! "
! " # $% &
'( ) * %+ ,, -,
# $ % &! & ' '!' $ ( $ & ! ' & ( ( ) * !# * $ ! ! + '
, ( ( # ! '!# ! + - # ! ( ! & ) * ! )- + ' , ( (*# &# # '
) & !# !( !& ) ! ! '! && (( ! . * + !- $ ! ! + ) & ! ' ) !
( $ & ! ! ! + ' . & ( ( # ! ' / '! ) $ & ( ( # ! ' ! ! + 0 ' ' ( $
)- '# * !# & $ !# ) ! ! + , ' '# * ( $ )- 121 ) !*
!# !* ) ' ! ! + 3 ' ( $ & ! )- '# * !# $ !# ) .$!
( $ & ! & ( ( ) * !# ' + ! $ !# ' ! '# $ &# '# * !' (
# & ( !# $ & $ !# ( ( ! '# / + ( $ &! + ! !# ! && ' &# $ !#
( ! & ) & & !# ! ( ' ! ( $ ( / '! ) ' !# ! ' 4 ( -'! (
) 5 - ( ! 6 78 09# + '( + ( & ( ! !# ( ' # * & ( ! 4 ( -'! (' ) 6 78 :9 $ + * $ ( !# + ! $ &! !# # # $ ' $ ) # ' !# ! $ &! + ! : -* 0 ! &! , ( ( # * ! " " ! #$# . " / " " / " / / " / " 0 / " / " / " / 1 / " / / " " " / " " / , , , ( ! - , " / . ," / " / " " ," " / /(/ / / 1 , 1 / " / / " / // / 1 ," 2 ," " / / 1 , , / / , , / / / / / / / " 3 / , , ! " / 4, " 3 / / / " / / , / , " " / #, , , , , , / " " , #, , / " " " , , , , / " ( / / // ,1 , #, , / , ( / , / , / / , " / ,, - / " " / / -" / " /
5 ! " / // " ,/ , / - / " / // . / // ,/ , " / / - // - , " / " / #$% & ' ! / " / 0 / 6 / 5 4 #, , 7, ! " / / // " ,/ 3!%888 / ) 0 , / / 1 / " , , , '# * % " / , / / 1 , 3! %888 " / / / / // '# * // ! #$( ) ) ( - / / " / " , " / , % / / / " 3 / '# * / " " / - , " $ " / / / , / , " " / -1 9 " / 1, / " " / -1 , '# * / // '# * // ! #$* &
.
/
"
/
/
0
/
6
/ #,
,
7,
!
"
/
/
//
"
,/
3!%888
/
/
/
)
!
,
/
/
#,
,
7,
/
"
" , "
/
%
.
$
//
'#
*
/
,
/
9
5
:
3
/
/
/
"
!
-
#
6
0
/
6
/
; 8$(
5% (%88%&
"
/
1
,
/
/
" " /
-
,
#$+ , / 3 " / : " / " / " ) $ ! " " ! ! " " " / " / / / / / , / 3 $ ) !, " ! " ) 0 " " 1, " 1 / , / " / ! - " " / / $' ) -0 " ( / / , / / / $ ! ! ' ! 0 " " / / $ !")" 0 " " / " / / ,/ / " / " ) !, " ! " ) %$# ) 0 " / " " / // " - / / , / (/ / " " " " / / ,1 " 0 " / ,1< ! " " / / / , ,/ , ,/ = / " " / " " " " / " / = / " " , , ,/ " " / " " / = / " " , ,/ " " / / " " / " " , " / " " & - >, 1/ / %88 & %$% #, , , , " / / / " " " / " / / " / / 1 / " , , , / " / " ) . , , , ! ! 0 ! 0 ! ! " 6 ! & - / " $ , , " , " / " / " ) #, , // / / / #, , " , / / / " / / , , / / / / / / // / " / % #, , // / 0 / " / / / , , / / / " / , , $ #, , #, , , , / / / / / " ,1 / " " / / , , / " ) . , , , ! ! 0 ! 0 ! ! " 6 ! & " / / / / / // ( " / , / " " $:, / / / -, -, , / " / / , , / " / , , / " / / , , / / / " " :8 / , , / / " / / / " " ) . , , , ! ! 0 ! 0 ! ! " 6 ! 7 % $(% 9& %$( 0 , " / , ?, / / " " / / " / " " " / " / & " 0 , / " 1 / " / / / , , . - " , " - ( -/ " " " / , " , ; " 1 // / / " / / " , , 0 , " 1 / , " " / #, " / / " / / " , , / / ' ( / " " / / " , # " / " " " 6 " " " " " , " " // / " / / // " , & 0 -" -" - " " , " , " / ) 0 , ! / / / // 0 , / / / // " , / / / " % 0 , ! / / / / 3 " " / " , " / " , / " " " , / / " / $ 0 , 0 , " , / " " 1 " " " / " / " / " / " , ! - " , , " " 1 " // 1 1 " " , / " " ) . , , , ! ! 0 ! 0 ! 6 ! &
! " 0 " " - " " , " , " / ) 0 , 0 , " , / " , , " , / / " / , , / , , 0 , " / - " / / " / 0 , - " / / " " , / " - 0 , " " / ) " , / / / / " " / 0 " 0 " 7 0 " " , & " 0 , 3 0 , " , / " " , " / / , , 0 , " / -" / / " / " ) . , , , ! ! 0 ! 0 ! 6 ! & - 0 , 0 / 0 , " / " , / / " / " , / " , @ " , / " , %$* . / / / / - / / / / " " / " / / / / , , / " / " / " / / / " / . / / 6'# * 9 " / / / 1 1 / / " / // 7 " / , / / 1, " / - / 1 / / " / " " // / " / / / / / / , . " / / / , " (" / / " / / / / / " - >, 1/ / %88 & 0 / / " / " / " " " " - 3 " / / / " 1 " / / / / 1 " " // // , / / / / / / / " " / ! / " " , " / " ) ->, 1/ / %88 & . - / / / / 6'# * 9 / " " / // / / " / / $ 0 ; 8$( 5 %(%88% / / / / / " , " / " / / / 1 / " " / " / / - / " " , , " , / / & / , / / " " / / / 1 / / / " / / / / " " / // " / / " / / , , / / / / " . / / ", " , / " " " " / / . / / // / " / " / / / / / $! // / , ; ( 5 %(%88% / / " / ) . / / " , " /
%88 ! " 3 " / / - / " " , , " , / / & / , / / " " / / / , // " / / ", / % " " ", / : % . / / " , " / " / " / / / 1 / " " / " / / - / " " / / / / , " , (" , / / / , ( / " , (" , / / / /( / , / / " / / / , " / // " , / ", " 9 %$+$ $ ! / " / 1 -" / " / . , " , / / 0 " , " / " / / , " / " - ( --, " ( -" " , " , " / " , , ( , , " / " / / " ) . , , , ! ! 0 ! 0 ! ! " 6 ! & -" % - ) ! " / ! " / / / / , / / / , / , / , -" / - / " / / , / - , 1 , % ! " / ! " / / ! " / / (/ " " /( / ! / / / " / A& " " " / / & 0 " / " / / / " / " @AB % & / , " / ; 8$(%<95(%88% / " / " , / / / // / " / // " " / 1 / " " / , , 4 / " , / / / / " / / / " /( " / " / " :8C / / 1, " / " " " / , , / / / " / " " / , , " / / " ) . , , , ! ! 0 ! 0 ! ! " 6 ! & %$. / / ! - " " " , " " (" " / " " / -" -" - , - / / " / " ) %$.$# / ' 0 " / / " " , " 0 " / " " / / " / " / " / " / 6 (/ / / " " " / " " " / / ( / / " , , , 0 " " / / / " " , " - >, 1/ / %88 & ! / " , / / / /
%8 ! " - / , " 1, ( ( D / / " , : C ( %8 C , , , %888& %$.$% / 0 " " " / " / // / / / " " (" " / " " /(" / / " ( / " / / / / / / / // / " " " " " - >, 1/ / %88 & %$.$( / ! / / -; 8$2 5% 2%88% 5 ( / / / " / // " 98 , / . / / / / " / / " " / / (/ " / , / " / 3 / " " / " / / / " / " / , / . " / / / " / 1 $. / " 1 , / 1 / / " ",", 1 , / % " ,, , ,/, / / / / , " / / / /( / " " / " , ", " , ( 1 , / " " / " " : 0 " / , , / // / " ; , " / / / " " / , ", " / <8C , / 0 , " / / / / / , E ' )- - - ! ) ! 0 - / - " " / - / / " / / - " " / " / // // ,/ , . / , / // ,/ 3!%888 / " / / / #, , 7, ! " / ($# ) " , , ,/ / / 3 / ( / / / / ) ($#$# / / - / " (" / " / / " / / / / / / / " / " " / / - " / // / / / / / 7 " " " , , // / , / " -/ " , , - ( / " (/ " -.'.& ($% " / / " " / " / 5 F / / / '# * & / " %: -" / - ?, / 1 / , / . ( / ,/ 3!%888 " // " ,/ 0 , / / " $ $ 9 )
%8% ! " 6 " . 6 / #, , 7, 6 " % 0 / 6 / #, , 7, 6 " $ / 6 / #, , 7, 6 " 9 . 4 6 / #, , 7, ($( , / / / / / ; 8$( 5% (%88% // , , -" / " ,/ ( / ) & ! " " " " " " " " / & "& ! " " / / 3 . -& , , " , / / / *$#
"
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
.
! / / ,/ 3! %888 / " / " / / " / / / // , / / / , / " / 7 - , / / / 3 0 L . " 9 , - / / 3 " 9 % , - / / 0 " 9 $ , - / / L " 9 9 , - / / . " 9 , . - / / 3 3 4 5 43; 3 - L L % 8 8% 9%$ 8 8%89 $ ( < $ 8 8:8 :9 8 8$:$5 ( %$9% 9 8 8595 $ 8 8: 5 ( $ :9 : 8 8 << 8 8< 9 ( 9 5 8 % 5 8 :%% ( :$ 5 5 8 9%59 8 95<5 ( :55% < 8 5959 8 5<$9 ( %$8 " 9 % , . - 6 / 0 3 4 5%8: ! " 43; 3 L L -% 8 8 %< 8 8% 55: (8 99% $ 8 8$ 8:9 8 8:%9 < (8 <%%$ 9 8 8:8 : 8 8<$% 5 (8 <5 $ : 8 85:%8< 8 $<: :%: 8 8%%:< 8 9:<9 ( $9< 5 8 $ < 8 < :5 ( 9 8 < 8 $85: 8 % 555$ ( : $ " 9 $ , . - 6 / L 3 4 5 43; 3 - L -% 8 8%::< 8 8%< 9< ( % $ $ 8 89< 9$ 8 8:$ ( %%%:% 9 8 85$ : 8 8< 9$ ( 98$9< : (8 8 <9 8 $:$ ( %5 8 <85 8 %8 :8: ( 5<%8% 5 8 $ %$ 8 %<9<:$ ( < $ < 8 5 < 8 $$ 5% (8 8%: " 9 9 , . - 6 / . 3 4 5 43; 3 - L -% 8 8$< $: (8 8 < ( <%$ $ 8 8 85: (8 8 58< ( %$ 9< 9 8 8<9 $ 8 8% : ( 9 % : 8 89< 8 89$%$ ( 58 $$ 8 98%% 8 8<8 % ( <$ $ 5 8 %8$855 8 5 $ ( %:9% < 8 $8 8<9 8 $%$$ ( : 8 " 9 : , 6 3 / / 3 43; 3 D '; $& 6 E%& 3 !& % ( 9< %9 589 5 5$< 99 $ ( :%: 5 ( : < $ < < 9 ( 888 ( :55 <% 5$< 99 : ( 5$9% ( :5 8% 98 ( <% :% ( :5% <5 ( $8 %% 5 ( <5$:9 589 5 (:: $: < ( <<5 9 <%5 5 ( 5 %% " 9 , 6 3 / / 0 43; 3 D ';
$& 6 E%& 3 !&
% ( 5: : ( :99 $$ 89 $ ( :$ ( 5 : 9 ($ 9 :: 9 ( 9%% $ ( $ <<% 8 : ( 888898 8888 9 < ( 8%$ ( 5 % 9 ( 5< % 5 ( 9 9% < << (%5 8 %: < (:85%8 9 9< 8% (9 9$ : " 9 5 , 6 3 / / L 43; 3 D ';
$& 6 E%& 3 !&
% ( 8% $ 985 ( %55 59 $ ( 889 << ( 9 < 8: $9 5 9: 9 ( 9 < 8: $9 5 9: %<89 8% : ( 85<8 :%$ 8$ % < :: ( 89 ( 8: $5 5$9 5 ( %5 % ( 59 :< << :5 < (:%%%:9 ( %8$ : ( 8 89 " 9 < , 6 3 / / . 43; 3 D ';
$& 6 E%& 3 !&
% ( 99$ 9 589 5 %9%: $ ( <8%8 ( %% :: % : 5$ 9 ( <8%8 ( %% :: % : 5$ : ( 95 58 85 85 $99 ( 98% $ ( 9 5< 9 9 5 ( 9$%< ( 9: 5< ( 9 8: < ( 58: ( 8: $5 (%959 %
4.7 Perbandingan Antara Displacement,
Momen, Geser, Aksial
Setelah didapat dimensi struktur
beton yang akan digunakan, maka selanjutnya
dapat dibandingkan hasil output program
SAP2000 berupa perbandingan displacement ,
momen , geser, dan aksial yang di jelasi pada
kurva 4.1 sampai 4.5 di bawah ini :
%8
! "
Kurva 4.2 Perbandingan Gaya Geser Maksimum
Kurva 4.3 Perbandingan Gaya Aksial
Kurva 4.4 Perbandingan Displacement Arah Y
Kurva 4.5 Perbandingan Displacement Arah X
Kurva 4.6 Perbandingan Berat Sendiri Gedung
*$6
/
*$6$# / ' ' ! % " " / / / , / / 0 / ( 5: / -! $ , / / L / ( 889 < / - ! 9 , / / . / ( <8%8 / - ! : , / / L / ( 85<8 / - ! , / / L / ( 89 / - ! 5 , / / L % $ 9 : 5 < 6 / ( ( ( ( ( ( ( 6 / ( ( ( ( ( ( ( 6 / " ( ( ( ( ( ( ( 6 / - ( ( ( ( ( ( (( :88888
( 888888
(:88888
8
'-' !
% $ 9 : 5 < 6 / 58 ( ( 8 ( ( ( 6 / 58 ( ( 8 ( ( ( 6 / " ( : ( 5 ( 88 ( 5 <% 9 9 6 / - 98 ( 9 $9 :% ( ( ( % ( :888 ( 8888(:888 8 :888 8888 :888 & % $ 9 : 5 < 6 / 5$< $ 5$< 98 ( $ (:: ( 6 / %9% % % $9 9 ( (%9 6 / " $$ ($ << 9 ( (%5 (9 6 / - ( % $9 %<8 % 5$ <<5 ( ( 888 (9888 (%8888 %888 9888 % $ 9 : 5 < 6 / 8 8% 8 8$ 8 8 8 8< 8 8 9 8 5 6 / " 8 8$ 8 8: 8 8< 8 8 9 8 < 8 % 6 / - 8 8% 8 8: 8 8< 8 $ 8 %8 8 %< 8 $$ 6 / (8 8 (8 8 8 8$ 8 89 8 8< 8 8 $,- !)
0 ' !)
&
4
% $ 9 : 5 < 6 / 8 8% 8 8: 8 859 8 8 < 8 % 8 9% 8 59 6 / " 8 8 8 8$ 8 8:8 8 85: 8 8% 8 $ 8 $ 6 / - 8 8%: 8 89< 8 85$ (8 8 8 8 $ 8 5 6 / 8 8$< 8 8 8 8 8<9 8 89 8 98 8 %8$ 8 $8,- !)
0 ' !)
&
3
6'. ;6 3 6'. ;6 0 6'. ;6 L 6'. ;6 . $ 8 % 5 $< % : % $9 5 88 :8 %888 %8:8 % 88 % :8 & ) ! & " !&
!
!
!
& )
!
&
"!
%85 ! " / ( %5 / - ! < , / / 3 / ( <<5 9 / - ! " , " " '# * , '# * / 1 ( , / / L . , / " " - " / / / / / // , / / L *$6$% / 7 ' ! % " " / / / / / / / 3 / ( 589 5 / ! $ / / / / 0 / ( 5 : / ! 9 / / / / 0 / ( $ / ! : / / / / 0 / ( 8888 / ! / / / / L / ( 8: $ / ! 5 / / / / L / ( 59 : / ! < / / / / 3 / ( 8: $ / *$6$( / 7 ' ! % " " / / / / A / / . / %9%: / ! $ / A / / L / $9 5 9: / ! 9 / A / / L / (%<89 8% / ! : / A / / L / % < :: / ! / A / / L / 5$9 / ! 5 / A / / 0 / %5 8 % / ! < / A / / 3 / 9 9$ / +$# . " " / - , / 1 , '# * " / / " , / / 1 L " '# * 'JFK " / / , " ( 89 / -% . " " / - / / / 1 / / '# * " / / " , : / / 1 0 " '# * // , , / / / / / " ( 8888 / $ ; 1 / " / " 1 < / / 1 L " '# * JFK / 1 " 8 $$ - // / / / 1 " 9 ; 1 / A < / / 1 . " '# * / // / / / 1 " 8 $8 -1 . ' * / // / " / / A 1 " '# * / " A : 0 , / " " / - 1 / 1 3 " $ $ 1 0 " % 5 $ 1 L " % $ 1 . " % $9 $ , / " -1 3 " / / A / '# * " $ $ 1 3 // / , " ! 0& / /
%8< ! " 1 // / , ! #& E, 1 . " '# * / // / / " % $9 $ '# * / / " " " / 1( 1 / +$% 8) & " ) 0 ; , %88% ! , 8 & : ! # ; ( ! 0 ; " = "" 0 / % 0 ; , %88% ! , 8 & ! ! 0 % ! 0 ; " > "" 0 / $ . ," , , > , %88 ?+ ' : % 0 0 % # ; ( 3 .8 """ G ! 7 9 . ," , , > , %885 . ' 7 - ' : '! ' .8 """ ! " ! ' A #, , : . , , , ! ! 0 ! 0 ! ! " ! 6 ! 8 ( 8 ' : % 8 ! ' . # %885 G 5 3/ %88< 8 & ! ! 0 % ! 743 < , 0 " / %8 0 % .8 """ . ' ' ; ( ! " M ! " / =,/
