7$17$1*$1'$/$03(1$1*$1$1'8*$$135$.7,.32/,7,.
8$1*3$'$3,/.$'$6(5(17$.
6UL:DK\X$QDQLQJVLK )DNXOWDV+XNXP8QLYHUVLWDV'LSRQHJRUR -O3URI6RHGDUWR6+7HPEDODQJ6HPDUDQJ (PDLOD\XBIKXQGLS#\DKRRFRP $EVWUDFW0RQH\ SROLWLF LV D FULPLQDO YLRODWLRQ LQ HOHFWLRQV LQFOXGLQJ LQ FRQFXUUHQW HOHFWLRQ 7KLV YLRODWLRQLVRIWHQGRQHLQSUDFWLFHEXWGLýFXOWWRSURFHVVLW0DQ\REVWDFOHVLQKDQGOLQJPRQH\ SROLWLFFDVHVDUHWKHUHLVQRVDQFWLRQQRUPLQUHJXODWLRQOLPLWHGDXWKRULW\RI(OHFWLRQ6XSHUYLVRU\ &RPPLWWHH DQG GLüHUHQW SHUFHSWLRQ LQ 6HQWUD *DNNXPGX 7KHUH DUH VRPH HüRUWV WR UHVROYH WKH REVWDFOHVLQHOHFWLRQVXFKDVUHYLVLRQRIUHJXODWLRQDQG JLYLQJIXOODXWKRULW\IRU(OHFWLRQ 6XSHUYLVRU\&RPPLWWHH
.H\ZRUGV&KDOOHQJHV0RQH\3ROLWLFV&RQFXUUHQW(OHFWLRQV
$EVWUDN
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
.DWD.XQFL7DQWDQJDQ3ROLWLNXDQJ3LONDGD6HUHQWDN
$ 3HQGDKXOXDQ
3HPLOX PHUXSDNDQ EDJLDQ GDUL XSD\D X Q W X N P H O D N V D Q D N D Q G H P R N U D V L G D Q NHGDXODWDQ UDN\DW 3HPLOX GLODNXNDQ DJDU S H P H U L Q W D K D Q \ D Q J W H U E H Q W X N PHUHSUHVHQWDVLNDQ NHKHQGDN EHUVDPD GDUL V H J H Q D S H O H P H Q N H E D Q J V D D Q X Q W X N PHPEHQWXN GDQ PHODQMXWNDQ NRQVHSVL NHQHJDUDDQ 0HQXUXW 5DPODQ 6XUEDNWL WXMXDQGDULSHPLOXPHOLSXWLWLJDKDO\DNQL DVHEDJDL PHNDQLVPH XQWXN PHQ\HOHNVL SDUD SHPLPSLQ SHPHULQWDKDQ GDQ DOWHUQDWLI NHELMDNDQ XPXP EVHEDJDL PHNDQLVPH PHPLQGDKNDQ NRQÀLN NHSHQWLQJDQ GDUL PDV\DUDNDW NHSDGD EDGDQEDGDQ SHUZDNLODQ UDN\DW PHODOXL ZDNLOZDNLO UDN\DW \DQJ PHPHQDQJNDQ NXUVL VHKLQJJD LQWHJUDVL
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
5LD&DVVPL$UUVD³3HPLOX6HUHQWDNGDQ0DVD'HSDQ.RQVROLGDVL'HPRNUDVL´-XUQDO.RQVWLWXVL9RO1R 6HSWHPEHUSSKOP
5DPODQ6XUEDNWL0HPDKDPL,OPX3ROLWLN-DNDUWD*UDPHGLD3XVWDND8WDPDKOP
-LPO\$VVKLGGLTLH³3DUWDL3ROLWLN'DQ3HPLOX6HEDJDL,QVWUXPHQ'HPRNUDVL´-XUQDO.RQVWLWXVL9RO1R KOP
5DPODQ6XUEDNWL³8UJHQVL.RGL¿NDVL883HPLOX´+DULDQ.RPSDV1RYHPEHU
.DFXQJ 0DULMDQ 6LVWHP 3ROLWLN GL ,QGRQHVLD .RQVROLGDVL 'HPRNUDVL 3DGD 0DVD 2UGH %DUX -DNDUWD .HQFDQDKOP
%HQQ\*H\V³([SODLQLQJ9RWHU7XUQRXW$5HYLHZRI$JJUHJDWH/HYHO5HVHDUFK´LQ(OHFWRUDO6WXGLHV9RO ,VVXH'HFHPEHUKOP
,ELGSS
'DYLG 6DPXHOV ³&RQFXUUHQW (OHFWLRQV 'LVFRUGDQW 5HVXOWV 3UHVLGHQWLDOLVP )HGHUDOLVP DQG *RYHUQDQFH LQ %UD]LO´&RPSDUDWLYH3ROLWLFV-RXUQDO2FWREHUSS
7DWLDQD.RVWDGLQRYDDQG7LPRWK\-3RZHU³'RHV'HPRFUDWL]DWLRQ'HSUHVV3DUWLFLSDWLRQ"9RWHU7XUQRXWLQWKH /DWLQ$PHULFDQDQG(DVWHUQ(XURSHDQ7UDQVLWLRQDO'HPRFUDFLHV´-RXUQDO3ROLWLFDO5HVHDUFK4XDUWHUO\9RO ,VVXH6HSWHPEHUSS
6FKUDXIQDJHO6FRWW0LFKDHO%XHKOHUGDQ0DXUHHQ/RZU\)ULW]³9RWHU7XUQRXWLQ'HPRFUDWL]LQJ6RXWKHDVW$VLD $&RPSDUDWLYH$QDO\VLVRI(OHFWRUDO3DUWLFLSDWLRQLQ)LYH&RXQWULHV´7DLZDQ-RXUQDORI'HPRFUDF\9RO 1R-XO\SS
,QGUD ,VPDZDQ 0RQH\ 3ROLWLFV 3HQJDUXK 8DQJ 'DODP 3HPLOX <RJ\DNDUWD 0HGLD 3UHVLQGR KOP
NXUVLNXUVL \DQJ GLPHQDQJNDQ ROHK SDUWDL DWDXFDORQ
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
0RGHO SHPLOX VHUHQWDN FRQFXUUHQW HOHFWLRQV GL ,QGRQHVLD WHUVHEXW PHUXSDNDQ SHPLOX VHUHQWDN SHUWDPD NDOL GL ,QGRQHVLD 3HPLOX VHUHQWDN DGDODK VLVWHP SHPLOX \DQJ PHODQJVXQJNDQ EHEHUDSD SHPLOLKDQSDGDVDWXZDNWXVHFDUDEHUVDPDDQ %HQQ\ *H\V PHQXOLV EDKZD VLVWHP SHPLOX VHUHQWDN VXGDK GLWHUDSNDQ GL QHJDUDQHJDUD \ D Q J W H O D K O D P D P H Q H U D S N D Q V L V W H P GHPRNUDVL VHSHUWL $PHULND 6HULNDW GDQ
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
GH¿QLWLI GDQ DWDX PDV\DUDNDW SHPLOLK PHPEHULNDQ VXDUDQ\D NHSDGD FDORQ \DQJ EHUVDQJNXWDQSHPEHULED\DUDQDWDXEDQWXDQ WHUVHEXW 6HODQMXWQ\D *DU\ *RRGSDVWHU PHQXOLV EDKZD SROLWLN XDQJ LWX EDJLDQ GDUL NRUXSVL \DQJ WHUMDGL GDODP SURVHV 3HPLOX 3ROLWLN XDQJ SDGD GDVDUQ\D PHUXSDNDQ WUDQVDNVL VXDSPHQ\XDS \DQJ GLODNXNDQ ROHK VHRUDQJ FDORQ GHQJDQ WXMXDQ XQWXN PHQGDSDWNDQ NHXQWXQJDQ VXDUD GDODP SHPLOLKDQ
'DUL VLVL SHUDWXUDQ SHUXQGDQJDQ \DQJ WHUNDLW GHQJDQ SLONDGD WLGDN GLWHPXNDQ SHQJHUWLDQ WHQWDQJ SROLWLN XDQJ 1DPXQ GHPLNLDQ WHUGDSDW QRUPD ODUDQJDQ \DQJ GLNDWDNDQVHEDJDLSROLWLNXDQJ\DNQL 3DVDO 881R7DKXQWHQWDQJ3HQHWDSDQ 3HUDWXUDQ 3HPHULQWDK 3HQJJDQWL 8QGDQJ 8QGDQJ1R7DKXQ7HQWDQJ3HPLOLKDQ *XEHUQXU %XSDWL 'DQ :DOLNRWD 0HQMDGL 8QGDQJ8QGDQJ3DVDOPHQ\DWDNDQ 3DUWDL3ROLWLNDWDXJDEXQJDQ3DUWDL3ROLWLN
GLODUDQJ PHQHULPD LPEDODQ GDODP EHQWXNDSDSXQSDGDSURVHVSHQFDORQDQ *XEHUQXU%XSDWLGDQ:DOLNRWD
'DODPKDO3DUWDL3ROLWLNDWDXJDEXQJDQ 3DUWDL 3ROLWLN WHUEXNWL PHQHULPD LPEDODQ VHEDJDLPDQD GLPDNVXG SDGD D\DW 3DUWDL 3ROLWLN DWDX JDEXQJDQ 3DUWDL 3ROLWLN \DQJ EHUVDQJNXWDQ GLODUDQJ PHQJDMXNDQ FDORQ SDGD SHULRGH EHULNXWQ\D GL GDHUDK \DQJ VDPD
3DUWDL 3ROLWLN DWDX JDEXQJDQ 3DUWDL 3ROLWLN \DQJ PHQHULPD LPEDODQ VHEDJDLPDQD GLPDNVXG SDGD D\DW KDUXV GLEXNWLNDQ GHQJDQ SXWXVDQ SHQJDGLODQ \DQJ WHODK PHPSXQ\DL NHNXDWDQKXNXPWHWDS
6HWLDS RUDQJ DWDX OHPEDJD GLODUDQJ PHPEHULLPEDODQNHSDGD3DUWDL3ROLWLN DWDX JDEXQJDQ 3DUWDL 3ROLWLN GDODP E H Q W X N D S D S X Q G D O D P S U R V H V SHQFDORQDQ *XEHUQXU %XSDWL GDQ :DOLNRWD
'DODP KDO SXWXVDQ SHQJDGLODQ \DQJ WHODKPHPSXQ\DLNHNXDWDQKXNXPWHWDS PHQ\DWDNDQVHWLDSRUDQJDWDXOHPEDJD WHUEXNWLPHPEHULLPEDODQSDGDSURVHV
SHQFDORQDQ *XEHUQXU %XSDWL DWDX :DOLNRWD PDND SHQHWDSDQ VHEDJDL FDORQ FDORQ WHUSLOLK DWDX VHEDJDL *XEHUQXU %XSDWL DWDX :DOLNRWD GLEDWDONDQ
3DVDO PHQMHODVNDQ &DORQ GDQDWDXWLP.DPSDQ\HGLODUDQJPHQMDQMLNDQ GDQDWDX PHPEHULNDQ XDQJ DWDX PDWHUL ODLQQ\D XQWXN PHPSHQJDUXKL 3HPLOLK &DORQ\DQJWHUEXNWLPHODNXNDQSHODQJJDUDQ VHEDJDLPDQD GLPDNVXG SDGD D\DW EHUGDVDUNDQ SXWXVDQ SHQJDGLODQ \DQJ WHODK PHPSXQ\DL NHNXDWDQ KXNXP WHWDS GLNHQDL VDQNVL SHPEDWDODQ VHEDJDL FDORQ ROHK .38 3URYLQVL GDQ .38 .DEXSDWHQ.RWD GDQ GLNHQDL VDQNVL SLGDQD VHVXDL GHQJDQ SHUDWXUDQ SHUXQGDQJXQGDQJDQ 7LP . D P S D Q \ H \ D Q J W H U E X N W L P H O D N X N D Q SHODQJJDUDQ VHEDJDLPDQD GLPDNVXG SDGD D\DWEHUGDVDUNDQSXWXVDQSHQJDGLODQ\DQJ WHODK PHPSXQ\DL NHNXDWDQ KXNXP WHWDS GLNHQDL VDQNVL SLGDQD VHVXDL GHQJDQ NHWHQWXDQSHUDWXUDQSHUXQGDQJXQGDQJDQ % H U G D V D U N D Q S H Q G D S D W S H Q G D S D W WHUVHEXW GDSDW GLVLPSXONDQ EDKZD SUDNWLN SROLWLN XDQJ GDSDW GLGH¿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
-RKQ\/RPXOXV³6LNDS3HPLOLKWHUKDGDS3DVDQJDQ&DORQ0HQMHODQJ3LONDGD/DQJVXQJGL.RWD%LWXQJGDODP 'HPRNUDVL0DWL6XUL´-XUQDO3HQHOLWLDQ3ROLWLN9RO1R/,3,KOP
*DU\*RRGSDVWHU5HÀHNVLWHQWDQJ.RUXSVLGL,QGRQHVLD-DNDUWD86$,'KOP
. D E X S D W H Q . R W D E H U N H G X G X N D Q G L .DEXSDWHQ.RWD 3DQZDVOX .HFDPDWDQ EHUNHGXGXNDQ GL .HFDPDWDQ 3HQJDZDV 3 H P L O X / D S D Q J D Q E H U N H G X G X N D Q G L .HOXUDKDQ GDQ 3HQJDZDV 3HPLOX /XDU 1HJHULEHUNHGXGXNDQGL/XDU1HJHUL
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
7DQWDQJDQ 3HQDQJDQDQ 3UDNWLN 3ROLWLN 8DQJ 3DGD 3LONDGD 6HUHQWDN %HUGDVDU 3HQJDODPDQ 3LONDGD 6HUHQWDN
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
%DZDVOX %DZDVOX SURYLQVL 3DQZDV NDEXSDWHQNRWD 3DQZDV NHFDPDWDQ 3HQJDZDV 3HPLOX /DSDQJDQ GDQ 3HQJDZDV 736 PHQHULPD ODSRUDQ SHODQJJDUDQ SHPLOLKDQ SDGD VHWLDS WDKDSDQSHQ\HOHQJJDUDDQSHPLOX
/DSRUDQ SHODQJJDUDQ SHPLOLKDQ GDSDW GLVDPSDLNDQ ROHK D :1, \DQJ PHPLOLNL KDN SLOLK SDGD SHPLOLKDQ VHWHPSDWE3HPDQWDXSHPLOLKDQDWDX
F3HVHUWDSHPLOLKDQ
/ D S R U D Q S H O D Q J J D U D Q S H P L O L K D Q GLVDPSDLNDQ VHFDUD WHUWXOLV SDOLQJ VHGLNLW PHPXDW D 1DPD GDQ DODPDW SHODSRUE3LKDNWHUODSRUF:DNWXGDQ WHPSDW NHMDGLDQ SHUNDUD G 8UDLDQ NHMDGLDQ
/DSRUDQ SHODQJJDUDQ GLVDPSDLNDQ SDOLQJ ODPEDW WXMXK KDUL VHMDN GLNHWDKXL GDQ DWDX GLWHPXNDQQ\D SHODQJJDUDQSHPLOLKDQ
' D O D P K D O O D S R U D Q S H O D Q J J D U D Q SHPLOLKDQ VHWHODK GLNDML WHUEXNWL NHEHQDUDQQ\DPDND%DZDVOXSURYLQVL 3DQZDV NDEXSDWHQNRWD 3DQZDV NHFDPDWDQ3HQJDZDV3HPLOX/DSDQJDQ G D Q 3 H Q J D Z D V 7 3 6 Z D M L E PHQLQGDNODQMXWLODSRUDQSDOLQJODPD WLJDKDULVHMDNODSRUDQGLWHULPD ' D O D P K D O G L S H U O X N D Q % D Z D V O X SURYLQVL 3DQZDV NDEXSDWHQNRWD 3DQZDV NHFDPDWDQ 3HQJDZDV 3HPLOX /DSDQJDQ GDQ 3HQJDZDV 736 GDSDW PHPLQWD NHWHUDQJDQ WDPEDKDQ GDUL SHODSRUSDOLQJODPDGXDKDUL
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
3URVHV SHQDQJDQDQ WLQGDN SLGDQD SHPLOLKDQWHUPDVXNGDODPSURVHV\DQJFHSDW :DNWXSHQDQJDQDQROHK%DZDVOXSDOLQJODPD OLPD KDUL LWXSXQ VXGDK WHUPDVXN ZDNWX
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
3 H Q J D G L O D Q 1 H J H U L 3 1 K D U X V PHPHULNVDPHQJDGLOLGDQPHPXWXVSHUNDUD GDODP ZDNWX SDOLQJ ODPD WXMXK KDUL WHUKLWXQJ VHMDN GLWHULPDQ\D EHUNDV SHUNDUD 3HOXDQJ SHUPRKRQDQ EDQGLQJ DWDV SXWXVDQ 31 GLDMXNDQ SDOLQJ ODPD WLJD KDUL VHMDN SHPEDFDDQ SXWXVDQ -LND XSD\D EDQGLQJ GLWHULPD 31 KDUXV PHOLPSDKNDQ EHUNDV SHUNDUD SHUPRKRQDQ EDQGLQJ NHSDGD 3HQJDGLODQ7LQJJL37SDOLQJODPDWLJD KDUL VHMDN SHUPRKRQDQ EDQGLQJ GLWHULPD 6HODQMXWQ\D 37 PHPHULNVD GDQ PHPXWXV SHUNDUD SDOLQJ ODPD WXMXK KDUL VHWHODK GLWHULPDQ\D SHUPRKRQDQ EDQGLQJ 3XWXVDQ 37 PHUXSDNDQ SXWXVDQ WHUDNKLU ¿QDO GDQ PHQJLNDW3DVDO881R7DKXQ
3UDNWLNQ\D SURVHV SHQDQJDQDQ NDVXV NDVXVSUDNWLNSROLWLNXDQJGL3LONDGDVHUHQWDN VDQJDW VXOLW +DO LQL GLVHEDENDQ ROHK NHQGDOD NHQGDODSHUWDPDEHUXSD WLGDN DGDQ\D QRUPD VDQNVL SLGDQD XQWXN WLQGDN SLGDQDSROLWLNXDQJ/DUDQJDQSUDNWLNSROLWLN XDQJPRQH\ SROLWLF VHFDUD LPSOLVLW GLQ\DWDNDQ GDODP 3DVDO 88 1R7DKXQ
%DZDVOX %DZDVOX SURYLQVL 3DQZDV NDEXSDWHQNRWD 3DQZDV NHFDPDWDQ 3HQJDZDV 3HPLOX /DSDQJDQ GDQ 3HQJDZDV 736 PHQHULPD ODSRUDQ SHODQJJDUDQ SHPLOLKDQ SDGD VHWLDS
WDKDSDQSHQ\HOHQJJDUDDQSHPLOX
/DSRUDQ SHODQJJDUDQ SHPLOLKDQ GDSDW GLVDPSDLNDQ ROHK D :1, \DQJ PHPLOLNL KDN SLOLK SDGD SHPLOLKDQ VHWHPSDWE3HPDQWDXSHPLOLKDQDWDX F3HVHUWDSHPLOLKDQ
/ D S R U D Q S H O D Q J J D U D Q S H P L O L K D Q GLVDPSDLNDQ VHFDUD WHUWXOLV SDOLQJ VHGLNLW PHPXDW D 1DPD GDQ DODPDW SHODSRUE3LKDNWHUODSRUF:DNWXGDQ WHPSDW NHMDGLDQ SHUNDUD G 8UDLDQ NHMDGLDQ
/DSRUDQ SHODQJJDUDQ GLVDPSDLNDQ SDOLQJ ODPEDW WXMXK KDUL VHMDN GLNHWDKXL GDQ DWDX GLWHPXNDQQ\D SHODQJJDUDQSHPLOLKDQ
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
. R Q G L V L G L P D Q D U H J X O D V L W L G D N PHQGXNXQJGDODPSHQHJDNDQKXNXPWLQGDN SLGDQD SROLWLN XDQJ PHPSHUVXOLW %DZDVOX PHQDQJDQLNDVXVGXJDDQSUDNWLNSROLWLNXDQJ .HQGDOD LQLODK \DQJ PHQJDNLEDWNDQ NDVXV SUDNWLN SROLWLN XDQJ MDUDQJ ELVD GLSURVHV KLQJJDSHQJDGLODQ.HWLGDNEHUGD\DDQGDODP SHQDQJDQDQ NDVXV PHQMDGL SHOXDQJ SHVHUWD SHPLOX PDXSXQ WLP NDPSDQ\H PHODNXNDQ SUDNWLNSROLWLNXDQJGHQJDQOHOXDVDVHKLQJJD SUDNWLNSROLWLNXDQJPDUDNWHUMDGL 6HEHQDUQ\D DGD XSD\D PHQJDMXNDQ DOWHUQDWLI ODLQ \DQJ GDSDW GLJXQDNDQ \DNQL .LWDE88+XNXP3LGDQD.8+3NHWLND88 1R7DKXQWLGDNELVDGLKDUDSNDQGDODP SHQHJDNDQKXNXPNDVXVSUDNWLNSROLWLNXDQJ 3DVDOD\DW.8+3PHQ\DWDNDQ %DUDQJ VLDSD SDGD ZDNWX GLDGDNDQ SHPLOLKDQ EHUGDVDUNDQ DWXUDQDWXUDQ X P X P G H Q J D Q P H P E H U L D W D X P H Q M D Q M L N D Q V H V X D W X P H Q \ X D S VHVHRUDQJ VXSD\D WLGDN PHPDNDL KDN SLOLKQ\D DWDX VXSD\D PHPDNDL KDN LWX PHQXUXWFDUDWHUWHQWXGLDQFDPGHQJDQ SLGDQDSHQMDUDSDOLQJODPDEXODQDWDX
SLGDQD GHQGD SDOLQJ ODPD HPSDW ULEX OLPDUDWXVUXSLDK
3LGDQD \DQJ VDPD GLWHUDSNDQ NHSDGD SHPLOLK \DQJ GHQJDQ PHQHULPD SHPEHULDQDWDXMDQMLPDXGLVXDS +DO \DQJ PHQDULN GDUL 3DVDO DGDODK SHQJHQDDQ KXNXPDQ EDJL XQVXU SLKDN SHPEHULGDQSHQHULPDVXDS.HPXGLDQVHFDUD NRQWHNVWXDOSHQJHUWLDQ³SROLWLNXDQJ´GDODP .8+3 PHOLSXWL XQVXU ³DJDU SHPLOLK WLGDN PHPDNDL KDN SLOLK´ GDQ ³DJDU SHPLOLK PHPDNDL KDN SLOLK GHQJDQ FDUD WHUWHQWX´ 7LGDN DGD XQVXU ³DJDU PHPLOLK SDVDQJDQ FDORQ WHUWHQWX´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¿NDVL ROHK %DZDVOX EDQ\DN WHUODSRU\DQJGHQJDQVHQJDMDWLGDNPDXKDGLU PHVNLSXQ WHODK GLXQGDQJ VHFDUD IRUPDO WHUWXOLVKLQJJDWLJDNDOLSHPDQJJLODQ'L VDWXVLVLNHWLDGDDQNHZHQDQJDQXSD\DSDNVD
SHPDQJJLODQ PHQJDNLEDWNDQ WHUODSRU WLGDN ELVDGLSDNVDXQWXNKDGLU'LVLVLODLQ%DZDVOX KDQ\D PHPLOLNL ZDNWX SHQDQJDQDQ SDOLQJ ODPD OLPD KDUL $NLEDW NHWLGDNKDGLUDQ WHUODSRU EDWDV ZDNWX SHQDQJDQDQ ROHK %DZDVOX KDELV VHKLQJJD NDVXV PHQMDGL NDGDOXDUVD
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
8SD\D GDODP 3HQDQJDQDQ 'XJDDQ 3UDNWLN 3ROLWLN 8DQJ 3DGD 3LONDGD
%HVDU KDUDSDQ PDV\DUDNDW SLONDGD VHUHQWDNNHWDKXQDNDQEHUMDODQOHELK EDLNGLEDQGLQJ3LONDGD2OHKNDUHQDLWX EHUNDLWDQ GHQJDQ SUDNWLN SROLWLN XDQJ SHUOX DGDXSD\DXSD\DVHEDJDLEHULNXW D 0HODNXNDQUHYLVL883LONDGD 3HPLOXPHUXSDNDQVXDWXVLVWLP\DQJPHOLSXWL HOHFWRUDOUHJXODWLRQHOHFWRUDOSURFHVV GDQHOHFWRUDOODZHQIRUFHPHQW.HWLJDQ\D PHUXSDNDQ VDWX NHVDWXDQ -LNDHOHFWRUDO UHJXODWLRQWLGDNEDLNPDNDDNDQEHUGDPSDN SDGDHOHFWRUDO ODZ HQIRUFHPHQW \DQJ WLGDN ELVD EHUMDODQ (OHFWRUDO SURFHVVQ\DMXJD PHQMDGLWLGDNEHUNXDOLWDV0DNDGDULLWX88 3LONDGD \DQJ DGD VHNDUDQJ \DLWX 88 1R 7DKXQ MR 88 1R 7DKXQ KDUXV GLODNXNDQ UHYLVL NKXVXVQ\D WHUNDLW GHQJDQ QRUPD WHQWDQJ VDQNVL WLQGDN SLGDQD SROLWLN
-3ULKDWPRNR 3HPLOLKDQ .HSDOD 'DHUDK /DQJVXQJ )LORVR¿ 6LVWHP 'DQ 3UREOHPDWLND 3HQHUDSDQ 'L ,QGRQHVLD6HPDUDQJ3XVWDND3HODMDU /308QLY:DKLG+DV\LPKOP
XDQJ
E 3HPEHULDQNHZHQDQJDQSHQXK%DZDVOX GDODP SHQDQJDQDQ SLGDQD SHPLOLKDQ WHUPDVXNSUDNWLNSROLWLNXDQJ
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
$UUVD 5LD &DVVPL ³3HPLOX 6HUHQWDN GDQ 0DVD'HSDQ.RQVROLGDVL'HPRNUDVL´ -XUQDO .RQVWLWXVL9RO 1R 6HSWHPEHUSS $VVKLGGLTLH-LPO\³3DUWDL3ROLWLN'DQ 3HPLOX6HEDJDL,QVWUXPHQ'HPRNUDVL´ -XUQDO.RQVWLWXVL9RO1R
)DFKUXGLQ $FKPDG -DODQ 7HUMDO 0HQXMX 3HPLOX 0HQJDZDVL 3HPLOX 0HPSHUNXDW 'HPRNUDVL´ -DNDUWD*UDPHGLD8WDPD3XEOLVKLQGR *RRGSDVWHU *DU\ 5HÀHNVL WHQWDQJ
.RUXSVLGL,QGRQHVLD-DNDUWD86$,' *H\V %HQQ\ ³([SODLQLQJ 9RWHU 7XUQRXW $
5HYLHZRI$JJUHJDWH/HYHO5HVHDUFK´ (OHFWRUDO6WXGLHV-RXUQDO9RO,VVXH 'HFHPEHU
.RVWDGLQRYD7DWLDQD DQG7LPRWK\ - 3RZHU ³'RHV 'HPRFUDWL]DWLRQ 'HSUHVV 3DUWLFLSDWLRQ" 9RWHU 7XUQRXW LQ WKH /DWLQ$PHULFDQDQG(DVWHUQ(XURSHDQ 7UDQVLWLRQDO 'HPRFUDFLHV´ -RXUQDO 3ROLWLFDO 5HVHDUFK 4XDUWHUO\ 9RO ,VVXH6HSWHPEHUSS /RPXOXV -RKQ\ ³6LNDS 3HPLOLK WHUKDGDS
3DVDQJDQ &DORQ 0HQMHODQJ 3LONDGD /DQJVXQJ GL .RWD %LWXQJ GDODP ' H P R N U D V L 0 D W L 6 X U L ´ - X U Q D O 3HQHOLWLDQ 3ROLWLN 9RO 1R /,3,
0DULMDQ .DFXQJ 6LVWHP 3ROLWLN GL ,QGRQHVLD .RQVROLGDVL 'HPRNUDVL 3DGD 0DVD 2UGH %DUX -DNDUWD .HQFDQD
3ULKDWPRNR - 3HPLOLKDQ .HSDOD 'DHUDK/DQJVXQJ)LORVR¿6LVWHP'DQ 3UREOHPDWLND3HQHUDSDQ'L,QGRQHVLD 6HPDUDQJ 3XVWDND 3HODMDU /30 8QLY:DKLG+DV\LP
6XUEDNWL 5DPODQ 0HPDKDPL ,OPX 3ROLWLN-DNDUWD *UDPHGLD 3XVWDND 8WDPD
6XUEDNWL 5DPODQ ³8UJHQVL .RGL¿NDVL 88 3 H P L O X ´ + D U L D Q . R P S D V 1RYHPEHU
6DPXHOV 'DYLG ³&RQFXUUHQW (OHFWLRQV 'LVFRUGDQW 5HVXOWV 3UHVLGHQWLDOLVP )HGHUDOLVPDQG*RYHUQDQFHLQ%UD]LO´ &RPSDUDWLYH3ROLWLFV-RXUQDO2FWREHU SS
6FKUDXIQDJHO 6FRWW 0LFKDHO %XHKOHU GDQ 0DXUHHQ /RZU\)ULW] ³9RWHU 7XUQRXW LQ 'HPRFUDWL]LQJ 6RXWKHDVW $VLD $ &RPSDUDWLYH $QDO\VLV RI (OHFWRUDO 3DUWLFLSDWLRQ LQ )LYH &RXQWULHV´ 7DLZDQ-RXUQDORI'HPRFUDF\9RO 1R-XO\SS 881R7DKXQWHQWDQJ3HQ\HOHQJJDUD 3HPLOX 88 1R 7DKXQ WHQWDQJ 3HQHWDSDQ 3HUSX 1R 7DKXQ WHQWDQJ 3HPLOLKDQ *XEHUQXU %XSDWL GDQ :DOLNRWD0HQMDGL8QGDQJ8QGDQJ 881R7DKXQWHQWDQJ3HUXEDKDQ$WDV 88 1R 7DKXQ WHQWDQJ 3HQHWDSDQ 3HUSX 1R 7DKXQ WHQWDQJ 3HPLOLKDQ *XEHUQXU %XSDWL GDQ :DOLNRWD 0HQMDGL 8QGDQJ 8QGDQJ
