bukti korespondensi artikel jurnal internasional bereputasi

(1)

BUKTI KORESPONDENSI

ARTIKEL JURNAL INTERNASIONAL BEREPUTASI

Judul artikel : Maintain Sustainability of Historic Village as Tourism Village. The Case of Bustaman Village in Semarang, Indonesia

Jurnal : Aestimum, Volume 76 (2020): 79-98

Penulis : Suzanna Ratih Sari, Muhammad Fariz Hilmy, Eko Punto Hendro, Dhanoe Iswanto

No Perihal Tanggal

1. Submit artikel dan konfirmasi artikel sukses disubmit 2 Maret 2020 2. Penulis menanyakan apakah artikelnya sudah direview 30 Maret 2020 3. Konfirmasi editor sedang memproses artikel 1 April 2020 4. Keputusan jurnal menerima artikel dan memberi review 11 Mei 2020 5. Submit kembali artikel dan permintaan jurnal mengisi response

letter

20 Mei 2020

6. Konfirmasi editor menerima respon letter 26 Mei 2020 7. Keputusan jurnal menerima artikel untuk dipublish 19 Juni 2020 8. Permintaan jurnal mengisi “technical editing manuscript” 22 Juni 2020 9. Permintaan jurnal menambahkan JEL code pada artikel 23 Juni 2020 10. Penulis mengirimkan JEL code pada editor 23 Juni 2020 11. Jurnal mengirimkan final page proof dan meminta penulis

memastikan semua penulisan sudah sesuai

9 Juli 2020

12. Penulis memastikan apakah Aestimum masih terindex Scopus 11 Juli 2020 13. Konfirmasi jurnal bahwa Aestimum masih terindex Scopus 11 Juli 2020 14. Submit final proof dan permintaan untuk menambahkan

acknowledgment

12 Juli 2020

15. Konfirmasi editor menerima artikel dan akan menambahkan acknoledgment

13 Juli 2020

16. Pemberitahuan artikel telah terbit di volume 76 (2020) 20 Juli 2020 17. Pemberitahuan jurnal bahwa artikel belum masuk ke database

Scopus dan akan berusaha memperbaiki masalah tersebut

26 April 2021

18. Penulis mengkonfirmasi dan menyatakan bahwa artikelnya sudah seharusnya masuk ke dalam Scopus database

27 April 2021

19. Penulis menanyakan lagi apakah artikel sudah masuk ke dalam Scopus database

17 Mei 2021

20. Konfirmasi editor akan segera memperbaiki masalah tersebut 17 Mei 2021

21. Penulis merespon konfirmasi editor 18 Mei 2021

(2)

22. Editor mengirimkan konfirmasi dari pihak Scopus bahwa artikel sedang dalam masa tunggu

18 Mei 2021

23. Penulis merespon konfirmasi editor 20 Mei 2021

24. Penulis menanyakan bagaimana progres artikelnya 25 Mei 2021 25. Editor menyatakan belum ada konfirmasi dari pihak Scopus 28 Mei 2021 26. Penulis menanyakan lagi mengapa indexasi artikel memakan

waktu yang lama

23 Juni 2021

27. Penulis menanyakan lagi apakah editor masih kontak dengan pihak Scopus dan bagaimana progressnya

8 Juli 2021

28. Editor mengirimkan konfrimasi dari pihak Scopus bahwa artikel akan muncul di database Scopus dalam dua minggu

14 Juli 2021

29. Penulis menanyakan lagi bagaimana progress artikel dengan pihak Scopus

3 Agustus 2021

30. Editor menyatakan bahwa artikel belum masuk ke dalam database Scopus dan tidak mengetahui mengapa demikian

9 Agustus 2021

31. Penulis merespon konfirmasi editor 9 Agustus 2021

32. Penulis menanyakan lagi bagaimana progress artikel dan apakah antara Aestimum dan Scopus ada konflik sehingga menyebabkan permasalahan demikian

20 Agustus 2021

33. Editor menyatakan bahwa tidak ada konflik apapun dan akan menanyakan ke pihak Scopus

21 Agustus 2021

34. Penulis menanyakan lagi bagaimana progress artikel dan belum dibahas

12 September 2021

(3)

17/09/21 11.19 Yahoo Mail - [Aestimum] Submission Acknowledgement

[Aestimum] Submission Acknowledgement

Dari: Enrico Marone ([email protected]) Kepada: [email protected]

Tanggal: Senin, 2 Maret 2020 15.37 GMT+7

Suzanna Ratih Sari:

Thank you for submitting the manuscript, "Developing Sustainable Tourism of Goat Village: The Case of Bustaman Village, Semarang, Indonesia" to Aestimum. With the online journal management system that we are using, you will be able to track its progress through the editorial process by logging in to the journal web site:

Submission URL: https://oaj.fupress.net/index.php/ceset/authorDashboard/submission/8284 Username: ratihsaris

If you have any questions, please contact me. Thank you for considering this journal as a venue for your work.

Enrico Marone

________________________________________________________________________

Aestimum

(4)

17/09/21 11.26 Yahoo Mail - Re: [Aestimum] Submission Acknowledgement

Re: [Aestimum] Submission Acknowledgement

Dari: Suzanna Ratih sari ([email protected]) Kepada: [email protected]

Tanggal: Senin, 30 Maret 2020 10.49 GMT+7

Dear Aestimum,

I would like to ask about my submission if my manuscript has been reviewed? please give us information about that, thankyou

Sincerely,

Dr. Ir. Suzanna Ratih Sari, MM.,MA.

Department of Architecture Diponegoro University Semarang, Indonesia

Pada Senin, 2 Maret 2020 15.37.05 WIB, Enrico Marone <[email protected]> menulis:

Suzanna Ratih Sari:

Enrico Marone

________________________________________________________________________

Aestimum

(5)

17/09/21 11.26 Yahoo Mail - [Aestimum] Submission Acknowledgement

[Aestimum] Submission Acknowledgement

Dari: Fabio Boncinelli ([email protected]) Kepada: [email protected]

Tanggal: Rabu, 1 April 2020 04.25 GMT+7

Dear Suzanna Ratih Sari,

Thank you for your email. Your manuscript is still under review. Unfortunately, We are facing some difficulties to find two experts in the field of your study willing to review it.

We strongly hope to reach an editorial decision in the next two months.

Please do not hesitate to contact us should you have further enquiry Yours sincerely

Fabio Boncinelli Section Editor Aestimum

--- Messaggio Inoltrato ---

Oggetto:Re: [Aestimum] Submission Acknowledgement Data:Mon, 30 Mar 2020 03:49:29 +0000 (UTC) Mittente:Suzanna Ratih sari <[email protected]>

A:Enrico Marone <[email protected]>

Dear Aestimum,

I would like to ask about my submission if my manuscript has been reviewed? please give us information about that, thankyou

Sincerely,

Pada Senin, 2 Maret 2020 15.37.05 WIB, Enrico Marone <[email protected]> menulis:

Suzanna Ratih Sari:

(6)

17/09/21 11.30 Yahoo Mail - [Aestimum] Editor Decision

[Aestimum] Editor Decision

Dari: Fabio Boncinelli ([email protected])

Kepada: [email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected] Tanggal: Senin, 11 Mei 2020 17.19 GMT+7

Suzanna Ratih Sari, Muhammad Fariz Hilmy, Eko Punto Hendro, Dhanoe Iswanto:

We have reached a decision regarding your submission to Aestimum, "Developing Sustainable Tourism of Goat Village:

The Case of Bustaman Village, Semarang, Indonesia".

Our decision is to: Resubmit for Review

The reviewers have raised a number of points which we believe would improve the manuscript and may allow a revised version to be published in Aestimum. Please consider that your article is borderline since Reviewer B suggests to submit your article elsewhere. Their reports, together with any other comments, are below.

If you are able to fully address these points, we would encourage you to submit a revised manuscript including a point- by-point response letter. Please ensure you describe additional experiments that were carried out and include a detailed rebuttal of any criticisms or requested revisions that you disagreed with. Please also ensure that your revised manuscript conforms to the journal style, which can be found in the journal website.

The due date for submitting the revised version of your article is 28 June 2020. Do not hesitate to contact me if you need extra time.

We look forward to receiving your revised manuscript soon.

Best wishes, Fabio Boncinelli University of Florence [email protected]

--- Reviewer A:

Dear colleagues,

this is an interesting field research, providing important insights on how a traditional village with a reputation on goat meat can follow a strategy to increase its appeal as a sustainable tourism destination.

Despite the descriptive analysis provided, the paper in its current version lacks some important aspects that are relevant for the quality standards of this journal.

(7)

be improved.

The rest of the paper should be re-written according to the above mentioned section. For instance, quotes could be included, references to the different kind of data collected should me mentioned, and more generally, a clear summary of these information could be provided in a table.

Finally, I've found several typos mistakes and it does not seem to me that the paper flows very well. I would suggest a professional proof reading to increase the readability of this work.

---

--- Reviewer B:

Based on the informative manuscript, I understand the unique attributes of Bustaman village regarding tourism and cultural heritage. However, it seems to be an essay or report, not an academic article adequate to Aestimum. I recommend it would be much more appropriate if the authors resubmit this manuscript to other journals that focus on the theme such as community planning, urban planning of developing countries, qualitative research of tourism, or Asian development (Of course, the contents should be revised a bit). The topic and a way of the suggestion definitely could help other places experiencing similar problems. My review of this manuscript is as below.

First of all, even though the authors explain the reason why this village should be developed as an attractive tourism destination through the introduction part, I could not understand “why Bustaman village, not for other villages in Semarang city or elsewhere in Indonesia. Organizing tourism destinations requires lots of budgets, governmental and private resources, changes in residents’ lifestyle, etc. The authors should provide the logical explanation or analysis results about “why Bustaman, and how the plan make happen.”

In a methodology part, the way of interview and observations should be presented in detail. As the authors argue this research had been conducted by the qualitative methods, the detailed information about the interviews and

observations is quite important.

Lastly, the rearrangement of the zoning pattern the authors proposed seems much more effective and plausible (see Figure 9), but the feasibility is doubtful. Also, I am not sure that it could promote the goat tourism of Bustaman village.

The authors’ suggestion would help the street neat, hygienic, and well-organized, but it is arguably limited to improve tourists’ visit. That is because it is not related to eco-tourism, religious tourism, or even animal-friendly tourism, which attracts tourists nowadays. The concept the authors proposed seems to be only about the zoning regarding community planning. Of course, the authors mention environmentally friendly village and sustainability, however the terms seem to be over-interpreted. Merely using biogas is not considered as an environmentally friendly village (It is not even tightly connected to the blueprint of goat tourism.) and the logical flow the authors refer to sustainability is not convincing. And how much demand would exist for this type of goat tourism in Indonesia or near the Bustaman village? In my

understanding, it is doubtful how many people want to just see the high-density breeding, butchering, and processing in their bare eyes. To achieve the goal of this research, the authors rather suggest the rearranged zoning pattern and value-added activities including environmentally friendly breeding, cultural activities related to goat tourism, well- processed goat meat, goat-themed goods closely. Despite the questions I raised, if the demand for goat tourism the authors assume is huge in Indonesia, the author should add the information or demand analysis results.

---

________________________________________________________________________

Aestimum

(8)

[Aestimum] Editor Decision

Kepada: [email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected] Tanggal: Rabu, 20 Mei 2020 17.35 GMT+7

Thank you to submit the revised version of your manuscript. Please include a point-by-point response letter. Please ensure you describe additional experiments that were carried out and include a detailed rebuttal of any criticisms or requested revisions that you disagreed with. Please also ensure that your revised manuscript conforms to the journal style, which can be found in the journal website.

I am looking forward to receiving your revised version with the response letter.

Best regards Fabio Boncinelli University of Florence [email protected]

________________________________________________________________________

Aestimum

(9)

17/09/21 11.37 Yahoo Mail - Re: [Aestimum] Editor Decision

Re: [Aestimum] Editor Decision

Dari: Fabio Boncinelli ([email protected]) Kepada: [email protected]

Tanggal: Selasa, 26 Mei 2020 15.03 GMT+7

Dear Suzanna,

Thank you for your e-mail. I hereby confirm we received your response letter and the revised version of your manuscript. The Reviewers are revising your study.

Best regards Fabio Boncinelli Aestimum

Il 26-05-2020 08:50 Suzanna Ratih sari ha scritto:

Dear Aestimum,

I have submit revision of our manuscipt with response letter in the website. Here, I send it again by email to make sure you recieve my manuscript and response letter.

Thankyou very much

Pada Rabu, 20 Mei 2020 17.35.38 WIB, Fabio Boncinelli <[email protected]> menulis:

Thank you to submit the revised version of your manuscript. Please include a point-by-point response letter.

Please ensure you describe additional experiments that were carried out and include a detailed rebuttal of any criticisms or requested revisions that you disagreed with. Please also ensure that your revised manuscript conforms to the journal style, which can be found in the journal website.

I am looking forward to receiving your revised version with the response letter.

Best regards Fabio Boncinelli University of Florence [email protected]

(10)

[Aestimum] Editor Decision

Kepada: [email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected] Tanggal: Jumat, 19 Juni 2020 23.30 GMT+7

C-8284-Article Text-12582-1-4-20200521def.docx 1.8MB

We have reached a decision regarding your submission to Aestimum, "Developing Sustainable Tourism of Goat Village:

The Case of Bustaman Village, Semarang, Indonesia".

Our decision is to: Accept Submission Fabio Boncinelli

University of Florence [email protected]

________________________________________________________________________

Aestimum

(11)

17/09/21 11.39 Yahoo Mail - [Aestimum] New notification from Aestimum

[Aestimum] New notification from Aestimum

Dari: Andrea Dominici ([email protected]) Kepada: [email protected]

Tanggal: Senin, 22 Juni 2020 15.01 GMT+7

You have a new notification from Aestimum:

You have been added to a discussion titled "Technical editing manuscript" regarding the submission "Developing Sustainable Tourism of Goat Village".

Link: https://oaj.fupress.net/index.php/ceset/authorDashboard/submission/8284 Enrico Marone

________________________________________________________________________

Aestimum

(12)

17/09/21 11.42 Yahoo Mail - Aestimum information

Aestimum information

Dari: andrea dominici ([email protected]) Kepada: [email protected]

Tanggal: Selasa, 23 Juni 2020 14.18 GMT+7

Dear Dr. Ir. Suzanna Ratih Sari,

I'm Andrea Dominici, the Editorial Manager of Aestimu. Yesterday you have received a notification from Aestimum because I send you a message in the "Review Discussions" section about your manuscript. In particular, in the message I want to congratulate you on having your paper “Maintain Sustainability of Historic Village as Tourism Village. The Case Of Bustaman Village In Semarang, Indonesia” accepted for publication in Aestimum.

Before formatting the article for publication and author proofing, I need you provide the JEL codes for your article. Please supply these codes answering to this mail. I will add this missing information on your manuscript.

Thank you for your contribution. For any problem, do not hesitate to contact me.

Best regards, Andrea Dominici

--

Andrea Dominici, Ph.D.

DAGRI - Dipartimento di Scienze e Tecnologie Agrarie, Alimentari, Ambientali e Forestali Università degli Studi di Firenze

P.le delle Cascine, 18 50144 Firenze Tel. +39 0552755738

Cell. +39 3406731378

(13)

17/09/21 11.42 Yahoo Mail - Re: Aestimum information

Re: Aestimum information

Tanggal: Selasa, 23 Juni 2020 14.57 GMT+7

Dear Editor,

Thankyou for your explanation. with this email, I would like to add our JEL codes: Q56, Z32 Please give us further information regarding the publication.

Thankyou very much Best regards,

Pada Selasa, 23 Juni 2020 14.18.04 WIB, andrea dominici <[email protected]> menulis:

Dear Dr. Ir. Suzanna Ratih Sari,

I'm Andrea Dominici, the Editorial Manager of Aestimu. Yesterday you have received a notification from Aestimum because I send you a message in the "Review Discussions" section about your manuscript. In particular, in the message I want to congratulate you on having your paper “Maintain Sustainability of Historic Village as Tourism Village. The Case Of Bustaman Village In Semarang, Indonesia” accepted for publication in Aestimum.

Before formatting the article for publication and author proofing, I need you provide the JEL codes for your article. Please supply these codes answering to this mail. I will add this missing information on your manuscript.

Thank you for your contribution. For any problem, do not hesitate to contact me.

Best regards, Andrea Dominici

--

Cell. +39 3406731378

(14)

17/09/21 11.45 Yahoo Mail - Final version article Aestimum

Final version article Aestimum

Cc: [email protected]

Tanggal: Kamis, 9 Juli 2020 21.32 GMT+7

8284-Article Text-14434-RatihSari.pdf 2.6MB

Dear Author,

I'm writing you regarding your article "Maintain Sustainability of Historic Village as Tourism Village. The Case Of Bustaman Village In Semarang, Indonesia", accepted on Aestimum and that will be published in the number 76 (2020).

I send you the final version of the article, formatted for publication.

Please read it accurately, and verify if the name of the authors are corrected. Then, following the instruction of the first page of PDF, please correct eventually errors and add the missing information (these written in red font in the PDF). The abstract is in red font because it exceeds the 1000 characters (space included) allowed by the Journal guidelines. Please revise it considering this maximum dimension.

Courteously, I need to receive the corrected final version of the PDF for Monday 13 July.

Thank you for your contribution, best regards

Andrea Dominici

Editorial Assistant of Aestimum --

Cell. +39 3406731378

(15)

17/09/21 11.46 Yahoo Mail - Re: Final version article Aestimum

Re: Final version article Aestimum

Tanggal: Sabtu, 11 Juli 2020 00.19 GMT+7

Dear Aestimum,

Thank you very much for your information. If you don't mind, I would like to ask a question. I open the Scopus website and find out that Aestimum's coverage years are from 2008 to 2019. Would you explain if Aestimum is not covered on Scopus now or not? Please give me information about this.

Sincerely,

Pada Kamis, 9 Juli 2020 21.32.29 WIB, andrea dominici <[email protected]> menulis:

Dear Author,

(16)

Re: Final version article Aestimum

Tanggal: Sabtu, 11 Juli 2020 00.43 GMT+7

Dear Author,

all articles published in Aestimum since 2008 are indexed by Scopus. So your article, as all the articles that Aestimum will publish in 2020, will be indexed by Scopus.

As remino, please send me the final version of the article revised before Monday 13.

Best regards, Andrea Dominici

Editorial Assistant of Aestimum

Il giorno 10 lug 2020, alle ore 19:19, Suzanna Ratih sari <[email protected]> ha scritto:

Dear Aestimum,

Thank you very much for your information. If you don't mind, I would like to ask a question. I open the Scopus website and find out that Aestimum's coverage years are from 2008 to 2019. Would you explain if Aestimum is not covered on Scopus now or not? Please give me information about this.

Sincerely,

<1594401358197blob.jpg>

Dear Author,

I'm writing you regarding your article "Maintain Sustainability of

(17)

Re: Final version article Aestimum

Tanggal: Minggu, 12 Juli 2020 14.11 GMT+7

Dear Aestimum,

Here I send you the revision of our article. I would like to ask, may I add the acknowledgment part?

If I may, please add the acknowledgment that I write below:

Authors thank informants in Bustaman Village and all of those who have helped researchers in completing this Research. Researchers are also grateful to Diponegoro University for providing grants to researchers so that this Research can be completed on time.

Thank you very much.

Sincerely

Dear Author,

Courteously, I need to receive the corrected final version of the PDF for Monday 13 July.

Thank you for your contribution, best regards

Andrea Dominici

Editorial Assistant of Aestimum --

(18)

Re: Final version article Aestimum

Tanggal: Senin, 13 Juli 2020 18.49 GMT+7

Dear Author,

Thank you for your revisions. I have also added the acknowledgments, as you suggested.

Il 12/07/2020 09:11, Suzanna Ratih sari ha scritto:

Dear Aestimum,

Here I send you the revision of our article. I would like to ask, may I add the acknowledgment part?

If I may, please add the acknowledgment that I write below:

Authors thank informants in Bustaman Village and all of those who have helped researchers in completing this Research. Researchers are also grateful to Diponegoro University for providing grants to researchers so that this Research can be completed on time.

Thank you very much.

Sincerely

Dear Author,

(19)

17/09/21 11.51 Yahoo Mail - AESTIMUM - article publication

AESTIMUM - article publication

Dari: andrea dominici ([email protected]) Tanggal: Senin, 20 Juli 2020 17.46 GMT+7

Dear Author,

I am glad to communicate that the Aestimum new volume (76), with your contribution, is officially out. All articles are available online at this page:

https://oaj.fupress.net/index.php/ceset/issue/view/533

We would like to thank all of those who contributed to the Volume!

Best Regards, Andrea Dominici

Aestimum Editorial Assistant --

Cell. +39 3406731378

(20)

17/09/21 12.01 Yahoo Mail - Technical editing manuscript Aestimum

Technical editing manuscript Aestimum

Tanggal: Senin, 26 April 2021 16.12 GMT+7

Dear Author,

Congratulations on having your paper “Sustainability of Traditional Markets Post-Revitalization” accepted for publication in Aestimum. The article will be published in the Volume 78 (June 2021). However, it will be immediately available online on the "Just Accepted" page with its DOI.

Before posting the article in the "Just Accepted" page, I am writing to you in regards to a technical editing. In particular:

- the abstract should be reduced according the Journal Guidelines (max 1000 characters, spaces included).

- the references in the references list at the end of the manuscript should be revised according to the journal guidelines.

- please provide the title and the keywords also in Italian language, responding to this message. While the keywords in Italian will appear in the article, the Italian version of the title will be appear only in the index of the paper volume of Aestimum (and not in Scopus or other online resources). If you find some difficulties in

translation, we will translate these.

You can upload a corrected version of the last file you have uploaded on Aestimum, with corrections in track.

Regarding your article published in Aestimum 76 (2020) "Maintain Sustainability of Historic Village as Tourism Village. The Case of Bustaman Village in Semarang, Indonesia", Scopus has not inserted it in its database, while other articles of the same volume are present. I have already solicited Scopus for it. If you also demand to Scopus to add the article, I think they will do it faster.

Thank you for your contribution. For any problem, do not hesitate to contact me.

--

(21)

17/09/21 12.08 Yahoo Mail - Re: Technical editing manuscript Aestimum

Re: Technical editing manuscript Aestimum

Tanggal: Selasa, 27 April 2021 11.25 GMT+7

Dear Andrea,

I have submitted the final manuscript to the Aestimum website. Please check it out and confirm that you have received my manuscript.

I also confirm regarding my previous article entitled "Maintain Sustainability of Historic Village as Tourism Village. The Case of Bustaman Village in Semarang, Indonesia" that I demand my paper to be included in the Scopus database. I think that it is automatic while we publish the paper in the scopus-indexed journal, the paper will be inserted into the Scopus database.

Best regards,

Pada Senin, 26 April 2021 16.12.32 GMT+7, Andrea Dominici <[email protected]> menulis:

Dear Author,

- please provide the title and the keywords also in Italian language, responding to this message. While the keywords in Italian will appear in the article, the Italian version of the title will be appear only in the index of the paper volume of Aestimum (and not in Scopus or other online resources). If you find some difficulties in translation, we will translate these.

You can upload a corrected version of the last file you have uploaded on Aestimum, with corrections in track.

Regarding your article published in Aestimum 76 (2020) "Maintain Sustainability of Historic Village as Tourism Village. The Case of Bustaman Village in Semarang, Indonesia", Scopus has not inserted it in its database, while other articles of the same volume are present. I have already solicited Scopus for it. If you also demand to Scopus to add the article, I think they will do it faster.

(22)

Re: Technical editing manuscript Aestimum

Tanggal: Senin, 17 Mei 2021 08.44 GMT+7

Dear Andrea,

I want to follow up on my article entitled "Maintain Sustainability of Historic Village as Tourism Village. The Case of Bustaman Village in Semarang, Indonesia" that has published in Aestimum 76 (2020). Has my article included in the Scopus database?

Please give me the information about your journal. Was Aestimum indexed in Scopus (2020) and still (2021). Please give me the evidence such as the link or screenshot. I need this information because there is an issue that my latest article is not indexed in Scopus, So I want to verify to you about the Aestimum journal in 2020 and 2021. Thank you very much. I really wait for your response.

Best regards,

Dear Author,

- please provide the title and the keywords also in Italian language, responding to this message. While the keywords in Italian will appear in the article, the Italian version of the title will be appear only in the index of the paper volume of Aestimum (and not in Scopus or other online resources). If you find some difficulties in translation, we will translate these.

(23)

Re: Technical editing manuscript Aestimum

Tanggal: Senin, 17 Mei 2021 14.27 GMT+7

Dear Suzanna,

your article "Maintain Sustainability of Historic Village as Tourism Village. The Case of Bustaman Village in Semarang, Indonesia" (volume 76) must be included in the Scopus database. Of Volume 76, Scopus has included only 2 articles out of a total of 5. I have informed Scopus Support with a mail on 23 March, attaching the pdf of the missing articles, and they have guaranteed me "this correction may take up to four weeks to be completed".

I ask you sorry for this delay. Today I will write again to Scopus Support to solve this problem. Next week, I will have a meet with the publisher where I inform him about this Scopus delay in uploading the articles, asking to urge Scopus to avoid this problem.

In the meantime, my suggestion for you is to contact the Scopus support asking them to insert your article in the database.

Do not hesitate to contact me for any further problems.

Best Regard, Andrea Dominici

Aestimu Editorial Assistant

Il giorno lun 17 mag 2021 alle ore 03:44 Suzanna Ratih sari <[email protected]> ha scritto:

Dear Andrea,

Please give me the information about your journal. Was Aestimum indexed in Scopus (2020) and still (2021).

Please give me the evidence such as the link or screenshot. I need this information because there is an issue that my latest article is not indexed in Scopus, So I want to verify to you about the Aestimum journal in 2020 and 2021. Thank you very much. I really wait for your response.

Best regards,

Dear Author,

(24)

Re: Technical editing manuscript Aestimum

Thank you for your answer. Please give me further information regarding this problem. I need these articles to be included in the Scopus database.

Pada Senin, 17 Mei 2021 14.27.18 GMT+7, Andrea Dominici <[email protected]> menulis:

Dear Suzanna,

your article "Maintain Sustainability of Historic Village as Tourism Village. The Case of Bustaman Village in

Semarang, Indonesia" (volume 76) must be included in the Scopus database. Of Volume 76, Scopus has included only 2 articles out of a total of 5. I have informed Scopus Support with a mail on 23 March, attaching the pdf of the missing articles, and they have guaranteed me "this correction may take up to four weeks to be completed".

I ask you sorry for this delay. Today I will write again to Scopus Support to solve this problem. Next week, I will have a meet with the publisher where I inform him about this Scopus delay in uploading the articles, asking to urge Scopus to avoid this problem.

In the meantime, my suggestion for you is to contact the Scopus support asking them to insert your article in the database.

Do not hesitate to contact me for any further problems.

Best Regard, Andrea Dominici

Aestimu Editorial Assistant

Il giorno lun 17 mag 2021 alle ore 03:44 Suzanna Ratih sari <[email protected]> ha scritto:

Dear Andrea,

Please give me the information about your journal. Was Aestimum indexed in Scopus (2020) and still (2021).

Please give me the evidence such as the link or screenshot. I need this information because there is an issue that my latest article is not indexed in Scopus, So I want to verify to you about the Aestimum journal in 2020 and 2021. Thank you very much. I really wait for your response.

(25)

17/09/21 12.18 Yahoo Mail - Fwd: Aestimum [210517-007880]

Fwd: Aestimum [210517-007880]

Dear Suzanna,

This is the answear of Scopus Support.

Andrea

--- Messaggio inoltrato ---

Da: Scopus Support (ELS) <[email protected]>

Data: mar 18 mag 2021 alle 04:36 Oggetto: Re: Aestimum [210517-007880]

A: <[email protected]>

Dear Andrea Dominici,

Thank you for the email regarding the article: "Maintain Sustainability of Historic Village as Tourism Village. The Case of Bustaman Village in Semarang, Indonesia"

I apologize unreservedly for the delay in processing your request.

After verification, I would like to let you know that the above article is processed in Ticket no. 210321-004825 and updates on this will be provided through the mentioned ticket no.

Please be advised that due to some technical issues the article is getting delayed in reflecting in Scopus.

Our technical team has identified the issue and have initiated a workaround to solve this issue on high priority and I will personally follow your request.

I will contact you again to confirm the date in which the article is going to reflect in Scopus.

Again, I am sorry for the time that it is taking and the inconveniences that it is causing you.

Thank you and have a nice day.

If I can be of any further assistance, please do not hesitate to contact me.

Kind Regards, Krishna Pradeep Content Service Desk

ELSEVIER

[---002:002511:61711---]

--

(26)

17/09/21 13.11 Yahoo Mail - Re: Aestimum [210517-007880]

Re: Aestimum [210517-007880]

Tanggal: Kamis, 20 Mei 2021 10.19 GMT+7

Thank you for your prompt answer. I will be waiting for your further updates. Thank you.

Pada Selasa, 18 Mei 2021 11.37.33 WIB, Andrea Dominici <[email protected]> menulis:

Dear Suzanna,

Andrea

After verification, I would like to let you know that the above article is processed in Ticket no. 210321- 004825 and updates on this will be provided through the mentioned ticket no.

Our technical team has identified the issue and have initiated a workaround to solve this issue on high

(27)

17/09/21 12.19 Yahoo Mail - Re: Aestimum [210517-007880]

Re: Aestimum [210517-007880]

Dear Andrea,

How far is the progress of my article? Please give me some updates. I really need this article to be indexed in Scopus because I have to submit it to my institution

Best regards,

Pada Selasa, 18 Mei 2021 11.37.33 GMT+7, Andrea Dominici <[email protected]> menulis:

Dear Suzanna,

Andrea

After verification, I would like to let you know that the above article is processed in Ticket no. 210321- 004825 and updates on this will be provided through the mentioned ticket no.

Our technical team has identified the issue and have initiated a workaround to solve this issue on high priority and I will personally follow your request.

I will contact you again to confirm the date in which the article is going to reflect in Scopus.

Again, I am sorry for the time that it is taking and the inconveniences that it is causing you.

(28)

Re: Technical editing manuscript Aestimum

Tanggal: Rabu, 23 Juni 2021 15.03 GMT+7

Dear Andrea,

concerning your article "Maintain Sustainability of Historic Village as Tourism Village. The Case of Bustaman Village in Semarang, Indonesia" (76, 2020), I would ask why it takes so long to include my article in the Scopus database? Is there a problem? Please give me some updates.

Pada Jumat, 28 Mei 2021 18.31.13 GMT+7, Andrea Dominici <[email protected]> menulis:

Dear Suzanna,

concerning your article "Maintain Sustainability of Historic Village as Tourism Village. The Case of Bustaman Village in Semarang, Indonesia" (76, 2020), unfortunately I have no news from Scopus. As I wrote to you, I have informed the publisher about this Scopus delay in uploading the articles, asking to urge Scopus to avoid this problem. I don't know if you also have contacted the Scopus support to pressure them.

For the new issue of Aestimum (78, 2021), I'm sorry but I don't have an exact date. I think it will be ready between the end of June and the 15th of July.

Aestimum Editorial Assistant

Il giorno gio 27 mag 2021 alle ore 11:34 Suzanna Ratih sari <[email protected]> ha scritto:

Dear Andrea,

I want to follow up on my article entitled "Sustainability of Traditional Markets Post-Revitalization". When my article will be published in June? If it's possible please give me information about the exact date. I'm looking forward to your further information. Thank you so much

Best regards,

Department of Architecture

(29)

17/09/21 12.26 Yahoo Mail - Follow Up

Follow Up

Dari: Suzanna Ratih sari ([email protected]) Kepada: [email protected]; [email protected] Tanggal: Kamis, 8 Juli 2021 15.24 GMT+7

Dear Aestimum,

Regarding my article entitled "Maintain Sustainability of Historic Village as Tourism Village. The Case of Bustaman Village in Semarang, Indonesia" (76, 2020). Are you still contacting Scopus and following up on my article to be included in Scopus database? Because until now, my article does not appear on my Scopus id. I really need your help to fix this problem. I think other authors have the same problem as me. If you can help us, we really appreciate it. Thank you very much.

Best regards,

(30)

17/09/21 12.26 Yahoo Mail - Re: Follow Up

Re: Follow Up

Cc: [email protected]

Tanggal: Rabu, 14 Juli 2021 23.32 GMT+7

Dear Author,

I'm very sorry for this situation. The Editor in Chief of Aestimum has asked the Publisher to contact Scopus and to resolve this problem of indexing. I have contacted Scopus again, and today I have received this answer:

Thank you for your patience while we were dealing with your request.

I can confirm that the requested titles

1.A decision support system for assessing the perception and acceptance of WTs in high-value landscapes:

The case of Chianti Classico (Italy)

2.Le esternalità ambientali dell’irrigazione in Italia

3.Maintain Sustainability of Historic Village as Tourism Village. The Case of Bustaman Village in Semarang, Indonesia

4.Modeling preference heterogeneity in recreation random utility models when relevant information about users is limited

will reflect in Scopus within 2 weeks.

Should you notice that it does not reflect within this time frame, please do not hesitate to contact me.

ELSEVIER

I hope that this problem should be resolved as soon as possible.

Il giorno gio 8 lug 2021 alle ore 10:24 Suzanna Ratih sari <[email protected]> ha scritto:

Dear Aestimum,

Regarding my article entitled "Maintain Sustainability of Historic Village as Tourism Village. The Case of

(31)

17/09/21 12.27 Yahoo Mail - Re: Follow Up

Re: Follow Up

Tanggal: Selasa, 3 Agustus 2021 10.23 GMT+7

Dear Andrea, your latest email (July 14) said that my article will be reflecting in Scopus within 2 weeks. And today is more than 2 weeks. would you please check it out or follow up with the Scopus Service Desk? Actually, I am very stressed waiting for this uncertainty. what is the problem actually? why is my article not included in the Scopus database while other articles in the same volume as me are included? Is there any problem between Aestimum and Scopus? please be honest and transparent with me and other authors that have the same problem as me. I will not stop emailing you if you don't give me the certainty.

Pada Rabu, 14 Juli 2021 23.32.44 GMT+7, Andrea Dominici <[email protected]> menulis:

Dear Author,

I'm very sorry for this situation. The Editor in Chief of Aestimum has asked the Publisher to contact Scopus and to resolve this problem of indexing. I have contacted Scopus again, and today I have received this answer:

Thank you for your patience while we were dealing with your request.

I can confirm that the requested titles

1.A decision support system for assessing the perception and acceptance of WTs in high-value landscapes:

The case of Chianti Classico (Italy)

2.Le esternalità ambientali dell’irrigazione in Italia

3.Maintain Sustainability of Historic Village as Tourism Village. The Case of Bustaman Village in Semarang, Indonesia

4.Modeling preference heterogeneity in recreation random utility models when relevant information about users is limited

will reflect in Scopus within 2 weeks.

Should you notice that it does not reflect within this time frame, please do not hesitate to contact me.

ELSEVIER

I hope that this problem should be resolved as soon as possible.

(32)

17/09/21 12.29 Yahoo Mail - Re: Wondering

Re: Wondering

Tanggal: Senin, 9 Agustus 2021 13.50 GMT+7

Dear Suzanna,

I apologize for this delay in answering your two mails. I’m here to give you assistance and to answering your questions.

Regarding your article “Maintain Sustainability of Historic Village as Tourism Village”, this is the only paper now missing in the platform Scopus. I don’t know why, despite my several requests to Scopus for all the three missing articles of the Volume 76 (including yours), two were included as you can see in Scopus. I have so contacted the support for

understanding why your article is still missing, although it has already been some months since I made the first enquiry.

They have replied to me that this correction need further time. The Editor and the Publisher are informed about this intolerable way of acting of Scopus, and collaborate with me to solve this problem. I ask you and to your co-authors sorry for this circumstances. My suggestion for you is to persist with us in contacting Scopus support to include the article in the platform.

Regarding the New volume of Aestimum, 78 (2021), we had some delay due to a paper included in the volume. In last days, I’ve solve this problem and all articles have been sent to the publishers for preparing the last proof copy. I also apologize on behalf of the Editor for this further delay.

It is in my interest and in the Journal interest that the authors are satisfied in collaborating with Aestimum. I'm doing everything possible to ensure it is too for you.

I’m here for all the assistence you need.

Il giorno lun 9 ago 2021 alle 05:05 Suzanna Ratih sari <[email protected]> ha scritto:

Why haven't you replied to me? I need your certainty regarding my paper. Please give me your assistance to fix this problem. I have been waiting so long for this. Please.

Department of Architecture Diponegoro University Semarang, Indonesia --

P.le delle Cascine, 18 - 50144 Firenze, Italy

(33)

17/09/21 12.29 Yahoo Mail - Re: Wondering

Re: Wondering

Tanggal: Senin, 9 Agustus 2021 20.14 GMT+7

Dear Andrea,

Thank you for your kindly assistance and information. I do really hope that my paper would be soon listed in the scopus platform just like the others. I do really need it Andrea. Regarding the new volume, if you don't mind, could you please give me information when it would be published? Because I have to inform my university.

I am looking forward for your further information. Thank you very much.

Best Regards,

Pada Senin, 9 Agustus 2021 13.50.00 GMT+7, Andrea Dominici <[email protected]> menulis:

Dear Suzanna,

I apologize for this delay in answering your two mails. I’m here to give you assistance and to answering your questions.

Regarding your article “Maintain Sustainability of Historic Village as Tourism Village”, this is the only paper now missing in the platform Scopus. I don’t know why, despite my several requests to Scopus for all the three missing articles of the Volume 76 (including yours), two were included as you can see in Scopus. I have so contacted the support for understanding why your article is still missing, although it has already been some months since I made the first enquiry. They have replied to me that this correction need further time. The Editor and the Publisher are informed about this intolerable way of acting of Scopus, and collaborate with me to solve this problem. I ask you and to your co-authors sorry for this circumstances. My suggestion for you is to persist with us in contacting Scopus support to include the article in the platform.

Regarding the New volume of Aestimum, 78 (2021), we had some delay due to a paper included in the volume. In last days, I’ve solve this problem and all articles have been sent to the publishers for preparing the last proof copy. I also apologize on behalf of the Editor for this further delay.

It is in my interest and in the Journal interest that the authors are satisfied in collaborating with Aestimum. I'm doing everything possible to ensure it is too for you.

I’m here for all the assistence you need.

Il giorno lun 9 ago 2021 alle 05:05 Suzanna Ratih sari <[email protected]> ha scritto:

Why haven't you replied to me? I need your certainty regarding my paper. Please give me your assistance to fix this problem. I have been waiting so long for this. Please.

(34)

17/09/21 12.32 Yahoo Mail - follow up the progress

follow up the progress

Tanggal: Jumat, 20 Agustus 2021 17.40 GMT+7

Dear Andrea, is there any update about my papers? I have checked the Scopus website and there is still none of my paper. I have also checked the Aestimum website and there is not either. Please give me some updates, I really need my papers on my Scopus ID for my institution's purpose. I am stressed when I know only my paper which is not included in the Scopus database while other papers on the same volume are included. Please fix this problem really soon. I hope there is no serious problem between Aestimum and Scopus.

Head of Master Program of Architecture Department of Architecture

Diponegoro University Semarang, Indonesia

(35)

17/09/21 12.33 Yahoo Mail - Re: follow up the progress

Re: follow up the progress

Tanggal: Sabtu, 21 Agustus 2021 16.18 GMT+7

Dear Suzanna,

I really understand your needs, because I myself am an author before being the Editorial Assistant of Aestimum. I ensure you that there is no problem between Aestimum and Scopus. Yesterday I sent an other email to the Scopus support asking for updates about your article.

About your second article, I'm waiting for the final proof by the Editor. The delay of these days is due to the summer holidays, which In Italy generally correspond to the week before and the week after August 15th. Next week I will return to my office and I will meet the Editor of Aestimum, Prof. Bernetti, trying to solve all your problems.

Il giorno ven 20 ago 2021 alle ore 12:41 Suzanna Ratih sari <[email protected]> ha scritto:

Dear Andrea, is there any update about my papers? I have checked the Scopus website and there is still none of my paper. I have also checked the Aestimum website and there is not either. Please give me some updates, I really need my papers on my Scopus ID for my institution's purpose. I am stressed when I know only my paper which is not included in the Scopus database while other papers on the same volume are included. Please fix this problem really soon. I hope there is no serious problem between Aestimum and Scopus.

(36)

17/09/21 12.38 Yahoo Mail - Re: follow up the progress

Re: follow up the progress

Tanggal: Minggu, 12 September 2021 20.31 GMT+7

Dear Andrea,

I would remind you again regarding your last reply. You said that the final proof will be done after August 15 but it is already September. Could you please push the Editorial Aestimum to speed up their work?

On the other side, my article has not been included in the Scopus database yet. Could you please push the Scopus support again to fix this problem? Remembering that only my article in one volume (76) which is not included in the Scopus database.

I am waiting for hearing from you. Thank you.

Pada Sabtu, 21 Agustus 2021 16.18.30 GMT+7, Andrea Dominici <[email protected]> menulis:

Dear Suzanna,

I really understand your needs, because I myself am an author before being the Editorial Assistant of Aestimum. I ensure you that there is no problem between Aestimum and Scopus. Yesterday I sent an other email to the Scopus support asking for updates about your article.

About your second article, I'm waiting for the final proof by the Editor. The delay of these days is due to the summer holidays, which In Italy generally correspond to the week before and the week after August 15th. Next week I will return to my office and I will meet the Editor of Aestimum, Prof. Bernetti, trying to solve all your problems.

Il giorno ven 20 ago 2021 alle ore 12:41 Suzanna Ratih sari <[email protected]> ha scritto:

Dear Andrea, is there any update about my papers? I have checked the Scopus website and there is still none of my paper. I have also checked the Aestimum website and there is not either. Please give me some updates, I really need my papers on my Scopus ID for my institution's purpose. I am stressed when I know only my paper which is not included in the Scopus database while other papers on the same volume are included. Please fix