23 2
1400
442 - 429
: !"
! "
#
#
$ % &
'
*1 2
! 3
" # "$
2
1 . .& ' ' () $ )" *) +' , ! $ -. / $ 0 )
2 1 " .2) . .& ' ' () $ )" *) +' , ! $ -. / $ 0 1
3
*) $34 .
$ )"
5 $34 &
& 6 7 $ / .& & !8
: : ; < = 8 19
/ 09 / 1398 : : ; B C4 = 8 10
/ 03 / 1399
!
"
#$
% . # ' (#
) *+
, ( - )!
# . / % 01 . -
"
2 3) 4 ) ) 5 6
# *" 1 78 9 # : ; 1 < => "
. # ? # @A
# ) .
-
! B - 8 -
" # ) E "
F)8 )
G ) 2 G8 ( 100ppm
, ( ( FL
6 ) 500ppm 250 (
! . . B
- O PQ 8-HQS
% . %*1 ! ' #
,R(
%*G
>
(#
-# !
! 4 S
* # + - 1 4 ? $ 8 T) U #
)!
/ V)
?) 6
! - ) . W *
! L
B . # %"
- 250ppm , ( FL 4 * # 9 6
/ 8 ! 6 # 5)
- + V Z ' 6 . * % V3 -#
[ 3 ! L\
# ) ppm
500
*@ 6 F B % V3 # ? -
O PQ 8-HQS
# +
% -#
V . [ 3 ! - # %" #$
# ) B - , ( FL
250ppm O 4 * # 9 ( % V3
# )
*B Q #
%
# ) 8-HQS B - ] O # -
; .
# ! - ( * F) )
T1 # ^LS L
L " # . / S .V
V)
* , ( *"
* F*1 ! ' # W
/ # * " O P V)
?)
*B 4 # @_ . Q #
% 8-HQS 4
=> "
2 3Z .
`8
% ' (#
, ( - )!
% S V) 9 T_ / ) )
a
*"
#
%*
6 2 Z O b V 6 P).
) )
* S V( "
.
4[ 3 ! :
V) S a 4 ?)
4 !
. 4 # @_
8 -
" # ) E "
F)8 ) 2 G8 ( .
Comparison of Vase Life and Quality of Gerbera in Preservative Solutions Including Essential Oils and Chemicals
Hanifeh Seyed Hajizadeh1*, Zohreh Maani 2, Fataneh Yari3 and Fahimeh Gholizadeh Vakilkandi2
1. Associate Professor. Department of Horticultural Sciences and engineering, Faculty of Agriculture, University of Maragheh, Maragheh, Iran 2. M.Sc. Student, Department of Horticultural Sciences and engineering, Faculty of Agriculture, University of Maragheh, Maragheh, Iran
3. Assistant Professor, of Department of Agriculture, Iranian Research Organization for Science and Technology (IROST), Tehran, Iran Received: December 10, 2019 Accepted: May 30, 2020
Abstract
Water imbalance and vascular occlusion are two serious factors in sort lasting of cut gerbera. In order to evaluate the potentials of essential oils as an alternative to chemicals in the protective solution, a factorial experiment has been conducted in a completely randomized design with four replications. The treatments contain 8-hydroxyquinoline sulfate (0, 100 ppm) and thyme and savory essential oils (250, 500 ppm).
Preservative solutions include distilled water and 8-HQS, both considered as the controls. Every day in a week, in addition to evaluating flower longevity, physiological parameters, plant water relations, and bactericidal population are measured. Results show that the protective solution with 250ppm of thyme essential oil offer 8.6 days longer vase life than the control. The 500ppm savory displays the best performance to protect the petal membrane stability, compared to both controls (distilled water or 8-HQS) at the end of the experiment.
Gerbera petals, treated with thyme essential oil at 250 ppm, are fresher, having higher water content than other treatments, even in comparison with 8-HQS. During longevity, anthocyanin and dry matter have had an increasing trend with the Tss, showing a decreasing trend. The antibacterial properties of the essential oils have been significantly established in respect to the desired results of growth controlling of the microbial population in the preservative solution, even compared to 8-HQS, so it seems that the essential oils are a good alternative for antibacterial chemicals and can even reduce the harmful environmental side-effect of conventional preservative.
Keywords: Antimicrobial properties, petal water balance, preservative solution, vase life, 8-hydroxyquinoline sulfate.
1 .
c 6 (#
! -
%S 4 d#
U #
? $ 8 ) )e)+
# )!
%
# ' 5 "
2 a
2] <.
# ) 6 )8
6 (##
V(
.
#
;
# ,+
6 4V
% V / U
6
% / 2
# 4F) + -
47(
V ;#
3
4F) + )!
U 5 6
%/
)
Wagstaff et al.,
.(2010
5
#
%
"# ;
% 6 2 ))f
P
# )!
. 6
% / F 2 ))f
%
4 ! g+
))f 4h # iT # 5b 6
)!
/
4 ! [ 3 !
% /
# )
Jiang, 2012
(.
/
i6#
- <*9 6
! -
%S 4 V) 9
- `+ 1 ]
%*
=]
# ) "
# . 6 F
# 4
% ! i>
- 5 T1 -# !
6 j ;
* "
- )+
G*(
6 V(
-6#
-
?)* $ - # )
4 ) )
# 5 "
2 a ,+
6
* Zk )
Kharrazi et al.,
(.2017
#$
(Gerbera jamesonii)
? 6 l@
F
! -
%S i6#
<*9 - ]
# V
!
# "
-
%3 #
# @A
#
# F)
! -
%
S m <*S .V(
?L ,+
6 V
F
! 4
"
;
# Z S
! )
F* ?
!
! g+
V(
)
KousheshSaba &
Nazari, 2017
(.
7 \ . - 01 . - B
8-HQS
* 4
%"
7)"
) )
* G*( #
#
-# ) 6
! 6
% /
#$
)
Soad et al., 2011
(
V(
.
%A ! 3)"
# )
! -
* >(
n )
Shanan et al., 2010
.(
F V)
- *"
L"
%*
% 5 T1 O`/
O
% g 6
%"
6# " (
%
? G*(
)
Asrar, 2011
.(
6
# #
*(
-
`B c 5 "
G*(
6 3)"
2
T* ( 4- Q)Q.
2 6 - - T_ / ) )
)3;
T!
i#
-
* - L
%"
)!
# - # 3)"
V) S
* ) "
* #
? 8 )
Nakano & Asada, 1981
G 2 Z ( )
" 0GB # V)G)
-
! 6 -
%S
8 o * T) )
Bayat et al., 2013
4(
^b) )
Shanan et al.,
(2010
- )
Bidarigh, 2015
(# 2 3Z % ( )
.V(
F)_ )
;
! -
* 8 l9#
Sacramento
# ) O
PQ
( )
16 / 17 6 # 4
8 B#
%"
F)_ )
;
! -
# ) 50
)
!
#
*)8
" # "
6# " ( 16 / 21
! 6 # -
# ) 100
)
!
#
*)8 , ( )!
# 6
46# " ( 20 6 #
>
V(
)
Sabzmeidan et al.,
(2012
. 5 T1
;
!
#$
6 VG 6 #
) (
% 11 6 #
#
# ) 15
*)8 ?)
#
*)8 ) 6
)(#
5 "
V) /
4 ?)
3@
6 3
5 T1 O`/
. !
%
!g - a
?)
, ( - )!
2#q Q V3 V(
(KousheshSaba & Nazari, 2017)
.
F % %/
%"
, ( - )!
2 3)"
)3;
F F T_ /
3(
- ) )
G*( #
# 5 T1 !
! -
%S
(Bayat et al., 2010)
. a B 5 g+ 6 c
(#
Q1 ? V) / T_
F
"
2 3) 3;
)
#
Q 7)"
) )
# 0GB 2 ) <S G)"
5 T1
-# !
! -
%S
#$
.
2 .
! -
%S
#$
)
Gerbera jamesonii L.
( 6
% b ! -#
d 1 4%\ ) (
#
% B r -#
6 )
# @A
# s 6
%e ! - /# S ( )A
% 1>
% _L 6 Q*
. ,R(
# 6 O
T)
%9 (
% t G # 35
* (
*
% 2#
i 6
# ) .
7)"
- -# )
G*( # 2# 3
6
T0
= O PQ
4( )
T1
=
8-HQS ppm
100 + 6# " ( 3 4 #
T2
= , ( 6
250ppm
+ 6# " ( 3 4 #
T3
= , ( 6 500ppm
+
6# " ( 3 4 #
T4
= , ( FL
250ppm
+ 6# " (
3 4 #
T5
= , ( FL
500ppm
+ 6# " ( 3
# . ,R(
!
# - 1 10±
%/#
* (
!
V ;#
3 65 - 60
# + *1
12 V (
# 12
V (
#
?
# 9 . *1 ! VG
!
# 78 9 : ; => "
1 <
9 2 G
% 2#
5 6
# *" 1
# 78 9 : ;
=> "
1 <
# @A
# ?
# *" 1) :
- # ) .
01 .
# 6
yP(
# *" 1 :
6
% -#
# 4 (yP(
V1 !
%(
6 #
^
# V -#
.
S
! )
%9 ( 5) 6 90 4%/#
! g+
[ 3 !
_* ?
%9 (
% lE>
+
;
# '
%*1 ! 6 #
L F lE>
%
;
! V
)
Macnish et al., 2008;
Getaspolus et al., 1999
(.
- F)) 2 3Z - L\
8 (
MSI)
# Q ( 2 / 0
!
6 [ 3 ! -
# ?
#
# - ( / 6 "
#
% U(
*EC
T) VL
#
% 7)
% 2#
c1
c2
VE 9 G*(
6
%P # ) 1 (
# Q
% V(
)
Sairam et al., 1997
.(
%P # ) 1 (
= 1 − × 100
V Z + -#
L\
(%)
) T "
) 2 # "
% i #
Irigoyen et al.
) (1992
9 VE ) T O`/
#
; } 625
*
! F) )( * .
[ 3 ! j P i #
Bariola et al.
) (1999
6 - )!
G*(
6
* *1 *?R(
UV-1800, Shimadzu, Japan)
# (
; } 530 657
* T) O`/
VE 9
G*(
6
%P # ) 2 ( 4
# Q
@
%3( . .
/ . U(
* *" 1#
8 *) )
Japan, Atago
DA-A1
( 6 - )!
.
%P # ) 2 (
Anthocyanin =D530 – 0.24 D657
- *.
3 O [ 3 ! ) 1
(RWC
- *.
O
[ 3 !
(PWC) ٢
% 7) G*(
6 6 L"
%)8
[ 3 !
%
# Q
! 4FW
F)) 6 o
)
# @A V (
%; \
# -
# O PQ ( ,R( TW
6
^LS ) DW
48 V ( - )!# 9
# )
(6 ( S 70
%/#
* (
! (
%P # ) 3 ( )
Gunes et
al., 2008
.(
%P # ) 4 ( )
Ramirez-Vallejo & Kelly
,1998
(
%3( . .
%P # ) 3 (
RWC = [(FW-DW)/(TW-DW)]×100
%P # ) 4 (
PWC = [ (FW – DW) / FW] × 100
) T 3 "
O V3
% V8 B
3 t 3
WSD) 6 (
j ;
%P # ) 5 (
%"
) T 3 "
O V3
% 100
#
V ;#
[ 3 !
# '
%*1 ! 4
%3( .
)
Nadafzadeh et al., 2017
(.
%P # ) 5 (
WSD = 100 – RWC
WSD = [(TW-FW)/(TW-DW)]
Q1 O [ 3 ! (PWL) 4
j P
%P # ) 6 (
%3( .
(Nadafzadeh et al., 2017)
.
%P # ) 6 (
PWL = (FW-WW)/FW
%"
6 :FW
[ 4 6 : WW
6 [ 3 ! ,+
6
# @A V (
# 9 F*1 !
# - 6 .
1. Relative water Content
2. Petal Water Content 3. Water Saturation Deficit 4. Petal water Loss
- (#
V) /
?) 6 i #
Balestra et al.
) (2005
G*(
! .
#
# ) j)9#
-6 (
%
V3 9:1 4
^ )
*)8 . ! / 9 )
*)8 O
PQ 2#
4V1 ! ,R(
%1 a 6
B
j)9#
-6 (
# @A _ # )
D104
(
# ? . ,R(
100
*)8 ?) 6
S F j)9#
-6 (
#
*+
- 5 - - *.
U).
VL"
V
# ! VL"
#
# ?
25
%/#
* (
! -# @_
. i#
"
6
48 V ( 7 B
"
- )?L
# )
*)8
)
cfu/ml
( .
% T ) .
G*(
6
# T1 ) 1 / 9 (
Q SAS
% F)_ ) Z
# )
% i # 6
% A
- F?
#
# T1
2016)
Microsoft Office Excel( l(#
.
3 .
!
"
#$
3 . 1 .
%&
'! ( )
Z
# ) . - s *b 01 .
! !
# /) 1 (
% Q F)_ ) L
!
! . # %"
B - 250ppm
, (
FL
# 4 * # 9 -
5) F ! ) 21 (6 #
) % V3 33
/ 12 . (6 # F
8 B # %" V(
, ( FL
yP( # 6 500ppm
2 G
lLA )!
- ? ) * l 1
.(
Bayat et al.
(2010)
; (#
- S
# # )Z~
, ( - )!
# 5 T1 !
!
%S
^b)
% F
% )*
)(#
%"
, (
# V' \ !
^b)
#
*@
6 5 T1
, ( 6
) 100ppm
5) ( F )Z~
#
# 5 T1 !
) 4 / 4
6 # ( V3
% V
. )Z~
, ( - V3 s *b t %
) )
8-HQS
# 5 T1
! S
6
! -
%S ' ) ) ^b)
Ahmadi
Mirabad et al., 2015
(
* 8 )
Sabzmeidani et al.,
(2012
T) ) ! F V(
%"
V) S a
?)
, (
# .
# @_
!
=] *B )Z~
5) -
# 5 T1
!
!
# . c>S 5 g+
Shaman et al.
) 3 (2010
Q* %P # / l)
F) 6
6 # , ( -
! 4 F) A
%P # -
% # ;
9 j) V' \ # 500ppm
, ( FL
`8 . L L
% ' (#
F) V' \ , ( - G*(
t )!
, ( - )!
V1
%9 (
! -
#$
# F 5 g+
%P # /
#
%
# ' (#
*B 6
V) (
6 V' \ -]
, ( FL
5 g+
- "
-
2#
)_
. 6 4 ( _
!
* )9 , ( -
)!
%1 - <*9 Q d
# T) 3 6 '
#
V .
: '(
1
@6 . / )
=- / ,B)
% :;1 "
<. "
C1 D"
, , 5 / 617 47 E '/, ), 9
F)_ )
2 %/#
6
- ))f •
!
72**
/
26 5 - # )
66 /
0 12 PS
6 / 4
- 2 ))f 7 a
* 4
**
ns
% : 7)
# -
# yP(
*B 5 1
#
# - .
3 . 2 .
*
! +
, - ) .
W * L
%"
Z Q*
# ) 6 T)
V Z
-# + [ 3 ! - L\
2 G -#
# yP(
*B 1
) V # /
2 5) .(
F T) + V Z -#
L\
% % € 7) - # )
8-HQS
, ( FL
250ppm
# F)8
%*G
% -#
? ) 2 ( .
4F 1 . ,B)
% :;1 "
617 , , 5 / 617 47 E '/, ), 9
%
# ; -
%"
V `!
6 V Z + -#
L\
5 "
V1
%"
%*1 -
Danai et al.
(2011) Fereidouni
Mehr et al.
(2011)
VQ P . #
l 5) F) A F
V Z + -#
L\
# S F
%*G
% -#
€
%
# ) , ( 6 500ppm
%"
V3
% Q
%)
# )
*@
"
F
# 8 B V )
%"
# ) , ( FL
500ppm
4 l"
F -# + [ 3 ! - L\
# V .
l F) A T) V Z -# + L\
# [ 3 ! -
# )
, ( 6
500ppm
2 G -#
# )
8-HQS
# S F
%*G
% -#
V . F W *
%*1 - _ 5 g+
! V(
%"
)
*
#
!
#$
)
KousheshSaba & Nazari, 2017
(
•S
# + - L\
#
* -
%*G 6
! ]
#
%*G )+
- 5 "
F)) .
2 3Z L\
-
8 ( T)
! g+
!
# 5)+
) .
% ! - 1 g) "
6 - -
% B
%
L\
- 8 ( 6 S L )
Chanjirakul et
al., 2008
( F
% )*
Q V(
%"
5 "
#
# + - L\
%
*B 6
# Z 5 T1 V)8 1
% ! - g) "
1 5 "
V)8 1 l T
- )( ) " a
; 1 + - )
! )
Ezhilmathi
et al., 2007
.(
3 . 3 . / 0 1
2 , - )
%/
% Z Q*
# /) 2 ( . -
01 . 6
%
# -
#
%
? ) 3 (
•bL
%"
5) F
# Q 2 # ) "
"
€
%
[ 3 !
%"
# . B - 500ppm
, (
6
# 9
%*1 ! .
#
%
# )
% T/
, (
FL 500ppm
# F) (
%*G
% -#
T)
2 # ) "
5 T1 V1
4 8
#
%*G
# @A
%
# ;
9
%'B>
- 5 "
L . F F
% )*
# 5)+
) "
%"
!
#
%*G (
*
# Q 2 # ) "
5) - 6 . ! O`/
"
.
#
*
% )
# Q "
2 # ) 5 T1
%*1
#
F S
%*G
=] *B
% V -
2 # ) "
- 6 O`/
?
# F 2#
# Q 2 # ) "
# F
%*G V1
# L .
Z ( - # ) s *b
# Q 2 # ) "
"
# 3 4
# Q 2 # ) "
"
# [ 3 !
#
e
d cd
b
a
bc
0 5 10 15 20 25
,H!" I) 8-HQS *," =- &)
250ppm
*," =- &)
500ppm
J / K =- &)
250ppm
J / ) =- &)
500ppm
47 ,5 :;L)day(
' : 5) %
F S 6 #
% -#
% T) 9
@/
5 "
V1 .
! -
%
# "
%*1 !
%"
* 6
#
l ) !# ?) - )! /
"
S V
,G
#
% )*
c <
2 # ) "
# 5 "
% 5 T1
-# !
! -
%S
^ "
"
.
`8
V) P T)
2# ) "
"
#
# - # ) , (
U3 F
# V . 6 _ 4 ( 2 ))f 2 # ) "
"
#
;
# 6 ,+
6
# )
#
8 B
# 6#
# 9 V1 !
%"
%) "
- # ) 8
%(
# 6# " ( .
2 # ) "
F a F) ~
-$
6]
- 1 - 1
? $ 8 T) ) ) )
- 6 / 6
)!
-#
)Sq
`\
6]
#
-
?.*(
# *S (
# 8 ( T)
-$
6 ) #
-
#
; (
# l 1 . "
: '(
2
@6 . / )
=- / :;1 " ,B) L C1 D" <. "
, "*
> ?B
; ,3 + O +>) '%
&; -K +J%- % + TSS
* P E
) +(Dw
); "
? - IK ) (+RWC
)@%"
;? 3 IK 8? - 8 $ Q ? ) ) (+WSD
); "
) R,?17 IK ( PWC
IK )'!.
) R,?17 ( PWL
E 47 ), 9 '/,
2 F)_ )
%/#
6
- ))f •
PWL PWC WSD RWC Dw TSS F) )( * " 2# ) " L\ 2 3Z 0036*
/ 0
0/96* 0/0037** ns0/0025 0/00049** 34/31** 0/065** ns0/014 210/09** 5 01 . . # ) 023**
/ 0
11/43** 0/0168** 0/036** 0/0042** 134/57** 2/197** 0/411** 5029/46** 3 -# % 6 0042**
/ 0
0/97** 0/0056** 0/0057** 0/00038** 32/46** 0/036** 0/05* 234/63** 15 6×# ) 0012
/ 0
0/29 0/0003 0/0022 0/0001 4/78 0/014 0/022 23/75 48 PS 79
/ 23
8/34 18/02 5/31 7/82 17/91 12/97 11/87 6/69 - (%)2 ))f 7 a
** 4*
: ns
% 7)
# -
# yP(
5 1
#
# -
.
'/, E 47R,?17 O )'/ 8 B' , 0S L 617:;1 " % 4 ! ">),B) .24F ), 9
ac a
ab af ab
ag af ae
ch ag ad
af
eh gh
h
dh bg
eh
k
i
j
fh
jk
l
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
PQ O 8-HQS 6 , (
250ppm
6 , ( 500ppm
FL , ( 250ppm
FL , ( 500ppm
R,?17O )'/ 8B '
%*G %*G ( %*G
# @A %*G 100
90 80 70 60 50 40 30 20 10 0
4F 3 .
>),B) 4 ! "
% :;1 "
617 L 0S ,
)@%"
>) '% ; ,3 43
R,?17 47 E '/, ), 9
3 . 4 . / 0 4 5 6 , - )
Z Q*
# )
# 6 /) 3
(
% Q
V' \ - s *b - # ) .
- # @_
? ) 4 5) %" L ( F
T) ( * F) )
% €
# ) 6 , ( 250ppm
, ( FL
500ppm
# F S
%*G
% -#
V(
.
# Q F) )( * [ 3 !
- #
^
# -
#
; 6
%
%? # ; .
- # @_
B - ( * # Q 4 t 6 r# 1 , ( F) )
5) - % V3
# )
8-HQS
% g S # F
% %*G -#
. *
: '(
3 . /@6
=- / )
% ,B) :;1 "
C1 D" <. "
L
"*
, )@%"
7 ; K ,F%"
:;1 "
617 F)_ ) 2
%/#
- 6 ))f •
#
! 8 77**
/
3072 5 - # )
11**
/ 711
1 -# % 6
11*
/
181 5 6×# )
38 / 51
24 PS
68 /
21 - 2 ))f 7 a
3 . 5 . 8 9 $
TSS) , - )(
5) F
# Q /
.
% 7)
€
%
- # ) , (
6 250ppm
4 , ( FL
250ppm
, ( 6 500ppm
% ) 7) 3 / 22 4 8 / 21 9 / 20 (
#
F)8
%*G
% -#
l"
F
# Q
€
%
8-HQS
V(
%"
c>*S -#
l
* .
8
# B -
%/
%
#
•bL V(
%"
T) /
.
%*1#
%*1#
#
% 5 "
V(
. F
# L "
%/
% 6 # O 6 - )+
!
; 4 6 )3;
% ' (#
? ) 5 .(
3 . 6 .
; <
DW) (
# Q
^LS 3 Q
#
%
# )
% W # 5 T1
%*1 ? ) 6 (
`8 F
% !
% )*
- )!
"
%"
V `!
6
% V -
%"
#
! ƒ#
4
! O l"
- O`/
"
# j3;
4
l"
F S # ^LS # Q F
% € %*G
, ( FL
250ppm
. F
% )*
#
. / #
T) /
%) # Q %" "
TSS
# F
# ) S # F l" # %*G F
V( # Q
*. # % %/
- [ 3 ! O T)
%" V( •bL
eg cg cg cg dg
bc
g
bf
fg
cg dg
g ab
be
ab
a
ab
be be
eg eg dg dg
bd
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2 1.4 1.6 1.8
PQ O 8-HQS 6 , (
250ppm
6 , ( 500ppm
FL , ( 250ppm
FL , ( 500ppm
43 >)'%;,3)@%" )mg/100 gr FW(
%*G %*G ( %*G
# @A %*G 1,8
1,6 1,4 1,2 1 0,8 0,6 0,4 0,2 0
F)
# ) S # F
# %*G - 5) F O # Q
V(
.
3 . 7 .
$ '->
?6 , - )
RWC) (
W * / ) 2 ( ? ) 7 ( 5) %" L F
# Q
*.
- 3 % € [ 3 ! O
# ) 6 , (
250ppm
# F)
%*G
% -#
%"
%*1#
%*1#
V `!
6 - *.
3 O [ 3 ! l"
•bL V(
%"
V `!
6
!
% ] s *b
_*1 ! A
* *
O 5) - O`/
"
Z 5 T1 yP(
)b3
„ V1 O
5)
-
# Z V `!
6
%*
4 %"
F
*.
-
3 # O
# ) , ( FL
V' \ #
% 7) 500 250ppm
%
# Q 77 / 0 82 / 0
#
F) (
%*G
% -#
% l"
F
# Q S )(#
.
# F)
# )
# F S
%*G
% -#
- *.
3
" [ 3 ! O T1
5 V1 =] *B .
# )
6 , ( 500ppm
# 0GB F
* # + F *@
# )
4 6 - *.
3 O [ 3 ! 7)
>
V `!
6 5 "
%*1 V(
? ) 7 (
%"
=] *B
)
! 7)
%
# O`/
O 6 j ;
# F
. ! V(
.
4F 4 . ,B) 4 ! "
% :;1 "
617 L 0S ,
)@%"
J%- %&; -K R,?17
47 E
'/, ), 9
4F 5 .
>),B) 4 ! "
% :;1 "
617 L 0S ,
)@%"
);"
'" ( :;1 "
47 E '/, ), 9
jl
l l
jl kl kl
eh
gk hj ei fi
ik cd
dg dg
gi
dc de
ab
df
a
ab bc
ab
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2 1.4 1.6 1.8
,H!" I) 8-HQS *," =- &)
250ppm
*," =- &) 500ppm
J / K =- &) 250ppm
J / ) =- &) 500ppm
J%-%&;-K '
%*G %*G ( %*G
# @A %*G
cf df
a a a
bc ef
cf cf cf cf bf
be
f
bd
cf cf bf
bf be bd bd
cf
b
0 5 10 15 20 25
,H!" I) 8-HQS *," =- &)
250ppm
*," =- &)
500ppm
J / K =- &)
250ppm
J / ) =- &)
500ppm
:;1" '"();" ' )TSS (
%*G %*G ( %*G
# @A %*G 1,8
1,6 1,4 1,2 1 0,8 0,6 0,4 0,2 0
25 20 15 10 5 0
#$ %S !- [ 3 !^LS T) %*G # @A ;- ! . - # ) Q* 2 Z .6 ?
'/, E 47 R,?17IK ? - ); "' , 0S L 617:;1 " % 4 ! ">),B) .74F ), 9
3 . 8 . / 0 -%
?6 ->
A B C -D ) (WSD
T) 3 "
O V3
% V8 B t 3
#
* - B
6 5 A
! 6 6 )!
-#
/
%9 ( l
6 l8 (
4 O
5) -
* [ 3 ! V3
% V8 B t 3 3 "
l"
- L
% :>P O
4
%
# W V `!
6 T) O l"
T)
3 "
6 V8 B t 3 6 .
# )
8-HQS
*@ O V %*G # -
* # " O`/
% ) l" O 3 "
8
#
B O
l"
- O`/
"
3 "
O 5 T1
)+
"
.
# F)
# ) - , ( 4
# ) , ( FL
250ppm
Q % V3
%)
# )
*@
- A T)
3 "
%
# 5 T1 V1 S # F V3 %*G
%
%*G 39 T) O`/
O
*@
3 "
O 5 "
V1
? ) 8 .(
F ! „ < t a
5)
! -
%S # F
# @_ .
? ) 1 .(
3 . 9 .
/ H
?6 , - )
PWL) (
%/
W *
) /
2 (
? ) 9 ( L
%"
# ) - , (
%*
/ - 8 O V1
%)
_ O O`/ 3@ =] *B # V1 )
%*G #
[ 3 ! O 3 "
V3
%
# ) l"
.
dh fh eh fh h
dg
h eh gh dg
eh h
dg eh cf ce
ab ab
bd bd ab bc
df
a
0 0.02 0.04 0.06 0.08 0.1 0.12 0.14 0.16 0.18 0.2
,H!" I) 8-HQS *," =- &)
250ppm
*," =- &)
500ppm
J / K =- &)
250ppm
J / ) =- &)
500ppm
R,?17 PE ")gr (
' : 5) %
%*G %*G ( %*G
# @A %*G
bead abac ada ab a be
be ac a
be ab df df
gh gh
eg eg
gh fh cf
h
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2
,H!" I) 8-HQS *," =- &)
250ppm
*," =- &)
500ppm
J / K =- &)
250ppm
J / ) =- &)
500ppm
R,?17 IK ?- );" ' )RWC(
' : 5) %
%*G %*G ( %*G
# @A %*G 0,2
0,180,16 0,14 0,12 0,1 0,08 0,06 0,040,02 0
1,2 1 0,8 0,6 0,4 0,2 0
4F 8 .
>),B) 4 ! "
% :;1 "
617 L 0S ,
'
;? 3 IK 8? - 8 $ Q ? )
), 9 '/, E 47 R,?17IK )'!.' , 0S L 617:;1 " % 4 ! ",B) .94F
# %A ! …"
# ) 6 V `!
T) Q1
[ 3 ! O 5 T1
4V1
% -# ;
%"
%A T) F
[#T [ 3 !
O 5) - 6 V(
T) O O`/
T) 5 "
%*1 # .V(
# )
8-HQS
8 B # [ 3 ! O Q1
%) 6
%*G 6 V `!
[ 3 ! ( O
*@
- O`/
* # "
% ) 8 l" O Q1 S #
F 4%*G
*.
- T1 # O Q1 5
V1 # ? j P .
- # ) B - 6 * [ 3 ! O Q1 , (
l" % ( %*G # F
(# S # Q )
S %*G # T1 #
5 V1 5) . F [ 3 ! O Q1 # Q
% €
# ) 250ppm
, ( FL
;
%*G S
.
3 . 10 .
$
?6 , - )
(PWC)
- *.
O [ 3 !
;
%*G
% -#
F)
%*G
% -#
5 T1 V1
%
# W t
%
5 "
/) ) 2 (
? ) 10 ( .(
#
# )
8-HQS
#
%(
%*G 3 Q
? L "
L 4
8
# S F
%*G F 5 "
lLA )!
.
#
# )
bc
l
gi
kl jl ik
ik
l l
fh fh
hj ik
cf dg
gi
a
bd
l
eh
be
b
be
a
0 0.05 0.1 0.15 0.2 0.25
,H!" I) 8-HQS *," =- &)
250ppm
*," =- &)
500ppm
J / K =- &)
250ppm
J / ) =- &)
500ppm
Q?) 8 $ 8?- IK ;?3 ' %*G
%*G ( %*G
# @A %*G
fh
bd
cg
ab ad
dg ad
bf
ac bd
bf cg
cf
eh fh
gh h h
ab
bd
fh
be
a
cf
0 0.05 0.1 0.15 0.2 0.25 0.3
,H!" I) 8-HQS 250ppm *," =- &)500ppm *," =- &) J / K =- &) 250ppm
J / ) =- &) 500ppm
R,?17 IK )'!. '
%*G %*G ( %*G
# @A %*G 0,25
0,2 0,15
0,1 0,05
0
0,3 0,25
0,2 0,15
0,1 0,05
0
, ( 6
500ppm
- *.
O [ 3 !
*
%
# Q
88 / 0
# F S
%*G
%
# Q 84 / 0 )(#
. 5) F
# Q
*.
- O [ 3 !
# 8 F)
%*G
€
% , (
FL 250ppm
# B - 5 "
V1
%"
#
%*G (
% l"
F
# Q )(#
#
%*G S
#
5 T1 V1 .
3
. 11 . J ') A6
W * B 6
% T , # /)
2 (
Q 2 F)_ )
? ) 11 ( L
%"
5) F T)
! 8
€
%
%"
T
^
% 80
#
! 8 L
# )
8-HQS
T)
# V ( T)
! 8 l"
-
%*
8
# V
# @A B 50
#
! 8 L .
4F 10 . ,B) 4 ! "
% :;1 "
617 L 0S )
1 + 2 + 3 4 ( , ' ); "
IK R,?17
'/, E 47 ,F%" 7 ; K )@%", X 0S X;& L 617:;1 " % 4 ! ",B) .114F ), 9
be
ab ad ab a
be a
ac a
be
ac
a be
ab
df df
gh gh
eg eg
gh fh
cf
h
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
,H!" I) 8-HQS *," =- &)
250ppm
*," =- &)
500ppm
J / K =- &)
250ppm
J / ) =- &)
500ppm
R,?17 IK '
%*G %*G ( %*G
# @A %*G
a
de de
de e
de a
bc
ce
de de
de
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90
,H!" I) 8-HQS *," =- &)
250ppm
*," =- &)
500ppm
J / K =- &)
250ppm
J / ) =- &)
500ppm
//,37; K ')CFU / ml (
( -# %
# @A -# % 8
7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0
# - # )
€
% , ( T)
! 8 )S l"
4
%
# ; -
%"
# ) , ( FL
250ppm
# F)
# ) - # l"
F
! 8 V3
%
%)Q
# ) *@
* %"
W
Ahmadi Mirabad et al.
(2015)
# #
V) S a
?) , ( VQ P
# .
%/
%
F
%"
!
#$
% 2#
# 6 - # 15 g
*"
"
#
#
%9 ( 4
%
# ; ,+
6
# @A W +
6 # 6 - )!# 9
%S
!
# . 4 ! )
-
*"
-
#
#
%9 (
"
O`/
. !
?L
%/
S .
F
2 3)"
# <
%"
- #
!g
*" a
F* `!6 -
-
%9 (
# 5 T1 !
)G S 4
%*38
%
;
%"
# V' \ -
7(
G*(
. , (
- )+
$ # )
%
F) + - O T ! - L\
%*S
<*
% )* #
5 T1
" `+q G L\
% [ - *"
(Juven et al., 1994)
i# T! . %" V(
Zk
, ( FL
\ 7)(
%
#
%*S - L\
† VL
?8 [
# - *"
.(Pichersky et al., 2006)
i# T!
" B 6 F
V(
%"
, ( - )!
5 "
-# + L\
7 b l* )(
T )!#
# )8 -$
2 3)"
-# *S ( (
T) !# ?)
† l"
"
! 8 -
?) )
Sakihama et al., 2002
(.
4 . ( )
; + - )
% ! 3; # ; ) 6 5 "
% ( 6
9
• + - ) ƒ#
. %A !
% ' (#
# ) , (
L " # %*
S~ % # )
6 ) # F *( #
, ( 6
~Z ) 5) - Q* %P # %*
) F)
# )
, ( 5 T1
T) /
.
^LS ( 6 .
- _ ;
^ %P # !
Q*
) T)
* . # V 6 ,+ . O`/
W
) Z ! #
1
# -
# )
# - - *.
8
%)
[ 3 ! O
% . '
; (#
%*G %"
! 1 ? B # "
T) . O`/
T1 5
%*1 V(
4 %"
~Z ) , ( # F T1 5 O`/
o . .
# )
8-HQS
Q #
%
, (
~Z ) 5) - . O`/ #
# ( %*G
l" V ! U(
F T) # O`/
# ) 500ppm
, ( FL
5) =] *B %"
% 8)
( 7) #
! g+ # .
!
6 V `!
5)
* . W 6 5 L %"
# ) , (
8-HQS
# Q
% T)
! 8
?) 5 " #
# F
*( # )Z~
# "
, (
# ) lLA )!
6
8-HQS
.
`8
%/
% 5 g+
-# / 5 g+
-
%*1 !
4 _ G*(
6 , ( - )!
#
# . 01 .
!
@ L)+
"
%"
l -
# *(
U).
V 6 l
V) S - *"
L"
)3;
*@
6 ) ) 6 S
6 .
%A ! V' \
% )@
-
! 2 6
# )
#
! - s *b 9#
s *b F?
V(
%
% )@
-6 ( 6 )
%*
.
5
' K L .
6 + V g
% %\ _L L ; S
~ 6 Lb F)
% T + -
%4 l 6 F) A
3\ ! _L 6
% _L 6
l 1 ; S
? # 2
_L 6
+ F - g
5 4 ?L # 9 . !
6 . MH N O PL
‡)
% ! ˆ#
•1 U(
! /
# .
