Repository Universitas Negeri Manado: Competitive Intelligence framework for Increasing Competitiveness Vocational High School Management

(1)

LEMBAR HASIL PENILAIAN SEJAWAT SEBIDANG ATAU PEER REVIEW KARYA ILMIAH: PROSIDING

Judul karya : Competitive Intelligence framework for increasing competitiveness Vocational High school Management

ilmiah (paper)

Jumlah Penulis : 2 Orang Penulis ke 1 Status Pengusul :

: a. Judul Prodisiding : The 5th UPI International Conference on Technical and Vocational Education and Training focuses

on “Globalization, challenges, and disruptions in TVET Identitas

Prosiding

b. ISBN / ISSN 9781510882041

c. Tahun terbit, Tempat pelaksanaan

: 2019/ UPI Bandung

d. Penerbit/organizer :Atlantic Press / UPI Bandung -UNIMA

e :

Alamat repository PT/ Web www.atlantis-press.com › proceedings › ictvet-18 prosiding

f. Terindeks di (jika ada) :Altantic Press Kategori publikasi makalah (beri √

pada kategori yang tepat)

Prosiding forum ilmiah International Prosiding forum ilmiah Nasional…

Hasil Penilaian Peer Review:

Komponen yang dinilai

Nilai maksimal prosiding

Nilai akhir yang diperoleh International Nasional

a. Kelengkapan unsure isi paper (10%)

2 1

b. Ruang lingkup dan kedalaman

pembahasan (30%)

6 2

c. Kecukupan dan kemutahiran data/

informasi dan metodelogi (30%)

6 2.5

d. Kelengkapan unsurdan kualitas terbitan/

prosiding (30%)

6 2.5

Total = (100%)

20 8

Nilai Pengusul

8

Catatan Penilaian paper oleh Reviewer:

√

(2)

Reviewer : 1

Nama : Prof Dr. Ph.E.A.Tuerah,MSI,DEA NIP. : 19601219 198503 1 003

Unit Kerja : Fakultas Matematika dan Ilmu Pengetahuaan Alam Unjiversitas Negeri Manado Sebuah inovasi untuk meningkatkan inovasi dalam mengembangkan daya saing di SMK.

Research objective juga telah dikemukakan dengan baik.

Metode yang digunakan sudah akurat dan baik.

Analisis yang dilakukan sudah memadai dan baik dengan hasil yang akurat. Pembahasan telah dilakukan dengan baik sehingga menghasilkan kesimpulan yang akurat, sahih dan terjangkau. ini sangat baik untuk diterapkan pada SMK

Tanggal, bulan, tahun : 18 April 2020

Tanda Tangan

(3)

√

LEMBAR HASIL PENILAIAN SEJAWAT SEBIDANG ATAU PEER REVIEW KARYA ILMIAH: PROSIDING

Judul karya : Competitive Intelligence framework for increasing competitiveness Vocational High school Management

ilmiah (paper)

Jumlah Penulis : 2 Orang Penulis ke 1 Status Pengusul :

: a. Judul Prodisiding : The 5th UPI International Conference on Technical and Vocational Education and Training focuses on “Globalization, challenges, and disruptions in TVET

Identitas Prosiding

b. ISBN / ISSN 9781510882041 c. Tahun terbit, Tempat

pelaksanaan

:2019/ UPI Bandung

d. Penerbit/organizer :Atlantic Press / UPI Bandung -UNIMA

e. :

www.atlantis-press.com › proceedings › ictvet-18 Alamat repository PT/ Web

prosiding

f. Terindeks di (jika ada) :Altantic Press

Kategori publikasi makalah (beri √ Prosiding forum ilmiah International pada kategori yang tepat) Prosiding forum ilmiah Nasional…

Hasil Penilaian Peer Review:

Komponen yang dinilai

Nilai maksimal prosiding

Nilai akhir yang diperoleh International Nasional

a. Kelengkapan unsure isi paper (10%)

1 1

b. Ruang lingkup dan kedalaman

pembahasan (30%)

2.5 2.5

c. Kecukupan dan kemutahiran data/

informasi dan metodelogi (30%)

2.5 2.5

d. Kelengkapan unsurdan kualitas terbitan/

prosiding (30%)

2 2

Total = (100%)

8 8

Nilai Pengusul

8 8

Catatan Penilaian paper oleh Reviewer:

(4)

Tanggal, bulan, tahun :10 April 2020

Reviewer : 2

Tanda Tangan

Nama : Prof Dr. Julyeta P.A. Runtuwene,MS NIP. : 19640709 199011 2 001

Unit Kerja : Falkultas Teknik Universitas Negeri Manado

1. The introduction and methods sections are good and there are many references

2. From the introduction The topic of this paper is important and the outcome he study seem original in concept

3. first the paper has to explain (in the methods section) exactly what methodology was used clearly.

4. the discussion comprehensively discuss the results with appropriate language

5. The topic of this paper is important and the outcome are very appropriate to be develop to the next level of study.

Writers present clear background, appropriate method and detailed description of the results. Other than that, the scope and discussions in this research are good. It strongly recommends that in result and discussion, writers draw the statistic of the result because questionnaire is one of measurement techniques used in this study besides empirical study.

Repository Universitas Negeri Manado: Competitive Intelligence framework for Increasing Competitiveness Vocational High School Management

LEMBAR HASIL PENILAIAN SEJAWAT SEBIDANG ATAU PEER REVIEW KARYA ILMIAH: PROSIDING

2 1

6 2

6 2.5

6 2.5

20 8

8

LEMBAR HASIL PENILAIAN SEJAWAT SEBIDANG ATAU PEER REVIEW KARYA ILMIAH: PROSIDING

1 1

2.5 2.5

2.5 2.5

2 2

8 8

8 8

1. The introduction and methods sections are good and there are many references

2. From the introduction The topic of this paper is important and the outcome he study seem original in concept

3. first the paper has to explain (in the methods section) exactly what methodology was used clearly.

4. the discussion comprehensively discuss the results with appropriate language

5. The topic of this paper is important and the outcome are very appropriate to be develop to the next level of study.

However, writers need to increase more experiment data to describe and confirm clearly

the conclusion of the study.