Reviewer’s Comment on:
JMEM- 1136-3398-1-RV.doc Hydroxy Gas (HHO) Supplement of Ethanol Fuel Mixture In A Single-Cylinder Spark-Ignition Matic-Engine
General:
The article : Hydroxy Gas (HHO) Supplement of Ethanol Fuel Mixture In A Single-Cylinder Spark-Ignition Matic-Engine is a good research work
Some revisions need to be made in order to meet publication novelty and scientific approach.
The suggested revisions are elaborated below.
Specific:
Comment 1
After the Introduction, a Comprehensive Problem statement should be formulated.
For example:
Hence the objective of the present work is a.
b.
c. etc
and the results will be compared with baseline data....
etc.
Comment 2
In the introduction, in the sentence “The effect of the addition of HHO on the IC engine was investigated by Yilmaz et al. Their yields reported an increase in engine torque by an average of 19.1%, reduction in CO and HC emissions,..”, reference number associated with Yilmaz et al should be given (Yilmaz et al [..])
Comment 3
a. Prior to Results and Discussion, the author(s) should discus the reliability and reproducibility of the data. The statistics of the date taken, errors, accuracy, etc, should be elaborated.
b. Then the data obtained should be validated by theoretical estimate or other standard data (should be “apple to apple”).
Comment 4
Conclusions should be based on all the information which should incorporate those obtained from the comments of the reviewer
