View of DYNAMICS OF INDO SAUDI ECONOMIC COOPERATION SINCE 2010: A REVIEW

VOLUME: 08, Issue 01, Paper id-IJIERM-VIII-I, February 2021

128

DYNAMICS OF INDO SAUDI ECONOMIC COOPERATION SINCE 2010: A REVIEW JV’n Neelam Shekhawat, Research Scholar

JV’n Prof. (Dr.) Mini Amit Arrawatia, Supervised Dr. Devadutta Indoria, Co-Supervised

Assistant Professor in Commerce, V Deb Government Autonomous College, Jeypore, Odisha

1 INTRODUCTION

The two main members of their regional bocks are India and Saudi Arabia. In the South Asian Association, Saudi Arabia is a leading country, a significant Member State of the Gulf Cooperation Council and India. The cordial and constructive relations between both nations reflect the centuries-old economic and cultural legacy. The two nations' economies have been liberalised, restructured and joined the World Trade Organization (WTO).

International trade between India and Saudi Arabia has increased more rapidly, been reinforced in recent decades, reached the level of strategic partnership and has encompassed more political, social and security elements. Trade, economic possibilities, energy procurement and supply, terrorist worries, strategic security, the workforce and the Hajj have historically formed a significant component of their bilateral relationship. India is one of the main Saudi oil, agri-business and other commodities purchasers. Saudi Arabia has always known that its markets are for the East, India and China. Saudi Arabia is an important member of the OPEC and the Arab Petroleum Exporting Countries Organization (APC) (OAPEC). In Saudi Arabia, large oil reserves and huge potential for oil production have had a major influence on the world petroleum market. Saudi accounts for about 25% of world oil reserves and contains 3% of world oil reserves. Through high- level visits to Saudi Arabia from India, diplomatic and commercial connections began in 1947. In 1955, King Saud arrived in India, while Indian Prime Minister Jawaharlal Nehru travelled to the Kingdom in 1956. Indian Prime Minister Gandhi subsequently visited Saudi Arabia in 1982 and strengthened diplomatic relations between the two countries. King Abdullah's extraordinary journey to India in 2006 led to the signing of the "Delhi Declaration," which gave new momentum

to bilateral ties between the two nations, and created a collaborative framework in all areas of mutual interest. The level of bilateral involvement was boosted with the Strategic Partnership in Saudi Arabia in 2010, and a spirit of enhanced political, economic and security cooperation was expressed in the Riyadh statement signed during its visit. His Excellency Prince Salman Bin Abdulaziz Al-Saud, Vice Premier and Kingdom of Saudi Arabia Defense Minister, visited the Crown Prince for further strengthening their links in 2014.

1.1 Background

India has ancient connections to Arabia.

Many Indians used to study medicine in Arabia. Arab traders introduced Islam as Islam grew in coastal towns in Kerala, Gujarat and other inland regions in the seventh century AD. Several Indians visited pilgrimage centres including Mecca, Madina, Bethlehem, Jerusalem, Najaf, Karbala, Mashad, Cairo and others.

The Indian shipping trade finally passed into Arab hands, which began to dominate the Red Sea, the Gulf and the Indian Ocean. Many Indian Hajis traded with local Arab women in the Holy Land.

A large number of Indian ships arrived in Jeddah and Calcutta from Calcutta, Surat and Bombay carrying cotton, textiles, silk, spices, gems and other products. Jeddah merchants gained large returns from Indian commodities which were then moved to Suez and Europe via Venice and Genoa. Interestedly, between 1661 and 1667, Aurangzeb was sent more missions to protest his brutal treatment of his father and his brothers by numerous Muslim foreign authorities such as the sheriff of Mecca and others. It was also usual for the wealthy Indian princess to give expensive contributions on Mecca's Sherife and Holy Squares since the Hashimi dynasty controlled Mecca in the 11th century.

VOLUME: 08, Issue 01, Paper id-IJIERM-VIII-I, February 2021

129 2 REVIEW OF LITERATURE

Various scholars have done a lot of study on Saudi Arabia's diversification economy.

The following are important. Important W.

A. Lewis, a type of school consultant, has produced a dual economic system model that indicates his division into an industry-including capitalism region and a non- capitalist sector with the agrarian segment. There was a glide between the two areas. The economic growth of the capitalist quarter depends on the drift of excessive pressure from the non-capitalist sector. The capitalist quarter which produces export commodities absorbs and accumulates labour. The normal area, on the other hand, has the right to manufacture the goods to be imported. In this view, trade abroad would surely contribute to market expansion and therefore to increased demand for goods in the capitalist industry. It also reduces labour wages. It would also enhance earnings, accumulate a section and contribute to monetary expansion. The notion of a freshly growing school (via Roomer, Lucas and Swenson) acknowledged that you want to increase production if you want to look ahead to industrialized countries. A number of models were developed especially to explore the link between technical advancement, international commerce and economic growth. You believe that technology development will promote the economic growth by offering a range of external incentives to boost global commerce. The technical transmission between foreign trading countries is unconscious (sometimes conscious). In a distinctive sense, a worldwide change that creates a better market where the universal alternative to recordings is no problem Each state is also compelled by protracted rivalry around the world to innovate and enhance new, applied sciences and goods. There is a harmonic reciprocal acceleration in the international realm between alternative and technical advances. This can be a realistic monetary boom in the long term.

Haierpoman Paul Krugman, economist for New Commerce Theory, moreover claimed that global commerce supports monetary expansion in two ways. The first thing he stressed was that the enlarged economy through trade has a significant influence

on growth. He also found that global alternatives contribute to the proper balance of available resources and resources. This equilibrium between the field of material production and the understanding of the industrial sector is maintained. Whenever criteria are favorable, the financial boom accelerates.

There are a range of empirical research studies which show that the global alternative has a positive influence on financial growth through increased capital accumulation, technological modernization, upgrades of industry and institutional advancement. More importantly, the expansion of imports for these items can also boost productivity in the manufacturing industry on local markets when intermediate goods and capital is no more available (Lee, 1995).

(Wagner, 2007) When Maizels (1963) became aware of seven developed nations' correlation, he discovered that the association between international alternative and financial advance was outstanding. Kavoussi (1984) found an efficient relationship between mid- and low- profit nations between better export growth and higher economic development rates after learning about the 73 countries. Conversely, the conventional outside option has led to global injustice, enhancing prosperous global locations at the expense of horrible countries. Myrdal (1956) writes: "Commerce does everything it can to choose wealthier and more advanced sites and disadvantage the less developed countries." Other economists like as Perish and Singer believe that global alternatives have delayed the progress of impoverished nations. In short, Nurkse says: "Even the unpredictable growth in international trade is actually preferable than no development." Given this age, trade between India and Saudi Arabia dates back to 0.33 thousand BC. But, if we study this relationship thoroughly, we discover that through 100 centuries AD, southern India- Arabia ties developed and formed a backbone of the Arab economy.

Arab traders were the only spice dealer to India's growing imperialist powers across Europe. India might declare it is the pioneers of the Third Saudi State exchange (Gauri 2013). Regular visits by leading authorities from every place in the

VOLUME: 08, Issue 01, Paper id-IJIERM-VIII-I, February 2021

130 rest of the world improve the changing

family members and strengthen existing partnerships. According to Pradhan (2012), one of the greatest steps in this direction was the signing of the Delhi Declaration in 2006. The paper focused on numerous important alternatives and focused on enhancing exchanges between different neighborhoods and on global concerns in the areas of education, health, energy, commerce, political cooperation and science and technology.

The 2010 statement from Riyadh adds to the previous statement. It has prepared India to make a huge leap beyond oil and change its relation to Saudi so that a strategic partnership may be established among the Kingdom of Companions. In his article Khan (2014) highlighted the relevance of alternative energy businesses in the Gulf of India.

Saudi Arabia's article (2007): From Oil to Market, Girijesh Pant emphasises Saudi Arabia's accession to the World Trade Organization in December 2005.

(WTO). He says that this rise represents the beginning of a new era in the economic governance of the country. This entry will require the state to warm, and the market must step m. It will be necessary to rewrite the social compact between State and society. In addition, the interaction must be made evident between home and global markets. This progress is not without its inconvenience.

As a result of market-driven development, property values have soared, in particular since watering the land is expensive. Food security is an obvious victim under these conditions but, given increasing demand and wishes, issues about subsidised services and infrastructural scenario based on the policy being pursued for another decade. The first alternate scenario examines the implications of false taxes and changes in privatisation.

The second examines the effects of altering petroleum phonies. Finally, she analyses what these internal options could entail for Saudi Arabia's relations with the OECD (OPEC). Although it is doubtful that Saudi Arabia will act independently in OPEC. We may expect that Saudi Arabia will continue to support OPEC on economic and political grounds.

Singh L. Man and L. Lahiri L.

(1997). "The Twenty-First Century Agenda

for India" presents a 21^st century agenda aimed at providing a perspective on India's foreign policy in the previous 50 years as well as the issues ahead for India in the 21^st century. This book helps to understand the effect of foreign policy changes in India, in particular foreign trade policy. The study must be revised and updated, on the other hand.

In the 'India-ASEAN trade cooperation and investment opportunities,' Behl, R. and Mago, L.D.

(1996) assert that growth rates in South- Eastern Asia were strong and are projected to continue. For example, ASEAN members had yearly growth rates of around 7 percent on average in 1994.

In addition, Indo-ASEAN joint ventures can develop to the advantage of India and ASEAN in sectors including infrastructure, investment and high-tech industries. The work should also be updated.

M. Azhar (1999) speaks of the influx of the Gulf countries' great oil money to produce the wealth and the prosperity they now enjoy, in his book

"Contemporary Gulf Economies and Indo- Gulf Relations." In recent years, however, declining oil sales and preparations for the post-oil future have been promoting economic diversification and reforms among the policy-makers of such economies. The first portion deals with Oman, Qatar, Kuwait, Bahrain and Iran's economic strategies and challenges. The second section of the book covers the bilateral economic relations of India with the aforementioned Gulf countries. The book explores economic links between the Indo- Gulf and how they might be strengthened in the future. However, not all Gulf nations, including Saudi Arabia, are covered in this book.

Ahluwalia's (1991) broad examination endeavors to break down the drawn out patterns in complete factor and halfway consider productivities the coordinated assembling area in India over the period from 1959-60 to 1985-86.

Ahluwalia, in her 1991 investigation on usefulness and development in Indian assembling, arrived at the determination that there was a stamped speed increase in absolute factor efficiency development (TFPG) in Indian assembling during the 1980s. As per her gauges, the

VOLUME: 08, Issue 01, Paper id-IJIERM-VIII-I, February 2021

131 development pace of TFP in Indian

assembling was 3.4 percent per annum in the period 1980-81 to 1985-86, as against an expected development pace of - 0.3 percent per annum for the period 1965 to 1979-80. Her appraisals of TFP development rate depended on the single- collapsed esteem added strategy, Balakrishnan and Pushpangadan (1994) and Rao (1996) have called attention to the insufficiencies of TFP gauges dependent on the single-flattened worth added proportion of yield, and have given solid contentions for utilizing the twofold emptied esteem added technique or the gross yield work structure.

Balakrishnan and Pushpangadan (1994) in their investigation, assessments of complete factor usefulness for total assembling having adapted to changes in relative cost. They contended for the different emptying of the yield and material info segments of significant worth added by their particular value files and against the utilization of a typical yield value deflator which Ahluwalia and others had utilized. Their outcomes show that, in opposition to what is accepted, efficiency development during the 1980s may, really, have been more slow than in the prior decade. They have attempted to show that estimation of genuine worth added by the twofold emptying technique, rather than single flattening strategy which is all the more broadly utilized by the analysts, it's difficult changes quantitatively the gauge of TFPG, yet in addition influences subjective decisions about the conduct of TFPG over the long run.

Dholakia and Dholakia (1994) discovered shortcoming on various focuses in the exact exercise detailed by Balakrishnan and Pushpangadan, for example (1) the investigation depends on the ASI information, however stays quiet on the changes for the non- revealing units; (2) presence of conglomeration predisposition in utilizing loads from input-yield exchange table which is additionally collected to frame 19 info bunches that may contort the outcomes;

(3) while the Balakrishnan and Pushpangadan study considers, best case scenario, a huge piece of the enlisted fabricating area just, the I-O table depends on the data sources and yields of

whole assembling area which can present huge inclinations and mutilate the deflator utilized, and so forth They have distinguished 19 info bunches as the segments of the general material contribution for the coordinated assembling area and have gotten their particular loads from the information yield exchanges framework arranged by the CSO for the reference year 1973-74 by renaming different classifications into these 19 gatherings yet as we have seen input-yield exchange grid, various enterprises utilizing various sorts of material info so 19 information bunches is a little gathering to utilizing weight in collapsing the material information.

An investigation by Balakrishnan et al. (1998) explores the pattern in usefulness development by receiving two methodologies for example development bookkeeping just as econometrics, two similarly standard methodologies for assessment which may yield altogether various outcomes. They utilized an example of 2300 firms and 11009 perceptions, spreading over the period 1988-89 to 1997-98 and discovered no proof of speed increase in usefulness development since the post change time frame however this investigation noticed a change in efficiency development from the year 1991-92 to 1997- 98. In any case, this period is excessively short for researching the effect of exchange progression on usefulness of assembling area.

Krishna and Mitra (1998) in their examination covering four Indian ventures tracked down that in the post- change period, markup declined altogether in three of the four enterprises, utilizing the primary relapse approach of Corridor to consider the impact of financial changes on markups in Indian enterprises and utilizing a post-change sham variable. The decline was to such a level that the markup boundary for firms dropped to a worth of short of what one, for example the firm would bring about misfortunes. They discovered proof of a critical positive impact of changes on mechanical efficiency.

Trivedi. et al. (2000) assessed the absolute efficiency and the complete factor usefulness (TFP) lists inside the development bookkeeping system utilizing

VOLUME: 08, Issue 01, Paper id-IJIERM-VIII-I, February 2021

132 translog record for assessment, whose

prevalence over the opponent efficiency files has been abundantly shown in the writing, utilizing both single and twofold collapse strategies. They are utilizing two elective arrangement of capital stock, one arrangement of capital stock determined by utilizing speculation deflator and another arrangement acquired by utilizing WPI for machine and instruments. They tracked down the Indian assembling area recorded positive paces of development of TP, TFP (single emptying technique) and TFP (twofold flattening strategy) in assembling area were 1.0 percent, 2.6 percent and 4.4 percent per annum, individually, during the period 1973-74 to 1997-98. Utilizing the twofold emptying strategy for assessing TFP is higher than the single collapse technique.

Speed increase of TFP development in Indian assembling during the post-change time frame in the investigations of Unel (2003), gauge of normal yearly development rate in TFP in total assembling is 1.8 percent per annum for the period 1979-80to 1990-91 and 2.5 percent for each annum for the period 1991-92 to 1997-98.2 The gauge depends on the worth added work structure, taking worth added as yield, and work and capital as sources of info. The pay portions of work and capital are utilized as loads for figuring the development pace of TFP. The primary inadequacy in his examination was Unel has not utilized a speculation arrangement before the base year to get a decent gauge of base year capital stock and not introduced the yield input arrangement in the paper nor clarified in adequate detail how yield of the assembling area has been estimated.

A generally lethargic development in TFP in Indian assembling in the post- change time frame, when contrasted with the pre-change time frame, has additionally been accounted for in an examination attempted as of late by the Goldar and Kumari (2002) significant industry bunches for the period 1981-82 to 1997-98. This examination has zeroed in on the effect of exchange change on efficiency development of Indian assembling area. Principle discoveries of the investigation are (I) Considerable advancement of imports in India during the 1990s, didn't bring about any flood in

fabricated imports nor did it's anything but a sharp ascent in the degree of import entrance in the assembling area. (ii) There was critical development in all out factor efficiency in Indian assembling during the 1980s. In the post-change time frame, there has been a remarkable decline in the development pace of TFP in assembling. (iii) The incubation slack in speculation ventures may have adversely affected efficiency and this seems, by all accounts, to be a significant reason for the deceleration in complete consider usefulness development Indian assembling during the 1990s.

Chand and Sen (2002) in their examinations discovered the impact of exchange progression on the TFPG Indian assembling utilizing board information on 30 businesses which represented 53% of gross worth added and 45 percent of work in assembling over this period more than 1973-74 to 1988-89. They measure insurance by the proportionate wedge between the Indian and U.S. cost and gauge TFPG in the three business bunches found the middle value of more than three non-covering periods: 1974-78, 1979-83 and 1984-88. They then, at that point relate this efficiency development to advancement. They discovered exchange changes India during this period, the Indian economy has seen a lethargic yet consistent progression of the exchange system relating to the assembling area and it has been that it has only centered around the moderate and capital products areas with little change in import controls on customer merchandise imports. The effect of the progression of the halfway merchandise area on usefulness ends up being genuinely critical in the entirety of their relapses.

An examination by Goldar and Kumari (2003) on efficiency and import progression, utilizing industry level information from Yearly Overview of Ventures (ASI) and consolidating some exchange – related factors unequivocally into the econometric investigation, assesses that there was considerable advancement of imports in India during the 1990s under the monetary changes program. This didn't, notwithstanding, bring about any flood in produced imports nor did it's anything but a sharp ascent in the degree of import infiltration in the

VOLUME: 08, Issue 01, Paper id-IJIERM-VIII-I, February 2021

133 assembling area. There was critical

development in all out figure efficiency Indian assembling during the 1980s. In the post-change time frame, there has been an outstanding reduction in the development pace of TFP in assembling.

The deceleration in usefulness development in assembling during the 1990s doesn't appear to have been brought about by import advancement.

Maybe, the decrease in compelling security to ventures seems to have favorably affected usefulness development in Indian enterprises. The principle impediment of this examination is the time taken for the post progression was excessively little. Inferable from the delay for post progression gauges, a drawn out point of view is important to notice the effect of such advancement on the economy. Since the Goldar and Kumari study requires just a seven years time frame, the outcomes/effect may not be solid or indisputable.

In the Goldar study (2004), assessments of TFP development for the time of pre-and post- change periods, depend on the gross yield work structure.

Worth of gross yield emptied by the discount value record for made items has been taken as the proportion of yield.

Three sources of info have been thought of: work, capital and transitional information. Number of workers has been taken as the proportion of work input. Net fixed capital stock at steady costs has been taken as the proportion of capital info. Consumption on materials, force and fuel flattened by the discount value list for fabricated items has been taken as the proportion of moderate information. The TFP gauges made in his investigation demonstrate a fall in the development pace of TFP in the post-change time frame. The normal yearly development rate in TFP is discovered to be 0.92 percent for the period 1981-82 to 1990-91 and 0.68 percent for the period 1991-92 to 1999-2000.

Kaur and Kiran (2008) investigation the patterns in yield and contributions just as halfway usefulness and absolute factor efficiency at total level just as at disaggregate level for 22 modern grouping. To figure complete factor usefulness development, they utilized Translog list strategy. The time frame for

the examination is 1980-81 to 2002-03, the entire period partition into two sub- periods: period I - pre change period 1980-81 to 1990-91 and period II – post change period 1991-92 to 2002-03. The investigation the information from Yearly Overview of Ventures by Focal Factual association, attempts to see the progressions in development of yield and data sources and efficiency in the pre and post change time frame. At aggregative level a generally speaking long haul development of 7.78 percent per annum in esteem included assembling area during 1980- 81 to 2002-03 is related with a fast development of capital for example 6.05 percent per annum and a low development of work for example 0.65 percent per annum. The gauge of absolute factor efficiency development of Indian assembling is 1.24 percent per annum over the whole period 1980-81 to 2002- 03.

Gupta (2008) has discovered that yield development in India till 1980s is related with factor gathering while the speed increase in the financial development in the post 1980s has been fundamentally because of the ascent in the efficiency development. He compute usefulness development by utilizing development bookkeeping procedures for the time of 1961 to 2004 and this period isolated into 1960-1980 and 1980-2004.

The outcomes for patterns in usefulness development shows that in 1960s the normal yearly TFP development was an unobtrusive 0.22%. It bended in to - 1.16% in 1970s and came to a normal of 1.63% from 1981 to 1990. Usefulness development rate increment to 2.57% to 2.95% to 3.08% from the period 1991- 1995 to 1996-2000 to 2001-2004. He additionally determined development pace of usefulness by utilizing human resources bookkeeping with Mincer Profit relapse. His experimental outcomes show that without representing human resources, contrasts in absolute factor usefulness throughout the time represents 48% to 69% of yield variety.

TFP development represents 35% to 70%

of the all out Gross domestic product development somewhere in the range of 1960 and 2004 relying upon proportion of human resources.

VOLUME: 08, Issue 01, Paper id-IJIERM-VIII-I, February 2021

134 Rajan et al. (2008) gauge

development pace of efficiency of three chose enterprises in coordinated assembling area utilizing customary development bookkeeping approach, over the time of 1973-73 to 2004-05. The whole examination partition into two stage for example pre-change period (1973-74 to 1992-93) and post-change period (1993-94 to 2004-05).

Development pace of efficiency of aluminum and refined oil based goods ventures expanded during the post advancement time frame though, usefulness development pace of iron and steel enterprises decay during post change ear. They additionally applied econometric creation work approach and tracks down that absolute factor usefulness development or the lingering factor assumes a vital part in development of the chose enterprises, and all around, in the assembling area of India

In the Das and Kalita study (2009), evaluations of TFP development for 2-digit areas are gotten by amassing up from the 3-digit industry level assessments, utilizing the Domar proportion of total efficiency development.

Further, an endeavor is additionally made to contrast the Domar proportion of usefulness and the total worth added measure, a procedure generally utilized in examinations on estimation of total efficiency development. Time of assessment of TFP began from 1980-81 to 1999-2000 and this period further separated into four sub period for example 1980-85, 1986-90, 1991-95 and 1996-2000. For the period 1980-85, we notice sharp variety in TFP development rates across the distinctive 2-digit businesses. A larger part of the ventures showed either negative or low sure development rates in TFP. The 10- business normal for the TFP development rate was negative, however the development in esteem added was around 3.41 percent per annum. The second time of 1986-90 affirming the halfway progression of the Indian economy showed a minor improvement to the extent the quantity of areas recording positive development in usefulness is concerned. The normal TFP development for the period is around 1.74 percent per

annum and records an improvement over the negative development saw in the primary time frame. The third time of 1991-95 the normal TFPG declined from that of the second 50% of the 1980s. The last sub-time of the examination, 1996- 2000, comprises the time of major financial changes that were begun in the last part of the 1980s and mid 1990s.

This period alongside the prior ones saw major upgrading of the exchange and mechanical business climate. True to form, we notice an improvement in the TFP development rates for the majority of the business gatherings.

Virmani and Hashim (2011) in their investigation expected a constructive outcome on development just as all out factor efficiency, which are relied upon to extensively follow a S-shape design in moving from the lower consistent state to a higher consistent state level. At more disaggregated level of assembling sub- areas we would expect a larger part of sub-areas to follow a S-bend design, yet to likewise track down some sub-areas that will truth be told decay since they are in a general sense non-serious. The riddle of India's changes was that such an example was to be sure found ensuing to the 1980s changes, yet no such example or maybe even a converse example was found after the 1990s changes. The last seemed to loan backing to the philosophical rivals of changes who related adverse consequences of efficiency to changes

Ghose and Biswas (2009) in their investigation attempted to clarify the intra-modern contrasts in TFPG, considering the impact of genuine compelling conversion standard alongside some other exchange related factors and furthermore some different determinants of TFPG, remembering that the impact of genuine successful swapping scale on a particular industry gathering will mutually rely upon development of exchange related factors and mechanical attributes of that specific industry bunch.

They clarify the variety in TFPG at disaggregated level of assembling ventures of India considering the distinctions in between modern construction and featuring the part of exchange related components. They discovered positive connection between Successful

VOLUME: 08, Issue 01, Paper id-IJIERM-VIII-I, February 2021

135 Conversion standard (REER) and TFPG,

examination in regards to the connection between genuine compelling swapping scale, other exchange related factors and TFPG comprehensively reports that practical change of genuine viable swapping scale and bringing down of duty, non-levy obstructions, moving of items from limited rundown to OGL classification may have contributed decidedly to Add up to Factor Usefulness Development of various assembling ventures.

There is a solid help for the effectiveness upgrading impacts of exchange progression the Indian setting.

Sen (2009) examine exchange change Indian assembling emphatically affects TFP development and an adverse consequence on the homegrown costs.

Sen discovers solid proof i.e decrease in quantitative limitations has positively affected All out Factor Efficiency. A decrease in cost twists, alongside an increment in intra-industry exchange middle and capital merchandise, showed a solid positive effect on Complete Factor Efficiency. Creator likewise tracks down that an expansion in amount contest from abroad adversely affects homegrown market power, and in homegrown costs.

Regarding value rivalry from abroad, he tracks down that the devaluation in swapping scale during the 1980s to 1990s may have had a countervailing impact on homegrown costs by giving more assurance to import-contending areas.

The net impact of cost rivalry from abroad was to such an extent that it's anything but an increment in homegrown costs and in homegrown market power, despite a decrease in levies since 1991.

Not very many issues in Indian financial improvement have produced such a lot of discussion than the estimation of TFPG in Indian assembling.

This discussion has heightened following the major financial changes in 1991.

Utilizing three unique strategies - development bookkeeping (non- parametric), creation work representing endogeniety (semi-parametric) and stochastic creation boondocks (parametric), Kathuria, Raj and Sen (2013) endeavor a vigor testing of efficiency gauges for coordinated and sloppy assembling areas in India for the

period from 1994-95 to 2005-06. Their outcomes demonstrate that TFP development of coordinated and chaotic area has varied extraordinarily during this period and that the evaluations are delicate to the procedure utilized. The creators accordingly recommend that any derivation on efficiency development in India since the financial changes of 1991 is contingent on the strategy for estimation utilized, and that there is no unambiguous picture arising on the course of progress in TFP development in post-change India.

Parameswaran (2014) inspects the usefulness development of Indian assembling industry during the post progression time frame. The investigation centers around two wellsprings of usefulness development that one could expect in a changing economy, specifically asset redistribution and making up for lost time. Utilizing firm-level board information for the period 1992-93 to 2005-06, the investigation shows that the segment of usefulness development accounted by the redistribution of assets to more useful firms isn't just critical yet additionally expanding over the long haul in larger part of the enterprises. With respect to making up for lost time, the investigation tracks down that in greater part of the businesses, the getting up to speed measure and ensuing assembly in efficiency across firms is available, especially during the second 50% of the examination time frame. The investigation additionally tracks down that, in the greater part of the ventures, sending out firms have higher efficiency and that asset portion to trading firms expanded industry-level usefulness. This gives proof to an extra wellspring of total usefulness development from exchange progression.

The examination shows that asset designation and making up for lost time, invigorated by the liberal strategy system and uplifted contest, represented a huge part of the efficiency development in greater part of the enterprises. As per the investigation, the meaning of asset designation and getting up to speed in the total usefulness development, hence, stresses the requirement for reciprocal strategy changes, for example, expulsion of limitations on the size of the firm, to boost the advantages from the all around

VOLUME: 08, Issue 01, Paper id-IJIERM-VIII-I, February 2021

136 executed changes, for example, exchange

advancement.

Datta (2014) in her investigation, gauges TFP development for the Indian enlisted fabricating area for the period 1980-81 to 2003-04. The examination is performed for the whole time frame just as for two sub-periods, 1980-81 to 1990- 91 and 1990-91 to 2003-04. The examination takes note of that the enrolled fabricating area at the all-India level seems to have fared much better as far as TFPG in the decade preceding progression in 1991 when contrasted with the post-advancement time frame. It is the pre-progression time frame that saw the most noteworthy pace of development of work usefulness, least pace of decrease in capital efficiency and consequently a similarly high pace of TFPG. The investigation additionally calls attention to that noticed fall in TFPG in the change time frame was more set apart during 1995-96 to 2003-04.

An investigation by Mehta (2014), measures the specialized failure for the coordinated assembling ventures in India by assessing the stochastic wilderness model with the time- shifting shortcoming model for the period, 1980-81 to 2005-06.

The examination additionally attempted to research the effect of changes on various innovation serious mechanical sub- gatherings — High-innovation (HT), Medium-High innovation (MHT), Medium- Low innovation (MLT) and Low-innovation (LT), a grouping set forward by the OECD.

The outcomes utilizing board dataset shows that there exists a more elevated level of shortcoming in the vast majority of the businesses in the assembling area in India. The outcomes at disaggregate level show that the LT enterprises which were close to the boondocks in the pre- change time frame, have seen a fall flat in their effectiveness level in the change period. The creator contends that the prior strategies for creation in the LT area became excess and the area stayed hesitant in receiving and dominating the new methods. On enterprises from the MHT mechanical sub-bunch the other hand, certain have seen an ascent in their effectiveness, level in the post-change period when contrasted with the pre- change time frame. The examination additionally noticed that high

shortcoming in the post-change time frame when contrasted with the pre- change time frame and expanding capital power in the change time frame have prompted lower work flexibility in the HT sub-bunch.

Bhandari et al. (2014) track down that the impacts of the monetary changes on TFP development of Indian assembling businesses utilizing an industry-level board dataset from 1980-2003. They utilize a nonparametric strategy, in particular, Information Envelopment Examination (DEA) to quantify TFP that likewise permits separating getting up to speed to the boondocks from shifts in the wilderness. The examination tracks down that the usefulness development in Indian assembling is mostly proficiency driven during the pre-change time frame and consistent specialized advancement has been the primary hindrance in accomplishing undeniable degrees of TFP during this period. The examination likewise discovers huge variety in execution across ventures. The investigation finds that changes neglected to add to usefulness development as TFP showed decay during the change time frame. In spite of huge specialized advancement, TFP declined because of absence of progress in specialized productivity. This demonstrates that most of the enterprises neglected to find the moving boondocks innovation, bringing about a lessening in their relative effectiveness. As indicated by the creators, the test before policymakers, consequently, lies in resolving the inquiry concerning what decreases proficiency and why the level of effectiveness has disintegrated regardless of the presentation of market-situated changes.

The examination finds that development in specialized advancement neglected to add to the usefulness development in Indian assembling businesses, owing basically to the inability to improve productivity in the post-change time frame.

While investigating the degree of local assembling execution of India, Babu and Raj (2014) track down that the topographical spread of modern action shows no huge change during the last over twenty years, in this way demonstrating that the supportive of

VOLUME: 08, Issue 01, Paper id-IJIERM-VIII-I, February 2021

137 market changes have not had the option

to adjust the local component of industrialization. The investigation keeps up that areas which were at that point industrialized in the previous arranging period keep on enlisting quicker development and receive rewards of early- mover benefits. What is considerably really intriguing, as indicated by the investigation, is the way that the states which have accepted the situation with early-movers in execution of changes, for example, Andhra Pradesh doesn't appear to have yielded critical results. Then again, there is by all accounts a convincing requirement for the mavericks, similar to West Bengal to speed up the cycle of industrialization as their offer declined significantly. The examination likewise finds that larger part of the states have seen a decrease in their particular offers highlighting an escalation of convergence of assembling movement in the time of monetary changes particularly in the western and southern areas of the country. The creators additionally cause an endeavor to break down the patterns in efficiency across states to comprehend the results of changes, assuming any, in speeding up usefulness development.

They report MPI of complete factor usefulness development (TFPG) assessed utilizing DEA. Their investigation noticed an improvement in TFPG in the greater part of the states during the changes time frame. The decay practice completed by the investigation takes note of that the majority of the states have recorded mechanical advancement in the changes time frame yet couldn't interpret the additions in innovation to higher usefulness development because of impressive decrease in productivity.

The examination by Saha (2014) endeavors to assess the total absolute factor usefulness for the Indian economy utilizing the traditional strategy for development bookkeeping over the time of 1961 to 2008. He saw that on a normal the TFP has developed by 1.49 percent during the 1961 to 2008. During 1961 to 1970 the normal TFP development in India was positive however it was low and it was near nothing. Similarly, the assembling area experienced on a normal negative TFP development during the period 1971 to 1980 inferring that rather

than specialized advancement, there had been mechanical relapse in the economy, he gave plausible motivations to low efficiency of the economy because of outer stuns like dry season, war, oil value climb alongside inflexible standards and guidelines.

The miniature level investigation by Das (2014), inspects the usefulness and proficiency of jute plants in India utilizing firm-level information for the coordinated area. The impact of changes on the presentation of the jute mechanical area is additionally inspected. The examination has utilized both the customary creation work approach and the non-parametric wilderness way to deal with assess the commitments of work and capital and the degree of proficiency and limit usage. By applying the regular creation work approach, this investigation sees that the commitment of work to yield development in jute industry was a lot higher than that of capital wherever in the country. As per the examination, the work's commitment saw a minor decrease when contrasted with that of capital during the changes time frame. The examination additionally tracks down that the business endure essentially based on modest work and crude materials with no huge innovative improvement. While utilizing non-parametric boondocks approach, the investigation sees that jute industry in India encountered a fall in specialized effectiveness during the 1980s. The 1990s, as per the examination, seen an improvement in specialized and scale effectiveness in the jute area yet this has been accomplished without huge mechanical advancement.

In any case, the productivity level and the ability to use the plant were essentially low even following one and a half decade of changes in India.

Harris (2000) contended that, inside a macroeconomic system, usefulness treat as an endogenous variable, in which the conversion scale system is either fixed or gliding. The intensity approach features that genuine conversion standard deteriorations speed up efficiency development in specific conditions.

Choudhri and Hakura (2000) investigate the impact of the example of global exchange and creation on the

VOLUME: 08, Issue 01, Paper id-IJIERM-VIII-I, February 2021

138 general usefulness development of a non-

industrial nation by assessing a multi- area structure dependent on Krugman's

"mechanical hole" model. They examine that impact of expanded receptiveness on usefulness development fluctuates across areas and the impact relies upon the development capability of the area. In low development (conventional) fabricating areas, expanded global exchange has next to zero impact on usefulness development. For medium-development areas, be that as it may, more noteworthy import rivalry is found to have a huge development improving impact.

Richard Harris (2001) gave proof for board model that upholds the intensity perspective on the positive short run impacts of conversion scale deterioration on usefulness for example in the short run the outcomes are reliable with the intensity theory which proposes that conversion standard deteriorations help usefulness development in the short run and the drawn out bad stock outcome as an of underestimated trade rates influences usefulness development for example genuine swapping scale deterioration have adverse results for long haul efficiency development.

Parida, Kamaiah and

Mathiyazhagan (2001) study the impacts of usefulness contrasts in the exchanged and non-exchanged sectors1 on genuine conversion scale with regards to India and Japan during the time of 1974 to 1998.

By applying the cointegration strategy, the examination presumes that notwithstanding the unit work costs differentials, the distinctions in efficiency in the exchanged and non-exchanged areas have a stable since a long time ago run balance relationship with genuine swapping scale. The outcomes support the B-L speculation in the structure of India. Disadvantage of the examination is they are excluded many exchanged products the exchanged area for the investigation.

MacDonald and Ricci (2001) additionally utilize the OECD sectoral information base to construct usefulness estimates which are then utilized in board relapses of the CPI-based genuine conversion scale. They find that when the contrast between usefulness in the exchanged and non-exchanged area is

entered as a differential it is effectively marked, emphatically critical and has a conceivable greatness, specifically, they discover a point gauge on relative efficiency of around 0.8, which is predictable with its understanding as the portion of consumption on non-exchanged merchandise. MacDonald and Ricci in any case, show that the Balassa–Samuelson expectation that the coefficients on usefulness in the exchanged and non- exchanged areas are equivalent and inverse and unequivocally dismissed.

Moreover, when the compensation is come into the board relapses the coefficient on efficiency on the exchanged area turns out to be altogether negative.

Without the Harrod-Balassa- Samuelson impact on genuine swapping scale, the Flek, Markova and Podpiera (2002) study predicts the genuine conversion standard of merging economies to devalue as opposed to the appreciate. Notwithstanding, their theory clarifying genuine conversion scale appreciation dependent on exogenous efficiency differential is by all accounts experimentally damaged. Taylor and Taylor (2004), the likelihood of time fluctuating Harrod-Balassa-Samuelson impact has been confirmed by considering direct and non-straight deterministic patterns. There might be an inclination that throughout some undefined time frame, the genuine harmony trade to move in light of between transient varieties in family member 1 They take producing merchandise were consider as exchanged products and non-assembling merchandise are treated as non- exchanged products efficiency differentials. The consideration of direct or non-straight deterministic patterns offer significant help in settling the riddles about how quick the conversion scale returns to its mean level Taking everything into account, Kohli (2002) has conveyed a period arrangement examination of genuine swapping scale of India during the new buoy time frame to test for mean inversion property. This examination applies unit root tests and difference proportion tests. She discovers proof of mean inversion in genuine conversion scale arrangement developed with the customer value file as deflator, just as for an arrangement built utilizing

VOLUME: 08, Issue 01, Paper id-IJIERM-VIII-I, February 2021

139 the proportion of discount and purchaser

value records to intermediary for portions of tradable and non-tradable products.

Prior time arrangement investigation of conversion scale for India are lacking as these examinations have not considered potential wellsprings of misspecification like primary breaks in the restrictive mean and afterward testing consistency and nonlinear reliance in the model with suitably determined contingent mean and difference.

For arising and non-industrial nations, Chinn (2000) gauges an efficiency based model of relative costs and genuine trade rates for nine East Asian economies and discovers clashing outcomes. The theory of efficiency driven genuine conversion standard appreciation is upheld for Japan, Malaysia, and Philippines yet not for quickly developing nations like China and Thailand in the time-arrangement tests; the board gauges support the usefulness impact with government spending and terms of exchange arising as irrelevant components.

Benigno and Thoenissen (2002) utilized a powerful model that incorporates home predisposition for the UK economy to find that efficiency improvement prompts devaluation of the genuine swapping scale. From both static and dynamic models, apparently efficiency improvement will bring down the cost of home products, and that this terms-of-exchange impact will convert into genuine devaluation of genuine conversion standard dependent on tradables. (Lee and Tang, 2007)

Jeanneney and Hua (2003), explore the effect of the enthusiasm for genuine swapping scale in China on absolute factor efficiency development.

They utilized DEA Malmquist lists to ascertain absolute factor usefulness development and run a board assessment of efficiency development. Their outcomes show that the enthusiasm for the genuine swapping scale unfavorably affected specialized advancement yet a great impact on proficiency development and these two impacts counterbalance each other somewhat to give a lesser adverse consequence on efficiency development.

Choudhri and Khan (2004), concentrate exclusively after non-

industrial nations. In a board test of 16 nations research the materialness of the Balassa-Samuelson impact on the since quite a while ago run conduct of genuine trade rates. They track down that the exchanged nontraded area usefulness development differential to be a critical determinant of the overall cost of nontraded products, thusly applying a huge impact upon the genuine conversion scale consequently giving a strong check of Balassa-Samuelson impacts for agricultural nations. The presentation of the assembling area as of late, especially in the post 1991 change period has been disputable and has drawn in the consideration of a few specialists. The investigation by Kaliappa (2004) uncovers that development of yield in the assembling area in the post-change time frame is "input driven" instead of proficiency driven. Assembling has been a motor of development in India in the seventies and eighties. After the 1991 monetary change, apparently the speed of the motor has eased back down. The investigation demonstrates that on a normal around 15% yield development can be accomplished by improving firms' productivity without expanding any information sources.

Christain (2004) in his examination utilizing "Another Open Economy Macroeconomic" (NOEM) model to contemplate the impact of an efficiency stun on conversion scale elements. He stretching out a standard NOEM model to join defective security market coordination and a particular for families' inclinations that includes a "finding the Joneses" impact can bring about a deferred conversion scale overshooting in the result of a usefulness stun.

Numerous investigations have inferred that efficiency stuns effectsly affect genuine swapping scale variances.

However, Annika (2005) in her investigation, investigate the since a long time ago run harmony connection between genuine conversion scale level and relative usefulness stuns utilizing VAR model. She experimentally shows the overall usefulness stuns are discovered to be the overwhelming wellspring of since a long time ago run developments in genuine trade rates. For five of the six genuine trade rates, 60– 90% of the

VOLUME: 08, Issue 01, Paper id-IJIERM-VIII-I, February 2021

140 lasting developments are because of

efficiency stuns.

Most experimental examinations which incorporate the Balassa-Samuelson impact either center around total proportions of usefulness or efficiency in the tradable area or the total Balassa- Samuelson term. MacDonald and Ricci (2005) utilized tradable area usefulness and non-tradable area efficiency independently in the model. They investigates the impact of the circulation area on the genuine conversion scale and other large scale factors just as controlling for the Balassa-Samuelson impact. They utilized ten nations information for the time of 1970 to 1991 gauge since quite a while ago run coefficients utilizing a board dynamic OLS assessor. Experimental proof recommends that with expansion in the efficiency and rivalry in the item market of the dissemination area concerning far off nations prompts an enthusiasm for the genuine swapping scale.

In the McLeod and Mileva (2011) study, estimates country fixed effects panel model of TFP growth on the real effective exchange rate and several standard control variables for 58 developing Countries for the period 1975 - 2004. According to the country fixed effects panel data estimates, 10%

depreciation of the real exchange is associated with a 0.2% increase in the average annual TFP growth rate.

Ray (2012), in her study assesses the impact of various determinants that affect total factor productivity growth in seventeen manufacturing industries during the period of 1980-81 to 2001-02.

In her analysis, she found trade variables as well as macro-economic variables have relevant significant impact on TFPG of those industries. The regression result of individual sector reveals that export is a negative determinant of total factor productivity growth in most of the energy intensive industries in India. But, many earlier studies on the trade-growth nexus imply that exports enhance productivity growth because firms exposed to international competition tend to absorb best-practice technology. The analysis also reveals that in most of the industries, real effective exchange rate has a significant negative impact on

productivity growth as is expected. It indicates that decrease in real effective exchange rate should increase the demand for traded industries’ output by stimulating export vis-à-vis enhances TFP growth.

Ghose and Biswas (2012) examine the impacts of real effective exchange rate along with other trade related variables and some technological-socio-economic variables on total -factor- productivity- growth of Indian Manufacturing sector.

Productivity growth is measured by Malmquist-Productivity-Index, using non- parametric Data-Envelopment- Analysis.

They found from the period of 1980-81 to 2001-2002, considering 17 industry groups, the average TFPG is reported as 3.90% per annum. The coefficient of Real Effective Exchange Rate (REER) is expected to be positive throughout the regressions and it happens so for four industries - Food Products Industry;

Paper, Paper Products Industry; Non - electrical Machinery Industry whereas;

the significance level is low for Wood, Wood Products Industry. Notably, with change in each of these variables the magnitude and responsiveness of TFPG vary across industries. Effective rate of protection as a proxy of measure of import liberalization and negative coefficient of ERP implieslowering of ERP has favorable effect on TFPG as shown by two industry groups - Metal Products Industry and Transport Industry.

There is a link between exchange rate volatility and productivity growth that is either positive or negative. The impact volatility in exchange rate depends on the level of financial development of the countries. Daillo (2012) used panel data instrumental variable regression and threshold effect estimation methods to study the link between total factor productivity growth and real effective exchange rate volatility on a sample of 74 countries (24 developed and 50 developing countries) on six non- overlapping sub- periods starting from 1975 to 2004. For developed nation, a rise in exchange rate volatility by 100%

reduces total factor productivity growth just by an amount equivalent to 0.362 percent point. But for developing nation, an increase in exchange rate volatility by 100% reduces total factor productivity

VOLUME: 08, Issue 01, Paper id-IJIERM-VIII-I, February 2021

141 growth by an amount equivalent to 2.41

percent points. This suggests that exchange rate volatility is more harmful to developing countries than to developed countries.

Biswas and Ghose (2012) measures technical efficiency using Stochastic-Frontier Production- Function at disaggregated level of West-Bengal’s manufacturing sector, employing 3-digit level data during 1980-1981 to 2001- 2002. They estimates the technical efficiency value then clubbed into corresponding 2-digit industry groups 14 in number.2 The information of technical efficiency for 2-digit industries are obtained by taking the average value of technical efficiency corresponding to their 3-digit classification. They observed that trade related variable like real effective exchangerate, effective rate of protection and import coverage ratio play significant role on technical efficiency. Other variables like firm size, real wage rate and capital labour ratio also have a significant impacts on manufacturing sector to test whether growth in India is export-led or import led at firm-level. They also investigate the relationship between export and import performance using a panel of firms from the Indian manufacturing industries for the period 1994–2006 and to obtained productivity growth rate of manufacturing sector, using Levinsohn and Petrin (2007) method. Results show that at industry level, the impact of imports on exports fluctuates, positive in transport equipment and pharmaceutical industries while in cotton textile, relation is weak and insignificant. This positive effect increases over a period of time. The role of productivity growth on exports is found to be significant at overall industry while mixed at the specific industry level.

Impact of real exchange rate found to be insignificant both at the overall industries and also across the industries. They found that imports and exports are inter- linked. Import intensity rather than exchange rate is a major factor in boosting exports as well as productivity.

Berka et al. (2014) investigate the link between sectoral total factor productivity and real exchange rates measures for countries in the Eurozone over the period of 1995-2009. They

construct a sticky price dynamic general equilibrium model to generate a cross- section and time series of real exchange rates data which can be directly compared. Assumption of a common currency, for the Eurozone, estimates from simulated regressions are very similar to the empirical estimates. Their findings contrast with previous studies that have found little relationship between productivity levels and the real exchange rate among high-income countries.

However, those studies have included country pairs which have a floating nominal exchange rate. They combine the panel of real exchange rates with measures of sectoral total factor productivities for each country and a separate measure of unit labor costs.

They conduct panel regressions of real exchange rates to explore the link between the productivity and real exchange rates. Their results indicate that for the Eurozone countries, there is substantial evidence of an amended Balassa-Samuelson effect. Total factor productivity increased in traded goods is associated with a real appreciation and total factor productivity increased in non- traded goods correlates with a real depreciation.

Das (2008) in his study found industry-level evidence regarding the connection between trade policy reforms and labour market indicators within organized manufacturing industries in India. The period of study is from 1980-81 to 1999-2000 in four phases of trade liberalization, 1980-85;1986-90; 1991-95, and 1996-2000, and the sample covers around 75 industries in the three-digit Classification of the Annual Survey of Industries. The study attempts to the connection between trade policy reforms and employment, labour productivity, and real wages growth in the organized manufacturing industries. Trade liberalization is quantified in terms of various trade policy indicators - customs tariff as well as non-tariff measures.

Using these quantified trade policy indicators, the paper examines the trends in employment, wages, and productivity in the organized manufacturing industries. The researcher observe that for organized manufacturing, successive phases of trade liberalization bring out a

VOLUME: 08, Issue 01, Paper id-IJIERM-VIII-I, February 2021

142 positive relationship between high labour

productivity growth and employment growth for a large number of industry groups.

Khundrakpam (2008) examines the behaviour of exchange rate pass- through to domestic prices in India after the reforms initiated in the early 1990s.

He finds a rise in exchange rate pass- through to domestic prices until recent years. Apart from economic factors that are usually associated with economic liberalization, a persistent higher inflation is a critical factor for the rise in pass- through.

Diallo (2010) used panel data and empirically investigate the relationship between real exchange rate and total factor productivity on a sample of 68 developed and developing countries for the period 1960-1999. The study puts forward argument to explain how productivity, technical efficacy and technological progress are affected by real exchange rate. He obtained productivity by using a Solow residual of an estimation of a Cobb- Douglas stochastic production function frontier. He empirically proved that an exchange rate appreciation causes an increase of total factor productivity and the relationship between real exchange rate and productivity is nonlinear. Total factor productivity rises by 4% due to 35% change in the real effective exchange rate. While the real exchange rate affects productivity negatively below the threshold the same affects productivity positively above the threshold.

A study done by Ben (2010) develops a dynamic structural model that captures the effect of plant level productivity and real exchange rate fluctuations on plant entry and exit decisions in the Canadian agricultural implements industry and finally it affects aggregate productivity. He used second stage simulation model to investigate the effects of shocks to the exchange rate process on aggregate industry productivity. The estimates of the study show that large real exchange rate shocks can have an immediate impact on aggregate productivity through plant turnover and little effect in the long run.

McMillan and Rodrik (2011) argue that applying the developed countries

inter-sectoral distribution of production to developing countries (holding unchanged their sectoral productivity levels) would entail productivity gains ranging from 100% for India to 1000% for Senegal.

Mustafa and Firat (2011) empirically examine the impact of the level and the volatility of the real exchange rate on firm level productivity growth, conditional on firms’ access to domestic and foreign equity markets, and to debt finance. They used a unique panel of the top 1,000 private manufacturing sector firms from a major emerging market, Turkey, covering the 1993-2005 period. The study finds that firm productivity is negatively affected by exchange rate appreciation and the effect is significant economically and statistically. Further, the negative productivity growth impacts of exchange rate shocks is not reduced either by availability of external credit or access to foreign or domestic equity market. The study also concludes that productivity growth of export-oriented firms significantly hurts more severely than inward oriented firms by exchange rate uncertainty.

The above study is close to a recent paper by Mcloed and Mileva (2011).

Using simulations of a two-sector open economy growth model based on Matsuyama (1992) and panel estimates for 58 countries, they conclude that a weaker real exchange rate can lead to a growth surge, as workers transfer from non-traded goods sectors with slower productivity growth to traded good industries characterized by more learning by doing.

However, the approach of the letter study differs conceptually from the former study. While the McMillan and Rodrik Study tested whether the growth impact of real exchange rate undervaluation operates through an economy-wide productivity improvement, the Mcloed and Mileva study focuses on the level of the exchange rate rather than its misalign. They exclusively discussed the appreciation and depreciation phases without commenting on the equilibrium real exchange rate. Their approach seems preferable since it takes into account the probable evolution of the equilibrium real exchange rate over time.