LAMPIRAN
Lampiran 1. Data Nilai dan Volume Ekspor Cengkeh Indonesia dan Madagaskar
Tahun Nilai Ekspor (US$) Volume Ekspor (kg) Indonesia Madagaskar Indonesia Madagaskar 2008 7.251.121 30.108.217 4.251.418 8.308.441 2009 5.585.926 48.374.301 5.142.028 15.742.013 2010 12.580.578 31.684.770 6.007.927 8.305.914 2011 16.304.446 159.941.538 5.396.749 20.534.213 2012 24.767.357 167.744.463 5.940.677 19.168.146 2013 25.399.060 87.209.506 5.177.340 9.949.090 2014 33.834.027 114.161.596 9.136.458 11.754.273 2015 46.483.663 161.608.964 12.888.870 20.328.774 2016 41.568.960 149.865.409 12.754.369 20.895.625 2017 28.927.619 228.224.871 9.087.130 31.302.064 2018 101.746.314 146.156.209 20.249.116 21.059.286 Rata-
Rata 31.313.552 120.461.804 8.730.189 17.031.622
Lampiran 2. Data Nilai dan Volume Ekspor Cengkeh Indonesia dan Madagaskar Tahun Ke Negara Tujuan
Negara Tujuan
Tahun
Negara Eksportir (Indonesia)
Negara Eksportir (Madagaskar) Nilai
Ekspor (US$)
Volume Ekspor (Kg)
Nilai Ekspor
(US$)
Volume Ekspor (Kg)
Singapura
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018
546.773 142.844 1.239.371 1.427.966 4.388.569 4.642.377 7.759.441 10.815.441 3.525.417 3.034.607 10.000.321
199.053 327.856 412.713 427.359 549.827 602.828 746.48 1.403.888 691.258 512.862 1.514.597
17.607.273 21.238.206 14.173.139 84.343.661 45.600.666 23.492.239 16.540.335 21.368.906 59.306.794 82.666.372 44.634.449
4.530.558 6.844.010 3.551.026 9.743.403 4.710.473 2.318.918 1.618.734 2.698.048 7.524.606 10.747.450 6.330.500
India
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018
836.994 1.010.688 1.018.929 6.670.735 2.422.357 473.404 3.414.689 6.603.518 5.687.099 4.687.554 23.835.267
769.194 2.242.354 1.355.796 2.319.564 1.381.132 314.762 2.918.704 2.418.269 2.535.904 2.629.007 4.490.243
1.862.905 10.945.524 3.728.720 32.116.542 42.492.980 22.381.870 40.501.259 84.338.626 46.438.286 69.900.128 46.416.456
565.02 3.639.762 1.016.450 5.280.149 5.248.215 2.987.084 4.686.598 10.858.857 7.377.090 10.607.096 6.982.404
Vietnam
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018
96.618 551.181 3.281.262 2.375.603 2.667.298 2.283.607 1.168.806 2.870.968 5.589.541 1.512.424 14.948.011
304.509 567.025 875.661 778.184 1.245.541 1.167.809 1.287.343 3.224.128 3.834.246 1.109.458 5.249.813
1.276.027 3.788.440 2.013.760 4.118.157 9.019.667 7.627.776 7.448.712 12.241.850 17.094.365 42.531.125 12.043.076
598 1.541.550 632.25 977.8 1.721.612 1.048.204 684.05 1.496.200 2.052.591 5.160.670 1.435.140
Amerika Serikat
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016
1.078.925 607.077 1.016.120 1.312.356 3.458.480 5.903.290 5.575.000 5.331.300 2.665.599
261.077 209.655 239.193 234.262 337.914 491.938 397.084 593.754 384.748
1.397.443 1.490.207 1.664.006 3.832.126 6.018.663 2.322.253 3.409.114 3.273.743 1.596.086
391.747 397.821 377,75 431,08 569,8 218,41 296.503 394.812 205.016
2017 2018
3.353.642 6.137.685
415.177 802.412
2.123.302 790.765
307.798 116.305
Uni Emirat
Arab
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018
142.830 133.783 163.644 16.009 85.979 14.460 317.014 1.524.050 2.001.716 1.453.871 5.300.540
397.995 189.633 300.949 33.981 75,31
12,2 69.131 316.309 334.974 211.881 807.758
1.644.400 2.552.151 2.237.523 2.393.545 8.300.397 5.664.585 5.121.373 8.348.926 4.541.754 2.221.069 3.757.152
495,9 782 543.045 345.015 928,71 581.514 575.411 1.040.661 737.951 374.435 634.915
Arab Saudi
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018
1.247.742 1.031.217 2.615.489 1.303.575 2.878.306 3.462.137 5.110.675 5.010.548 7.938.248 3.979.811 14.313.803
561.273 413.858
650,05 197
453,48 396.393 466.053 720.285 1.327.043
562.22 1.787.460
297.778 885.270 934.213 2.098.804 10.602.557 2.601.178 4.211.724 3.115.629 1.781.119 1.627.950 2.102.951
75 274 252,25 249 1.069.500 262,45 407,8 360,5 236 230 311,34
Lampiran 3. Hasil Analisis Daya Saing Cengkeh Indonesia dan Madagaskar Ke Pasar Dunia Menggunakan Metode RCA
Negara Tahun Xij Xj Xiw Xw Xij/Xj Xiw/Xw RCA Indeks
RCA
Indonesia
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018
7.251.121 5.585.926 12.580.578 16.304.446 24.767.357 25.399.060 33.834.027 46.483.663 41.568.960 28.927.619 101.746.314
137.020.424.402 116.509.991.781 157.779.103.470 203.496.619.185 190.031.839.234 182551754383 176036194332 150366281305 144489796418 168810042930 180.215.034.437
150.628.000 171.008.000 159.610.000 737.061.000 418.228.000 337.868.000 410.723.000 361.370.000 392.657.000 500.988.000 438.073.000
16.007.659.828.000 12.384.813.282.000 15.098.981.170.000 18.141.372.916.000 18.399.990.900.000 18.858.726.557.000 18.862.399.126.000 16.416.895.796.000 15.923.096.945.000 17.561.440.015.000 19.327.897.410.000
0,000053 0,000048 0,000080 0,000080 0,000130 0,000139 0,000192 0,000309 0,000288 0,000171 0,000565
0,000009 0,000014 0,000011 0,000041 0,000023 0,000018 0,000022 0,000022 0,000025 0,000029 0,000023
5,62 3,47 7,54 1,97 5,73 7,77 8,83 14,04 11,67 6,01 24,91
0,21 0,62 2,17 0,26 2,91 1,35 1,14 1,59 0,83 0,51 4,15
Rata-Rata 8,87 1,43
Madagaskar
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018
30.108.217 48.374.301 31.684.770 159.941.538 167.744.463 87.209.506 114.161.596 161.608.964 149.865.409 228.224.871 146.156.209
1.667.400.686 1.095.897.922 1.082.167.741 1.259.683.023 1.224.513.561 1.626.888.977 2.243.189.647 2.164.461.193 2.261.351.178 2.851.663.745 3.133.017.751
150.628.000 171.008.000 159.610.000 737.061.000 418.228.000 337.868.000 410.723.000 361.370.000 392.657.000 500.988.000 438.073.000
16.007.659.828.000 12.384.813.282.000 15.098.981.170.000 18.141.372.916.000 18.399.990.900.000 18.858.726.557.000 18.862.399.126.000 16.416.895.796.000 15.923.096.945.000 17.561.440.015.000 19.327.897.410.000
0,02 0,04 0,03 0,13 0,14 0,05 0,05 0,07 0,07 0,08 0,05
0,000009 0,000014 0,000011 0,000041 0,000023 0,000018 0,000022 0,000022 0,000025 0,000029 0,000023
1.918,97 3.196,82 2.769,77 3.125,12 6.026,83 2.992,07 2.337,23 3.391,99 2.687,49 2.805,42 2.058,22
0,75 1,67 0,87 1,13 1,93 0,50 0,78 1,45 0,79 1,04 0,73
Rata-Rata 3.028,18 1,06
Lampiran 4. Hasil Analisis Daya Saing Cengkeh Indonesia Ke Negara Tujuan Menggunakan Metode RCA
NegaraTujuan Tahun Xij Xj Xiw Xw Xij/Xj Xiw/Xw RCA Indeks
RCA
Singapura
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018
546.773 142.844 1.239.371 1.427.966 4.388.569 4.642.377 7.759.441 10.815.441 3.525.417 3.034.607 10.000.321
17.135.025.448 16.686.238.643 16.752.339.986 12.632.634.348 17.135.025.448 16.686.238.643 16.752.339.986 12.632.634.348 11.246.431.902 12.767.192.917 12.991.592.744
40.793.022 50.343.785 23.790.518 176.900.480 106.596.467 63.200.730 53.988.022 44.458.093 90.308.160 107.808.577 76.049.969
323.019.797.003 247.216.196.618 313.071.073.658 372.640.256.623 385.832.691.727 388.046.698.517 377.937.643.311 308.121.655.073 291.908.368.784 327.709.713.161 370.503.520.526
0,000032 0,000009 0,000074 0,000113 0,000256 0,000278 0,000463 0,000856 0,000314 0,000238 0,000770
0,00013 0,00020 0,00008 0,00047 0,00028 0,00016 0,00014 0,00014 0,00031 0,00033 0,00021
0,25 0,04 0,97 0,24 0,93 1,71 3,24 5,93 1,01 0,72 3,75
0,03 0,17 23,16 0,24 3,89 1,84 1,90 1,83 0,17 0,71 5,19
Rata-Rata 1,71 3,56
India
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018
836.994 1.010.688 1.018.929 6.670.735 2.422.357 473.404 3.414.689 6.603.518 5.687.099 4.687.554 23.835.267
7.163.336.232 7.432.892.524 9.915.038.943 13.335.706.464 12.496.314.269 13.031.302.738 12.248.959.579 11.731.001.096 10.093.804.356 14.083.572.994 13.725.675.911
42.801.166 36.517.024 50.255.831 75.573.091 90.618.283 61.080.430 104.523.385 150.641.327 141.564.272 158.028.837 136.191.017
315.712.105.614 266.401.552.908 350.029.386.927 462.402.790.771 488.976.378.496 466.045.567.333 459.369.463.603 390.744.731.405 356.704.792.107 444.052.353.836 507.615.733.027
0,00012 0,00014 0,00010 0,00050 0,00019 0,00004 0,00028 0,00056 0,00056 0,00033 0,00174
0,00014 0,00014 0,00014 0,00016 0,00019 0,00013 0,00023 0,00039 0,00040 0,00036 0,00027
0,86 0,99 0,72 3,06 1,05 0,28 1,23 1,46 1,42 0,94 6,47
0,07 1,15 0,72 4,28 0,34 0,26 4,42 1,19 0,97 0,66 6,92
Rata-Rata 1,68 1,91
Vietnam
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018
96.618 551.181 3.281.262 2.375.603 2.667.298 2.283.607 1.168.806 2.870.968 5.589.541 1.512.424 14.948.011
1.672.903.368 1.454.233.868 1.946.220.540 2.354.191.428 2.273.693.205 2.400.879.753 2.451.196.725 2.740.178.896 3.045.496.445 3.587.475.436 4.583.936.595
239.058 143.040 363.570 1.057.568 1.154.745 1.165.365 956.356 708.970 1.405.765 1.650.590 1.008.000
80.713.829.087 69.948.810.000 84.838.552.670 106.749.853.535 113.780.430.859 132.032.531.179 147.839.047.559 165.775.857.847 174.978.350.264 213.215.299.139 236.868.822.761
0,00006 0,00038 0,00169 0,00101 0,00117 0,00095 0,00048 0,00105 0,00184 0,00042 0,00326
0,0000030 0,0000020 0,0000043 0,0000099 0,0000101 0,0000088 0,0000065 0,0000043 0,0000080 0,0000077 0,0000043
19,50 185,35 393,42 101,86 115,59 107,76 73,71 244,99 228,45 54,46 766,29
0,09 9,50 2,12 0,26 1,13 0,93 0,68 3,32 0,93 0,24 14,07
Rata-Rata 208,31 3,03
Amerika Serikat
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018
1.078.925 607.077 1.016.120 1.312.356 3.458.480 5.903.290 5.575.000 5.331.300 2.665.599 3.353.642 6.137.685
13.079.933.994 10.889.078.628 14.301.875.648 16.497.615.839 14.910.181.324 15.741.131.921 16.560.075.701 16.268.488.416 16.171.284.269 17.810.479.989 18.471.771.383
5.235.149 6.126.628 6.650.895 10.091.051 17.790.274 19.731.431 16.647.372 17.657.101 12.709.000 14.353.000 14.160.790
2.164.834.031.060 1.601.895.815.130 1.968.259.900.993 2.263.619.062.869 2.334.677.716.383 2.326.590.208.528 2.410.855.476.207 2.313.424.569.327 2.247.167.254.438 2.405.276.626.657 2.611.432.490.157
0,00008 0,00006 0,00007 0,00008 0,00023 0,00038 0,00034 0,00033 0,00016 0,00019 0,00033
0,0000024 0,0000038 0,0000034 0,0000045 0,0000076 0,0000085 0,0000069 0,0000076 0,0000057 0,0000060 0,0000054
34,11 14,58 21,03 17,84 30,44 44,22 48,75 42,94 29,15 31,55 61,28
1,34 0,43 1,44 0,85 1,71 1,45 1,10 0,88 0,68 1,08 1,94
Rata-Rata 34,17 1,17
Uni Emirat
Arab
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013
142.830 133.783 163.644 16.009 85.979 14.460
1.652.087.435 1.265.836.373 1.475.344.153 1.734.502.265 1.619.000.949 1.589.066.711
7.937.404 7.869.928 7.796.249 9.658.248 4.783.349 21.845.278
175.485.699.238 164.251.000.000 187.001.000.000 210.945.000.000 261.022.920.180 294.955.904.012
0,00009 0,00011 0,00011 0,00001 0,00005 0,00001
0,000045 0,000048 0,000042 0,000046 0,000018 0,000074
1,91 2,21 2,66 0,20 2,90 0,12
0,1795 1,1540 1,2062 0,0758 14,3758 0,0424
2014 2015 2016 2017 2018
317.014 1.524.050 2.001.716 1.453.871 5.300.540
2.503.133.955 1.926.403.037 1.612.105.635 1.630.063.289 1.460.698.874
38.744.564 25.022.525 17.578.917 21.882.416 20.322.791
298.608.729.224 287.024.695.498 270.779.148.786 257.686.922.234 244.645.890.108
0,00013 0,00079 0,00124 0,00089 0,00363
0,000130 0,000087 0,000065 0,000085 0,000083
0,98 9,07 19,13 10,50 43,68
7,9444 9,2972 2,1076 0,5491 4,1591
Rata-Rata
8,49 3,74Arab Saudi
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018
1.247.742 1.031.217 2.615.489 1.303.575 2.878.306 3.462.137 5.110.675 5.010.548 7.938.248 3.979.811 14.313.803
1.191.949.529 956.245.242 1.167.296.586 1.430.125.699 1.776.506.999 1.734.016.654 2.156.325.133 2.060.685.084 1.333.074.993 1.380.375.130 1.222.426.859
1.261.868 2.158.584 2.165.336 1.406.402 3.720.538 5.189.073 8.200.222 6.908.690 6.920.541 8.351.217 17.850.761
112.273.148.075 92.457.155.434 103.621.530.060 127.962.726.620 151.260.012.541 163.013.498.700 168.239.638.203 174.785.637.598 140.169.249.878 134.519.129.744 135.211.178.073
0,0010 0,0011 0,0022 0,0009 0,0016 0,0020 0,0024 0,0024 0,0060 0,0029 0,0117
0,000011 0,000023 0,000021 0,000011 0,000025 0,000032 0,000049 0,000040 0,000049 0,000062 0,000132
93,14 46,19 107,23 82,93 65,87 62,72 48,63 61,52 120,61 46,44 88,69
0,45 0,50 2,32 0,77 0,79 0,95 0,78 1,27 1,96 0,39 1,91
Rata-Rata
74,91 1,10Lampiran 5. Hasil Analisis Daya Saing Cengkeh Madagaskar Ke Negara Tujuan Menggunakan Metode RCA
NegaraTujuan Tahun Xij Xj Xiw Xw Xij/Xj Xiw/Xw RCA Indeks
RCA
Singapura
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018
17.607.273 21.238.206 14.173.139 84.343.661 45.600.666 23.492.239 16.540.335 21.368.906 59.306.794 82.666.372 44.634.449
22.823.192 23.997.131 18.478.998 92.036.414 49.528.290 26.653.067 22.371.643 31.250.079 70.738.383 84.305.663 50.312.483
40.793.022 50.343.785 23.790.518 176.900.480 106.596.467 63.200.730 53.988.022 44.458.093 90.308.160 107.808.577 76.049.969
323.019.797.003 247.216.196.618 313.071.073.658 372.640.256.623 385.832.691.727 388.046.698.517 377.937.643.311 308.121.655.073 291.908.368.784 327.709.713.161 370.503.520.526
0,77 0,89 0,77 0,92 0,92 0,88 0,74 0,68 0,84 0,98 0,89
0,00013 0,00020 0,00008 0,00047 0,00028 0,00016 0,00014 0,00014 0,00031 0,00033 0,00021
6.108,84 4.346,00 10.093,15 1.930,43 3.332,53 5.411,77 5.175,70 4.739,17 2.710,00 2.980,63 4.322,03
0,98 0,71 2,32 0,19 1,73 1,62 0,96 0,92 0,57 1,10 1,45
Rata-Rata 4.650,02 1,14
India
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018
1.862.905 10.945.524 3.728.720 32.116.542 42.492.980 22.381.870 40.501.259 84.338.626 46.438.286 69.900.128 46.416.456
10.596.480 20.817.108 46.107.316 56.989.494 67.117.625 39.612.291 68.220.721 118.549.280 84.653.327 90.006.738 77.318.058
42.801.166 36.517.024 50.255.831 75.573.091 90.618.283 61.080.430 104.523.385 150.641.327 141.564.272 158.028.837 136.191.017
315.712.105.614 266.401.552.908 350.029.386.927 462.402.790.771 488.976.378.496 466.045.567.333 459.369.463.603 390.744.731.405 356.704.792.107 444.052.353.836 507.615.733.027
0,18 0,53 0,08 0,56 0,63 0,57 0,59 0,71 0,55 0,78 0,60
0,000136 0,000137 0,000144 0,000163 0,000185 0,000131 0,000228 0,000386 0,000397 0,000356 0,000268
1.296,78 3.835,81 563,26 3.448,16 3.416,27 4.311,15 2.609,16 1.845,34 1.382,25 2.182,23 2.237,58
0,49 2,96 0,15 6,12 0,99 1,26 0,61 0,71 0,75 1,58 1,03
Rata-Rata 2.466,18 1,51
Vietnam
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018
1.276.027 3.788.440 2.013.760 4.118.157 9.019.667 7.627.776 7.448.712 12.241.850 17.094.365 42.531.125 12.043.076
1.717.199 5.115.933 3.201.751 7.085.427 15.759.192 12.910.217 18.848.163 26.331.026 35.813.920 57.265.886 25.709.164
239.058 143.040 363.570 1.057.568 1.154.745 1.165.365 956.356 708.970 1.405.765 1.650.590 1.008.000
80.713.829.087 69.948.810.000 84.838.552.670 106.749.853.535 113.780.430.859 132.032.531.179 147.839.047.559 165.775.857.847 174.978.350.264 213.215.299.139 236.868.822.761
0,74 0,74 0,63 0,58 0,57 0,59 0,40 0,46 0,48 0,74 0,47
0,0000030 0,0000020 0,0000043 0,0000099 0,0000102 0,0000088 0,0000065 0,0000043 0,0000080 0,0000077 0,0000043
250.890,32 362.124,91 146.765,97 58.667,27 56.394,67 66.939,64 61.091,63 108.710,80 59.411,80 95.937,86 110.077,07
1,53 1,44 0,41 0,40 0,96 1,19 0,91 1,78 0,55 1,61 1,15
Rata-Rata 125.182,9 1,08
Amerika Serikat
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018
1.397.443 1.490.207 1.664.006 3.832.126 6.018.663 2.322.253 3.409.114 3.273.743 1.596.086 2.123.302 790.765
364.733.588 196.031.479 44.519.551 34.840.600 54.384.912 126.959.663 186.983.549 234.521.967 292.396.342 531.390.573 646.740.789
5.235.149 6.126.628 6.650.895 10.091.051 17.790.274 19.731.431 16.647.372 17.657.101 12.709.000 14.353.000 14.160.790
2.164.834.031.060 1.601.895.815.130 1.968.259.900.993 2.263.619.062.869 2.334.677.716.383 2.326.590.208.528 2.410.855.476.207 2.313.424.569.327 2.247.167.254.438 2.405.276.626.657 2.611.432.490.157
0,0038 0,0076 0,0374 0,1100 0,1107 0,0183 0,0182 0,0140 0,0055 0,0040 0,0012
0,0000024 0,0000038 0,0000034 0,0000045 0,0000076 0,0000085 0,0000069 0,0000076 0,0000057 0,0000060 0,0000054
1.584,36 1.987,62 11.061,31 24.672,95 14.523,32 2.156,78 2.640,36 1.828,93 965,18 669,61 225,48
0,65 1,25 5,57 2,23 0,59 0,15 1,22 0,69 0,53 0,69 0,34
Rata-Rata 5.665,08 1,27
Uni Emirat
Arab
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013
1.644.400 2.552.151 2.237.523 2.393.545 8.300.397 5.664.585
4.726.186 13.133.106 34.879.581 15.758.732 11.153.033 10.475.334
7.937.404 7.869.928 7.796.249 9.658.248 4.783.349 21.845.278
175.485.699.238 164.251.000.000 187.001.000.000 210.945.000.000 261.022.920.180 294.955.904.012
0,35 0,19 0,06 0,15 0,74 0,54
0,00004523 0,00004791 0,00004169 0,00004579 0,00001833 0,00007406
7.692,37 4.055,80 1.538,70 3.317,35 40.611,82 7.301,29
2,13 0,53 0,38 2,16 12,24 0,18
2014 2015 2016 2017 2018
5.121.373 8.348.926 4.541.754 2.221.069 3.757.152
9.033.721 14.199.231 24.650.002 78.917.397 108.905.854
38.744.564 25.022.525 17.578.917 21.882.416 20.322.791
298.608.729.224 287.024.695.498 270.779.148.786 257.686.922.234 244.645.890.108
0,57 0,59 0,18 0,03 0,03
0,00012975 0,00008718 0,00006492 0,00008492 0,00008307
4.369,30 6.744,56 2.838,11 331,43 415,30
0,60 1,54 0,42 0,12 1,25
Rata-Rata 7.201,46 1,96
Arab Saudi
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018
297.778 885.270 934.213 2.098.804 10.602.557 2.601.178 4.211.724 3.115.629 1.781.119 1.627.950 2.102.951
422.856 1.038.859 1.372.812 3.871.799 11.351.884 3.233.448 4.673.370 3.950.111 2.869.948 3.242.264 3.788.011
1.261.868 2.158.584 2.165.336 1.406.402 3.720.538 5.189.073 8.200.222 6.908.690 6.920.541 8.351.217 17.850.761
112.273.148.075 92.457.155.434 103.621.530.060 127.962.726.620 151.260.012.541 163.013.498.700 168.239.638.203 174.785.637.598 140.169.249.878 134.519.129.744 135.211.178.073
0,70 0,85 0,68 0,54 0,93 0,80 0,90 0,79 0,62 0,50 0,56
0,0000024 0,0000038 0,0000034 0,0000045 0,0000076 0,0000085 0,0000069 0,0000076 0,0000057 0,0000060 0,0000054
62.655,92 36.499,82 32.565,63 49.321,14 37.971,79 25.271,90 18.489,81 19.954,76 12.569,89 8.087,74 4.205,08
1,86 0,58 0,89 1,51 0,77 0,67 0,73 1,08 0,63 0,64 0,52
Rata-Rata 27.963,04 0,90
Lampiran 6. Hasil Analisis Daya Saing Cengkeh Indonesia Ke Negara Tujuan Menggunakan Metode EPD
Negara
Tujuan Tahun
Sumbu x Xivj/Wivj
Sumbu y Xivt/Wt
Average Growth x
Average
Growth y Matriks Posisi EPD
Singapura
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018
0,013403591 0,002837371 0,052095167 0,008072143 0,041169929 0,073454484 0,143725232 0,243272715 0,039037635 0,028148104 0,131496714
0,053046363 0,067496543 0,053509702 0,033900348 0,044410507 0,043000594 0,044325672 0,040998853 0,038527268 0,038958848 0,035064694
N/A -0,01056622 0,049257796 -0,044023023 0,033097786 0,032284555 0,070270748 0,099547483 -0,20423508 -0,010889531 0,10334861 0,320947251
N/A 0,01445018 -0,013986841 -0,019609354 0,010510159 -0,001409913 0,001325078 -0,003326819 -0,002471585 0,00043158 -0,003894154
0,000917596 FALLING STAR
Rata-Rata 0,03991 -0,00155
India
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018
0,019555402 0,027677173 0,020274841 0,088268654 0,026731438 0,007750502 0,032669139 0,043836032 0,040173265 0,029662649 0,175013503
0,022689457 0,027901086 0,028326304 0,028840022 0,025556069 0,027961435 0,026664723 0,030022161 0,028297361 0,031716019 0,027039501
N/A 0,008121771 -0,007402332 0,067993812 -0,061537216 -0,018980936 0,024918637 0,011166893 -0,003662767 -0,010510615 0,145350854 0,137669446
N/A 0,521162861 0,042521877 0,051371724 -0,328395217 0,240536537 -0,129671162 0,335743747 -0,172479941 0,3418658 -0,467651864
-0,234981107 RISING STAR
Rata-Rata 0,01555 0,04350
Vietnam
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018
0,404161333 3,853334732 9,025117584 2,246288655 2,309858887 1,959563742 1,22214531 4,049491516 3,976156043 0,916292962 14,82937599
0,020726354 0,020789973 0,022940285 0,022053346 0,019983166 0,018184002 0,016580171 0,016529421 0,01740499 0,0168256 0,019352216
N/A 3,449173398 5,171782852 -6,778828929 0,063570232 -0,350295145 -0,737418432 2,827346206 -0,073335473 -3,059863081 13,91308303 -9,34002741
N/A 0,000064 0,002150 -0,000887 -0,002070 -0,001799 -0,001604 -0,000051 0,000876 -0,000579 0,002527
0,000981 FALLING STAR
Rata-Rata 0,46229 -00004
Amerika Serikat
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018
0,20609251 0,099088275 0,152779438 0,130051468 0,194402852 0,299182051 0,334887693 0,301935182 0,20974105 0,233654428 0,433428149
0,006042003 0,00679762 0,007266254 0,007288159 0,006386398 0,006765752 0,006868962 0,00703221 0,007196298 0,007404753 0,007073425
N/A -0,107004235 0,053691163 -0,02272797 0,064351383 0,104779199 0,035705642 -0,032952511 -0,092194132 0,023913378 0,199773721 -0,034264317
N/A 0,000756 0,000469 0,000022 -0,000902 0,000379 0,000103 0,000163 0,000164 0,000208 -0,000331
-0,000112 RISING STAR
Rata-Rata 0,01755 0,00008
Uni Emirat
Arab
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018
0,017994548 0,016999266 0,020990094 0,001657547 0,017974645 0,000661928 0,008182154 0,060907123 0,113870269 0,06644015 0,260817523
0,009414371 0,007706719 0,007889499 0,008222533 0,006202524 0,005387472 0,008382655 0,006711628 0,005953581 0,006325751 0,005970666
N/A -0,00100 0,00399 -0,01933 0,01632 -0,01731 0,00752 0,05272 0,05296 -0,04743 0,19438 0,21647
N/A -0,00171 0,00018 0,00033 -0,00202 -0,00082 0,00300 -0,00167 -0,00076 0,00037 -0,00036
-0,00087 FALLING STAR
Rata-Rata 0,04175 -0,00039
Arab Saudi
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018
0,988805485 0,477728455 1,2078906 0,926886481 0,773626287 0,66719759 0,623236176 0,725252978 1,147055989 0,476554615 0,80185954
0,010616515 0,010342577 0,011265 0,011176111 0,011744723 0,010637258 0,012816986 0,011789785 0,009510467 0,010261553 0,009040871
N/A -0,51107703 0,730162145 -0,281004119 -0,153260193 -0,106428697 -0,043961414 0,102016803 0,42180301 -0,670501374 0,325304925 0,052863988
N/A -0,000274 0,000922 -0,000089 0,000569 -0,001107 0,002180 -0,001027 -0,002279 0,000751 -0,001221 1546,999638
LOST OPPORTUNITY
Rata-Rata -0,01219 140,63619
Lampiran 7. Hasil Analisis Daya Saing Cengkeh Madagaskar Ke Negara Tujuan Menggunakan Metode EPD
Negara
Tujuan Tahun
Sumbu x Xivj/Wivj
Sumbu y Xivt/Wt
Average Growth x
Average
Growth y Matriks Posisi EPD
Singapura
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018
0,431624629 0,421863513 0,59574739 0,476785936 0,42778778 0,371708349 0,306370458 0,48065278 0,656715783 0,766788453 0,586909496
0,00007066 0,00009707 0,00005902 0,00024699 0,00012837 0,00006869 0,00005919 0,00010142 0,00024233 0,00025726 0,00013580
N/A -0,0097611 0,1738839 -0,1189615 -0,0489982 -0,0560794 -0,0653379 0,1742823 0,1760630 0,1100727 -0,1798790 -0,2700222
N/A 0,0000264 -0,0000380 0,0001880 -0,0001186 -0,0000597 -0,0000095 0,0000422 0,0001409 0,0000149 -0,0001215
-0,0001037 RETREAT
Rata-Rata -0,010431 -0,000004
India
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018
0,04352463 0,29973757 0,07419477 0,42497325 0,46892281 0,36643275 0,38748515 0,55986380 0,32803677 0,44232514 0,34081878
0,00003356 0,00007814 0,00013172 0,00012325 0,00013726 0,00008500 0,00014851 0,00030339 0,00023732 0,00020269 0,00015232
N/A 0,25621294 -0,22554280 0,35077848 0,04394956 -0,10249006 0,02105239 0,17237866 -0,23182704 0,11428838 -0,10150637 -0,00347123
N/A 0,00004458 0,00005358 -0,00000848 0,00001402 -0,00005226 0,00006351 0,00015488 -0,00006607 -0,00003463 -0,00005038
0,00000689 RISING STAR
Rata-Rata 0,026711 0,000011
Vietnam
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018
5,337729756 26,48517897 5,53885084 3,893987904 7,810959995 6,545396507 7,788639377 17,2670917 12,1601868 25,76722566 11,94749603
0,00002128 0,00007314 0,00003774 0,00006637 0,00013851 0,00009778 0,00012749 0,00015884 0,00020468 0,00026858 0,00010854
N/A 21,14744921 -20,94632813 -1,64486294 3,91697209 -1,26556349 1,24324287 9,47845232 -5,10690489 13,60703886 -13,81972963 -5,90873477
N/A 0,00005186 -0,00003540 0,00002863 0,00007213 -0,00004072 0,00002971 0,00003134 0,00004584 0,00006391 -0,00016004
-0,00002405 RISING STAR
Rata-Rata 0,063730 0,000006
Amerika Serikat
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018
0,266934714 0,243234451 0,250192794 0,379754894 0,33831199 0,117693086 0,204783914 0,185406596 0,125587064 0,147934369 0,05584187
0,00016848 0,00012238 0,00002262 0,00001539 0,00002329 0,00005457 0,00007756 0,00010137 0,00013012 0,00022093 0,00024766
N/A -0,02370026 0,00695834 0,12956210 -0,04144290 -0,22061890 0,08709083 -0,01937732 -0,05981953 0,02234730 -0,09209250 -0,03432902
N/A -0,00004611 -0,00009976 -0,00000723 0,00000790 0,00003127 0,00002299 0,00002382 0,00002874 0,00009081 0,00002673 -0,00004004
LOST OPPORTUNITY
Rata-Rata -0,022311 0,000004
Uni Emirat
Arab
2008 2009 2010 2011
0,20717101 0,32429153 0,28699994 0,24782393
0,00002693 0,00007996 0,00018652 0,00007471
N/A 0,11712052 -0,03729159 -0,03917601
N/A 0,00005303 0,00010656 -0,00011182
LOST OPPORTUNITY
2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018
1,73526895 0,25930478 0,13218301 0,33365642 0,25836370 0,10150017 0,18487382
0,00004273 0,00003551 0,00003025 0,00004947 0,00009103 0,00030625 0,00044516
1,48744502 -1,47596417 -0,12712177 0,20147341 -0,07529272 -0,15686353 0,08337365 -0,06303108
-0,00003198 -0,00000721 -0,00000526 0,00001922 0,00004156 0,00021522 0,00013890 -0,00010368
Rata-Rata -0,007757 0,000029
Arab Saudi
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018
0,23598189 0,41011608 0,43144020 1,49232154 2,84973759 0,50127990 0,51361097 0,45097247 0,25736702 0,19493566 0,11780736
0,0000038 0,0000112 0,0000132 0,0000303 0,0000750 0,0000198 0,0000278 0,0000226 0,0000205 0,0000241 0,0000280
N/A 0,1741342 0,0213241 1,0608813 1,3574161 -2,3484577 0,0123311 -0,0626385 -0,1936055 -0,0624314 -0,0771283 -0,0930808
N/A 0,0000075 0,0000020 0,0000170 0,0000448 -0,0000552 0,0000079 -0,0000052 -0,0000021 0,0000036 0,0000039 -0,0000213
LOST OPPORTUNITY
Rata-Rata -0,019205 0,0000003
Lampiran 8. Hasil Analisis Daya Saing Cengkeh Indonesia Menggunakan Metode ISP
Tahun Xij Mij Xij-Mij Xij+Mij ISP
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018
7.251.121 5.585.926 12.580.578 16.304.446 24.767.357 25.399.060 33.834.027 46.483.663 41.568.960 28.927.619 101.746.314
N/A 111.872 1.336.217 345.150.592 110.792.865 3.298.661 N/A 127.205 61.472.864 113.468.366 105.650.154
7.251.121 5.474.054 11.244.361 -328.846.146 -86.025.508 22.100.399 33.834.027 46.356.458 -19.903.904 -84.540.747 -3.903.840
7.251.121 5.697.798 13.916.795 361.455.038 135.560.222 28.697.721 33.834.027 46.610.868 103.041.824 142.395.985 207.396.468
1,00000 0,96073 0,80797 -0,90978 -0,63459 0,77011 1,00000 0,99454 -0,19316 -0,59370 -0,01882 Rata- Rata 0,28939
Lampiran 9. Hasil Analisis Daya Saing Cengkeh Madagaskar Menggunakan Metode ISP
Tahun Xij Mij Xij-Mij Xij+Mij ISP
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018
30.108.217 48.374.301 31.684.770 159.941.538 167.744.463 87.209.506 114.161.596 161.608.964 149.865.409 228.224.871 146.156.209
46.782 270 27.830 61 667.410 979.744 255.239 N/A N/A 337 231.817
30.061.435 48.374.031 31.656.940 159.941.477 167.077.053 86.229.762 113.906.357 161.608.964 149.865.409 228.224.534 145.924.392
30.154.999 48.374.571 31.712.600 159.941.599 168.411.873 88.189.250 114.416.835 161.608.964 149.865.409 228.225.208 146.388.026
0,99690 0,99999 0,99824 1,00000 0,99207 0,97778 0,99554 1,00000 1,00000 1,00000 0,99683 Rata- Rata 0,99612
