52
1 1401 # $%&
108 - 81 ) (
2021 - 2001
∗1 2
# )* + ,- 1
+.
/
0 , 1 2
3 2
7 / ,48 45 6 9
: *
; 2
< = ,1 0 , 1
3> ?,- - @
1 A B / C . 4 4. 9D E
; C A B
@ 0 2 B F )
?
* ,8 9 (
?,
- , I1 45 # , /
J 9
: *
;D 0 , K.L B
I1 C , = C B 1
A B 1 0 ,2 B MN A :
/, - B 1 / C L B / , / . = . 45 8 9D E 4
$1
L K.L A OD
9D E ) . A %4 = ,
/ J P1 . 9 24; = .
4
B
#Q
$4 ( R 8 : -A . & 3 ,D B
4 9
# N A : 1 . 2?
/ C B 1
. 4 B 9 MN I1 # ,U < ; 45 ,
/ C ,NC V
- . 4 9D E W=
2 . =*
9D E
X ? B C B B / , C B 1
/ Y 4 . .
,1 B Z;
B B / A /,NB :[ ;
7 $ 4;BA W=
U,V 3C \D ]Q 4
/ C B 1 8 .
4 B ,4;- 9 ^
,2 .8 / 3 = C A
B _ 0 ,2 4* , A . 1 X B
F J ` D # ,U
B 9 C B 1 / A
,2B #Q $1 4 .
45 / 9D E , .
= . a C
$1 3C \D 9B , B -
. N1
,J b ? ? /
06 c .d8 M4
= . 3 ,D ` D 94V B / , C
A
$1 e
% : 8
. %
4*
C ,NC f , /
. = # Y 9D E 0 g24
B 4V C \D / C 0 . 8
%4
.
` D 9D E C B 1 / 0 4 X # h& $ ] e,4;-
1 B J )1 i
C / C / 9
* =8
# J 9
* , / / C B 1 0 4
= .
: 1 9B 4 . / C B 1 9D E ,
B Z;
/ C B ,N / I1 # , 7 $ 4;BA
at
B ∗
B ] j; .;
=V B `B 1 :
25 ,5 1398 m1 `B 1 MB : 30 ,5 1401
DOI: 10.22059/JPQ.2022.283591.1007449 © University of Tehran
82
52 1 1401
1 .
, K.L 0 B D A OD 9 5 :
/ ; * ML
. , I1 0
C / =
9D E 4 . .
b ? ? / C B 1
4.
4;C 0 ,$
/ # X 3B @V * ,8
9 ? / m4X J ML
9D E B 1 < ;
) Japan Ministry of Defense, 2021:
16-20
.(
: 9B ?,-
nP1 B V ,IL B @ : * : / BA ,
- , / < ;
.4 9D E . B 1 3B D
/ C B 1 / CA, 94 , 0 A 4 . 9B
B V ,IL MN
4 . c , I1 6 B 1 < ; 9D E 0 4
. 9B .8
C @ B 8 j;
06 =; , K.L 0 J , _ / 0 ,$ C
C /
+.
/ 9
* V 9D E 5 A < ; MN 9
* / , 8 9B ,
C ,NC , I1 C
/ 0 ,$ 9B B 2> D C
. 3C \D 9B o 6 D
> D B 2 6 Z M* X 3 ,D
p,+
: .1
. / C B 1 2?
4 B 9 MN
I1 # ,U < ; V / C ,NC 45 ,
- . 4 W= 9D E 2
. 9D E =*
X ? B C C B 1 B B / , /
W= Y 4 .
U,V ]Q 4 3C \D
8 . / C B 1 4
B ,4;- 9 ,2 q.8 ^
/
A 3 = C B
_ 0 ,2 4* , A . 1 X B
F J ` D # ,U
B A C B 1 9
45 4 . #Q $1 ,2B / /
9D E =q
. qU,V Mq X q.N 9qB ,q
rV 8 = 4 B
$ 9D E 8 B
= C / 45 X /
) 9 q 0 X
J / C @ =; 8 = . (
9B ` D C B 1
q =q
C q =q8,
9D E / . / 45 # , I1 0
C / q B 2>q D / ,q q8 q4 . q
4 . 9B :[ ; Z 4;C
. 9D E ` D .B ,V 9B qX A ,q- :
qC q q : 1 .
I1 X # h& / # , s
2 . )1 C i / qC / q 9 q * 7q e,4;q-
N L qB
#Q q$4 q B, . a qC q $1 3C \qD 9qB ,q B
- q q. N1
,J b ? ? /
c .d8 M4 06
= 1
. q.? q qL 1 q I4
, / q tq$ u qU 0
C = 9B qv : $1 3C \D =q 2
. 3q ,D q `q D 94V qB / ,q $1 e A qC
q :
% 8 4* . % C ,NC f ,
/ . = # q Y 9D E 0 g24q
B 4V %4 0 . 8 C \D / C .
1. Copenhagen School
2. Causal Analysis
"#$
% # &" '#() * (+ ,' - . / (0 ' . -*
83
2 . :
/ C B 1 , I1 ] 4 .
,4;- / ph A C / 4;C / ? X b6 N 8 1
0 ; / C
B /,N / C / : , - .
K.L ?,- 9 Z 4;
= 3C 8 ] C 8 -
, / C / 7 $ #h X
] 4;BA
.4;C 3B @V .
9B A 7N1, :[ ;
+ $ = .
@V R B.
/ = . ,
9 C M* _ C 8 j;
MN =
/ C B 1 1 ,2
C / 06 7N1,
u U A B / C
:V $ &
9
* :B N1 .
L A
/ V
C B 1 9B / , ,nw ^B, / C C 9B 1 A .8 / C B 1 - o D
B F
= , Q
/ MN ,2B / A 06 0 =>
/ , # . / C ,NC ,R
06 C
) Florescu & Glenn, 2015: 6
.(
, <
. ,J 2018
1 D 0 @
_ / C B 1 0 A B 1 4. ,
. # , I1 b6
B C ,B A /,NB / C
4;C / C B 1 . 4. / C B 1 /
* ,8
...
= 4V,- D
.,2019) Poushter &
Huang
B(
A B C , / 9 7 B L 8 : *
,4;- )
. =
^ A ,1 D 3
= x .d8 M4 45 . .
0 C / B b 48 M4 9 C
B .
=* ,
< ,C C
) 0 A 1378
? ? (
, A 1 /
$1 . :
=
) 0 ,2B 0 A 1386
(
,V / A /
. , /
* 0 A B
B D B
@ / . A - B B 0 A A
D B
& 0 g- B
9 B ,
» . = B ) .?
/ ,2 B
=;
«
) C , 1386 : 445
.(
B 9
. ) 2 =
.1 J =;
A : C
/ L B ,1 . 0 A #,L C
/
.L B ,V ,V
$ 7 AB m4X V =;
/ Z .
,1 B 4 9 0 A 8
. ) .? = /
,)1 B } .8 I1 45 # , /
J 9
@V : * B
24; 3
: 4 C 8 0 3B D
L / C B 1 B
/ , ,- . B ,)1 9 B . A } 0 A =
) .1 .
,8 L 1 .
=
&
% #
9 C~Q [ .8 .
B . 2 9 =
% • 8
» ) L 45 ,
2«
= 2
) 0 A 1379 : 13 .(
C ,)1 9 B } 9 C~Q .) B . A
$1 8 = MN = :
C / B 9 B K ,
A 2 5 2 ,
) C , 1393 : 16 - 15 (
€ m5 .
1 % B
,J. A
,J B
=* 8 B C B 1 x .d8 M4 0 A ,D 6 C
,
; D o ) /
/ BA
= . J :[ ; .1 , 4 : $1 / ,
/
=*
1 8 C .
8
45 . 6 C B 1 ,BA
M gD B , /
=*
C 2 #P } 4> ^ . A 1 ,
.
1.PEW
2. Socially constructed
84
52 1 1401
B ^ . 9 J 1
_ J , , . B . 9 D = B / ) .?
/ - ,V = ,
) . A 1396 : 182 - 180
.(
€ m5 A 0 ,2 .8 %
B . A 0 ,2
=
* n6
& ^L, =* 0 A . :[ ;
4 ,)1 B }
) 0 A 1378
] (
C / A _6 B 9
C 1990 . ^L , e,4;- C _ 0 ,2 .8 =
4* , ,- C / 4L 4;C
Z
) ,m / 1390 : 116
.(
A B ,- ,V ,J. 9 C
/ ,V 0 A C / _ 4* , ,V
,V ,1 C
B Z;
=* .8 0 1 . ^L , 0 .
4 ,8 m1
) C , 1386 : 443 (
B .
9B 4
@ ,8 8
=V C
% 1 0 A 1 B C
6 M gD B , / C
; . 1 /
A A C / J B _ J , 6 L B.
J.
B . :[ ; 8g . 4
6 B.
B 7 U X R
•> i /
8
06 A C B
L :[ ; } /
.1 4
B @ A ..8 = +
) C , ,V . /
1394 : 25 (
.
B
@- x .d8 M4 4 9 C
/
? 06 A .
,X %4 .
.4V,- :
=;>
$1 . #Q $1 : 4
9D E ah5, B
C , /
^X ,- B 8 .1 ,
=* 3 C
A 0 . B
& 0 ,2 =
9 8P1 : * A
B M4 ,
c .d8 A 945 . =
B _ 0 ,2 4* , , 4V,-
= . B @- 9
0 - 2 B
A 8 0 9 B
,2 .
,- C / ,1 B 4;
0 A B
B @
^L , 0 . 1
B , ..8 . 6 / C B 1
/ 6 9D E ` D
J :[ ; = X
# X 9 C
/ +.
/ 9
*
& @- 0 . ,X ,J
=; 8 4V,2 B
8,1 , N ) .? 2 /
) / . ,1 B / C B 1 Z;
7 $ :[ ; B B / A /,NB
K.L 4;BA C
/
=* 5 C
1 / ,
. D B .d8 M4 0 L 1 x
,V B / C . 4L
9 C~Q . 0 =
1 B B =&,V 9 ,8 ZC ,V
2 A .1 C B 1 1
0 4
=*
C A
2 , , 1 @ B ‚ . . ,J [ C
/ )4 B
9 4 4 =; 8 B
9
- B
= .
3 .
!"#$ % # &' () *
2021 - 1991
. #Q $1 , 4
, K.L ;D .N , 9D E
/ B -\
C / ,2 .8 . 7N1, /
. 7N1, :[ ; =
9 . 1 : * /
C / J 0 1
A ) 2001 -
1991 2021 - 1991 (
; 1 ,8 Z . L 5 = 9D E 4 . / C ,NC
2001 - 1945 , 4 $
: 1 . 1,1 . # N 4 9D E - B, 2 .
$ B
= C / 0 X
1. Failed States
"#$
% # &" '#() * (+ ,' - . / (0 ' . -*
85
) 9 ( C ,
/ J $ .1 8 B
F , / u V F? 8 -
A -
1 5
= 3 . eh1 C / B 1 d , F / ,X, / ‚ &
# Nn
) Saltzman, 2014: 7
. (
%*w C /
&
/ C ,NC .
4 9D E # )* + < , 9 D
7 &h5 ,BA ] L .
:
1 / 1 . 3 4 5 $-6 # -* 7 8 9
, 2001 - 1945
3 4 5
?6
1 .
; L Z8
J 3>
B ; B A , 06 0 $ C
A ,4 8 2 8 L :8 A &
. (Attwell, 2016:
55-59)
2 . _ 7 ;1 J , . :[ ; , 0 4
],4.8 8 B
C , / 1 ,8 , F
C , / J .
»6 9D E u V O E
2«
>1 A : 8 C
B # A .
# A L 5
s B A 06 :8, B
A L 5 , B
, . (Atanassova-
Cornelis, 2007: 5)
3 .D 2 , / L 5 =
# 1
.N , $ /
» ,48 B B 9
3« ^ . € m45
) 1 8 m4X
/ J ) 1 .
(Robinson, 2010:
313Atanassova- Cornelis, 2007: 4)
4 . r C , / J 6 g- 9D E c 5 B, /
1 J
B 9
, 8 D <
C 0 / V - . 4 N L 1954 D 0 C / ).
1960 1976 1997
و 2000 , 9D E )1 /
C K.L 0 N L
: 4 # . (Robinson, 2010:
313;Söderberg, 2005: 1)
5 .
‚ & K.C,V + N R
C .C / J U ,-
/ : 1 ) L ‚+
,•8 B 0 X ) L = 1947
9 )
‚ & . ( , /
-,C 1 = =8, B
. 1 = / C / J . (Atanassova-
Cornelis, 2007: 4)
6 . X =8 ‚ & 7N1, :[ ;
9 ,4 s: * X
C M*
/
# : 0 A 7N1, .
/ , ] • m1 0 1 B
C 0 X M /
C , /
.D E : 0 A ‚ & ƒ% # 1992
r A L 8 ,8
$ C , / 4 D # 8 1 N
9D E B 9
# . (Robinson, 2010:
314)
] • R 9D E r
# „ N 8 ‚ & ƒ%
) ,N 4d 1992 ,N 4d q
1993 ( N A F ) 1993 E q B 1995 ( 0Q L / C / . )
V A B 1996
0 .8 1 ( 1 X, ) ,N 1999 - V B 2000 .(
(Miyaoka, 2011:
245;Singh, 2002:
83)
7 . 0 8 4 Bd
m4X / F 8 C /
* , / 0 ,$ : C
/
. 4 9
* . 5 K.L
… C ,U 9D E 8 < V A , †
/
F 8 s .8 ] K.L @
Q / ,8 %48 . (Miyaoka, 2011:
245)
^N.
:
0 - 2
1.Self-Defense Forces
2. Japan Defense Agency (JDA) 3. Yoshida Doctrine
86
52 1 1401
, B 9 B -\
C 0 8 C ZC : ZC 9D E /,J ‡ $*
C 1 † B :
A L / , / J :[ ; r .
4 s=
OD A 2001 =8, C )
D 6 , 4
/ I1 A _6 . 45 # ,
4 4;C 9D E A Z
B ) ] 9 I1
# ,
. = 4 Q b 4 9D E B
- ,
) Söderberg, 2005: 2 (
4 .
/ ,4 Z V
A C / I1 A ,nP4
•5 # , C
/ I1 A , D
A OD 3 2001
] L
2 [ .
1 / 2 .
@0 A
$ $-6 # #$ 1()B , 9 –
CD E F 2001 CD
#$
2021 - 2001
, 0 J , _ # J 3>
C / V ) ] • :
, L 5 # A + . =
4
u V O E6 $ 3 .(
# X - , / J 0 ) ] • : N1 B u V O E6 :
>1 A 2006
J 0 „ 5 + A
L 5 # A
.(
$ B
* 1 =
;1 e ,V # $
) ] • :
.
* 1 = e ,V
;1
# $ .(
B » 1 0 A V # @
« 0 X 94 ,
$ B
;1 & = # $
2014 ) ] • : )
C ,X / C 8 $ e ,V B
. 0 4; 2
.C
* ,4 .(
J L } 9 )1 )
] • : A ,4 8 B F
* 1 A &
5 •* 5 .(
@V B 3 J L )
] • : m1 B ,1Q M B L 9
J 1 B 9D E ` 2020
.(
K.L r / , 94 A L
C /
A, ,V . ) ] • : K.L 94 r C
/
5
… 0 4; IV , < V .(
;%1 0 X , 0 ,$ r A L
C /
L 5 ) ] • :
;%1 0 X , 2015
.(
=8, _ #
J , N 4 D ) ] • :
=8, 0 X
# : 0 A ‚ & ƒ%
1992 ( ..
=8, J #
) ] • : A A N /
B B
* 5
0 … .(
8
% Q = / 4; * 3>
4 D N ) ] • :
F 8
=5 # -
, / K.L
IV 0 4;
.(
8 N
% 1 = / 1 J # @ )
] • : ,5 B
D 4V, ,1 B
F 9
C C /
2.L B, A
, B g- / , @8, 1 F
C / 4;*
F
@V B 3 AB , B B C A 16 22 ,V .(
24; ] )%
B, : 8 )
] • : ,
5 K.L M .
… 0 4; IV , < V
U B4 B, .(
1 B L = B . $1 9D E 2 4
N L
) ] • : A . C : )* 4 /
B, - 9D E
2015 8P1 3 , ,V6 B.
9D E
$4 0 . /
] )V .(
. 7 4 ) ] • : B, N L $1 -
9D E .(
, e,4;-
=8 C / . 4 +.
/ 9
*
N L .?
,- B ) ] • : C ) ) . / C
4
* ,4 .C N L .?
C 8 / 1 06 6 .(
V )
] • : 1 : 8 =%* >
B ) =
J .(
gD B
* j; e, =
C 9D E ,4 /
. 4
L < ; 1 A
B J ) = )
] • :
4 B . ,J … 0 X # h& C
.(
^N.
:
0 - 2
"#$
% # &" '#() * (+ ,' - . / (0 ' . -*
87
# h& 1 +. 4
# &
4V,-
=;
/ C . 1 3B @V , 5 *
9D E ) L L a, , I1 9D E J . A
J :[ ;
= . ,D 8
p,+ 3> 9B 0 B D ? #Q $1 9B Y / C B 1 3 8 = 9B
eh1 W=
1 3 ,D 8g
` D .
4 .
!"#$ %/ 0 # 1 % # !2 3 2 ) ] C / 5 , . V .
4 )4 / . B p,R 1 B C / L B nP1 ,
06 C , .
= 9D E 45 ,D 8
A L 0 1
: )* 4 C / u V ,
) 2010 ( , 0
u V #
….D 1
, 9D E * /
] C / 2023 - 2019
) Japan
Ministry of Defense, December 2018
* ] / , V , : )* 4 (
2019
06 A ,1 ,V 9D E u V # A . 2
2021
Japan Ministry of Defense, 2021) (
,8 . ) t$N 9B Z
,1 B _ / C B 1 9 4. ,
=$1 9D E = . 8
nP1 ,X , .
9B
M 1,1
# N A /,NB / C B 1 Z;B ,1
7 $ :[ ; B B / A
5 K.L 4;BA
=*
C /
/ C / , - .
4 . 1 . 1 ) 2 45
,1 B 8 Z;
A ,V f ,V
,- B
= 5 6
_ 0 ,2BA / A = @ 4* ,
C =B
Honna, 2015: 293)
(
5 = . / , / L B 1 9
* :B N1
=
) Japan Ministry of Defense, 2021: 15
.(
a,&
Z;B ,1 8 3B @V A ,J
=* Z;B ,1 = C % 8 , I1 - @ 4 . :r) C
= ,8
) Hughes, 1998: 40
.(
9D E B C 8 A ,X C 8 =
4;B ,1 / C
/ , 8 = 0 1
,BA ,8
: A - B
8 1 ,4 9
1995 ) a ,) ,1 B 9 B ,1 B 4;
5 9D E ) (
5800 5A 13
4 8 (
M g- / C / .& , B ^
3 ;4 1974 ) 207 5A 8 4 8 ( 0 45
/ 8 C 0 4 B
D 1976
) 80 5A 2 4 8 ( 8 B 9 L /
40
2000 D , )
10 5A ( 4 B
1 ;1 A 1994 5
) 600 5A 7
4 8 ( 8 n
6 B 1998 ) 67 5A 4
4 8 (
Asai & Arnold,)
1.Medium Term Defense Program
2.National Defense Program Guidelines for FY 2019 and Beyond 3. Mitsubishi
4. Yosakoi-Soran 5. Matsumoto sarin 6. Wakayama
88
52 1 1401
(2003
0 4 8 24
.D E R / C
11 ,N 4d 2001 0 - ,- - , / .D E 0 ,2 ,-
A O 1
<
2015 ) 5A ,% 0 4 8 ,% 0
B ,2 ( / A
h ,- B 0 B ]
) Yu, 2016: 119
.D E 0 , A ,% 0 4 8 (
2015 A
,1 ,- / B
4;
3
) Zarate, 2016: 4
4;B ,1 / C (
K.C C B E
2016 1 8 L
) Zarate, 2016: 7
M (
g- / 2018 / m4X M 6 . B 1 c
9D E
) Zarate, 2016: 8
. (
4V B 9B,4
$1 / C :
B C /
1Q ,BA : :
1 . ,4 X / C
M 6 .D E 0 , 8 „ 5 4;B ,1 ,- / A
C / .1
s= h 4;B ,1 2
. 4;B ,1 / C
4V,- 8 4; R Z
06 a C .D E 0 , A
,4 8 ,_ / C 8 0 , Z 4; / C
s=
3 . A OD 1995 .D E 0 , 0 ,X a C , ,4 8 4;B ,1 / C
nP1 , ,4 g-,
/ ,
= C / 4 @8, 1 8 1
) Pietrzyk, 2016: 199
. (
/ , ] •
a C 3 / C , / A .D E , 0 4 8 =B 0 ,8 }X 4
U ah4[ A 9D E =* *
= 3 s2
4 . 9D E m1 B 0 .
# X A C
/
m4X / FB A 6
M C / m4X / ,1 B A Z;
/ B ,2 B
@- 9
,1 8 B Z;
; ) .1 )
0 , 0 L B 1 (
m4X A /
@
D C /
%.
/, 2 ?
$1 9D E ,
= ,8 : .
4 . 2 . 3 2 ) 62 7
- ,4;- / C
B ,N / ) Nq # hR =X, : qC
/ q4*
qJ
AB
=5 , C / (...
06 94V ,V ] q q8 =q q MN / CA, A C
qC /
,q 5 q /,NB q / C qB 1 qN1 q L 3* q?
B : q
) Information Security Policy
Council Japan, 2013: 1 Japan Ministry of Defense, 2021: 11-16;
q C q (
* 9 q :
, rV 0 . 8 5 /
A / rV C B 9 A A OD 0 .
» Kq.L Z .D 0 «
..8 }B,)1
) Florescu & Glenn, 2015: 7 (
.
B , 9 B 7 8 ?,C /
24;q
q ,4 /
.V / 6 ˆ,) ,4 4 = ,4.B ,X M
- ,
) Noor, 2015: 160 (
.
1 . / , B # hR =V
@L ,4 B # X i
,1 ‰ ,1
B 4;
0 L 0 L .D E 0 245
06
) (Pietrzyk, 2016: 198
.
2 . A B 5 A 6 @.
] ,V B F 8 )1 200
Q 0 / 9D E B
U ah4[ A = MN 3
,$1 B F B ,1 ,- 9 B
4;
X Vh1 L B .D E 0 ,
) Yu, 2016: 119
.(
"#$
% # &" '#() * (+ ,' - . / (0 ' . -*
89
/ 9D E B
A ‚+ 9B,1Q A B
=5 , C /
= 0 L 1 , >
. 9B 3B @V
.) # R N1 # hR / .V A %4 ‚+
/ 6 M gD B , / /Q u , , 9D E
/ C B 1
= 4 ,4.B )
Information Security Policy Council Japan, 2013: 1
.(
0
C 8
/ 9D E 0 L 6 ? N1
M gD B , / / C B 1 =N;
B 4 ,4.
,X .
9B
Š ZX 6 A 3 , , M
gD B , / .L ,8 . B 6 / C 8 ,B . BA * ,4
= D 2.
) Dardenne, 2018: 1
( A .
Z L
,1 B 9 ] /,NB / C C
/ , 5
0 1 ;4 =8,
) x @ ,1 B 9D E V D 9 (
C /
B / =8, 9B )
Z4;
C / F =5 ,R f , .2.L / C D C C
(
) Dardenne, 2018: 1
( /,NB / C 2015
A 3 m> # hR 0 V
,% 0 )
Kallender &Hughes: 2017: 122
( 1000 N /,NB
C / 4*
06 7N1, @8 , 2016
)
Dardenne, 2018: 1
( / C
?
=8, 9 C
/
& m5
8 9;8 =5 A ] )V B
19 . #
B B ,N / / A
/ 0 A C / A 7N1, /
C / d * 8 1 F
Japan Ministry of Defense, 2021: 22) (
,8 . B 6 A 0 @ 9 M
gD B , / . ,J 1 = MN /,NB / C B 1 , ,
4V,- 2018
,)1 9D E , ,J A 4 . B 1 9 4;> /,NB / C B
} .
1 / 3 . 7H -B ' . -I. ,
#( J K3B * " L$- 9
# X 9 ? ~ %
4;C , /
* ,8
3 L # , I1
b6 C
/,NB / C C 8 ,B
8
82 67 63 86 81 .L ,8
69 73 52 75 81 ,
56 61 79 67 69 9 d V
51 47 59 60 58 * ,4
43 57 81 56 56 /@
56 61 63 67 69 9 2
^N.
: (Poushter & Huang, 2019: 3)
€ m5 P . 4;B ,1 / C
[ 0 ,2 .8 A 4 0 1 :
] ,-
,- € >
C / ,1 B 4;
4* , _ 0 ,2BA s
=* ,- 0 ,2 .8 C
4 : )
Dardenne, 2018: 2
.(
, D <
3 B , 4. . O 2021
/ A ,NC 4
/ . = B ,N
1/
* ,8
? .8 9 A A
B
& 0 ,2
1. Cybersecurity Strategic Headquarters (CSHQ)
90
52 1 1401
1 B . ..8 = B ,N / , / V,) 9D E .
A <
B B 4 9 B
8 9
1 ] B
= X
= C / B ,N / ) B J A \ (
/ C B ,N / a C
m4X /
.4;C
) Won-Gi, 2021
.(
,
<
6 40 A &
/,NB / C
9D E 2014
= 4V,- # & 9 ? / A .
B 8 8 9 B
A rV 9
;C = X ] C rV .4
/ A / N1 Z .D 0
B ,8 :
) Kallender&
Hughes, 2017: 139
.(
4 +.
B - = X 9 9D E 0 4V ,
B 1 5,?
J /A
,NB / rV 8 C 5
@V A B . 1 3 /
C / J B
,N / A NX B F
/ C B ,N / A / B = ,2
) Baylon, 2014: 7
.(
6 c M gD B , / / C B 1 , , 9D E B
,N /
$ . 7 4 6 , 6 B
/
$ B
= C / X 9D E L 1 / C
=V,- C 5 # & ,4 C B 1 .
i + 9
A J %4 0 X .V
/ . C u 9
u U MN
=
; 8 /
. 1 A /
C X / C _ A 9D E J ,
‚ & %4 6
@
&h5 .
C 9 . A ,- /,NB / C 0 .
,NC C / %4 0 4
}B,)1 9 / C , })U A Z .8
2 6 0 1 5 9D E })U 2? 8 ,8 c
4 X B 2> D / C @ = )X 9D E 94V,- ,X 9 %4 ‹ MN
D B 9
= 9B,B =N; ,1 .
B B .V j; 9 /
C / rV B
= 9D E .
B j; 9 \B
] C / , 5
= X C / A } 4> / C 8 9 B rV L
< ; ; B rV J ) t$ 9 ?
) Suzuki, 2014: 30 (
.
4 . 3 . 8 2
%2
C C / L K.L A OD A 6
C / L 5 =
* 9D E B
= C / . =
,
<
m4X i+.
/
& 5 D B B
@ /
) Attwell, 2016: 66 (
B .
i+. 9
4;>
D 9 B . B = . 9 r1 /, / A6 B B = / ,NC f +5
1 Z ; 9D E / m4X = . / , 9D E / , u U 9B 8 B L 1
j;
/ 1 1
) Japan Ministry of Defense, 2021: 32
.(
] C / , 5
B B / C, ; . B B / A 4 D R
N•1 4 . ,2 FB 0 .
=
= . L P1 A ,2 < ; 9B
, 6 = . 9 C
/ 9
* = .
X / C / C B 1 B 2> D J MN J
0 4V,- 9D E
FB 0 .
@L 8
B , / D [E < ; 7B , 4
,B 24; 4 . ] )% 7B , F
P1 / , C 8 = . 9
=
) Japan Ministry of Defense, 2013: 243
9 C (
"#$
% # &" '#() * (+ ,' - . / (0 ' . -*
91
< ; u , / , 8 9B c,$ - X
B C 0 ,$ ` D / , C
= .
# $( . 1 . ' P Q R 8
#$ Q $E$
' '
#$ S 9T U+ * 2018
Statista, 2019 :^N.
4 . 4 . ( 96) :; 5 9
8 2 05
?,- / C,+5 7 $
4;BA
= L
6 +.
X ,B A 3 6 <
= ,nP4 j; 9B A iR . .
,X ,U ] 0
V A B NR ^ ) 6 +.
-
D
% F ,4 B € m45 5 0 L 9 .
, 6 <
0 ] C /
1970 1 2011 2
6 ,% 0 ,n
V B NR ^ ) 4 8 8
B 9 0 @
75 V # % 1 :8 A &
B : 0 L , , ^
) Femia & Werrell, 2015:
(14
. @ 9D E
@L 8 FB 0 . B
, / 6 +.
- D A / C B 1 A F %
b6 # , I1 A / C B 1 =; 0 + $ # , I1 C
MN =
8
# , I1 4. / C B 1 .8 b6
B C 3* ? A B 0 .
C / m1 = .
) Japan Ministry of Defense, 2021: 22
.(
, <
…B 4
$1 i D # $1 @8, ,2
C
. A I1 7 $ # ,
4;BA
@L
‹ ,2
&
9D E ,
= .
:BQ ,2 I1 A 9D E 7 $ # ,
4;BA 0 1
,BA # &
,8 ,8~
:
1 .
@L B , / A A ,2 9D E 0 B
, 9 A 3B ,- ,n 8 9B 94V b6
) Chowdhury, 2017: 14
( s 2 . , V NR ^ . ) 1 B D 9D E m4X I1
7 $ # ,
4;BA ) A 6 ^ . 94V 0 /
C . 2
, / A 8 / (...
s 3 . , A <,1 B
D =
I1 7 $ # ,
C 8 4;BA /
; C B 9D E .
- / B D
, / C /
= 5 6 B @V / m4X D ,V @ B 1 CA, 3.1 X, _ #,L B D 3
s/A, iR . 4
. ^ . N 8 B 3C 8 / ,NC
) B g_ B B ^ . .
/, 2 C (...
92
52 1 1401
b6 ^ . =B,B 3.1 C
/ A, ,V / 4 7 ;1 / , C 8 0 = X B
^ . ,
) Council for Security Cooperation in the Asia Pacific, 2010: 2
.(
D B B 0
8 =%- + $ = .
B L ) /
Z ? @V L = . A
) Florescu & Glenn,
2015: 7
8 (
9B MN u U / V ,IL , I1
= C / C 8 V
) Youngs, 2014: 13 (
/ 8 ,- 0 9B ] .
. / , J AQ / C @ 9D E
` D 1 Nn
. 7 $ / C B 1 A
4 4;BA ,B A 3
. <,1 < ; C 8 .8
.
1 / 4 . 7H -B ' , ' HB 9
#(
"
- 3 J
8 . B 1
* 4
&
8 **
4 . B 1
&
I1 L # , b6
39 C I1
L # , b6
52 C
# X ~ %
39 B, 1 Nn
9 *
50 *
9 ? 1 Nn
9 *
38 *
* ,4
4;C , /
* ,8
47
4;C , /
* ,8
77
I1 L # , b6
59 C
? ~ % # X
74 9 1 Nn
9 *
56 *
9D E I1 L # , b6
72 C
@ / ,- C / .1 / h 49
~ % # X B,
60
1 Nn 9 *
* 47
,- C / .1 / h
34 4;C ,
/
* ,8 45
0 4;8 D 1 Nn 0 4;8 D
23
@*
/ 4;C , / 0 ,B 44
I1 L # , b6 C 85
I1 L # , b6 C 66
1 Nn 9 *
* 83
4;C , /
* ,8 61
,8 .L 4;C , /
* ,8 82
V d 9 ,- C / .1 / h 60
= B*) : Z ,1 B . / C B 1 9 4
s
**
& , ,2 0 @ (
ﻊﺒﻨﻣ : (Pew Research Center, 2013: 5)
4 . 5 . /=# > ?
% 0@1 A 3
) L A , 9
* L 3* ? B
/ . , X L =
L 06 =
f , ZC
D C / 9
*
=*
C / =
) Tokyo Foundation, 2008: 9 (
?,- .
11 ,N 4d nP1 =$1 9D E = . Z 4; R
,X , 0 4 8 0 4 B
B 0 ,$ 0 B,L .D E , /
nP1 A Z 4; , =*
, B
,8 X 9D E = . .
- , D 9D E 0 C
/
%.
=*
C / A
B F
"#$
% # &" '#() * (+ ,' - . / (0 ' . -*
93
D / , L : A J / C @ =; 8 # ,U 2
, / ],4.8 =B,B
K.L C / ,2B / A .. / C 8 5 ,J p,R MN
B C
€ m5 , I1
C @ / 4 . J N 4 D / m4X A B 2> D ,+5
/ C A
=*
C / ..
.
4 . 6 . C 3 D#1
# : E@ F 1
2 1 G1
u / C / D /,; , - B
B L / `B 1 ] R =;
C 4V %1
= . ) .? + /
3> 945 , - 0 C
/ ) L } 4>
/ C / /,;
R ] ) 4 2 = . ‚ & J , _ / C B 1 A B 0 . .
L 1 / C D 9 2.
/ / C /,;
9B u U M .1 7B , .?
4
8 /
= . 0 A :
$4 ,X 4V,-
= 8 A L 0 1
MB m1
.)+X B C
€ m5 A B
) .)+X 1308 1983 ]
/ C 2000 2011 ( Q
) .)+X 2177 2014
( ,8
) r X 6 / 1399 : 189 - 188 (
,8 / .
0 .
A 9B,1 B L /
/ C C - =N; , C
/ ,4;- 3> 5 A 3 D ,1
/
45 , - /, ^ L A =
9 C j;
= )U 0 L , , 1 MN
h / ,+U
) Allgayer & Kanemoto, 2021; OECD, 2020
.(
9D E , 9B A @
N .•4 6 C
/ 9B A _6 0 A A 8 Z 2020
8 9B # )V
» / ,+U = )U «
h
) Japan Extends, 2021
.(
B C 8 L A 9D E ?,-
# 1 iV < ,B u * : , 8 11
4 8
C / 06
5000 X ,%
B E A 6 9B 2021
3B @V # B
=V ZX 1
14000 ,% @C
) Aoki, 2021
.(
5 . H 3 2 ) !"#$ %2 IJ7 " 3 63#
_ / C B 1 , 4. ,
B ,C 8 06 A = B
,8~ / C B 1 A F 4;L, 3
/
I1 .C~ , = 4 9D E 0 4 3 ,D s
/ C 8
B A 9 p,+ .
B 9D E 4 . #Q $1 /,4 0A C B 1 8 Q / C B 1 0 A 8 = 9
4 / C ,NC , I1 J ` D @ 9D E C B 1 9B ,?
,8 4 .
B W= 2? C B 1 9B 9D E ` D = =%- B =;> 3 ,D ` D
8 ,J 8 B C B 1
,X ,+5 ˆ,) 9D E = . Z 4; R
.C nP1 9D E 4 . # , I1 , C B 1 ,B A 3 g-,
. 9 C . A
94
52 1 1401
B C B 1 .
8 B B / A . Z 4; R
/E, = . /, / A6 B B =
8 9B / 1 f +5 m4X i+. 8
/ ) , B 9B,48 <
( 6 B D , 9D E
= g-
B 1 ..8
/,NB / C B 1 B 8
4* 0 8 ZC Z 4; R
,X ,+5 ˆ,) 9D E ) L ZC .C
B 7 $ / C B 1 =
n6 4;BA
06 A …4.
) ) NR ^ . c,4 =B,B L
/ m4X B L - .C .D #,L
- , / C / /A, ( 8 D E 4;BA . A, / rV Z 4; R 9
B 1 .8
=N;
=* / C B 1 C
/ B
= L , I1 , ,4 Z;B ,1 -
, / g-,n 9D E 0 ,NC
.
€ m5 C B 1 ,B =N; B 1 9B b >4 = 4 .? 0 1
,X L 1 :
=;>
[E = )X t$
D 4 9D E )
@L = )U B
, / 8 9B
7 $ # , I1 A B 0 ,nP4
4;BA 1
P1 9
= X A C /
B B 7 $ , , 9 ? / m4X (
f +5 = . ƒ% # ,U B
B ) 24;
6 / C, ; 9D E B 9
* / , P1
^ . 9 ( )1 2B L 9
4;L, ..8
9D E ) L m4X / .V .
3 ,D ` D )
J / C @ =; 8 9D E @* B ,?
( B 4 .?
,X ,J :
1 . 6 M C / . ^ 4 m4X / ^R X # ,U B
C B 1 9
2 . 8 B
= C / 9D E L )
_ / C @ J ,
( D 2 , / C B 1 ` D
) Pietrzyk, 2016: 197
3 (
. / . 1 J # X A $+ 0 # ,U
C B 1 9B =B $ 0 ^B, B 2> D 4
. L # J4 9D E A 1
, /
=8 J ,4
: * 1 B /Q / m4X .V
/ 4V, D
) Zarate, 2016: 9 (
5 . $1 / ,NC 9D E B,
= 5 C
/ B , 8 9 /
C , C J # .
` D 3 ,D )
/ C ,NC B 2> D
9D E
=N;
1 B C / 9B ( B
-
=%
8 1 3 D A
@C C
X C / 9D E .4N , / C @ J , _
9B
8 ,R A B F 8 i C /
* P 3 / %B N 4 D 4 , B
= C /
9 * .
: 0 A ‚ & ƒ% # =5 ,D
) The Advisory Panel, 2014:
(15
] .
C / ,J , 5 4
9 / C B 1 B 2> D / C ,NC 9D E 4 . 9B
> u .1 4 . #hr) 5 .
3> 9B 0 1
A 4 X C ,8 ,8~
:
1 . 5 # h&
) I1 : X # ,
/ ( 2 . )1 e,4;- C i
/ C /
9 * 8 B j; 9
6 R .
/ ,NC O ).
=
) Japan
1 . / , ] • 0 ; .8 $4 : 0 A
€ m5
= 1 8 0 B B / A B B / A b 8, C
,2B B B ..8 / C : 8 R
) Japan Ministry of Defense, 2013: 243 .(
"#$
% # &" '#() * (+ ,' - . / (0 ' . -*
95
Ministry of Defense, 2021: 23-33
.(
/ , 2013
4;>
9 ,NC . = 9D E
, 9D E 8 ,8 h C :& <
/ 9
* Q )V =8
/ A ‚ & .
B ,8 C 5
) Tatsumi, 2014
.(
.N , / B 6 C . 9 ] 8 Z
C / 5 9D E ,
eh1 C / , 5 / C e,4;- /
C / 9
* A . :[ ; . 4
7N1, :[ ;
= e,4;- ‚ &
. / , 1
eh1 0 , 9D E
/ r B ah4[ =
1 hR a ,)
» Z ? ….D
1« A : 4 8 B
#Q
* ,4 8 $4 .*A
= 0 4; 2 ,8
) Won-Gi, 2021
.(
B r ,2 B
= B 8 9
» 8 ,-
2«
* ,4 .C B, A : 4 9D E
) Kutty & Basrur, 2021
,1 (
B …
%
» B.
-
D
% F A6 A
3« / A B
,- 9
=
Japan Ministry of Defense, 2021: 1-2) (
.
0 @V , . A o 6 9B , 6 @.
=;>
AB 9D E 9 D , ,
6B B 9
,U ] 8 = iV 1
m5
€ / C B 1 .
=
` D C /
06
= 6 L s
B 8 # & 9 B
. 8P1 ^ L = 1 ,
. ) =
4 ,J 9 C 4. / C B 1 0 @ _
, 4.
J 9
Z8 : * L Z8 / B ,
m4X / P1 . 9 = $1 B
#Q
= 4V,- $4 .
B 9 B 9D E ,
. a C 0 ,8 ,4;- 4
/ . . A =Y % 4 . 7 $ N , =
9
* ; = . 9 r1 L ‚+ ? , D 7 $ ? ...
45 ,D
= ,NC
A . =
4
= 4; 8 :
1 . 1 B C 45 = /
5
) 0 X ‡ $* ? g-
/ ‡ $* ? /
( 2 . 1 B $1 = B
#Q $4 0 .
& 0 4 .
= 9D E 3 . 1 e,4;- B
C = /
C / +.
/ 9
* , /
3* ? C
/ 4. / C B 1 Y .
J A / C B 1
B 9
. 4 B A =%- 0 4 /
B B 4;> A C @ =; 8 8
/ J 5
B
= . , X <
~ >1 9 2009
9D E 4 8 A =; 1
C / : 1
.8 =JV $ B B / A , , .
0 @V 9B ,
= L @ ph A %4 0
) Japan
Ministry of Defense, 2013: 244 (
/ , ) ] 9B A .
9 4;>
/ C , @ C
U N L .? =B P 5 A u V B C , : )1 B B / A
A , _ B
#Q $4
) / C 40
,2B 8 (
$ / , 4 8 A =JV
C / : 0 … 5 / 1
4;C * Z
) Vosse, 2016: 2 (
.
1. The Five Eyes Alliance
2. Quad
3. The “Free and Open Indo-Pacific” (FOIP)
96
52 1 1401
6 . K
; ?,- /
$1 A : C . #Q $1
4 9D E B
C , /
^X ,- B @8, 1
, / C B 1
?
* ,8 9
4* 0 ,2 .8 0 . 1
B # & A -
, B 9
eh1 4
@- =; 8 C
/ , x .d8 M4 3
/ C B 1 _
4. ,
. #Q $1 4
45 ,D 9D E .
4 ,J =; 8 9
@- C / / $ M4
x .d8 .
A 3 B _ 0 ,2 4* , ,V / C B 1
A, ,V / . _ = J ,
1 3 B _ 4. , I1 , ,nw . # ,
4 2 C 8 45 ,D 9D E 06
C B -\
C B
. . nP1 ^ g-, / A, ,V / 0
= , ,4;- <
=; 8 # ,U Q
C @ / _ J , 06 : c,4 C
. L C c ,4
B 9 C B 1
B -\
C / Q 4 0 B L 1 # %1 g-,n 0 @
/ ,C # B
A F C B 1 ,
. = 9D E 06 D
. #Q $1 4
B
= 8 9
. A B B A / C B 1
_ 4. , g-,n /
06 I1 , C C ,NC ,
/ . 4 9D E 1 4 ,J 8 =%- 0 9
)X D [E < ; = 4
F B 24; 8 9 B
m4X / L 5 # R N1 06
.o C .V K ,D 3 9 /
1 9D E ) L m4X B
A / B B / C
B ,N / I1 # , 7 $ 4;BA A 3 B , C B 1 .
=*
C / B
,1 B Z;
/ C / ,;
/
= L , -
, / C / .8 nP1 9D E =*
g-, .
,C B 9 C B 1
,NC # @*
/ , /
= ,)1 9D E 0 g- B
L 06 A 8 ,8 } 0 1
u .1
>
C ,NC C @ /
2> D B s ,8 U I1 8 A , B C , /
m4X / B C , / J A N L ,- B N L .?
,- B D C / /, 2 ? ,
. 45 = 4
L , 9D E /
.4 g- . D B 0 B
; 9D E 8 =%- ,
/ 1
Q R , / - , / J : 8 0 ,$ :[ ;
C / L B L s
9 4;>
A , B ,V 9 B I1 A N . : 8 ,
9 0 X B
= 8 9
.
B .;
0 - h 8 ..
C,D : 3C \D h5 :[ ; 1 L ^V . ˆ )1 8 A A @
/
4 B ] 3 A B 1 * F 3C \D ,
B 0 ,2 A
/ B :)L
^N. C A / :)L
U ^ . B = C -6 E B 3C \D 4V ‹
_ , R : 8 B = ,8 .
L=Ĥ 1 N
O@#
(
%7 Q 1 . C , N
• ) . 1393 0 6 (
» , B
; / . % ,5P4 M1 = .
4 V « . m # )* +
,NC / 17 66 : 30 - 7 . : http://quarterly.risstudies.org/article_11559.html
