24 3
1401 975 - 961
DOI: 10.22059/jci.2022.322875.2545
: ! "#
) Cucumis sativus L.
(
!
1 2
*
! " 3 4
1 .
%&" ' (&" ) *+
,&" - . / 0+ 1"2 +) 3 /%4+ 56 '%( 2 3 /2 . .
2 . 3 /2 . " + '%( 2
,&" - . / 0+ 1"2 +) 3 /%4+ 56 .
3 . / 0+ 1"2 +) 3 /%4+ 7 8 5 9- 2 , "1 /2 . ' ,&" - .
.
4 . ,&" - . / 0+ 1"2 +) 3 /%4+ :; '%( /2 . " + .
: = ,> " ? " 8 12
/ 03 / 1400 B C! ? " 8
= 19: / 10 / 1400
!" # $%& '() * +
, - - . / + " * +
. !"
1 2 3
3 4 56
% 4 + %&
7%
89 3 1 : ; <
' =& )
>? @ A B 1 "
C9 &
) ( '()
D "
E 9
)
# / (
* 1, 4 I - = J 8 % 1&
K
$L;
M '3 '()
D "
E 1
>
# 7 C1 7 / 16 '3
1 '() D "
# 7 C8 0 / 7 '3 1
'() E .
S
# T K UV, W
# 7 C10 6 / 2866
= ,
= Z UV, W '() D "
# 7 C8 0 / 9341
= ,
= Z UV, W '() E 8<
8 + 8 , 1
+ 5
>, + '()
$%&
L=, .
S
# T J = 1 DI 1 1L?]
+
; 1 DI + :9"
$ M . 8 % 1&
K C8
"
+ : L; ^5 : L;
_ % 5,
+ $%&
'() - . S
# T M K
# 7 C1 0 / 5
M 1
" '() D
# 7 C10 0 / 5 M 1
'() E .
1 DI :
+ :9"
. 5 _$%& '() _ _ M _
Evaluation of Yield Stability of a Number of Cucumber Lines ( Cucumis sativus L.) during Spring and Autumn Cropping Seasons
Atefeh Beylari1, Jamalali Olfati2*, Masoud Esfahani3, Nader Pirmoradian4
1. M.Sc. Student, Department of Horticultural Science, Faculty of Agricultural Science, University of Guilan, Rasht, Iran.
2. Associate Professor, Department of Horticultural Sciences, Faculty of Agricultural Sciences, University of Guilan, Rasht, Iran.
3. Professor, Department of Agriculture and Plant Breeding, Faculty of Agricultural Sciences, University of Guilan, Rasht, Iran.
4. Associate Professor, Department of Water Engineering, Faculty of Agricultural Sciences, University of Guilan, Rasht, Iran.
Received: June 2, 2021 Accepted: January 9, 2022
Abstract
This study aims at evaluating the yield of cucumber genotypes in two seasons, and identifying cucumber genotypes with high yield and stability. The research has been carried out in the greenhouse of the Department of Horticultural Sciences, University of Guilan, as a factorial experiment in a completely randomized design in autumn and spring seasons with nine cucumber genotypes in three replications. Results show that in terms of number of female flowers in autumn and spring, genotype C1 with an average of 16.7 per plant and genotype C8 with an average of 7.0 per plant have been the best, respectively. Also, in terms of leaf area, C10 genotype with an average of 2866.6 cm2 in autumn and C8 genotype with an average of 9340.990 cm2 in spring outperform the rest and can be used to achieve suitable hybrids for each growing season. Results of principal components analysis and population biplot show that C8 genotype is a suitable genotype for cultivation in two cropping seasons in terms of stability of yield-related traits and vegetative traits. Finally, in terms of number of fruits, genotype C1 with an average of 5.0 per plant in autumn, and C10 genotype with an average of 5.0 per plant in spring have been superior.
Keywords: Biplot analysis, cultivation season, genotype, hybrid, number of fruit.
1 .
* SE
# +D5, + +
$,
)
Peyvast, 2005
4 @ .(
+ W + _W D
1I "
+ #- D5, a 1 ' - 3
+ S&
b
-
? K . 1 2 3
+ _8
* 15
4
M 1. 3 7 ) @ )
Gent, 2012
# .(
+D5, _
* ET
# 1. 3 c" SE (d 7 )
_
" S &
.$,
# - bB 4 C 5 e (d
&
+ / 20 1.
= , 3
=E
# -
)
Tatlioglu, 1993
f , .(
<
- %=
^,
8 ,
* + %&
' _ d=
# T
?
70288130
#
* _
# ?
%&
W D
& ?
#
(d 8 E.
$, .
%&
8 D
? 871692
#
* 15
SI "
1
* g (=*
$,
)
FAO, 2019
.(
D) 8 D)
$ M . +
8 ) 8<
1 . _ h6 + %&
1 i +
=
= ,
_S&
7 + 7 .
#
$ i
+
# + %&
_S& =
$%&
1 2 3 +
$, )
Cetin &
Vardar, 2008
( 1 .
= & K '
=* -
M, _ 1 .
? %& :/ (d +
1
!
; L : .
$d - "
1 2 3 + - )
Thongbai et
al., 2010
.(
, +
* 1.
1 D)
$ M . 1
# j h6
_ S ) 8
^ -
>,
$E.
4 I ) :/ (d ? + %&
1 2 3 1
i = 3
$, . '() 8 =
5 &
- k
:/ (d +D5,
:9 %
+ 8 l d -
.
* 1 . +D5,
$, 1&
B 8 = 1 e S&
? - .
$%&
+ m * '()
+ 8 =, 89 3
1.
1
^ -
>? 6 1 2 3
1&
@ ) _ =
'
;
& d _ ?
5 &
/
8 M + +
$, . 3<
$ n ' e=
d
^ 1 A9;
8 3 o &
&
=
$@
+ &
+
" K +
) & l 2= /
Roy,
.(2000
. n ' e=
d
^ 8 %
#
$, 1&
=E
# o
d
^
#
$,
d
^ + 7
=E
# ) - 5
Perkins & Jinks,
.(1971
1M? V + + J "
*
$%&
-
ET
^ d : L=
K + %&
_ ? &
1 DI
c 1& 8 %
: L _
n
^ d
n ' e=
×
^ d M
$, )
Thanki et
al., 2010; Derera et al., 2008
i D3 .(
+ + M=
g (*
nj '() 4 @
* .
)
Iwo & Odor, 2018
- D3 .(
1 % n ' e=
×
^ d + +
* M i D3 -
1&
# <
Poinsett
# 7
t.ha-1
43 / 48 +
# 3 , + d
^
$, )
Iwo & Odor, 2018
3 .(
' e= n
d
^ M _ -
e f L + + + 3
"
+ +
1M? V 1
+
q9;
$, )
Ebdon & Gauch, 2002
+ " .(
*
$ ) _
$& - +
& ? h
4 @ 3 ,
^ - V d : L=
1 4 @ 3 , 1
^ - g * U . .
: L;
1=
1
: L;
M 1
UV, _W
# n
S e=
.
# 4 @ A9;
+ '() _$%&
'() 8 >, 4 @
L=,
# !"
, - +
>, +
" E $%&
D 8< $,
A9;
4 @ +
$%&
() r =2 L=, .
2 .
# !"
1 : ; 3 ,
1397 1398
1 2 3 3 4
56
% 4
+ %&
7%
89 3 1 : ; <
' =& )
>? @
A B 1 "
C9 &
) ( '()
D "
E 9
)
# / (
* 1,
. - .
#
# /
'; q o "
A9;
5
@9
# / +
+ E . oT
D&
# ? : I D5,
= 1&
>? @ o <
+ '?<
S
@9 -
m = 8<
"
%3 * +
_ s? *
#
# 8<
l 2=
- )
Moradipour et
al., 2017; Moslemi et al., 2019
.(
# / + l 2=
-
+
$ e 5
1 t L, + "
K
' - k =
= . +
1M? V
^, 8 <
, 1397 '
L,
1397 +
'() D "
^,
# ) 1398
* 1398
+ '() E 4 I - .
. ) 1 ( 3!
+
^ - + .
4 I <
8 % .
8 3 c .
o =,9"
V@
1 22
= ,
= k L 20
= ,
= 1&
=
$%&
+ q
$ " & &
$ / "
1
$5
Iq 1:1 "
- . + h +
r =2 M
L v c =
+ I 10
;
$E.
1 .
1 : 48
$ , w
+ ="
@
$) 3 M
1 . 1
8 3 +
% 'e=
- c"
Ew
# W _ e eq 1x 3 1
8 3 +
; 'e=
- :
$- 8 ,
1 1 q
?
4 I - . + 1 2 3 25 1.
= , 3 S K - .
+ 3 1
: ; 1
$ , 11 U5;
4
Ew M
^ - l<
: L=
7=,
Quantum PAR meter
)
Hydro Farm USA
_
$* ,
%&
<
( 4 I
$) 3 .
# + 3 U d(
+ 7=
, - B
$%&
4 I
- 1&
f , 1V , 3
# + '; q
8 '*
1 2 3
# U d(
4 I - .
$E.
hy 1
3 8 1=L
d 3 1z - +
o 8 3 ) - L=,
Hogland & Arnon,
.(1950
d
# <
1 ' ?
# 1&
l , 1 3 .
E 1 - . o ?
=
" d 1 _# <
+ b @ + ,
1000 ?
= <
) & l .) $, 2
.(
> 4+
1 .
#
@& 6
* A6 0 B(C
>.$
DEF 4 C
M I ) µmol. m-2 . s-1 (
B |& q-'@ q
- '*
1 2 3 )
˚C ( D "
E
8
1 2 3 8 1 2 3
86 / 119503
24341/3 342431/67 163162 18-25
> 4+
2 . C
>.( # -GH 4I(C.
o5?, c :L?, + :L?, D7& ,o :L?,DS < :L)4 :=,="S := &S
-
02 /
0 0/08 0/22 1/18 2/86 439 115 505/5 1181 l< ?= 100 4 3
$L;
f , M +
8 3
8 3 1 q
+ "
S
# T
> q
q 4 3 1
+ 3 - )
UPOV, 2017
.(
L;
B 1
)
Gwanama et al., 1998
(
> q
= ,
= 1=L
*<
- + 3
- . UV, W
> q
= ,
= Z 3 S D "
1 / W + ' &
L=, i
5 2 6
15, d - )
Blanco & Folegatti, 2003
=L, .(
$)
1 q + "
L=, 7=,
= = "
)
Mc cormic-FT327
_
$* ,
%&
? = (
> q 4 3 &
= ,
= Z <
- .
+ 1 e 8 _8 3
= W 1@ , 1 +
8 3 + E=
1 q - . - 1 ; )9
1 +
= I
$@
001 / 0 4 3 8
- . + + 3
8 _o%*
W 1@ ,
8 3
8 3 8 <
+ 72 1.
= , 3
1 : 24
$ , @
$) 3 . c"
o%*
8 -
1 8 , 1 8 _$ n -
+ 3 - )
Hejaze et al., 2004
.(
V@
L=, c ? &
= I
$@
01 / 0 'd
|& q V@
}
$5n - . B
1 + 1 q
+ "
D 1 b B
1 % L=,
c ? &
= I + 3
-
)
Adel et al., 2017
SIq .(
1 q + "
^, 'v L UV, l<
* - 1 =,
_m
'5@
M
8 @
1 i D3 -
$ E
? 7T L=,
)
d=m/v
15, d - 1&
8<
? 7T d
_ 8 m
SIq v
$,
)
Adel et al., 2017
: L; .(
$ o%*
_'&
M W _1
8 _
^, = 8
_
; 8 o%*
W _
^, = B 8
3 + E=
- 1 + 3 - . + =d
5 ' ) &
L=, 7=,
' ) &
= )
SPAD
502, Minolta, Japan
( 1 : ;
# 7 1,
4 I - . 1 DI c _>&
1 DI 1 1L?]
+ _ ;
1 DI + :9"
$ M . 1 e
# 7 L=,
4 D) )SAS
12 2 / 9 ( 4 I - .
3 .
J = 1 DI c
b5B 8 % 1&
n ' e=
× '() + : L;
M _W
^, = B
8 _ 3 B _1 UV, _W
; 8 o%*
_W
$ _'&
$ o%*
_'&
M
'3 _ B _
V@
_
; 8 o%*
_
8 _
^, = 8 _
? 7T _
=L,
$, "
=L, 8
_$, "
UV, o
; M _
+
$L;
+ =d 5
' ) &
) ' ) &
= ( n ' e=
× '()
M
% ) . + 3 - 6 ( . M 8 - n
' e=
× '() 1&
k y
>
8 % 8<
$, 1&
+ '()
>, = 8<
'() l 2=
- .
~ 1&
^ d + r =2 -
&
_$,
> 6 : ,
' @ E.
8 % _
#
& , 1&
$d nj
^ - r =2 V d
$,
8<
1 8 n ' e=
×
^ d -
)
Allard & Bradshaw, 1964
1M? V .(
+ n ' e=
×
^ d + v _$,
8 , -
+ /
1&
+ 3 , + "
+ /
*
= S )
&
8
, -
>,
# +
o 1eV
bed , )
Freitas et al., 2013
.(
J = 1 e
# 7 + : L;
% ) . 7 (
8 % 1&
+
$L;
" '() W M _D
# 7 C3
3 / 18
# =E M
8<
A11
# 7 0 / 17
$ E
# 7 C10
0 / 10
W S&
#
# 7 W
=- E '() .
# 7 C8
7 / 32 W
#
# 7 C3
0 / 21 S&
#
# 7 1=-
. K
$L;
M W 9=* C3
# 7 7 / 2
'() S&
# 8 D y 8 % M
8<
1
>
+
A11
9=* C1
# 7 7 / 8 7 / 9
'() S&
# y 8 % .
# 1&
S&
# 8 D y
=- 7 + "
8<
$, + ,
7 7 L &
8 8<
$L;
1&
$d
nj
^ d @ 1=) 7
$, .
# _ !"
M W 1 '() E )
"
(
$5 1 '() D "
) S&
( D) 8 % .
D) : - 1
5 8<
D) lh.
+
# & &
^, _ 3 D= , =) 1
' ? D) 8 D
8 - 1
$ 5|
+
# & &
D)
M W 8 3
$E.
L=,
^ -
1
< . D)
)
Jalili Marandi, 2010
.(
S
# T D)
• D) D= , =) D)
8 D - - )
Muneer et al., 2014
.(
S
# T : M? V 8 %
D) +
# & &
I 1 D) n 1M,
3 +
- . 1 1 3 + 1&
D) +
# & &
_ B
_1* - M W - 1 . + 5 . D)
$) .
S
# T
• D) D= , =) D)
8 D 1%
- )
Muneer et al., 2014
: - .(
q
-
% 8 3 n L . q
>5,
' % W + oT &
- )
Rhie et al., 2014
.(
J = 1 e
# 7 ) . 7 ( 8 % 1&
+
$L;
^, = B 8
" '() 3 _D
A11
# 7 7 / 9
= ,
=
# =E M
8<
C3
# 7 2 / 8
= ,
=
$ E
# 7 B12
4 / 3
= ,
= S&
#
# 7 g (=* * 1
E '() .$,
# 7 A11
3 / 10
= ,
=
# =E
# 7 C6
5 / 4
= ,
=
S&
#
# 7 1=-
. K
$L;
^, = B
8 3 9=* C3
# 7 1 / 0
= ,
=
'() S&
# 8 D y 8 % M
8<
1
>
+
A11
9=* C8
# 7 6 / 0 0 / 1
= ,
= '() S&
# y 8 % .
: -
S&
3 + 8 3 + ' B _ -
#
^ - S e
= 1 ' ? )
# &
Z , 4 I
3 )
Jalili Marandi, 2010
.(
> 4+
3 . J ,0 A6 K0 - L
M '& .#
N 6.0O 9
6 .0
# 7 : M
1.
+ <
: y Z
1 B
38 B ^, = E W M ~,
344**
/ 299216
24/116* 2041/185** 1372/795** 1 $%&'()
783 / 102
0/290 0/592 1/773 4 ('())
668**
/
3786 10/628** 37/000** 16/299** 8
865**
/
5131 7/136** 32/518** 6/890ns 8 '() ×
221 / 193
0/747 2/175 3/328 32 V*
150 /
8 11/945 7/215 7/118 - (% ): y > v
PQ,9- 2 4& :** * )ns
I*#
- I*# PQ,9- -
> ,S- TUM 5
1 .4
: M? V
* 8 %
$, 1&
E 1. 3 7 )
^ - _S&
8 3 W 5
+
%&
S
# T
UV, W W D + 1&
2, "
1 l =.
1 ,
$, )
Xu et al., 2013
€M .(
+ )
# / (
1M? V
^, = 8 3 '() D "
S&
'()
E
% - .
+
$L;
" '() 1 B _D
A11
# 7 9 / 136
= ,
=
# =E M
8<
# 7 C6
1 / 122
= ,
=
$ E
B12
# 7 4 / 41
= ,
= S&
#
# 7 * 1
.) $, g (=*
7 E '() .(
C8
# 7 9 / 309
= ,
=
#
C6
# 7 3 / 159
= ,
= S&
#
# 7 1=- . K
$L;
B 1
C6
9=*
# 7 2 / 37
= ,
= '() S&
# 8 D y 8 % . k L
3
$d nj B _ %
" =) ,
'
$, )
Kafi et al., 2007
= .(
J 3 1& 8 % E 1&
: - } M e =- @
1 3 8
_ 7 oT &
&
)
Cerdan & Chory,
.(2003
: -
>5, S 2v 8 - W S& =
&
8 - 3 1 : ; 1
+ - .
#
? q
$,
1&
+ /)
# ( '() E B 1 -
% +
"
' % M 3 W
% - .
+
$L;
" '() W UV, _D
C10
# 7 6 / 2866
= ,
= Z
# / 8 D
M 8<
# 7 C8
3 / 2788
= ,
Z =
$ E
# 7 A11
7 / 1122
= ,
Z =
S&
#
# 7 * 1
.) g (=*
8 E '() .(
C8
# 7 0 / 9341
= ,
Z =
# /
# 7
# 7 C3
2 / 2545
= ,
Z =
S&
#
# 7 1=-
. K
$L;
UV, W
9=* C3
# 7 8 / 351
= ,
Z =
'() S&
# 8 D y 8 % . s* - UV,
W
# 3 D) : - D)
.$)
UV, W
$ 2v W
nj=
8 D
$,
1 + B 1&
D) $ 2v _W UV, _ : -
$ W
3 D) .
3 1&
D) } M
( ) : -
@ (
_ 3
$5 1 M 5B
-
$ +
*
$, . B _ 7
^ - 5 &
+D= , =) )
^ - 5 &
(
$ , i = 3 UV,
W S&
$, e
*•
: &
3 1
$5 UV, W
&
_
? e
: &
+
1 - 3 D) )
Muneer et al., 2014;
Emmanuel & Mary, 2014
.(
+
$L;
" '() W o%* 8 ; _D
# 7 C1
2 / 33
;
# M
8<
# 7 C8
9 / 24
;
$ E
# 7 C10
0 / 10
; S&
#
# 7
E '() .$, g (=* * 1
C2
# 7 0 / 29
#
# 7
# 7 C5
1 / 10 S&
#
# 7 1=-
.) 8 .(
K
$L;
; 8 o%*
W
C8
9=*
# 7 0 / 1
; '()
S&
# 8 D y
8 % M
8<
1
>
+
C3 C6
9=*
# 7 7 / 1 5 / 2
; '()
S&
#
y 8 % .
? o%*
S&
^ -
: -
# "
1 B *
$ ) w +D= , =)
# "
8<
"
8<
- 3 &
)
Akhter et al.,
.(2009
1 K , D) '
o%* 8
W -
^ _
S ) l V 8 -
1 W UV, i = 3 $E.
D= , =) 4 I 8< 5
*•
D= , =) + ) -
Ma et al., 2003
.(
+
$L;
f
" '() '&
_D
C2
# 7 0 / 390 4 3
# M
8<
# 7 C8
5 / 332 4 3
$ E
B12
# 7 6 / 199 4 3 S&
#
# 7 * 1 g (=*
E '() .$,
C10
# 7 5 / 623
4 3
#
# 7
# 7 C5
3 / 256
4 3 S&
#
# 7 1=-
.) +
4 5 .(
K
$L;
f '&
9=* C8
# 7
0 / 35 4 3 '()
S&
# 8 D y 8 % .
+
$L;
f
" '() '& o%*
_D
# 7 C6
3 / 25 4 3
# M
8<
# 7 C1
6 / 24 4 3
$ E
C3
# 7 7 / 14 4 3 S&
#
# 7 . g (=* * 1
E '()
# 7 C8
9 / 44 4 3
#
# 7
# 7 C3
5 / 23 4 3 S&
#
# 7
1=- .) 8 .(
K
$L;
f o%*
'&
A11
9=*
# 7 5 / 7 4 3 '()
S&
# 8 D y 8 % . J = <
8 % 1&
D)
$) + + - * B
_8
?
o%*
* - . 9=*
1 o%* '&
= 1I
= S D= , =) $ , 9=*
1I : L
B 1 8< D= , =) 1& $,
)
Koocheki & Khajeh Hosseni, 2008
.(
M? V
1 % : - S&
f J UV,
#
# &
)
Hole & Dearman, 1993
.(
I 8 T 9=*
f o%*
&
' L
# s* -
$L;
1 E
1 1I = q9;
K _ , 7
# 1&
M
- >, 8
"
E % &
~
9=* 1&
f
& '& o%*
_ '()
~ M K 1&
8 8 ,
S&
+
@9 . -
+
$L;
M '3 '()
_D "
# 7 C1
7 / 16
# M 8<
C3
# 7 0 / 14
$ E
# 7 A11
3 / 3 S&
#
# 7 1
* g (=*
$, .
#
? q 1&
E '()
# 7 C8
0 / 7
#
# 7 A11
0 / 1 S&
#
# 7
=- .) 9 .(
K
$L;
M '3
C6
9=*
# 7 0 / 0 '()
S&
# 8 D y 8 % M
8<
C5
9=*
# 7 7 / 1 '()
S&
# y
8 % .
> 4+
4 . A6 J ,0 K0 -
L M '& .#
N 6.0O
.0 6 9
: M # 7
1.
+ <
: y Z
'& o%* f
'& f W o%* 8 ; E W UV,
329**
/
3356 359487/987** 134/707** 195095135/5** 1 $%&'()
350 / 3
1575/208 0/779 421531/5 4 ('())
271**
/
204 36993/847** 154/142** 6103803/1** 8
052**
/
44 24553/138** 132/333** 5412166/4** 8 '()×
739 / 9
597/974 2/190 459897/8 32 V*
332 /
11 6/861 8/553 16/520 - (% ): y > v
I*# PQ,9- 2 4& :** * )ns
I*# PQ,9- - > ,S- TUM -
5 1 .4
> 4+
5 . J ,0 A6 K0 - L
M '& .#
N 6.0O 9
6 .0
# 7 : M
1.
+ <
: y Z
8 ;
o%*
V@
B
M
'3 121ns
/
0 1031/573** 1/251ns 384/000** 1 $%&'()
052 / 0
11/654 1/398 0/555 4 ('())
386**
/
9 223/042** 8/802** 38/750** 8
853**
/
2 130/698** 13/981** 21/500** 8 '()×
184 / 0
13/289 1/165 1/659 32 V*
039 /
15 9/493 9/211 16/563 - (% ): y > v
I*# PQ,9- 2 4& :** * )ns
I*# PQ,9- - > ,S- TUM -
5 1 .4
+
$L;
B
" '() _D
A11
# 7 7 / 16
= ,
=
# M
8<
# 7 C5
4 / 13
= ,
=
$ E
# 7 B12
0 / 8
= ,
= S&
#
# 7
. g (=* * 1 '()
E
# 7 C8
5 / 14
= ,
= +
# B
$%&
E
.) 9 .(
K
$L;
B
C6
9=*
# 7 1 / 0
= ,
= '()
S&
# 8 D
y 8 % M
8<
1
>
+
C3
9=* C1
# 7 5 / 0 5 / 0
= ,
= '()
S&
# y 8 % .
+
$L;
V@
'()
"
_D
# 7 C1
1 / 50
=
# =E
M 8<
C10
# 7 1 / 50
=
$ E
# 7 C6
6 / 28
= S&
#
# 7 E '() . g (=* * 1
C3
# 7 7 / 46
= +
# V@
$%&
E .) 9 .(
K
$L;
V@
9=* C3
# 7 0 / 1
= '()
S&
#
8 D y 8 % M
8<
1
>
+
C6 B12
9=*
# 7 0 / 2 0 / 3
=
'() S&
# y 8 % .
+
$L;
; o%* 8
" '() _D
# 7 A11
8 / 4 4 3
# =E M
8<
# 7 C6
0 / 4 4 3
$ E
C2
# 7 8 / 1 4 3 S&
#
# 7 g (=* * 1
E '() .
# 7 C6
6 / 6 4 3 +
#
; 8 o%*
$%&
E
.) 9 .(
K
$L;
; 8 o%*
9=* C1
# 7 0 / 0 4 3 '()
S&
#
8 D y 8 % . +
$L;
8 '()
"
_D
# 7 C2
5 / 281 4 3
#
M 8<
# 7 C8
7 / 250 4 3
$ E
# 7 A11
7 / 76 4 3 S&
#
# 7 1
E '() . g (=* *
C10
# 7
7 / 438 4 3 +
#
^, = 8
$%&
E .)
9 .(
K
$L;
8
9=* C2
# 7 4 / 4 4 3 '()
S&
#
8 D y 8 % ) . 10 .(
> 4+
6 . J ,0 A6 K0 - L
M '& .#
N 6.0O 9
6 .0
# 7 : M
1.
+ <
: y Z
$, " 8 =L,
$, " =L, ? 7T 8 ^, = 8
946**
/
73 108/202** 0/159** 7854/991** 20610/401** 1 $%&'() 093
/ 0
0/384 0/009 75/151 1055/119 4 ('())
346**
/
2 2/466** 0/053** 1456/133** 48452/363** 8
443**
/
3 1/710** 0/042** 786/789** 27080/416** 8 '()×
410 / 0
0/389 0/005 86/540 400/755 32 V*
892 /
9 7/706 7/963 14/440 9/964 - (% ): y > v
I*# PQ,9- 2 4& :** * )ns
I*# PQ,9- - > ,S- TUM -
5 1
.4
+
$L;
8 ^, =
" '() _D
C8
# 7 4 / 80 4 3
# M
8<
C2
# 7 6 / 75 4 3
$ E
# 7 C3
0 / 34 4 3 S&
#
# 7 . g (=* * 1
E '()
# 7 C2
8 / 96 4 3 +
#
^, = 8
$%&
E .)
10 .(
K
$L;
^, = 8
A11
9=*
# 7
0 / 1 4 3 '()
S&
# 8 D y 8 % . M
8<
1
>
+
C5
9=* C8
# 7 5 / 7
6 / 10 4 3 '()
S&
# y 8 % .
+
$L;
? 7T
" '() _D
# 7 C8
03 / 1 4 3
= ?
# M
8<
C6
# 7 0 / 1 4 3
= ?
$ E
C1
# 7 5 / 0 4 3
= ? S&
#
# 7 * 1
E '() .$, g (=*
C3
# 7
0 / 1 4 3
= ? +
#
? 7T
$%&
E .) 10 .(
K
$L;
? 7T
C2
9=*
# 7 057 / 0 4 3
= ? '()
S&
# 8 D y 8 % . M 8<
C6
9=*
# 7 059 / 0 4 3
= ? '()
S&
#
y 8 % . +
$L;
=L,
" '() $, "
_D
# 7 B12
3 / 11 4 3 &
= ,
= Z
#
M 8<
# 7 A11
1 / 10 4 3 &
= ,
= Z
$ E
# 7 C1
0 / 6
4 3 &
= ,
= Z S&
#
# 7 1
*
g (=*
$, E '() .
B12
# 7
3 / 7 4 3 &
= ,
= Z +
#
=L,
$%&
E .)
6 .(
K
$L;
=L,
$, "
C10
9=*
# 7 1 / 1 4 3 &
= ,
= Z '() S&
# 8 D y 8 %
M 8<
1
>
+
C1
9=* C2
# 7
3 / 1 3 / 2 4 3 &
= ,
= Z '()
S&
#
y 8 % .
+
$L;
=L, $, " 8
" '() _D
# 7 B12
7 / 9 4 3 &
= ,
= Z
# M
8<
C6
# 7 6 / 8 4 3 &
= ,
= Z
$ E
# 7 C1
0 / 6 4 3 &
= ,
= Z S&
#
# 7
E '() .$, g (=* * 1
C2
# 7 5 / 6 4 3 &
= ,
= Z +
#
=L,
$%&
E .)
10 .(
K
$L;
=L,
8
$, "
C1
9=*
# 7 2 / 0
4 3 &
= ,
= Z '() S&
# 8 D y
8 % M
8<
1
>
+
C10 C2
9=*
# 7 6 / 0 0 / 1 4 3 &
= ,
= Z
'() S&
# y 8 % .
I <
1&
n ' e=
× '() +
$L;
$K 6
' ) &
M _ 5 : n , 8 %
#
‚ 1 )C2
533 / 28 ( S&
#
‚ 1
)A11
738 / 23 ( - ) . 11 .(
f , D ? <
1 DI 1 1L?]
+
; _
# 17
1L?] _ . 1L?]
+ 1 5 f ,
# 1&
Eigenvalue
/ + o /
+ 90 M I ; _ ; .
1 c
e +
. = *
c"
f , J =
‚ 1 1 DI J "
1L?]
e
+ . 1L?]
1&
> v L
W D 1
: L;
^5 M
'3 _ 8
...
$ M . K
&
8 D
^ -
+ , .
1L?]
4 1&
> v
$5|
1
: L;
% UV,
_W M _W
^, = B
8 3 ...
1 9=*
-
%
^ -
V d 1=* "
' -) $, 1
( .
# 1&
f ,
# 1L?]
1eV o @ 3 8
S e=
$E.
+ &
q9;
+ M l 2=
.
> 4+
7 .
"#
/ # W0 8 'X- D& ",#
6.0O N DEF '&
L -4*6 )Y'&
ZM.,#
>.$
# 2 'C
>.$
6.&
N 6.0O 9
'()
$%&
M W
^, = B 8 3 (cm) B
1 (cm)
hij C1
000 / 13 373cde
/ 5 564fgh
/ 84
ij C2
666 / 11 400cde
/ 5 203fgh
/ 84
efg C3
333 / 18 160abc
/ 8 330def
/ 121
g-j C5
000 / 15 801bcd
/ 6 050def
/ 118
D "
ghi C6
333 / 15 809abc
/ 7 140def
/ 122
f-i C8
333 / 16 186a-d
/ 7 417efg
/ 99
j C10
000 / 10 324cde
/ 5 883gh
/ 56
fgh A11
000 / 17 712ab
/ 9 890de
/ 136
B12
000hij / 12 364e
/ 3 433h
/ 41
cde C1
666 / 22 626abc
/ 7 670c
/ 216
bcd C2
000 / 25 869abc
/ 7 460ab
/ 271
def C3
000 / 21 288abc
/ 8 300bc
/ 257
abc C5
666 / 27 427abc
/ 8 120c
/ 216
E a C6
000 / 31 465de
/ 4 330d
/ 159
a C8
666 / 32 149abc
/ 8 900a
/ 309
cd C10
000 / 24 315abc
/ 8 170bc
/ 233
bcd A11
666 / 25 309a
/ 10 840ab
/ 274
ab B12
666 / 29 711abc
/ 7 000abc
/ 266
P 'S
& # ' )2.,M 3- '[0
#\
TUM
> ,S- 1 4
=.6 2.#3\
PQ,9- I*#
- 40 -40 .
D5 1 N 6.0O C4I=-' - . 0 .
!]# ^ M-'&
_ > -
> 4+
8 .
"#
/ # W0 8 'X- D& ",#
6.0O N DEF '&
L TUM )Y'&
4 23
` 9 Y'&
&
^ #.
'6
` 9 D=
N 6.0O 9
'()
$%&
UV, W (cm2)
; 8 o%*
W (%) f
'&
(gr) f
o%*
'&
(gr)
de C1
230 / 2783 716a
/ 33 770d-g
/ 308 640def
/ 24
e C2
45 / 1545 189ef
/ 16 070cd
/ 390 604ef
/ 19
de C3
460 / 2193 055fg
/ 14 830i
/ 206 702f
/ 14
de C5
990 / 2306 583cd
/ 21 560d-g
/ 302 222f
/ 15
D "
de C6
730 / 1863 017fg
/ 14 550hi
/ 210 334def
/ 25
de C8
340 / 2788 825bc
/ 24 490c-f
/ 332 939def
/ 20
de C10
640 / 2866 006g
/ 10 850e-h
/ 298 750f
/ 14
e A11
700 / 1122 186fg
/ 14 630ghi
/ 223 068ef
/ 19
de B12
890 / 2367 362cde
/ 21 590i
/ 199 635def
/ 22
cd C1
510 / 4168 558fg
/ 14 790ab
/ 584 081abc
/ 39
bc C2
840 / 5820 017ab
/ 29 030b
/ 513 035ab
/ 40
de C3
220 / 2545 379fg
/ 12 160c
/ 403 460def
/ 23
b C5
210 / 6701 155g
/ 10 340f-i
/ 256 088cde
/ 28
E b C6
040 / 6805 542fg
/ 11 060cde
/ 365 925a
/ 43
a C8
990 / 9340 822bc
/ 23 530cde
/ 367 946a
/ 44
bc C10
770 / 6156 523def
/ 16 490a
/ 623 278bcd
/ 31
bc A11
290 / 6088 238g
/ 10 370def
/ 312 566de
/ 26
bc B12
830 / 6424 275fg
/ 13 220b
/ 516 415ab
/ 41
P 'S
& # ' )2.,M 3- '[0
#\
TUM
> ,S- 1 4
=.6 2.#3\
I*# PQ,9- -
40 -40 .
C1
C2
C3
C5 C6
C8
C10 B12 A11
0 500 1000 1500 2000 2500
-2500 -2000
-1500 -1000
-500 0
500
