3(1*8-,$1.8$/,7$7,)7(5+$'$3-(1,6.2$*8/$1'$/$0
%$+$12/$+.$5(7
4XDOLWDWLYH$QDO\VLVRI&RDJXODQW7\SHLQWKH5DZ5XEEHU0DWHULDO 0LOL385%$<$GDQ'LGLQ68:$5',1 %DODL3HQHOLWLDQ6HPEDZD3XVDW3HQHOLWLDQ.DUHW -O5D\D3DOHPEDQJ²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
FRDJXODQW ´;µ 7KH WHVW UHVXOWV VKRZHG WKDW WKHFRDJXODQW´;µFRQWDLQHGVXOIDWHLRQVWKDW GHULYHGIURPVXOIXULFDFLG
.H\ZRUGV 5DZ UXEEHU PDWHULDO FRDJXODQW TXDOLWDWLYHDQDO\VLVUHDJHQW
$EVWUDN
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
FDPSXUDQ SHUHDNVL 1+ &O GDQ 1+ 2+
FDPSXUDQSHUHDNVLHWDQROGDQDVDPVXOIDW GDQ FDPSXUDQ SHUHDNVL +12 GDQ
DPPRQLXP PROLEGDW +DVLO SHQJXMLDQ VHQVLVWLYLWDV PHQXQMXNNDQ EDKZD EDKDQ SHQJJXPSDO QRQ DMXUDQ GDSDW GLGHWHNVL SDGDGRVLVPLQLPDOP//ODWHNVJ/ ODWHNV XQWXN FXNDSDUD DVDP VXOIDW P// ODWHNV J/ ODWHNV XQWXN SXSXN 763 GDQ P// ODWHNV J/ ODWHNV XQWXN WDZDV GHQJDQ NRQVHQWUDVL PDVLQJ PDVLQJ 3HQJXMLDQ NXDOLWDWLI LQL NHPXGLDQGLDSOLNDVLNDQXQWXNPHQJHWDKXL NDQGXQJDQ LRQ SDGD NRDJXODQ ´;µ +DVLO SHQJXMLDQ PHQXQMXNNDQ EDKZD NRDJXODQ ´;µ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
%HUGDVDUNDQ KDVLO VXUYHL 6\DULID $JXVWLQD 1DQF\ XQWXN SURYLQVL 6XPDWHUD 6HODWDQ VHEDJLDQ EHVDU SHWDQL PHQJJXQDNDQEDKDQSHPEHNXDVDPVXOIDW DWDX \DQJ OHELK GLNHQDO GHQJDQ VHEXWDQ ´FXNDSDUDµ 6HGDQJNDQ \DQJ PHQJJXQDNDQ EDKDQ SHPEHNX DQMXUDQ VHSHUWL DVDP VHPXW GDQ DVDS FDLU GHRUXE KDQ\DVHGLNLW\DLWXGDQVHPHQWDUD VLVDQ\D PHQJJXQDNDQ EDKDQ SHPEHNX EXNDQ DQMXUDQ VHSHUWL WDZDV SXSXN 763 GDQ JDGXQJ 3DGDKDO SHQJJXQDDQ EDKDQ SHPEHNXQRQDQMXUDQGDSDWPHQJDNLEDWNDQ SHQXUXQDQ PXWX ERNDU VHSHUWL UHQGDKQ\D QLODL SODVWLVLWDV DZDO 3R GDQ LQGHNV NHWDKDQDQ SODVWLVLWDV 35, VHUWD SHQLQJNDWDQ NDGDU DEX GDQ NDGDU NRWRUDQ 6ROLFKLQHW DO 5DFKPDZDQ 9DFKOHSLHWDO3XUED\DHWDO
$NLEDW \DQJ GLWLPEXONDQ DSDELOD ERNDU WHUVHEXW GLRODK PHQMDGL SURGXN MDGL PDND SURGXN NDUHW DNDQ WLGDN WDKDQ WHUKDGDS RNVLGDVL GDQ PHPLOLNL VLIDW PHNDQLN \DQJ UHQGDK
3HQ\HEDE XWDPD SHWDQL PDVLK PHQJJXQDNDQNRDJXODQQRQDQMXUDQDGDODK NDUHQD WLGDN DGD SHUEHGDDQ KDUJD \DQJ GLWHULPDSHWDQLMLNDPHQJJXQDNDQNRDJXODQ QRQ DQMXUDQ GHQJDQ NRDJXODQ DQMXUDQ +LQJJD VDDW LQL EHOXP DGD DODW SHQGHWHNVL DWDXPHWRGHNKXVXVXQWXNPHQJHWDKXLMHQLV EDKDQSHQJJXPSDO\DQJGLJXQDNDQSHWDQL VHKLQJJD SHWDQL PDVLK PHQJJXQDNDQ NRDJXODQ QRQ DQMXUDQ 8QWXN LWX SHUOX GLWHPXNDQDODWDWDXPHWRGHNKXVXVXQWXN PHQGHWHNVL EDKDQ SHQJJXPSDO \DQJ GLJXQDNDQ SHWDQL VHKLQJJD SHQJJXQDDQ NRDJXODQQRQDQMXUDQGDSDWGLKLQGDULGDQ XVDKD LQL GLKDUDSNDQ GDSDW PHQLQJNDWNDQ PXWX ERNDU SHWDQL GDQ PHPEHUL GDPSDN VLJQLILNDQ GDODP SHQLQJNDWDQ PXWX NDUHW DODP ,QGRQHVLD GL PDWD GXQLD 'DPSDN Q\DWD \DQJ GDSDW GLUDVDNDQ DGDODK NDUHW PHQWDK ,QGRQHVLD 765 DWDX 6,5 \DQJ GLRODKGDULERNDUMHQLVNRDJXOXPODSDQJDQ GDSDWOHELKEHUVDLQJGHQJDQNDUHW765GDUL QHJDUDSHQJKDVLONDUHWODLQVHSHUWL605 GDQ675 6DODK VDWX PHWRGH \DQJ GDSDW GLJXQDNDQ XQWXN PHQGHWHNVL NRDJXODQ DGDODK PHWRGH SHQJXMLDQ VHFDUD NXDOLWDWLI 0HWRGH LQL PHUXSDNDQ WHNQLN SHQJXMLDQ NDQGXQJDQNDWLRQDWDXDQLRQ3HQJXMLDQLQL GLODNXNDQ GHQJDQ SHQDPEDKDQ SHUHDNVL W H U W H Q W X \ D Q J P H Q J K D V L O N D Q HQGDSDQJHODWLQ DWDX SHUXEDKDQ ZDUQD \DQJPHUXSDNDQNDUDNWHULVWLNXQWXNLRQLRQ WHUWHQWX+HOPHQVWLQH 3HQHOLWLDQ LQL GLODNXNDQ XQWXN PHQJXML SHUHDNVLSHUHDNVL \DQJ GLGXJD GDSDWGLJXQDNDQVHEDJDLEDKDQSHQGHWHNVL NRDJXODQQRQDQMXUDQ0HWRGHLQLNHPXGLDQ G L D S O L N D V L N D Q X Q W X N P H Q J H W D K X L NDQGXQJDQLRQSDGDNRDJXODQ´;µVHKLQJJD GDSDWGLNHWDKXLDSDNDKNRDJXODQLQLGDSDW GLJXQDNDQVHEDJDLSHQJJXPSDODWDXWLGDN %$+$1'$10(72'( %DKDQ \DQJ GLJXQDNDQ GDODP SHQHOLWLDQ\DLWXODWHNVVHJDU\DQJGLSHUROHK GDUL .HEXQ 3HUFREDDQ %DODL 3HQHOLWLDQ
6HPEDZD NRDJXODQ DQMXUDQ DVDP IRUPDW
GDQDVDSFDLUGHRUXENRDJXODQQRQDQMXUDQ DVDP VXOIDWFXNDSDUD SXSXN 763 GDQ WDZDV \DQJ GLSHUROHK GDUL VXSSOLHU ORNDO 3HUHDNVL\DQJGLJXQDNDQWHUGLULGDUL%D&O
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´;µ \DQJ WLGDN GLNHWDKXL NRPSRVLVLQ\D %DKDQ SHQJJXPSDO ´;µ \DQJ GLSHUROHK GDUL &9 0XOWL7HNQLN6DUDQDEHUZXMXGFDLUDQMHUQLK 3HQJJXPSDODQ/DWHNV
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
3 H Q J X M L D Q L Q L G L O D N X N D Q G H Q J D Q PHUHDNVLNDQ SHUHDNVL NXDOLWDWLI GHQJDQ DLU UHQGDPDQ NRDJXOXP 'LPDQD NRDJXOXP \DQJ GLJXQDNDQ GLSHUROHK GDUL KDVLO SHQJJXPSDODQODWHNVGHQJDQPHQJJXQDNDQ EHUEDJDLPDFDPEDKDQSHQJJXPSDOGHQJDQ NRQVHQWUDVLGDQYDULDVLGRVLV GDQP//ODWHNV 3HQJXMLDQ .XDOLWDWLI GDODP 3HQHQWXDQ .DQGXQJDQ,RQSDGD.RDJXODQ´;µ 3HQJXMLDQ NXDOLWDWLI GLODNXNDQ GHQJDQ PHUHDNVLNDQ EHUEDJDL SHUHDNVL GHQJDQODUXWDQNRDJXODQPXUQLVHUXPKDVLO SHQJJXPSDODQGDQDLUUHQGDPDQNRDJXOXP \DQJ GLSHUROHK GDUL KDVLO SHQJJXPSDODQ ODWHNV GHQJDQ NRDJXODQ ´;µ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
SHNDW WHUNDQGXQJ DPPRQLD VHEDJDL EDKDQ SHQJDZHWODWHNV\DQJFXNXSWLQJJLVHKLQJJD XQWXN PHQJJXPSDONDQQ\D GLSHUOXNDQ VHQ\DZDDVDPNXDWVHSHUWLDVDPVXOIDW
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
VLQHUHVLV \DLWX VLIDWQ\D \DQJ GDSDW PHQJHOXDUNDQ DLU 6ROLFKLQ HW DO 9DFKOHSL 6ROLFKLQDNLEDWQ\DVHUXP NRDJXOXP DVDS FDLU GHRUXE DGDODK \DQJ SDOLQJEDQ\DN
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
7DEHO S+ ZDNWX GDQ NRQGLVL SHQJJXPSDODQ SDGD ODWHNV \DQJ GLJXPSDONDQ GHQJDQ EHUEDJDLNRDJXODQ 7DEOHS+WLPHDQGFRQGLWLRQRIFRDJXODWLRQIRUODWH[WKDWFRDJXODWHGZLWKYDULRXVFRDJXODQW &DPSXUDQNRDJXODQ\DQJWHUGLULGDULFDPSXUDQDVDPIRUPDWDVDPVXOIDWWDZDVSXSXN763GDQ DVDSFDLUGHRUXE 0L[HGFRDJXODQWWKDWFRQVLVWRIWKHPL[LQJRIIRUPLFDFLGVXOIXULFDFLG763IHUWLOL]HUDQGGHRUXEOLTXLG VPRNH *DPEDU3HQJDPDWDQYLVXDOVOHE\DQJGLJXPSDONDQGHQJDQEHUEDJDLEDKDQSHQJJXPSDO )LJXUH7KHYLVXDOREVHUYDWLRQRIVODEWKDWFRDJXODWHGZLWKYDULRXVFRDJXODQWV
3HQJXMLDQVHFDUD.XDOLWDWLI
+DVLO UHDNVL EHUEDJDL NRDJXODQ VHUXP NRDJXOXP GDQ DLU UHQGDPDQ NRDJXOXPGHQJDQEHUEDJDLPDFDPSHUHDNVL GDSDWGLOLKDWSDGD7DEHO
D 5HDNVL'HQJDQ%D&O
5HDJHQ %D&O GLJXQDNDQ XQWXN
PHQJLGHQWLILNDVLNDQGXQJDQLRQVXOIDW\DQJ WHUGDSDW GDODP VXDWX ODUXWDQ 6YHKOD x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
&D %D&O &D&O DT VE%D
6HGDQJNDQ NRDJXODQ DVDP IRUPDW GDQ DVDS FDLU GHRUXE WLGDN PHQJKDVLONDQ HQGDSDQ LQL PHQXQMXNNDQ EDKZD NHGXD NRDJXODQ LQL WLGDN PHQJDQGXQJ LRQ VXOIDW DWDXSXQLRQNDOVLXP
x 6HUXP+DVLO3HQJJXPSDODQ
6HPXD VHUXP SRVLWLI PHQJKDVLONDQ HQGDSDQ SXWLK NHFXDOL VHUXP KDVLO SHQJJXPSDODQ GHQJDQ NRDJXODQ DVDS FDLU 'HRUXE ,QL PHQXQMXNNDQ EDKZD VHPXD VHUXPPHQJDQGXQJLRQVXOIDWGDQNDOVLXP \DQJ EHUDNVL GHQJDQ %D&O PHQJKDVLONDQ
HQGDSDQ SXWLK ,RQ VXOIDW SDGD VHUXP EHUDVDOGDULNRDJXODQ\DQJGLJXQDNDQ\DLWX NRDJXODQWDZDVDWDXFXNDSDUD6HGDQJNDQ LRQNDOVLXPGDSDWEHUDVDOGDULNRDJXODQ763 DWDXGDULODWHNVNDUHQDVHFDUDDODPLODWHNV PHQJDQGXQJ LRQ NDOVLXP GLPDQD SDGD SHQJJXPSDODQ SDUWLNHO NDUHW DNDQ PHQJJXPSDO GDQ NDQGXQJDQ EXNDQ NDUHW VHSHUWLLRQLRQDQRUJDQLNGDQLRQLRQORJDP DNDQ WHUODUXW GDODP VHUXP $EHGQHJR
*DPEDU3HUVHQWDVHVHUXPKDVLOSHQJJXPSDODQODWHNVGHQJDQEHUEDJDLNRDJXODQ
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
7DEHO5HDNVL NRDJXODQ PXUQL VHUXP KDVLO SHQJJXPSDODQ GDQ DLU UHQGDPDQ VOHE GHQJDQEHUEDJDLPDFDPSHUHDNVL 7DEOH 7KHUHDFWLRQRISXUHFRDJXODQWWKHVHUXPDVFRDJXODQWLRQUHVXOWDQGWKHZDWHU LPPHUVLRQRIUDZUXEEHUPDWHULDOZLWKYDULRXVUHDJHQWV .HWHUDQJDQ5HPDNV 6LPERO¥PHQXQMXNNDQDGDQ\DSHUXEDKDQVDPSHOVHSHUWLZDUQDHQGDSDQDWDXEDX 6\PERO¥VKRZVWKDWWKHUHZDVDFKDQJHLQWKHVDPSOHDVFRORUVHGLPHQWRURGRU
x $LU5HQGDPDQ.RDJXOXP
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x .RDJXODQ0XUQL . R D J X O D Q W D Z D V S R V L W L I PHQJKDVLONDQJHODWLQSXWLK$O2+ EHJLWX
MXJD GHQJDQ NRDJXODQ FDPSXUDQ NDUHQD MXJD PHQJDQGXQJ LRQ DOXPXQLXP \DQJ E H U D V D O G D U L W D Z D V D O X P L Q L X P VXOIDW$O 62 .RDJXODQSXSXN763MXJD
PHQJKDVLONDQ JHODWLQ SXWLK NDUHQD SXSXN 763 PHQJDQGXQJ LRQ NDOVLXP \DQJ DNDQ EHUHDNVL GHQJDQ DPRQLDN PHQJKDVLONDQ NDOVLXP KLGURNVLGD &D2+ \DQJ
EHUEHQWXN JHODWLQ DWDX HQGDSDQ SXWLK 0HNDQLVPH UHDNVL \DQJ WHUMDGL DGDODK VHEDJDLEHULNXW
$O 62 DT1+ 2+ $O2+ DT VE1+ 62DT
&D 1+ 2+ &D2+ DT VE1+
x 6HUXP+DVLO3HQJJXPSDODQ
6HUXP KDVLO SHQJJXPSDODQ GHQJDQ SHQJJXPSDO WDZDV GDQ SXSXN 763 PHQJKDVLONDQ HQGDSDQ SXWLK VDPD VHSHUWL UHDNVL NRDJXODQ PXUQL 7HWDSL VHUXP KDVLO SHQJJXPSDODQ GHQJDQ NRDJXODQ ODLQQ\D MXJD PHQJKDVLONDQ HQGDSDQJHODWLQ SXWLK LQL PHQXQMXNNDQ EDKZD VHUXPVHUXP WHUVHEXW PHQJDQGXQJ LRQ NDOVLXP \DQJ VHFDUDDODPLWHUGDSDWGLGDODPODWHNVVHJDU
x $LU5HQGDPDQ.RDJXOXP
8QWXN XPXU VOHE KDUL KDQ\D DLU U H Q G D P D Q N R D J X O X P 7 6 3 \ D Q J PHQJKDVLONDQ VHGLNLW HQGDSDQ SXWLK \DQJ PHQXQMXNNDQNDQGXQJDQNDOVLXPSDGDDLU UHQGDPDQ NRDJXOXP 763 8QWXN XPXU VLPSDQ KDUL VHPXD DLU UHQGDPDQ NRDJXOXP WDZDV GDQ SXSXN 763 SRVLWLI PHQJKDVLONDQ HQGDSDQ SXWLK WHWDSL DLU U H Q G D P D Q N R D J X O D Q O D L Q Q \ D M X J D
PHQJKDVLONDQ HQGDSDQ SXWLK GHQJDQ MXPODK \DQJ OHELK VHGLNLW +DO LQL WHUMDGL GLGXJD EDKZD DLU UHQGDPDQ NRDJXOXP ODLQQ\DMXJDPHQJDQGXQJLRQNDOVLXP\DQJ EHUDVDOGDULODWHNVVHJDU3DGDXPXUVLPSDQ VOHEKDULWLGDNWDPSDNDGDQ\DHQGDSDQ DWDX JHODWLQ GL GDVDU WDEXQJ UHDNVL ,QL PHQXQMXNNDQ EDKZD NDQGXQJDQ LRQ DOXPLQLXP PDXSXQ LRQ NDOVLXP WLGDN WHUGHWHNVLODJLSDGDXPXUVLPSDQWHUVHEXW DNLEDWGDULVOHE\DQJWHODKNHULQJ F 5HDNVL.RDJXODQ'HQJDQ(WDQROGDQ + 62
3HUHDNVL HWDQRO GDQ DVDP VXOIDW GLJXQDNDQ XQWXN PHQGHWHNVL NDQGXQJDQ NDOVLXP WHUXWDPD SDGD SHQJJXQDDQ NRDJXODQQRQDQMXUDQ\DLWXSXSXN763,RQ NDOVLXP DNDQ EHUHDNVL GHQJDQ HWDQRO GDQ DVDP VXOIDW PHPEHQWXN HQGDSDQ JHODWLQ &D62 6YHKOD0HNDQLVPHUHDNVLQ\D
DGDODK
&D & + 2+ + 62 &D62 VE & + + 2
x .RDJXODQ0XUQL .RDJXODQ QRQ DQMXUDQ SXSXN 763 SRVLWLI PHQJKDVLONDQ HQGDSDQ SXWLK \DQJ PHQDQGDNDQNDQGXQJDQNDOVLXPGLGDODP SXSXN 763 .RDJXODQ FDPSXUDQ MXJD PHQJKDVLONDQ HQGDSDQ SXWLK NDUHQD MXJD PHQJDQGXQJLRQNDOVLXP\DQJEHUDVDOGDUL NRDJXODQSXSXN763 x 6HUXP+DVLO3HQJJXPSDODQ
6HPXD VHUXP SRVLWLI PHQJKDVLONDQ JHODWLQSXWLKGHQJDQMXPODK\DQJEHUEHGD 6HUXP GDUL KDVLO SHQJJXPSDODQ ODWHNV GHQJDQ PHQJJXQDNDQ NRDJXODQ QRQ DQMXUDQ SXSXN 763 PHQJKDVLONDQ SDOLQJ EDQ\DN JHODWLQ SXWLK NDUHQD PHQJDQGXQJ LRQNDOVLXP\DQJSDOLQJEDQ\DN\DQJEHUDVDO GDUL SXSXN 763 &D+ 32 6HGDQJNDQ
VHUXP \DQJ ODLQQ\D PHQJKDVLONDQ JHODWLQ GDODP MXPODK \DQJ VHGLNLW NDUHQD VHUXP VHUXP LQL PHQJDQGXQJ LRQ NDOVLXP \DQJ VHFDUDDODPLGLSHUROHKGDULODWHNVPXUQL
x $LU5HQGDPDQ.RDJXOXP
3DGD XPXU SHQ\LPSDQDQ KDUL WHUOLKDW DGDQ\D VHGLNLW JHODWLQ SDGD DLU UHQGDPDQ NRDJXOXP \DQJ EHUDVDO GDUL SXSXN 763 \DQJ PHQDQGDNDQ NDQGXQJDQ NDOVLXP GDODP NRDJXOXP 3DGD XPXU SHQ\LPSDQDQNRDJXOXPKDULKDVLOUHDNVL DLU UHQGDPDQ NRDJXOXP GHQJDQ SHUHDNVL HWDQRO GDQ DVDP VXOIDW PHQXQMXNNDQ WHUEHQWXNQ\D JHODWLQ SDGD VHPXD DLU
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x .RDJXODQ0XUQL 0DVLQJPDVLQJ NRDJXODQ VHWHODK GLWDPEDKNDQ +12 GDQ DPPRQLXP PROLEGDW WLGDN PHQXQMXNNDQ SHUXEDKDQ UHDNVLWHUXWDPDSDGDNRDJXODQSXSXN763 +DO LQL WHUMDGL GLGXJD EDKZD NDQGXQJDQ IRVIDWGLGDODPNRDJXODQSXSXN763GDODP MXPODK VDQJDW VHGLNLW VHKLQJJD VXOLW WHUGHWHNVLGHQJDQSHQJXMLDQLQL x 6HUXP+DVLO3HQJJXPSDODQ 6HPXDVHUXPPHQJKDVLONDQJHODWLQ DWDX HQGDSDQ ,QL PHQXQMXNNDQ EDKZD VHUXP ODWHNV PHQJDQGXQJ LRQ IRVIDW \DQJ GDSDWEHUDVDOGDULSXSXN763DWDXEHUDVDO GDUL ODWHNV NDUHQD VHFDUD DODPL ODWHNV PHQJDQGXQJ LRQ IRVIDW $EHGQHJR GLPDQDSDGDVDDWSURVHVSHQJJXPSDODQLRQ IRVIDW LQL WLGDN LNXW PHQJJXPSDO EHUVDPD SDUWLNHONDUHW
x $LU5HQGDPDQ.RDJXOXP
3DGDVHPXDXPXUVLPSDQVHPXDDLU UHQGDPDQ KDVLO UHDNVL PHQXQMXNNDQ WHUEHQWXNQ\DHQGDSDQDWDXJHODWLQGHQJDQ MXPODK\DQJEHUEHGD+DOLQLPHQXQMXNNDQ E D K Z D D L U U H Q G D P D Q N R D J X O X P PHQJDQGXQJLRQIRVIDWGLPDQDLRQLQLGDSDW EHUDVDO GDUL SHQJJXQDDQ SXSXN 763 PDXSXQLRQIRVIDW\DQJEHUDVDOGDULODWHNV 8ML6HQVLWLYLWDV.RDJXODQ
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¥PHQXQMXNNDQDGDQ\DSHUXEDKDQVDPSHOVHSHUWLZDUQDHQGDSDQDWDXEDX 6\PERO¥VKRZVWKDWWKHUHZDVDFKDQJHLQWKHVDPSOHDVFRORUVHGLPHQWRURGRU
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´;µ x 3HUHDNVL%D&O +DVLOUHDNVLNRDJXODQPXUQLVHUXP GDQ DLU UHQGDPDQ NRDJXOXP GDSDW GLOLKDW SDGD *DPEDU .RDJXODQ ´;µ SRVLWLI
PHQJKDVLONDQ HQGDSDQ SXWLK XQWXN NHWLJD SHUODNXDQ VHGDQJNDQ NRDJXODQ DVDP IRUPDW WLGDN PHQJKDVLONDQ HQGDSDQ ,QL PHQXQMXNNDQ EDKZD NRDJXODQ ´;µ SRVLWLI PHQJDQGXQJLRQVXOIDWDWDXLRQNDOVLXP,RQ VXOIDW GLGXJD EHUVXPEHU GDUL WDZDV DWDX FXNDSDUD VHGDQJNDQ LRQ NDOVLXP EHUVXPEHUGDULSXSXN763
x 3HUHDNVL1+ &OGDQ1+ 2+
5HDNVL NRDJXODQ PXUQL VHUXP GDQ DLU UHQGDPDQ NRDJXOXP GHQJDQ SHUHDNVL 1+ &O GDQ 1+ 2+ GDSDW GLOLKDW SDGD
*DPEDU .RDJXODQ GDQ DLU UHQGDPDQ NRDJXOXP´;µVDPDGHQJDQNRDJXODQGDQDLU UHQGDPDQ NRDJXOXP DVDP IRUPDW WLGDN PHQJKDVLONDQ HQGDSDQ LQL PHQXQMXNNDQ EDKZDNRDJXODQ´;µWLGDNPHQJDQGXQJLRQ DOXPLQLXP\DQJEHUVXPEHUGDULWDZDVGDQ LRQ NDOVLXP \DQJ EHUVXPEHU GDUL SXSXN 763 7HWDSL KDVLO UHDNVL VHUXP ´;µ PHQJKDVLONDQ HQGDSDQ SXWLK LQL GLGXJD EDKZD VHUXP WHUVHEXW PHQJDQGXQJ LRQ NDOVLXP\DQJVHFDUDDODPLWHUGDSDWGLGDODP ODWHNVVHJDU$EHGQHJR
*DPEDU5HDNVLNRDJXODQPXUQL,VHUXP,,GDQDLUUHQGDPDQNRDJXOXP,,,GHQJDQ SHUHDNVL%D&O D;GRVLVE;GRVLVGDQFDVDPIRUPDW )LJXUH7KHUHDFWLRQRISXUHFRDJXODQW,VHUXP,,DQGZDWHULPPHUVLRQRIFRDJXOXP,,,ZLWK UHDJHQW%D&O DFRDJXODQW´;µZLWKGRVDJHEFRDJXODQW´;µZLWKGRVDJH DQGFFRDJXODQWIRUPLFDFLG *DPEDU5HDNVLNRDJXODQPXUQL,VHUXP,,GDQDLUUHQGDPDQNRDJXOXP,,,GHQJDQ SHUHDNVL1+ &OGDQ1+ 2+D;GRVLVE;GRVLVGDQFDVDPIRUPDW )LJXUH7KHUHDFWLRQRISXUHFRDJXODQW,VHUXP,,DQGZDWHULPPHUVLRQRIFRDJXOXP,,,ZLWKUHDJHQWV1+ &ODQG1+ 2+ DFRDJXODQW´;µZLWKGRVDJHEFRDJXODQW´;µZLWK GRVDJHDQGFFRDJXODQWIRUPLFDFLG
x (WDQROGDQ+ 62 +DVLOUHDNVLNRDJXODQPXUQLVHUXP GDQDLUUHQGDPDQNRDJXOXPGHQJDQHWDQRO GDQ + 62 GDSDW GLOLKDW SDGD *DPEDU 6HSHUWLKDOQ\DDVDPIRUPDWNRDJXODQPXUQL GDQ DLU UHQGDPDQ NRDJXOXP ´;µ WLGDN PHQJKDVLONDQ HQGDSDQ ,QL PHQXQMXNNDQ EDKZDNRDJXODQ´;µWLGDNPHQJDQGXQJLRQ NDOVLXP \DQJ ELDVDQ\D EHUVXPEHU GDUL SHQJJXQDDQSXSXN7637HWDSLVHUXPKDVLO S H Q J J X P S D O D Q P H Q J K D V L O N D Q HQGDSDQJHODWLQ SXWLK LQL PHQXQMXNNDQ EDKZD VHUXP WHUVHEXW PHQJDQGXQJ LRQ NDOVLXP \DQJ VHFDUD DODPL GLSHUROHK GDUL ODWHNVPXUQL
x 3HUHDNVL +12 GDQ DPPRQLXP PRO\EGDWH
+DVLOUHDNVLNRDJXODQPXUQLVHUXP GDQ DLU UHQGDPDQ NRDJXOXP GHQJDQ +12
GDQDPPRQLXPPRO\EGDWHGDSDWGLOLKDWSDGD *DPEDU 6HSHUWL KDOQ\D DVDP IRUPDW NRDJXODQ PXUQL GDQ DLU UHQGDPDQ NRDJXOXP´;µWLGDNPHQJKDVLONDQHQGDSDQ ,QLPHQXQMXNNDQEDKZDNRDJXODQ´;µWLGDN PHQJDQGXQJ LRQ IRVIDW \DQJ ELDVDQ\D EHUVXPEHU GDUL SHQJJXQDDQ SXSXN 763 7HWDSL VHUXP KDVLO SHQJJXPSDODQ PHQJKDVLONDQ HQGDSDQJHODWLQ SXWLK LQL PHQXQMXNNDQ EDKZD VHUXP WHUVHEXW PHQJDQGXQJ LRQ IRVIDW \DQJ VHFDUD DODPL GLSHUROHK GDUL ODWHNV PXUQL %HUGDVDUNDQ KDVLO SHQJXMLDQ NXDOLWDWLI NRDJXODQ ´;µ GHQJDQ EHUEDJDL SHUHDNVL PDND GDSDW G L V L P S X O N D Q E D K Z D N R D J X O D Q ´;µ PHQJDQGXQJLRQVXOIDW\DQJNHPXQJNLQDQ EHVDUEHUVXPEHUGDULDVDPVXOIDW
*DPEDU5HDNVLNRDJXODQPXUQL,VHUXP,,GDQDLUUHQGDPDQNRDJXOXP,,,GHQJDQ SHUHDNVLHWDQROGDQ+ 62 D;GRVLVE;GRVLVGDQFDVDPIRUPDW )LJXUH7KHUHDFWLRQRISXUHFRDJXODQW,VHUXP,,DQGZDWHULPPHUVLRQRIFRDJXOXP,,,ZLWK UHDJHQWV(WDQRODQG+ 62 DFRDJXODQW´;µZLWKGRVDJHEFRDJXODQW´;µZLWK GRVDJHDQGFFRDJXODQWIRUPLFDFLG *DPEDU5HDNVLNRDJXODQPXUQL,VHUXP,,GDQDLUUHQGDPDQNRDJXOXP,,,GHQJDQ SHUHDNVL+12 GDQ DPPRQLXPPRO\EGDWHD;GRVLVE;GRVLVGDQF DVDPIRUPDW)LJXUH7KHUHDFWLRQRISXUHFRDJXODQW,VHUXP,,DQGZDWHULPPHUVLRQRIFRDJXOXP,,,ZLWK UHDJHQWV+12 DQGDPPRQLXPPRO\EGDWHDFRDJXODQW´;µZLWKGRVDJHE FRDJXODQW´;µZLWKGRVDJHDQGFFRDJXODQWIRUPLFDFLG
.(6,038/$1
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
$SOLNDVL 3HQJXMLDQ VHFDUD NXDOLWDWLI WHODK GLODNXNDQ SDGD NRDJXODQ ´;µ XQWXN PHQJHWDKXLNDQGXQJDQ LRQSDGD NRDJXODQ WHUVHEXW +DVLO SHQJXMLDQ PHQXQMXNNDQ EDKZDNRDJXODQ´;µPHQJDQGXQJLRQVXOIDW \DQJ NHPXQJNLQDQ EHVDU EHUVXPEHU GDUL DVDPVXOIDW '$)7$53867$.$ $EHGQHJR-*3HQJHWDKXDQODWHNV GDODP NXUVXV SHQJDZDVDQ PXWX 6WDQGDUG,QGRQHVLDQ5XEEHU-DNDUWD ,QGRQHVLD 'LUHNWRUDW VWDQGDUGLVDVL QRUPDOLVDVL GDQ SHQJHQGDOLDQ PXWX ' H S D U W H P H Q 3 H U G D J D Q J D Q G D Q .RSHUDVL %DGDQ 6WDQGDULVDVL 1DVLRQDO 61, WHQWDQJ %DKDQ 2ODK .DUHW-DNDUWD,QGRQHVLD%61 'DUXVVDPLQ $ $QZDU $ <DK\D 0 3HQJDUXK SHQJJXQDDQ SXSXN 763 VHEDJDL SHQJJXPSDO ODWHNV WHUKDGDSVLIDWNDUHW%XOHWLQ3HUNDUHWDQ
+HOPHQVWLQH $ 0 4XDOLWDWLYH DQDO\VLV LQ &KHPLVWU\ ,QWURGXFWLRQ WR TXDOLWDWLYH DQDO\VLV ,GHQWLI\LQJ DQLRQV D Q G F D W L R Q V ' L D N V H V G D U L KWWSFKHPLVWU\DERXWFRP
2WKPDQ$ /\H&%(IIHFWRIS+ FRDJXODWLRQ DQG VXOIXULF DFLG DV D F R D J X O D Q W R Q Q D W X U D O U X E E H U SURSHUWLHV -RXUQDO RI WKH 5XEEHU 5HVHDUFK ,QVWLWXWH RI 0DOD\VLD
²
3XUED\D 0 6DUL 7 , 6DSXWUL & $ )DMULDQW\ 0 7 3HQJDUXK EHEHUDSDMHQLVEDKDQSHQJJXPSDOODWHNV GDQKXEXQJDQQ\DGHQJDQVXVXWERERW NDGDU NDUHW NHULQJ GDQ SODVWLVLWDV 3URVLGLQJ 6HPLQDU 1DVLRQDO $92(5 $GGHG9DOXHRI(QHUJ\5HVRXUFHVNH SS²3DOHPEDQJ,QGRQHVLD )DNXOWDV7HNQLN8QLYHUVLWDV6ULZLMD\D 5DFKPDZDQ $ $VDP DQRUJDQLN
VHEDJDL SHQJJXPSDO ODWHNV VXDWX WLQMDXDQ VLQJNDW :DUWD 3HUNDUHWDQ
6ROLFKLQ 0 3UDPXDML , $QZDU $ 3HUEDQGLQJDQ EHEHUDSD MHQLV N R D J X O D Q W H U K D G D S N R Q G L V L S H Q J J X P S D O D Q G D Q P X W X N D U H W 3DOHPEDQJ ,QGRQHVLD %DODL 3HQHOLWLDQ 6HPEDZD 6ROLFKLQ07HGMDSXWUD1+HQGUDWQR6 1DQF\&9DFKOHSL$ 'DUPDZL0 $SOLNDVLDVDSFDLU'HRUXEXQWXN SHQJJXPSDOODWHNVGDQPDQIDDWQ\DEDJL SHWDQL SHGDJDQJ GDQ SDEULN NDUHW UHPDK UHPDK 6WXGL NDVXV GL 'HVD $\XQDQ 3DSDQ .HFDPDWDQ /RNSDLNDW .DEXSDWHQ 7DSLQ 3URYLQVL .DOLPDQWDQ 6HODWDQ3URVLGLQJ/RNDNDU\D1DVLRQDO $JULELVQLV.DUHW<RJ\DNDUWD,QGRQHVLD 3XVDW3HQHOLWLDQ.DUHW
6\DULID/)$JXVWLQD'6 1DQF\& (YDOXDVL SHQJRODKDQ GDQ PXWX EDKDQ RODK NDUHW UDN\DW %RNDU GL WLQJNDW SHWDQL NDUHW GL 6XPDWHUD 6HODWDQ-XUQDO 3HQHOLWLDQ .DUHW
6YHKOD * (G 9RJHOV TXDOLWDWLYH LQRUJDQLF DQDO\VLV 1HZ <RUN 86$ 3HDUVRQ(GXFDWLRQ
9DFKOHSL $ 6ROLFKLQ 0 $QZDU $ 3HQJDUXK EHUEDJDL NRDJXODQ ODWHNVWHUKDGDSNRQGLVLSHQJJXPSDODQ VSHVLILNDVL WHNQLV NDUDNWHULVWLN YXONDQLVDVL GDQ VLIDW ILVLN YXONDQLVDW %XOHWLQ 3HQHOLWLDQ 8QLYHUVLWDV 'MXDQGD
9DFKOHSL$ 6ROLFKLQ0$SOLNDVL IRUPXOD DVDS FDLU 'HRUXE . VHEDJDL SHQJJXPSDO ODWHNV:DUWD 3HUNDUHWDQ ²
