IJCJS- Korespondensi -I Budiartha

(1)

Korespondensi Publikasi

Regulation Number 5 Of 2020 Concerning Standards for Organizing Balinese Cultural Tourism to Promote

Sustainable Village-Based Tourism

I Nyoman Putu Budiartha

Faculty of Law, Universitas Warmadewa, Denpasar, Bali, Indonesia

International Journal of Criminal Justice Science Vol 17 Issue 1 January – June 2022

• Pendaftaran akun ke jurnal: 05 November 2021: [IJCJS] [Confirmation Required]

Notification about your account creation at ManuscriptLink

• Submit Paper: 10 November 2021; [IJCJS] Acknowledgment of a new

manuscript submission.

• Keputusan Editor: 10 November 2021; [IJCJS] Acknowledgment of a new

manuscript submission

• Keputusan Editor: 17 January 2022: [IJCJS] Editor Decision

• Submit Revisi: 15 February 2022: [IJCJS] Acknowledgment of a manuscript

revision submission

• Keputusan Editor: 10 March 2022: [IJCJS] Editor Decision

• Submit Revisi: 28 March 2022: [IJCJS] Acknowledgment of a manuscript revision submission

• Keputusan Editor: 25 April 2022: [IJCJS] Editor Decision

(2)

I Nyoman Putu Budiartha <[email protected]>

[IJCJS] [Confirmation Required] Notification about your account creation at ManuscriptLink

1 message

IJCJS <[email protected]> Fri, Nov 05, 2021, at 12:44 PM To: I Nyoman Putu Budiartha<[email protected]>

Dear Dr. I Nyoman Putu Budiartha,

This mail is to let you know that your account (Signin ID: [email protected]) was created at the online manuscript submission and peer-review system of International Journal of Criminal Justice Sciences.

[NOTE] Before starting to use ManuscriptLink service, you need to confirm your email address (signin ID) by clicking the link below:

https://www.manuscriptlink.com/user/confirm/1e3514eb9fa24d43bba7g3f14173d7l8

Through the following link, you can access the online manuscript submission and peer-review system of International Journal of Criminal Justice Sciences

* Online System URL: https://www.manuscriptlink.com/journals/[email protected] In the ManuscriptLink online system,

* If you are an author of manuscript, you can submit a manuscript and keep a close watch over the on- going review process including the review history of past manuscripts.

* If you are a manager of a journal, you can create and manage a new journal submission and review service, and customize your service according to the demand of editorial members.

* If you are an editorial member of a journal, you can manage a review process for a submitted manuscript and enhance the academic value of the journal by accepting or rejecting publication of submitted manuscripts.

* If you are a reviewer of a journal, you can evaluate a submitted manuscript and send your review report to editorial members of the journal.

Best regards,

ManuscriptLink Support Team Email: [email protected] https://www.manuscriptlink.com Terms of Service and Privacy Policy

Terms of Service : https://www.manuscriptlink.com/docs/termsOfService Privacy Policy: https://www.manuscriptlink.com/docs/privacyPolicy

=============[Note]=============

This email is only for the delivery service.

Please do not reply to this mail.

(3)

IJCJS] Acknowledgment of a new manuscript submission

1 message

IJCJS <[email protected] Wed, Nov 10, 2021, at 02:22 AM To: I Nyoman Putu Budiartha<[email protected]>

Thank you for submitting the following manuscript to the International Journal of Criminal Justice Sciences.

Track: Regular Track

Title: Regulation Number 5 Of 2020 Concerning Standards for Organizing Balinese Cultural Tourism to Promote Sustainable Village-Based Tourism

Author(s): I Nyoman Putu Budiartha, I Made Suwitra, I Gusti Agung Ayu Gita Pritayanti Dinar, Anak Agung Sagung Laksmi Dewi, Rosino da Cruz, Cesaltina Angela Soares

Corresponding Author: I Nyoman Putu Budiartha

Affiliation of Corresponding Author: Faculty of Law, Universitas Warmadewa, Denpasar, Bali, Indonesia Date of Manuscript Submission: 10-November-2021 (UTC)

In a couple of days, a confirmation email including the manuscript ID will be again forwarded to you when the journal manager looks through your submission and confirms it. Further progress on your submission can be checked through the following online system.

* Online System URL: https://www.manuscriptlink.com/journals/ijcjs

If you have any question regarding your submission, please contact the journal editor-in-chief.

Best regards,

Journal Editor-in-Chief

International Journal of Criminal Justice Sciences Homepage: https://www.ijcjs.com

=============[Note]=============

(4)

[IJCJS] Editor Decision

1 message

IJCJS <[email protected]> Wed, Nov 10, 2021, at 09:15 AM To: I Nyoman Putu Budiartha<[email protected]>

Thank you for submitting the following manuscript to the International Journal of Criminal Justice Sciences.

Affiliation of Corresponding Author: Faculty of Law, Universitas Warmadewa, Denpasar, Bali, Indonesia

Date of Manuscript Submission: 10-November-2021 (UTC) The manuscript ID: IJCJS-367-2022

We have confirmed and forwarded your submission for reviewing process. Further progress on your submission can be checked through the following online system.

Best regards,

=============[Note]=============

(5)

[IJCJS] Editor Decision

1 message

IJCJS <[email protected]> Mon, Jan 17, 2022, at 02:54 PM To: I Nyoman Putu Budiartha<[email protected]>

We have reached a decision regarding your submission to the International Journal of Criminal Justice Sciences, "Highlighting the legislation concerning environmental protection and the promotion of sustainability within Indonesia".

Our decision is: Revisions Required

Please revise your manuscript based on reviewers' comments and suggestions accordingly and resubmit your revised manuscript no later than one month.

Let me know if you have any questions.

Best

=============[Note]=============

Please do not reply to this mail

--- Reviewer- A

Decision: Major revisions required

The research provides a comprehensive and informative overview of the Balinese laws and regulations related to tourism, as well as the importance of village-based tourism in Bali and Timor Leste. The paper could be further improved by adding a more critical analysis and synthesizing the findings from the different sources. Here are some specific suggestions for authors

1. The literature review must discuss two main themes: Balinese laws and regulations

related to tourism and village-based tourism in Bali and Timor Leste.

(6)

2. The review should provide a comprehensive overview of the Balinese laws and regulations related to tourism, including the most recent regulation enacted in 2020.

The author also needs to highlight the government's commitment to protecting Balinese nature and culture, which are considered the main resources of Bali's tourism industry.

3. Regarding village-based tourism, the authors are encouraged to highlight the importance of community participation in tourism development as a vital factor in economic growth, citing the Bali Provincial Regulation of 2015. The author should note that rural or village-based tourism is unique, rooted in local cultural traditions and nature, and enhances the development of local and rural communities.

4. The Results & conclusion should provide an overview of the legal framework for sustainable tourism in Bali, highlighting the importance of preserving Balinese cultural values and promoting responsible tourism practices.

5. The paper could also provide more information on the specific challenges and opportunities faced by each village in developing its tourism sector and explore how local communities are involved in decision-making processes related to tourism development.

--- Reviewer -B

Decision: Major revisions required

The study provides a clear and concise overview of the research field. Here are some more suggestions for authors

A. The abstract must include relevant keywords that can assist readers in identifying the focus of the study.

B. The introduction should provide a good background of the context of the study and highlights the importance of the Bali Provincial Regulation No. 5/2020 and the need for comparative research to develop village-based tourism destinations in Bali and Timor Leste.

C. The study could be more specific about the methods used in the study, as it only mentions a normative and empirical legal analysis without providing further details.

D. The authors could also provide more information on the findings of the study, especially in terms of how Bali Provincial Regulation No. 5/2020 compares with other regulations in neighboring countries.

E. Finally, the authors could benefit from a clearer statement on the implications of the study's findings for the tourism business in Bali and Timor Leste.

____________________________________________________________

(7)

[IJCJS] Acknowledgment of a manuscript revision submission

1 message

IJCJS <[email protected]> Tue, Feb 15, 2022, at 11:47 AM To: I Nyoman Putu Budiartha<[email protected]>

Thank you for submitting the following manuscript revision to the International Journal of Criminal Justice Sciences.

We have confirmed and forwarded your revision submission for reviewing process. Further progress on your submission can be checked through the following online system.

Best regards,

=============[Note]=============

(8)

Response to Reviewer 1

Sr.

No.

Reviewer's Comment Response

The research provides a comprehensive and informative overview of the Balinese laws and regulations related to tourism, as well as the importance of village-based tourism in Bali and Timor Leste. The paper could be further improved by adding a more critical analysis and synthesizing the findings from the different sources. Here are some specific suggestions for authors

Thanks a lot, dear reviewer, for your kind and detailed review.

1 The literature review must discuss two main themes: Balinese laws and regulations related to tourism and village-based tourism in Bali and Timor Leste.

Many thanks for your kind suggestions. In literature review we have now discuss two main themes: Balinese laws and regulations related to tourism and village-based tourism in Bali and Timor Leste.

Please see pages 5-7 2 The review should provide a

comprehensive overview of the Balinese laws and regulations related to tourism, including the most recent regulation enacted in 2020. The author also needs to highlight the government's commitment to protecting Balinese nature and culture, which are considered the main resources of Bali's tourism industry.

Dear reviewer, Thank you for your kind suggestions. The review now provides a comprehensive overview of the Balinese laws and regulations related to tourism, including the most recent regulation enacted in 2020. We have also highlighted the government's commitment to protecting Balinese nature and culture, which are considered the main resources of Bali's tourism industry.

Please see pages 5-11 3 Regarding village-based tourism, the

authors are encouraged to highlight the importance of community participation in

Dear reviewer, Thank you for your kind suggestions. Done as suggested

Please see page 9

(9)

Response to Reviewer 2

tourism development as a vital factor in economic growth, citing the Bali Provincial Regulation of 2015. The author should note that rural or village-based tourism is unique, rooted in local cultural traditions and nature, and enhances the development of local and rural communities.

4 The Results & conclusion should provide an overview of the legal framework for sustainable tourism in Bali, highlighting the importance of preserving Balinese cultural values and promoting responsible tourism practices.

Respected reviewer, Thank you.

Done as suggested Please see pages 16-18

5 The paper could also provide more information on the specific challenges and opportunities faced by each village in developing its tourism sector and explore how local communities are involved in decision-making processes related to tourism development.

Respected reviewer, Thank you Done as suggested

Please see page 19

Sr.

No.

Reviewer's Comment Response

The study provides a clear and concise overview of the research field. Here are some more suggestions for authors

Thanks a lot, dear reviewer.

1 The abstract must include relevant keywords that can assist readers in identifying the focus of the study.

Many thanks for your kind suggestions.

The abstract now includes relevant keywords

that can assist readers in identifying the focus

(10)

of the study.

Please see page 1 2 The introduction should provide a good

background of the context of the study and highlights the importance of the Bali Provincial Regulation No. 5/2020 and the need for comparative research to develop village-based tourism destinations in Bali and Timor Leste.

Dear reviewer, Thank you for your kind suggestions. In introduction we have now provide a good background of the context of the study and highlights the importance of the Bali Provincial Regulation No. 5/2020 and the need for comparative research to develop village-based tourism destinations in Bali and Timor Leste.

Please see page 3 3 The study could be more specific about the

methods used in the study, as it only mentions a normative and empirical legal analysis without providing further details.

Dear reviewer, Thank you for your kind suggestions. The study is now more specific about the methods used in the study, as it only mentions a normative and empirical legal analysis without providing further details.

Please see page 9 4 The authors could also provide more

information on the findings of the study, especially in terms of how Bali Provincial Regulation No. 5/2020 compares with other regulations in neighboring countries.

Dear reviewer, Thank you.

We have now provided more information on the findings of the study, especially in terms of how Bali Provincial Regulation No.

5/2020 compares with other regulations in neighboring countries.

Please see page 16 5 Finally, the authors could benefit from a

clearer statement on the implications of the study's findings for the tourism business in Bali and Timor Leste.

Done, dear reviewer. We have now clearly stated the implications of the study's findings for the tourism business in Bali and Timor Leste.

Please see page 20

(11)

[IJCJS] Editor Decision

1 message

IJCJS <[email protected]> Thu, Mar 10, 2022, at 11:22 AM To: I Nyoman Putu Budiartha<[email protected]>

We have reached a decision regarding your submission to the International Journal of Criminal Justice Sciences, " Regulation Number 5 Of 2020 Concerning Standards for Organizing Balinese Cultural Tourism to Promote Sustainable Village-Based Tourism."

Our decision is: Revisions Required

Please revise your manuscript based on the reviewers' comments and suggestions accordingly and resubmit your revised manuscript no later than one month.

Let me know if you have any questions.

Best

IJCJS-367-2022_review.docx 15Kb

=============[Note]=============

Please do not reply to this mail

---

(12)

[IJCJS] Acknowledgment of a manuscript revision submission

1 message

IJCJS <[email protected]> Mon, Mar 28, 2022, at 09:54 AM To: I Nyoman Putu Budiartha<[email protected]>

Thank you for submitting the following manuscript revision to the International Journal of Criminal Justice Sciences.

We have confirmed and forwarded your submission revision for reviewing process. Further progress on your submission can be checked through the following online system.

Best regards,

=============[Note]=============

(13)

Response to Reviewers

Sr.

No.

Reviewer's Comment Response

Reviewers recommended some minor changes as a second round of review. For instance,

Thanks a lot, dear reviewer.

1 The revised version of the manuscript provides a presentation of the research area, but there is room for improvement in terms of specificity and clarity.

Many thanks for your kind suggestions.

Done as suggested

2 The author should also discuss the negative impacts of tourism on Balinese culture and the environment and the need to restore and conserve them through tourist contributions.

Dear reviewer, Thank you for your kind comments. Now we have discussed the negative impacts of tourism on Balinese culture and the environment and the need to restore and conserve them through tourist contributions.

Please see pages 16-17 3 Additionally, the paper could benefit from

a more in-depth discussion of the impact of natural disasters on tourism in Bali and Timor Leste, including the measures taken by governments and communities to mitigate its effects.

Dear reviewer, Thank you for your kind suggestions. We have now conducted a more in-depth discussion of the impact of natural disasters on tourism in Bali and Timor Leste, including the measures taken by governments and communities to mitigate its effects.

Please see pages 19-21

(14)

[IJCJS] Editor Decision

1 message

IJCJS <[email protected]> Mon, Apr 25, 2022, at 11:10 AM To: I Nyoman Putu Budiartha<[email protected]>

Congratulations! t

he following of your manuscript.

Has been accepted for publication in International Journal of Criminal Justice Sciences (Vol. 17 No. 1, 2022). Thank you for your interest in our journal. Your Journal paper would be indexed in Scopus (Elsevier), Google Scholar, Scirus, GetCited, Scribd, so on.

We look forward to receiving your subsequent research papers.

Best regards,

=============[Note]=============