Analisis Putusan Mahkamah Konstitusi Dalam Menyelesaikan Perselisihan Hasil Pemilukada Ditinjau Dari Perspektif Teori Hukum Progresif (Kajian Terhadap Putusan Mk Atas Sengketa Hasil Pemilu Kepala Daerah Jawa Timur Dan Putusan Mk Dalam Perkara Perselisiha

! ! ! "# ! $ % $ $ & % ! $ % # ! $ ! ! $ % $ % % $ ' " " $ ()*)+ ! " # $%%& ' ( ' ! ) ! * + ) ! * + + ) ! , - ! ! ( " " - . ' / + 0 ! '

! " #$$%& ' ( _' " ' " & ) " ' " # " * + ! & " ' & ' ( _& , * ,(- ) ./-#$$% 0 ! " * 1$ " #$$% " (( * #$$% 2 ' ) 3 ) ! " " #$$% & 4 ' & (5 0 #$($ ) (6 * #$($ # _{7 ) , -01 0} -8 -.'% ! & ($ ) #$($ 9 (,:5; 3/ ) (( ) #$($

< )1 _& < < <

< <

' & & &

< ) & = : ( > ! " #$$% " ' #$($ < < ? # > ! " #$$% " ' #$($ ? ) & < & 1 _{< )& # % '" ! / 0 # $ 1! /& 3} 2 ' 7 3 & $1 * #$($ ##:55 ) (6 * #$($

& & &

& & ! & 0

) ) & = 0 < < = 2 - %1 " # % " $ ! ! # % ' ! ! $ % ! $ ! ! $ % $ # 1 & % ())3 % $ # ' " " $ ()*) ! # / # % '" ! / ) ) ! " ) " ' & & ! " #$$%& = > ! " & < < / & ! & (,

* #$$%& ' ' < @ < & = , _{) &} " A$ ##1 = & ' ' < @ < ; ;#6 6,,& ; AA6 ;#( " = 5 ) & #5 - A ) 3 ) ! " " #$$% //& ' & (5 ! #$$% ) ' & ' & 7 > = + ' ' & ' 0 ) ! " & 0 #1 ) = ! " //& , _{2 " & ! " #} ! ! & #$($ & A; ' * ,(- ) ./-#$$% < B# (C 5 _A; A_' * ,(- ) ./-#$$% < B# (C

& & ! " * 1$ " #$$% (( * #$$% 2 ' ) 3 ) ! " " #$$% // 0 & ' ) ! " " #$$% : 7 > 3 > ! " * ( < < / ; A5, ;,# & 7 > 3 > ! " * 5 ) ' & ) ' < @ < ; A1# #%( 7 > 3 > * ( < < / 7 " ) ! " " #$$% // 0 & " 2 ) & & & & ) ; < < & ; _{< B1 1C& B1 ,C& < B1 5C}

0 & & < A$ = ) ! " & & 1$ = % < & " ' & (5 ! #$$% ) ' & ' & 7 > = + ' ' & ' 0 ) ! " & 0 #1 ) = ! " // 0 & / & * ' & #1 * #$$%& 0 = ' = 6 " & <& & < & % _{2 " & 3 ;$&} * ,(- ) ./-#$$% < B5C 6 _{< B1 #,C& < B1 #, (C} < B1 #, ,C

) & = < = #1A7 * (# " #$$% 0 & ) (6,5 & = ) & " 2 < & 4 5 6 <4 ! 5 6 < < & (% , ) (6,5 ) = &

< & & & & &

##D ( )

(6,5 ' =

F

4 7 5 6

' #, ( ) (6,5

& F

F #%) ( ) (6,5

& G' & &

& F ) (6,5 ,5 ( & E ) * 2 / " (6,5 F($ < & ) ) (6,5& ( 1 ) (6,5 ' & & 4 & = & = (( ' , " ' ! & (6 * #$($& 0 * 5%#- 0* -#$($& // ' & ## * #$($ ($ _{< B1 #%C} (( _{< B1 1$C}

* #$6- ) .///-#$($ ) 0 & ' 0 " 7 3 3 3 ) 3 ) " ' " #$($ * 1 ' #($- ) .///-#$($ ) @ ' & & ' = * ' & ' / 7 3 3 3 ) 3 ) " ' " #$($ * ( ) 3 ) " ' & 0= 2 ' ) 3 ) " ' " #$($ (; * #$($& " ' * ,1- - " ' -H/-#$($ ' 7 3 3 3 " ' 3 3 3 " ' " #$($ (; * #$($& " ' * ,,- - " ' -H/-#$($ 7 3 3 3 " 3 3 3 " ' " #$($& (; * #$($(# & 0= "

& & & &

(#_'

< & & < = ' & & 2 & #, 7 ( ($ ( < * #, " #$$1 5 ($A ( # * 1# " #$$, ) * (# " #$$% #6 ( < * ,% " #$$6 (1 &(, (5 / & " ' * ,1- -" ' -H/-#$($ ' 7 3 3 3 " ' 3 3 3 " ' " #$($& (; * #$($ " ' ) 3 ) " ' " ' " ' 7 ) 3 ) & : (1 _{< B1 1C} (, _{< B1 ($C} (5 _{< B5C}

) @ ' & & ' = * ' & ' / I 2 * & ' D ' @ I = ) 0 & ' 0 " I 0 2 = ) & ' & ) ) I ' & & & & " ' & 6$ = ' " & < < < & = < ($A # 1# #$$, 5 (# #$$% , (5 #$$% ) $ = = = ' & < = &

8 & 8 ! ,5 ( & E ) * 2 / " (6,5 F ) #,7 ( ) (6,5 & E & F ) E F E F E F & < & & < &

<

& (A_&

/& " & " &

0 & " / = < 7 & & < ' & " & 7 & 8 & 2"-23 " *- % $ # ! ! # % ' ! ! $ % ! $ ! ! $ % $ # 1 & % ())3 % $ # ' " " $ ()*) = & & / & = ' . ! &(; = < ' = < & (A _{< B1 1(C} (; _{. & # %&&'( 4 /*/} 8D 0>0 4 /*/ $6-(#-#$$% ) (6 * #$($

;; * #, " #$$1 & & * (5 " #$$% = ' & , & (1 1 3 &(% _{;5 *} #1 " #$$1 & : ( I # ) & ! " = ;5 ;5 & = < = & = ! & // ) 2 ' & ,, " #$$; #$$6 #11 * (% _{3 ) ! (5& #$($} 0 ) " : 3 & ) (6 * #$($

(# #$$% * 1#-#$$, ) & ) #$$% (6 = " ' & " ' ' ) * ! = ' & = ! & = = & #$ ) & 0 / > 0 = E' ) :

F& * & ! &

! A0 #$($& & ' ## #$$; & + & (6 _{8 = ' & ' ! ) =} ) * ' &$A-(#-#$$%$,:5$3/ ) #% ) #$($ #$

& * = #( ) & ! & " ' " ' (5 0 ' ) 2) ! J ) 2) ) = 2 ,$ ## " ' & : & & < #1 _{) " & / = &} ) #(_{" = 2 ! K & $A} 0 #$($ 9 ((:16 3/ "D 4 -/ <-& ! ) #% ) #$($ ##_{8 = ' 3} #1 _{4 0' = / : " & ' & < 4 /*/} 0 ' 9 (5 ) = #$($ 9 #1:55 " 2 5# " 7 # = )

6$ & ) #, (- $ ! ! %1 " # % " $ ! ! # % ' ! ! $ % ! $ ! ! $ % $ # 1 & % ())3 % $ # ' " " $ ()*) ! # / # % '" ! / ) ! " & & < "

& & & = &

& ' = & & & ' <& = = #5 _& ! " = & & < & ! " < ) < #,_{7 ) 3} #5 _{2 " &3 ;A}

= 5 & & #A _' < ' 2 & 0 2 < #; _: ( # < < < & < 1 ) < & & ' = & & * < = & = < = = = & ) *2/ (6,5 " #A_{' 2 & ! " ) &} ! <& ) / *)/ . # * (-0 #$$5& (6 #; _{0 2 < & "} ! " ! &#$($ ,A

= < ' 2/& < )& <& #% ) & #,7 ( ) (6,5 & E & F ) & ) *2/ (6,5 & )& #6 EL 5 8 8 119 : 5 8 8 119 : ; &% _! ) #%_{0 7 * + !} ! ' 0'/ J 3>. // * (& ! #$$6& (1( #6 _{< )& & ,! ! - ! " #} ! ! & #$($ & (, 1$_{8 #( * #, #$$1 "}

&

) (6,5&1(

(% , ) (6,5

) = &

< &

& & & &

##D ( ) (6,5 #%) ( ) (6,5 & G' & & & F ) < & & <& & 0 & -& -1# _* " 2 ! 1(_{8 ( # 1 ) *} 2 / (6,5 1# _{8 (1 * (5 " #$$% "} = ) ) 2 /

) ,5 ( ) * 2 / " (6,5 ' <& 11 = E 7 5 < & 5 < 5 & < < 0 7 & E) @ D &F E) F / & < 1, ' 5 ( * ,% " #$$6 & & '

11_{' 2 & ! " ! &#$$A & 5A}

15 & < & = ' < 1A 0 2 < &< = 5 5 >; &? ₎ < < & & < & & !

< 4 6& & &

1% _{) <} <& " 16 4- $ ! ! % $ # ! ! # % ' ! ! $ % ! $ ! ! $ % $ # 1 & % 15_{0 2 < &3 #;}

1A _{0 2 < & 3 ,;& & ' "}

* , " #$$,& 0 2/& ! & #$$5& #$6

1; _%A

1% _.//

())3 % $ # ' " " $ ()*) = ) ! " & < = & < ' = ) ! " & ) ) * (# " #$$% ) & ) ($A # 1# #$$,5 (# " #$$% , (5 " #$$% ' , * (5 " #$$% 4 " : 7 I 7 * & ' 0&

' = < & ! " * & = ' ! = & & = ;A 5 ;%5 %$ * ## " #$$; ' ($1 * 1# " #$$, ) & " ' : = I = I = = & & & = I I

-&,$ " ' ($5 1# #$$,& " ' & = = * ' & =

& & < &

< 0 & ) ! ) " ) & E F < * ## #$$;& & ,$ _($,

' J < @-; ,( & & - & & = ' = & J &

& & ) "&

& & &

E F E F& < & <& & = < ,# 4 & ' &

,(_{0 J &%.&/ ! & #$($ &}

A#

' & J & -& ,1 < < &,, ) ! " & 0 ! < * 6 0& ) 2 = & = < & ) @ 5 * #$$6 & < ! & = & & ,1 _{A1 A,} ,,_{8 #, 7 ) 2 / " (65,&} ) ($ ( * #, " #$$1 "

& =

& & &

,5 _' & ,A ' & ! " & & (% , ) (6,5 = & = & & & = ,; & - & / = & & < & ! #$$% " ' #$($ ,5_{2 " &3 (,% (,6} ,A _#(1 ,; _{2 & = &} ) ) %& #$$% 0 ) ' : ! & , ) #$$% ) #% ) #$($

= ' & ) ! ) *2/ (6,5 0-& : ) ) ! " #$$% " ' #$($ < <& ! " & & < = ) = ! " -& & & =

& & & & &

-< )

) *2/ (6,5 #

& & <&

) * < 0 & ! #$$% " #$($ = & E8 ! F& = = ' & < & & < < * 6 & < &

& : ( " & & = & / = # " & < & ' / = 1 0 ! 8 & = ) *2/ (6,5 2 * '

= & & <&

0 & @ #$$$ " ! ( : 0 & 2 " #$($ ! " # ! ! : " 2 > < ) " & #$$A ! ! ! : " 2 > < ) #$$% "! 0 + ( ! : = J & 0 #$$5 1 : #$$A ! ! ! : #$($ %.&/ ! : / " 8 & ' (661 + ! : 8 < & < #$($ * + ! 2 ! ( ! : // 2/ #$($ 3 1 + ! 4'56 3 + ! 1! ! %5 %&&. ! ! : ' !

< )& & #$($ ,! ! - ! " # ! ! ( : & 0 ' $%%& ! * ! $ ! ! + ! ! ( : * 7 2 & ' #$$A ! " ! : " * #$($ ! " ! : " * 2 < & 0 #$($ " ! "(! : ' > < ' #$$6 + * + ! ( ) ' 0 (661 # 3# (@ : " 7 0 ' & $%% , 7 * 8 ! (@ : // ' & #$$$ ) 9 " :! ! + ! ( @ : " " 3 = @ 3 & (6%A + ! # ! : 2 $5 $ # % 6 0 7 * + ! ! ' 0'/ J 3>. // * (& ! #$$6

J & 0 N * ! $ . " HH. * #6; 0 #$($ = &+ ! 1 7 ! 7 ! . " HH. * #%% * #$$6 & ! 8 * 0 ) $ . " HH/. * #%# #$$6 2 & ' ! " ) & ! <& ) / *)/ . # * (-0 #$$5 ' & ! 8 # . " HH. * #61 0 #$($ " & < 0 7 7 * ! . " HH. * #6% ' #$($ 3 & D 8 " %&&' . " HH/. * #%, ! #$$6 6 ) & 7 # # # $# $ "- 8 -.'% ! & ($ ) #$($ 9 (,:5; 3/ ) (( ) #$($

& / $ $% ! #$($ 9 (,:5, 9 ) (6 * #$($ ! & . # %&&'( 4 /*/ 8D 0>0 4 /*/ $6-(#-#$$% ) (6 * #$($ < ) ! " , ' < 3 2 ' 7 3 & $1 * #$($ ##:55 ) (6 * #$($ O & ! "; " ! ! + ! 1 * #$($ * & 2 = @ ! " + ! & /*)D D*)D*"& < = = - = = &D : = = & = & < = = > :207 0) @ 8/0)/ *0'/2 & > :> J = " ) 0 & > :> J = ( $$$ $$$ 4 . * ' 0= 1 * #$($ & 2 = & ) ) %& #$$% 0 ) ' : ! & , ) #$$% ) #% ) #$($ * ,(- ) ./-#$$% 0 ! " * 1$ " #$$% " (( * #$$% 2 ' ) 3 ) ! " " #$$%

* #$6 #($- ) .///-#$($ ) 3 ) " ' " #$($& ' & 8 = *! 9 ) * ' &$A-(#-#$$%$,:5$3/ ) #% ) #$($

' & 0 & / : " & ' & <

4 0' = 4 /*/ 9 (5 ) = #$($ 9 #1:55 " 2 5# " 7 # = ) #% ) #$($ " = 2 ! K & $A 0 #$($ 9 ((:16 3/ "D 4 -/ <-& ! ) #% ) #$($ & & 4 ' & (5 0 #$($ ) (6 * #$($ 3 & 0 ) ! (5& #$($ 0 ) " : 3 & ) (6 * #$($ "7 " ) * 2 / " (6,5 2 / & & * #, " #$$1& 8* " #$$1 * 6%& "8* * ,1(A

2 / & & * ,% " #$$6& 8* " #$$6 * (5;& "8* * 5$;A 2 / & & * ## " #$$;& 8* " #$$; * 56& "8* * ,;#( 2 / & * (# " #$$% " * 1# " #$$, " ) 8* " #$$% * 56& "8* * ,%,, * (5 " #$$% " = ) ) 2 /