• Tidak ada hasil yang ditemukan

PROSIDING Judul Karya Ilmiah : Kaji Eksperimental Peng

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2023

Membagikan "PROSIDING Judul Karya Ilmiah : Kaji Eksperimental Peng"

Copied!
21
0
0

Teks penuh

(1)

LEMBAR

HASIL PENILAIAN SEJAWAT SEBIDANG ATAU PEER REVIEW KARYA ILMIAH : PROSIDING

Judul Karya Ilmiah : Kaji Eksperimental Pengaruh Bentuk Geometri Sudut Converging Duct dan Panjang Constant-Area Section Pada Performa Sistem Refrigerasi Steam Ejector

Jumlah Penulis : 3

Status Pengusul : Penulis ke-3

Identitas Prosiding : a. Judul Prosiding : Prosiding Seminar Nasional Sains dan Teknologi 4

b. ISBN/ISSN : 978-602-99334-2-0 c. Thn Terbit, Tempat Pelaks. : 2013, Semarang

d. Penerbit/Organiser : Fakultas Teknik Universitas Wahid Hasyim Semarang

e. Alamat Repository/Web : KWWSVSXEOLNDVLLOPLDKXQZDKDVDFLGLQGH[SKS 3526,',1*B6167B)7DUWLFOHYLHZ Alamat Artikel : KWWSVSXEOLNDVLLOPLDKXQZDKDVDFLGLQGH[SKS

3526,',1*B6167B)7DUWLFOHYLHZ f. Terindeks di (jika ada) : Google Scholar

Kategori Publikasi Makalah : Prosiding Forum Ilmiah Internasional (beri pada kategori yang tepat) √ Prosiding Forum Ilmiah Nasional Hasil Penilaian Peer Review :

Komponen Yang Dinilai

Nilai Maksimal Prosiding

Nilai Akhir Yang Diperoleh Internasional Nasional

a. Kelengkapan unsur isi prosiding (10%) 1 1

b. Ruang lingkup dan kedalaman pembahasan (30%)

3 2 c. Kecukupan dan kemutahiran data/informasi dan

metodologi (30%)

3 2,5 d. Kelengkapan unsur dan kualitas terbitan

/prosiding (30%)

3 2,5

Total = (100%) 10 8,0

Nilai Pengusul = 40% x 8 /2 = 1.6

Catatan Penilaian Paper oleh Reviewer :

1. Kesesuaian dan kelengkapan unsur isi prosiding:

Artikel terdiri dari: Judul, Abstrak, Pendahuluan, Metoda Penelitian, Hasil dan Pembahasan, Kesimpulan dan daftar pustaka dan ditulis sesuai dengan Guide for Author. Substansi artikel merupakan salah satu bidang fokus Teknik Mesin

2. Ruang lingkup dan kedalaman pembahasan:

Artikel membahas tentang penelitian ejektor untuk aplikasi mesin pendingin. Sudut entrainment pada ejektor mempengaruhi entrainment ratio dan akan mempengaruhi performansi mesin pendingin. Data yang ditampilkan sebenarnya cukup baik, hanya tidak dibahas secara komprehensif.

Tabel 1 juga hanya ditampilkan dan tidak dibahas dalam artikel ini.

3. Kecukupan dan kemutakhiran data/infrmasi dan metodologi:

Jumlah referensi dalam 10 tahun terakhir hanya sebanyak 1 dari 6 artikel (16.7%). Tingkat kebaruan menjadi kurang. Metode penelitian dituliskan cukup lengkap, set-up peralatan uji dijelaskan dengan gambar dan informasi deskriptif yang cukup baik.

4. Kelengkapan unsur dan kualitas terbitan:

Prosiding diterbitkan oleh Fakultas Teknik Universitas Wahid Hasyim Semarang. Peserta sebanyak 87. Kualitas terbitan cukup baik untuk kategori proseding seminar nasional dan article dapat diunduh secara online dan konsisten serta dilengkapi dengan petunjuk penulisan yang jelas. Nilai similaritas artikel berdasarkan Turnitin sebesar 9%.

(2)

Semarang, 24 Maret 2020 Reviewer 1

Prof. Dr. Mohammad Djaeni, S.T., M.Eng.

NIP. 197102071995121001

Unit Kerja : Fakultas Teknik Universitas Diponegoro

Bidang Ilmu : Teknik Kimia

(3)

LEMBAR

HASIL PENILAIAN SEJAWAT SEBIDANG ATAU PEER REVIEW KARYA ILMIAH : PROSIDING

Judul Karya Ilmiah : Kaji Eksperimental Pengaruh Bentuk Geometri Sudut Converging Duct dan Panjang Constant-Area Section Pada Performa Sistem Refrigerasi Steam Ejector

Jumlah Penulis : 3

Status Pengusul : Penulis ke-3

Identitas Prosiding : a. Judul Prosiding : Prosiding Seminar Nasional Sains dan Teknologi 4

b. ISBN/ISSN : 978-602-99334-2-0

c. Thn Terbit, Tempat Pelaks. : 2013, Semarang

d. Penerbit/Organiser : Fakultas Teknik Universitas Wahid Hasyim Semarang

e. Alamat Repository/Web : KWWSVSXEOLNDVLLOPLDKXQZDKDVDFLGLQGH[SKS 3526,',1*B6167B)7DUWLFOHYLHZ Alamat Artikel : KWWSVSXEOLNDVLLOPLDKXQZDKDVDFLGLQGH[SKS

3526,',1*B6167B)7DUWLFOHYLHZ f. Terindeks di (jika ada) : Google Scholar

Kategori Publikasi Makalah : Prosiding Forum Ilmiah Internasional (beri 3pada kategori yang tepat) — Prosiding Forum Ilmiah Nasional Hasil Penilaian Peer Review :

Komponen Yang Dinilai

Nilai Maksimal Prosiding

Nilai Akhir Yang Diperoleh Internasional Nasional

a. Kelengkapan unsur isi prosiding (10%) 1 1,00

b. Ruang lingkup dan kedalaman pembahasan

(30%) 3 2,50

c. Kecukupan dan kemutahiran data/informasi dan

metodologi (30%) 3 2,50

d. Kelengkapan unsur dan kualitas terbitan /prosiding (30%)

3 2,25

Total = (100%) 10 8,25

Nilai Pengusul = 40% x 8,25 / 2 = 1,65 Catatan Penilaian artikel oleh Reviewer :

1. Kesesuaian dan kelengkapan unsur isi prosiding:

Artikel ditulis sesuai dengan kaidah penulisan suatu artikel ilmiah pada prosiding.

2. Ruang lingkup dan kedalaman pembahasan:

Ruang lingkup cukup jelas. Pembahasan cukup.

3. Kecukupan dan kemutakhiran data/informasi dan metodologi:

Data cukup. Metodologi cukup jelas.

4. Kelengkapan unsur dan kualitas terbitan:

Prosiding Seminar Nasional Sains dan Teknologi 4 termasuk prosiding nasional. Sehingga nilai AK maksimum 10. Ybs sebagai penulis ketiga dari 3 penulis sehingga nilai maksimum = ½ x 40% x 10 = 2.

Surakarta, 9 Maret 2020 Reviewer 2

Prof. Dr. techn. Suyitno, S.T., M.T.

NIP. 197403262000031001

Unit Kerja : Fakultas Teknik Universitas Sebelas Maret Bidang Ilmu : Teknik Mesin

—

Surakarta, 9 Maret 2020 Reviewer er er er er r r r r r r r r r r r r r r r r r r r r r r r r r r r r r r r r r r r r r r r r r 2

Pro of f f. f. f. f. f. f f. f f. f f. f f f. f. f f. f f f f. f f f. f f f. . . . . . D D D D D D D D D D D D D D D D D D D D D D D D D D D D D D D D D D D D D D D Dr r r r r r r r r r r r. r r r r r r r r r r t te te te te t te te te te te te te te te t te te t te t te te te tec e e e e e e e e e ch ch ch ch ch ch ch ch ch ch ch ch ch ch ch ch ch ch ch ch ch ch ch ch ch c ch ch ch ch ch ch ch c c ch c ch chn h h h h n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n. Suyitno, NI

NI NI I N N NI NI NI NI NI NI NI NI N NI NI NI NI NI NI NI NI N N NI NI N N NI N N N NI N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N

N P P P. P P P P P 19740 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 32620000310

Unit K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K Ker er er er r r r r r r r r r r r r r r r r r r r r r r r r r r r r r rja ja j j j j j j j j j j ja j j j j ja ja ja j j j j j j j j j j j j j j j j j j j j j j j : Fakultas T

Bidang I I Ilmu : Teknik M

(4)

KWWSVVFKRODUJRRJOHFRPVFKRODU"KO HQ DVBVGW & T .DML(NVSHULPHQWDO3HQJDUXK%HQWXN*HRPHWUL6XGXW&RQYHUJLQJ'XFWGDQ3«

06XEUL768WRPR%)7.3URVLGLQJ6167«SXEOLNDVLLOPLDKXQZDKDVDFLG 5HIULJHUDVLVWHDPHMHFWRUPHUXSDNDQVLVWHPUHIULJHUDVLGHQJDQPHPDQIDDWNDQOLPEDK SDQDVVHEDJDLVXPEHUHQHUJLXWDPDQ\D6WHDPHMHFWRUEHUSHUDQVHEDJDLSHQJJDQWL NRPSUHVRUSDGDVLNOXVNRPSUHVLXDS5HIULJHUDVLVWHDPHMHFWRUPHPLOLNLNRHILVLHQNLQHUMD

&RHILVLHQRISHUIRUPDQFH&23\DQJUHQGDKVHKLQJJDSHUOXGLODNXNDQSHQHOLWLDQ NDUDNWHULVWLNGHQJDQPHPEXDWGHVDLQJHRPHWULVWHDPHMHFWRUXQWXNPHPSHUEDLNLGDQ PHQJRSWLPDONDQNLQHUMDGDULVWHDPHMHFWRUQ\D.LQHUMDVWHDPHMHFWRUGDSDWGLOLKDWGDUL«

&LWHGE\ 5HODWHGDUWLFOHV $OOYHUVLRQV

6KRZLQJWKHEHVWUHVXOWIRUWKLVVHDUFK6HHDOOUHVXOWV

.$-,(.63(5,0(17$/3(1*$58+%(178.*(20(75,68'87&219(5*,1*

'8&7'$13$1-$1*&2167$17$5($6(&7,213$'$3(5)250$«

(5)

FRYHUBLVVXHBBHQB86MSJî

KWWSVSXEOLNDVLLOPLDKXQZDKDVDFLGSXEOLFMRXUQDOVFRYHUBLVVXHBBHQB86MSJ

(6)

KWWSVSXEOLNDVLLOPLDKXQZDKDVDFLGLQGH[SKS3526,',1*B6167B)7LVVXHYLHZVKRZ7RF

12(0,1740$.5;56(/5 ,1740$.+(.2 75(4

7UGTPCOG 2CUUYQTF

4GOGODGTOG /RJLQ

/RJLQ

016á)á&$6á105 8KGY 5WDUETKDG

,1740$.&106(06 5GCTEJ

5GCTEJ5EQRG

$OO 6HDUFK 6HDUFK

%TQYUG

%[áUUWG

%[$WVJQT

%[6KVNG 1VJGT,QWTPCNU

&CVGIQTKGU )1065á<(

á0)14/$6á10 )QT4GCFGTU )QT$WVJQTU )QT.KDTCTKCPU

|

|

|

|

|

|

|

|

|

| +1/( $%176 .1*á0 4(*á56(4 &$6(*14á(5 5($4&+ &744(06 $4&+á8(5

+QOG!$TEJKXGU!8QN0Q

7^Z|’"^|£}{|~¤

3526,',1*6(0,1$51$6,21$/6$,16'$17(.12/2*,

/GODCPIWP5KUVGOFCP6GMPQNQIKáPHQTOCUKWPVWM/GPKPIMCVMCP'C[C5CKPI%CPIUCFK(TC*NQDCNKUCUK á5%0

1=EZJ^O^\lJ\lj

ilRFZJj

2(0*$47+9$-676(4+$'$2-$0'70*$0*.7-15$2$'$4($-5á+á'41.á5$(0<á/$6á5 '$70$2á$2á$XGEGPPKCCNDC'(0*$0/(0**70$-$05(.7.$5(

5[CKHWN4QÕMáPFCJ4KYC[CVK

$2')

126á/$.á5$5á.á/%$+5(4%7--$;7/(0,$'á%á1(6$01.5(%$*$á(0(4*á$.6(40$6á) 6(4%$47-$0/(0**70$-$0'á56á.$5á*(.1/%$0*/á-41

'GFF[-WTPKCYCP9KMCPVC)CJOK$TKHCP.WVJÕCPC$\OK1MVKU[C'GXK9KF[CPKPIUKJ4GOKVC5GRVTKCPK 2KPCPFKVC4GM[CP*WRKVC$PKU5KVK0WTLCPPCJ

$2')

2(0*$47+2(0$/%$+$0:+$06$0*7/'$.$/$2.á-$5á6(-01.1*á('á%.(&1$6á0*

$.1(8(4$7067-/(/2(46$+$0-$0/76761/$651.$07/.;&12(45á&7/

/(0**70$-$0/(61'(524$;

+KFC[CVWN/CUTWTQJ$EJOCF)CTKVU)CW\K'YK$PIIT[CPK58KVC2CTCOKVC

$2')

4(-$;$5$2415(52(/%7$6$05(4%7-2(9$40$%$6á-%á1'(*4$'$%.(%(4%$+$0

$0615á$0á0.á/%$+-7.á66(410*%(.$0'$&J[RQOCPFTCDGVCEGC'(0*$0-1/%á0$5á (-564$-5á*(.1/%$0*7.64$510á-'$0$37$51.8(06

;QIC$UOCTC$LK%C[W-5GRVKCP$FK*2)CLCT$KPKáUVK2WFLKJCUVWVK

$2')

2(/%7$6$02$0*$06(40$-.(.(14*$0á-%(4%$+$0%$-72416(á0'$4á%7.7$;$/

'(0*$0/(61'()(4/(06$5á%á1

$\KU$PFTG'YK$NCOU[CJ,QFF[&JTKUV[CYCP$IPGU2TKUMC6KCTCUWMOC8KVC2CTCOKVC

$2')

2(4%('$$09$-67)(4/(06$5á'$.$/2(/%7$6$06(+-1/%7&+$'$4á(-564$-6(+

+á,$7.1-$.$TTCEC-KCTC$TTCEC;CDWMKVC2GMQG'$0'GYCVC5(%$*$á/á07/$0 )70*5á10$.7067-$06á1-5á'$0

$IWUVKPG5WUKNQYCVK

$2')

$.6(40$6á)(0<á/á07.á0$5('$4á-$2$0*(0'1)á6+$5á.á51.$5á-7.á67/%á'$+.á$

/(4$+'CJNKCURR.1-$.'$0$2.á-$5á0;$5(%$*$á57/%(4(0<á/á07.á0$5(7067- 2(41.(+$05(4$6á07.á0

$IWUVKPG5WUKNQYCVK

$2')

$'51425á.1*$/%(4$62D'$.$/.$476$0/(0**70$-$05(0;$9$:$06+$6(,(4$/á 2$'á

<CJTQJ(N%CKFJQ6KUC.C\WCTF[5QHC4QJOCPKCáPFCJ+CTVCVK

$2')

21.$'á5(/á0$5á2(0*(.1.$$06$0$/$06(42$'72$'á'á2418á05á-(27.$7$0%$0*-$

%(.á670*

/WJCOOCF)CLTK/KPCU62CPIICDGCP/COKM5CTYGPFCJ

$2')

á018$5á%4190á(5È%GG6QHWÉ(/2$65(+$6.á/$5(/2740$5(%$*$á&(/á.$0;$0*

4(0'$+-$.14á%$*á2(0'(4á6$'á$%(6(5/(..á675

$OCNKC2TKVC[CPVK+GTNCPK5KVK+KFC[CPVK6JQ[KD+CPKHCP5[WJCFC+GP[-WUWOC[CPVK

$2')

2(0(4$2$0$.$6)1612$56(74á5$5á787067-/(0á0*-$6-$0/767241'7-5á5(.$á '$0,$/%7$+,$/%7/(6('á'(5$*$274$*$;$/67-.7-0*$'á41,19101*á4á

$DFWNNCJ4KFJYCP2WTPQOQ$FKUVK2WVTKáPVCPKCUCTK9KPFC-TKUVKCPC/(PF[;WNKCPVQ

$2')

+7%70*$02(-(4,$$06(/2$66á0**$.'(0*$06á0*-$6-(/$6$0*$0-$6$4$- 'KFKM9CJ[WFK4KPC[CVK4KPC[CVK$ODCT'YK(TCYCVK

%2')

216(05á&+á611.á*15$&&+$4á'(&155(%$*$á24(%á16á-'$02(0*$9(6$.$/á'$.$/ %2')

(7)

9RO1R

KWWSVSXEOLNDVLLOPLDKXQZDKDVDFLGLQGH[SKS3526,',1*B6167B)7LVVXHYLHZVKRZ7RF

2(/%7$6$06$+75á0%á16á-

$IPGU5TK+CTVK$PKU0WTJKFC[CVK'GUK+CPFC[CPK

6(/2(%(-$67.-á615$05(%$*$á%á1572.(/(024(%á16á-5(+$6$.$/á%$*áá%7+$/á.

$NFKNC2WLK0WITQJQáMC/WTPK9(MC4GHVKCPC<$IPGU5TK+CTVK

%2')

+7%70*$0$06$4$-$'$4+(/1*.1%á0'(0*$024(56$5á%(.$,$4/$+$5á59$241*4$/

567'á'ááá-(%á'$0$056á-(59á';$+75$'$5(/$4$0*6$+70

*KVC$OCNNKC0WTáUVKSQOCJ4KPC[CVK4KPC[CVK&JWUPWN<WNCKMC'KFKM9CJ[WFK

%2')

()(-/(6$01.-$'$44(0'$+6(4+$'$2()á5á(05á6(4/$./(5á0'á(5(.á0,(-5á .$0*570*'(0*$05á56(/(*4

5WIGPI5WIGPI5[CKHWN5[CKHWN

&2')

()(-2(/$-$á$0.19274á6;/(6+$01.6(4+$'$2-(2(-$6$0$5$25/1-(12$&á6;

2$'$/(5á0'á(5(.'(0*$05á56(/(*4 4KC%CICU5[CKHWN5[CKHWN

&2')

$0$.á5$07/(4á-$.á4$0'7$)$5$'$.$/8(0674á5&47%%(4 6QOO[+GPFCTVQ5[CKHWN5[CKHWN/5-6QP[5WT[Q

&2')

-$,á(-52(4á/(06$.674%á0$0*á0/7.6á%.$'(6á2(57'7).$6(2.$6(5(%$*$á 2(0**(4$-/7.$21/2$$á4

;WUWH'GYCPVQTQ+GTNCODCPI

&2')

2(0*$47+6(/2(4$674%$+$0%$-$4%á151.$4'$051.$4'(:6(4+$'$270,7--(4,$

/1614'á(5(.276$4$0-1056$0 0WITCJ4GMVQ2TCDQYQ

&2')

4(-$;$5$%(067-57'7674%á02(.6107067-5á56(/2(/%$0*-á6.á564á-6(0$*$

/á-41+á'41

%QPQ%QPQ

&2')

567'á(-52(4á/(06$.$.á4$0&$/274$0$á4&47'(1á./(.(9$6á2á2$2(0*(&á.$0 /(0'$'$-+14á<106$.%(42(0$/2$0*.á0*-$4$0

(ÖKVC;QJCPC$ODCPICP5KTGICT$UVTKF$[WVCUCTK$FK-WTPKC/WMVCDCT)CVKJ-JCOFCPK

&2')

()(-/(6+$01.-$'$44(0'$+6(4+$'$2()á5á(05á6+(4/$./(5á0'á(5(.á0,(-5á .$0*570*'(0*$05á56(/+16(*4/(0**70$-$0&$/274$0%$+$0%$-$4%á151.$4 '$0,$6412+$

;CÕF(àGPFK5[CKHWN5[CKHWN

&2')

/1'(.21/2$$á4'(0*$06(0$*$$0*á07067-2(/$0)$$6$0á4á*$5á5$9$+

%GPP[5[CJRWVTC

&2')

-$,á(-52(4á/(06$.2(0*$47+%(067-*(1/(64á57'76&108(4*á0*'7&6'$02$0,$0*

&1056$06$4($5(&6á102$'$2(4)14/$5á56(/4()4á*(4$5á56($/(,(&614 /WJCOOCF5WDTK6QP[5WT[Q7VQOQ%GTMCJ)CLCT6-

&2')

-$,á$0/1614$4755($4$+6$02$5á-$6985(%$*$á2(0**(4$-/1%á..á564á- /CTICPCOCTICPC

&2')

2(/$0)$$6$0.á/%$+-á.$0*/á0;$-/)1E5V;$0*'á(0&(4-$0'(0*$051.$4 5(%$*$á%$+$0%$-$4$.6(40$6á)2(0**$06á51.$42$'$'4;-á.0á0'7564á-(&á.

*$4$/'(5$-$.á14á-$%72$6(04(/%$0*,$9$6(0*$+

áN[CU4QEJCPK

&2')

$0$.á5$-(47*á$0-$.145(46$5á5$7/7412(4$5á-(475$-$0á51.$5á2á2$7$2 á0'7564á2415(5

+CTK[QVGLQ2WLQYKFQFQ

&2')

-$4$-6(4á5$5á-1/215á6'$4á5(4%7-*(4*$,á-$;75$9'756'(0*$02415(5 +1624(555(%$*$á%$+$0%$-72$2$02$46á-(.

5WIGPI5NCOGV

'2')

$0$.á5$2(0á0*-$6$05á)$6/(-$0á-/$6(4á$.4á0*2á5610612-1/24(5á;$/$+$

,72á6(4<'(0*$02415(5+($664($6/(06

+GTCYCP(XC-TKUFKCPVQ5QNGEJCP5QNGEJCP5COUWFK4CJCTLQ

'2')

2(0á0*-$6$0-7$.á6$5/$6$2á5$7%$,$/(5á0&475+(42.$56á-'(0*$02415(5+($6 64($6/(06/(.$.7á%$,$)$5$*$0'$

)CKUJQN/WJCOOCF5COUWFK4CJCTLQ5QNGEJCP5QNGEJCP

'2')

567'á2(0*$47+014/$.á5á0*6(4+$'$2-$4$-6(4á56á-'$05á)$6/(-$0á-

5$/%70*$0.$55/$92$'$2.$6,á55/%/(0**70$-$0(.(-641'$('$0(

/WJCOOCF4QOFJQP5QNGEJCP5QNGEJCP5COUWFK4CJCTLQ

'2')

$0$.á5$2(0*$47+,$4$-'$0-('$.$/$06(4+$'$20á.$á6$+$0$02(/%7/á$0 '(0*$0(.(-641'$%$6$0*

9CJ[QPQ9CJ[QPQ%WFJK2TCUGVK[Q

'2')

2(0*$47+8$4á$5á%$+$06(4+$'$25á)$6)á5á5'$05á)$6/(-$0á5-12.á0**(5(- 5(2('$/1614'(0*$0%$+$0'$5$4)á%(4*.$555(4%7-$.7/70á7/5(4%7-6(/%$*$

'$04(5á02+(01.á&

'2') -$,$ á (-52(4á/(06$. 2(0*$47+ %(067-*(1/(64á 57'76 &108(4*á0* '7&6 '$02$0,$0*

&1056$06$4($ 5(&6á102$'$ 2(4)14/$ 5á56(/ 4()4á*(4$5á 56($/ (,( (&614 /WJCOOCF 5WDTKT 6QP[P 5WT[T Q 7VQOQQ %GTMTT CJ )C)) LCC T 6-

(8)

KWWSVSXEOLNDVLLOPLDKXQZDKDVDFLGLQGH[SKS3526,',1*B6167B)7LVVXHYLHZVKRZ7RF

2TCOWMQáNOW2WTDQRWVTQ4CJOCV-WUWOC

$0$.á5$2(0*$47+2$&-&$4%74á<á0*/(0**70$-$0$4$0*/.$0'á0*7067- /(0á0*-$6-$05á)$6/(-$0á55241-(65(2('$/161457<7-á

/CUÆCF/CUÆCF/WJ$OKP5QNGEJCP5QNGEJCP

'2')

2(0á0*-$6$0-(-(4$5$05+$)62$'$*($427/2.1-$.'(0*$02415(5+($6 64($6/(06

/KPCTFK/KPCTFK/WJ$OKP5QNGEJCP5QNGEJCP

'2')

567'á2(0á0*-$6$05á)$6/(-$0á55241-(6á/á6$5á5724$'(0*$05á56á/2$&- -$4%74á5á0*

&CJ[C2WVTC.GNCPC5QNGEJCP5QNGEJCP5COUWFK4CJCTLQ

'2')

$0$.á5$2(0**70$$06(/27470*-(.$2$7067-/(0á0*-$6-$0-(-(4$5$0%$+$0 2á5$76á/%$0*$0/(,$'(0*$02415(52$&-&$4%74á<á0*

$TKH(MQ/WN[CPVQ4WDKLCPVQ,WPK2TKDCFK5QNGEJCP5QNGEJCP

'2')

4(-$;$5$'$0/$07)$-6744$0'1/&1&1076)á%(4&1/215á6(5%(4/$64á-(21:;

7067-2$0(.á06(4á14$761/16á8(

$IWU+CTK[CPVQ9CJ[W)KVTKCPVQ

'2')

2(0*(/%$0*$0/$6(4á$.5(/(0%(4%$+$0'$5$4á05á0(4$5á.á/%$+47/$+5$-á6 '(0*$06(-01.1*á+á'416(4/$.

$FG4COQU)GTFKPCPF$IWU6TK2TCUGV[Q$VJCPCUKWU2TKJCT[QVQ%C[WUGPQ

'2')

2(0*$47+21569(.'+($664($6/(06'$0$4$+2(0*(.$5$06á*670*56(0á0(46*$5 6(4+$'$25á)$6/(-$0á-'$05647-674/á-412$'$2(0;$/%70*$0$.7/á0á7/

2$'7$0

5QH[CP$DFKNNCJ*WPCYCP'YK+CTK[CFK$2%C[WUGPQ5GQP,KP-KO

'2')

567'á/(6$.1*4$)á+$5á.2(0*(.$5$052169(.'á0*6á2(-108(05á10$.'$0 2(0$/%$+$0*$5$4*10

/WJ$NHCVKJ+GPFTCYCP6WVWT$PIIC-WUWOC

'2')

*;257/5(%$*$á/$6(4á$.$.6(40$6á)7067-/(/%7$6&(6$-$02.$56á-á0,(-5á

%CODCPI-WUYCPVQ

'2')

2(/%(067-$0-(4$--$.5á7/-$4%10$6&C&1'$.$/2á2$%(4$.á4$0.$/á0(4 '(0*$02$4$/(6(4-105(064$5á.$476$0'$02(0$/%$+$0$'á6á)$5$//$.$6

,QVJQ,QVJQ$2%C[W5GPQ5VGHCPWU/WT[CPVQ

'2')

2(/%(067-$0-(4$--$.5á7/-$4%10$6&C&1'á'$.$/2á2$%(4$.á4$0.$/á0(4 2$'$.$,7$.á4ONOGPKV+á0**$ONOGPKV'$02(0$/%$+$0$'á6á)$5$//$.$6

+KU[CO/CÆOWP$2%C[WUGPQ5/WT[CPVQ

'2')

2(/%(067-$0-(4$--$.5á7/-$4%10$6&C&1'$.$/2á2$$.á4$0.$/á0(42$'$

6(/2(4$674&+á0**$&'$02(0$/%$+$0$'á6á)$5$//$.$6 /WJCOOCF7UCOCJ$2%C[WUGPQ5/WT[CPVQ

'2')

2(0*$47+2(4.$-7$0$0á.6(4+$'$25á)$6/(-$0á5'$05647-674/á-412$'$

5$/%70*$0.$52á2$%$,$<

+GTW'CPCTDTQVQ$2%C[W5GPQ*WPCYCP'YK+CT[CFK5GQP,KP-KO

'2')

4$0&$0*%$0*702(/$0$5á0'7-5á%(4-$2$5á6$597067-2415(52(4.$-7$0 2$0$5'$02(4.$-7-$02(4/7-$$0

9CJ[W2WTYQ4CJCTLQ%CODCPI-WUJCTLCPVC

'2')

2(4$0&$0*$0/(5á02(.7-+7*/$&+á0(5(%$*$á2(4$0*-$66(4$2á$76á5/(

$YCP4CUYCP5WOCT+CFK5WT[Q,COCTK,COCTKáUOQ[Q+CT[CPVQ

'2')

2(4$0&$0*$0$76á5//1%á.(5($67067-$.$6%$0676(4$2á$76á5/(

*QUVUC-JWUPWP0CWHCN$YCP4CUYCP5WOCT+CFK5WT[Q,COCTK,COCTKáUOQ[Q+CT[CPVQ

'2')

2(4$0&$0*$0/(5á02(/(.7-+7*/$&+á0(,(0á5á0).$6á0*94$27067-$.$6%$067 6(4$2á$76á5/(

5WOCT+CFK5WT[Q$YCP4CUYCP,COCTK,COCTKáUOQ[Q+CT[CPVQ

'2')

4$0&$0*%$0*70/(5á02(0&(6$-2$8á0*%.1&-'(0*$0-$2$5á6$5%7$+2$8á0*

%.1&-6á$22(0*(24(5$0

%CODCPI5KPIIKJ+CTFLWPQ%CODCPI6LCJLQPQ%QPQ%QPQ&CTNK&CTNK0CPCPI%WFK5TK[CPVQ

(2')

'á5$á02(/%7$6$0'$02(0*7,á$0'á(55$5á5/1%á./á0á647-(5(/-$

%CODCPI9CNW[Q)GDTKCPVQMQ

(2')

2(4$0&$0*$0$.$62(4$,$0*7/%á7/%á$0'(0*$0/(61'(37$.á6;)70&6á10 '(8(.12/(063)'

0WPKPI$TVCVK5WVCTPQ5WVCTPQ0WITCJ4GMVQ2TCDQYQ

(2')

2(0*7-74$0%7'$;$14*$0á5$5á2$'$á0'7564á/á07/$0'á,$9$6(0*$+7067- /(0á0*-$6-$0'$;$5$á0*'á(4$*.1%$.

+CPPC.GUVCTK$PFK4CJCFKCP9KLC[C5WDC[Q5WDC[Q

(2')

$0$.á5$ 2(4%$á-$0 /(5á0 &0& /$ '(0*$0 /(0**70$-$0 á0'á-$614 -á0(4,$ 18(4$.. ( 2')

(9)

9RO1R

KWWSVSXEOLNDVLLOPLDKXQZDKDVDFLGLQGH[SKS3526,',1*B6167B)7LVVXHYLHZVKRZ7RF

$0$.á5$2(4%$á-$0/(5á0&0&/$'(0*$0/(0**70$-$0á0'á-$614-á0(4,$18(4$..

(37á2/(06())(&6á8(0(551((

4CVPCPVQ)KVTKCFK*CPECPI%C[W-WPEQTQ

( 2')

2(0*$/%á.$0-(27675$0'$.$/2(/á.á+$02(/$51-*$.10'(0*$0 /(0**70$-$0/(61'()7<<;$+2567'á-$575'á26%;05$/$4á0'$

)CEJTKCJ)CEJTKCJ+2)CVMJWN+CPK4'WVJQ5WJ7VQOQ

(2')

126á/$5á5á56(/2(.$;$0$0%10*-$4/7$62(6á-(/$5'á2(.$%7+$06$0,70*(/$5 5(/$4$0*'(0*$0/1'(.5á/7.$5á$064á$0

5KUYCFK5KUYCFKáOCP/WLKCTVQ

(2')

2(0*(/%$0*$0/(61'(2(0*(&14$0537((<(7067-/(0á0*-$6-$0-7$.á6$55(2$67 -$/2$54(/-(0'$4$$0%(4/1614%(4%$+$0$.7/7á07/'$747.$0*

'CTOCPVQ'CTOCPVQ+GNO[2WTYCPVQ5TK/WN[Q%QPFCP4GURCVK

(2')

$0$.á5$-(27$5$0/$+$5á59$6(4+$'$29(%5á6(70á8(45á6$50(*(4á;1*;$-$46$

70;

9CJKFKP$DDCU

)2')

á/2.(/(06$6á101)81á&(4(&1*0á6á106(&+01.1*;10(0*.á5+.($40á0*

$22.á&$6á10%;5(.).($40á0*%$5('10$0'41á''(8á&(

'GTYKP5WJCTVQPQ&CNXKP&CNXKP/GT[;WUVKPC5JCPF[-WTPKCYCVK+CT[QPQ5QGRCTPQ)TGF[2WTPQOQ

)2')

567'(065.($40á0*&(06(4564$6(*;%$5('10(.($40á0*$0'%.1*5 .GQP$PFTGVVK$DFKNNCJ

)2')

2(/1'(.$056$0'$45á56(/á0)14/$5á2$'$2(4*747$06á0**á'áá0'10(5á$

&WM6JQ/GKNKCPC/GKNKCPC4QUOKPC4QUOKPC

)2')

4$0&$0*%$0*705á56(/á0)14/$5á.$%14$614á7/5á.$%%(4%$5á59(%'á6(-0á- á0)14/$6á-$7051('

.CUOGFK$HWCPáRWPI2GTOCFK

)2')

2(0*(/%$0*$0(-7.á0(4-16$-72$0*

;GTOKCU,á.GWJQG$ND,QMQ5CPVQUQ(FWCTF4WUFKCPVQ

)2')

$2.á-$5á5(05142$55á8(á0)4$4('2á47067-2(0'(6(-5á$0/$-+.7-+á'72'$.$/

47$0*

%WUVCPWN$TKÕP

)2')

5+$4á0*'$6$$06$4$.á07:'$09á0'195'(0*$0,$4á0*$02((4612((4 5CTK0QQTNKOC;CPVK'JCTOC[CPVK'JCTOC[CPVK/WJCOCFáMDCN

)2')

(.($40á0*%$+$5$á0**4á5-15$-$6$'$5$47067-$0$-24$5(-1.$+%(4%$5á5 /7.6á/('á$

2CTPQ2CTPQ(UVK5GVK[CPKPIUKJ)CFN[)CVCJ

)2')

5(%7$+6á0,$7$06(4+$'$26(-01.1*á$-7á5á5á'$6$'$02(/$06$7$0,$4$-,$7+

$TKGH+GPFTC5CRVCFK

)2')

$2.á-$5á76á.á6$54$0'1/'$.$/2(0*+á670*$00á.$á(-101/á6(4+$'$22(47%$+$0 -7$.á6$52$4á9á5$6$'á1%;(-9á5$6$%7-á6&á06$-$%72$6(05(/$4$0*

5TK5WDCPVK4CTC5WIKCTVK(PFCPI9KFK[CUVWVK$TKH4CJOCP+CMKO

)2')

2(0*$47+/$*0(62(4/$0(05(%$*$á2(0*7$6/('$0/$*0(62$'$2(/%$0*-á6 6(0$*$.á564á-

6GIWJ+CTKLQPQ/WNWF

)2')

$2.á-$5á-(0'$.á-70&á2á067,$4$-,$7+'(0*$0%1$4'')4'7á01'$069á66(4 9CJ[W2TCOWUKPVQ(PFK2TCFQRQ$OKP)GTFKCPU[CJ)GTFKCPU[CJ

)2')

2(4(0&$0$$0'$;$.á564á-2$'$-$9$5$02(/7-á/$0'(0*$0á06(424(6$5á)161 7'$4$

áOCP5GVKQPQ

)2')

4$0&$0*$0/1'(.2(0*(.1.$$012(4$5á'$02(/(.á+$4$$02$'$2.6/+&á06$

/(-$41.(+-12(4$5á/(-$45$4á'á-$%72$6(057%$0*2418á05á,$9$%$4$6 (MQ$TK[CPVQ'KFKM(MQ%WFK5CPVQUQ

)2')

2(4$0&$0*$05á56(/á0)14/$5á2(4(0&$0$$02(/%$0*70$0'$(4$+/(0**70$-$0 2(0'(-$6$02415('74$.567'á-$575%$22('$-$%72$6(02(/$.$0*

6GIWJ&CJ[QPQ

)2')

$2.á-$5á2$-$0á-$0161/$6á5%(4%$5á5/á-41-10641..(4$6/(*$

)GTFKCPU[CJ)GTFKCPU[CJ-COCTCF[$TKGH

)2')

2(0'(6(-5á$0)14/$.á02$'$%$+$02$0*$0'(0*$05(0514*$5%(4%$5á521.á/(4 /(0**70$-$0/(61'(,$4á0*$05;$4$)6á47$0

%WFK*WPCYCP$TKGH5WFCTOCFLK

)2')

2(4$0&$0*$064$á0(42á'$0$.1*7067-/(0*$674-(&(2$6$0276$4$0/1614'&

/5WDEJCP/CWNWFKP$PFK-WTPKCYCP

)2')

(10)

KWWSVSXEOLNDVLLOPLDKXQZDKDVDFLGLQGH[SKS3526,',1*B6167B)7LVVXHYLHZVKRZ7RF

5á/7.$5á6á/(4'$0&1706(42.&1/4106;2(<(05(%$*$á2(0**$06á5(0514%(4$6

2$'$,70-%1:2$2(4/á..&10641.5;56(/

'CXKF$TKU[CPFK-WTPKCYCP/5WDEJCP/CWNWFKP

)2')

2(4$0&$0*$05á56(/2(0'7-70*-(27675$02(0(4á/$$06$470$%$47 /(0**70$-$0%$5á5'$6$)7<<;567'á-$575'á$-2(.0á5(/$4$0*

(MQ0WT+KFC[CV4CJOCV*GTPQYQ$TKU5WIKJCTVQ

)2')

241616á2(/(5á024(55161/$6á5'(0*$05á56(/20(7/$6á-%(4%$5á5241*4$//$%.(

.1*á&&10641..(42.&7067-241'7-5á2$8á0*%.1-%(456$0'$40$5á10$.

á0'10(5á$50á

/QJ'CJNCP5WIGPI5NCOGV%WFK*WPCYCP

)2')

2(0*(/%$0*$0'$0á/2.(/(06$5á5á56(/á0)14/$5á,(,$4á0*47,7-$0

-(*$9$6'$474$6$0/$6(40$.0(10$6$.%(4%$5á59(%'$05/55+146/(55$*(

5(48á&(

&CTYQVQ&CTYQVQ%CODCPI9KLC[CPVQ

)2')

2(0(4$2$0-019.('*(/$0$*(/(062$'$2(4*747$06á0**á567'á-$575$/á-%5á 27491-(461

(PFCPI4GVPQPKPIUKJ'K[CJ2WVTK7VCOK

)2')

$0$.á5$*(152$5á$.2(0;(%$%2(07470$0/7-$6$0$+'á-16$5(/$4$0*

%CODCPI'CTOQ;WYQPQ+CUCPWFFKP<$DKFKP/WJCOOCF+KNOK

*2')

$0$.á5á52(0á0*-$6$0)70*5á%$0*70$07/7//(.$.7á72$;$'(5$á0$&&(55á%á.á6;

'GPK5WMCOVQ+GV[QTKPK+GV[QTKPK

*2')

'(5$á0á018$6á)%$*á47/$+6á0**$.%(4'$5$4-$024á05á2%á1&.á/$6á- /QEJCOCF5CTVQPQ$PYCT(HGPFK

*2')

2(4$0'$06$06$0*$02(4(0&$0$$047$0*27%.á-5(%$*$á2(47%$+$0-(+á'72$0 /$5;$4$-$6

4KEJG/C[C+CRUCTK(MQ0WTUCPV[

*2')

á/2.á-$5á241*4$/2(0*(/%$0*$0-16$+á,$72-+6(4+$'$22(/(07+$0.7$5$0 47$0*6(4%7-$+á,$746+2(4-16$$0

;QJCPGU'KEM[(MCRWVTC/CTICTGVC/CTKC5WFCTYCPK

*2')

(11)
(12)

!"#

$%&'%'%%()*+,-."/%0%%1 $'(%(*$+'$

222 22223# -40$#$$1 '%+5

$$(+$

(13)
(14)
(15)
(16)
(17)
(18)
(19)

6 7

8,89 8":8;<

6 7

8;" ;"=.

$ 7

.98"8=;

' 7

".;"

$ 5 7

' ' 7

5 $ 7

( $ 7

* $ 7

+ > $ 7

0 > $ 7

4 > $ 7

= 88;98": = "

8, :=.

# ##

8

???#3#

8

#3#

8

##

8

3.88

# ##

8

#3#

8

#$'5#

8

(20)

6 > $ 7

$% > $ 7

@A =

@33 B =

@ =

???# #

8

3."3

(21)

!8;9

C$

, = "

; 9=,,;"

$ ' 5 (

*

+

Referensi

Dokumen terkait

Terindeks di jika ada : Kategori Publikasi Makalah :  Prosiding Forum Ilmiah Internasional beri pada kategori yang tepat Prosiding Forum Ilmiah Nasional Hasil Penilaian Peer

Terindeks di jika ada : Kategori Publikasi Makalah : Prosiding Forum Ilmiah Internasional beri pada kategori yang tepat  Prosiding Forum Ilmiah Nasional Hasil Penilaian Peer Review

Terindeks di jika ada : Scimagojr dan Scopus Kategori Publikasi Makalah :  Prosiding Forum Ilmiah Internasional beri pada kategori yang tepat Prosiding Forum Ilmiah Nasional Hasil

Terindeks di jika ada : Kategori Publikasi Makalah : Prosiding Forum Ilmiah Internasional beri pada kategori yang tepat  Prosiding Forum Ilmiah Nasional Hasil Penilaian Peer Review

Terindeks di jika ada : Scimagojr dan Scopus Kategori Publikasi Makalah : Prosiding Forum Ilmiah Internasional beri pada kategori yang tepat  Prosiding Forum Ilmiah Nasional Hasil

Terindeks di jika ada : Scimagojr dan Scopus Kategori Publikasi Makalah :  Prosiding Forum Ilmiah Internasional beri pada kategori yang tepat Prosiding Forum Ilmiah Nasional Hasil

Terindeks di jika ada : Kategori Publikasi Makalah :  Prosiding Forum Ilmiah Internasional beri pada kategori yang tepat Prosiding Forum Ilmiah Nasional Hasil Penilaian Peer Review

Terindeks di jika ada : Kategori Publikasi Makalah :  Prosiding Forum Ilmiah Internasional beri pada kategori yang tepat Prosiding Forum Ilmiah Nasional Hasil Penilaian Peer Review