• Tidak ada hasil yang ditemukan

Central Bank Independence and the Centra

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2018

Membagikan "Central Bank Independence and the Centra"

Copied!
26
0
0

Teks penuh

(1)

ĐE’s ! ! "#$%&' #

ı

(

!

" " "

# !

!

# ! "

! "

# $ " ! "

% &

# "

" " #

! "

#

"

! ! "

!

$

%& ' () *

! !

+ , - *.#/ 0 1 2 1

- 3

++ - 1 *.#/ 0 1 2 1

(2)

'( Đ)* & " + 45

- !

!

%& )6

%7 4')6

% 5 ) #

8

!

!

# #

6 $

# 8

- !

# !

! !

" * !

!

! !

" $ !

8 7 $ 0 ,

+ ) , -./012! !

- $

! $

! ! !

$ ! 9

!: !

! # !

! ; ! 1 * ! !

:

9 *

!

%, 4< 4(46

= " : ' >< >() # ! $

(3)

% % & 4

!

! !

! ! !

7

" #

#

$

%

&'(

!(()*

#

#

+ * ' < A4

2 < 0 6 * < 6 * < 6 .&<

#

# !

9 #

$ B

B !

-!

! ! *

6

! !

# !

(4)

'( Đ)* & " +

2 $

! , : $8 "

# !

! !

! ! 0

" " 6

!

6 $

!

! ! % $ 4< 55"5 )

-$ ? ! @ % 4<

5 ) & "

$

: !

8

!

B 9 !

E $

!

# "

#

! - C 8 C !

B

* $ &

E ! !

$ !

%C ' (< A )

C $ 8 !

! !

! & ! !

! $ C

-

%-' 5) "C

! $

! $

(5)

% % &

!

$

6

? @ !

# !

#

! $ E !

, #

,

# !

#

1 2

$ ; ! *

1 2

$ "

E !

- 1 !

$ 9 "

# 2

:

" ! $

%- " 0 ' < " 5) # $

! B 9

2

$ $

! !

" %C < (5"4 )

1 2

2 "

%F ' < > 4)

# 1

2

" !

1 - ? "

@

%# ' >< A5("A5 )

(6)

'( Đ)* & " + '

? @ 1

$

!

& % ) ? @

! ! "! % 0

/ 2 )

"! % ,

/ 2 ) #

!

! !

B ?

G@

%- 5 < 5() !

! "!

%- H ' < A ) !

#

! ; ! * !

, .$ 2 #

= 8

"

! # !

$ !

$ $

B

-; !

* "

$

% ' (< A5A6

I ' (< A>) # ! ! !

8

6

!

" %: ' < 4 ))

) ; ! * 9 !

(7)

% % & A

- " ! !

= " 1 % ) " C % 5A)

$ ; ! *

"

" # B

8 !

$ ! " %= "

: 5< 4" ) # "

$ %* 5< A)

# 1

!

$ 7 !

? @ %, 5() ?

@ %: () ,

!

#

$ %= " : 5< " )

: !

J ! J

! 8

!

E %: (< ( ) #

9

" "

!

%* (< ' ) # !

! !

! !

#

! 8

! " "

! $ 8

: $ !

! 6 , 1

(8)

'( Đ)* & " + >

! !

-! # !

!

%7 (< ' ') I ! 8

!

#

: !

! ! <!

! "

E

%C < A45"A4 )

-<

! %. E "

0 & 4)

!

! .

! %

'< A4 )

# !

! #

!

%- " 2 A6 0 & " 2 ')

!

! %

'< >A )

%# : ' '< >) #

!

! #

$ %

! ) ! "! !

(9)

% % & (

#

!

! 7 !

( #

E $

!

! 9

* !

E

! ! B

B ! $

# 9

! !

% " I < '6 * 5< > )

-!

! %C

) # !

! , 8 % 5()

#

! ! # !

!

K 8 % "

I < ')

# !

# !

! $

!

! #

!

6 ! E 6

(10)

'( Đ)* & " + 4

6 ! !

# ! 7

! 9

<

%0 ". ' < '4"'5)

! ! !

* 8 $

%* 5< )

#

0

7 $

C ; ! L ! !

E ! E

.

! 6 " "

! 6

6 . M - ,

. 1 * .

E .

1 6 B

* # %0 & ' (< " A) !

1

$

$

E

6 E 6

6

1 8

E !

/ !

9

#

- !

$

(11)

% % &

!

"

%- 5 < 5A) #

!

-? @ $

E $

%2! " < >' ) #

! "

" 6

# ! $ $

8

7 $ ' 5"'

! #

"

-% ! ) !

9 !

-$ !

8

-.

#

! ! !

!

2 !

!

(12)

'( Đ)* & " + 5

2 /

! !

9

, # !

! #

!

# !

7 : : !

E !

! ! !

!J ! # !

% >< "

) :

. % " I

< 4 ) "ı ı"

54A ! ! E ! . 7

. # . 8

!

! ! %= 9 ' < >A">>6

# "Đ < ( )

# ! ! : : ' !

? @ !

C 2 2 %1 ' < '4"'5)

! 8 B

! ! !

%# " Đ < '>')

: $ ! !

2

# , #

, # % ,#) ! N

A $

! # ,# ! !

E ! 2 #D 8 ! ?!

! $ @

- ,# !

%I ! ; ( - AJ )

! $ ! C

2 !

? J @ 2 : :

(13)

% % &

# : ! ! / 2

& >( ! /2 !

7 $ E $ !

/2 ! ! # /

2 ! 9 !

* 7 !

: E

! 8 ! # ! ! !

9

= !

%0 ' < ( ) . !

= !

9 ! # E

! $ ! !

% >< '>) #

4

! ! ? ! @

! 6 !

! ! ? @

% ' < 5" '>) ! > N

,# !

!

? ! !

@ I ! ; ' - >J ) $

,# $

8 %= 9

' < 45" A)

: !

" / 2 8 "

O : C 7

$ $

$ "

: ! !

$

6

-!

! #

9 ! ! $

%- H ' < ('6 " I < >) #

(14)

'( Đ)* & " + 5

E

- :

?

9 $

@ %#

: ' (< ) #

E !

B !

! <

3 " ! 4

$ # " !

4

" $ # "

+ # "

! $

! # #

! "

" - ! 05567 8/2

#

$ !

! %2 "7 ' (< 4)

5 / 2

E ! "

!

%& ' (< ) ! 2 C %' )

#

! 8

# ? @

*7 ! ! :

$ 9

%: A< AA'" AAA) #

?:

(15)

% % & 5

N 5 ! 6 !

! < $ !

$ 6

! M8 !

E ! ?

"P" 9 @ %' < >5)

# E

# " 9

E

$ : 1 "

: % 1: )

! ! 6

?

@ 9 %2 9 56 & ' 4<

>A ) #

- $ % 4< A5)

!

" !

-!

#

%C (< > ) 7 C ?

@

%' (< 5 ) # ! 9

! !

!

? @

$

2

? 2 @ !

#

#

(16)

'( Đ)* & " + 5'

# 9

! 9 2 C %' )

? ! @

# E ? @ 8

!

E

#

! !

"

% . )6 "

!

2 # %' ')

# E

! !

*

? 9 @

! %# ' '< ') !

! *

6 !

6 !

! B

# !

! 2 (

-> !

# ! ' - >

*7 % ı ' < > )

,# !

.

*7 / !

E ,# ! 6 !

6 ,# ! $

!

# 8 ! . / *7

(17)

% % & 5A

% ı ' < (5>"(5(6 #D ' < >)/# 9

./ & 2 0

* #

-*7 0 '

,# ! !

! ,# ! & ! !

7 ' !

= 0 :

! ! # B 1 * D

.

?9 # # ) 7 :

+ # @ ! = 0

!

$ ! ? ( ! (

0 @ # ! !

1 ": E

? 6

@ %2

# . 1 ' < ') 0 8

#

# . ! ! <

;

" <

( !

# .==5 + !

# # # " !

# ! # #

! # <

#

# # "

" # -( ! 05567 .512

0 8 !

$

"

0 "

? @ &

/ : ; "C # ? @ !

" % " ' < ''5"'A ) #

$ ! *7

: . / !

! ! ! #

!

- ! ,#

(18)

-'( Đ)* & " + 5>

"

# !

!

! $

! 7 1 !

? @ !

"

! ! ,# !

I ! '( - ' #

E ,# ! ?

@6 ! 9 ! !

E ! %I ! ; >4( - >) #

- ,# " # !

6 # * 1 !

,# !

# ,#

9 < # ,# I !

,# * !

!

1 C ;

-# * $

,# !

! !

-' 4 ,# $

"

& ! $ '

! $ !

! %# * ' 4< ' "'A)

# ,#8 '

!

# %. ğ "

- ' () " %#D ' 6 ı

' ) #

,# !

!

% )

,# !

(19)

% % & 5(

/ # ./

,#

! >

% ' ) 2

,#

B %- "

0 ' )

8 ,#

! %F ' ()

! ! $

%- H ' )

,# '

!

! !

0

! ' #

,# $

%0 ğ " 0 ğ ' (< ' A) & ! #

5 ! ! ,#

! !

0

% ! ' 56 = ' 5)

(20)

'( Đ)* & " + 54

!0 "

1

-

1

223 224 22' 22& 222 !((( !(( !((! !(() !((/ !((3

C ! ,

%C;1) 5 5 A A "4 4 A " ( ( 4

,

%:1 ) 4 5 4 45 5 A 45 ( ' 5 > A

/

, 4 4 4 4 5 4 4 ( 5 > A ( A A

) ( % & ? 9 ! 9+' ? 9

- # 8

! #

!

- , #

$ !

. !

! 4"

'

! ! "

!

"'

# ! "

! $

!

! !

$

- $

9 ? J !

$ @ ! 9

"

# ,# !

7 !

F

6

! !

% ' 5)

! ' ' ' 4

!

(21)

% % & 5

, +

" 6

! 2

:

$ ,#

- C 2

!

!

# , # !

C 2

,# ? @

# ,# I ! ! ! !

:

! ! !

8 $ 5 !

! #

2 8

! $

#

! 8

$ ; !

*

8 B

$ $ ? @

2

1 2

" & !

"

$ # $

! '

& ! !

(22)

'( Đ)* & " + 55

! ,#8

! 2

! ? @

B

!

! 6

9 K @

" $

! $ ,#8

! !

!

-"- - -+

- H Q %' ) + ! ! ( 7 @ ı

ğı ı ı ı ) + ğ 2 - ı O ı

Đ

- " 0 0 %' ) ?1 0D9 1

- @ A Đ ( # 2 ı ; < '

- - % 5 ) ?1

0 @ ) + O 5 ((" 5

- - " 2 I ! & % A) ?

* 1 < 2

. @ B @ ! % # O '( ( " 4'

- - N %. ) %' 5) C ! + ) !

& 7 @ + , ) 1

* ; ! F

, . %' () ?# , 7 * . <

. , 2 @ * 2 C "

1 %. ) & C D )

# 9 E F8 D +

) 0 / 1 0 A(("A '

ğı ı9 2 %' 5) 055/ A ğı 7 9

F = Đ

- ! %' 4) C 9 7 G @ ! %

C G C , I

ı %' ) @ 7 % @

ı H ı A ı ı Đ Q

(23)

% % & 5

ı %' ) ?1 . <

* " C , @ C 7

B + ! O ''

; < > ( "(

, N " C 0 % 5A) ?, 0 ,

* * 1 @ B @ ) O '

; < " '

= %' ) Đ 7 .=5/ 055I - Đ

=

N * % 5 ) ?# . 1 @

) & " O ; < A '>A"'(

. %' 5) ?FD 7 9 R 0 FD 7 9 0 ğ @

<JJ J J $G S 545 T 9 S'

4 % ' ' )

7 " C " 7 2 " 2 ;

% >) 9 ) #

/ 1

, # %' 4) ) D

#D * 9 ı

-$ , : % 4) " /

1

- $ " : 2 " ; ı % ') ?*

. 1 @

? ) & " O 4 ; < A A(A"A 5

0 & N " . E 2 : " : 2 %' ()

) % 7 % ! %

# * # 1

0 = " - 2 " ı F %' 4) A Jı ı J ğ

9 ( 7 A ( ı 0 ğ = Đ

0 1 %' ) ? 8 2 ı< . . 1 ğ

2 0 = 9 @ ğ - " -ğ = %. ) 0.

ı A + * ' 7 9 + 4 ' +

) Đ F ı ı Đ ( " 4

0 ; 9 ; " . %' ) ? # <

: : : : . G@, )& ? # + ; A A

"(

0 ğ 7 " 0 ğ 2 %' () * )

#D * 9 ı

-0D ı %' ') ? ( & 05507 #

@ $ / 1 ; ! F

0D ı %' () ? ( & 055I7

% ) $ / 1 ; ! F

. E 2 : " 0 & N % 4) + )

% 9 +

(24)

'( Đ)* & " +

. ğ ; " - - %' () ? :; ğı ı9ı U HD

# * 8 / ı@ ( ğ ( # 4 ; < "

7 2 % () ? " , @

) & " O 5( ; < ' ' "' 4

7 * % 4') ?2 # - *

- @ F I %. ) 9 ' @

% & / 1 ' "'>A

C 2 % () ?C * 0

; @ B 9 O '> ; < A A "

>'A

C 2 %' ) % C % #

: 1 1 2 -

-8 2 # ğ I

-C - %' () 9 + ,

C V & " C ; 2 %. ) I < I ! :

C O 0 " * 0 " # C % ) ?1

* 1 7 1 9

@ ) + O A A> "A '

C * 2 % ) ?# ; ! 1 . < 1 .

; 1 @ C * 2 %. ) + +

@ # ( # % 7 + , " +

) 2 7 2 1 > "4

CD D - %' A) ?FW < #D Đ 2 @ +

A" 4

CD9 ı 2 %' >) ?= FW 0 F =

Đ ğ FW F ı ı@ U = " U D W D

/ğ %. ) A K C C 9 ı Đ E F ı

- 5(" A

& 0 %' () D , $ /

1 $

& 7 - % ) ( @ L #

& 7 + %

% # . - I

& 0 - % ) ?1 1 * 1 @

+ 9 & " O ; < > >4 " >5

& , %' 4) ? C 9 < # $

; @ = ! 7 " * . ! 0

%. ) ' # C C &

1 ; ! F >'4">>A

<JJ!!! J " " J J "' " " ""

A4> ' )

*7 I %' )

(25)

% % &

! ! 7 C ,# N ' 5

-* " I % ) + ) @

G I *

= 9 & " U9 D * " = D * %' )

% @ ı Đ F ı ı ı

= = O " : 7 O %' >) ?KC 8

! < "

@

) B + & O >A ; < ' >A"

= 7 " : & % 5) ?

< @ ( #

O '(( "(A

= . %' 5) ?1 ı ı9 ı @

<JJ J

J $G S '(A T 9 S % ' ' )

= 7 . " 1 . ! % ) ?, , 0 <

# 1 @ B + ) O

5( ; < A > A">

I %' () ?* . ; . @

2 "7 - X N 0 %. ) , %

& 1 1 I A ">

* C % 5) ?* <

E B @ '$ ) + O (

; < A >45"> '

* * %' ) ? , - : <

; - - C @ # X I 1 %. )

# , " + @ # 7 +

9 & - - A(" (A

* # % () ?#! 7 "

@ ) & " O 5( ; < ' ' "

'

* 7 2 % 5) ? 0 2 <

# @

<JJ!!! J J J

107 J0.* ,-# 5L % ' ' )

; : 0 % () ?# 1 @ & "

) 9 O >' ; < ' 4 "

1 = %' ) C 7 + )

' # ' 1

, , - : % 4) ?# ; ! C < C !

C @ + 9 O >> ; < > 4('"44

, 0 % 4') ? % ( &

(26)

'( Đ)* & " + '

, = % 5() ?# 0

* # @ M B )

O ; < > 4 " 5

2 "7 - %' () ?7 : 1 ":

< ; - . 0 @ 2 "7

- X N 0 %. ) , % &

1 1 I A"

2 9 N . % 5) ?@ # 7 @ #

" ? # @ 5 : 0.,

-I 8 2 # ğ &

2 # . < # 8 # 1

<JJ!!! J J J" Y J

%' ' )

2! * " " * % ) ?

7 @ 0 ! 1 " O 9"

L , 9 %. ) ) # & %

* 7 : > >">>>

CD " U %' ) ?/ W = 9 < 2

0 / W #D 8 / W # @

+ "'>

# # %' ') . . .$ 1 < .$ .

1 0 0 L I

# Đ "Đ 2 % ) + A 9 '

7 % @ ı #D

* 9 ı

-# 7 %' >) + Đ + ı Đ E F ı

-#D %' ) ?# * 9 ı8 F F R H < >4( 2 ı ı

= Q9 CW9 0 ğ @ @ '( ; < ''

"54

: . % () ? @

) & " O 5( ; < ( " 4

: * ! %' ) + ) %

@ 1 * ; ! F

: N % A) ?0 K: 8@

? ( O ' ; < 5 A5 "> '

F C %' 4) ?= 9 0 < = & @ Q

" - H Đ %. ) Đ ! 9 ! ( ı 7 +

( A 9 ı ı* ğ ğ F ı ı Đ A(">5

F C %' ) ?. # 2 K.

8< , "2 - .$ @ @) H 9

( O A> ; < ' A5 "> '

F . H %' () ?@ ı* ı N ğı ı ığı*O

Referensi

Dokumen terkait

b be mc4kd 4 ft Dajor prebtns. fudioi]4 .l bdiig syscns, si nd

Monthly disposable income (February 2009) ISK mortgage debt. Foreign currency-denominated mortgage debt Mixed

Siddiqi suggests several-innovative tools which would enable central banks to control and regulate commercial banks operating on an interest free basis. In order to control

Thus, the first hypothesis is proposed as follows: H1A: The mean rate of inflation in a country i and time t is higher, the lower Independence of its Central Bank the higher δ, recall

Apparently, the result shows that central bank independence has negative and significant effect on inflation rate for countries adopting full democracy, but has insignificant effect on

Sebaliknya, saat g dan e sama dengan nol, maka bank sentral akan memiliki preferensi yang sama dengabn preferensi pemerintah dalam hal pengurangan inflasi; dan ini mengimplikasikan

Specifically, our analysis suggests that central bank independence improves inflation performance because the optimal divergence between the weights that the government and the central

Moreover, financial asset prices have an essential role in monetary policy transmission to the extent that a change in CBI affects the exchange rate, bond yield, stock price, thereby