Positioning Paper KPPU terhadap Kebijakan dalam Industri Gula

! "

#

'

&(&(

)

! "

! " # $

% &_'

(

)**+

)*&* " ,

%

-%

#

! %

.

#

(

(

(

0 & &

)

. 1 )**+

&2 234

+4 &4

) _{5* ! )**+}

0 & )

8 5

! )**+

9 : +** % " . . )**+

9 2 ;** %

.

% ) <:4

. - )**+

% 2 &34

. ! )**+

.

- )**+

( ,

= =

% %

5 _{)* - )**+}

&($(

!

(

6

%

7

&(*(

+

= %

%

% %

#

,

&(,(

)

) "

!

; ( 8

&

) (

%

5 (

#

3 (

5,59%0,38%

1,36% 6,24%

1,42% 15,64%

18,72%

PTPN X PTPN XI PT Madubaru

PT Kebon Agung PT Laju Perdana Indah PTPN II

PTPN VII PTPN XIV PT Gula Madu Plant

Sugar Group PT Gorontalo PT Pemuka Sakti Manis Indah

0 " D 0 " D 0 " D 9"

! >

$(&(

# " ! ) ! ) $%%0

0 " D 0 " D

% )**+

&2 :)4 &; <34 &2 +<4

)**+

Angels Products 16%

PT Jaw amanis Raf inasi

15%

PT Sentra Usahatama Jaya

20% PT Permata DSU

20% PT Dharmaphala

Usaha Sukses 5% PT Sugar Labinta

9%

PT Makassar Tene 11%

PT Duta Sugar International

4%

, .

%

, ,

, ;** *** &*

)**2 ,

&** *** &&

! $(*( ! /

)**< 25 +:& <*5 :&& &&; 3<) :3&

& C A A A A 9

.

.

C C

$ '

&

- # ,

) C A A A 9

8

9 $ '

-, !

5 C A A 9

.

PTPN

PETANI

SWASTA

IMPORTIR TERDAFTAR

SUPPLIER LUAR NEGERI DENGAN HARGA

KESEPAKATAN

SUB

DISTRIBUTOR GROSIR RETAIL

K

GROSIR RETAIL

RETAIL LOKAL

IMPOR

TENDER

HARGA NEGOSIASI

9 ;*

)**+ ):

# 0

=

8

#

, #

%

%

"

-( - ,

)**2 8

' ()"

. + ! ( - *

0 "C9"

( &3 4 ) ;<

(

0 "C9" $ 0 "C9" ( '

! $(5( ! ! ) $ &% &5(0%: &60955% **(7%: * 0, 7,(6%: &$896&* $5(6%: &$6 &%%: 5%$976* &%%:

1

)*&& =

"

!

C

!( $(7( # ' ! ) # ' ! !

' 2 . 3 ) _{! !}' ₂ ) $_{. 3} :

)**3 53&* &: 1 ! 53;3 ; & *&

)**; 52** )& - ! 3<<+ & & )5

)**< 32** &+ - ! ;5;) 5 & &)

)**: 3+** 5* ! ! ;3*: 5 & &

)**2 ;*** )+ ! ! ;&&) & *&

)**+ ;5;* ! 2*** 3+ ;

)*&* <5;* !

, ( )**+

% 3+ ;4

,

0 % )**+

9 2 2**

.

,

&

)**+

)*&* ) :

) 5

) M 2**C

" ,

, ,

,

( ,

5 0

9 + ;** 0

9 2 ***

. 9 : 3**

9 + *** ( . )*&*&;

15

( &3 . )*&* 6

Perbandingan Harga Ritel & harga Lelang Tahun 2009

Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov

R

p

/K

g

Harga retail Harga lelang

9 & ;** 9 ) ***

.

- )**+

)**+

9 2 *** 9 &* ***

$(5(*( )

.

! $(&%( ) ! " ! # ) !

! " )

/ 9 2 2** 25 2&

$ (=!"' 9 : 3** 2& 5)

9 2 &** % + ;** < <: A : <+

9 2 <** % &* *** 3 :< A ; 3+

9 ! 9 &* *** A&) *** )5 3; A )< 5&

9 0 9 + &** A &* ;** 3 :< A ; 3+

)5 3; % )< 5&4 9

< <: 4%: <+4

3 :<4%; 3+ 4 3 <:4%; 3+4 &

$(5(,( ) ) !

.

$(0( ) ) !

/

/ .

$(5(5(

<

/

,

, ,

2*4 ,

. )*&*

,

C

. )*&* , . 0 .

0 . ( / ,

!

. ( = $ 0 ' > $. 0 '&<

-,

16

$(&%( ' ! ) ! ) #

1 !"#"

$(6(&(*( + " ) " ) # ) !

! . 0

9 . 0

B 0

. 0

9 &) ***

B

• _{9 &* ***C}

• _{9 + ;**C}

. 0 C

#

! , B0

, . 0

. 0 ;*4

9 && +<<

4265

4121 5993

6186 ₅₉₀₈

8259 10862

10548

10420 10276

9900

: .

0

- )*&*

!

(

! . 0

! )*&* %

9 + ;**C

$(&*( " ' !

# $%&%

2 $ !"#"

0 . 0

, ,

# . 0 )&

,

21

$(6(*( ) - < " )

& <&:

= )**+

3: 33&

! $(&$( " ' ! # ?

-# $%%7 $%%8 $%%0

. <5:+ ;2** <&;: 1 <);+ ;+)& :*<3 ! <5<5 ;+&: :&)*

- <352 ;2;* :3*3

! <3** ;25: :+)2

. <:22 ;2** 2&+) . <&+) ;:** :++& - <)3) <&35 2:<: <&+2 <*** +;<5

E <*+5 ;25: +322

" # <*** ;+3) +&3) ;:)& <&:2 +++&

3 !"#"

)*&*

$(&,( " ' !

# # ! #

-3 !&#-34;#&#-34;

%

! $(&*( ' ! # "

# # ! # ) #

" ' ) 4 ) !

)3 . )*&* ); . )*&*

& + ;** + ;**

) - + ;** + ;**

5 + ;** + ;**

3 + ;** + ;**

2 1 !"#"

0 )3 . );

. )*&* (

$(6(,(*( ! )

0 . (

>

( .

( % ,

<35 0

%

0

*($(

)

)

)

# )

#

#

( 5$7

$%%, )

)

)

!

)**3 ! " ;):! C C+C)**3

&: )**3 $ '

(=!" ( 0 $ 0 '

(=/E

" (=!"

0 " 0 9" (=!"

( 0 " 9"

;):

" <35C! C C+C)**) 0 "

;): ,

( 8

& 0

) 0 9 5 3&*

5

3 ,

! 0

;): $ '

% $ >=! -'

,

.

9 5 &**

0

9 5 3&* =

*(*(

=

?

5$7

$%%,

<35 ;):

<35

,

;):

$ ' ,

# ;): )&

- )**; !

" *2C!% - C B9C3C)**;

" ;):C! C C+C)**3

>=! - :* = )** =

!

9 3 +** $!

" &2C!% - C B9C3C)**:' 9 ; *** $!

! " &+C!% - C B9C;C)**2' 9

; 5;* $! ! " " ;<*C!%

- C B9C3C)**+'

.

(

,

%

- ;):

,

$ '

-, , ,

,

9

" )**+

E

! ,

B0

B0

B0

-%

% 0 B0

% , ,

B0

%

. 0

)*&* 9 < 5;*

9 :;**

, #

*(5( ! ) # " ! ! # ) !

#

C ,

<35 # ;):

-C

;):

%

C

C , ,

-, ,

# ,

! ,

,

=

;

,(&(

!

!

;): )**3

%

)**3 (

(

,(&( ' !

$ '

$ '

Harga Gula

Indonesia

(

,

,

,(&(&( !

-,(&($( !) ) / " ! <

)**3

"

= M 2** $

' #

,

.

,

-,

)**+

!

,(&(*( + " ! )

!

-Gula Rafinasi

Gula Impor

Produksi Gula

•

Konsumen

gula konsumsi

•

Industri pemakai

gula

,

, C

0

,

,($(

!

! "

C

1 )*&*

(

!

(

9 & ;**%) *** $ '

! )**+ ,

9 & )**

Digiling

Di PG

BUMN

30% BUMN

Dilelang

T

Petani

Tebu

Harga

Terbentuk

Harga Lelang – HDG

60%

40 %

#

Pedagang Biasa :

Hanya

memperoleh

Margin distribusi

Lelang

Gula Petani

Pedagang

sekaligus

Penyedia talangan

:

Margin Distribusi +

40% selisih

Pada harga

berapapun

pedagang/peny

0 (=!"

(=!"

0

&

,

9 &* ***

9 &) *** 9 + )**%+ 3**

9 &**%)** )<

C

2*4

,

,

= M;**C!0

$ '

26

#

! ,(&( ' ! - # " ) ) /

' 2 3 ) 2 A3 ' _{2 3}) !

)**3 5 3&*

)**; 5 2**

)**< 3 2**

)**: 3 +** 5** : ***%2 ***

)**2 ; *** 52* : ***%2 ***

)**+ ; 5;* ;**%<** &* ***%&) ***

)*&* < 5;* 2** ;** + ;**%&) ;**

,

C

,(*(

!

+ "

!

, ,

-,

-,

-,

,

$ C '

$ ' $

, ' ,

!

,

%

,

;

5(&(

!

(

1.

_$

'

0

2.

3.

_{- ) $ '}

0

,

!

4.

₌

,

/

, ! ,

,

5($(

"

#

(

& =

) ! 6 7

#