Bukti Korespondensi: Environmental Law Enforcement in Illegal Mining Cases in Indonesia

(1)

10/1/23,10:53AM Gmail-[IJCJS]Acknowledgmentofanewmanuscriptsubmission

https://mail.google.com/mail/u/2/?ik=ff2b48e652&view=pt&search=all&permthid=thread-a:r-6469756828619792544&simpl=msg-a:r14765962778… 1/1

[IJCJS] Acknowledgment of a new manuscript submission

Thank you for submitting the following manuscript to theInternational Journal of Criminal Justice Sciences.

Track: Regular Track

Title: Environmental Law Enforcement in Illegal Mining Cases in Indonesia Author(s): Zainuddin

Corresponding Author: Zainuddin

Affiliation of Corresponding Author: Universitas Lambung Mangkurat, Banjarmasin, Indonesia Date of Manuscript Submission: 11-February-2023( UTC)

In a couple of days, a confirmation email including the manuscript ID will be again forwarded to you when the journal manager looks through your submission and confirms it. Further progress on your submission can be checked through the following online system.

* Online System URL:https://www.manuscriptlink.com/journals/ijcjs

If you have any questions regarding your submission, please contact the journal editor-in-chief.

Best regards,

Journal Editor-in-Chief

International Journal of Criminal Justice Sciences Homepage:https://www.ijcjs.com

=============[Note]=============

This email is only for the delivery service.

Please do not reply to this mail.

Zainuddin <[email protected]>

IJCJS<[email protected]>

To: "Zainuddin" <[email protected]>

Dear Dr. Zainuddin,

Sat, Feb 11, 2023 at 12:09 PM

(2)

10/1/23,10:53AM Gmail-[IJCJS]EditorDecision

[IJCJS] Editor Decision

Thank you for submitting the following manuscript to theInternational Journal of Criminal Justice Sciences.

The manuscript ID: IJCJS-675-2023

We have confirmed and forwarded your submission for reviewing process. Further progress on your submission can be checked through the following online system.

Best regards,

=============[Note]=============

Dear Dr. Zainuddin,

Sat, Feb 11, 2023 at 2:41 PM

(3)

[IJCJS] Editor Decision

We have reached a decision regarding your submission to theInternational Journal of Criminal Justice Sciences, "Environmental Law Enforcement in Illegal Mining Cases in Indonesia".

Our decision is: Revisions Required

Please revise your manuscript based on reviewers' comments and suggestions accordingly and resubmit your revised manuscript no later than one month.

Let me know if you have any questions.

Best regards,

=============[Note]=============

---

The paper Environmental

aw

Enforcement in

Illegal

ining Cases in Indonesia presents a comprehensive overview of the issue of illicit mining in Indonesia , its impact on the environment and society ,and the need for effective enforcement of environmental laws .Here 's acriticalreviewofvariousaspectsofthepaper:

The introduction effectively outlines the purpose of the research , which is to examine the enforcement of environmental lawin cases ofillegal mining in Indonesia . It provides aclear context forthereader.It shouldalsoset thescope ofthestudy by brieflyexplainingthesignificanceofmining permits ,the linkbetween mining law and environmental law ,and the problems associatedwith mismanagementandcorruption.

Dear Dr. Zainuddin,

Mon, Mar 27, 2023 at 11:38 AM

Reviewer- A

Decision: Major revisions required

The literature review part does well in highlighting the detrimental environmental impacts of illicit mining , such as water contamination , deforestation , and biodiversity decline . This creates a compelling case for the need for strong environmental law enforcement . It should also give an overview of Indonesia 's legislative framework related to environmental protection , which provides context for the subsequent discussion on enforcement.

The authors must acknowledge the complexity of issues related to illegal mining , such as social unrest, criminal behavior , and economic inequalities . This will add depth to the discussion and show an understanding of the multifaceted nature of the problem.

The mention of corruption in the mining sector is critical , as it highlights a significant challenge . However, it would be beneficial to provide some examples or case studies to illustrate the extent of corruption.

1.

2.

3.

4.

(4)

The discussion of mismanagement during the decentralization era is insightful, but it could be further enriched with data or concrete examples to strengthen the argument.

--- eviewer

R -B

ecision

D :Major revisions required

The current study effectively lays out the background and context for the study of illegal

mining in Indonesia and the importance of enforcing environmental laws. To further improve the paper, you could consider improving the following areas.

The literature review and methodology section provides a detailed and comprehensive

overview of the environmental law in Indonesia and its enforcement in the context of illegal mining. However, the literature review must effectively identify the research gap related to the impact of public environmental regulation on private lenders ' monitoring efforts and their effectiveness in mitigating corporate pollution.

___________________________________________________________

The review cites recent studies (Choy et al., 202; hao et al., 2022; Shi et al., 2021) to support the research background, indicating that the study is up-to-date with the latest research in the field.

The methodology section is clear and well -structured . It explains the research philosophy, approach, data sources, and methods employed in the study. The rationale for choosing a qualitative research methodology is provided , emphasizing its ability to provide a comprehensive understanding of the issue . However , it might be useful to briefly mention the limitations of this approach.

The authors should discuss specific legislation related to environmental protection and mining , such as the ineral and Coal ining aw, Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA ) Regulation , Forestry aw, arine and Fisheries aw, and others. This detail is beneficial for readers seeking specific information.

The limitations section should mention challenges related to data collection , the

evolving nature of illegal mining, and the complexity of social and political factors . This is essential for acknowledging the constraints of the study.

5.

1.

2.

3.

4.

5.

(5)

10/1/23,10:53AM Gmail-[IJCJS]Acknowledgmentofamanuscriptrevisionsubmission

[IJCJS] Acknowledgment of a manuscript revision submission

Thank you for submitting the following manuscript revision to theInternational Journal of Criminal Justice Sciences.

We have confirmed and forwarded your revision submission for reviewing process. Further progress on your submission can be checked through the following online system.

Best regards,

=============[Note]=============

Dear Dr. Zainuddin,

Tue, Apr 25, 2023 at 2:08 PM

(6)

Response to Reviewer 1

Sr. No. Reviewer's Comment Response

The paper Environmental Law Enforcement in Illegal Mining Cases in Indonesia presents a comprehensive overview of the issue of illicit mining in Indonesia, its impact on the environment and society, and the need for effective enforcement of environmental laws. Here's a critical review of various aspects of the paper:

Many thanks respected reviewer for your kind remarks and suggestions.

1 The introduction effectively outlines the purpose of the research, which is to examine the enforcement of environmental law in cases of illegal mining in Indonesia. It provides a clear context for the reader. It should also set the scope of the study by briefly explaining the significance of mining permits, the link between mining law and environmental law, and the problems associated with mismanagement and corruption.

Many thanks for your kind suggestions.

Done as per suggestion.

Please see pages 2-6

2 The literature review part does well in highlighting the detrimental environmental impacts of illicit mining, such as water contamination, deforestation, and biodiversity decline. This creates a compelling case for the need for strong environmental law enforcement. It should also give an overview of Indonesia's legislative framework related to

Dear reviewer, following your kind guidelines. We have now provided and overview of Indonesia's legislative framework related to environmental protection, which provides context for the subsequent discussion on enforcement.

(7)

environmental protection, which provides context for the subsequent discussion on enforcement.

3 The authors must acknowledge the complexity of issues related to illegal mining, such as social unrest, criminal behavior, and economic inequalities. This will add depth to the discussion and show an understanding of the multifaceted nature of the problem.

Dear reviewer, Thank you for your kind suggestions. We have now acknowledged the complexity of issues related to illegal mining, such as social unrest, criminal behavior, and economic inequalities

Please see page 12 4 The mention of corruption in the mining

sector is critical, as it highlights a significant challenge. However, it would be beneficial to provide some examples or case studies to illustrate the extent of corruption.

Dear reviewer, Thank you for your kind suggestions. Done.

Please see page 14 and 19

5 The discussion of mismanagement during the decentralization era is insightful, but it could be further enriched with data or concrete examples to strengthen the argument.

Dear reviewer, Thank you for your kind suggestions. Done.

Please see page 16

(8)

Response to Reviewer 2

The current study effectively lays out the background and context for the study of illegal mining in Indonesia and the importance of enforcing environmental laws. To further improve the paper, you could consider improving the following areas.

Thank you, dear reviewer.

1 The literature review and methodology section provides a detailed and comprehensive overview of the environmental law in Indonesia and its enforcement in the context of illegal mining. However, the literature review must effectively identify the research gap related to the impact of public environmental regulation on private lenders' monitoring efforts and their effectiveness in mitigating corporate pollution.

Dear reviewer, done as suggested.

2 The review cites recent studies (Choy et al., 2023; Zhao et al., 2022; Shi et al., 2021) to support the research background, indicating that the study is up-to-date with the latest research in the field.

Many thanks.

3 The methodology section is clear and well- structured. It explains the research philosophy, approach, data sources, and methods employed in the study. The rationale for choosing a qualitative research

Dear reviewer, we have now briefly mentioned the limitations of this approach.

Please see page 14

(9)

methodology is provided, emphasizing its ability to provide a comprehensive understanding of the issue. However, it might be useful to briefly mention the limitations of this approach.

4 The authors should discuss specific legislation related to environmental protection and mining, such as the Mineral and Coal Mining Law, Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) Regulation, Forestry Law, Marine and Fisheries Law, and others. This detail is beneficial for readers seeking specific information.

Dear reviewer, Thank you.

We have now discussed specific legislation related to environmental protection and mining, such as the Mineral and Coal Mining Law, Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) Regulation, Forestry Law, Marine and Fisheries Law, and others.

Please see pages 12, 16-18 5 The limitations section should mention

challenges related to data collection, the evolving nature of illegal mining, and the complexity of social and political factors.

This is essential for acknowledging the constraints of the study.

Done, dear reviewer as suggested.

(10)

https://mail.google.com/mail/u/2/?ik=ff2b48e652&view=pt&search=all&permthid=thread-a:r-5412272569415764818&simpl=msg-a:r-48110163507… 1/1

[IJCJS] Editor Decision

We have reached a decision regarding your submission to theInternational Journal of Criminal Justice Sciences, "Environmental Law Enforcement in Illegal Mining Cases in Indonesia".

Our decision is: Revisions Required

Please revise your manuscript based on the reviewers' comments and suggestions accordingly and resubmit your revised manuscript no later than one month.

Let me know if you have any questions.

Best regards,

=============[Note]=============

Dear Dr. Zainuddin,

Sat, Jun 17, 2023 at 9:53 AM

(11)

10/1/23,10:54AM Gmail-[IJCJS]Acknowledgmentofamanuscriptrevisionsubmission

https://mail.google.com/mail/u/2/?ik=ff2b48e652&view=pt&search=all&permthid=thread-a:r3948340532405964260&simpl=msg-a:r-27561359334… 1/1

[IJCJS] Acknowledgment of a manuscript revision submission

Dear Dr. Zainuddin,

Thank you for submitting the following manuscript revision to theInternational Journal of Criminal Justice Sciences.

We have confirmed and forwarded your submission revision for reviewing process. Further progress on your submission can be checked through the following online system.

Best regards,

=============[Note]=============

IJCJS<[email protected]> Fri, Jul 07, 2023 at 12:40 PM

(12)

Response to Reviewers

This is a good version of the paper. Many thanks, Respected Reviewer.

1 However, one minor improvement could be to ensure consistency in numbering the sections of your implications. Overall, it's a well-structured and informative conclusion section.

Dear reviewer many thanks, Done.

2 The limitation section should also touch on the enforcement mechanisms, such as penalties and oversight agencies, which are crucial in understanding how the laws are enforced.

Dear reviewer. The limitation section is now aligned on the enforcement mechanisms, such as penalties and oversight agencies, which are crucial in understanding how the laws are enforced.

Please see page 21 3 The authors must successfully link each

piece of legislation to its relevance in addressing illegal mining activities, which aligns with the study's objective.

Dear reviewer, Thank you for your kind suggestions. We have linked each piece of legislation to its relevance in addressing illegal mining activities, which aligns with the study's objective . Please see pages 5, 20-21

(13)

[IJCJS] Editor Decision

Dear Dr. Zainuddin,

Congratulations! the following of your manuscript.

Has been accepted for publication in International Journal of Criminal Justice Sciences (Vol. 18 No. 2, 2023).

Thank you for your interest in our journal. Your Journal paper would be indexed in Scopus (Elsevier), Google Scholar, Scirus, GetCited, Scribd, so on.

We look forward to receiving your subsequent research papers.

Best regards,

=============[Note]=============

IJCJS<[email protected]> Fri, Aug18,2023 at 11:46 AM