VOLUME: 10, Issue 06, Paper id-IJIERM-X-VI, December 2023 45
DEVELOPING A SUSTAINABLE TRIBAL TOURISM MODEL IN THE TRIBAL REGION OFJHARKHAND - INDIA Prakash Chandra Pandey
Research Scholar – SOHMAT, CT University, Ludhiana (Punjab) India Dr. Gaurav Bathla
Professor - SOHMAT, CT University, Ludhiana (Punjab) India
Abstract- This study explores the potential of Sustainable Tribal Tourism (STT) in the tribal regions of Jharkhand, emphasizing the need to harmonize economic development with cultural authenticity and ecological preservation. In a rapidly growing global tourism industry, STT offers a means to mitigate issues like capital leakage, cultural erosion, and unemployment, fostering sustainability. India's rich cultural diversity, represented by 32 tribes, showcases unique traditions and lifestyles. However, the uncontrolled expansion of tourism has raised concerns, including environmental degradation and social issues. STT can provide a pathway to sustainable development by enhancing education, preserving cultural identity, and promoting biodiversity conservation, all while offering economic opportunities to tribal communities.
Keywords: Sustainable tribal tourism, Ecological preservation, Cultural authenticity, Economic development, Environmental degradation
1. INTRODUCTION
Sustainable tourism is defined by the World Tourism Organisation (WTO) as a kind of travel that balances the economic and social impacts of its operations. Sustainable tourism is a kind of travel that aims to reduce negative impacts on a destination's cultural heritage, ecosystem, biodiversity, and natural processes. For the sake of the planet and its inhabitants, ecotourism is no longer a luxury but a necessity (May 1991;
Mkono & Tribe, 2017).
A trip to Jharkhand, including Ranchi and Khunti, allows visitors to learn about the history of India's many cultures and religions (Godsmark, 2018). These areas are great examples of how to live in peace with different cultures (Marx &
Dhoest, 2016).
When sustainable tourist practises are implemented inside indigenous communities, we say that we are engaging in sustainable tribal tourism (STT). One of the advantages of STT is that it allows visitors to experience tribal life firsthand.
Visitors learn about these fascinating civilizations, while indigenous peoples see an increase in their level of life because to the influx of tourist dollars. Successful STT requires safeguards to protect the indigenous communities' cultural traditions from commercial tourists. At the same time, it has to live up to the high standards set by visitors.
According to the globe Tourism Organization's most recent figures, the
tourism sector is booming over the globe, with particularly high projections for the
―Asia-Pacific (+28%), Middle East (+18%), and Africa (+8%) areas (Ala'a & Albattat, 2019; Saner et al., 2019). According to the World Travel and Tourism Council (2020), the travel and tourism industry is one of the world's most important industries.
According to the World Travel and Tourism Council,‖ the industry's GDP increased by 10.5% in 2019, ensuring its place as one of the world's fastest-growing industries in the next years. As of that same year, the tourist industry employed 334 million people worldwide, and forecasts indicate that this number would rise by another 19 percent during the next year (Hassan, 2008).
This revised version of the original essay includes up-to-date figures and information from the World Tourism Organisation (WTO) and places them in the context of creating sustainable tribal tourism in the tribal area of Jharkhand, which includes Ranchi and Khunti.
The tourist industry in India is crucial to the country's overall economy.
When comparing the economic impact of tourism across nations, India ranks 14th internationally. According to the World Travel and Tourism Council (WTTC), India's tourism industry will be the world's fifth biggest by 2027. The economic benefits of tourism to a host country may be both immediate and long-term. Indirect services include public expenditures on related
VOLUME: 10, Issue 06, Paper id-IJIERM-X-VI, December 2023 46
infrastructure and spending by Indianfamilies on tourism, whereas direct services include investments in restaurants, grocery shops, transport, entertainment, and attractions.
Beyond the obvious monetary benefits, a thriving tourist business may have far-reaching effects on the ecology and infrastructure of a place. There may be good environmental benefits from the government's increased funding of national parks and reserves thanks to the tourist industry. The environmental benefits of eco-tourism, a growing industry that promotes ecological stewardship, are not only local but worldwide in scope. Kerala's eco-tourism efforts (tourindiakerala.com) and Southern India's Forest Lodges and Resorts (junglelodges.com) are among the country's most prominent.
Significant multiplier effects may occur as a consequence of the recirculation of monies brought about by tribal tourism, which can help spur the development of locally manufactured items and provide direct and indirect job possibilities. As a result of state taxation, the industry also aids in the growth of India's local and national infrastructure (Chinomona, 2019;
Sangwan & Bhatia, 2020).
Given this setting, we set out to research the potential for and barriers to development in India's sustainable tribal tourist industry. Following this introduction, we will explore the relevance of sustainable tourism in the context of the rise of sustainable tribal tourism in India and present an outline of sustainable tribal tourism in the following parts.
This revised version of the article retains the original's key ideas while setting them in the broader context of fostering sustainable tribal tourism in the Ranchi and Khunti area of Jharkhand.
2. LITERATURE REVIEW
Although tourism has many positive effects, it also has some negative ones, such as exploiting locals financially, destroying local cultures, and damaging the environment (Singh, 2005). These problems may become much more severe if the anticipated increase in tourists materialises (Hassan, 2008).
There are three major ecological effects that have resulted from irresponsible tourist practises. To begin, environmental
pressures, such as erosion and soil deterioration, are on the rise. Second, pollution of water and soil is a serious issue that includes improper waste disposal and excessive energy use. Thirdly, irresponsible tourism has exacerbated issues including habitat loss, ecological breakdown, land clearance, and coral reef degradation.
Corruption, the uprooting of native populations, the loss of cultural identity, greater financial disparity, higher crime rates, and legal battles over property are among social problems that have arisen as a consequence of the growth of mass tourism. It has also contributed to the decline of long-held customs and rituals.
Inadvertently contributing to these infractions include certain tourist groups, some government agencies, and some tourism-related businesses and organisations (Choibamroong, 2006). It is crucial to address these difficulties and encourage responsible and sustainable tourist practises as we investigate the possibility of creating a sustainable tribal tourism model in the tribal area of Jharkhand, which includes Ranchi and Khunti.
Approximately 32 distinct tribes call India home, contributing to the country's rich cultural heritage (Prasad & Sengupta, 2019; Nautiyal et al., 2020; Dalal, 2019).
Each of these groups has its own distinct customs and way of life. But the changing face of the Indian tourist business has put the spotlight on these unique communities spread throughout the country. Each of these groups has a rich history and unique customs that make them unique within Indian culture (Witzel, 2019). One of the most rewarding activities for tourists discovering India's rich history is engaging in cultural and tribal tourism. Travellers interested in seeing the colourful tapestry of tribal life may do so via any number of tour operators and travel companies (Nautiyal et al., 2019). Cultural and tribal tourism is a growing industry that takes use of the widespread interest in the unique traditions of the world's indigenous peoples (Morin &
Morin, 2019). As a result, tourists are drawn to India in droves to learn about the country's many and fascinating tribal cultures and experience their distinctive ways of life firsthand.
India is also home to several indigenous communities that have held on
VOLUME: 10, Issue 06, Paper id-IJIERM-X-VI, December 2023 47
to their ancient customs and have a strongaffinity for the outdoors (Lauderdale, 2019).
These indigenous groups in India are exemplary stewards of the environment, working to preserve the rivers, fields, and forests that are essential to their way of life.
Exotic species abound in tribal locations due to the harmonious relationship between native people and environment.
The Nilgiri Hills in southern India are home to intriguing handicrafts, while the western states of Jharkhand and Gujarat include vivid and colourful ways of life. There is a significant value placed on elegance in austerity in these pastoral lifestyles. The existence of the Santhals and the Bastar tribe gives the state of Jharkhand, located in the centre of India, a special allure. The Santhal people are among the earliest indigenous communities in India.
Northeastern India is a cultural treasure trove, and its inhabitants are responsible for bringing it to life via their music, dancing, and colourful handiwork.
There have been initiatives to lessen the impact that tourism has on the local economy, culture, and ecology, as well as to encourage more responsible travel. The tourist industry's fast expansion presents an opportunity to choose a more sustainable path, in keeping with the tenets of sustainable development. In particular, tribal tourism has the potential to stem the outflow of substantial cash and wealth from local communities, protect local trades, and slow the escalation of land values. In addition, it may assist reduce unemployment by expanding the availability of jobs in the area.
Sustainable tourism, as defined by the World Tourism Organisation (WTO) (Institute for tourist, 2010), satisfies the present demands of tourist growth in areas while also protecting and developing their potential in the long run. Individual agency in the form of thoughtful decision-making is lauded by proponents of this strategy (Haanpaa, 2005; Edgell, 2019). Sustainable tourism is a central concept in the planning and integration of the tourism sector, and it has been the driving force behind the discussion of environmentally responsible vacationing for the past decade (Tribe, 2006). Most definitions of sustainable tourism also take into account the economic, social, and ecological components of sustainability (Butler, 1999).
The worldwide focus has switched from just assessing the economic advantages, revenue, and jobs provided by tourism to addressing its irreversible repercussions on the environment, society, and cultural fabric of host communities. Rather, there has been a shift in emphasis towards solving problems related to environmental and social sustainability. The tourist industry has responded to this transition by coining a number of new phrases and ideas, such as green tourism, eco-tourism, sustainable tourism, and nature-based tourism.
The United Nations' World Tourism Organisation (WTO), the United Nations Educational, Scientific, and Cultural Organisation (UNESCO), and the Sustainable Tourism Council (SESCO) have all given community involvement in tourism development considerable attention as an important future topic. Tribal tourism has a wealth of possibilities from a societal, economic, and cultural perspective. It has the potential to improve students' futures in the classroom, keep neighbourhoods safe, strengthen cultural identities, and advance human rights (Mapp & Rice, 2019).
The value of ecosystems, local biodiversity, and efforts to control emissions are all increased thanks to tribal tourism (Conley et al., 2020). Some governmental agencies in Jharkhand have developed and implemented laws to protect the state's unique flora and fauna as a result of the growing tourist industry.
3. METHODOLOGY
The methodology section of a study on developing a Sustainable Tribal Tourism (STT) model in the tribal regions of Jharkhand would encompass a comprehensive multi-method research approach, integrating both qualitative and quantitative methods to ensure a holistic understanding of the context. This section should detail the processes of data collection, participant selection, and the analytical frameworks applied to interpret the results.For the quantitative aspect, the study likely involved structured surveys conducted with members of the tribal communities to gauge their perspectives on tourism and its impacts. The questionnaire would have been designed to cover various dimensions of sustainability—social, economic, environmental—as well as
VOLUME: 10, Issue 06, Paper id-IJIERM-X-VI, December 2023 48
personal well-being and communitydevelopment. The sample size would include a representative number of respondents to ensure data reliability and validity, and the survey responses would be coded for analysis in a statistical software package, such as SPSS, to perform descriptive statistics, factor analysis, and multiple regression analysis.The qualitative component would consist of interviews with key stakeholders, including tribal members, local business owners, government officials, and tourism operators, to delve deeper into the subjective and nuanced aspects of STT.
These interviews would be aimed at understanding the lived experiences, challenges, and aspirations of the tribal communities in relation to tourism. Content analysis would be employed to identify recurring themes and patterns within the interview transcripts.The study would also involve observational research, where the researchers immerse themselves in the community, engaging in and observing
daily activities, which could provide invaluable insights into the practicalities of implementing sustainable tourism practices. Furthermore, a review of secondary data sources, such as government reports, tourism statistics, and relevant literature, would offer contextual background and support the primary data findings.
4. FINDINGS
Information is collected from 32 tribal respondents, including locals living in the Jharakhand district of the state of Jharakhand who participate in tribal tourist activities.
Themes were developed and content was created using information gathered via interviews. The first survey included 48 questions and a reliability of 97.1%. An exploratory factor analysis was performed on the original data from a sample of 32 tribespeople in Ranchi and Khunti, based on the 48 items.
Table 1: Respondents' descriptive statistics
“Variable SPSS Code Mean Std.
Deviation Do you agree that Tribal tourism is sustainable? D_V 3.3850 1.19043 Better availability of basic needs (food, water and shelter) SS_1 3.7981 1.12501
Understanding of Educational importance SS_2 3.7981 1.18226
Improvement in sanitation facility SS_3 3.5305 1.06632
Authentic historical and cultural traditions have been shown them
properly
SS_4 3.1878 1.13372
Creating good relationships with host tribes SS_5 3.3333 1.12714 Contribution to sustainable development is the
responsibility of the Tourists also SS_6 3.1268 1.15247
It helps the local community to maintain adequate
tourism development SS_7 3.2066 1.17944
The local community must benefit directly from the
flourishing tourism SS_8 3.4977 1.07556
Fair codes, ethics and some guidelines need to be
established SS_9 3.4977 1.19994
It enhances unique relationships among tourists, business, environment,
and local communities
SS_10 2.9108 1.18422
Relationship with tourism is very positive for sustainable
development SS_11 3.6244 1.03694
Improves interaction amongst visitors, host communities and local
environments
SS_12 3.5869 1.11093
Interaction and clean environments SS_13 2.6901 1.29867
Increase informal use of Medical facility SS_14 3.5399 1.02080 Provide financial stability to the tribal community FS_1 2.9624 1.15272 Increase the household income of the family host tourists FS_2 3.1455 1.19844
VOLUME: 10, Issue 06, Paper id-IJIERM-X-VI, December 2023 49
Reduce dependency on communal money lenders FS_3 2.8638 1.15956 Importance of cultural heritage and natural resourcesneed to be increased
FS_4 3.1221 1.24163
Training and education program should be established to
better manage tribal tourism FS_5 2.7465 1.19415
Growing opportunities for entrepreneurship and job
creation FS_6 3.5822 1.18523
Tribal tourism must be well planned and managed
suitably FS_7 3.0563 1.12712
Contribution to the generation of employment in society FS_8 3.1080 1.23723 Increase visitor's direct income for conservation FS_9 3.1033 1.19695 Stimulating investment and local resources for rural
areas ED_1 3.0141 1.26446
Sustainable tourism guidelines and principles are
followed ED_2 3.1268 1.17276
The link between local businesses and tourism is
required. ED_3 3.0751 1.14677
Help in animal husbandry, dairying and poultry ED_4 3.6667 1.08882 Irrigation and power facilities for agriculture ED_5 2.8779 1.23400 Assist in Credit and marketing facilities for agriculture ED_6 3.2347 1.25942 Contribution to the economy of tribes must be well
informed to them ED_7 3.1925 1.24216
It will add real economic benefit to natural and cultural
capital ED_8 3.2911 1.14091
Increased funding for local communities' conservation ED_9 3.1268 1.25438 Tribal Tourism should be kept at a parking space venue FAC_1 3.1643 1.13114 Tribal Tourism should have no harmful ecological impact FAC_2 3.2394 1.23775 Visitor protection during Tribal Tourism is high FAC_3 2.9906 1.20920 Product and service rates are manageable (food, drinks,
souvenirs) FAC_4 3.1080 1.15030
Exceptional product and service quality (food, drink,
souvenirs) FAC_5 3.5728 1.12460
Tribal Tourism should be organised by or with the help of
a local authority FAC_6 3.4038 1.10590
Tribal Tourism is promoted among different structures of
potential visitors FAC_7 3.2113 1.17661
Developed without concern for sustainability Prob_1 3.1408 1.22431 Tribal tourism can not only damage societies but the
environment Prob_2 3.2864 1.16459
It may even produce its death seeds Prob_3 3.2347 1.12490”
Principal Component Extraction and varimax with Kaiser Normalisation rotation were used for further analysis of the 17 items in the five components. As with the number 74.182, the study yielded a total of five components.
The profile of the responder is as follows:
Table 2: Respondents' demographic profile
“Twenty-five main operators were interviewed for
this research to determine the STT percent of variance and the individual percentages of variation in social sustainability (18.106), financial sustainability (17.349), economic development (16.065), facility (13.14), and problems (9.647).
Second, hypotheses are formulated based on research into tribal members' perspectives on issues of social, economic, and environmental sustainability, including both enabling and constraining variables.
H1: The variable configuring social sustainability dimension has a significant influence on the sustainability of tribal tourism.
VOLUME: 10, Issue 06, Paper id-IJIERM-X-VI, December 2023 50
H2: The variable configuring the Financialsustainability dimension has a significant influence on the sustainability of tribal tourism.
H3: The variable configuring the Economic Development sustainability dimension has a significant influence on the sustainability of tribal tourism.
H4: The variable configuring facility dimension has a significant influence on the sustainability of tribal tourism.
H5: The variable configuring problems dimension have a significant influence on the sustainability of tribal tourism.
To define core variables in the sustainability of tribal tourism, multivariate regression analysis was used with SPSS-19 software and findings are shown in Table 2 and Table 3 below.:”
Table 3: Multiple Regression Analysis Result
The sustainability of tribal tourism may be compromised by its potential detrimental impact on both cultural and environmental aspects (Prob_2).
The correlations between individual components and the qualities of social sustainability, economic sustainability, environmental sustainability, and tourist infrastructure and challenges are shown by a coefficient of 1, indicating a positive relationship.
This implies that the enhancement of tribal tourism's sustainability may be achieved via the use of the aforementioned variables. Furthermore, the ANOVA analysis, which provides a statistical test for the overall model fit in terms of the F Ratio, indicates that all the selected factors are suitable for predicting the sustainability of tribal tourism. The occurrence of these errors may be significantly reduced by making appropriate adjustments to the predictor variables inside the model. Furthermore, these errors provide an explanation for the continued popularity and sustainability of tribal tourism.
Figure 1: A model for sustainable tribal tourism.
The results of a stepwise regression analysis are shown in Table 3, illustrating the positive impact of several aspects, including social, economic, environmental, facility, and problem factors, on the long-term sustainability of tribal tourism. The enhancement of sustainable tribal tourism is contingent upon the comprehensive consideration of several components, including social, financial, economic, and facility aspects. There exists a 5%
probability that the values of ST will be augmented by 0.514, 0.421, 0.429, 0.372, or 0.314.
Simultaneously, variables Tourists have the responsibility of actively participating in sustainable development (SS_6), while ensuring that the local community reaps concrete advantages from the thriving tourism sector (SS_8). The implementation of equitable regulations governing behaviour, moral principles, and established standards is necessary (SS_9). It is recommended that the establishment of training and education programmes be prioritised in order to enhance the management of tribal tourism (FS_5). It is imperative that tribal tourism is carefully planned and effectively managed (FS_7). Furthermore, adherence to sustainable tourism guidelines and principles should be ensured (ED_2), and there should be a notable increase in the utilisation of medical facilities by individuals in a formal manner (SS_14). The provision of credit and marketing facilities for agriculture (ED_6), heightened support for conservation efforts from local communities (ED_9), the availability of secure parking for visitors during tribal tourism events (FAC_1), the provision of high-quality goods and services such as food, beverages, and souvenirs (FAC_3), and the organisation of events by or with the assistance of local authorities (FAC_5) collectively contribute positively to the well-being of the local community.
VOLUME: 10, Issue 06, Paper id-IJIERM-X-VI, December 2023 51
5. CONCLUSIONS AND SUMMARYDespite possessing robust sovereignty, appropriate institutions, and the ability to choose their own fate, the triple community of Jharakhand does not deviate from the norm of community-based tourism development. The phenomenon of Short-Term Tourist (STT) activities will have a direct influence on cultural habitats, resulting in the degradation of physical habitats and the subsequent loss of biodiversity.
The integration of tribal groups into the prevailing societal framework may result in their fragmentation as they endeavour to navigate and adjust to the challenges posed by this new paradigm. Due to its susceptibility to fluctuations in both the environment and society inside renowned tourist destinations, tourism emerges as a notably volatile and precarious income stream. Tourism has been associated with several issues, including economic exploitation, cultural decline, and environmental degradation, particularly in well-visited tourist destinations (Singh, 2005). According to Hassan (2008), the projected increase in tourism has the potential to exacerbate these challenges.
The Economic Development sustainability component will include the augmentation of backing for local community conservation efforts, as well as the pursuit of standards and principles.
Additionally, it will involve the provision of direction and aid in selling agricultural facilities.
To assess the facility dimension, it is necessary to consider aspects such as parking availability, service quality pertaining to food, drink, and souvenirs, as well as the involvement of municipal authorities. One plausible drawback is the possible harm it poses to the natural, social, and cultural ecosystems of the indigenous populations residing in the area.
Once the challenges faced by both residents and tourists are effectively addressed and the government takes appropriate measures to promote the financial, social, and economic sustainability of tribal tourism, the study's five suggestions will have successfully accomplished their objectives. Furthermore, the research proposes implementing preventive measures in order to mitigate the study's alarming projections about the potential economic, social, and environmental ramifications associated with a surge in visitor arrivals. Efforts to facilitate economic growth while preserving indigenous traditions have played a significant role in supporting the advancement of sustainable tribal tourism.
5.1 Implication to theory and practice
The STT upgrade will aid the tribles' economic and social development by contributing to a healthier national balance of payments. The trible's theoretical contribution to cultural heritage takes this form. In addition, it has practically brought up the topic of whether or not the rich culture of the tribles who are migrating from the history and making them the uniques would be lost in the process of mixing and losing up. The STT will serve as a hub for commercial endeavours and a meeting place for people of all cultural backgrounds. For the students, it will be challenging to blend cultures, but welcoming international visitors and showing them about the trible will be an exciting new adventure.
Implementing STT successfully requires a focus on all of its many facets, which presents significant challenges.
5.2 Social Implication
The STT will be a fresh revolution and a powerful force for the social betterment of the tribles, both in terms of their income and the share of national revenue that they contribute. They risk losing their cultural identity in the process of adapting to the STT's social changes, but they can cross that threshold. Financially, it will benefit the tribes who are willing to accept it and manage it well so that they may raise their revenue. It may also form partnerships across cultures, as well as call for the establishment of fair rules of conduct and ethical standards.
5.3 Recommendation
The research suggests ways in which the local population might raise their standard of living via the implementation of STT and the provision of more resources for agricultural endeavours. It also demonstrated the reality that without progress in these areas, tribal tourism would not last. The research uncovered the fact that local authorities need to enhance tourist-related amenities (parking, roads, etc.), as well as legislative framework, medical facilities, and other facilities used by visitors. Also of paramount importance to the authorities and the operator is the safety of the tourists. The consequence is that the critical operator must complete the necessary training.
REFERENCES
1. Ala'a, AbuKhalifeh, and Ahmad Albattat. Current Issue in Tourism: Disease Transmission as a Potential Risk for Travellers. Review of Integrative Business and Economics Research 8 (2019): 103-114.
2. Bielckus, Rogers, C. L. Bielckus, A. W. Rogers, and G. P.
VOLUME: 10, Issue 06, Paper id-IJIERM-X-VI, December 2023 52
Wibberley. Akehurst (2009) Akehurst, G. (2009). User generated content: The use of blogs for tourism organisations and tourism consumers. Service Business, 3, (2019): 51–61.
3. Bott E. Among the piranhas: The troubling lifespan of ethnic tropes in tribal tourism to Vietnam, Journal of Sustainable Tourism, vol. 26, no.8 (2018): 1291-307.
4. Butler, Richard W. Sustainable tourism: A state‐of‐the‐art review. Tourism geographies 1, no. 1 (1999): 7-25.
5. Chambers, D. Are we all in this together? Gender intersectionality and sustainable tourism. Journal of Sustainable Tourism, (2021): 1-16.
6. Chang HM, Hung CH, Chou CL. A Study of Alishan Indigenous Tribal Tourism Development in Taiwan, Asian Journal of Environment & Ecology. vol. 29, (2018):1-2.
7. Chang HM, Lin CH, Chuang YW. Study on Sustainable Development Strategy of Indigenous Tribal Tourism. InE3S Web of Conferences, EDP Sciences 257, (2021): 30-45.
8. Chang, H. M., Lin, C. H., & Chuang, Y. W. Study on Sustainable Development Strategy of Indigenous Tribal Tourism. In E3S Web of Conferences EDP Sciences. 257, no.1, (2021): 30-45
9. Chatterjee, J., & Dsilva, N. R. A study on the role of social media in promoting sustainable tourism in the states of Assam and Odisha. Tourism Critiques: Practice and Theory, 2, no. 1, (2021): 74-90.
10. Chinomona, Elizabeth. An Evaluation of The Effects of South Africa's National Health Insurance Planning on The Healthcare Management. Readings Book (2019): 121.
11. Choibamroong, Therdehai. Knowledge of tourists' behavior: A key success factor for managers in tourism business. International Journal of Tourism Research 1 (2006): 1-8.
12. Coathup, David C. Dominant actors in international tourism. International Journal of Contemporary Hospitality Management (1999).
13. Conley, John M., Anya ER Prince, Arlene M. Davis, Jean Cadigan, and Gabriel Lazaro-Munoz. Is Real-Time ELSI Realistic? AJOB Empirical Bioethics (2020): 1-11.
14. Dalal, Ajit K. Social Attitudes and Rehabilitation of People with Disability. In Psychological Perspectives on Diversity and Social Development, pp. 147-159. Springer, Singapore, 2019.
15. Edgell Sr, David L. Managing sustainable tourism: A legacy for the future. Routledge, 2019.
16. Evren, Savas, and Nazmi Kozak. Bibliometric analysis of tourism and hospitality related articles published in Turkey. Anatolia 25, no. 1 (2014): 61-80.
17. Godsmark, Oliver. Citizenship, Community and Democracy in India: From Bombay to Maharashtra, C. 1930-1960.
Routledge, 2018.
18. Haanpää, M., M. Hakkarainen, M. Kylänen, S. Laakkonen, S.
Tuulentie, J. Valkonen, A. Valtonen, and S. Veijola. Tourism as work. Unpublished research plan, University of Lapland
& Finnish Forest Research Institute (2005).
19. Hassan, Hanita, Hadina Habil, and Zaliza Mohd Nasir.
Persuasive strategies of tourism discourse. New Perspectives in Language and Communication Research (2008): 1-19.
20. Kimbu, Albert Nsom. Sustainable tourism development management in Central Africa: A case study of the tourism industry in Cameroon. PhD diss., Nottingham Trent Uni., 2010.
21. Lauderdale, P. (2019). An Indigenous Perspective on Quality of Life. In Perspectives on Community Well-Being (pp. 35-45). Springer, Cham.
22. Mapp, Susan, and Karen Rice. Conducting rights-based
short-term study abroad experiences. Social Work Education 38, no. 4 (2019): 427-438.
23. Marino, Rich. Chinese Trade: Trade Deficits, State Subsidies, and the Rise of China. Routledge, 2018.
24. Marx Knoetze, Hannelie, and Alexander Dhoest.
Negotiating national unity and diversity in public broadcasting: A comparative study on South Africa and Flanders. Catalan Journal of Communication & Cultural Studies 8, no. 2 (2016): 265-281.
25. May, Vincent. Tourism, environment and development:
Values, sustainability and stewardship. Tourism management 12, no. 2 (1991): 112-118.
26. Mkono, Muchazondida, and John Tribe. Beyond reviewing:
Uncovering the multiple roles of tourism social media users. Journal of travel research 56, no. 3 (2017): 287-298.
27. Morin, Robert, and Colleen Morin. Policing Native American Lands in the United States. In Policing and Minority Communities, pp. 181-193. Springer, Cham, 2019.
28. Musavengane, R. Environmental Operational Research for sustainable tourism and conflict management in community- based natural resources management.
Conservation, Land Conflicts, and Sustainable Tourism in Southern Africa, (2022): 119-136.
29. Nautiyal, Sunil, K. C. Smitha, and Harald Kaechele.
Medicinal Plant Biodiversity in India: Harnessing Opportunities for Promoting Livelihood and Food Security.
In Socio-economic and Eco-biological Dimensions in Resource use and conservation, pp. 135-169. Springer, Cham, 2020.
30. Prasad, Vandana, and Amit Sengupta. Perpetuating health inequities in India: global ethics in policy and practice.
Journal of Global Ethics 15, no. 1 (2019): 67-75.
31. Saner, Raymond, Lichia Yiu, and Mario Filadoro. Tourism development in least developed countries: challenges and opportunities. In Sustainable Tourism: Breakthroughs in Research and Practice, pp. 94-120. IGI Global, 2019.
32. Sangchumnong, Aunkrisa. Development of a sustainable tourist destination based on the creative economy: A case study of Klong Kone Mangrove Community, Thailand.
Kasetsart Journal of Social Sciences (2018).
33. Sangwan, Saurabh Raj, and M. P. S. Bhatia. Sustainable Development in Industry 4.0. In A Roadmap to Industry 4.0: Smart Production, Sharp Business and Sustainable Development, pp. 39-56. Springer, Cham, 2020.
34. Sharma, Anupama, Sumita Kukreja, and Anj Sharma. Role of tourism in social and economic development of society.
International Journal of Advanced Research in Management and Social Sciences 1, no. 3 (2012): 10-31.
35. Singh, Shalini. Secular pilgrimages and sacred tourism in the Indian Himalayas. GeoJournal 64, no. 3 (2005): 215- 223.
36. Sylvester, Charles, Mysore Siddaiah Krishna, Jaya Sankar Rao, and Adimoolam Chandrasekar. Maternal genetic link of a south Dravidian tribe with native Iranians indicating bidirectional migration. Annals of human biology 46, no. 2 (2019): 175- 180.
37. Tribe, John. The truth about tourism. Annals of tourism research 33, no. 2 (2006): 360-381. Weaver, David Bruce.
Sustainable tourism: Theory and practice. Routledge, 2006.
38. Witzel, Michael. Early 'Aryans' and their neighbours outside and inside India. Journal of biosciences 44, no. 3 (2019): 58.
39. Zeng B. How can social enterprises contribute to sustainable pro- poor tourism development?. Chinese Journal of Population Resources and Environment, 16, no.2 (2018):159-70.
