5,$3'$1'8*$$192/80(7(*$.$1$03838
(XFDO\SWXVXURSK\OOD
67%ODNH',.$:$6$1+87$1
:2/2/2%2%$-$:$)/25(6
7KH,QFUHPHQWDQG9ROXPH(VWPDWLRQRI(XFDOLSW6WDQG
DW:RORORER)RUHVW$UHD%DMDZD)ORUHV
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
\HDU IRUWUHHKHLJKWLQFUHPHQWDQGP KHFWDUH \HDU IRUYROXPHLQFUHPHQW7KHIRUPIDFWRURIVWHPIZDV
7KHYROXPHHVWLPDWLRQPRGHORQFURZQEDVHKHLJKWZDV ZLWKVWDQGDUGHUURU VTXDUH
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
QJHQDLKXWDQWDQDPDQ\DQJWHUVHGLDDGDODKLQIRU PDVL\DQJEHUVLIDWNXDOLWDWLIVHGDQJNDQGDWDNX DQWLWDWLIQ\D EHOXP EDQ\DN GLNHWDKXL SDGDKDO LQIRUPDVL \DQJ EHUVLIDW NXDQWLWDWLI VHSHUWL GDWD SHUWXPEXKDQGDQSRWHQVLWHJDNDQVDQJDWGLSHUOX NDQ%HUGDVDUNDQLQIRUPDVLSHUWXPEXKDQGDSDW GLNHWDKXL PHQJHQDL GDXU SROD WDQDP SRWHQVL NXELNDVLWHJDNDQSHQJDWXUDQKDVLOGDQODLQODLQ
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± VH KLQJJD PHQ\HEDENDQ ELDV GXJDDQ FXNXS WLQJJL RYHUHVWLPDWHDQWDUD±6LVZDQWR 6X\DW 6HKXEXQJDQGHQJDQLWXFDUDSHQDNVLUDQ YROXPH SRKRQ VHFDUD VHUDJDP GHQJDQ PHQJ JXQDNDQSHUDQJNDWSHQGXJDYROXPHSRKRQ\DQJ PHQJJXQDNDQVDWXPDFDPDQJNDEHQWXNEDWDQJ VHEDLNQ\DGLKLQGDUNDQNDUHQDKDOWHUVHEXWPHUX SDNDQVXPEHUNHVDODKDQKDVLOWDNVLUDQ
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
6HKXEXQJDQ GHQJDQ LWX LQIRUPDVL GDQ KDVLO SHQHOLWLDQ LQL GLVXVXQ GDODP UDQJND PHQJDQWL VLSDVLSHUPDVDODKDQWHUVHEXWGLDWDV8QWXNLWX SHQHOLWLDQ LQL EHUWXMXDQ XQWXN PHPSHUROHK SH UDQJNDW SHUWXPEXKDQ \DQJ GLSHUOXNDQ ULDS GDQ PRGHOSHQGXJDDQYROXPHSRKRQEHUGLULDPSXSX VDPSDLWLQJJLSRKRQSDQJNDOWDMXNGDQLQIRUPDVL ULDS WHJDNDQ DPSXSX GL .DZDVDQ +XWDQ:ROR ORER%DMDZD)ORUHV ,,0(72'2/2*, $/RNDVLGDQ:DNWX3HQHOLWLDQ
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
&0HWRGH3HQHOLWLDQ
3HQJDPDWDQULDSWHJDNDQDPSXSX
3HQJDPDWDQ 5LDS WHJDNDQ DPSXSX GLDZDOL GHQJDQSHPEXDWDQSHWDNXNXUSHUPDQHQ383 SORWGLDPELOVHFDUDSXUSRVLYHVDPSOLQJ7DWDFDUD SHPEXDWDQQ\DPHQJDFXSDGDWDWDFDUDSHPLOLKDQ GDQSHPEXDWDQ383XQWXNKXWDQWDQDPDQ+DU EDJXQJ :DK\RQR3URVHGXUSHPEXDWDQ 383GLODNXNDQGHQJDQXUXWDQVHEDJDLEHULNXW D 3HPEHUVLKDQSHPEDEDGDQWXPEXKDQEDZDK GLDUHDO383
E 383 GLEXDW GDODP EHQWXN EXMXU VDQJNDU GH QJDQXNXUDQMDUDNGDWDU[P
F 'LWHQJDK383GLEXDWSHWDNSHQJDPDWDQEHU XNXUDQ [ P GDQ WHUEDJL ODJL PHQMDGL SORWSORWXNXUDQ[PEHUMXPODKSORW *DPEDU
G 6HPXD SRKRQ \DQJ EHUDGD GLGDODP SORW
GLSROHWGLWDQGDLGDQGLEHULQRPRU3HQRPRU DQ GLODNXNDQ VHFDUD EHUXUXWDQ GLPXODL GDUL SRKRQSRKRQ \DQJ WHUOHWDN SDGD SORW NH NHPXGLDQGLDNKLULSDGDSORWNH H 3DUDPHWHU\DQJGLXNXUDGDODKGLDPHWHUSRKRQ VHWLQJJLGDGDPGDQWLQJJLSRKRQWRWDO SDGDVHWLDSLQGLYLGXSRKRQGLGDODPSORWSDGD 383
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
+DVLO SHQJXNXUDQ SDUDPHWHU SRKRQSRKRQ FRQWRK LQL VHEDJLDQ GLJXQDNDQ XQWXN SHQ\XVX QDQPRGHOSHQGXJDDQYROXPHSRKRQGDQVHEDJL DQ ODJL XQWXN XML YDOLGDVL PRGHO 6HEDUDQ NHODV GLDPHWHU GDQ MXPODK LQGLYLGX SRKRQ XQWXN SH Q\XVXQDQ PRGHO GDQ XML YDOLGDVL PRGHO GLVDML NDQSDGD7DEHO'DWDSDUDPHWHUVDWXLQGLYLGX SRKRQFRQWRKGLEXDQJSHQFLODQNDUHQDXNXUDQ GLDPHWHUEDWDQJGEK!FP '$QDOLVLV'DWD 5LDSWHJDNDQ 5LDS WHJDNDQ DPSXSX GLKLWXQJ EHUGDVDUNDQ LQIRUPDVL ULDS UDWDUDWD WDKXQDQPHDQ $QQXDO ,QFUHPHQW±0$,GDQULDSWDKXQEHUMDODQFXU UHQWDQQXDOLQFUHPHQW±&$,\DQJGDSDWGLQR WDVLNDQVHEDJDLEHULNXW
< W
0$,
W
.HWHUDQJDQ5HPDUNV<W GLDPHWHUFPDWDXWLQJJLSR KRQPSDGDXPXUNHW W XPXUWDKXQ
7DEHO7DEOH 6HEDUDQ GLDPHWHU SRKRQ FRQWRK XQWXN SHQ\XVXQDQ PRGHO GDQ YDOLGDVL PRGHO 'LVWULEXWLRQRIVDPSOHWUHHGLDPHWHUIRUPRGHOSUHSDUDWLRQDQGYDOLGDWLRQ .HODVGLDPHWHU &ODVVHVRIGLDPHWHU FP -XPODKSRKRQ1XPEHURIWUHH 3HQ\XVXQDQPRGHO 0RGHOSUHSDUDWLRQ 9DOLGDVLPRGHO 0RGHOYDOLGDWLRQ ± ± ± ± ± -XPODK 6XPEHU6RXUFH'LRODKGDULGDWDODSDQJ&RPSLOHGDQGDQDO\]HGIURPILHOGGDWD 6XPEHU6RXUFH6XVLOD
< <W W &$, 7
.HWHUDQJDQ5HPDUNV < GLDPHWHU FP DWDX WLQJJL W SRKRQPVDDWSHQJDPDWDQ < GLDPHWHU FP DWDX WLQJJLW SRKRQPVHEHOXPQ\D 7 MDUDN ZDNWX SHQJXNXUDQ EXODQ 3HQGXJDDQYROXPHSRKRQ
9ROXPH SRKRQ PHUXSDNDQ MXPODK YROXPH VHWLDS VHNVL GDUL SRKRQ \DQJ EHUVDQJNXWDQ 9ROXPH VHWLDS VHNVL GLKLWXQJ GHQJDQ UXPXV 6PDOOLDQ3URGDQ %E 9V [/ .HWHUDQJDQ5HPDUNV9V YROXPHVHNVLEDWDQJ
% OXDV ELGDQJ GDVDU SDQJNDO VHNVL
E OXDV ELGDQJ GDVDU XMXQJ VHNVLGDQ
/ SDQMDQJVHNVL
$QJND EHQWXN EDWDQJ I GLKLWXQJ VHEDJDL SHUEDQGLQJDQDQWDUDLVLND\XPHODOXLSHUKLWXQJDQ YROXPHSHUVHNVLGHQJDQLVLVLOLQGHU\DQJPHP SXQ\DLGEKGDQWLQJJLSRKRQ\DQJVDPD3HQJ XMLDQKLSRWHVDDQJNDEHQWXNEDWDQJGHQJDQ GLODNXNDQ GHQJDQ XML W VHEDJDL EHULNXW ,ULDQWR
+ ) ODZDQ+ )
I)
7KLW GHUDMDWEHEDVQ 6I
.HWHUDQJDQ5HPDUNV) DQJND EHQWXN EDWDQJ KLSRWH WLN
I UDWDUDWD GDUL DQJND EHQWXN SRKRQ 6I NHVDODKDQEDNXDQJNDEHQWXN EDWDQJ 0RGHO SHQGXJDDQ YROXPH SRKRQ GLVXVXQ GHQJDQDQDOLVLVUHJUHVL+XEXQJDQDQWDUDYROXPH GHQJDQ GLDPHWHU GDQ WLQJJL GLDVXPVLNDQ PHP SXQ\DL KXEXQJDQ \DQJ OLQHDU GDQ QRQ OLQHDU VHKLQJJD GDODP KDO LQL PRGHO SHQGXJD YROXPH DPSXSXDGDODKIXQJVLGDULû ¦'7
SW SW
.HWHUDQJDQ5HPDUNVûSW YROXPHEDWDQJSRKRQVDPSDL WLQJJL SRKRQ SDGD SDQJNDO WDMXNP ' GLDPHWHUVHWLQJJLGDGDFP 7 WLQJJL SRKRQ SDGD SDQJNDOSW WDMXN P 4LURP 6XSUL \DGL 0RGHOUHJUHVL\DQJGLXMLDGDODKPRGHOOLQHDU
SRZHUORJDULWPD NXDGUDWLN GDQ HNVSRQHQVLDO GHQJDQ PHOLKDW NHVDODKDQ EDNX NRHIHVLHQ GHWHUPLQDVL (OFRP GDQ NHVHGHUKDQDDQ PRGHO 0RGHOPRGHO UHJUHVL \DQJ GLFREDNDQ GDSDWGLQRWDVLNDQVHEDJDLEHULNXW6LPRQ GDQ&XUYH([SHUW y0RGHOOLQHDUJDULVOXUXVû DE' E SRZHU y0RGHO JHRPHWULNû D' E' HNVSRQHQVLDO y0RGHO û DH y0RGHO/RJDULWPDû /RJDEORJ' y0RGHOOLQHDUû DE'F7GXDSHXEDK y0RGHOSRZHUû D' 7 GXDSHXEDKE F
.HWHUDQJDQ5HPDUNVû GXJDDQYROXPHSRKRQ ' GLDPHWHUEDWDQJGEK 7LQJJLSRKRQDEGDQFDGDODKNRQVWDQWDGDQH
8NXUDQNHVDNVDPDDQPRGHOYROXPHGLGDVDU NDQ SDGD SHUWLPEDQJDQ NHFLOQ\D SHUVHQ VLP SDQJDQEDNX6(VLPSDQJDQDJUHJDWLI6$GDQ VLPSDQJDQUDWDDQ656(6$GDQ65GLKLWXQJ GDODP EHQWXN UXPXV VHEDJDL EHULNXW +XVFK 6XEHGL 6KDUPD
6( DQWLORJ06([ 6$ 9$±9 9$[
65 _9$±9_9$1[
.HWHUDQJDQ5HPDUNV 06( UDWDDQNXDGUDWJDODW 9 $ YROXPHDNWXDO
9 YROXPH GXJDDQ PHQXUXW SHUVDPDDQGDQ1DGDODK MXPODKSRKRQVDPSHO
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
&$,GDULXPXUWDKXQNHXPXUWDKXQVH
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
WHUD 8WDUD ULDS YROXPH WHJDNDQ P KD WDKXQGHQJDQGDXUWHEDQJWDKXQ'DUZRHWDO 0HQXUXW%DGDQ/LEDQJNHKXWDQDQ ULDSYROXPHWHJDNDQXQWXNMHQLVEHUGDXUSHQGHN VG XPXU WDKXQ DGDODK ± P KDWDKXQ GDXU PHQHQJDK VG WDKXQ DGDODK ± P KDWDKXQGDQEHUGDXUSDQMDQJVGWDKXQ DGDODK P KDWDKXQ 'L $XVWUDOLD WHUFDWDW SURGXNVL ND\X DPSXSX \DQJ EHUDVDO GDUL ELML ELDVDVHEHVDU±P KDWKKDVLOXMLSURYHQDQ P KDWKKLEULGDQWDUD (XURSK\OOD[(XFD O\SWXV JUDQGLV ± P KDWK \DQJ GLSDQHQ SDGDXPXUWDKXQ7XUQEXOO %URNHU %$QJND%HQWXN%DWDQJ $QJND EHQWXN EDWDQJ DPSXSX I GLKLWXQJ VHEDJDL SHUEDQGLQJDQ DQWDUD LVL ND\X PHODOXL SHUKLWXQJDQYROXPHSHUVHNVLGHQJDQLVLVLOLQGHU \DQJPHPSXQ\DLGLDPHWHUEDWDQJVHWLQJJLGDGD PGDQWLQJJLSRKRQVDPSDLSDQJNDOWDMXN 1LODL UDWDUDWD DQJND EHQWXN EDWDQJ SRKRQ DPSXSXDGDODKI 6HEDJLDQEHVDUSRKRQ PRGHO PHPSXQ\DL DQJND EHQWXN DQWDUD ± 7DEHO
7DEHO7DEOH 3HUNHPEDQJDQULDSWHJDNDQDPSXSXGLNDZDVDQ+XWDQ:RORORER%DMDZD7KHWUHQGRI DPSXSXVWDQGLQFUHPHQWDW:RORORER)RUHVWDUHD%DMDZD 3DUDPHWHU 5LDSWDKXQDQUDWDUDWD0HDQDQQXDOLQFUHPHQW FPWDKXQPWDKXQPKDWDKXQ 7DKXQEHUMDODQ &XUUHQW DQQXDO 3HQJXNXUDQ0HDVXUHPHQW, 3HQJXNXUDQ0HDVXUHPHQW,, 'LDPHWHUFP 7LQJJLSRKRQP 9ROXPHPKD
.HWHUDQJDQ5HPDUNV3HQJXNXUDQ,XPXUGDQ,,XPXUWDKXQ7KHILUVWDQGVHFRQGPHDVXUHPHQWRIDJH\HDUVDQG\HDUV
-DUDNZDNWXDQWDUDSHQJXNXUDQ,GDQ,,VHODPDEXODQ7KHWLPHGLVWDQFHEHWZHHQILVUWDQGVHFRQGPHDVXUHPHQWZDV
7DEHO7DEOH!6HEDUDQ IUHNXHQVL DQJND EHQWXN EDWDQJ SRKRQ DPSXSX 'LVWULEXWLRQ RI IUHTXHQF\ RI VWHPIRUPIDFWRURIDPSXSXWUHHV $QJNDEHQWXN )RUPIDFWRU 1LODLWHQJDK 0HDQ )UHNXHQVL )UHTXHQF\ 3HUVHQWDVH 3HUFHQWDJH ± ± ± ± -XPODK
%HUGDVDUNDQ VHEDUDQ QLODL DQJND EHQWXN VH SHUWL7DEHOPDNDGDSDWGLWHQWXNDQVLPSDQJDQ EDNXQ\D\DLWX0HODOXLXMLWPDNDGLSHU ROHK WKLWXQJQ\D DGDODK \DQJ OHELK EHVDUGDULSDGDWWDEHOGHQJDQWLQJNDWNHSHUFD\D DQW\DLWX:LELVRQR +DOLQLPHQXQMXNNDQEDKZDDQJNDEHQWXNSRKRQ DPSXSXWLGDNELVDPHQJJXQDNDQGDQDQJND EHQWXNSRKRQ\DQJWHSDWDGDODK-LNDPHQJ JXQDNDQDQJNDEHQWXNXQWXNPHQGXJDYROX PHSRKRQDPSXSXEHUGLULVDPSDLWLQJJLSRKRQGL EDZDKSDQJNDOWDMXNPHQJKDVLONDQGXJDDQ\DQJRYHUHVWLPDWH OHELK GDUL YROXPH ND\X GHQJDQ PHQJJXQDNDQI VHEHVDU
&3HQGXJDDQ9ROXPH3RKRQ
0RGHOPRGHO UHJUHVL \DQJ GLFREDNDQ XQWXN PHQGXJDYROXPHSRKRQDPSXSX\DLWXPRGHOOL QHDUORJDULWPLNNXDGUDWLNSRZHUGDQHNVSRQHQ 0RGHOUHJUHVLWHUEDLNGLSLOLKEHUGDVDUNDQWLQJNDW NHWHOLWLDQNHWHSDWDQ GDQ NHVHGHUKDQDDQ PRGHO 7LQJNDWNHWHOLWLDQPRGHOGLFLULNDQROHKUHQGDK Q\DQLODLNHVDODKDQEDNX6(GDQWLQJJLQ\DQLODL NRHIHVLHQGHWHUPLQDVL5 0RGHOPRGHOGXJDDQ \DQJ GLSHUROHK GDQ GLDJUDP SHQFDU KXEXQJDQ
YROXPH GHQJDQ GLDPHWHU SRKRQ GLVDMLNDQ SDGD 7DEHO
3DGD 7DEHO GDSDW GLOLKDW EDKZD VHPXD PRGHOPHPSXQ\DLNHVDODKDQEDNXVHVXDLGHQJDQ SHUV\DUDWDQ \DQJ GLSHUNHQDQNDQ 0HQXUXW 3URGDQ GDODP +DUGMDQD GDODP PHQ\XVXQPRGHOEHUGDVDUNDQSHUVDPDDQUHJUHVL \DQJ PHQJJXQDNDQ VDWX SHXEDK GLSHUNHQDQNDQ NHVDODKDQEDNX6(PDNVLPDOVHGDQJNDQ DSDELODPHQJJXQDNDQGXDSHXEDKGLSHUNHQDQNDQ NHVDODKDQ EDNX PDNVLPDO 6HPXD PRGHO PHPSXQ\DLNRHIHVLHQGHWHUPLQDVLUHODWLIWLQJJL \DLWX UDWDUDWD OHELK GDUL GDQ IDNWRUIDNWRU \DQJ EHUSHQJDUXK VDQJDW VLJQLILNDQ GHQJDQ VHODQJNHSHUFD\DDQOHELKGDUL%HUGDVDUNDQ QLODL6(PRGHO\DQJSDOLQJDNXUDWDGDODKPRGHO QRPRU PRGHO NXDGUDWLN GHQJDQ 6( \DQJ SDOLQJUHQGDK\DLWXGHQJDQ5 8QWXNSHQJXMLDQPRGHOOHELKODQMXWXMLYDOLGDVL NHVHGHUKDQDDQ PRGHO SHUOX MXJD GLSHUWLPEDQJ NDQGLVDPSLQJNHVDNVDPDDQPRGHONDUHQDOHELK PXGDK PHQJDSOLNDVLNDQ GL ODSDQJDQ 0RGHO SHUVDPDDQQRPRUPRGHOOLQHDUGDQQRPRU PRGHOSRZHU OHELK VHGHUKDQD GDULSDGD PRGHO NXDGUDWLN
7DEHO7DEOH! 0RGHOPRGHO SHQGXJD YROXPH SRKRQ VDPSDL WLQJJL SDQJNDO WDMXN 0RGHOV RI WUHH YROXPHHVWLPDWLRQRQFURZQEDVHKHLJKW 1R 0RGHOUHJUHVL 3HUVDPDDQUHJUHVL 6( 5 6LJ /LQHDU 9SW ' 3RZHU 9SW ' /RJDULWPD 9SW ORJ' 4XDGUDWLN 9SW ±'' ([SRQHQWLDO 9SW H' /LQHDUEHUJDQGD 9SW '7SW 3RZHUEHUJDQGD 9SW '7SW
.HWHUDQJDQ5HPDUNV û 9ROXPHSRKRQVDPSDLWLQJJLSRKRQSDQJNDOWDMXN9ROXPHRIWUHHRQFURZQEDVHKHLJKW P ' 'LDPHWHUVHWLQJJLGDGD'LDPHWHUDWEUHDVWKHLJKW 7 7LQJJLSRKRQSDGDSDQJNDOWDMXNSW +HLJKWRIWUHHRQFURZQEDVH 6XPEHU6RXUFH'LRODKGDULGDWDODSDQJ&RPSLOHGDQGDQDO\]HGIURPILHOGGDWD 6XPEHU6RXUFH'LRODKGDULGDWDODSDQJ&RPSLOHGDQGDQDO\]HGIURPILHOGGDWD3DGD 7DEHO GDSDW GLOLKDW EDKZD NRUHODVL
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û GL %DOLNSDSDQ
' %XVWRPL MHQLV GDPDU $JDWKLV ORUDQWKLIROLDGL%DQ\XPDVû ' 6LVZDQWR .ULVQDZDWL GDQ MHQLV UDVD PDOD $OWLQJLD H[FHOVD VDPSDL WLQJJL SRKRQ EHEDVFDEDQJû GL&LDQMXU '
EF
6LVZDQWR :DKMRQR
7DEHO7DEOH .RUHODVL DQWDUD YDULDEHOYDULDEHO VDPSDL GLDPHWHU EDWDQJFDEDQJ FP &RUUHODWLRQ EHWZHHQYDULDEOHVXQWLOGLDPHWHURIFPVWHPEUDQFK
1R $QWDUYDULDEHO9DULDEOHV .RHIHVLHQNRUHODVL
&RUUHODWLRQFRHIILFLHQWU
'LDPHWHUEDWDQJGEKGHQJDQWLQJJLSRKRQSDGDSDQJNDOWDMXN
'LDPHWHUEDWDQJGEKGHQJDQYROXPHSRKRQ9SW
9ROXPHSRKRQ9GHQJDQWLQJJLSRKRQSDQJNDOWDMXN7SW
.HWHUDQJDQ5HPDUN 6LJQLILNDQSDGDWDUDIQ\DWD6LJQLILFDQWDWWKHOHYHO 6XPEHU6RXUFH'LRODKGDULGDWDODSDQJ&RPSLOHGDQGDQDO\]HGIURPILHOGGDWD
7DEHO7DEOH 6( 6$ GDQ 65 SHUVDPDDQ UHJUHVL SDGD WLQJJL SRKRQ SDQJNDO WDMXN6WDQGDUG HUURU DJUHJDWLYHGHYLDWLRQDQGPHDQGHYLDWLRQRI5HJUHVVLRQHTXDWLRQVRQWUHHKHLJKWRIFURZQ EDVH 1R 3HUVDPDDQUHJUHVL5HJUHVVLRQHTXDWLRQV 6( 6$ 65 9SW ' 9SW ' 9SW ORJ' 9SW ±'' 9SW H' 9SW '7SW 9SW '7SW 6XPEHU6RXUFH'LRODKGDULGDWDODSDQJ&RPSLOHGDQGDQDO\]HGIURPILHOGGDWD
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
'$)7$53867$.$
$OUDVMLG+)DNWRUNXDOLWDVODKDQSHP EDWDVXQWXNSHUWXPEXKDQ*PHOLQDDUERUHD %XOHWLQ 3HQHOLWLDQ +XWDQ %RJRU 3XVDW3HQHOLWLDQGDQ3HQJHPEDQJDQ+XWDQ $QRQLP/DSRUDQ7DKXQDQ'LQDV.HKXWDQDQ .DEXSDWHQ1JDGD7DKXQ%DMDZD'LQDV .HKXWDQDQ.DEXSDWHQ1JDGD %DGDQ /LEDQJ .HKXWDQDQ 5RDGPDS 3HQHOLWLDQ GDQ 3HQJHPEDQJDQ ± -DNDUWD 'HSDUWHPHQ .HKXWDQDQ %DGDQ 3HQHOLWLDQGDQ3HQJHPEDQJDQ.HKXWDQDQ %XVWRPL 6 7DEHO LVL SRKRQ ORNDO$FDFLD PDQJLXPXQWXNGDHUDK%DOLNSDSDQ%XO3HQ +XWDQ%RJRU3XVDW3HQHOLWLDQGDQ 3HQJHPEDQJDQ+XWDQ%RJRU %XVWRPL6+DUEDJXQJ:DK\RQR' 3DUWKDPD ,%3 3HWXQMXN WHNQLV WDWD FDUD SHQ\XVXQDQ WDEOH YROXPH SRKRQ,QIR KXWDQ %RJRU %DGDQ 3HQHOLWLDQ GDQ 3HQJHPEDQJDQ .HKXWDQDQ
&OXWWHU -/ )RUWVRQ-& 3LHQDDU/9
7LPEHUPDQDJHPHQW$TXDQWLWDWLYHDSSURDFK 0DODEDU)/.ULHJHU3XEOLVKLQJ &XUYH([SHUW$NVHVWDQJJDO6HSWHPEHU GDULKWWSZZZ)OXRUJFQHQGRZQORDG± +WQO 'DUZR6XKHQGDQJ(-D\D,163XUQRPR+ 3UDWLZL .XDOLILNDVL NXDOLWDV WHPSDW WXPEXKGDQSURGXNWLYLWDVWHJDNDQXQWXNKXWDQ WDQDPDQHXNDOLSWXVGL.DEXSDWHQ6LPDOXQJXQ 6XPDWHUD 8WDUD-XUQDO 3HQHOLWLDQ 7DQDPDQ +XWDQ7DQDPDQ
(OFRP63666WDWLVWLNGHVNULSWLIWDEXODVL VLODQJGDQNRUHODVLPHDQWUDQVIRUPDVLGDWD DQDOLVLV YDULDQ DQDOLVLV UHJUHVL <RJ\DNDUWD &9$QGLRIIVHW
*DUGLQJHQ35 3KLOOLSV3'(FRORJLFDO VSHFLHV JURXSLQJ IRU IRUHVWPDQDJHPHQWE\ 37,QKXWDQL,%)035HSRUW%DOLNSDSDQ +DUEDJXQJ0RGHOSHUWXPEXKDQGLDPHWHUGDQ WLQJJL WHJDNDQ KXWDQ WDQDPDQ (XFDO\SWXV XURSK\OOD%ODNHGLGDHUDK3XMRQ-DZD7LPXU %XOHWLQ3HQHOLWLDQ+XWDQ +DUEDJXQJ :DK\RQR ' 7DWDFDUD SHPEXDWDQ GDQ SHQJXNXUDQ 3HWDN 8NXU 3HUPDQHQ 383,QIRUPDVL 7HNQLV %RJRU 3XVDW3HQHOLWLDQGDQ3HQJHPEDQJDQ+XWDQGDQ .RQVHUYDVL$ODP
+DUEDJXQJ .XDQWLILNDVL SHUWXPEXKDQ GDQ KDVLOSDGDKXWDQWDQDPDQMHQLVMHQLVSULRULWDV DQGDODQVHWHPSDW-DNDUWD%DGDQ3HQHOLWLDQ GDQ3HQJHPEDQJDQ.HKXWDQDQ
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
3URGDQ 0 )RUHVW %LRPHWULF /RQGRQ 3HUJDQRQ2[IRUG
4LURP 0$ 6XSUL\DGL 0RGHO SHQGXJD
YROXPH SRKRQ Q\DZDL )LFXV YDULHJDWD %OXPH GL .DOLPDQWDQ 7LPXU -XUQDO 3HQHOLWLDQ+XWDQ7DQDPDQ
5L\DQWR +' 7MDNUDZDUVD * 3HUWXP EXKDQ WDQDPDQ UHKDELOLWDVL SROD DJURIRUHVWU\ VHQJRQ GDQ MDERQ SDGD ODKDQ WHUGHJUDGDVL GL 7ORJRZXQJX 3DWL3URVLGLQJ 6HPLQDU 1DVLR QDO +DVLO 3HQHOLWLDQ 7HNQRORJL 3HQJHORODDQ '$6 %RJRU 3XVDW 3HQHOLWLDQ GDQ 3HQJHP EDQJDQ.RQVHUYDVLGDQ5HKDELOLWDVL
6LPRQ+6WDWLVWLNXQWXNNHKXWDQDQ<RJ\D NDUWD3XVWDND3HODMDU
6LVZDQWR %( ' :DKMRQR 7DEHO LVL SRKRQ MHQLV 5DVDPDOD $OWLQJLD H[FHOVD 1RURQKDH GL .3+ &LDQMXU -DZD %DUDW%XO
3HQ+XWDQ 6LVZDQWR %( .ULVQDZDWL + 7DULI LVL SRKRQ XQWXN$JDWKLV ORUDQWKLIROLD 6DOLVE GL .HVDWXDQ 3HPDQJNXDQ +XWDQ %DQ\XPDV %DUDW-DZD7HQJDK%XO3HQ+XWDQ 6LVZDQWR%( 6X\DW0RGHOSHQGXJDDQLVL
SRKRQ MHQLV(XFDO\SWXV GHJOXSWD %OXPH GL
%RULVDOOR6XODZHVL6HODWDQ-XUQDO3HQHOLWLDQ +XWDQGDQ.RQVHUYDVL$ODP 6XEHGL 05 6KDUPD 53 $OORPHWULF
ELRPDVV PRGHOV IRU EDUN RI&LQQDPRPXP WDPDOD LQ 0LG+LOO RI 1HSDO%LRPDVV DQG %LRHQHUJ\
6XFKRPHO & 3\WWHO 3 %HFNHU * %DXKXV %LRPDVV HTXDWLRQV IRU VHVVLOH RDN 4XHUFXVSHWUDHD0DWW/LHEODQGKRUEHDP &DUSLQXVEHWXOXV/LQ$JHG&RSSLFHG)RUHVW LQ 6RXWKZHVW *HUPDQ\ %LRPDVV DQG %LR HQHUJ\ 7XUEXOO- %URNHU,7LPRUPRXQWDLQJXP (XFDO\SWXVXURSK\OOD67%ODNH )RUHVW7UHH 6HULHV 0HOERXUQH $XVWUDOLD &RPRQ ZHDOWK 6FLHQWLILF DQG ,QGXVWULDO 5HVHDUFK 2UJDQL]DWLRQ
9DQFOD\ -. 0RGHOOLQJ IRUHVW JURZWK DQG \LHOG$SSOLFDWLRQWR0L[HG7URSLFDO)RUHVW :DOOLQJIRUG8.&$%,QWHUQDWLRQDO
:LELVRQR<0HWRGH6WDWLVWLN<RJ\DNDUWD *DMDK0DGD8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV
