaN`! OR^N^`V! YNTV! ]R^aONUN[! WN[TXN! c N X ` a ! U N X & ! X N ^ R [ N ! ] R ^ a _ N U N N [ ! O R ^ ] R Y a N [ T ! ZRZVYVXV! ?>K! UNZ]V^! _Ra_VN!

(5)

Sa[T_V ]RYNdN[N[ ]aOYVX( HKK!GR^`N[NUN[!]R^Ya! ZR[TRTRZONYVXN[ ?GC XR]NQN cN`N`NX N_YV[dN _RONTNV! ##`N[NU! [RTN^N^N#! dN[T! QVXRY\YN! V[_`N[_V! ]RZR^V[`NU a[`aX ZR[WNYN[XN[ `aTN_[dN ZRYNdN[V!]aOYVX(

GR^R^_\NYN[! YNV[! QR[TN[! ?GC! NQNYNU! N]N! dN[T!QV_ROa`XN[!QNYNZ!XR`R[R[`aN[ GN_NY , NdN`!.! KKG7( ;V! _V`a! QV[dN`NXNXN[! ONUcN! ]RYNX_N[NN[ ?NX DR[TaN_NV ERTNTN^N^N QN]N` QVXaN_NXNXN[ XR]NQN! QNR^NU! QN[! ZN_dN^N^NXNXN`! UaXaZ! NQN`(! 8VYNZN[N!QN[!QNYNZ!UNY!N]N!ZN_dN^N^NXNXN`!UaXaZ! N Q N ` Q N ] N ` Z R [ R ^ V Z N ] R [ Q R Y R TN _ VN [ XRcR[N[TN[!ZR[TaN_NV!ERTN^N^N!V`a6!8NTNVZN[N! ZR[NS_V^XN[!XNV`N[!N[N[`N^N^N!GN_NY!, NdN`!$.%!KKG7! QR[TN[!GN_NY - dN[T!ZR[TNXNXaV!XROR^NQNN[!UNX! aYNdN`6!

K[QN[T'K[QN[T! E\Z\^! 0 JNUa[! ,*+.! `R[`N[T ;R_N ZR[[dROa`XNXN[ ONUcN `N[NU NQNYNU! _NYNU! _N_N`a! OR[`aX! N_R`! QR_N( 7]NXNU! OR[`aX! UNX! dN[T! `R]N`! ONTV QR_N! `R^UNQN]! `N[NU[dN!V`a!`VQNX!QVN`a^!QNYNZ!KK!;R_N6!HKK! G

GR^`N[NUN[ OR^]RYaN[T ZR[WNcNO UNY V[V QR[TN[!ZRZa[TXV[XN[[dN!?GC!ONTV QR_N( ?NX GR[TRY\YNN[ $?GC% ZR^a]NXN[

ONTVN[ QN^V UNX ZR[TaN_NV [RTN^N dN[T QVYNX_N[NXN[!\YRU!V[_`N[_V!]RZR^V[`NUN[&!HKK! GR^`N[NUN[! a_aYN[! ;G;! H@! ZR[dN`NXNXN[! h?NX! ]R[TRY\YNN[!NQNYNU!UNX!ZR[TaN_NV!QN^V [RTN^N^N! dN[T! XRcR[N[TN[! ]RYNX_N[NN[[dN! _RONTVN[! QVYVZ]NUXN[ XR]NQN ]RZRTN[T[dN QN[ QV]R^Ta[NXN[! aa[`aX! ]RYNdN[N[! aZaZ(i! ?NX! ]R[TRY\YNN[! NQNYNU! Sa[T_V ]RYNdN[N[']aOYVX! XR]NQN! ]VUNX! YNV[( GR^Ya! ]R[RTN_N[ fSa[T_Vg! ]RYNdN[N[ `R^R^_ROa`! _RONTNV! OR[`aX! QN^V! ?NX! DR[TaN_NV! \YRU! ERTN^N^N&! OaXN[! _RONTNV! fUNXg! QR[TN[!XRcR[N[TN[!XR]R^QNQN`NN[(

;NYNZ GR^N`a^N[ DR[`R^V ERTN^N 7T^N^VN)BR]NYN 8NQN[ GR^`N[NUN[ EN_V\[NY E\Z\^ 3 JNUa[ +333 `R[`N[T JN`N 9N^N^N GRZOR^VN[ QN[! GRZON`NYN[! ?NX! 7`N_! JN[NU! ERTN^N^N!QN[!?NX!GR[TRY\YNN[& ?GC!UN[dN!QN]N`! QVOR^VXN[! XR]NQN! $G$GN_NY 01! N[TXN! +%4! @[_`N[_V! G

GRZR^V[`NU `R^ZN_aX GGRZR^V[`NU ;NR^N^NU5 8NQN[!K_NUN!DVYVX!ERTN^N^N5!8NQN[!K_NUN!DVYVX! ;NR^NU5! GJ( GR^R^_R^\5! 8NQN[! FF`\^V`N5! 8NQN[' ONQN[!UaXaZ!GRZR^V[`NU!YNV[[dN!dN[T!QV`a[WaX! ]RZR^V[`NU(! ;NYNZ! ]RYNX_N[NN[[dN! ?GC! V[V ZR[TNTNYNZV ]R^TR_R^N^N[( MN`NX ]^VbN` QN[ ZR[PNPN^V ]^\SV` YROVU ZR[TRTRZaXN QN^V]NQN

6EN!>HQJHOROEEQ

;HPSHTMHOEU!"AEQEK!<HJETETE"E" 0HFHTESE!?HNHNRPHQGEUL! WQ

(6)

>=971D!

8H@<=

*

7 Q U V L V W V H

L\YaZR!+!JNUa[!,*+0

+( HKK!GR^`N[NUN[!]R^Ya!ZR[RTN_XN[!OR^NXUV^[dN!_R_N`!]VXV^!`R^UNQN]!`N[NU![RTN^N! dN[T! NPN]! QVN^`VXN[! _RONTNV! `N[NU! ZVYVX! [RTN^N(! JN[NU! [RTN^N! ZR^a]NXN[! \OWRX! ]RYNX_N[NN[! cRcR[N[T! [RTN^N! OaXN[! UNX![RTN^N!ZRZVYVXV! `N[NU(! FYRU! XN^R[N!V`a! ]R^Ya! QVaONU! ]R[dROa`N[! `N[NU! [RTN^N! ZR[WNQV! `N[NU! OR^_NZN! ON[T_N! $`N[NU! ON[T_N%!dN[T!ORYaZ!NQN!UNX!N`Na!`VQNX!`R^ZN_aX!`N[NU!aYNdN`(!

,( GR[QNS`N^N[!`N[NU!UN^a_!QVYNXaXN[!_RPN^N!NX`VS&!^a`V[!QN[!`R^R[PN[N!ZR[dV_V^!QR_N! QRZV!QR_N&!_RUV[TTN!QV]R^\YRU!XRWRYN_N[!UNX'UNX!N`N_!`N[NU!dN[T!NQN!QV!ZN_dN^NXN`(! GR[QNS`N^N[!`N[NU!$XaN_N%![RTN^N!WaTN!]R^Ya!QVYNXaXN[!_RPN^N!NX`VS!QV_R^`NV!`V[QNXN[! UaXaZ!dN[T!ZR[dN`NXN[!fQVXaN_NV!YN[T_a[T!\YRU![RTN^Ng!`R^_ROa`(!FYRU!XN^R[N!V`a! ]R[QNS`N^N[! `N[NU! UNX! QR[TN[! ]R[QNS`N^N[! `N[NU! [RTN^N! UN^a_! OR^WNYN[! _RPN^N! OR^_NZNN[(!@[V!QVUN^N]XN[!QN]N`!ZR[TUV[QN^V!`V[QNXN[!XYNVZ!_R]VUNX!]R[TaN_NN[! `N[NU!QN[!`V[QNXN[!]R[RTN^NN[!`N[NU!^NXdN`(

-( HKK!GR^`N[NUN[!UR[QNX[dN!ZRZOR^VXN[!UNX!]^V\^V`N_!XR]NQN!ZN_dN^NXN`!dN[T!`RYNU! ZR[TaN_NV! `N[NU! [RTN^N! YROVU! QN^V! ,*! `NUa[! a[`aX! QN]N`! QVNWaXN[! UNX! ZVYVX! ]R^\^N[TN[! N`Na!OR^_NZN(!GR[TaN_NN[! SV_VX!_RZR_`V[dN! `RYNU!PaXa]!ZR[WNQV!OaX`V! NYN_! UNX! QN[! NYN_! UNX! `R^`aYV_! NQNYNU! OR^_VSN`! ZRYR[TXN]V(! HKK! GR^`N[NUN[! ]R^Ya! ZR[T\^RX_V! GG! E\Z\^! .*! JNUa[! +330! QN[! `NS_V^! ZR[TR[NV! UNX! ]^V\^V`N_! dN[T! ZR[dN[QR^N!XRcR[N[TN[![RTN^N!ZR[TaN_NV!XRZONYV!`N[NU!ON[T_N(!

.( HKK! GR^`N[NUN[! ]R^Ya! ZRZ]R^`RTN_! _`N`a_! `N[NU! ]R_V_V^! N]NXNU! _RONTNV! `N[NU! [RTN^N!N`Na!QN]N`!ZR[WNQV!`N[NU!UNX!QN[!`N[NU!aYNdN`(!

/( DR[TV[TN`! `N[NU! [RTN^N! NQNYNU! `N[NU! OR^_NZN! ON[T_N! @[Q\[R_VN&! ZNXN! HKK! GR^`N[NUN[! ]R^Ya! ZR[RTN_XN[! ONUcN! _RTNYN! ]R[TaN_NN[! `N[NU! `R^_ROa`! `N[]N! QVYN[QN_V!UNX!N`N_!`N[NU!dN[T!WRYN_!ZNXN!QN]N`!QVN[TTN]!_RONTNV!]RYN[TTN^N[!UaXaZ(! GRYN[TTN^N[!V[V!_R^V[T!`R^WNQV!a`NZN[dN!\YRU!V[_`N[_V!]RZR^V[`NU!dN[T!ZR[TN[TTN]! _RONTNV!^R]^R_R[`N_V![RTN^N(!

0( DR[TaONU!?NX!GR[TRY\YNN[!$?GC%!ZR[WNQV!BRcR[N[TN[!GR[TRY\YNN[!dN[T!QV!N`N_[dN! OV_N! QV`R^OV`XN[! UNX! $OR^WN[TXN%&! QN[! ZRZ]R^`RTN_! ONUcN! GR[TRY\YNN[! `R^_ROa`! NQNYNU!caWaQ!QN^V!UNX!ZR[TaN_NV![RTN^N!QR[TN[!Sa[T_V!]RZON[`aN[(!

1( HKK!GR^`N[NUN[!]R^Ya!ZR[dROa`!ZN_dN^NXN`!UaXaZ!NQN`!N`Na!QR_N!_RONTNV!]VUNX! dN[T!QN]N`!ZRZ]R^\YRU!XRcR[N[TN[!]R[TRY\YNN[&!_RXNYVTa_!_RONTNV!_aOdRX!UaXaZ! dN[T!QN]N`!ZR[R^VZN!UNX!N`N_!`N[NU!QV!N`N_!Sa[T_V!]R[TRY\YNN[!`R^_ROa`(

2( HKK! GR^`N[NUN[! _RXNYVTa_! ZR[WNQV! XR_RZ]N`N[! a[`aX! ZR[TNXUV^V! QaNYV_ZR! NQZV[V_`^N_V! ]R^`N[NUN[! dN[T!_RYNZN! V[V! `R^WNQV!QV!XNcN_N[!Ua`N[! QN[! [\['Ua`N[(! BNcN_N[!Ua`N[!`VQNX!QR[TN[!_R[QV^V[dN!NQNYNU!Ua`N[![RTN^N(!;R[TN[!QRZVXVN[!]R^Ya! ]R[QNS`N^N[!`N[NU!QV!QNYNZ!XNcN_N[!Ua`N[!_RUV[TTN!QV]R^\YRU!XRWRYN_N[!XROR^NQNN[! N[`N^N!`N[NU![RTN^N&!`N[NU!UNX&!QN[!`N[NU!aYNdN`(!

?38=;3<2/@7

;HPSHTMHOEU!"AEQEK!<HJETE 0HFHTESE!?HNRPHQGEUL!

(7)

;HPSHTMHOEU!"AEQEK!<HJETETE"E" 0HFHTESE!?HNHNRPHQGEUL! WQ

WQVWN!?BB!>HTVEQEKEQ

BRYYd&!7YVPR!8!"!EN[Pd!CRR!GRYa_\!$,*+/%!5SQPUKGST!QH! 2QOOQFKHKECUKQP- @UCUCUGUG ;CPFT CPF AJGKS 5QSOCNK[CUKQP&! I\PVR`d! "! ENEN`a^NY! HR_\a^PR_&! ,24/(

BUa^VdN`V& IV`V =VX^VdNU $,**3% 1CDCF ACPCJ 6CSCRCP-! 1CDCM%DCDCM! >GPIVCTCCP! ACPCJ! AKODVN!=VTC!9CODCPICP&!@[_V_`!G^G^R__(!

Ca`USV& 7UZNQ EN_UVU& $,*+.% \ACPCJ >GTKTKS BSVUTGXV-!ACPCJ!<KNKM$!ACPCJ!3GTC$!CUCUCVMCJ! ACPCJ! =GICSC.]&! QNYNZ! ;R;Rbd! ;9&! B\[\[SYVX! 7T^N^VN! QV! K^a`_Rca4! GR[QRXN`N[! <X<X\Y\TV! G\YV`VX&!IJGE!G^G^R__(

HNPUZN[&! E\R^! =NaeV! $,*+,%&!<GSCNCU! =GICSCKTCTK! ACPCJ!0FCU&!<GORGSDCKMK!?VUG!ASCPTHQSOCTK! 9GXCSICPGICSCCP <CTZTZCSCMCU 0FCU FCP <GPIVMVJMCP 9GODCNK 4MTMTKTUGPTK =GICSC

1CPITC( EN_XNU BR`R^N[TN[ 7UYV dN[T

QV_NZ]NVXN[! XR]NQN! DNUXNZNU! B\[_`V`a_V! QNYNZ! _VQN[T! TaTN`N[! AaQVPVNY! HRbVRc! dN[T! QVNWaXN[! 7YVN[_V! DN_dN^N^NXNXN`! 7QN`! Ea_N[`N^N^N! $7D7E%!N`N_!K[QN[T'a[QN[T!E\(!.+!`RR[`N[T! BRUa`N[N[&!`N[TTNY!/ Aa[V!,*+,(

2E

(8)

>=971D!

8H@<=

L\YaZR!+!JNUa[!,*+0

,

7 Q U V L V W V H

3SLUVHPE!7QUVLVWVH!ZR[Q\^\[T!a[`aX!`R^caWaQ[dN!]a_N`']a_N`! ]RZORYNWN^N[!`R[`N[T!UaXaZ&!ZN_dN^NXN`!QN[!YV[TXa[TN[! QNYNZ!^N[TXN!ZR[QaXa[T!TR^NXN[!XR!N^NU!`R^OR[`aX[dN!_V_`RZ! UaXaZ![N_V\[NY!dN[T!OR^YN[QN_XN[![VYNV'[VYNV!QRZ\X^N_V&! XRNQVYN[!_\_VNY!QN[!YV[TXa[TN[&!_R^`N!]Ya^NYV_ZR!XROaQNdNN[(

;HPSHTMHOEU!"AEQEK!<HJETE 0HFHTESE!?HNRPHQGEUL!

WQVWN!?BB!>HTVEQEKEQ

>HQWOLU-

4RVR!GEQ!2RNWPHQVEUL-;VNVM!BNKZCJ$!9QNGMTK!4RKTUGOC

AEVE!9HVEN-4NPKPQ

0JOCF!=CTJKJ!;VUJHK

>QNKEZ!1SKGH!KPK!FKUGSDKUMCP!QNGJ

CUCT!FVMVPICP!FCSK!

ANYN[!AN`V!GNQN[T!HNdN!E\(!,/&!ANXN^`N!+,/.*(! JRYR]\[4!*,+'122-,+01! =NX_VZVYR4!*,+'122-*/**! <'ZNVY4!GRKTUGOC/GRKTUGOC&QS&KF!

Referensi

Dokumen terkait

Sebagaimana kita ketahui bahwa Putusan MK 35/2012 tidak memindahkan hutan (wilayah) adat dari dalam kawasan hutan keluar kawasan hutan. Ini artinya bahwa di dalam kawasan hutan itu

Para pihak mengakui bahwa adaptasi adalah tantangan global yang dihadapi oleh semua pihak dalam level lokal, sub-nasional, nasional, regional, dan dimensi internasional, dan hal

Dilihat dari sisi materi muatan atau isi produk hukum daerah, secara umum dapat diklasifikasikan menjadi lima, yaitu: (1) kelembagaan adat, peradilan adat dan hukum adat; (2)

Proses Inventarisasi Penguasaan, Penggunaan, Pemilikan dan Pemanfaatan (IP4T) di dalam kawasan hutan merupakan satu proses yang lahir dari terbitnya Peraturan Bersama

Can the Joint Regulation of the Minister of Home Affairs, Minister of Forestry, Minister of Public Works and the Head of the National Land Agency on Procedures for Land

Dengan demikian maka penguasaan tanah dalam kawasan hutan dapat terdiri dari penguasaan oleh negara, masyarakat hukum adat dan orang perorangan atau badan hukum.. Karena itu, PP

P.62/ Menhut-II/2013 agar memuat penyelarasan konsep hutan hak baik sebagai hutan hak perorangan, badan hukum atau hutan adat sebagai bagian kawasan hutan; pengaturan mengenai

This policy brief from RECOFTC - The Center for People and Forests discusses ways for governments to support community forestry, based on the understanding that it can