ATOM INDONESIA JOURNAL
Associate Editor's ReportArticle No. : 474
Title of Paper : The evaluation of the effective diameter (Deff) calculation and its impact on the size-specific dose estimate (SSDE)
Associate Editor Name : Comment on Descriptions
Criteria Evaluation
Associate editor's evaluation
Yes No Comments
1. Originality of the article
Free of Plagiarism/Similarity
(max 20%) v
New article/not yet Published (presented/ in proceeding max 30%)
v 2. Related to nuclear/atomic science
and technology v
3. Reference
The number of references at least 10, at most 20 for nonreview papers; at least 26 for review papers.
x
The paper's 35 references are at least fifteen too many for a nonreview paper. Reduce the number of references by at least 15.
The use of recent references 80%
(maximum 5 years ago) x
Only 19 of 35 (54 %) of the references are that new. Add recent references – or reduce older references if they are not really necessary.
Type of the references (primarily,
secondary etc.) 85% from journal v
Only 28 of 35 (80 %) references are from journals. Add references from journals – or reduce references from other sources if they are not really necessary
Cross link reference (traceable) x
It would make the references more traceable if DOI crosslinks are given. For instance, for Ref [13], the DOI crosslink is
http://dx.doi.org/10.1088/0031-9155/59/3/R129
Reference style standard: Elsevier
numeric without title v
When reference has more than 3
Authors, write only 3 names, et al. x
[5, 6,20-22,26-35] list more than three names.
[8,10,23] correctly give only three names, but et al. should be italicized.
Article follows the Atom Indonesia
template and guidelines v
Table (clear, without vertical line) v
Figure (clear, min 300 dpi) v
Final recommendation:
1. Continue review process [ ] 2. Return to the Author [ v ] 3. Reject [ ]
Comments:
The paper should be returned to the authors to allow for the necessary improvements to be made.
