Supplementary Table 10. Checklist scoring regarding the experimental design for all 16 TNBS papers included in the systematic review. Quality analysis scored as ‘Good’ if all essential criteria in a section were provided. For the checklist, Y = yes, N = information not supplied, * = criterion not applicable. Percentage score is calculated using the weights from Table 2.
Information about the experimental design TNBS model Experiment design Colitis monitoring & scoring
Author/Date 8.1 8.2 8.3 8.4 9.1 9.2 9.3 9.4 9.5 Section quality Section score (%) Overall quality Overall score (%)
Huang Z (2013) Y N Y N Y Y N Y N Key criteria missing 58.2278481 Key criteria missing 80
Brenna A (2013) Y Y Y N Y Y N N N Key criteria missing 54.43037975 Key criteria missing 86.21621622
Kremer B (2012) Y N Y Y N Y N Y Y Good 74.6835443 Key criteria missing 89.18918919
Mariman R (2011) Y N Y N N Y N Y Y Key criteria missing 62.02531646 Key criteria missing 85.13513514 Hamilton MJ (2010) Y N Y N Y Y N N Y Key criteria missing 59.49367089 Key criteria missing 85.40540541
Zhou W (2009) Y N N Y Y Y N N Y Key criteria missing 59.49367089 Key criteria missing 82.97297297
Martinez-Augustin O (2008) Y Y Y N N N N Y Y Key criteria missing 56.96202532 Key criteria missing 78.64864865 Zwiers A (2008) Y N N N N N N N Y Key criteria missing 25.3164557 Key criteria missing 72.97297297 Billerey-Larmonier C (2008) Y Y Y Y N Y N N Y Key criteria missing 70.88607595 Key criteria missing 82.97297297
Wu F (2007) Y N N Y N Y N N Y Key criteria missing 50.63291139 Key criteria missing 78.37837838
te Velde AA (2007) Y N N N N Y N N Y Key criteria missing 37.97468354 Key criteria missing 72.97297297 Rivera E (2006) Y N N N N N N N Y Key criteria missing 25.3164557 Key criteria missing 75.94594595 Guzman J (2006) Y N Y N Y Y N N Y Key criteria missing 59.49367089 Key criteria missing 72.7027027 Yamamoto S (2005) Y N N N N N N N N Key criteria missing 12.65822785 Key criteria missing 72.16216216
Abad C (2005) Y N N N N N N N Y Key criteria missing 25.3164557 Key criteria missing 72.97297297
Nur T (2002) Y Y Y N N N N N Y Key criteria missing 45.56962025 Key criteria missing 79.45945946
