ry*
a
E€'nI
otrgr=
\
)Ja FIFIJ3'
='to
ctI
;T
o
=-3
r
o
L) L)='
rD N)5
I IJJ <:)z.
o
fD3
rDt$
O
J ,J,$ .-.: ..r**
.', .\i.r:Sq1
g$i ,
GI
-ql!t
J6'
CLo
o
(o
Jo
Fl'o::
{o
-3)T'
JG'
qt J F| t\\
./ - UNlvt4-\ /a
lz
""\l;
z''\?
\..:t
-a./ \ t- Ivvna+ ' ,/
:.l.c
tr4
n€'E I
g.J
g.?
JJI.+
..+ J
='
='@
ctI
€
Jo
;+
o
cr
rt
gl
E
:.
t
r.G','*
:&:
....1&,..--,/*ulpture
lrawing randycraft lraphic design
Painting
photography carving
painting
'oror^ "s
+
q
n:
gil€r€
g$E;$s9B5
H.g€3€q
=
2
qE:EBia
$€aEf+==g
6x^,=.:c.
a
-
€
J
*5gds+i=
9.6 -
=-t€gE4aa
T€=gr*
t
n
5l+sE*aa
€glagEfga
EaEiE=
E
=
3=fed-F=
ss?$tss:=
$++=g=
'
egqE-g€.9
qg'r-po,==
c6toorii
u*4FEE
9=+;il3st6
saFr=
aae€==E E=e#,*3E
*
a
€:',i*
+','
d
I
tr
o
g
:
g
i
a -J€
_-.6
F
r
a
a,i
€+Eg3i
=g-:sqsEiE
e-gFiq
=--**+-**EBe+EEa+a$E[fiE
Pj
gAsSEE rq
isa=s
:
iq
*sE
AE
5!E
E$tFEBa€a
[$e+
a;
d:==36
E===.1
+!2o,q
€l: sf,
2
i*tEd=E
€=5=E;3i€
I
c€==E
=5$
cg
s
EE-r=
's
ssE
i€,:
=
fE=1+i
$aaes;FE
q*aF
=g 6j:.= =<;'E3_-=-,
5s46
*a;e+
asE*=
;-E=$sqt
HggiiS-9*F
$=ea
s-o;
tr
*9gAt
E;-F*#13
1336
EiAE3
gsggiE€
+
EFEE
s#+3t-
$€Fqg€s4
i€58
z.
= -.{$'
:tlttuie
'.
carvlng !'awtnq
-
oarntrno andycraft
raphic
design
PhotograPhY painting=".''"
2
i'
^..*
: .it'
-/
i
F
:?ss E*a:
EE3gE€.q
gEE
'z
i
E
gIE
ggE$EaABEAEEEiA*EEEH
:EEFSEE+g*EEESEgf,FFgEgE
€et$ga
aiiF=rsq.i€EE
*$E
3?
BaggEgggEgg
*;3
+gagEaE
lgg
4=
A*-$[+$EBEg;g;i3eE+
:3e
EI
aiiars
sriEEiE6;iEg
;6g
AEqEH;
iegg-
*q=e*
ar
:E
=
usF*B
d&FE'€REg=.
5t
qE€
=glE+ i*=a alEe'=?#
=+=
€E33
$€ag
Ee;qEgE
=a=
,iculpture
'Irawing
randycraft
lraphic
design
painting
\J di
oJ x---- o)
c,
photography
Garvlng
painting.
q3
-Pd
;t
oJ-oa
=-OJ; O)o
o o
f lJ
O)
E
,t
*.
icu lptu re
carvrng
lrawing
landycraft
painti
lraphic
design
painti
I
tr
Ii'$,
z^
rDc
-d
no,
-.(D --'l a o)5
O->o
3 9.
o
f
o
OJ
l
OJ
ryo
l:-gq
o
OJ
0!
F
c
e o
l O l
CJ
J
.<'i
,^o
ol oa
J^ -CC=
r,r---,--
--
Cafving
.Iravvtnq
I
v
painting.
handycraft
trraphic
design
PhotograPhY
painting
5+
!o
3.
rpoP
EF
3=
px
S<
+3.
=0,
-:E (D:to
--4
tE
I
Z.D5
d30,
A(D
;culpture
Irawing
nandycraft
lraphic
design
Painting
7
ftr.r,,-!.'',".--l
r\
f''r#
carving
painting
photographY
o
)
F'
O^ -Y.
o_o
5o LN OJ
==
o<
EiY
7E oa
de
OJ
4-6o
t: rf
qJ CL
?c PE =Ol
o-L
g
o
-
oOJ
f O
.TT
fo o6'
f.c
i
,ril'i.,
9?:
a!l
io-
<9
.OJ4" q-a .)
O ,f
,0) {o
\
l-F
:r
:-^
l 0 l
o
I
0,
l.
OJ
<=
i--f='
)J
0C
*?'o '.'l .j.'.& ;* .'. *$o
:tJ' . ', I '. &
4' ,' ,.:i.:ri\ ... ,.
' \'
',-\..,
.. : . I \., t
\,, r,!.
\i'!3 \.
1-\
l''i..
i ,.'
iculpture
lrawing
randycraft
lraphic
design
painting
carvrng
painting
J
,
o
o
o
-ll
<-;0rdtt O^
z>
rO=+ T-0A o\l
o--cO
::f
9o
-o =
0l
r
*7
s
f
\l
&.
G
s
!fi
oa a-.oe
1a _(D
4o
d+
--:-+uo f^ a-. aJ
,
,:rcffiryF-
.
carvino
rl
f€tWt
ilg
g
r.
-
painting
randycraft
irupttic
design
PhotograPhY
painting
O- 0J l- gq
J J
-o
(J
:
o f
c)
:
ol
:OJ
j=
O^ J\J
:
o:
c)
0)
f
tculpture
lrawing
randycraft
carving
painting
photograPhY
';raphic design
pa
intin
g
:4
-=
:l: Ya
CJ = OJ
6 (/'r !
tu-Ja -O^
-r- l-
U-;
:-t
&
*tae
,t
T-' l
o
="--7:
il ui. N:
os
l:
,brawing
carvlng
painting
'handycraft
graphic design
painting
photography
:l- \J (ct
HE.>
.rtr8
+i-o,
- >c
-3
o
q
6-=6l =.O
;-i'
o-*o ttt
Vt
o
€
qJ
u
ou'
;
;
3
iculpture
Irawing
randycraft
carvinE
painting
photographY
praphic design
Painting
xe,e
F: i
:Aa
=
o.<
f-o o OJs.C lm-Ln==
2- N
vo-t.1 :,.r "f\
71
s,L
i+i
#
,it.
ir"i,{:r::
,4.
zct
-.
o)-;
{so
oa oi<9
,D€ :J^
lT
-o=o
o
-o
o J -o o.)
!
rD
l
G
I
g
30.
ci-29.
q-=>a
:. tl::..:.:. r::ri::': ..rai.
i:i j :i.::,....r\r..
ar',rr.!,::?ii-, . !'1.1:i trilirj.!\\1tillw
;cu
lptu re
lrawing
randycraft
carving
painting
photography
lraphic design
,w lc oJ
.lo-:l-. *
t lor o
u
dl;
lo
.'a!q
il ^'i
^
t€a'
1o
=
,=
r-)
rP
"-:i.) I
OJ
!9
-:-:{)L =lJ
JOJ oa
a
o)
o
1
0) 0)
5
o7(
oO
cr
cr<.4
-cr
f0) o-3 oJ 0q
:].0) --15 OJ^
=.
-u$r f-oJO
:5"
ga
oi
!
f-5
iculpture
lrawing
randycraft
;raphic
design
Painting
photograPhY
carving
painting
tDF
a;--n=4
;:c=
-''l a
O-=atoJ Oa=o) !:"-6
c
t.
==!!alD
=7u
ftz!
oiis.
o ooq'Y@ru
o
rculpture
lrawing
eilru$ng
paSnting
nndycraft
praphic
design
Paintl
ffi-",
'*s
*t.. , ,,.';S:\".;;-iffi
klt ''K-{
':,$
1l
SE
.d
orotJ 3^
d9
t4l o
35
r!, c'l c=a?
l!)Or
J@ {trt v
F€
=0, O*o,
I
o
3
11 o,
f
raphic design
.photograPhY
dycraft
painting.
painting
carving
:EF
o:'
r:'
o)Jri
o)o-:t
orlJn )
oi Ct
9
o
=
.)
p f
OJ
I
=o
E,i
oJ 0,
)
>J
3$
rJ0cL
-.1 c
5o)
O)-€cr
oJ ='
-oe
ax
o0,
3-'
9:
-.
=
;culpture
lrawing
randycraft
carvrng
painting
painting
photography
yraphic
design
T- (,
h =5
;oo
mO O
d.E
ooJo):'
bl--5=
6=t.€
FOJ NJ+uro 5
x 'Tt
qfD .bvr
\t
a^
oo
ed
Qsq
eoJ !|!
^'
lrawing
randycraft
lraphic
design
Painting
.photograPhY
carving
painting.
.?s i
@
s
t
i { ,.r
I
f, F
ln!
*
i& '?a
Y.n
SJ
>3
=^
sc*
orO
-o
gqo)
E T
2G=
oJ :'lD30 5
E€E
O-q, o,-'E E
g3
qr CL
€
fo
o
cn
E J t')
-< 0,
:.E
OE
di
cretse'
Lno fo =o) o5
carvlng
;culpture
lrawing
painting.
Tvr co
=.f -O, fE CL ti
:9.
9ii
J. OIQ
0,
1t
:t
^A<
T;6'
6q€
ag
s
6X ='
=O-d
;iculoture
,_____=_
_
carving
ilrawrno
v
oainting.
handvcraft
I. '
.photography
,.lraphic
design
'rvrlvr
.^ - : -- .a.: --
^-n
q)
J
{
o) J
OJ
€
o o_r')
OJ
f
I
oa
0l
o,
3 o
)
:
€
o
v1
c
3
OJ
-U
f o
<7
:> 0J C6
,OJ
><
ul
a
re
ulp
;c
lrawing
randycraft
lraphic design
Painting
.photographY
calYlng
painting.
€<
='o
dF
1O
.<: AJY
a3
-q)
o
=
3
r'B
o'^= :: 0,
'+@ t 1x!J
93
j iofD
;culpture
carving
-l--.{r1
,'uTlIdi
tanl-L-a
---f:4ils..)-fral-''lI
3-o J o .D o 3 O T c
-o) ta o qJ l O:.
0 --l D L oq 0 :f T0 o 0 -o*
m 3 gI
f,:.
I Cl
z
o D J c 0a OJ :t --t:.
=
0J. 0:,
t o) (D f i. f o) To o t. f o) r)=
o:
o_ 0 -o 0 o-oo rD a o o o T u l oa r-,
al - tt , .\!*
.d
''&€w!*
&
llrawinq
randycraft
'
traphic
design
I
J.
k
r}
f
a!:.
o fD (.) o ra:r
l.D o = o(f
o 3 € :l(,
! f 5E*-t.
T 5 o) o;
6-!O -c 7 = c=
:J ),I
c 3 = = t=
'*&
.&, ;'f{
rD ol 5 oE
c
qr.."*gw
=l J
I
wr''
3
E
.r/-ry
-z
;
o = -td:E
{
I
I a"r.qi.',,
-ffi
l
s
?rS
tr
\
:
*
$
.t. tr
\-]
\*
f$
n
a-*
{<
{c
!
o
o
(o
-l
q)
q
r
-dl
=
E
,rirll..
.t +t+^ r
t it:{
q
=,
LEMBAR
HASIL PENILAIAN
SEJAWAT SEBIDANGATAU
PEER REVIEWKARYA
PAMERAN SENI RUPAINTERNATIONAL
: "Kuta Kemulihen"
:
Nelson Tariganffi
E
T
Judul Karya Seni
Pembuat Karya Seni
ldentitas Karya Seni
Kategori Publikasi Karya
Seni
:(beri /pada kategori yang tepat)
Hasil Penilaian Peer Review '.
a. Nama Pameran
b. Pelaksanaan
c. Bahan karya seni d. Tempat
e. Halaman
: Pameran Seni Rupa lrrternational
: 24 sld 30 Novernber 201 1 :
Oil
on canvas: ALrditorium Lobby Unimed
:2
Tingkat Internasional Tingkat Nasional Tingkat Lokal
Maksima ngkat asional
Medan Oktober 2014
Revi
Drs.
NIP.
27
-1
Bri(man
Silaban, M.SiKomponen
Yang
Dinilai
Nilai
Tingkat Internasional
V
Ti
Na
a. Kelengkapan karya seni (10%)
b. Ruang lingkup dan kedalaman karya seni (30%) c. Kecukupan dan kernutahiran datalinformasi karya
seni (30%)
d. I(ualitas hasil karya seni (30%)
Total
:
(100%)I Pameran
NilaiAkhir
Yang Diperoleh Tingkat
Lokal
n
8
28
Lg
)a
93
Lampiran
9LEMBAR
HASIL PE,NILAIAN SEJAWAT SE,BIDANG
ATAU
PEER REVIEWKARYA
PAMERAN SE,NI RUPAINTERNATIONAL
JudulKarya Seni
Pernbuat Karya Seni
Identitas Karya Seni
Kategori Publikasi Karya
Seni
:(beri "'pada kategori yang tepat)
Hasil Penilaian Peer Review '.
"Kuta Kemulihen" Nelson Tarigan
a. Nama Pameran
b. Pelaksanaan
c. Bahan karya seni
d. Ternpat
e. Halaman
: Pameran Seni Rupa International
: 24 sld 30 Novernber 201 1 :
Oil
on canvas: Auditoriurn Lobby Urrimed
:2
d,
u-, rlrutr nternas ionalTingkat Nasional Tingkat Lokal
tl
n
ksima gkat iona
Medan.
27
Oktober 2014Reviewer
- 2Komponen
Yang
Dinilai
N
TurgL"t
--Internasional
g
ai Ma
-Trn
Nas
a. Kelengkapan karya seni (10%)
b. RLrang lingkr"rp dan kedalaman karya seni (30%) c. Kecukupan dan kemutahiran data/informasi karya
seni (30%)
a.
(*lirut
n^it
tutlt
t""'
GO'z.l- fotal :
(t00"/")
I Pameran
Nilai
AkhirYang Diperoleh Tingkat
Lokal
E
8
a
28
2E
g?,
Drs.
Sugito,M.Pd
Lampiran
9LEMBAR
HASIL PENILAIAN
SEJAWAT SEBIDANGATAU
PEER REVIEWKARYA
PAMERAN SE,NI RUPAINTERNATIONAL
: "Kuta Kemulihen"
:
Nelson TariganJr"rdul Karya Seni
Pernbuat Karya Seni
Identitas Karya Seni
Kategori Publikasi Karya
Seni
:(beri "'pada kategori yang tepat)
Hasil Penilaian Peer Review'.
Reviewer
-
2a. Nama Pameran
b. Pelaksanaan
c. Bahan karya seni
d. Tempat
e. Halaman
: Pameran Seni RLrpa lnternational
:24
slcl30 Novernber 2011:
Oil
on canvas: Auditoriurn Lobby Unirned
:2
Maksimal Tingkat tlasionaI
Medan.
2l
Oktober 2014-l
.1
V
Tilg1at
lnrerrrasiosalE
Tingkat Nasionaln
Tingkat LokalDrs.
Sugito,M.Pd
NIP.
19610427 198703Drs.
NIP
risman Silaban.
M.Si
Komponen
Yang
Dinilai
Nilai
Tingkat Internasional
/
V
N
a. Kelengkapan karya seni ( 10%)
b. Ruang lingkup dan kedalaman karya seni (30%) c. Kecukupan dan kemutahiran data/informasi karya
seni(30%)
d. Kualitas hasil karya seni (30%)
Totat
:
(100%)Pameran
Nilai Akhir
Yang Diperoleh Tingkat
Lokal
E
I
.lQ
ZU
zB,f
28
gTtr