30/10/2018 Review Form Response
http://aij.batan.go.id/index.php/aij/sectionEditor/viewReviewFormResponse/810/1011 1/1
REVIEW FORM RESPONSE
Editor's Comments
Comments *
Authors still do not address any comment that I have provided in the previous reviewing process.
1. In the abstract, there are two statements on the purpose of the study. Why do authors need to do this?
2. In the INTRODUCTION, there is no statement on the purpose of the study. Why?
3. Since the purpose of the study is to obtain reliable the control rod worth of the first core of RSG-GAS, authors have to discuss the reliable control rod worth in the RESULTS AND
DISCUSSION as well as in the CONCLUSION.
4. In the title, it is mentioned that .... using deterministic and Monte Carlo methods. However, in line #49, it is mentioned by deterministic and probabilistic calculation. Please justify.
If authors do not intend to revise the manuscript, please provide reason for that.
This Paper is recommended to be * Accepted without further revision Accepted with minor revision Major Revision is required Rejected
Close
* Denotes required field
