,3(1'$+8/8$1
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
()(.7,),7$6)81*,0,.25,=$$5%86.8/$57(5+$'$33(5780%8+$1
.,+,$1*
$OEL]LDSURFHUD
%HQWK',3(56(0$,$1'$1/$3$1*$1
(IIHFWLYLW\RI$UEXVFXODU0\FRUUKL]DO)XQJLRQ3ODQW*URZWKRI
$OEL]LDSURFHUD
%HQWKLQ1XUVHU\DQG)LHOG
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± $0)*ORPXVVSDQG *ORPXVVS LQFUHDVHGVLJQLILFDQWO\KHLJKWDQGGLDPHWHUJURZWKRI\RXQJSODQWLQWKHILHOGFRPSDUHGWRFRQWURO.H\ZRUGV$OEL]LDSURFHUDVHHGOLQJ*LJDVSRUD*ORPXVP\FRUUKL]DOGHSHQGHQF\
$%675$.
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±,QRNXODQ)0$*ORPXVVSGDQ*ORPXVVSGDSDWPHQLQJNDWNDQSHUWXPEXKDQWLQJJLGDQ GLDPHWHUWDQDPDQPXGDNLKLDQJVHFDUDQ\DWDWHUKDGDSNRQWURO
NKHODWROHK)HGDQ$OVHKLQJJDVXOLWGLVHUDSROHK DNDUWDQDPDQ2OHKNDUHQDLWXEDQWXDQVLPELRVH )XQJL0LNRUL]D$UEXVNXOD)0$NKHODVLXQVXU 3 ROHK LRQLRQ ORJDP WHUVHEXW DNDQ WHUOHSDV VHKLQJJD PHQMDGL WHUVHGLD EDJL DNDU WDQDPDQ 6HWLDGL $SOLNDVL )0$ GLODNXNDQ SDGD VDDW SHQ\DSLKDQ RYHUVSLQ GL SHUVHPDLDQ GDQ DNDQ PHPEDQWX SHQ\HUDSDQ XQVXU 3 GDQ XQVXU XQVXUODLQQ\DVHSHUWL1GDQ.ROHKELELWWDQDPDQ GLSHUVHPDLDQ:XODQGDULHWDO1HXPDQQ *HRUJH.LPHWDO+XDQJHWDOX
%LQJHWDO+DOGHUHWDO
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
,,0(72'2/2*, $7HPSDWGDQ:DNWX3HQHOLWLDQ
3HQHOLWLDQ GLODNVDQDNDQ GL SHUVHPDLDQ .H ORPSRN 3HQHOLWL 0LNURELRORJL +XWDQ 3XVDW /LWEDQJ .RQVHUYDVL GDQ 5HKDELOLWDVL %RJRU SDGDEXODQ6HSWHPEHUVDPSDLGHQJDQ'HVHPEHU 3HQDQDPDQ ELELW NLKLDQJ GLODNXNDQ GL .DZDVDQ+XWDQ'HQJDQ7XMXDQ.KXVXV.+' 7.&DULWD.HFDPDWDQ/DEXDQ.DEXSDWHQ3DQ GHJODQJ SDGD DZDO EXODQ )HEUXDUL 3HQJ KLWXQJDQSHUVHQWDVHNRORQLVDVLGDQSURVHVSHQJH ULQJDQGDQSHQLPEDQJDQEHUDWNHULQJGLODNVDQD NDQGL/DERUDWRULXP0LNURELRORJL+XWDQ %%DKDQGDQ$ODW
%DKDQEDKDQ \DQJ GLJXQDNDQ GDODP SHODN VDQDDQSHQHOLWLDQLQLDGDODKVHEDJDLEHULNXWELML
PHQJDQGXQJ PLVHOLDDNDUWHULQIHNVLGDQVSRUD 6HWLDS J LQRNXODQ PHPLOLNL NHSDGDWDQ VSRUD EHUWXUXWWXUXW*ORPXVVSVSRUD*ORPXV VS VSRUD*ORPXV VS VSRUD GDQ *LJDVSRUD VS VSRUD %DKDQ ODLQ \DQJ GLSHUOXNDQ DGDODK NDQWRQJ SODVWLN KLWDP SRO\ EDJXNXUDQ[FPNDQWRQJSODVWLNWUDQV SDUDQ XNXUDQ [ FP EDN SHUNHFDP EDKDQXNXUDQ[[FPSHVWLVLGDGHQJDQ EDKDQ DNWLI GD]RPHW WDQDKVXEVRLO SDGD NHGDODPDQ±FPGDQSDUDQHW$ODWDODW \DQJ GLJXQDNDQ GDODP SHQHOLWLDQ LQL DGDODK NDOLSHU SHQJJDULV PLNURVNRS NDPHUD HPEUDW GDQWLPEDQJDQDQDOLWLN
&0HWRGH3HQHOLWLDQ 6WHULOLVDVLPHGLD
0HGLDSHUNHFDPEDKDQ]HROLWGLVWHULOLVDVLNDQ R
GHQJDQ DODW DXWRNODI SDGD VXKX & GDQ WHNDQDQ DWP VHODPD PHQLW 6HGDQJNDQ VWHULOLVDVL PHGLD VDSLK ELELW GLODNXNDQ PHODOXL
WHNQLNIXPLJDVLGHQJDQFDUDVHWLDSVDWXP PHGLD GLFDPSXUGHQJDQJSHVWLVLGDGHQJDQEDKDQ DNWLI GD]RPHW 6HODQMXWQ\D PHGLD GLDGXN VHFDUD PHUDWD GHQJDQ FDQJNXO 0HGLD WHUVHEXW NHPXGLDQ GLWXWXS VHFDUD UDSDW GHQJDQ SODVWLN WUDQVSDUDQVHODPDGXDPLQJJX
3HUNHFDPEDKDQGDQLQRNXODVL
%LML GLVHEDUNDQ VHFDUD PHUDWD SDGD PHGLD ]HROLW\DQJVWHULOSDGDEDNSHUNHFDPEDKDQSODV WLN NHPXGLDQ GL DWDV ELML GLWDEXUL PHGLD ]HROLW VHWHEDO PP 6HODQMXWQ\D EDN SHUNHFDPEDKDQ WHUVHEXWGLVLPSDQGDODPSHUVHPDLDQ\DQJGLEHUL DWDS SDUDQHW GHQJDQ LQWHQVLWDV FDKD\D NHOHPEDEDQPHGLDGLMDJDGHQJDQFDUDSHQ\HP SURWDQGHQJDQDLUVHWLDSSDJLGDQVRUHKDUL
6HWHODK ELML EHUNHFDPEDK VHODQMXWQ\D GLSLQ GDK NH GDODPSRO\EDJ \DQJ WHODK GLLVL GHQJDQ FDPSXUDQ PHGLD WDQDK GDQ VHNDP SDGL VWHULO YY,QRNXODQ)0$GLOHWDNNDQSDGDOXEDQJ WDQDPGDODPSRO\EDJVHEDQ\DNJVHWLDSSRO\ EDJ 3HQDQDPDQELELWGLODSDQJ /XEDQJWDQDP[[FPGHQJDQMDUDN WDQDP[PGLSHUVLDSNDQVDWXEXODQVHEHOXP SHQDQDPDQNHPXGLDQGLLVLGHQJDQSXSXNNDQ GDQJD\DPSHGDJLQJNJGDQGLELDUNDQVDPSDL ZDNWXSHQDQDPDQ
3HQJDPDWDQSHUWXPEXKDQGDQNRORQLVDVL
DNDU
9DULDEHOSHUWXPEXKDQELELWWDQDPDQNLKLDQJ \DQJGLDPDWL\DLWXWLQJJLGLDPHWHUFPGLDWDV SHUPXNDDQ WDQDK EHUDW NHULQJ ELELW GLRYHQ
R
VHODPDKDULSDGDVXKX &VDPSDLEHUDWNRQV WDQ GDQ NRORQLVDVL DNDU 6HGDQJNDQ YDULDEHO SHUWXPEXKDQWDQDPDQGLODSDQJDQ\DQJGLDPDWL DGDODKWLQJJLGDQGLDPHWHUFPGLDWDVSHUPX NDDQWDQDK
.RORQLVDVLDNDUGLKLWXQJGHQJDQPHUHQGDP DNDUFRQWRKGDODPODUXWDQ.2+ZYVH ODQMXWQ\D GLUHQGDP GHQJDQ ODUXWDQ +&O 6HWHODK LWX DNDUDNDU WHUVHEXW GLUHQGDP GDODP ODUXWDQ SHZDUQD WU\SDQ EOXH 3HUVHQWDVH NRORQLVDVLDNDUGLKLWXQJGHQJDQPHWRGH*LRYDQ QHWWL 0RVVH
.HWHUJDQWXQJDQELELWWHUKDGDSPLNRUL]D .HWHUJDQWXQJDQ ELELW WDQDPDQ NLKLDQJ WHU KDGDSPLNRUL]D0'0\FRUUKL]DO'HSHQGHQF\ GLKLWXQJEHUGDVDUNDQUXPXV\DQJGLNHPXNDNDQ ROHK3OHQFKHWWHHWDO $±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
$QJND GDODP WDQGD NXUXQJ DGDODK SHUVHQWDVH SHQLQJNDWDQ VXDWX YDULDEHO SHQJDPDWDQ GLEDQGLQJNDQ GHQJDQ NRQWURO 1XPHULFLQWKHSDUHQWKHVLVLVSHUFHQWDJHRIYDULDEOHLQFUHPHQWFRPSDUHGWRWKHFRQWURO
EDKZD NHHPSDW MHQLV )0$ WLGDN PHPEHULNDQ SHQJDUXK\DQJQ\DWDWHUKDGDSEHUDWNHULQJDNDU SDGDEHUDWNHULQJSXFXNVHPXDSHUODNXDQPHP EHULNDQSHQJDUXKQ\DWDNHFXDOLSHUODNXDQ*LJDV SRUDVS6HGDQJNDQSDGDEHUDWNHULQJWRWDOELELW KDQ\DSHUODNXDQ*ORPXVVS\DQJPHPEHULNDQ SHQJDUXK\DQJQ\DWDGLEDQGLQJNDQGHQJDQNRQ WURO7DEHO 5DVLRSXFXNDNDUELELWNLKLDQJXPXUEXODQ GL SHVHPDLDQ PHQLQJNDW GHQJDQ DGDQ\D SHU ODNXDQ LQRNXODVL )0$ GHQJDQ NLVDUDQ ± GLEDQGLQJNDQ GHQJDQ NRQWURO 7DEHO %LELW NLKLDQJ\DQJPHQGDSDWSHUODNXDQLQRNXODVL)0$ GDSDWPHQLQJNDWNDQWLQJNDWNHWHUJDQWXQJDQELELW WHUKDGDS )0$ \DQJ EHUNLVDU DQDWDU ± 7DEHO
3HQ\HUDSDQKDUD
+DVLO DQDOLVLV VLGLN UDJDP PHQXQMXNNDQ EDKZDMHQLV)0$*ORPXVVS*ORPXVVSGDQ *ORPXVVSPHPEHULNDQSHQJDUXK\DQJQ\DWD WHUKDGDSVHUDSDQXQVXU13GDQ.\DQJWHUGDSDW SDGDMDULQJDQEDWDQJGDQGDXQELELW$SURFHUD NHFXDOL SHUODNXDQ LQRNXODVL*ORPXV VS SDGD SDUDPHWHUVHUDSDQXQVXU33HUODNXDQLQRNXODVL MHQLV )0$*LJDVSRUD VS KDQ\D PHPEHULNDQ EHULNDQUHVSRQ\DQJQ\DWD7DEHO 3HUWXPEXKDQWDQDPDQPXGD$SURFHUDGL ODSDQJ
+DVLO DQDOLVLV VLGLN UDJDP PHQXQMXNNDQ EDKZDLQRNXODVL)0$*ORPXVVS*ORPXVVS GDQ*LJDVSRUDVS GDSDW PHQLQJNDWNDQ SHU WXPEXKDQ WLQJJL GDQ GLDPHWHU VHFDUD Q\DWD GLEDQGLQJNDQGHQJDQNRQWUROLQRNXODVLGLODNX NDQ SDGD VDDWRYHUVSLQ GL SHVHPDLDQ NHFXDOL SHUODNXDQLQRNXODVL*LJDVSRUDVSWHUKDGDSSDUD PHWHU SHUWXPEXKDQ WLQJJL WDQDPDQ 3HQLQJ NDWDQSHUWXPEXKDQWLQJJLGDQGLDPHWHUEHUWXUXW WXUXW EHUNLVDU DQWDUD ± GDQ ± GLEDQGLQJNDQGHQJDQNRQWURO
%3HPEDKDVDQ
3HUODNXDQLQRNXODVLNHHPSDWMHQLV)0$GDSDW PHQLQJNDWNDQSHUWXPEXKDQWLQJJLGLDPHWHUGDQ ELRPDV ELELW WDQDPDQ NLKLDQJ XPXU EXODQ GL SHUVHPDLDQ GHQJDQ FXNXS WDMDP GLEDQGLQJNDQ GHQJDQNRQWURO+DOLQL GLGXJD NDUHQDDGDQ\D SHQLQJNDWDQNRORQLVDVLDNDUSDGDELELW\DQJPHQ GDSDW SHUODNXDQ LQRNXODVL EDLN*ORPXV VS *ORPXVVS*ORPXVVSPDXSXQ*LJDVSRUD VS\DQJEHUNLVDUSDGD±
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
! $QJND GDODP WDQGD NXUXQJ DGDODK SHUVHQWDVH SHQLQJNDWDQ VXDWX YDULDEHO SHQJDPDWDQ GLEDQGLQJNDQ GHQJDQ NRQWURO 1XPHULFLQWKHSDUHQWKHVLVLVSHUFHQWDJHRIYDULDEOHLQFUHPHQWFRPSDUHGWRWKHFRQWURO
-HQLV)0$ $0) 6HUDSDQKDUD 1XWULHQWXSDNH PJVHHGOLQJ 1 3 . *ORPXVVS D D D *ORPXVVS D EF D *ORPXVVS D D D *LJDVSRUDVS DE DE DE .RQWURO E F E 7DEHO7DEOH 3HQJDUXKLQRNXODVL)0$WHUKDGDSMXPODKVHUDSDQXQVXU13GDQ.SDGDELELWWDQDPDQ NLKLDQJXPXUEXODQGLSHVHPDLDQ7KHHIIHFWRI$0)LQRFXODWLRQWR13.XSWDNHRI WKUHHPRQWKVROG$OEL]LDSURFHUDVHHGOLQJVLQQXUVHU\
7DEHO7DEOH 3HQJDUXK LQRNXODVL )0$ WHUKDGDS SHUWXPEXKDQ WLQJJL GDQ GLDPHWHU WDQDPDQ PXGD NLKLDQJXPXUEXODQGLODSDQJ7KHHIIHFWRI$0)LQRFXODWLRQWRKHLJKWGLDPHWHUSODQW JURZWKRIVL[PRQWKVROG$OEL]LDSURFHUDLQWKHILHOG
.HWHUDQJDQ5HPDUNV
$QJND\DQJGLLNXWLROHKKXUXI\DQJVDPDPHQXQMXNNDQWLGDNDGDSHUEHGDDQ\DQJQ\DWDSDGDWDUDI EHUGDVDUNDQXML. 7XNH\1XPHULFIROORZHGE\WKHVDPHOHWWHUVDUHQRWVLJQLILFDQWO\GLIIHUHQWDW.DFFRUGLQJWR7XNH\WHVW
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
! $QJND GDODP WDQGD NXUXQJ DGDODK SHUVHQWDVH SHQLQJNDWDQ VXDWX YDULDEHO SHQJDPDWDQ GLEDQGLQJNDQ GHQJDQ NRQWURO 1XPHULFLQWKHSDUHQWKHVLVLVSHUFHQWDJHRIYDULDEOHLQFUHPHQWFRPSDUHGWRWKHFRQWURO
3HUVHQWDVH NRORQLVDVL DNDU DGDODK FHUPLQDQ GDUL DGDQ\D KLID LQWHUQDO YHVLNHO GDQ YDNXROD GDODPMDULQJDQDNDUKDOLQLDNDQPHQLQJNDWNDQ MXPODK KLID HNVWHUQDO \DQJ PXQFXO SDGD DNDU DNDUELELWNLKLDQJ'HQJDQVHPDNLQPHQLQJNDW Q\D KLID HNVWHUQDO WHUVHEXW \DQJ PHUXSDNDQ NHSDQMDQJDQGDULDNDUELELWGDQSHQLQJNDWDQELR PDV DNDU DNDQ PHQLQJNDWNDQ OXDVDQ GDHUDK VHUDSDQPHQMDGLOHELKEHVDUYROXPHQ\D'HQJDQ VHPDNLQEHVDUQ\DYROXPHWDQDK\DQJGLMDGLNDQ
VHEDJDL GDHUDK VHUDSDQ WHUVHEXW PDND SHOXDQJ KLIDKLID HNVWHUQDO XQWXN PHQJDEVRUEVL XQVXU XQVXUKDUDVHSHUWLXQVXU13.GDQDLUVHPDNLQ EHVDUGLEDQGLQJNDQGHQJDQELELWWDQDPDQWDQSD EHUPLNRUL]D)DQHW DO .KDGH 5RGUL JXHVGDQ7XUMDPDQHWDO 3HQHOLWLDQ-DNREVHQHWDOPHQ\DWDNDQ SDQMDQJKLIDKLIDHNVWHUQDOSDGD7ULEROLXPVXE WHUUDQHXP / \DQJ GLLQRNXODVL GHQJDQ*ORPXV VSGDQ6FXWHOORVSRUDFDORVSRUDGDSDWPHQFDSDL 6XPEHU6RXUFH'LRODKGDWDODSDQJ&RPSLOHGDQGDQDO\]HGIURPILHOGGDWD
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±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
GLEDJL PHQMDGL WLJD NHODV \DLWX UHQGDK VHGDQJ ± GDQ WLQJJL !±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
3HUWXPEXKDQ WLQJJL GDQ GLDPHWHU WDQDPDQ PXGD$SURFHUDXPXUEXODQGLODSDQJDQPDVLK PHQXQMXNNDQ DGDQ\D UHVSRQ LQRNXODVL )0$ *ORPXVVSGDQ*ORPXVVS\DQJQ\DWDGL EDQGLQJNDQ GHQJDQ NRQWURO LQRNXODVL GLODNX NDQ SDGD VDDWRYHUVSLQ GL SHVHPDLDQ 3HQLQJ NDWDQSHUWXPEXKDQWLQJJLGDQGLDPHWHUEHUWXUXW WXUXWEHUNLVDUDQWDUD±GDQ±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± GDQGLDPHWHUVHEHVDU
)0$ PHQJHOXDUNDQ HQ]LP KLGUROLWLN VHSHUWL VHOXORVHSHNQLQDVHGDQ[LORJOXNDQDVH\DQJWHU OLEDW GDODP PLQHUDOLVDVL EDKDQ RUJDQLN $WXO 1D\\DU9DODULQLPHQ\DWDNDQDSOL NDVL)0$PHQLQJNDWNDQXQVXUKDUDDHUDVLGDODP WDQDKDJHJUDVLSDUWLNHOWDQDKGDQNDSDVLWDVPH
QDKDQDLUZDWHUKROGLQJFDSDFLW\'LVDPSLQJ LWXSHPEHULDQEDKDQRUJDQLNMXJDDNDQPHQLQJ NDWNDQSHUWXPEXKDQ)0$DNDQOHELKEDLNGLGD ODPWDQDK*U\QGOHUHWDO ,9.(6,038/$1'$16$5$1 $.HVLPSXODQ
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
'$)7$53867$.$
$EERWW/. 5REVRQ$')RUPDWLRQRI ([WHUQDO +\SKDH LQ 6RLO %\ )RXU 6SHFLHV RI 9HVLFXODU$UEXVFXODU 0\FRUUKL]DO )XQJL
1HZ3K\WRO
$WXO1D\\DU $ & . +DPHO +DQVRQ DQG -*HUPLGD7KH$UEXVFXODU0\FRUUKL]DO 6\PELRVLV /LQNV 1 0LQHUDOL]DWLRQ WR 3ODQW 'HPDQG0\FRUUKL]D
%LQJ+*6KLURQJ+&KDR[LQJ<<DQDQG< ;LDQFKDQJ (IIHFWV RI $UEXVFXODU 0\FRUUKL]D)XQJL$0)RQWKH3ODQW*URZWK )UXLW <LHOG DQG )UXLW 4XDOLW\ RI &XFXPEHU 8QGHU6DOW6WUHVV&KLQHVH-RXUQDORI$SOOLHG (FRORJ\
%LQX1.3.$VKRNDQDQG0%DODVXQGDUDQ ,QIOXHQFH RI 'LIIHUHQW $UEXVFXODU 0\FRUUKL]DO )XQJL DQG 6KDGH RQ *URZWK RI 6DQGDO6DQWDOXPDOEXP6HHGOLQJV-RI7URS )RU6FL±
%XGL6:DQG/6HW\DQLQJVLK$UEXVFXODU 0\FRUUKL]DO )XQJL DQG %LRFKDU ,PSURYHG (DUO\ *URZWK RI 1HHP 0HOLD D]HGDUDFK /LQQ 6HHGOLQJ 8QGHU *UHHQKRXVH &RQGL WLRQV -XUQDO 0DQDMHPHQ +XWDQ 7URSLND
&UX]5(GHOD=DUDGH-)$QJJDQ]DH16 /RULOOD(%'LIIHUHQWLDO0\FRUUKL]DO 'HYHORSPQHWRI6RPH$JULFXOWXUDO+RUWLFXO WXUDO DQG )RUVHWU\ &URSV WR ,QRFXODWLRQ RI 0\FRUUKL]DO)XQJL
)DQ/'DOSp<)DQJ&'XEp& .KDQL]DGHK 6 ,QIOXHQFH RI $UEXVFXODU 0\FRU UKL]DH RQ %LRPDVV DQG 5RRW 0RUSKRORJ\ RI 6HOHFWHG 6WUDZEHUU\ &XOWLYDUV XQGHU 6DOW
6WUHVV%RWDQ\
*LRYDQQHWWL0 0RVVH%$QHYDOXDWLRQ RI WHFKQLTXHV IRU PHDVXULQJ YHVLFXODU DUEXVFXODU P\FRUUKL]DO LQIHFWLRQ LQ 5RRWV
1HZ3K\WRO
*U\QGOHU0+UVHORYD+6XGRYD5*U\QGOHURYD + .XEDW - 2UJDQLF DQG PLQHUDO IHUWOL]DWLRQ UHVSHFWLYHO\ LQFUHDVH DQG GHFUH DVHWKHGHYHORSPHQWRIH[WHUQDOP\FHOOLXPRI $UEXVFXODU0\FRUUKL]DO)XQJLLQD/RQJ7HUP )LHOG([SHULPHQW0\FRUUKL]D +DJH$KPHG . .UDPPHU - 6WHLQNHOOQHU 6
7KH ,QWHUFURSSLQJ 3DUWQHU $IIHFWV $UEXVFXODU0\FRUUKL]DO)XQJLDQG)XVDULXP R[\VSRUXP I VS O\FRSHUVLFL ,QWHUDFWLRQV LQ
7RPDWR0\FRUUKL]D
+DOGHU0'KDU 330XMLE$60.KDQ06 -RDUGDU -& $NKWHU 6 (IIHFW RI $UEXVFXODU 0\FRUUKL]D )XQJL ,QRFXODWLRQ RQ *URZWK DQG 8SWDNH RI 0LQHUDO 1XWULWLRQ LQ ,SRPRHDDTXDWLF&XUUHQW:RUOG(QYLURQPQHW
+H\QH.7XPEXKDQ%HUJXQD,QGRLQHVLD,, -DNDUWD %DGDQ /LWEDQJ .HKXWDQDQ 'HSDUWH PHQ.HKXWDQDQ
2IILFLQDO &RPSRQHQWV &KLQ -$SSO (FRO
,ULDQWR 56% D )XQJL PLNRUL]D DUEXVNODU PHQLQJNDWNDQ SHUWXPEXKDQ DZDO$TXLODULD FUDVVQD3LHUUHH[/HFRPWHGLSHUVHPDLDQGDQ ODSDQJ6XEPLWWHGWR-XUQDO3HQHOLWLDQ+XWDQ GDQ.RQVHUYDVL$ODP
,ULDQWR 56% E (IHNWLILWDV IXQJL PLNRUL]D DUEXVNXODUWHUKDGDSSHUWXPEXKDQSXODLKLWDP $OVWRQLDDQJXVWLORED0LTGLSHVHUPDLDQGDQ ODSDQJ6XEPLWWHGWR-XUQDO3HQHOLWLDQ+XWDQ GDQ.RQVHUYDVL$ODP
,ULDQWR 56% F 3HQJDUXK LQRNXODVL IXQJL PLNRUL]D DUEXVNXOD WHUKDGDS SHUWXPEXKDQ ELELWWDQDPDQVXUHQ7RRQDVXUHQL0HUUGDODP 0HQXQMDQJ.HEHUKDVLODQ.RQVHUYDVL([VLWX -)RUHVWDQG1DWXUH&RQVHUYDWLRQ5HVHDUFK
,ULDQWR 56% G 7KH HIIHFW RI DUEXVFXODU P\FRUUKL]DO IXQJL DQG VORZ UHOHDVH IHUWLOL]HU RQ WKH JURZWK RI$OVWRQLD VFKRODULVLQ WKH
1XUVHU\-)RU5HV
-DNREVHQ ,$EERWW /. 5REVRQ $' ([WHUQDO K\SKDH RI YHVLFXODUDUEXVFXODU P\FRUUKL]DO IXQJL DVVRFLDWHG ZLWK7ULIROLXP VXEWHUUDQHXP / 6SUHDG RI +\SKDH DQG 3KRVSKRUXVLQ)ORZLQWR5RRWV1HZ3K\WRO .KDGH :6 5RGULJXHV %) 6WXGLHV RQ DUEXVFXODUP\FRUUKLVDWLRQRISDSD\D$IULFDQ &URS6FLHQFH-RXUQDO .LP.<LP:7ULYHGL30DGKDL\DQ0%RUXDK +3' ,VODP 5 /HH * 6D 7 6\QHUJLVWLF HIIHFWV RI ,QRFXODWLQJ$UEXVFXODU 0\FRUUKL]DO )XQJL DQG 0HWK\OREDFWHULXP RU\]DH6WUDLQVRQ*URZWKDQG1XWULHQW8SWDNH RI5HG3HSSHU&DSVLFXPDQQXXP/3ODQW
6RLO
.HPHQWHULDQ .HKXWDQDQ 6WDWLVWLN .DZDVDQ +XDQ 'LUHNWXU -HQGHUDO 3ODQRORJL .HPHQWHULDQ.HKXWDQDQS
.REUD1-DOLO. <RXEHUW*(IIHFWVRI WKUHH*ORPXVVSHFLHV DV ELRFRQWURO DJHQWV DJDLQVW YHUWLFLOOLXPLQGXFHG ZLOW LQ FRWWRQ
-RXUQDO RI 3ODQW 3URWHFWLRQ 5HVHDUFK
/DUVHQ-*UDKDP-+&XEHUR- 5DYQVNRY6 %LRFRQWURO 7UDLWV RI 3ODQW *URZWK 6XSSUHVVLYH $UEXVFXODU 0\FRUUKL]DO )XQJL $JDLQVW 5RRW 5RW LQ 7RPDWR &DXVHG E\ 3\WKLXPDSKDQLGHUPDWXP(XU-3ODQW3DWKRO
JODVVEHDGV0\FRUUKL]D
3OHQFKHWWH&)RUWLQ-$)XUODQ9*URZWK UHVSRQVHV RI VHYHUDO SODQW VSHFLHV WR P\FRU UKL]DH LQ D VRLO RI PRGHUDWH 3)HUWLOLW\ , 0\FRUUKL]DO'HSHQGHQF\8QGHU)LHOG&RQGL WLRQV3ODQWDQG6RLO 6DOO - &UHLJKWRQ / /HKPDQ $ -03 QG 6WDUW6WDWLVWLF $*XLGHWR6WDWLVWLFVDQG'DWD $QDO\VLV8VLQJ-03DQG-03,16RIWZDUH 6HWLDGL<6WDWXVSHQHOLWLDQGDQSHPDQIDDWDQ FHQGDZDQPLNRUL]DDUEXVNXODGDQUKL]RELXP XQWXN PHUHKDELOLWDVL ODKDQ WHUGHJUDGDVL 6HPLQDU1DVLRQDO0LNRUL]D,1RYHP EHU
6LGGLTXL 0+ 1RGXODWLRQ VWXG\ RI D IHZ OHJXPHWUHHVSHFLHVGXULQJVHHGOLQJVWDJH,Q 7UHDF\ 0 DQG %UHZEDNHU - / HGV3URF 1LWURJHQ )L[LQJ 7UHH 5HVHDUFK 5HSRUWV 7KH 1)7$86$
6\DPVXZLGD'7HNQLNSHQJDGDDQEHQLKGDQ ELELW MHQLV NLKLDQJ $OEL]LD SURFHUD %HQWK XQWXNSHQJHPEDQJDQKXWDQUDN\DW3URVLGLQJ VHPLQDU EHQLK XQWXN UDN\DW 0HQJKDVLONDQ GDQ 0HQJJXQDNDQ %HQLK %HUPXWX 6HFDUD 0DQGLUL%RJRU'HVHPEHU
7XUMDPDQ0<7DPDL(6DQWRVR02VDNLDQG. 7DZDUD\D $UEXVFXODU 0\FRUUKL]DO )XQJL ,QFUHDVHG (DUO\ *URZWK RI 7ZR 1RQ 7LPEHU )RUHVW 3URGXFW 6SHFLHV'\HUD SRO\ SK\OODDQG$TXLODULDILODULD8QGHU*UHHQKRXVH &RQGLWLRQV0\FRUUKL]D±
7XUMDPDQ 0 7DPDL < 6LWHSX ,5 6DQWRVR ( 2VDNL07DZDUD\D.,PSURYHPHQW RI HDUO\ JURZWK RI WZR WURSLFDO SHDWVZDPS IRUHVWWUHHVSHFLHV3ORLDULXPDOWHUQLIROLXPDQG &DORSK\OOXP KRVHL E\ 7ZR $UEXVFXODU 0\FRUUKL]DO)XQJL8QGHU*UHHQKRXVH&RQGL WLRQV1HZ)RUHVWV 9DODULQL3-&XUDTXHR*6HJXHO$0DQ]DQR. 5XELR 5 &RUQHMR 3 %RWLH ) (IIHFW RI FRPSRVW DSSOLFDWLRQ RQ VRPH SUR SHUWLHV RI DYROFDQLF VRLO IURP &HQWUDO 6RXWK &KLOH&KLOHDQ-$JULF5HV :KLWPRUH7& 7DQWUD,*07UHHIORUD
RI,QGRQHVLD&KHFN/LVWIRU6XPDWHUD%RJRU )RUHVW5HVHDUFKDQG'HYHORSPHQW&HQWUH :XODQGDUL ' 6DULGL &KHQJ : 7DZDUD\D .
0\FRUUKL]DO FRORQL]DWLRQ HQKDQFHG HDUO\ JURZWK RI 0DOORWXV SDQLFXODWXV DQG $OEL]LDVDPDQXQGHUQXUVHU\FRQGLWLRQVLQ(DVW .DOLPDQWDQ ,QGRQHVLD ,QWHUQDWLRQDO-RXUQDO RI)RUHVWU\5HVHDUFK
