Problematika Normatif Pengadilan Hak Asasi Manusia sebagai Upaya Hukum untuk Perlindungan Hak Asasi Manusia di Indonesia.

Teks penuh

(1)

F=?!% !(F!% D?(-! =!(!!! !(9 ! F=?!% !(F!% D?(-! =!(!!! !(9 ! F=?!% !(F!% D?(-! =!(!!! !(9 !

F=?!% !(F!% D?(-! =!(!!! !(9 !?!-! 9!+!?!-! 9!+!?!-! 9!+!?!-! 9!+! 999(%9?= (9(-!(!!! !(9 ! (F(? !

999(%9?= (9(-!(!!! !(9 ! (F(? !999(%9?= (9(-!(!!! !(9 ! (F(? ! 999(%9?= (9(-!(!!! !(9 ! (F(? !

F FF F

"!3!6 "!3!6 "!3!6 "!3!6 H

H H

H ? 3&>:,2 *: ? 3&>:,2 *: ? 3&>:,2 *: ? 3&>:,2 *:7777 *>6)36#

*>6)36# *>6)36#

*>6)36#777736363636 !

! !

! ! 3&>':6 ! 3&>':6 ! 3&>':6

! 3&>':6 1 1 1 1 (

( (

( 1 11 1 11 1 11 1 11 ! (

! ( ! (

! (7777 # # # # " " " " 11

11 11

11 ! 1 ! 1 ! 1 ! 1 1 " ( ! 1 " ( ! 1 " ( ! 1 " ( ! 1 3 1 3 1 3 1 3 %*,,42**6

%*,,42**6 %*,,42**6

%*,,42**6 #"#"#"#" "1 ! ( 1 "1 ! ( 1 "1 ! ( 1 "1 ! ( 1 "1 1 ! "1 1 ! "1 1 ! "1 1 ! 3*,,*E);5

3*,,*E);5 3*,,*E);5

3*,,*E);57777);:6 );:6 );:6 );:6 !!!! ) 36 38 *,,&2 &;46

) 36 38 *,,&2 &;46 ) 36 38 *,,&2 &;46

) 36 38 *,,&2 &;46 1"

1" 1"

1" "!"!"!"! 1

1 1

1 1"(!1"(!1"(!1"(!

" ( "1 " ( "1 " ( "1 " ( "1 1!

1! 1!

1! %3*,,42*)6 %3*,,42*)6 %3*,,42*)6 %3*,,42*)6 "1 "1 "1 "1 # # # #

"1( "1( "1( "1( "1

"1 "1 "1

1 ! 3*,,)2 )56 " 1 ! 3*,,)2 )56 " 1 ! 3*,,)2 )56 " 1 ! 3*,,)2 )56 " (

( (

(7777 ! ! ! ! ( ( ( ( !

! !

!

(!3*,,&2;6 (!3*,,&2;6 (!3*,,&2;6 (!3*,,&2;6 (

( (

(7777

(2)
(3)

% % % % !O

!O !O

!O & 4 & 4 & 4 & 4 99( )>%&>>>!"! 99( )>%&>>>!"! 99( )>%&>>>!"! 99( )>%&>>>!"! ( ( ( ( 1 1 # " 1 1 # " 1 1 # " 1 1 # "

# # # # 1

1 1

17777""""

! # ! # ! # ! # # 1 # 1 # 1 # 1 ( F ! ( F ! ( F ! ( F !

( !( !( !( ! !1( !1( !1( !1( ( 1 # ( 1 # ( 1 # ( 1 # "

" "

" 31&>>52',

31&>>52', 31&>>52', 31&>>52',7777'&6 '&6 '&6 '&6

" 3 " 3 " 3

" 36 1 36 1 36 1 36 1 36 6 6 6

7777 " " " 7777 # " # # #

#

# #

# !1

!1 !1

!11111 1

1 1

17777 " " " "

7777 C C C C

7777 " # " # " # " #7777# # # # F

F F

F 7777 # # # # 38 38 38 38 *,,&2&:&6

*,,&2&:&6 *,,&2&:&6 *,,&2&:&6

!1" !1" !1" !1" !

! !

! 99 ( )> % &>>> 99 ( )> % &>>> 99 ( )> % &>>> 99 ( )> % &>>> 1" ! 1" ! 1" ! 1" ! 1 # !

1 # ! 1 # !

1 # !# # # # "1

"1 "1

"1 ! ( ! ( ! ( ! ( 1" ! ( 1" ! ( 1" ! ( 1" ! ( &499( )>%&>>>

&499( )>%&>>> &499( )>%&>>>

&499( )>%&>>>1A1A1A1A (11U A (11U A (11U A (11U A

! ! ! ! 3

3 3

3####6 1 36 1 36 1 36 1 36 6 6 6 ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( !(11( !(11( !(11( !(11( " 1 " 1 " 1 " 1 1 !

1 ! 1 !

1 ! 7777 3 3 3 36 6 6 6 !1

!1 !1 !1

!9

(4)

! 99 ( *4 % *,,, ! 99 ( *4 % *,,, ! 99 ( *4 % *,,, ! 99 ( *4 % *,,, !! !! !! !! 13'11

13'11 13'11

13'11 5555 : >6 &,' 99 ( )> % &>>> : >6 &,' 99 ( )> % &>>> : >6 &,' 99 ( )> % &>>> : >6 &,' 99 ( )> % &>>> ! 1 # ! 1 # ! 1 # ! 1 #

7777 ! 1 ! 1 ! 1 ! 1

! ! ! 7777! @1 A

@1 A @1 A @1 A

> 99 ( *4 % *,,, " > 99 ( *4 % *,,, " > 99 ( *4 % *,,, " > 99 ( *4 % *,,, " 1 1 1 1 " " " " 1 # 1 1 # 1 1 # 1 1 # 1 "1

"1 "1

"1777712121212 E

E E E E E E E # EEEE

#E #E #E #E

# # # # "

" "

"7777" 3" 3" 3" 377776 6 6 6 E

E E E E E E E

# # # # # # # #

7777 E

E E E

1111

# # # # E

E E E

#E #E #E #E 1 1 1 1 1

" " "

"1111 1

1 1

177771>1>1>1> 199( *4%*,,, 199( *4%*,,, 199( *4%*,,, 199( *4%*,,,

1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1

1 1 1

1 1 1 1 !1 !1 !1 !1

"! "! "! "! (((( !1

!1 !1

!1 81818181 1# 1# 1# 1# ! ! ! ! 8 8 8 8 !#" !#" !#" !#" 1 1 1 1 !

(5)

% 3*,,42 4' % 3*,,42 4' % 3*,,42 4' % 3*,,42 4'77774;6 4;6 4;6 4;6 !##1 !##1 !##1 !##1 ! ! ! !

1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1

1 1

1 99997777 !1!

!1! !1!

!1! 1111

99 ( *4%*,,, 99 ( *4%*,,, 99 ( *4%*,,, 99 ( *4%*,,,

7777 # " # " # " # " !1! !1! !1! !1!

899( *4%*,,, 899( *4%*,,, 899( *4%*,,, 899( *4%*,,, ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! 1

1 1

1 " " " "

7777 @ A 1 @ A 1 @ A 1 @ A 1 1

1 1

1#! #! #! #! !!!! #!99( *4%*,,,

#!99( *4%*,,, #!99( *4%*,,, #!99( *4%*,,,

1 1 " 1 1 " 1 1 " 1 1 " !1

!1 !1

!1

" 1 !

" 1 ! " 1 !

" 1 ! # # # #

1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 99( *4%*,,,

99( *4%*,,, 99( *4%*,,, 99( *4%*,,,

99( *4%*,,, 99( *4%*,,, 99( *4%*,,, 99( *4%*,,, 99( )>%&>>>

99( )>%&>>> 99( )>%&>>>

99( )>%&>>>!!!! ! 1 ! 1 ! 1 ! 1 !

! !

! !"&,

!"&, !"&,

!"&,'3&699( )>%'3&699( )>%'3&699( )>%'3&699( )>% &>>> 1 99( *4% &>>> 1 99( *4% &>>> 1 99( *4% &>>> 1 99( *4% *,,,

*,,, *,,,

*,,, %10&,'99( %10&,'99( %10&,'99( %10&,'99( )>%&>>>'5:>99( *4

)>%&>>>'5:>99( *4 )>%&>>>'5:>99( *4

)>%&>>>'5:>99( *4%*,,, %*,,, %*,,, %*,,,

1# (!% 1# (!% 1# (!% 1# (!% # D 3%D6

# D 3%D6 # D 3%D6

# D 3%D6 " " " " ! 99 ( *4 % *,,, 1 ! 99 ( *4 % *,,, 1 ! 99 ( *4 % *,,, 1 ! 99 ( *4 % *,,, 1 "&'8*,,&.!1&,'99( )> "&'8*,,&.!1&,'99( )> "&'8*,,&.!1&,'99( )> "&'8*,,&.!1&,'99( )> % &>>> % 1 !

% &>>> % 1 ! % &>>> % 1 !

% &>>> % 1 ! ! 1 ! 1 ! 1 ! 1 ( ! 1 ( ! 1 ( ! 1 ( ! 1 ! &,' 99 ( )> % &>>>O ! &,' 99 ( )> % &>>>O ! &,' 99 ( )> % &>>>O ! &,' 99 ( )> % &>>>O

( ! % ( ! % ( ! % ( ! % !1 !1 !1 !1

! ! ! !

'4 99 ( *4 *,,, " '4 99 ( *4 *,,, " '4 99 ( *4 *,,, " '4 99 ( *4 *,,, " !"

!" !"

!" 7777

(6)

1 1 1

1 9

9 9

977779 396 " 9 396 " 9 396 " 9 396 " 5:3&69""2 5:3&69""2 5:3&69""2 5:3&69""2

& 1#&36E1#&36E1#&36E1#&36E * 1 # 1 ) 1 # 1 ) 1 # 1 ) 1 # 1 )

36436E 36436E 36436E 36436E

) 1 # ) 36 &* 1 # ) 36 &* 1 # ) 36 &* 1 # ) 36 &* 3

3 3

36E6E6E6E

' 1 # &: 1 # &: 1 # &: 1 # &: 36

36 36 36

! ! ! ! 199( *4% 199( *4% 199( *4% 199( *4%*,,,*,,,*,,,*,,, "

" "

" 7777 1 1 1 1

7777 45, 45, 45, 45,

1 1" 1 1" 1 1" 1 1" 3*,,*2:46

3*,,*2:46 3*,,*2:46

3*,,*2:46"!"!"!"!

7777

! ! ! ! 1

1 1

1

!O !O !O

!O);99( *4%*,,,");99( *4%*,,,");99( *4%*,,,");99( *4%*,,," " " " " # !

# ! # !

# ! " " " " ! " ! " ! " ! " !!

!! !!

!! #### 1!1" 1!1" 1!1" 1!1"

7777 1 1 1 1 !

! !

! ! ! ! ! ' 1 ! ' 1 ! ' 1 ! ' 1 !

8" 8" 8" 8" # ( # ( # ( # ( 1

1 1

1 " " " "

7777 1 %1 1 %1 1 %1 1 %1

); 99 ( *4 % ); 99 ( *4 % ); 99 ( *4 % ); 99 ( *4 % *,,,

*,,, *,,, *,,,

!1""1( !1""1( !1""1( !1""1( # 1 # 1 # 1 # 1 99 ( *4 % *,,,

99 ( *4 % *,,, 99 ( *4 % *,,,

99 ( *4 % *,,, 1 1 1 1 36 9 36 9 36 9 36 9 ( )%*,,*);99( *4%*,,, ( )%*,,*);99( *4%*,,, ( )%*,,*);99( *4%*,,, ( )%*,,*);99( *4%*,,, ( ( ) % *,,*

( ( ) % *,,* ( ( ) % *,,*

( ( ) % *,,* =3*,,'2&6"## =3*,,'2&6"## =3*,,'2&6"## =3*,,'2&6"## @#A ! @#A ! @#A ! @#A ! 1 =3*,,'2) 1 =3*,,'2) 1 =3*,,'2) 1 =3*,,'2)7777'''6'666 # ! # ! # ! # ! "

" "

" 7777 1 ! 1 ! 1 ! 1 ! # # # # 1 1 1

(7)

@" @" @" @" /" A /" A /" A /" A ( )%*,,*1@

( )%*,,*1@ ( )%*,,*1@

( )%*,,*1@ # # # # 7777 A # 1 A # 1 A # 1 A # 1

7777

8! 8! 8! 8!

3*,,4254699( *4%*,,, 3*,,4254699( *4%*,,, 3*,,4254699( *4%*,,, 3*,,4254699( *4%*,,, ! #

! # ! #

! #

1" 1" 1" 1"

99 ( *4 % *,,, 99 ( *4 % *,,, 99 ( *4 % *,,, 99 ( *4 % *,,, 3*,,42''62

3*,,42''62 3*,,42''62 3*,,42''62

7777 # # # # " # " # " # " #

*: 99&>';#*: 99&>';#*: 99&>';#*: 99&>';# E

E E E 9

9 9

97777 # 1 # 1 # 177771 ! # 11 !1 !1 ! 1

1 1

177771! 1 1! 1 1! 1 1! 1

1 11 11 11 17777 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1E

1E 1E 1E

# 7777 # # # # ! ! ! ! 1 ! 1 ! 1 ! 1 !

')99( *4')99( *4')99( *4')99( *4 %*,,,3*,,,2 %*,,,3*,,,2 %*,,,3*,,,2 %*,,,3*,,,2 >>6 ')

>>6 ') >>6 ')

>>6 ')7777 " " " "

! ! ! ! ! ! ! !

( ! ( ! ( ! ( !

7777

######## #

# #

#1"1!1"1!1"1!1"1! " " " " " " " " 45, 45, 45, 45,

1 1 1 1 "

(8)

1"! 1"! 1"!

1"!

7777 ( 1" ( 1" ( 1" ( 1" "1 ! ! "1 ! ! "1 ! ! "1 ! !

" ( "1 " ( "1 " ( "1 " ( "1 ! "1 "1 ! "1 "1 ! "1 "1 ! "1 "1 1 ! %

1 ! % 1 ! %

1 ! %7777 1 1 1 1 "1

"1 "1

"17777"1( "1( "1( "1(

! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! 99 ( *4 % *,,, 1 99 ( *4 % *,,, 1 99 ( *4 % *,,, 1 99 ( *4 % *,,, 1

! ! ! ! ! 1 ! 1 ! 1 ! 1

7777 !

! ! !7777

! ! ! ! 0 0 0 0

7777 # # # # !

! !

! ! ! ! ! 1"

1" 1" 1"

(9)

!D%!9%!! !D%!9%!! !D%!9%!! !D%!9%!! *,,& *,,& *,,&

*,,&!!!! 82+! 82+! 82+! 82+!

D0 D0 D0

D07777*,,&*,,&*,,&*,,&????82-9 82-9 82-9 82-9 8*,,&

8*,,& 8*,,&

8*,,&!==!==!==!== 82

82 82 82

( ! *,,* ( ! *,,* ( ! *,,* ( ! *,,* = % *,,& ( != % *,,& ( != % *,,& ( != % *,,& ( !

82(!9! 82(!9! 82(!9! 82(!9! ! *,,;

! *,,; ! *,,;

! *,,; ! 9 ! 9 ! 9 ! 9 "1

"1 "1

"1+2+2+2+21 1 1 1

1&>>5 1&>>5 1&>>5

1&>>57777 82-9 82-9 82-9 82-9 &>>:

&>>: &>>:

&>>:!=(!=(!=(!=(82+82+82+82+ F

F F F 1 &>:5 1 &>:5 1 &>:5

1 &>:5 2222

? " *,,, ? " *,,, ? " *,,,

? " *,,, !2 11 !2 11 !2 11 !2 11 82828282 9-

9- 9- 9- *,,* *,,* *,,*

*,,* ! ! ! ! 82 82 82 82

! *,,) ! *,,) ! *,,)

! *,,) ! % ! % ! % ! % 82828282 9

9 9 9 %*,,4 %*,,4 %*,,4

%*,,436!36!36!36! 2.!

2.! 2.! 2.! 1 1" *,,*

1 1" *,,* 1 1" *,,*

1 1" *,,* 8 8 8 8 ! ! ! ! 2222 .!

.! .! .!

@. ! A @. ! A @. ! A

@. ! A++++? 5&? 5&? 5&? 5& %JH 8

%JH 8 %JH 8

%JH 8RRRR!*,,4 !*,,4 !*,,4 !*,,4

% 1 @9 % 1 @9 % 1 @9 % 1 @9

! ! !

!AAAA8888( &:H:F*( &:H:F*( &:H:F*( &:H:F*

Figur

Memperbarui...

Referensi

Memperbarui...