The Vanderbilt
Political Review
Fall 2010
!"#$%&'()*+,-.&,*-"#$-/#)0-12)*(34"&*(,"#-"5"$%1(5-6/2&#")- 7%"*2&(#8- %,,"0,- 4%&*"(#(#8- */- 4/)(*(5")9- ,/5(")9- "#$- %5/#/1(5-
%:%#*,-*;"*-"&%-*"<(#8-4)"5%-(#-/2&-=/&)$-",-=%-,4%"<>
!"#$%&'()*-?/)(*(5")-@%:(%=-(,-"#-"7.)("*%$-$(:(,(/#-/7-!"#3
$%&'()*-A*2$%#*-B/112#(5"*(/#,9-"#$-"-1%1'%&-/7-*;%-C))("#5%- /7-B/))%8("*%-D$(*/&,>
B/3?&%,($%#*,- !"#$%&'()%*+
,#**+&-'.#/01"
!(5%-?&%,($%#*,- 200&3"#'4115#5
4#6&&7'4#58&&
D$(*/&3(#3B;(%7- 9%::/',#"7&5
E#)(#%-F(&%5*/&- 41#+';"#)
D:%#*,-F(&%5*/&- <#55#+'=#")101->?%
A%5&%*"&0- ,&0%>>#'@A4&%00
G&%",2&%&- B/#5'<%33%5>
?2')(5-@%)"*(/#,-- 9#C"&5'2>+0&/'B100%5>
9%57>&/'D1+0 B/112#(*0-E2*&%"5;- 200&5#'D&""/
C)21#(-@%)"*(/#,- !"#$&'26%0&>
C&*-F(&%5*/&' E"%$'9/15>
F(&%5*/&-/7-H"0/2*- ,&0%>>#',$F%**"%$?
?&(#*-D$(*/&,- E0%G#'<1"5
H#55'D&5*0&/
4#*+#5'B1*+>$+%07 I+"%>*%5#'B13&">
<#55#+'B13&">
257"&#'I0#:1C3+
E)%0/',1"3&5>*&"5 4%$+10#>'H#5$&
!"#$"%&'($)%(*& ,&3#5'I16%53*15
,#"?'I+&""/
27#)'@>%#>15
=1+5';1>+&&
=%00%#5'<C3+&>
=&JJ'=#/
(%7'(#K"C
D:%#*,-A*"77- 9&%#'257"&-
D"%**5&/'=1+5>15 ,%$+#0'LC"?%&-%$G M#%7'I+1C7+"/
=&55%J&"',%#1 I#%*0%5'B115&/
F&55&*+'I1015&0 20&N'()#0#5>?#>O.1""&>
I"52)*0-C$:(,%&,- ,#"?'L#0+1C>&
;"#5$%>'P$%>01
VPR ONLINE
Want more exclusive content from VPR? Make sure to check out
Q' 2'R"1J&>>1"A>'R&">K&$*%6&S',15%TC&'9/0&
J#*%&:(%=--5/#$25*%$-'0- C))%8&"-K//#"#-"#$-L"**;%=-G"0)/&
J#*%&:(%=-*&"#,5&('%$-'0-M&"5%-C:()%,
U
';"1)'.+&'D1#"7S'R"&>%7&5*'F&55&7/A>' I#00'*1'H#57&":%0*'(*C7&5*>
!"#$%&'()%*+
B/3?&%,($%#*9-!"#$%&'()*-?/)(*(5")-@%:(%=
B)",,-/7-NOPP
V
'D&JC770&7'D1&+5&"'#57'*+&'2)&"%$#5' D"#%5'L"#%5
,-#+'."#) B)",,-/7-NOPQ -B/))%8%-/7-C&*,-"#$-A5(%#5%
W
'<%3+'<1K&>'J1"'I#0%J1"5%#
/#**'($#"#0- B)",,-/7-NOPR -B/))%8%-/7-C&*,-"#$-A5(%#5%
XY
'@:#)#'%>'@?#/
1#0'230$#0 B)",,-/7-NOPR B/))%8%-/7-C&*,-"#$-A5(%#5%
XX
'D1%0%53'%5'#'R1*'1J'.&#
4+#"5&6'7388&9&
B)",,-/7-NOPQ B/))%8%-/7-C&*,-"#$-A5(%#5%
XX
'2'R"&)#*C"&'E57'*1'I+%5#A>'R&#$&JC0' B%>&Z'
:08"&;'<--8 B)",,-/7-NOPP B/))%8%-/7-C&*,-"#$-A5(%#5%
X[
'.+#*A>'@5&'()#00'(*&K\\\']5'*+&'P"153' L%"&$*%15
'=#6&>'?%55 B)",,-/7-NOPR A5;//)-/7-D#8(#%%&(#8
XU
',%7*&")'^YXYS'B%53'D&*-&&5'*+&'9%5&>'
#57'B&7"#-%53'.+&)
@%086&>'7-+5 B)",,-/7-NOPP B/))%8%-/7-C&*,-"#$-A5(%#5%
Use your Smartphone’s barcode application to view articles and
post comments on Vanderbilt POlitical Review Online.
Wondering what you can use this code for?
The Vanderbilt
Political Review
'BMMt
7PMVNFt*TTVFVPR | Fall 2010
Table of Contents
2'R"1J&>>1"A>'R&">K&$O
*%6&S',15%TC&'9/0&
*OUFSWJFXDPOEVDUFECZ Allegra Noonan and Matthew Taylor
*OUFSWJFXUSBOTDSJCFECZ Grace Aviles
HRBS- -T;"*- - $/- *;%- &%,2)*,- /7- *;%- NOPO-1($*%&1-%)%5*(/#,-,"0-"'/2*-*;%-
%)%5*/&"*%U- - V":%- =%- ,%%#- "- 4%&1"3
#%#*-,;(7*-*/-"-1/&%-5/#,%&:"*(:%-%)%53
*/&"*%-/&-=",-*;%-:/*%-,(14)0-"8"(#,*- E'"1"W,-"8%#$"U-
,9S- - T%))9- J- $/#W*- *;(#<- *;"*- *;%- 1($*%&1- &%,2)*,- ,288%,*- "- 4%&1"3
#%#*- ,;(7*- */="&$,- "- 1/&%- 5/#,%&:"3
*(:%- %)%5*/&"*%>-J#- *%&1,- /7- ?&%,($%#*- E'"1"W,- "8%#$"9- J- 4%&,/#"))0- ;":%- ,/1%-,%&(/2,-X2%,*(/#,-"'/2*-*;%-%Y3
*%#*-*/-=;(5;-*;%-C1%&(5"#-%)%5*/&"*%- (,- %(*;%&- ,(8#(.5"#*)0- "="&%- /&- (#3 7/&1%$-/7-=;"*-*;%-?&%,($%#*W,-"8%#3
$"-(,>-J-'%)(%:%-*;"*-*;%&%-=%&%-"-7%=- 7"5*/&,-*;"*-5/#*&('2*%$-*/-*;%-&%,2)*,>- I/&- /#%9- ;(,*/&(5"))09- *;%- 4&%,($%#*W,- 4"&*0-*04(5"))0-)/,%,-,%"*,-(#-*;%-B/#3 8&%,,- $2&(#8- *;%- 1($*%&1>- I/&- *=/-
*%&1- 4&%,($%#*,- *;%- 8&%"*%,*- )/,,- /53 52&,- $2&(#8- *;%- .&,*- 1($*%&1>- Z",%$- /#-;(,*/&0-*;%-7"5*-*;"*-*;%-F%1/5&"*,- )/,*-,%"*,-=",-#/*-"*04(5")>-V/=%:%&9-
*;%0-$($-)/,%-"-8&%"*-#21'%&-/7-,%"*,9- 1/&%-*;"#-=%W:%-,%%#-(#-"-:%&0-)/#8-
*(1%>-C),/9-(#-"$$(*(/#-*/-*;%-7"5*-*;"*-
*;%- 4&%,($%#*W,- 4"&*0- )/,%,- ,%"*,- $2&3
(#8-*;%-1($*%&1,9-*;%&%-"&%-/*;%&-7"53
*/&,-*/-5/#,($%&>-I/&-%Y"14)%9-8&/24,-
*;"*- *04(5"))0- 5/14&(,%- *;%- F%1/3 5&"*(5- ?"&*0W,- '",%- =%&%- #/*- :%&0- 1/'()([%$- 7/&- *;%- 1($*%&1- %)%5*(/#,>-
\/2#8-4%/4)%-=%&%-#/*-",-1/'()([%$-
",- *;%0- =%&%- (#- NOO]9- 7/&- %Y"14)%>- C7&(5"#-C1%&(5"#,- =%&%- #/*- ",- 1/3 '()([%$- ",- *;%0- =%&%- (#- NOO]>- K/*- */- 1%#*(/#9-*2&#/2*-(,-62,*-)/=%&-$2&(#8- 1($*%&1-%)%5*(/#,-"#0="0>-G;%-F%13 /5&"*(5- ?"&*0- '",%- =",- #/*- ",- 1/'(3 )([%$- '0- *;%- 4"&*09- =;%&%",- 4%/4)%-
=;/- 5/14&(,%$- *;%- @%42')(5"#- '",%-
=%&%-;(8;)0-1/'()([%$-*;(,-4"&*(52)"&-
%)%5*(/#-,%",/#-(#-4"&*-$2%-*/-*;%-G%"-
?"&*0- 1/:%1%#*>- V/=%:%&9- J- *;(#<-
*;"*- *;%- 1/,*- (14/&*"#*- 7"5*/&- (#- *;%- /2*5/1%-/7-*;(,-%)%5*(/#-=",-4%/4)%W,-
%:")2"*(/#,- "#$- 4%&5%4*(/#,- /7- *;%-
%5/#/10>- D5/#/1(5- %:")2"*(/#,- "&%- ,*&/#8)0- ",,/5("*%$- =(*;- :/*%- 5;/(5%-
"#$- 4%/4)%- %:")2"*%- *;%- %5/#/10-
#%8"*(:%)0- &(8;*- #/=>- L/&%- C1%&(3 5"#,-7%%)-*;"*-*;%-%5/#/1(5-,(*2"*(/#- (,- 8%**(#8- =/&,%- *;"#- 8%**(#8- '%**%&9-
"#$- :/*%&,- *%#$- */- 42#(,;- *;%- 4"&*0- (#-4/=%&-=;%#-*;%-%5/#/10-(,-7"&(#8- 4//&)0>-I2&*;%&9-%5/#/1(5-(,,2%,-*%#$-
*/- 5/14&(,%- *;%- '2)<- /7- 5"14"(8#- 5/112#(5"*(/#9- "#$- @%42')(5"#,9-
;(,*/&(5"))09- ;":%- "44%"&%$- 1/&%- "$3
%4*- "*- 2,(#8- %5/#/1(5- 1%,,"8%,- */-
*;%(&-"$:"#*"8%>-
HRBS--J-="#*%$-*/-'&(#8-24-,/1%3
*;(#8-0/2-,"($-"*-*;%-'%8(##(#8-/7-*;"*>-
\/2- ,"($- *;"*- *;%- C1%&(5"#- 42')(5- (,#W*- (#7/&1%$- /#- E'"1"W,- 4/)(5(%,>- F/-0/2-*;(#<-(*,-$(,(#7/&1"*(/#9-)(<%9-
$2%-*/-=;"*-*;%-G%"-?"&*0-,"($-"'/2*-
$%"*;- 4"#%),- "#$- "))- *;"*- /&- $/- 0/2- 62,*-*;(#<-(*,-*;"*-*;%0-$/#W*-<#/=U
,9S--C-)(**)%-'(*-/7-'/*;-'2*-4&(1"&3 ()0- *;%- )"**%&>-G;%&%- 5%&*"(#)0- (,- "- )/*- /7- 5/#72,(#8- (#7/&1"*(/#- /2*- *;%&%-
&(8;*- #/=9- ;/=%:%&9-C1%&(5"#,- 8%#3
%&"))0- "&%- #/*- 4"&*(52)"&)0- (#7/&1%$-
"'/2*- 8/:%%#*- "#$- 4/)(*(5,>- G;"*-
$/%,#W*- 1%"#- *;"*- C1%&(5"#,- $/#W*-
;":%-&%")-"**(*2$%,9-*;"*-$/%,#W*-1%"#-
*;"*-C1%&(5"#,-$/#W*-;":%-"-,%#,%-/7-
=;"*W,-(14/&*"#*-*/-*;%19-'2*-C1%&(3 5"#,-"&%#W*-")="0,-4"&*(52)"&)0-<#/=)3
%$8%"')%- "'/2*- 42')(5- "77"(&,>- A/- J-
$/#W*-*;(#<-(*W,-%#*(&%)0-62,*-1(,(#7/&3 1"*(/#9- J- *;(#<- *;"*- C1%&(5"#,- 62,*-
"&%#W*- ",- <#/=)%$8%"')%- /&- %#8"8%$- (#-4/)(*(5,-",-,/1%-=/2)$-%Y4%5*>-
HRBS--F/-0/2-*;(#<-*;"*-*;%-&%,2)*,- /7-*;%-NOPO-1($*%&1-%)%5*(/#,-5;"#8%-
"#0- 4/,,(')%- /2*5/1%,- /7- *;%- NOPN-
%)%5*(/#,>-F/-0/2-*;(#<-*;"*-E'"1"W,-
&%%)%5*(/#- 4&/,4%5*,- =())- '%- ;%)4%$9-
;"&1%$9-/&-#/*-"77%5*%$-'0-*;%-@%42'3 )(5"#-:(5*/&(%,>-
,9S- - J- ,;/2)$- 4&%7"5%- 10- ,*"*%3 1%#*,-'0-,"0(#8-*;"*9-$%,4(*%-;":(#8-"-
?;>F>-(#-4/)(*(5")-,5(%#5%9-J-"1-'0-#/- 1%"#,-"-4/)(*(5")-4&/8#/,*(5"*/&>-J-"1-
#/*-/#%-*/-1"<%-,=%%4(#8-4&%$(5*(/#,-
"'/2*-*;%-72*2&%>-Z2*9-=(*;-*;"*-,"($9- J- =())- ,"0- *;"*- J- $/#W*- *;(#<- *;"*- *;%- NOPO- 1($*%&1- %)%5*(/#,- 4/&*%#$- "#0- 4%&1"#%#*- 5;"#8%,9- )(<%- *;%- %)%5*/&3
"*%-1/:(#8-(#-"-1/&%-5/#,%&:"*(:%-$(3
&%5*(/#9-#/&-$/-J-*;(#<-*;%0-$%.#(*(:%3 )0-,288%,*-?&%,($%#*-E'"1"-#/*-'%(#8-
&%%)%5*%$-(#-NOPN>-?"&*-/7-*;%-&%",/#-J- 7%%)-*;(,-="0-=(*;-&%8"&$-*/-E'"1"W,-
&%%)%5*(/#- 4&/,4%5*,- (,- *;"*- 1($*%&1-
%)%5*(/#,- "&%9- ;(,*/&(5"))09- 4//&- 4&%3
$(5*/&,-/7- 4&%,($%#*(")-%)%5*(/#,9- ,/- J-
$/#W*-*;(#<-=%-5"#-$%.#(*%)0-,"0-*;"*-
=;"*- ;"44%#%$- (#- NOPO- *%)),- 2,- "#03
*;(#8-$%.#(*(:%-"'/2*-NOPN>-V/=%:%&9- ,/1%-/7-=;"*-0/2W:%-'%%#-;%"&(#8-(,-
*;"*-*;(,-4/&*%#$,-$//1-7/&-;(1>-D:%#-
*;/28;-J-$/#W*-="#*-*/-1"<%-"-4&%$(53
*(/#-"'/2*-*;%-72*2&%9-J-$/#W*-*;(#<-*;"*-
*;(,- 4/&*%#$,- $//1- 7/&- ;(1- ",- ,/1%-
=/2)$-,288%,*>-J*-"5*2"))0-5/2)$-=/&<-
*/- ;(,- "$:"#*"8%- (#- ,/1%- ="0,>- I/&-
%Y"14)%9-=(*;-@%42')(5"#,-5"4*2&(#8-
"-1"6/&(*0-/7-*;%-,%"*,-(#-*;%-V/2,%9- (7- *;%0- %#$- 24- '%(#8- ",- 2#=())(#8- */- 5/14&/1(,%- ",- ,/1%- /7- *;%1- ;":%-
A Professor’s Perspective: Dr. Monique Lyle
,288%,*%$-*;%0-=())-'%9-*;%#-(*-5/2)$- 5/#*&('2*%- */- "- ,(*2"*(/#- /7- 8&($)/5<-
"#$- ;%- 1(8;*- '%- "')%- */- %77%5*(:%)0- )%:%&"8%-*;(,-"#$-')"1%-@%42')(5"#,- 7/&-*;(,-,*"8#"*(/#>--C),/9-(7-*;%-%5/#3 /10- (14&/:%,- (*- 5/2)$- =/&<- */- ;(,-
"$:"#*"8%>- - A/- J- 82%,,- *;%- )/#8- "#$- ,;/&*-/7-(*-(,-#/9-J-$/#W*-*;(#<-*;%-1($3
*%&1,- ,"0- "#0*;(#8- $%.#(*(:%- "'/2*- E'"1"W,-&%%)%5*(/#-4&/,4%5*,>-
HRBS- - J#*%&%,*(#89- X2(5<)09- =;%#- 0/2- ,"0- *;"*- *;%- 1($*%&1- %)%5*(/#,-
"&%-"-4//&-(#$(5"*/&-/7-NOPN-%)%5*(/#,9- (,-(*-'%5"2,%-/7-*;%-)/=-:/*%&-*2&#/2*-
"#$-/*;%&-7"5*/&,U-
,9S--J-1%"#9-*;"*W,-4"&*-/7-(*>-?"&3
*(%,- =/&<- ;"&$%&- "*- 1/'()([(#8- :/*3
%&,- (#- 4&%,($%#*(")- %)%5*(/#,- *;"#- (#- 1($*%&1- %)%5*(/#,>- C),/9- *;(#8,- 62,*-
;"44%#>-C,-J-1%#*(/#%$-'%7/&%9-%5/3
#/1(5-5/#,($%&"*(/#,-"&%-1/&%-",,/3 5("*%$- =(*;- C1%&(5"#,W- :/*(#8- $%5(3 ,(/#,- *;"#- ,/5(")- 5/#,($%&"*(/#,9- "#$- ,/1%-&%,%"&5;-,288%,*,-*;"*9-=;%#-(*- 5/1%,- */- %5/#/1(5- 5/#,($%&"*(/#,9- 4%/4)%-*%#$-*/- /#)0-)//<-'"5<-"*-*;%- 4&%:(/2,-0%"&9-#/*-*;%-)",*-*=/9-*;&%%9- 7/2&-0%"&,>-A/-=;"*-;"44%#,-(#-NOPN- (,- )(<%)0- */- 1"**%&- 1/&%- *;"#- *;%,%- 1($*%&1-%)%5*(/#,>
HRBS- - G;%- G%"- ?"&*0- 1"#"8%$- */-
%)%5*-^-A%#"*/&,9-QO-V/2,%-@%4&%,%#3
*"*(:%,9-"#$-#21%&/2,-/7.5("),-/#-*;%-
,*"*%- "#$- )/5")- )%:%),>- F/- 0/2- *;(#<-
*;"*- *;%- G%"- ?"&*0- =())- '%- "- )",*(#8- 7/&5%-/#-*;%-C1%&(5"#-4/)(*(5")-)"#$3 ,5"4%U- F/- 0/2- *;(#<- *;%- G%"- ?"&*0-
=())- '%- 1/&%- =())(#8- */- 5/14&/1(,%-
=(*;- F%1/5&"*,- "#$- L/$%&"*%- @%3 42')(5"#,- ",- *(1%- 8/%,- /#U- F/- 0/2-
*;(#<- *;%0- =())- '%5/1%- 1/&%- 4&"83 1"*(5-/&-&%1"(#-($%/)/8(5")U
,9S--C*-*;%-1/1%#*9-J-$/#W*-;":%-
"#0- &%",/#- */- '%)(%:%- *;"*- #%=)0-
%)%5*%$- /7.5("),- ",,/5("*%$- =(*;- *;%- G%"-?"&*0-=())-'%-"#0-1/&%-=())(#8-*/- 5/14&/1(,%- (#- *;%- 72*2&%- *;"#- *;%0-
;":%- ")&%"$0- ,288%,*%$>- V/=%:%&9-
*;%-%,,%#5%-/7-4/)(*(5,-(,-5/14&/1(,%>- J7- *;%0- "&%- 2#=())(#8- */- 5/14&/1(,%- /#-"#0*;(#89-*;%#-*;%0-"&%-#/*-)(<%)0-
*/- 8%*- 125;- "55/14)(,;%$- "#$- "&%-
#/*-)(<%)0-*/-'%-"-)",*(#8-7/&5%-(#-*;%- C1%&(5"#-4/)(*(5")-)"#$,5"4%>--J7-*;%0-
=/2)$-)(<%-*/-&%1"(#-"-4/=%&72)-7/&5%- (#- C1%&(5"#- 4/)(*(5,9- *;%#- *;%0- "&%- 8/(#8-*/-;":%-*/-5/14&/1(,%-/#-,/1%- (,,2%,>--Z2*9-&(8;*-#/=9-=;%*;%&-*;%0-
=())-'%5/1%-1/&%-=())(#8-*/-5/14&/3 1(,%-(,-2#5)%"&>--J-;":%-#/-&%",/#-*/- '%)(%:%-*;"*-*;%0-=())9-'2*-(*-&%1"(#,-
*/-'%-,%%#>-
HRBS- - A/- 1"#0- ,*"*%,- *;"*- =%#*- ')2%-$2&(#8-NOO]9-,25;-",-K/&*;-B"&3 /)(#"- "#$- !(&8(#("9- ,=2#8- '"5<- *;(,- 4",*- %)%5*(/#>- T())- *;%,%- ,*"*%,- '%3
5/1%- 4%&1"#%#*- ,=(#8- ,*"*%,- /&- $/- 0/2- *;(#<- *;"*- *;%- NOO]- 4&%,($%#*(")-
%)%5*(/#,-=%&%-"#-%Y5%4*(/#U
,9S--G;(,-4",*-=%%<-=%-;":%-;%"&$-
"-)/*-/7-*")<-"'/2*-!(&8(#("9-K/&*;-B"&3 /)(#"9- "#$- J#$("#"9- '2*- *;%- %Y*%#*- */-
=;(5;-*;%0W:%-_8/#%-&%$`-/&-=())-8/-
&%$-(#-NOPN-,%%1,-,/1%=;"*-$2'(/2,>- J#-K/&*;-B"&/)(#"9-7/&-%Y"14)%9-/#)0- /#%- &%4&%,%#*"*(:%- )/,*- ;(,- ,%"*- */- "-
@%42')(5"#9-"#$-*;"*W,-(*>-@%42')(5"#- (#521'%#*,-;%)$-/#9-'2*-JW1-#/*-,2&%-
*;"*-0/2-5"#-5"))-*;"*-"-1",,(:%-,;(7*- /&-,"0-*;"*-(*-,(8#"),-,/1%*;(#8-"'/2*- 72*2&%-4&%,($%#*(")-%)%5*(/#,>--J#-!(&3 8(#("-"#$-J#$("#"9-N-/&-Q-V/2,%-,%"*,-
=%#*- 7&/1- F%1/5&"*- */- @%42')(5"#9-
"#$-@%42')(5"#,-$($-4(5<-24-"-A%#"*%- ,%"*-(#-J#$("#">-G;%,%-"&%-1%"#(#872)- 5;"#8%,9-'2*-(*-,*())-$/%,#W*-#%5%,,"&3 ()0-1%"#-*;"*-*;%,%-,*"*%,-=())-'%-&%$- (#-NOPN9-*;/28;-(*-=/#W*-'%-(#5&%$(')0- ,2&4&(,(#8-(7-*;%0-"&%>
HRBS- - A/9- 0/2- $/#W*- *;(#<- *;(,- (,-
*;%-%#$-/7-*;%-,/2*;%&#-B/#,%&:"*(:%- F%1/5&"*U-
,9S- - K/*- #%5%,,"&()0>- G;%- Z)2%- F/8,-8/*-;(*-;"&$-(#-*;(,-%)%5*(/#a-*;%(&- 5"252,-8/*-52*-'0-1/&%-*;"#-;")7>-G;%-
?&/8&%,,(:%-B"252,-*%#$,-*/-'%-7&/1- 1/&%- )%7*- )%"#(#8- $(,*&(5*,9- =;()%- *;%- Z)2%-F/8,-"&%-#/*>-Z)2%-F/8,-*%#$-*/- '%- 7&/1- $(,*&(5*,- *;"*- "&%- 1/&%- 5%#3
*&(,*- ($%/)/8(5"))0>-T;%#- 0/2- ;":%- "- ,(*2"*(/#-=;%&%-4%/4)%-"&%-#/*-;(8;)0- ($%/)/8(5")9-8(:%#-*;%-%5/#/1(5-,(*23
"*(/#9-*;/,%-4%/4)%-"&%-1/&%-)(<%)0-*/- ,=(*5;- *;"#- *;/,%- =;/- "&%- ($%/)/8(3 5")>-J-5"#W*-,"0-J-=",-"#*(5(4"*(#8-*;%- Z)2%- F/8,- )/,(#8- ",- 1"#0- ,%"*,- ",-
*;%0-$($9-'2*-(#-;(#$,(8;*-(*-1(8;*-#/*- '%-(#5&%$(')0-,2&4&(,(#8>-J7-*;%-%5/#3 /10-&%5/:%&,9-;/=%:%&9-4%&;"4,-5/#3 ,%&:"*(:%-F%1/5&"*,-5/2)$-$/-'%**%&>- C),/9- 8(:%#- *;"*- *;%- Z)2%- F/8,- )/,*- ,/-1"#0-,%"*,-"#$-,/-0/2-;":%-7%=%&- 5%#*&(,*-F%1/5&"*,-#/=-(#-*;%-V/2,%9- B/#8&%,,-5/2)$-"44%"&-/&-"5*2"))0-'%3 5/1%-1/&%-4/)"&([%$-*;"#-(*-52&&%#*)0- (,9- =;(5;- 5/2)$- 5/#*&('2*%- */- 1/&%- 8&($)/5<-"#$-7%=%&-*;(#8,-8%**(#8-"53 5/14)(,;%$>-G;(,-5/2)$-=/&<-*/-5/#3
H OUSE
188DEM239REP
SENA TE
53D 46R
G O VE RN O RS
18 DEM
29 REP
.*%5&3.&-&$5*0/3&46-54 2010
,%&:"*(:%- F%1/5&"*,W- "$:"#*"8%- (#- NOPN>- G;%0- 5/2)$- &2#- ",- 2#(*%&,- /&- ($%/)/8(5")- 1/$%&"*%,- =;/- "&%- 1/&%- 5"4"')%- /7- &%"5;(#8- "5&/,,- *;%- "(,)%9- ,/-=%-5/2)$-,%%-"-&%,2&8%#5%-/7-5/#3 ,%&:"*(:%-F%1/5&"*,-(#-NOPN>-
HRBS- - F/- 0/2- *;(#<- *;%&%- (,- "- 5;"#5%-/7-*;(&$-4"&*(%,-'%5/1%-1/&%- :("')%- (#- NOPN- ",- "- &%,2)*- /7- *;%- (#3 5&%",(#8)0-4/)"&(["*(/#-/7-*;%-4"&*(%,U-
,9S--J*W,-;"&$-*/-,"0>-A/1%-5%&*"(#3 )0- '%)(%:%- *;"*- *;%&%- (,- "#- %1%&8(#8- 1/$%&"*%-/&-5%#*&(,*-&%:/)2*(/#-*;"*W,- 5/1(#89- ,/- =%- 1(8;*- ,%%- *;%- %1%&3 8%#5%- /7- "- ,255%,,72)- 5%#*&(,*- *;(&$- 4"&*0>- @(8;*- #/=9- ;/#%,*)09- JW1- #/*- ,2&%>-J*W,-$%.#(*%)0-4/,,(')%9-"#$-*;%&%-
"&%-4/)(*(5")-,5(%#*(,*,-=;/-'%)(%:%-*;%-
%1%&8%#5%-/7-"-<(#$-/7-1()(*"#*-1($3
$)%- (,- (11(#%#*9- '2*- *;"*- &%1"(#,- */- '%-,%%#>-
HRBS- - T;"*- $/- 0/2- *;(#<- "'/2*-
*;%- @%42')(5"#- 4)%$8%- */- /:%&*2&#- E'"1"W,-;%")*;5"&%-)%8(,)"*(/#U-
,9S--T())-*;%0-,255%%$-(#-/:%&*2 (#8- (*U-C',/)2*%)0- #/*>- J- $/#W*- *;(#<-
*;"*- =())- ;"44%#>- G;%0- 5/2)$- 5/#3 5%(:"')0- ,)/=- $/=#- (*,- (14)%1%#*"3
*(/#-'0-2,(#8-*;%-,2'4/%#"-4/=%&-*/- '&(#8- :"&(/2,- '2&%"25&"*,- 5;"&8%$-
=(*;-(14)%1%#*(#8-(*-'%7/&%-B/#8&%,,- 7/&-;%"&(#8,-"#$-,25;>-A/-*;%0-5/2)$- ,)/=-$/=#-(*,-(14)%1%#*"*(/#>-Z2*-J-
$/#W*-*;(#<-*;%0-=())-'%-,255%,,72)-"*- /:%&*2&#(#8-(*>-J-5"#W*-,"0-*;"*-J-*;(#<-
*;"*-*;%0-=/#W*-1"<%-"#-%77/&*>-D:%#- (7- @%42')(5"#,- (#- B/#8&%,,- &%")([%-
*;"*- *;%- 4&/,4%5*- /7- /:%&*2&#(#8- *;(,- (,- $(19- *;%0- ,*())- 1(8;*- 1"<%- "- &%")-
%77/&*- '%5"2,%- (*- ,%#$,- "- 1%,,"8%- */-
*;%(&- 5/#,*(*2%#*,>- -C*- *;%- :%&0- )%",*-
*;%0-=())-*&0-*/-;(#$%&-(*-/&-(*,-(14)%3 1%#*"*(/#9-J-62,*-$/#W*-*;(#<-*;%0-=())- '%-"')%-*/-&%4%")-*;%-=;/)%-*;(#8>-
HR@S--I(#")-5/11%#*,U-
,9S--G;%-/#)0-.#")-5/11%#*-*;"*- JW))- 1"<%- (,- *;"*- =%- ,;/2)$- '%- 5"&%3 72)-"'/2*-*;%-%Y*%#*-*/-=;(5;-=%-*;(#<-
*;"*-*;%-NOPO-1($*%&1-%)%5*(/#-&%,2)*,- 4/&*%#$-72*2&%-%:%#*,>-
From The Board:
President Kennedy’s Call
to Vanderbilt Students
Gracie Smith
Co-President, Vanderbilt Political Review
Class of 2011
College of Arts and Science I/&*03,%:%#- 0%"&,- "8/- *;(,- L"09-
?&%,($%#*-b/;#-I>-c%##%$0-$%)(:%&%$- +"& +,,(%**& +)& -+",%(.$#)& /"$0%(3 ,(*0- */- 5%)%'&"*%- *;%- ,5;//)W,- #(#%*(3
%*;- "##(:%&,"&0>- F2&(#8- ;(,- ,4%%5;9-
?&%,($%#*- c%##%$0- ,"($9- _J- 2&8%- "))- /7- 0/2- */$"09- %,4%5("))0- *;/,%- =;/-
"&%-,*2$%#*,9-*/-"5*d*/-%#*%&-*;%-)(,*,- /7-42')(5-,%&:(5%-"#$-&(8;*)0-=(#-e/&- )/,%f- *;%- 4&([%>`- D:%#- *;/28;- PghQ-
=",- #/*- "#- %)%5*(/#- 0%"&9- ?&%,($%#*- c%##%$0W,-",<%$-!"#$%&'()*-,*2$%#*,-
*/-*&"#,7/&1-"5"$%1(5-($%",-(#*/-"53
*(/#-7/&-42')(5-,%&:(5%9-=;%*;%&-(*-=",-
",-_"-4&%5(#5*-=/&<%&-/&-"-4&%,($%#*>`
G;%- =/&$,- *;"*- ?&%,($%#*- c%##%$0- ,4/<%- /#- *;(,- 5"142,- (#- PghQ- ,*())-
;/)$-*&2%-*/$"0>-D:%#-=;()%-;%-$%)(:3
%&%$-;(,-,4%%5;-*/-"#-"2$(%#5%-(#-*;%- F%%4- A/2*;- $2&(#8- "- *(1%- /7- &"5(")-
$(,5&(1(#"*(/#- "#$- 8&/,,- (#%X2(*09-
?&%,($%#*- c%##%$0- 1"(#*"(#%$- *;"*- _*;%- #"*2&")- "&(,*/5&"50- /7- 5;"&"5*%&-
"#$- *")%#*`- 5/2)$- /:%&5/1%- '"&&(%&,>-
?&%,($%#*- c%##%$0- =",- $%$(5"*%$- */-
*;%-($%"-*;"*-,*2$%#*,-;":%-*;%-4/=%&-
*/-(14&/:%-,/5(%*0-=;%#-*;%0-*"<%-*;%- (#(*("*(:%- */- '%- 5(:()- )%"$%&,>- J#- 7"5*9-
")1/,*- *;&%%- 0%"&,- %"&)(%&9- *;%- ,(*3(#- 1/:%1%#*- ;"$- ")&%"$0- 4&/:%#- *;%- ,2',*"#5%- /7- ;(,- ,4%%5;- */- '%- *&2%>- C7*%&-5/))%8%-,*2$%#*,-7&/1-I(,<-i#(3 :%&,(*09- G%##%,,%%- CjJ- A*"*%- i#(3 :%&,(*09- L%;"&&0- L%$(5")- B/))%8%9-
"#$- C1%&(5"#- Z"4*(,*- G;%/)/8(5")- A%1(#"&0-)%$-*;%-K",;:())%-,(*3(#,-(#- PghO9-(#,*(*2*(/#")-,%8&%8"*(/#-'%8"#-
*/-5&21')%9-"#$-*;%-B(:()-@(8;*,-C5*- 4",,%$-7/2&-0%"&,-)"*%&-(#-PghR>-D:%#-
*;/28;-$%1/#,-/7-4&%62$(5%-5/#*(#2%-
*/-;"2#*-/2&-,/5(%*09-*;%-5/112#(*03
$&(:%#-)%"$%&,;(4-/7-5/))%8%-,*2$%#*,-
;")7-"-5%#*2&0-"8/-(,-$(&%5*)0-&%,4/#3 ,(')%-7/&-*;%-4&/8&%,,-/2&-,/5(%*0-;",- 1"$%>- J7- *;%,%- ,*2$%#*,- ;"$- $%5($%$-
*/- ,*"#$- ",($%- (#,*%"$- /7- '%5/1(#8- (#:/):%$-(#-5;"#8(#8-*;%-=/&)$9-(*-(,-
$(,X2(%*(#8-*/-(1"8(#%-;/=-*;%-=/&)$-
=%- )(:%- (#- */$"0- 1(8;*- '%- $(77%&%#*- 7&/1-(#"5*(/#>
i#7/&*2#"*%)09-1"#0-0/2#8-C1%&(3 5"#,- '%5"1%- $(,5/2&"8%$- '0- *;%- /#3 ,)"28;*- /7- #%8"*(:%- 5"14"(8#,- "#$- 4%&,/#")-"**"5<,-7&/1-'/*;-,($%,-/7-*;%-
4 / 3 )(*(5")- "(,)%-
$2&(#8-*;%-&%5%#*-1($*%&1-
%)%5*(/#>- L"#0- 5/))%8%3"8%- :/*%&,-
=;/-5",*-*;%(&-'"))/*,-7/&-*;%-.&,*-*(1%- (#-NOO]-7"()%$-*/-&%"44%"&-"*-*;%-:/*3 (#8-'//*;-(#-NOPO>-C*-*;%-,"1%-*(1%9- ,*2$%#*,-"5&/,,-*;%-#"*(/#-1"&:%)%$-"*-
*;%-%1/*(/#")-7%&:/&-/7-*;%-G%"-?"&*0-
&%4/&*%$- (#- *;%- 1%$("9- "#$- %#6/0%$-
<%%4(#8-24-=(*;-*;%-)"*%,*-&($(52)/2,- 5/11%#*,- 1"$%- '0- :"&(/2,- 5"#$(3
$"*%,-/#-*;%-5"14"(8#-*&"()>-J*-,%%1,-
*;"*- *;%- 5/))%8%3"8%- %)%5*/&"*%- =",- 5"28;*- ,/1%=;%&%- '%*=%%#- 6"$%$-
"4"*;0- "#$- 5/#5%&#%$- "12,%1%#*9-
=(*;- 1"#0- :/*(#8- 7/&- =;/1- *;%0- ,"=-",-*;%-)%",*-'"$-/7-*=/-'"$-5"#3
$($"*%,9- (7- *;%0- :/*%$- "*- "))>- G/$"0W,- 5/))%8%- ,*2$%#*,- "&%- 2#$%&,*"#$"')0-
$(,())2,(/#%$- '0- 4/)"&([%$- 4/)(*(5,9- "- ,*&"(#%$-;%")*;-5"&%-,0,*%19-*;%-)"&83
%,*- 7%$%&")- $%'*- (#- ;(,*/&09- "#$- *=/- ,%%1(#8)0-%#$)%,,-="&,>-
V/=%:%&9-=%-12,*-&%1%1'%&-=;"*- ,*2$%#*,-(#-K",;:())%-=%&%-"')%-*/-"53 5/14)(,;-^O-0%"&,-"8/-(#-*;%-7"5%-/7- (#5&%$(')%-/44/,(*(/#>-!"#$%&'()*-,*23
$%#*,-12,*-"),/-&%1%1'%&-*;"*-/#%-/7-
*;%-1/,*-(#k2%#*(")-4&%,($%#*,-(#-/2&-
#"*(/#W,- ;(,*/&0- $(&%5*)0- 5"))%$- *;(,- ,*2$%#*-'/$0-(#*/-42')(5-,%&:(5%>-G;%-
#/')%-($%"),-*;"*-$%.#%$-!"#$%&'()*-",-
"#-(#,*(*2*(/#-/7-)%"&#(#8-"#$-,%&:(5%-
*;%#-$/-,/-%:%#-1/&%-*/$"0>-G;%-723
*2&%-/7-*;%-#"*(/#W,-4/)(5(%,-1"0-,%%1-
$(,5/2&"8(#89-'2*-(7-=%-",-(#$(:($2")- ,*2$%#*,-$/-#/*-&"))0-"&/2#$-*;%-(,,2%,-
1/,*-"77%5*(#8-2,-"#$-*"<%-24-
*;%-.8;*-#/=9-=;/-=())U
A/1%- 5/))%8%- ,*2$%#*,- 5",*- *;%(&- :/*%,- *;(,- K/:%1'%&9- "#$- /*;%&,- $%3 5($%$- #/*- */- :/*%- "*- "))>- D(*;%&- ="09-
"))- ,*2$%#*,- #/=- ;":%- *;%- /44/&*23
#(*0- */- 1"<%- "- )",*(#8- (14"5*- %"5;-
$"09-=;%*;%&-/&-#/*-(*-(,-D)%5*(/#-F"09-
*;&/28;- $(&%5*- ,%&:(5%- */- *;%(&- 5/13 12#(*(%,>- I/&- *;/,%- ,*2$%#*,- =;/-
"&%- $(,%#5;"#*%$- =(*;- *;%- 4/)(*(5")- ,0,*%19- #/=- (,- *;%- 5;"#5%- */- &(,%-
"'/:%- *;%- 4"&*(,"#- ,5;(,1- "#$- 5/1%-
*/8%*;%&-(#-42')(5-,%&:(5%>-T;()%-:/*3 (#8-(,-"#-(14/&*"#*-$2*0-"#$-&(8;*-/7- C1%&(5"#- 5(*([%#,9- (*- (,- #/*- *;%- /#)0-
$2*0-=%-",-5(*([%#,-"&%-5"))%$-*/>-J-%#3 5/2&"8%-5/))%8%3"8%-:/*%&,-*/-#/*-="(*- 7/&-NOPN-*/-8%*-(#:/):%$-(#-*;%-4/)(*(3 5")-4&/5%,,-"8"(#9-'2*-*/-8%*-(#:/):%$- (#-"5*(:%)0-1"<(#8-*;%-=/&)$-"-'%**%&- 4)"5%-*;&/28;-,%&:(5%-*/-*;%-5/1123
#(*0>- H%*W,- "#,=%&- ?&%,($%#*- c%##%3
$0W,-5"))-7/&*03,%:%#-0%"&,-)"*%&-=(*;-
"-&%,/2#$(#8-0%,>-
A-3'$#0'"'B"&6%8&0*'=&00&8>C6'DEFG'#88"&66'*-'H#0I 8&"J%5*' +&"&K' +**LKMM;;;N#)&"%$#0"+&*-"%$N$-)M6L&&$+I
&6MOP9Q#08&"J%5*$-0Q-$#*%-0N+*)
Befuddled
Boehner and the American Brain
Drain
Noah Fram Class of 2013
College of Arts and Science
&
J#- NOOO9- *;%- 5/2#*&0- ,="))/=%$-
"- ;%7*0- $/,%- /7- _4/)(*(5,- ",- 2,2")>`-- G;%-*=/-5"#$($"*%,-7/&-?&%,($%#*-*;"*- 0%"&d*;%- ,(**(#8- !(5%- ?&%,($%#*9- C)- M/&%a- "#$- *;%- M/:%&#/&- /7- G%Y",9- M%/&8%- T>- Z2,;d7/28;*- "- ,/1%3
*(1%,- 2#%:%#9- ")="0,- :(*24%&"*(:%- 5"14"(8#>--M/&%-5)"(1%$-*/-'%-1/&%- X2")(.%$- e=;(5;- ;%- =",f9- "#$- Z2,;- 5)"(1%$-*/-'%-1/&%-#/&1")-e=;(5;-;%-
=",f>--J#-"-=;/))0-4&%$(5*"')%-*2&#-/7-
%:%#*,9- *;%- 5/2#*&0- $%5($%$- (*- ="#*3
%$-*/-;":%-"-5/))%5*(:%-'%%&-=(*;-*;%-
?&%,($%#*9- ,%#*- *;%- V"&:"&$- 8&"$2"*%- M/&%- /77- /#- ;(,- )%5*2&%- 5(&52(*9- "#$-
;"#$%$- *;%- <%0,- */- M"&&0- G&2$%"2W,- 5/='/0- ;"*- =(*;- "- $&"=)(#8- _,*"0-
*;%-5/2&,%>`--K"*2&"))09-0/2&-7&(%#$)0-
#%(8;'/&;//$- ?&%,($%#*- 5&",;%$- *;%- 5"&9-"#$-*;%-&%,*-(,-;(,*/&0>
J#-PghO9-*;%-"**&"5*(:%-"#$-7&(%#$)0- b/;#- c%##%$0- $%7%"*%$- *;%- "&82"')0- 1/&%- (14&%,,(:%- @(5;"&$- K(Y/#- (#-
*;%- .&,*3%:%&- *%)%:(,%$- ?&%,($%#*(")-
$%'"*%- '2*- )/,*- *;%- &"$(/- "2$(%#5%>-- C44"&%#*)09- :(%=%&,- =%&%- 2#"')%-
*/- 8%*- 4",*- *;%- ,(14)%- 7"5*- *;"*- c%#3
#%$0- )//<%$- )(<%l=%))9- c%##%$09-
*VSHFBMMPG you today...to
act, to enter the lists of public service and rightly win
(or lose) the prize.
”
“
"#$-K(Y/#-5)/,%)0-&%,%1')%$-"-*/"$>-- T"&- ;%&/%,- "&%- 4/42)"&- e*;(#<- C#3
$&%=-b"5<,/#9-i)0,,%,-M&"#*9-F=(8;*- D(,%#;/=%&9- "#$- 4&/'"')0- 1"#0- 1/&%- */- 5/1%f9- =;()%- "5*/&,- *%#$- */- 7"&%- =%))- (#- %)%5*(/#,- /7- "))- ,*&(4%,- e@/#")$-@%"8"#-"#$-C&#/)$-A5;="&3 [%#%88%&9- "1/#8- /*;%&,f>- - !(,('()3 (*0- "#$- 5/112#(5"*(/#- ,<()),- "&%9- (*- ,%%1,9- *;%- 1/,*- (14/&*"#*- X2")(.5"3
*(/#,-7/&-4/)(*(5")-/7.5%9-",-7"&-",-*;%- 8%#%&")- 42')(5- (,- 5/#5%&#%$>- - V%#5%-
*;%- $21'(#83$/=#- /7- 4/)(*(5")- 4)"*3 7/&1,>--M/#%-"&%-*;%-;")50/#-$"0,-/7-
%)%8"#5%- "#$- %)/X2%#5%9- %Y5;"#8%$- 7/&-"#-%&"-=;%&%-,4%%5;%,-"&%-&%$25%$-
*/- 5;"(#,- /7- 7/2&3,%5/#$- ,/2#$- '(*%,- ,*&2#8- */8%*;%&- =(*;- 5/#62#5*(/#,- (#- '%*=%%#>- - A255%,,72)- 4/)(*(5("#,- "&%-
#/=- (#.#(*%)0- X2/*"')%9- "#$- (7- 0/2&- /44/#%#*-,;/=,-*;%-,)(8;*%,*-5&"5<-(#-
*;%(&- ,(14)(,*(5- _1"#3/73*;%34%/4)%`- 7"m"$%9- *;%0- "&%- 5)%"&)0- 2#X2")(.%$>-- C44"&%#*)09- J- ="#*- 10- @%4&%,%#*"3
*(:%,-"#$-A%#"*/&,-*/-%Y4)"(#-(#*%&#"3
*(/#")-&%)"*(/#,-"#$-*;%-'2$8%*-$%.5(*-
*/-1%-(#-/#%3-"#$-*=/3,0))"')%-=/&$,9-
"#$-(7-*;%0-$"&%-*/-,;/=-*;"*-*;%0-2#3
$%&,*"#$- %5/#/1(5- *;%/&09- *;%0- "&%-
%)(*(,*,>
G;(,- %)%5*(/#- 505)%9- *;%- (#521'%#*- F%1/5&"*(5- ?"&*0- =",- 4/&*&"0%$- ",- /2*- /7- */25;- =(*;- *;%- #%%$,- /7- *;%- 5/11/#-1"#>--G;%(&-7"()2&%-*/-&%5/#3 ,*&25*- *;%- %5/#/10- (#- )%,,- *;"#- *=/- 0%"&,- =",- "- 5"4(*")- /77%#,%>- - Z0- *;%-
%#$- /7- *;%- 5"14"(8#9- J&"X- =",- ,(13 4)0-"-#/#3*/4(59-,(#5%-5/1'"*-*&//4,-
=%&%-,255%,,72))0-&%1/:%$-"#$-*;%&%-
"44%"&%$- */- '%- #/- 1/&%- ,%#,"*(/#")- e&%"$S- :(/)%#*f- #%=,- /#- *;"*- 7&/#*>-- G;(,- =",- ")="0,- 8/(#8- */- '%- "- '"$- 0%"&- 7/&- *;%- F%1/5&"*,9- "#$- 4%&;"4,-
$%,%&:%$)0-,/>--Z2*-*;%-@%42')(5"#,W-
"$1(**%$- 8/")- /7- 2#3,%"*(#8- Z"&"5<- E'"1"-;",-*;%1-*2&#(#8-*/-*;"*-*(1%3
;/#/&%$- *"5*(5- /7- $%1/#([(#8- 0/2&- /44/#%#*W,-(#*%))(8%#5%>--C$1(**%$)09- E'"1"- 5/1%,- "5&/,,- ",- "- 4&/7%,,/&9-
"#$-,25;-"#-(1"8%-$/%,-#/*-k0-=(*;-
*;%-/7*%#-%",()03(#,2)*%$-42')(5>--Z2*- ,*())9- *;(,- *&%#$- "="0- 7&/1- /':(/2,-
(#*%))(8%#5%-5"&&(%,-=(*;-(*-*;%-&(,<-/7-
%)%5*(#8- 4%/4)%- =;/- &%"))0- ;":%- #/- 5)2%-;/=-*/-&2#-"-5/2#*&0>--I/&-4&//79- ,%%-*;%-.&,*-4"&"8&"4;>
E7-5/2&,%9-*;(,-,(*2"*(/#-(,-$(77%&%#*9- ,(#5%- "*- )%",*- /#%- #/&1")- 5(*([%#- "53
*2"))0- ;",- ;"$- "- '%%&- =(*;- ?&%,($%#*- E'"1">- - G;%- ?&%,($%#*- ;",- 4&/:%#-
;(1,%)7- "- :%&0- 4%&,/#"')%- 4&/7%,,/&>-- Z2*-,(#5%-;%-(,-"),/-,1"&*%&-*;"#-*;%- 5/11/#- 1"#9- ;%- 12,*- '%- (#5"4"')%- /7- 2#$%&,*"#$(#8- /2&- 4)(8;*9- "#$- ,/- e"55/&$(#8- */- *;%- @%42')(5"#,9- "*- )%",*f- ;%- (,- 2#%)%5*"')%- 7/&- "- ,%5/#$-
*%&1>--T%-"&%-%Y4%5*%$-*/-%)%5*-*;%-2#3
%Y*&"/&$(#"&()0- "$%X2"*%- 5"#$($"*%,9-
=":(#8-*;%(&-4/134/1,-"#$-5;"#*(#8-
*/- _B/2&*%,0- /7- *;%- @%$9- T;(*%- "#$- Z)2%>`- - D:%#- *;%- %#*&%#5;%$- )%"$%&3 ,;(4-;",-'%82#-5"*%&(#8-*/-*;%(&-"#*(3 (#*%))%5*2")- 5/#,*(*2%#50a- =;0- %),%-
=/2)$- H(#$,"0- M&";"1- */2*- ;(,- )%,,-
*;"#-,"*(,7"5*/&0-ACG-,5/&%,-*/-8%#%&3
"*%-4/)(*(5")-5"5;%-"1/#8-&%5%#*-5/)3 )%8%-8&"$2"*%,U--G%"-?"&*0-%Y*&%1(,*,-
"&%- "),/- '%(#8- 5)"(1%$- '0- *;%- *&"$(3
*(/#")- &(8;*9- &%8"&$)%,,- /7- ,/1%- ,%&(3 /2,- ($%/)/8(5")- "#$l,;"))- =%- ,"09-
&;%*/&(5")l$(77%&%#5%,- e&%5"))- *;%- '&())("#*- /&"*/&0- /7- @"#$- ?"2)- "#$- A;"&&/#-C#8)%-/&-*;%-4%%&)%,,-$%'"*3 (#8- ,<())- /7- B"&)- ?")"$(#/f>- - G;"#<- 0/29-b/;#-Z/%;#%&9-7/&-'2()$(#8-,25;-
"#-(#5)2,(:%-5/")(*(/#>
Z2*9-/#-"-1/&%-,%&(/2,-#/*%9-=%-#/=-
7"5%- *;%- 4&/')%1- /7- 8/:%&#(#8- =(*;-
;")7-/7-B/#8&%,,-;"1,*&2#8-'0-(#*%&3
#")-,*&288)%,-"1/#8-(*,-1"6/&(*0-"#$-
*;%-/*;%&-;")7-$%$(5"*%$-*/-2#,%"*(#8-
*;%-,(**(#8-?&%,($%#*>--E#-*/4-/7-*;"*9-
#%(*;%&- ,($%- 5/11"#$,- "- :%*/34&//7- 1"6/&(*0-(#-%(*;%&-;/2,%>--A/9-(7-Z/%;3
#%&-"#$-@%($-,*(5<-*/-*;%(&-&%,4%5*(:%- 8/)$%#-82#,-"#$-'(/$%8&"$"')%-4)/=3 ,;"&%,9- =%- ;":%- *;"*- 1/,*- $%)(8;*72)- /7- 4/)(*(5")- ,5%#"&(/,S- 8&($)/5<>- - J#- 7"5*9-(7-"-5%&*"(#-@%4&%,%#*"*(:%-F"&3
&%))-J,,"-/7-B")(7/&#("-;",-;(,-="09-*;%- 8/:%%#*-=())-'%-;/'')%$-'09-"#$-J- X2/*%S-_,%:%#-;%"&(#8,-"-=%%<9-*(1%,- RO- =%%<,>`- - C#$9- (#- "- *(1%- =;%&%- ,/1%*;(#8- (,- 5%&*"(#)0- &/**%#- (#- *;%- ,*"*%- /7- C1%&(5"- e(#- 4"&*(52)"&9- *;%- ,*"*%-/7-A/2*;-B"&/)(#"f9-8&($)/5<-=())-
$//1-2,-_5/11/#-1%#`-*/-"-,*%"$0-
$(%*- /7- $%5"0(#8- "#$- $0,72#5*(/#")- 4/)(50>- - ?%&;"4,- (*W,- *;%- G%"- ?"&*0W,- 7"2)*9- *;"*- *;%- 42')(5- ;",- :/*%$- /2*- 1"#0- F%1/5&"*,- &"*;%&- *;"#- 8%#23 (#%)0- ,244/&*- "#- ")*%&#"*%- 5"#$($"*%>-- E&-1"0'%9-)(<%-%:%&0*;(#8-%),%-4/)(*(3 5")-*;%,%-$"0,9-K"#50-?%)/,(-"#$-;%&- 1"&(62"#"3"$$(5*%$- 5/#,*(*2%#50- "&%-
*/- ')"1%>- - T;/%:%&- (,- 52)4"')%9- *;%- 7"5*-(,-*;"*-*;%,%-#%=)0-%)%5*%$-($%/3 )/82%,- 12,*- .#$- "- ="0- */- ;%")- /2&- 5/2#*&0- ;"#$- (#- ;"#$- =(*;- *;%(&- '(*3
*%&-7/%,-7&/1-"5&/,,-*;%-"(,)%>--J-=(,;-
*;%1-)25<>
Eric Lyons
High Hopes for California
Matt Scarano Class of 2014
College of Arts and Science
&
J- "1- "- 4&/2$- B")(7/&#("#>- Z2*- )(<%- 1/,*- B")(7/&#("#,- *;%,%- $"0,9- J- "1-
=/&&(%$-"'/2*-*;%-72*2&%-/7-10-8&%"*- ,*"*%>- B")(7/&#("- (,- '"#<&24*a- ;%&- 4&(,/#,- "#$- 42')(5- ,5;//),- "&%- /:%&3 5&/=$%$- "#$- 2#$%&72#$%$9- "#$- *;%-
%,*%%1%$- i#(:%&,(*(%,- /7- B")(7/&#("-
"&%- (#- (#5&%",(#8)0- $(&%- ,*&"(*,>- D#*%&-
?&/4/,(*(/#-Pg9-*;%-@%82)"*%9-B/#*&/)9-
"#$-G"Y-B"##"'(,-C5*9-"),/-*;%-NOPO- 1($*%&1-%)%5*(/#W,-5;"#5%-*/-5/1'(#%-
*=/-=/&*;0-B")(7/&#("#-5"2,%,S-.Y(#8-
*;%- ,*"*%- '2$8%*9- "#$- 4&/$25(#8- "#$- 5/#,21(#8-*;%-=/&)$W,-'%,*-=%%$>
C,- (*,- %Y*%#$%$- *(*)%- ,288%,*,9- ;"$-
?&/4- Pg- 4",,%$- /#- K/:%1'%&- N9- (*-
=/2)$- ;":%- )%8")([%$- 1"&(62"#"- 7/&-
&%5&%"*(/#")- 2,%9- ;%":()0- &%82)"*%$- (*,-8&/=*;-"#$-$(,*&('2*(/#9-"#$-*"Y%$- (*-7/&-4&/6%5*%$-,*"*%-&%:%#2%-/7-/:%&- /#%- '())(/#- $/))"&,- 4%&- 0%"&>- i#7/&3
*2#"*%)09- (*- =",- $%7%"*%$- (#- *;%- 4/)),-
=(*;-^h-4%&5%#*-:/*(#8-#/-"#$-RR-4%&3 5%#*-:/*(#8-0%,>--- V/=%:%&9- *;(,- %)%5*(/#- &%4&%,%#*,- /#)0-*;%-'%8(##(#8-/7-=;"*-4&/1(,%,-
*/-'%-"-)/#8-'"**)%-/:%&-=;"*-*;%-\%,- /#- Pg- B"14"(8#- 5"))%$- _1"&(62"#"- 4&/;('(*(/#>`- A244/&*%&,- /7- )%8")(["3
*(/#-5)"(1-*;"*-)%8")-1"&(62"#"-=/2)$- 4&/:($%- 125;- #%%$%$- *"Y- &%:%#2%- 7/&- B")(7/&#("9- =;()%- "))%:("*(#8- #23 1%&/2,-/*;%&-4&/')%1,-*;"*-*;%-,*"*%-
;",- 7"5%$- (#- &%5%#*- 0%"&,>- J*- =/2)$- ,(8#(.5"#*)0- &%$25%- /:%&5&/=$(#8- (#- 4&(,/#,9-=;%&%-;2#$&%$,-/7-*;/2,"#$,- /7- (#1"*%,- "&%- (#5"&5%&"*%$- /#- 1"&(3 62"#"-5;"&8%,9-"#$-=/2)$-7&%%-24-)"=-
%#7/&5%1%#*-*/-7/52,-/#-1/&%-4&%,,3 (#8-(,,2%,-*;"#-,/7*-$&28-2,%-4&%:%#3
*(/#9- =;(5;- 52&&%#*)0- %"*,- *;&/28;-
;2#$&%$,- /7- 1())(/#,- /7- $/))"&,- /7- 72#$(#8-%"5;-0%"&>-J7-B")(7/&#("-5"#W*- .#$-")*%&#"*(:%-="0,-*/-,;/&%-24-;%&-
$%.5(*9- %5/#/109- "#$- (#7&",*&25*2&%9-
*;%#-72*2&%-(#(*("*(:%,-)(<%-?&/4-Pg-"&%- '/2#$-*/-&%"44%"&-"#$-%:%#*2"))0-,253 5%%$>
L"&(62"#"-4&/;('(*(/#-;",-"),/-'%%#- 5/14"&%$- */- ")5/;/)- 4&/;('(*(/#- /7-
*;%- PgNOW,9- =;(5;- 7"()%$- '%5"2,%- /7- :(/)%#5%- "#$- =($%,4&%"$- $(,/'%$(3
%#5%- /7- *;%- )"=>- F%,4(*%- 1"&(62"#"W,- ())%8")(*09- B")(7/&#("#,-,*())-,1/<%- (*9-
Reddenning The C-)//<-"*-;/=-*;%-NOPO- L($*%&1-%)%5*(/#,-5;"#8%$-
*;%-4/)(*(5")-)"#$,5"4%>
the progress
Mapping
A%#"*%-%)%5*(/#-&%,2)*,
2006-2010
@%42')(5"# F%1/5&"*
E*;%&-?"&*0 K/-@"5%
the Voices
Hearing
C-)//<-"*-=;"*-5"#$($"*%,-(#-
*;%-%)%5*(/#,-,"($>--C))-&
(#7/&1"*(/#-(,-7&/1-5"#$($"*%,W- 5"14"(8#-=%',(*%,>
2010
An gle (R) Rei d (D)
Reid beats angle in Nevada Senate
_@%($-1"0-;":%-;(,-2#(/#-*;28,-"#$-*;%- _5/112#(*0- /&8"#([(#8`- 8%*3/2*3*;%3 :/*%-(#7&",*&25*2&%-)%7*-/:%&-7&/1-?&%,(3
$%#*- E'"1"W,- %)%5*(/#- (#- NOO]9- '2*-
=%W&%-5/2#*(#8-/#-$%$(5"*%$-4"*&(/*,>>>`
_G/$"0-V"&&0-@%($-(,-*;%-L"6/&(*0-H%"$3
%&-(#-*;%-i>A>-A%#"*%9-"-1"#-=;/-5/13 1"#$,- *;%- &%,4%5*- /7- 5/))%"82%,- 7&/1- '/*;-4"&*(%,9-"#$-"-4/=%&72)-"$:/5"*%-7/&- K%:"$"W,-1($$)%35)",,-7"1()(%,>`
.VSLPXTLJ *
Mi ller (R)
Murkowski wins alaska with write-in
_>>>A%#"*/&- L2&</=,<(- ;",- ")&%"$0- 1"$%- 1"#0- ,*&($%,- /#- (,,2%,- 7"5(#8- C)",<"#,>- C,- ,;%- "$:/5"*%,- 7/&- )%8(,3 )"*(/#- /#- *;%- A%#"*%- k//&9- ;%&- 4",,(/#- 7/&- (14&/:(#8- *;%- ,*"*%- /7- ;%")*;- 5"&%9-
%$25"*(/#9-%#%&809-:%*%&"#,W-"77"(&,-"#$- (#7&",*&25*2&%-$%:%)/41%#*-(#-C)",<"-(,- 2#X2%,*(/#"')%>`
_H(,"-L2&</=,<(-"#$-;%&-7&(%#$,-(#-*;%- 1%$("- ;":%- 1(,)%$- 0/2>>>nA;%o- (,- 7/&53 (#8- *;%- 5/2#*- (#- C)",<"- p- '0- (8#/&(#8-
*;%- 4&(1"&0- 4&/5%,,>>>"#$- 5/#$25*(#8-
"- =&(*%3(#- 5"14"(8#- 5/,*(#8- 1())(/#,- /7- $/))"&,9- H(,"- %#,2&%$- "- $&"=#3/2*- 5/2#*(#8- 4&/5%,,- =/2)$- '%- &%X2(&%$- */-
$%*%&1(#%-"-:(5*/&>
Webster (R)
Grayson (D)Webster beats Grayson in Florida
_G;&/28;- %Y4%&(%#5%$- %0%,9- T%',*%&- ,%%,- 1"#0- 2#"55%4*"')%- 4&"5*(5%,- 8/3 (#8-/#-(#-T",;(#8*/#-*/$"0>-V%-<#/=,- .&,*- ;"#$- ;/=- */- .Y- '&/<%#- 8/:% 1%#*9- &%,*/&%- 7/&8/**%#- :")2%,- "#$- 5&%"*%-%77%5*(:%-4&"5*(5%,-"#$-4/)(50>`
_F"#(%)- T%',*%&- ="#*,- */- (14/,%- ;(,-
&"$(5")-72#$"1%#*")(,1-/#-2,>-T%',*%&-
*&(%$- */- $%#0- '"**%&%$- =/1%#- 1%$(5")- 5"&%9-"#$-*;%-&(8;*-*/-$(:/&5%-*;%(&-"'2,3
%&,>-V%-="#*,-*/-7/&5%-&"4%$-=/1%#-*/- '%"&- *;%- 5;()$>- G")('"#- F"#- T%',*%&>- V"#$,-/77-/2&-'/$(%,-"#$-/2&-)"=,>`
"#$- *;%&%- "&%- #/- ,(8#,- *;"*- *;%0- =())- ,*/4>- C#$- ")*;/28;- *;%&%- (,- #/*- ,(83
#(.5"#*- 1"&(62"#"3&%)"*%$- :(/)%#5%- (#,($%-C1%&(5"W,-'/&$%&,9-4&/.*,-*;"*- L%Y(5"#- 5"&*%),- 1"<%- ,%))(#8- 4/*- ()3 )%8"))0-(#-C1%&(5"-5/#*&('2*%-*/-$"#3 8%&/2,-5/#$(*(/#,-,/2*;-/7-*;%-'/&$%&>- A244/&*%&,- /7- )%8")(["*(/#- &%1(#$- 2,- *;"*- &"*;%&- *;"#- 72#$(#8- L%Y(5"#- 5&(1(#"),9-=%-5/2)$-'%-,244/&*(#8-)%3
8(*(1"*%-%#*&%4&%#%2&,-"#$-.))(#8-*"Y- 5/77%&,-(#,($%-B")(7/&#(">
G;/28;- 42,;%$- (#*/- *;%- )(1%)(8;*- '0- 4&"81"*(5- 5/#,($%&"*(/#,9- 125;- /7-*;%-52&&%#*-,244/&*-7/&-)%8")(["*(/#- 5/1%,- 7&/1- (#$(:($2"),- "#$- 8&/24,-
=;/-;":%-,(14)0-$%5($%$-*;"*-*;%&%-(,-
#/-&%",/#-7/&-1"&(62"#"-*/-'%-())%8")>- L"#0-)('%&"),-;":%-5/1%-*/-:(%=-*;%-
&(8;*- */- ,1/<%- 4/*- ",- "- 5(:()- )('%&*09-
"#$- ,*&(5*- H('%&*"&("#,- :(%=- ,1/<3 (#8- ",- "- 4%&,/#")- 5;/(5%- =(*;- =;(5;-
*;%- 8/:%%#*- ,;/2)$- #/*- (#*%&7%&%>-
\/2#8- :/*%&,- "&%- 1/,*- ,244/&*(:%>-
?&%3%)%5*(/#- 4/)),- (#$(5"*%$- *;"*- ]O- 4%&5%#*-/&-1/&%-/7-B")(7/&#("#,-2#$%&- QO-=/2)$-:/*%-7/&-?&/4-Pg>-G;(,-$%3 1/8&"4;(5-(,9-;/=%:%&9-*;%-)%",*-)(<%3 )0-*/-:/*%-(#-%)%5*(/#,-(#-8%#%&")>-C,- ,/1%-5/1%$("#,-;":%-&%*/&*%$-(#-&%3 5%#*-$"0,9-4%&;"4,-B")(7/&#("W,-0/2*;-
=/2)$- ;":%- :/*%$- 7/&- ?&/4- Pgl'2*-
*;%#-*;%0-8/*-;(8;>
G;%&%- (,- "),/9- /7- 5/2&,%9- "#- /44/3 ,(*(/#- 5"14- *;"*- ;",- .%&5%)0- 5"13 4"(8#%$- "8"(#,*- ?&/4- Pg>- G;%0- "&3 82%-*;"*-*"Y-&%:%#2%-7&/1-1"&(62"#"-
=/2)$-'%-/77,%*-'0-1%$(5")-5/,*,-*;"*- 2,%-/7-*;%-$&28-=/2)$-5"2,%9-"#$-*;"*- /*;%&- ,/5(")- '%#%.*,- =/2)$- '%- #2))(3 .%$- '0- (#5&%",%$- 5&(1(#")- "5*(:(*0-
"#$-$%5&%",%$-1/*(:"*(/#-"1/#8-*;%- 4/42)/2,>- H%8")- 1"&(62"#"- (#,($%- B")(7/&#("9- *;%0- ,"09- =/2)$- "**&"5*-
$&28- 2,%&,- */- *;%- ,*"*%9- =;/- =/2)$-
*;%#- '%5/1%- '2&$%#,- /#- *;%- ;%")*;-
"#$-=%)7"&%-,0,*%1>
G;%&%-(,-#/-$%#0(#8-*;"*-,/1%-/7-*;(,- 1"0-'%-*&2%9-*/-,/1%-%Y*%#*>-V/=%:3
%&9-*;%-4&(1"&0-&%",/#-?&/4-Pg-7"()%$- (,-*;%-#%8"*(:%-,*(81"-*;"*-1"&(62"#"-
;",- *&"$(*(/#"))0- '%%#- *(#8%$- =(*;- (#-
*;%- C1%&(5"#- 42')(5- ,4;%&%>- L"#0- C1%&(5"#,- '%)(%:%9- 4%&;"4,- $2%- */- 0%"&,-/7-"#*(3$&28-%$25"*(/#-"#$-42'3 )(5- ,%&:(5%- "$:%&*(,(#89- *;"*- ,1/<(#8- 1"&(62"#"- (,- $"#8%&/2,- "#$- 4%&;"4,-
%:%#- 1/&"))0- =&/#8>- - G;%0- '%)(%:%-
*;"*- 1"&(62"#"- (,- 1/&%- ;"&172)- *;"#-
")5/;/)9-*;"*-(*-(,-"-8"*%="0-$&289-"#$-
*;"*-(*-(,-;"&172)-*/-C1%&(5"#-0/2*;>- Z2*-,5(%#*(.5-,*2$(%,-"#$-,*"*(,*(5,-"&%-
Reddenning C-)//<-"*-;/=-*;%-NOPO- L($*%&1-%)%5*(/#,-5;"#8%$-
*;%-4/)(*(5")-)"#$,5"4%> sky
i*NOPU recommending for every future President that
they take a TIFMMBDLJOHMJLF*
did last night.”
?&%,($%#*-E'"1"9-K/:%1'%&-Q9-NOPO
2008 2006
Ro by (R) #3* ()5 %
Roby beats Bright in Alabama 2nd Dist.
_>>>K/=- "7*%&- '"()/2*,9- '20/2*,9- 7"()%$- ,*(12)2,9-5",;-7/&-5)2#<%&,9-;(8;%&-*"Y3
%,9- *&())(/#- $/))"&- $%.5(*,- "#$- 8/:% 1%#*3&2#- ;%")*;- 5"&%9- Z/''0- Z&(8;*- (,-
",<(#8-2,-*/-8(:%-;(1-"#/*;%&-/44/&*23
#(*0-,/-;%-5"#-*&0-"#$-8%*-(*-&(8;*U--G;"*- (,-/#%-5;"#5%-C)"'"1"-5"#W*-"77/&$>`
_Z/''0- Z&(8;*- (,- 4&/2$- "#$- ;21')%$-
*/- ,%&:%- C)"'"1"W,- N#$- 5/#8&%,,(/#")-
$(,*&(5*>--T;%*;%&-;%W,-;/1%-(#-*;%-$(,3
*&(5*-/&-"*-=/&<-(#-T",;(#8*/#9-;(,-$//&- (,- ")="0,- /4%#- 7/&- 5/#,*(*2%#*,>>>- V%- (,-
"-1%1'%&-/7-*;%-Z)2%-F/8-B/")(*(/#>`
Rub io (R) $SJTU *
Rubio beats crist Florida Senate Race
_Z%5"2,%- /7- 0/2&- ,244/&*- "#$- $%$(5"3
*(/#9- =%- "&%- /#- *;%- &/"$- */- @%5)"(1- C1%&(5">- - K/=- *;%- &%")- =/&<- '%8(#,>-- JW))- #%%$- 0/2&- 5/#*(#2%$- ,244/&*- ",- J- 8/-*/-T",;(#8*/#-*/-,%&:%-I)/&($"-"#$-
"#$-.8;*-*/-<%%4-C1%&(5"-%Y5%4*(/#")>`
_b/(#- /2&- 5"14"(8#- */- ,*/4- G%"- ?"&*0-
%Y*&%1(,*- L"&5/- @2'(/9- "#$- ;%)4- 8(:%- I)/&($"-"-'&(8;*%&-72*2&%>`
DesJarlais (R)
D avis (D)
DesJarlaisCFBUT*ODVNCFOUDavis
_J#- *;%- 4",*- 7%=- 0%"&,9- =%- ;":%- =(*3
#%,,%$- /2&- 5/2#*&0- '%(#8- ,="))/=%$- '0-Z(8-M/:%%#*9-&2#"="0-,4%#$(#8-
"#$-(#5&%",(#8-$%.5(*,-*;"*-=())-4)"82%- 8%#%&"*(/#,-*/-5/1%>-_
_J- =())- *"<%- 4/,(*(/#,- '%5"2,%- *;%0- "&%-
&(8;*- 7/&- *;%- 4%/4)%- /7- G%##%,,%%W,- I/2&*;- F(,*&(5*9- #/*- '%5"2,%- *;%0- "&%-
&(8;*- 7/&- F%1/5&"*,- /&- @%42')(5"#,-
")/#%>`
$%1/#,*&"*(#8- *;"*- *;%- )"**%&- 5/#5)23 ,(/#,-"&%-2#7/2#$%$9-"#$-(7-?&/4-PgW,- 4/)(*(5")- :("'()(*0- 4&/:%,- "#0*;(#89- (*- (,-*;"*-C1%&(5"#-e/&-"*-)%",*-B")(7/&3
#("#f- "**(*2$%,- */="&$- 1"&(62"#"- "&%-
&"4($)0-5;"#8(#8>
A/- ")*;/28;- ?&/4- Pg- 1"0- ;":%- 7"()%$-*;(,-*(1%9-)%8(,)"*(/#-)(<%-(*-=())-
")1/,*-5%&*"(#)0-&%"44%"&-(#-*;%-NOPN-
%)%5*(/#>- G;%- 5"14"(8#- 7/&- 1%$(3 5")- 1"&(62"#"- '%8"#- (#- B")(7/&#("- (#- PggP9-'2*-?&/4/,(*(/#-NP^-$($-#/*-)%3 8")([%-(*-2#*()-Pggh>-G;%,%-*;(#8,-*"<%-
*(1%>-C#$-/#5%-)%8")-4/*-$/%,-'%5/1%-
"-&%")(*09-4%&;"4,-(*-=())-'%-*;%-.#"#3 5(")-"#$-,/5(")-,":(#8-8&"5%-*;"*-B")(3 7/&#("-#%%$,>-?%&;"4,-#/*9-'2*-"*-)%",*-
*;%#- =%W))- '%- "')%- */- &/))- 24- "- )%8")- 7"**0-"#$-,1/<%-/2&-=/&&(%,-"="0>
Obama is Okay
*BO%VODBO Class of 2014
College of Arts and Science E#- K/:%1'%&- Q&$9- Z"&"5<- E'"1"-
"$$&%,,%$- *;%-C1%&(5"#- 4%/4)%- /#- "-
$(77%&%#*- #/*%- =(*;- "- $(77%&%#*- *2#%>- G;/,%-/7-2,-=;/-&%1%1'%&-1"0-;":%-
#/*(5%$- *;"*- Z"&"5<- E'"1"W,- ,4%%5;-
*;"*-T%$#%,$"0-$($-#/*-,/2#$-)(<%-;(,- NOOR-,%#"*%-:(5*/&0>-J*-$($-#/*-,/2#$- )(<%-*;%-/4*(1(,*(5-4&%,($%#*(")3;/4%3 72)- E'"1"- /#- *;%- NOO]- 5"14"(8#-
*&"()>- J*- =",- #/*- *;%- Z"&"5<- E'"1"-
=;/- =":%$- "- ;%":0- ,*(5<- "*- *;%- A23 4&%1%- B/2&*- "#$- B/#8&%,,- %"&)(%&-
*;(,- 0%"&9- 4&%,,2&(#8- *;"*- ;(,- "8%#$"- '%-72).))%$>-K/9-*;"*-T%$#%,$"09-"7*%&-
*;%-1($*%&1-%)%5*(/#,9-E'"1"W,-4)%"-
=",- #/*- "- _\%,- =%- 5"#`- ",- 125;- ",- _?)%",%q-J-5"#q`-
G;%-#(8;*-'%7/&%9-@%42')(5"#,-1"$%- ,/1%-'(8-8"(#,>-C-=;/44(#8-hO-,%"*,- (#-*;%-V/2,%-%Y"5*)09-1/&%-*;"#-%(*;%&- 4"&*0-,(#5%-*;%-PgQOW,>-b/;#-Z/%;#%&- (,- %Y4%5*%$- */- '%5/1%- A4%"<%&- /7-
*;%- V/2,%- /7- @%4&%,%#*"*(:%,- =(*;- "- F%1/5&"*(5-?"&*0-*;"*-;/)$,-)%,,-*;"#- NOO-,%"*,-7/&-*;%-.&,*-*(1%-,(#5%-PgRh>- G;%-F%1/5&"*(5-1"6/&(*0-(#-*;%-A%#3
"*%-;",-'%%#-;(*-;"&$-",-=%))>-G;%-@%3 42')(5"#,-,(14)0-/2*372#$&"(,%$9-/2*3 5"14"(8#%$9- "#$- 2)*(1"*%)0- /2*3$($-
*;%-F%1/5&"*,-*;(,-&/2#$>
C#$- 0%*- ?&%,($%#*- E'"1"- ,;/2)$-
#/*- '%- ",- =/&&(%$- ",- /*;%&,- ,288%,*>- J#- 10- ;/1%- $(,*&(5*9- *;%- L",,"5;23 ,%**,- h*;9- B/#8&%,,1%#- b/;#- G(%&3
#%0W,- =(7%- 5&%"*%$- "- ,5"#$")- =;%#- ,;%- 5/11(**%$- 8"1')(#8- 7&"2$- =(*;-
;%&-'&/*;%&9-'2*9-#%:%&*;%)%,,9-F%1/3 5&"*(5-(#521'%#*-G(%&#%0-'%"*-*;%-@%3 42')(5"#-5;"))%#8%&-=(*;-hOr-/7-*;%- :/*%>-E*;%&-*;"#-K%=-V"14,;(&%9-*;%-
#/&*;%",*- &%1"(#,- 2#$%&- F%1/5&"*(5- 5/#*&/)>-G;%-)"&8%-"1/2#*-/7-:(5*/&(3 /2,-B/#8&%,,(/#")-@%42')(5"#,-(#-243 ,*"*%-K%=-\/&<-5"##/*-5/1%-5)/,%-*/-
*2&#(#8- *;%- ,*"*%- 42&4)%>- J#- *;%- =%,*9- F%1/5&"*,- &%*"(#%$- 5/#*&/)- /7- *;%-
A%#"*%-,%"*,-(#-B")(7/&#("-"#$-T",;3 (#8*/#9-"#$-%:%#-@%($W,-K%:"$"-,%"*9-
$%,4(*%- 5/#.$%#*- 4/)),*%&,W- 4&%$(53
*(/#,-*;"*-@%($-=",-,2&%-*/-)/,%>-G;%- F%1/5&"*(5- 4/=%&;/2,%,- (#- K/&*;3
%",*-"#$-T%,*-&%1"(#-,*"')%>-
V/=%:%&9-*;%-&%$-&%:/)2*(/#-/7-*;%- M&%"*- H"<%- ,*"*%,- ;",- F%1/5&"*,- ,;"<(#8- (#- *;%(&- ,;/%,>- A=(#8- ,*"*%,- E;(/9- ?%##,0):"#("9- "#$- J#$("#"-
;":%- 8/#%- 7&/1- F%1/5&"*(5- 5/#3
*&/)-(#-*;%-;/2,%-*/-)"&8%-@%42')(5"#- 1"6/&(*(%,>- E;(/9- ,4%5(.5"))09- ;",-
")="0,- '%%#- "#- "552&"*%- '"&/1%*%&- 7/&-4&%,($%#*(")-%)%5*(/#,9-'2*-$%,4(*%- )"&8%-8"(#,-(#-*;%-,=(#8-,*"*%9-@%42'3 )(5"#,-*//<-*;%-8/:%&#/&,;(4-'0-/#)0- N- 4/(#*,d"- ,1"))- 1"&8(#- /7- :(5*/&0-
*;"*-F%1/5&"*,-5"#-%",()0-5)/,%>--G;(,-
&%8(/#-;",-#/*-8&/=#-1/&%-5/#,%&:"3
*(:%- /:%&#(8;*- ,(#5%- NOO]a- 4%&;"4,-
&%8(/#")- :/*%&,- ;":%- 1%&%)0- '%5/1%- )%,,-%14)/0%$>
Z%#-Z%&#"#<%-"##/2#5%$-)",*-=%%<-
*;"*-*;%-I%$%&")-@%,%&:%-=/2)$-4214- shOO-'())(/#-*;&/28;-'/#$-42&5;",%,>- G;(,-1"0-*"<%-"-=;/)%-0%"&-*/-,%*-(#-
*/-*;%-%5/#/109-'2*-(*W,-5%&*"(#)0-'%*3
*%&-*;"#-*;%-")*%&#"*(:%>-J*-,%%1,-)(<%- /#)0-"-,1"))-1"&8(#-/7-:(5*/&0-7/&-10- 7%))/=-@%42')(5"#,>-C1%&(5"#,-5",*-"- :/*%-"8"(#,*-E'"1"W,-%5/#/1(5-4&/3 4/,"),9-'2*-(#*%&4&%*(#8-*;(,-",-"-'")3 )/*-7/&-1/&%-5/#,%&:"*(:%-8/:%&#"#5%-
=/2)$-,288%,*-"-1/&%-.5<)%-%)%5*/&"*%-
*;"#-42')(5-/4(#(/#-,288%,*,>-H%8(,)"3
*(:%-.,5")-4/)(50-/7-*;%-#%Y*-*=/-0%"&,- 1"0-#/*-%Y"5*)0-%12)"*%-*;%-@%"8"#-
=":%-/7-*;%-%"&)0-%(8;*(%,9-'2*-"*-*;(,- 4/(#*9- C1%&(5"#- :/*%&,- "&%- =())(#8-
*/- &%="&$- *;%- ?&%,($%#*- 7/&- "#0- ,(8#- /7- (14&/:%1%#*>- @%"8"#- "#$- B)(#3
*/#- &/$%- )"#$,)($%,- (#*/- *;%(&- ,%5/#$-
*%&1,>- J7- ?&%,($%#*- E'"1"- 5"#- *2&#-
*;%-%5/#/10-"&/2#$-62,*-"-)(**)%9-JW1- 5/#.$%#*- ;%- 5"#- *//>- G;(,- 1($*%&1-
%)%5*(/#-5/2)$-%",()0-4&/:%-(&&%)%:"#*-
=(*;-*;%-="0-*;(#8,-"&%-8/(#8-#/=>
Eric Lyons
Boiling in a Pot of Tea
Charles Buddeke Class of 2013
College of Arts and Science H",*-=%%<-=",-#/*"')%-7/&-*=/-1"6/&-
$%:%)/41%#*,>- I(&,*- "#$- 1/,*- ;%"$3 )(#%- 8&"''(#89- *;%- @%42')(5"#- ?"&*0-
%Y4%&(%#5%$- "- ;(,*/&(5- &%:(:")- "7*%&- '%(#8-5/14)%*%)0-'&/<%#-(#-*;%-NOO]-
%)%5*(/#>-V/=%:%&9-(*-(,-#/*-=;/))0-"53 52&"*%-*/-5"))-*;(,-"-&%,2&8%#5%-/7-*;%- 4"&*0>-G;%-1"(#-$&(:(#8-7/&5%-'%;(#$-
*;%,%- %)%5*/&")- &%,2)*,- =",- *;%- %#(83 1"*(5- G%"- ?"&*09- =;/- &/$%- 8%#%&")-
$(,5/#*%#*-=(*;-*;%-%5/#/10-(#-*/-/73 .5%>-V/=%:%&9-*;%-8&%"*-(&/#0-(,-*;"*-
*;%- G%"- ?"&*0- (,- *;%- ,(#8)%- 8&%"*%,*-
;(#$&"#5%-*/-%5/#/1(5-&%5/:%&0>
G;%-,%5/#$-(14/&*"#*-$%:%)/41%#*- )",*- =%%<- =",- *;%- "##/2#5%1%#*- '0-
*;%- I%$%&")- @%,%&:%- /7- (*,- (#*%#*- */- 42&5;",%-hOO-'())(/#-$/))"&,-=/&*;-/7- iA-G&%",2&(%,- e"),/- <#/=#- ",- X2"#3
*(*"*(:%-%",(#8>f-G;%-8/")-/7-*;(,-4&/3 8&"1-(,-*/-(#5%#*(:([%-*;%-42&5;",%-/7-
",,%*,- '0- 1"<(#8- *;%- 5/,*,- /7- ;/)$3 (#8-/#-*/-5"4(*")-;(8;%&-"#$-)/=%&(#8- )/#83*%&1- (#*%&%,*- &"*%,- */- 7"5()(*"*%- '2,(#%,,- '/&&/=(#8- 7/&- (#:%,*1%#*>- C,-,//#-",-*;(,-=",-"##/2#5%$9-5/#3
$%1#"*(/#-5"1%-7&/1-1"#0-;(8;-4&/3 .)%-G%"-?"&*0-1%1'%&,>
A"&";- ?")(#9- *;%- .82&%;%"$- /7- *;%- 1/:%1%#*9-(14)/&%$-I%$%&")-@%,%&:%- B;"(&1"#- Z%#- Z%&#"#<%- */- _5%",%-
"#$- $%,(,*`- *;(,- 4/)(50>- K/*- /#)0- (,- L&,>- ?")(#- )%5*2&(#8- "- ?;F- /7- %5/3
#/1(5,-/#-%5/#/1(5,9-,;%-(,-$/(#8-,/-
=(*;/2*-8&",4(#8-*;%-5/14)%Y(*(%,-/7-
*;%-,(*2"*(/#>-L&,>-?")(#-5(*%$-(#*%&#"3
*(/#")-5/#$%1#"*(/#-/7-*;%,%-4/)(5(%,-
",- "$$(*(/#")- %:($%#5%- */- ;%&- 2,2")-
&"#*-"'/2*-8/:%%#*-%Y5%,,>-A(#5%- M%&1"#0-_<#/=,-"-*;(#8-/&-*=/-"'/2*-
*;%- $"#8%&,- /7- (#k"*(/#9`- L&,>- ?")(#-
&%",/#,- *;%- I%$%&")- @%,%&:%- ,;/2)$- )(,*%#-*/-*;%1>
J#- &%")(*09- *;%- (#*%&#"*(/#")- /2*5&0- (,- #/*- /2*- /7- 5/#5%&#- 7/&- *;%- =/&)$-
%5/#/109- '2*- &"*;%&- *;%(&- /=#- $%3 4%#$%#5%-/#-i>A>-5/#,214*(/#-",-*;%-
%#8(#%-/7-8&/=*;-7/&-*;%(&-%5/#/1(%,9-
=;(5;-(,-"-k"=-(#-*;%-=/&<(#8,-/7-*;%-
=/&)$-%5/#/10>-G;%-M%&1"#-%5/#/3 10- "#$- 1/,*- $%:%)/4(#8- %5/#/1(%,-
"&%- '",%$- )"&8%)0- /#- %Y4/&*,9- *;%- &%3 5/:%&0- /7- =;(5;- =/2)$- '%- ,%:%&%)0-
;2&*- '0- "- =%"<%#%$- $/))"&>-C- ,*&/#8-
$/))"&-=/2)$-1"<%-iA-%Y4/&*,-1/&%- 5/14%*(*(:%9-"#$-(*-=/2)$-&%$25%-iA-
$%1"#$- 7/&- 7/&%(8#- 4&/$25*,- $2%- */-
;(8;%&- 5/,*>- b2,*- '%5"2,%- ,;%- 7"(),-
*/-5"4*2&%-*;(,-$%*"()-$/%,-#/*-1%"#9-
;/=%:%&9- *;"*- L&,>- ?")(#- (,- =&/#8>- A;%- (,- &(8;*- (#- *;"*- *;%&%- "&%- ,%&(/2,-
$"#8%&,- */- *;%- i>A>- (7- *;%,%- 4/)(5(%,- 5"2,%- (#k"*(/#- */- *"<%- /779- "#$- L&,>-
?")(#-$/%,#W*-%:%#-*/25;-/#-*;%-4/,3 ,(')%-$"#8%&-*/-*;%-=/&)$-
%5/#/10- $2%- */- *;%- 52&3
&%#50-="&,-&%,2)*(#8-7&/1- 1%*;/$,- )(<%- X2"#*(*"*(:%-
%",(#8>
T;0- *;%#- (,- L&>- Z%&3
#"#<%- 2,(#8- *;%,%- 4/*%#3
*("))0-&(,<0-4/)(5(%,U-J&/#3 (5"))09- (*- (,- *;%- G%"- ?"&*0-
*;"*- 7/&5%$- L&>- Z%&#"#3
<%W,-;"#$>-G;(,-8&/24-;",- 1"$%- "#0- .,5")- ,*(12)2,- e8/:%%#*- ,4%#$(#8f- '%0/#$- 4/)(*(5"))0- */Y(5>- C$$(#8- */- *;%- ")&%"$0- 5/#,($%&"')%- (&/#09- .,5")-
,*(12)2,- =/2)$- ;":%- "- 125;- 8&%"*%&-
%77%5*-$2%-*/-*;%-")&%"$0-)/=-(#*%&%,*-
&"*%,- (#- *;%- i>A>- V/=%:%&9- *;%- G%"-
?"&*0W,-5"14"(8#-"8"(#,*-8/:%%#*- ,4%#$(#8-;",-4&%:%#*%$-"#$-=())-5/#3
*(#2%-*/-4&%:%#*-B/#8&%,,-7&/1-%#"5*3 (#8- "#0- "$$(*(/#")- ,4%#$(#8- */- ,42&-
%5/#/1(5-8&/=*;>
G;(,- (,- (#5&%$(')0- $"#8%&/2,>- G;%- 52&&%#*-2#%14)/01%#*-&"*%-(,-(#-$"#3 8%&-/7-'%5/1(#8-,*&25*2&")-(7-&"*%,-/7-
%5/#/1(5-8&/=*;-$/-#/*-4(5<-249-"#$-
*;(,-&(,<-(,-,%:%&")-/&$%&,-/7-1"8#(*2$%- 1/&%- $"#8%&/2,- *;"#- *;%- /#%- 4/,%$- '0- *;%- ,;/&*- *%&1- $%.5(*- ,4%#$(#8>- G;%&%7/&%9- ,/1%*;(#8- 12,*- '%- $/#%-
*/-$&(:%-$%1"#$>-D#*%&-L&>-Z%&#"#<%>- A(#5%-*;%-I%$%&")-@%,%&:%-(,-52&&%#*)0-
*;%-/#)0-'/$0-'/*;-5"4"')%-"#$-=())3 (#8-*/-,*(12)"*%-*;%-%5/#/109-")'%(*-(#-
"#-2,2")-="09-(*-12,*-'%-$/#%-$%,4(*%-
*;%-$"#8%&,>-G;%-G%"-?"&*0-=/2)$-$/-
=%))- */- (8#/&%- *;%- ,;/&*- *%&1- $%.5(*- (#-7":/&-/7-,*(12)"*(#8-*;%-%5/#/10>- J#,*%"$9-(*-,;/2)$-7/52,-/#-42**(#8-(#- 4)"5%- 4)"#,- */- &%$25%9- (7- #/*- %)(1(3
#"*%9-*;%-1%$(21-*%&1-$%.5(*9-=;(5;- (,- =;%&%- *;%- &%")- $"#8%&- 7&/1- .,5")- 4/)(50-%Y(,*,>
R&P&"&0$&6K
+**LKMM-05%0&N;6ON$-)M#"*%$5&M(7DSSSDTUTSVUWTXWSGV DTESTVWVFSGSUGSTSDFUUETN+*)5Y)-8Z<([\+L6\6&$I
*%-06\0&;6
A Premature End to China’s Peaceful Rise?
Andrew Wood Class of 2011
College of Arts and Science M(:%-Z%(6(#8-,/1%-5&%$(*a-(*-;",#W*- '%%#-%",0-5/#5%")(#8-*;%(&-$%)(8;*-(#-
*;%- ,2&4&(,(#8- "7*%&1"*;- /7- *;%- NOO]- 8)/'")- .#"#5(")- 5&(,(,>- - ?&(/&- */- *;%- 5&(,(,9- (*- =",- "- =($%)03;%)$- /4(#(/#-
*;"*-B;(#"W,-1%*%/&(5-&(,%-$"*(#8-'"5<-
*/- Pgtg- =",- 62,*- /#%- 1"6/&- T%,*%&#- .#"#5(")- 5&(,(,- "="0- 7&/1- 5/))"4,%>-- Eric Lyons
J#,*%"$9- ,*/<%$- '0- "- R- *&())(/#- 02"#- ,*(12)2,-4"5<"8%9-B;(#"-&/))%$-/#-*/- g>Pr- 8&/=*;- (#- NOOg- 7/))/=(#8- *;%-
#%"&-5/))"4,%-/7-=/&)$-5&%$(*-1"&<%*,9-
"#$- (,- 7/&%5",*- */- %Y4"#$- "*- "#- %:%#- 1/&%-(14&%,,(:%-g>gr-*;(,-0%"&-%:%#-
",- *;%- 8/:%%#*- %#"5*,- *(8;*%#(#8- 1%",2&%,>--G=/-0%"&,-)"*%&9-*;%-?@BW,-
;(,*/&(5- ,4&(#*- */="&$,- $%:%)/41%#*- )//<,-1/&%-2#,*/44"')%-*;"#-%:%&>--
J#- NOPO9- *;%- ?@B- =())- 7/&- *;%- .&,*-
*(1%- (#- (*,- ;(,*/&0- /:%&*"<%- b"4"#- */- '%5/1%- *;%- ,%5/#$- )"&8%,*- %5/#/10- (#-*;%-=/&)$9-*&"()(#8-/#)0-*;%-i#(*%$- A*"*%,>- - V/=%:%&9- *;%- ?@B9- "#$- *;%- B;(#%,%-B/112#(,*-?"&*0-(#-4"&*(523 )"&9-$/-#/*-;":%-*;%-)2Y2&0-/7-"))/=(#8-
*;%(&-",*&/#/1(5")-8&/=*;-#21'%&,-*/- 7")*%&>--i#)(<%-*;%-%5/#/1(%,-/7-b"4"#-
"#$-*;%-i#(*%$-A*"*%,9-B;(#"W,-%5/#/3 10-12,*-,244/&*-"-4/42)"*(/#-/7-1/&%-
*;"#-P>Q-'())(/#>--J#-NOOg9-*;(,-1%"#*-
*;"*-*;"*-MF?-4%&-5"4(*"-(#-B;(#"-=",-
)%,,- *;"#- PuPO*;- *;"*- /7- b"4"#- "#$- PuPN*;- /7- C1%&(5">- - G;%- 4"&*0- 7%"&,-
*;"*- 8&/=*;- '%)/=- ]- 4%&5%#*- 5/2)$-
*&(88%&-$(,5/#*%#*-"1/#8-*;%-*;&/#8,- /7-)/=%&-"#$-#%=)0-1($$)%-5)",,-=/&<3
%&,9-2#$%&1(#(#8-*;%-4"&*0W,-,*&/#8%,*-
"&821%#*-7/&-5/#*(#2%$-"2*;/&(*"&("#-
&2)%>--C,-7"&-",-*;%-4"&*0-(,-5/#5%&#%$9-
$(,5/#*%#*-5/2)$-X2(5<)0-1"#(7%,*-(*3 ,%)7- (#*/- =($%,4&%"$- $/1%,*(5- (#,*"3 '()(*09- =;(5;- =/2)$- *;%#- 6%/4"&$([%- '/*;- B;(#"W,- 5/#*(#2%$- $%:%)/41%#*-
"#$-*;%-:%&0-,*&25*2&%-/7-*;%-?%/4)%W,-
@%42')(5>- - J*- ;",- 5/#,(,*%#*)0- e"#$- X2(*%- ,255%,,72))0f- 2*()([%$- *;(,- 7%"&-
",-"-*"5*(5-*/-'&2,;-",($%-5/#5%&#,-*;"*- Z%(6(#8W,-1/:%1%#*-*/="&$,-4/)(*(5")-
"#$- %5/#/1(5- &%7/&1- ,%%1,- */- ;":%- 8&/2#$- */- "- ;")*>- - J#- *;%- $%:%)/4%$-
=/&)$9- *;(,- "44&/"5;- ;",- /7*%#- '%%#-
&%8"&$%$- ",- /#%- /7- $(:%&,(/#>- - V/=3
%:%&9- *;%- 8&/=*;- "#$- ,*"'()(*0- :%&,2,- 5;"/,-"&821%#*-;",-8"(#%$-5/#,($%&3
"')%-*&"5*(/#-$/1%,*(5"))09-=;%&%-*;%- 4"&*0-;",-'%%#-"')%-*/-"**"5;-(*,%)7-*/-
*;%-#/*(/#-/7-%5/#/1(5-8&/=*;9-(#%Y3
*&(5"')0-*0(#8-(*,-/=#-,255%,,-*/-*;"*- /7-*;%-%5/#/10>--
G;%-5/#5%4*-*;"*-"-$%:%)/4(#8-%5/#3 /10-&%X2(&%,-,*&(5*-8/:%%#*-&%823 )"*(/#- "#$- (#*%&:%#*(/#- (#- /44/,(*(/#-
*/-1/&%-*04(5")-H"(,,%[3I"(&%-$/5*&(#%-
;",-5/1%-*/-'%-<#/=#-",-*;%-_Z%(6(#8-
B/#,%#,2,`>--J*-12,*-'%-#/*%$-*;"*-*;%- 4"&*0-(,-%Y*&%1%)0-"$%4*-"*-2,(#8-*;%- +5/#,%#,2,W- ",- "- *//)- /7- /44&%,,(/#9- 5)"14(#8- $/=#- %:%#- 72&*;%&- /#- J#3
*%&#%*- 2,%- "#$- 7&%%$/1- /7- ",,%1')09- ,4%%5;9-"#$-*;%-4&%,,>--J#$("W,-&"8(#8-
%5/#/1(5- 8&/=*;- #/*=(*;,*"#$(#89-
*;%-4"&*0-5/#*(#2%,-*/-5)"(1-*;"*-*;%,%-
"5*(/#,-"&%-#%5%,,"&0-*/-1"(#*"(#-*;%- 4"*;- */="&$,- 8&/=*;- "#$- $%:%)/43 1%#*-(#-,25;-"-)"&8%-5/2#*&0>--@%"$(#8- '%*=%%#-*;%-)(#%,9-(*-(,-#/*-;"&$-*/-$%3
*%&1(#%-*;"*-*;%-4"&*0-(,-(#5&%",(#8)0- (#,%52&%-"'/2*-(*,-"'()(*0-*/-&%1"(#-(#- 4/=%&- ",- B;(#"- '%5/1%,- &(5;%&9- "#$-
*;"*-4%&;"4,-(*,-8&%"*%,*-7%"&-(,-(*,-/=#- 4%/4)%>- - A(#5%- *;%- %:%#*,- )%"$(#8- 24-
*/-*;%-G("#"#1%#-L",,"5&%-/7-Pg]g9-
=;%#-*;%-4"&*0-=",-'0-1"#0-"55/2#*,-
"*- $%"*;W,- $//&- '%7/&%- (*- $%5($%$- */-
"5*(:"*%- *;%- _?%/4)%W,- H('%&"*(/#`- C&10-"8"(#,*-(*,-/=#-4%/4)%9-(*-)/8(3 5"))0- 7/))/=,- *;"*- *;%- BB?- ;",- '%%#-
"52*%)0-"="&%-/7-(*,-*%#2/2,-;/)$-/#-
*;%-:",*-B;(#%,%-4/42)"*(/#>
B/#,($%&(#8- *;%- $%)28%- /7- (#*%&#"3
*(/#")- 5&(*(5(,1- &%8"&$(#8- *;%- 4"&*0W,- 5/#*(#2%$-/44&%,,(/#-/7-7&%%$/1,9-*;%- BB?-;",-7/2#$-(*,%)7-(#-*;%-"=<="&$- 4/,(*(/#- /7- "**%14*(#8- */- 1"(#*"(#-
#/&1")([%$- &%)"*(/#,- =(*;- *;%- $%:%)3 /4%$-=/&)$-=;()%-,*/<(#8-#"*(/#")(,1-
$/1%,*(5"))0>--E#%-12,*-)//<-#/-72&3
*;%&-*;"#-*;%-4"&*0W,-$%5(,(/#-1"<(#8- (#-&%5%#*-(#5($%#*,-,25;-",-*;%-(14&(,3 /#1%#*- /7- C2,*&")("#- '2,(#%,,1"#- A*%&#-V29-*;%-5/#*(#2%$-"#$-/#8/(#8- 7"()2&%-*/-"))/=-*;%-\2"#-*/-&(,%-#"*23
&"))09-"#$-*;%-:(&*2")-1"#;"#$)(#8-/7- b"4"#W,-)%8")-,0,*%1-$2&(#8-*;%-A%#3
<"<2- J,)"#$,- &/=- */- ())21(#"*%- *;%-
*(8;*&/4%-/#-=;(5;-(*-#/=-*&%"$,>-- J#- *;%- 5",%- /7- C2,*&")("#- 5(*([%#- A*%&#- V29- *;%- 8/:%%#*- "&&%,*%$- 7/2&-%Y%52*(:%,-/7-C2,*&")("#-1(#(#8- .&1-@(/-G(#*/-&(8;*-"*-*;%-5)(1"Y-/7-
"#- (14",,%- (#- #%8/*("*(/#,- '%*=%%#-
*;%-.&1-"#$-B;(#%,%-,*"*%3/=#%$-")23 1(#21- 4&/$25%&- B;(#")5/>- - G;%- 5/3 (#5($%#5%- /7- ,25;- "- 1/#21%#*")- $%3 5(,(/#-eV2-(,-#/=-,%&:(#8-"-*%#-0%"&- 4&(,/#- ,%#*%#5%f9- 5",*,- 5/#,($%&"')%-
