Re f e r e e ' s Re por t > >

(1)

22/2/2019 Review Form Response

http://aij.batan.go.id/index.php/aij/sectionEditor/viewReviewFormResponse/813/1017 1/4

REVIEW FORM RESPONSE

Referee's Report >>

1. The Title is Appropriate * [2] Partly Correct Comment

2. Abstract

The Content and Length of the abstract are appropriate * [2] Partly Correct

Comment

Please consider to add number of subjects for training and testing

3. Main Text

The results are important to be reported * [1] Completely Correct

Comment

What is the extension of PDA and PTA?

The number of subjects in this study should be added especially with the same vowels but with different authority to enter the facility.

The description for the password needs to be described more detail. Why do you choose the password as "aiueo"

The paper is of high scientific quality (scientifically sound) * Voice Classification Based on Fast Independent Component Analysis to Support Nuclear Power Plant Security

(2)

[2] Partly Correct

Comment

The paper is very good in describing a new technique, a new attempt and additional technique for NPP security.

However, this attempt should add description on password requirement, number of features, how to eliminate features that is not increase performance

The paper is well organized (experimental/theory/results/conclusion) * [1] Completely Correct

Comment

The description of password should more explicit. How many vowels do you use in the experiment. What is the requirement for the password

The length of the paper is appropriate to the content * [1] Completely Correct

Comment

Please consider to add some description how do you capture/acquire the voice, including the equipment, such as type of microphone, sound recording equipment, sampling rate do you use, etc. Can you explicitly change the parameters in the smartphone? Do you include soundproof in the experiment, as you describe in line 317

The references are adequate in complete / consist of 85% primary references and recent journals *

[1] Completely Correct

(3)

Comment

Please add title for Reference 17. Check how to write References

Please consider to add more references concerning Voice Classification (only Ref 10, and 18)

The English is alright * [1] Completely Correct

Comment

Where should be replaced to where as they are not in beginning of sentences.

Final Comments To the Author *

In the Conclusion

Please consider to add number of training and testing as you describe that 100% can be distinguishable. If the accuracy is 100%, do you propose that your method would replace the current method?

Confidential Comments to the EIC

This Paper is recommended to be * Accepted without further revision Accepted with minor revision

(4)

Major Revision is required Rejected

Close

* Denotes required field