یکشزپ مولع رد شزومآ ی هعسوت ی هلجم

(1)

! "#$% & ' 1393

12. #2 "

&

1

34 5 6 278

&

2

79 : ; 278

&

3

= >? 28 278 8 A%- 278 &

4

5

A>B4 1

# B C

! :

"

#$ % [email protected]

&' ()!

: 22 / 12 / 93 (0

# : 26 / 7 / 94

"+

, - .

:

» 567 # 7

« "9(9: 9(!

)

;6 ) <)!

=> ? @6<

<

&6A'

! ' )!

: B7 '

!$

.

» 7 # D

« E( F<)!

G(

F@

? 20

&6A' $ 9I)!

& 9 $ " 7 .

80 9I)!

&6A'

< 7 (! ? D: $ 567 # 7 <

&

. $ % K )!

< !) !! : ? E(

L @ # 7 96 M

9 ) ! &6D7 ! ' & )! $ 9 < 567 # 7

! ' 9(!

. E( 0

( A <

"

L)!! 9 6N L)!! 9 ( 5 ! 567 # 7

!$ ! .

: /

;7 O A ( A "

! ( ) <

6 P

7 !

! <

<

( 5 ! " ) !

Q )!

1393 5

9 . D

" 6 R6 ! <

152 5 ! ) 41 " 5 !

! 9 L)!

111 L)! ! 9 6N " 5 ! (

9 9 !)

. VD:) <

WX ") %

?

@ 133 7 ) < 9 < () 5@7 567 # -

Z6' ! [\

6[P ( 5 ! &F: ! <

( 5

?6 P $%$ 7 ! ! Anova

Ttest " ) $%

Kruskal Wallis 9(! ! ]

.

0 L)!! 9 ( 5 ! 567 # 7 E6 6 & % 6< : 77

/ 103 )!

( 5 !

! 9 6N L)!

41 / 98 $% ! <

( A Ttest Q D ^ _ )! ! E( 567 # 7 ! !

% 5 85) / 0

= ) ! @ ](P

!) 9 . ] )!

) ! @ ] ( ' ! L

9 9(! L)!! 9 6N L)!! 9 ( 5 ! E6<

) 004 / 0

= (.P )9 W6[P )

046 / 0

= ( P )

"

6[P ) 039 / 0

= ( P # 7 <

! ) ! @ ] L)! ! 9 ( 5 ! 567 )! 6

= )9 W6[P )

04 / 0

= ( P )! W6[P )

034 / 0

= ( P 567 # 7 <

9 9(! ) ! @ ] L)! ! 9 6N ( 5 ! .

: ! ( 5 ! 567 # 7 E6< ! ! b(

! : ) ! @ ] L)!! 9 6N L)!! 9 0 9

&]

9 < D 567 # 7 D:$ (! " 7 ( $ c < ") !) L < @ < ! < L)!! 9 d I .

567 # 7 &6D7 < : <

' L)!! 9 ( 5 ! ( @ " 7) 6 )! !! 6 ! F@ 6 567 # 7 < GR " 7) 6 !! ] D # 7 " 7) 6 < GA

$ ;6<

80 ? ) :)!! ' &6A' $ 9I)!

! & ") e ! ' K )!

D # 7) @ )! 567 # 7 < $ % c

9@( D : .

!2 : 3

& 1 !

&: E A 7

& 1

>

FE

1 - ( F ( ! #$ % 9 ) @ ) " 5 !

2 - ! "

[[\

") #$ % ) 6 !

! #$ %

(

3 - !

"

[[\

@6 < @ ) ) 6 !

( )! 9F< 9L !

F (

4 -

") #$ % ) 6 !

!

") A6AP (

5 - ! [[\ "

($ ) % ) 6 !

! (

Downloaded from zums.ac.ir at 10:57 IRDT on Monday May 8th 2017

(2)

&6' f $ " D5 567 # 7

&6 < g 7 7

) F ( & L @ 6N " 7 )! ) ! ' " 7

;( ' 6P " 7) ' 6h A < 6 % &6A' !) L <

97!

) 1 ( &6' f $ & ) R ( @ <

567 ) ! ! <) &L @ $ < i )!

! L " 7

(!

) 2 .(

^ &L @ $ 9@ ) R # 7 E( " 7 O(

9 $ )! j @ " 7 B6D[ " < ! ] E ( L Q @ ) Ve " L k L l " ) ! (

; $ & @7 < 6 96 ! 5( 7

d97 < E ' 6 & ! )

3 (.

! < B67 ] ( < & 6 F] 567 # 7

!) ! ) % m R ) 9 $ .

b( )! m R ) = E( $ \<

) D: % $ & 9 % AAP )

1998 ( ! D #)

< 567 # 7 "! ' m < ! $ 9 ) ! " c

9 ) !) L < 7) )! F< ! D QWA 9 $ .

E(

A n < < )! E6< # L 9 $ < &R ! ' ! < ) !) L < 9 $ )! 6< " 7 &6A' &' 6 $

9 ) 4 .(

l ( K $ )

2000 ( 567 # 7 < ! '

! c <

W < 9 6o $ 9@ 7 R &6[\ " ) < d 9@ L ; o < ) 7 &6 g 9 < 0

9@\ ) p6 5 )! ! ?D d97 )

5 .(

97 kRX

q6 ( ) ( () r 6L 7 O

) 2013 (

567 # 7 9 ! ! 6[P ! D 9

(

" 7 c < L @ O(

" 7 6[\

) R= <

;6 9@ @6<

).

6 (

! $ 9D^ " ] : )

1393 ( E6< 9@ ' ()!

@ &Rs RD7 6[P &' 6 567 # 7

!) ! ! : ") ! )

7 .(

D: $ 6D7 A < ! 9 " ) ! ! ' ( @ ' X $

& ! < dW L !) ?(

. (c!

!) E( )! "! ($ ? ! 9 ! < R ( k 96A $ !) ! ! :

&

. 9 ) ! 96 ! 9 ! < R < 9(9: " 7 Q9 )

8 .(

^ X " < $ % < t < 9 ! ' l \

& GR 6 ! .

n < ]( Q s " <

( 5 ! 9 < &6gWL < ) F % 9@( < ) uWL

9@ &( 97 6< &6gWL &D )

9 .(

)! 6<

96 ) 56 E( < 9 ! ) L)! ! 9 6^

9

( E !

< )! &6A' @6< ;6 &F: ( F@ <

& 6 ' gWL " 7 .

6 9@ (!

&6[\

Q [P 96 )! "! ($ 6D< D & 9

& => gWL )

10 .(

7! $ 80 ! ' ( @ 6 "!W6

v $ 9 v

&

D # 7 " 7 v

&D < )!

# )

& ! 66w ( @ t @ " 7 .

! L #) )! ( % #$ % 6 6D q6x) 9@ ) 96 Q )! @ <

1972 9 (

:

"

" 7! 9 < ! '

: < " 7 ( & < 9@ 7 L)!

c < ! D &6 < g " ) ! 9@ <

.

< < $ 6 ! ' E(

< ) @(! 9@ < 9 ) ! ( D 9L $ % " 7 9@@ ! : ! L

"

) 11 (.

? BF E66 )! ' X $ F@ 6[P &6A' < m <

20 <9I)!

" < 6 E( & ' ( y [ L IQ

) !) g 6[P "c < VX A )! ( 5 ! ;7 6 " E6x (! A < ^ 9 ) ! 6 < L 6[P

9< ( . )! "! ' E6< 567 6 ? ;A q

E( )! 6[P &' 6 $ D7 ( 5 ! $

97 L BF ) 6 < 9 ) !) L < (c < "! D # 7

! <

) 12 .(

D ) 6 $ ) )! e ^ Q ^ )! ' X $

L)! ! 9 @ < ! ' ( @ &F: Q9 () @ ) " ) ! c <IQ

(

! ! ] .

( ! ! #$ % ) 567 # 7 < @( !) )! R

!) ! ! : ' " 7 K dW L 6L

(3)

< ) ) 2003 ( @ < "

» 567 # 7 ;A

! Q Q ( 5 ! 6[P &' 6 )!

« ) 760 =

(n

! ! 5 . 567 # 7 " 7 ) F E6< ! ! b(

!) ! ! : ) ! @ m R ) 6[P &' 6 )

13 .(

% $ )

2004 ( " ) < 7 O )!

39 :

567 # 7 z9@ ' ()! 6 ) ?6 P k( X $ # 7 6 !) 9 D : 6[P &6A' )! ") ! @ ;A )

14 (.

) <

- 15 {L z 567

7 %! L ) : ? M

d 9D7 567

" (0

! Q @

"! ' E6< G< ) QWA ?^ ( @6< # L

&6 | ^! L ( ' ! L x $% &6 g ' w &6A' < m R ) )! ) ) ) ' D :

& ! D )

15 (.

! < t @ ! < : <

&6D7 7 6=

! L w 6[P 9 $ p \ ! < )! 567 ...

" 7 &6 g )! ! ' < m R ) )! 567 # 7

p \

") e

! <

} I [L )!

~ )! ( 5 !

) g c < D : @7 ' _ < ! 6[P ! ' " 7 &' 6 )! < ) )! DF & ) < 9 ) ! 9 ) ! D .

!) ! ! : ? E( $ % K )!

< F@

$ 9 < 567 # 7 96 M 6[P (

! ' 9(! 9 ) ! &6D7 ! ' & )!

. )!

! < 9@7 L : )! ) 0 6= ! ' 6 ) I 9@ < c < 567 # 7 " ) ! .

) E( )!

"

#$ % < ZD &F: e ^

<

" () y [L )!

567 # 7 " 6 ) < ) F

( 5 ! )!

#$ % B 6 • A ) k( X$

( 5 ! )! 567 # 7 @6 $ )! WX ( )

& ' (0 ) I .

(9 < < !) L $ < 9 < b( & 96 9 6 B6D[

979< t e &6D7 < : <

y L 6^ E( )! 7 % #$ % )! ) 0 6 9 ) ! <

.

/

E(

$ A ]6I t

! ( ) <

6 P !

67 )! ! R !

)!

1393 5

9(!

.

;7 O :

) ( 5 ! !

?6

9 ! ! .

< : <

) D7 E(9 6Ff )

16 (

) 6 d P E6 6 !) % <

2 / 3 21± 567 # 7 D

?g 9^ ) K ( 5 !)!

12 ( 5 ! < 9^

7 $ L)! ! 9 49

9(! !) % < ] .

E( )!

L)! ! 9 ( 5 ! D 6< &g! " <

<

' K )! L)!! 9 6N " 5 ! % <

9 .

D

;7 O " 7 ( 5 ! 6

!

)!

6[P Q 1393

<

# ) " 6 D

R6 9 9 l \

.

!) v v@ < n ! )! L)! ! 9 ( 5 ! ? )

") D ( 7$ " 5 ! @ ( % < <

v ) vD

'! [ ) [< q@: D7 E66

) vg v ) < !) v

9@ ' . < ! ) ) 6 :

( 5 ! 6

!

! )! $ )!

9 ! < ( 5 ! ) D " ) ! ?6[P < Q w 97 9 6N ( 5 ! L)! !

!)

L)! ! 9 ( 5 ! ?6

! ! . VD: ) <

% ")

7 ! ! :

@ [\ & \ ;\< "

( 5 ! 6[P Z6' ! )

&6 g &6 @: E

6[P V A ) (

? % ! ;\<

c

(4)

567 # 7 ) < 9 < () 5@7

- ) 133 Q | (

! <

.

? ) 0 @ 15

6^

"

6^

"

7 % ! L Z(

9 ) ! <)! 567

"

c 7 - 9 - 23 - 35 - 52 - 63 - 88 -

116 6^

"

9 ) ! <)! "9@ : !

"

c 22 -

37 - 67 - 82 - 96 - 111 - 126 6^

"

q] & ^

9 ) ! <)!

"

c 11 - 24 - 40 - 56 - 70 - 85 - 100 - 114 -

129 6^

"

9 ) ! <)! ( ' ! L ) Fo -

"

c 6 -

21 - 36 - 51 - 66 - 81 - 95 - 110 - 125 6^

"

QWA b@

9 ) ! <)!

"

c 3 - 19 - 32 - 48 - 92 - 107 - 121 6^

"

9 ) ! <)! 9D7 ;

"

c 18 - 44 - 55 - 61 - 72 -

98 - 119 - 124 6^

"

&]7 9 ) ! <)! "! ' E6< G< )

"

c 10 - 23 - 31 - 39 - 55 - 62 - 69 - 84 - 99 - 113 - 128

6^

"

& 7 9 ) ! <)! D : " (0 &6

"

c 16 - 30 - 46 - 61 - 72 - 76 - 90 - 98 - 104 - 119 6^

?^

9 ) ! <)!

"

c 1 - 15 - 29 - 45 - 60 - 75 - 89 -

118 6^

"

9 ) ! <)! ( $ &6 g !

"

c 8 -

35 - 38 - 53 - 68 - 83 - 88 - 97 - 112 - 127 6^

"

!$ (

9 ) ! <)! " (0 d

"

c 14 - 28 - 43 - 59 - 74 -

87 - 103 - 131 6^

"

9 ) ! <)! n ?DP !$ !

"

c 4 - 20 - 33 - 49 - 64 - 78 - 93 - 108 - 122 6^

"

! 6 c 9 ) ! <)! Q @ 13

- 27 - 42 - 58 - 73 -

86 - 102 - 117 - 130 6^

"

9 ) ! <)! ! !) Fo

"

c 2 - 17 - 31 - 47 - 62 - 77 - 91 - 105 - 120 6^

"

9 ) ! <)! @6< # L !

"

c 11 - 20 - 26 - 54 -

80 - 106 - 108 - 132 9 <

.

P

"

") 0 D

@( 5 % $ p6X Z( " ) < 7

5 6 " :)!

9 B6K@

$ ") 0 D 9 5

Z( <

) BA' W 5

W B] \ 1 ( )!

h <

( ]@ " P < c

n - ) D Q 9:)!

6 & W <

× 9 9 {\

-

< Z( $ 5

) Wv A' Bv 1 Wv

\ v B]

5 ( 5 v 9(!

. D

"

7 D t D5 < < < n 6A 7 ?

t D5 < < < $% ? D n 6A % c > $ Z(

D 15 6A 9 < n .

$% E( )! 6< $ 6 j

)! ( K !) n 6A )! ! ' 6< &6A' ?

9 < q < $%

. Ws c < $ 6 j n 6A )!

9@7! "$ < ! L

"

& ! ' )! 6< "$ < ! L .

v7 ! ! ") %! ) < ( ( ( ) :

) v< @v -

v567 # v7 v@6 $ )! v ) ! vL $% E( V :

&vv ) 7 ( )! vv 6

&vv 9vv < vv() 5@7 : ) vv .

)!

D ) ;7 O )

1383 ( " v] % $ ! ] v v< v $% ( (

• R 81 / 0

& 9 % & ! <

.

< ) < E(

v )!

v )! $ v % ;v ! 5v ! ?v6Rg $ pv \ " 7 L ! & 9 ' ) <

) 17 .(

( ) ( ( E6@rD7

) < 567 # 7 @ -

$ ! ] < " 6 7! G

9vv 9vv6( ' vv vv ?vv6 P ( vv $%$ < # )

&

) 18 .(

7 ! ! ") VD: # ) :

$ 9 < ) 5 &F:

v ! $ @6' $ ! ] < ~ X j( [ &v

") @' A6AP !

9 ! & ()$ $ : j <

7

@7 D7 <

&v 6 $ ! ] < 9 ! #$ % c

L)! ! 9 ( 5 ! v L)! ! 9 v v '! $ v

! 7 v') v $ % W6Fv v E6( < : <

9 9 {\ L)! " 7! 9 O(

) (%

" ) ! E6

11 D:$ 9@<

9( <

v $%

" v v v ( $%

< 5 j <

R )

")

"

$ D 500 vR )

" 7 ' (0 <

9v v $%)!

" v7

"! ) ) ! " v7

W6[P v 6D

9v ) v @ ) (.... Ph.D

&v 6

v v L)! ! 9 v 6N ( 5v ! &vF: ( 5 ! $

9v ' ! #$ % ) 6 L )! @v

( 5v !

) g

&' ( ‚ $ q v7 @

") % VvD:

9 . 7 ! ! ?6 P ( 5 # )

(5)

) ' !) 7 @ WX 6

SPSS16

9(!

qƒ 9(! < ($) b( ) R !) 9 7 ! ! 9 <

p6I " <

&F: ) ! D Q 9:$ 7 ! !

?6 P ( 5

$%$ 7 ! !

Kolmogorov-Smirnov

! < Q " <

! !

$%$ 7

Levene

() B7 " <

) ($)!

7 (

$% $

t test

9(! ! ] ! ( A " <

.

' ( q () 6 %

ANOVA

($ " <

< 7 m

B7 " ) $%$ ! < q ()

Kruskal-Wallis

" <

($

9(! ! ] q () B7 " 7 .

gWL K^W

WX " ' $ " 6 : P ?I [\

\ ( 9 F\ b( $ "!) ! ] )!

9(! &( ) .

0

7 O E( )!

v ; v

$ q 6 6 v

"

" 7 v

!9

" <

L v 0

t D5 $ 9 ?6D " 7 @ 152

V($ @

9 131

&' ) g ) < !) @ .

& 6 $ 56

" $ )! L)! ! 9 ( 5 ! " ] 15

$ ?6[P „) ' ] 41

] 4 9 ! 9 ‚ @ < ]

3 {L )! ]

D7

1 d0^ !) )! ]

$

9 9(! …) L .

E6< )! 9 V($ " 7 @ $

L)! ! 9 6N ( 5 ! 17

9 ! 9 ‚ ] 9

]

D7 {L )!

7 9@ ' ) g d0^ !) • : ]

9 9(! …) L $ .

' ( ) < E( )!

< " 7

< 9 % & ! & ($ ~

:

' (

" 7 <

9 % & ! E( )!

& % 6<

E6<

6N L)! ! 9 ( 5 ! 567 # 7

! 9

!) 9 ! : ) ! @ ] L)!

. 085 / 0

=

P

.

L)! ! 9 6N L)! ! 9 ( 5 ! E6<

& ^ "9@ : 7 %! L " 7 ] )!

q]

"! ' E6< G< ) 9D7 QWA " (0 &6

?^ D : &6 g

% ?DP " (0 d ( $

@ ] 6 @6< # L ! Q @ n ) ! @ ] ( ' ! L ] )! 9 97 ) ! ! 9 6N L)! ! 9 ( 5 ! E6<

9(! L)!

9 ) 004 / 0

= (.P

!) &6 D: )! ! ! Z6' ! " 7 ' ( ($ @ 25

L)! ! 9 ( 5 ! )! Q

<

5 / 81 < L)! ! 9 6N ( 5 !)! 9I)!

6 / 76

"c < @ E( 6< 9I)!

30 ( 5 !)! Q

< L)! ! 9 4

/ 7 D 9I)!

) ( 5 ! ! 9 E(

9 ! ! y [ L ! L < E( )!

.

< ! 5 L)! ! 9 ( 5 ! 8

/ 81 E( 6<9I)!

< ?7 2 / 18 ! 9 6N ( 5 ! )! E( D 9I)!

< ! 5 L)!

6 / 76 < ?7 9I)!

4 / 23 E( D 9I)!

9 ! ! y [ L ! L < E( )! ) .

( 5 !)!

B ƒ(! ($ ! 6< _ )! )! W6[P L)! ! 9 < < B ƒ(!

3 / 27 < " ! _ )! E( 6<9I)!

)! L)! ! 9 6N ( 5 ! )! E( D 9I)! ]I < B ƒ(! _ 3

/ 33 < " ! _ )! E( 6< 9I)!

)! ) )! W6[P _ E( D 9I)! ]I < E(

! ! y [ L ! L 9

.

' (

L)! ! 9 ( 5 !)! 9796 7

< B ƒ(! _ )! )9 W6[P 3

/ 33 )! E( 6<9I)!

< " ! _ 3

! 9 6N ( 5 ! )! E( D 9I)!

< B ƒ(! _ )! L)!

39 _ )! E( 6< 9I)!

< " ! 6

/ 2 _ E( D 9I)!

E( )! ) )9 W6[P

9 ! ! y [ L ! L <

. ( 5 !)! E6@rD7

< n) ' &6 g L)! ! 9 8

/ 81 E( 6<9I)!

< ED 2 / 18 ! 9 6N ( 5 ! )! E( D 9I)!

< n) ' &6 g L)!

8 / 71 < i E( 6< 9I)!

(6)

3 / 1 L < E( )! ) E( D 9I)!

! ! y [ L ! 9

.

)! L)! ! 9 ( 5 ! !) &6 D: )!

< ") " 7 ) 2

/ 18 )! E( 6<9I)!

E' G6P & 9F< 9 ! " 7 )

") % " 7

< E(

3 L)! ! 9 6N ( 5 ! E( D 9I)!

) )!

v "

v <

3 / 25 I)!

v 6< 9 v ) E(

v E'

") % < E( " 7 3

/ 1 9I)!

E( )! ) E( D ! L <

y [ L

! ! 9 . ' ( 9@7! 7

"

)! ") ! @ ]

)9 W6[P < 567 # 7 )

046 / 0

= (P

)

"

L)! ! 9 ( 5 ! )! 6[P )

039 / 0

= (P

)9 W6[P )

04 / 0

= (P

)!

) 034 / 0

= (P

( 5 ! )!

9 ! < L)! ! 9 6N .

C A5 4 - 1 : B4 H I 8 1 ! J K1 : E A 7 2 L : E A 7 # 2= :

M . * : H I 1 !

A 7 2 L : E A 7 : 4 1 : E N

Mean Std.

Deviation t

Sig. (2- tailed)

1 !

L)! ! 9 33

8 / 738 103

/ 1 738

/ 1 085

/

0 1/136 98/4 78 L)! ! 9 6N

= E L)! ! 9

33 8

/ 99 464

/ 1 136

/ 1 258

/

0 1/587 94/0 78 L)! ! 9 6N

A> , 25 L)! ! 9

33 9

/ 102 966

/ 2 464

/ 1 146

/

0 0/177 97/7 78 L)!! 9 6N

N.1 F 2I L)! ! 9

33 3

/ 103 043

/ 0 587

/ 1 115

/

0 0/938- 97/6 78 L)! ! 9 6N

4 9 E

L)! ! 9 33

0 / 166 107

/ 1 966

/ 2 004

/ 0

* 1/444 91/0 78 L)! ! 9 6N

L)! ! 9 C6 7 33

1

/ 99 732

/ 1 177

/ 0 859

/

0 0/054 98/4 78 L)! ! 9 6N

L)! ! 9 A%

33 6

/ 96 069

/ 1 043

/ 0 966

/

0 0/197- 96/4 78 L)! ! 9 6N

29 J * O*

L)! ! 9 33

6

/ 91 709

/ 1 938

/ 0 - 35

/

0 0/162 97/0 78 L)! ! 9 6N

24P F QB

%75 L)! ! 9

33 5

/ 101 0

/ 13 166

/ 1 246

/

0 27/8 95/6 78 L)! ! 9 6N

B I L)! ! 9

33 3

/ 101 7

/ 23 444

/ 1 152

/

0 26/8 93/6 78 L)! ! 9 6N

4 " F R L)! ! 9

33 0

/ 103 7

/ 14 732

/ 1 086

/

0 27/4 94/2 78 L)! ! 9 6N

(7)

24P S H 1

! ! 9 L) 33

1

/ 97 1

/ 23 054

/ 0 957

/

0 22/1 96/8 78 L)! ! 9 6N

T27 %- L)! ! 9

33 8

/ 98 3

/ 23 069

/ 1 288

/

0 28/9 92/8 78 L)! ! 9 6N

1 C27>8 L)! ! 9

33 6

/ 95 4

/ 26 197

/ 0 - 844 /

0 21/1 96/5 78 L)! ! 9 6N

L)! ! 9 8 33

5

/ 103 9

/ 13 709

/ 1 09

/

0 19/8 97/0 78 L)! ! 9 6N

> * ! E L)! ! 9

33 4

/ 98 9

/ 32 162

/ 0 872

/

0 15/1 97/6 78 L)! ! 9 6N

L)! ! 9 ( 5 ! 567 # 7 E6<

6N v

! 9

9 9(! ) ! @ ] L)!

. E6<

! ( 5 v

L)! ! 9 6N L)! ! 9

] )!

v 7 v : 7 %! L "

"9@

q] & ^

"! ' E6< G< ) 9D7 QWA " (0 &6

?^ D :

&6 g

% ?DP " (0 d ( $

@ ] 6 @6< # L ! Q @ n 9 97 ) ! ) ! @ ] ( ' ! L ] )!

L)! ! 9 ( 5 ! E6<

v L)! ! 9 6N

9 9(!

.

C A5 4 - 3 : : E A 7 2 L : E A 7 : 4 1 U- 7E > F %5 , UE

6w L)! ! 9 ( 5 !

L)! ! 9 ( 5 !

! 9 ) 9I)!

( @ Q D ^ _

") ! ) ( Sig

! 9 ) 9I)!

( @ Q D ^ _

") ! (Sig)

E 25

22 <

) 5 / 81 ( 292

/ 0 56

) 6 / 76 ( 501

/ 0

30 - 25 3

) 1 / 11 ( 4

) 4 / 23 (

30 >

2 ) 4 / 7 ( -

q@:

L!

27

) 8 / 81 ( 995

/ 0 59

) 6 / 76 ( 625

/ 0

6

) 2 / 18 ( 18

) 4 / 23 (

?7

! 5 27

) 8 / 81 ( 926

/ 0 66

) 6 / 84 ( 789

/ 0

?7 6

) 2 / 18 ( 12

) 4 / 15 (

( -

-

)! W6[P

! 6<

9

) 3 / 27 ( 472

/ 0 9

) 5 / 11 ( 034

/ 0

*

B ƒ(! ($

9

) 3 / 27 ( 25

) 1 / 32 (

B ƒ(!

9

) 3 / 27 ( 26

) 3 / 33 (

n @ ) 5

) 2 / 15 ( 15

) 2 / 19 (

9 ) n @ )

1 ) 3 ( 3

) 8 / 3 (

(8)

" ! -

-

)9 W6[P

! 6<

3

) 1 / 9 ( 046

/ 0

* 4

) 2 / 5 ( 04

/ 0

*

B ƒ(! ($

9

) 3 / 27 ( 11

) 3 / 14 (

B ƒ(!

11

) 3 / 33 ( 30

) 39 (

n @ ) 9

) 3 / 27 ( 21

) 3 / 27 (

9 ) n @ )

- 9

) 7 / 11 (

" ! 1

) 3 ( 2

) 6 / 2 (

&6 g n) '

27

) 8 / 81 ( 402

/ 0 56

) 8 / 71 ( 478

/ 0

ED 6

) 2 / 18 ( 12

) 4 / 15 (

‡ <

-

1 ) 3 / 1 (

i -

6 ) 7 / 7 (

( -

3 ) 8 / 3 (

6[P V A

n @ ) 23

) 7 / 69 ( 124

/ 0 48

) 3 / 62 ( 434

/ 0

9 ) n @ )

1 ) 3 ( 1

) 3 / 1 (

9

) 3 / 27 ( 28

) 4 / 36 (

PHD -

-

6[P )

6 ) 2 / 18 ( 039

/ 0

*

19

) 3 / 25 ( 578

/ 0

9 ! 3

) 1 / 9 ( 9

) 12 (

9 ! 1

) 3 ( 1

) 3 (

( $%

4 ) 1 / 12 ( 4

) 3 / 5 (

" R 7 3

) 1 / 9 ( 8

) 7 / 10 (

?D u 2

) 1 / 6 ( 4

) 3 / 5 (

D & 9F<

4 ) 1 / 12 ( 12

) 16 (

G6P & 9F<

1 ) 3 ( 2

) 7 / 2 (

E( " F() Ĥ@' 1

) 3 ( 1

) 3 / 1 (

") 6

) 2 / 18 ( 12

) 16 (

( 2

) 1 / 6 ( 3

) 4 (

$% $

T TEST

567 # 7 < E q@: = " <

! ] L)! ! 9 6N L)! ! 9 ( 5 ! 9 . " ) $% $

Kruskal Wallis

)! W6[P = " <

! ] L)! ! 9 6N ( 5 ! 567 # 7 <

9 .

$% $ ! ] < 7 6w g <

ANOVA

) g ;5@ !)

9@ ' . ) )9 W6[P )!

"

567 # 7 < 6[P

W6[P )9 W6[P )! L)!! 9 ( 5 ! ] L)!! 9 6N ( 5 ! 567 # 7 <)!

9 9(! ) ! @ .

(9)

45/

' ( 7

< b(

9 % & ! E( )!

& % 6<

N L)! ! 9 ( 5 ! 567 # 7 E6<

6

!) 9 ! : ) ! @ ] L)!! 9 6e ' E( < @<

! 96( k6AP )‰% 9( 7 ) < <

1386 ) 19 (

( A y [L )!

"

# 7 6 $ % ; ! 567 # 7

567 # 7 E6< ") ! @ ] ! ! 5 "!

D7 9 97 "! # 7 6 $ % ; !

<

9 .

)!

E(

)!

E6< ) ! @ ] ( ' ! L ]

9(! L)! ! 9 6N L)! ! 9 ( 5 ! 9 . ] ( ) < b(

1388 ) 20 ( " : E6< $ 97!

< 7 ] 6A< $ ;6< ( ' ! L ] 567 # 7

!) ! m R ) 567 # 7 .

<

K v ] E( 9 ) v

BF

<

L)! ! 9 ( 5 ! 6[P &6A' )! ( 9 < ! .

' ( <

9 % & ! E E6< ") ! @ ] k6AP E( )!

567 # 7 < 6[P V A ?7 &6 g q@:

! : L)! ! 9 6N L)! ! 9 ( 5 !

& 9 . ) < b(

) D7 6<

1388 ) 21 ( @6< ;6 )!

Z6' ! " 7 6w n < ( 5 ! 567 # 7 !) ! ) ! @ " < ) 567 # 7 < E ! !

) < " 7 ) < )!

- 2000 ) 22 ( 6 $ c < @

E6( @ < &R " c < 567 # 7 9 ) !) L <

.

! ' ( E( E66R ) 7

c < < 567 # 7 &]

< 9< ( ;( ' # < 5 ;( ' E E ') 9 < D kR @ E( ' ( .

9 % ?(c! $ (

9 < E( )! ! ' @ $ <

! 9^) 81 I)!

v $ <)! 9 19

25 9 ! < Q (.

)!

"

q@: E6< ") ! @ ] e ^ # 7 <

L)! ! 9 6N L)! ! 9 ( 5 ! 567 9 97

"9@D:) ?6 L ) <

1383 ) 23 ( E6@o 6

! ! ) " ' ( .

" 6 7! ) <

1382 ) 24 ( E6< )!

F " F7 ! ( 5 ! B6 ^

"! : 1383 ) 25 (

"9 1384 ) 26 (

‡ - q6 1997

) 27 ( 9 ! 9 ) 6 @: ] 6 .

") [@

1380 ) 28 ( 9 ) @ ) ( 5 ! ) < <

F " F7 !

! ! : )! 567 # 7 E6<

!) ! ! : ) ! @ ] L!

.

] $ 9 7 ' ( ] ( D7 9 E(

E6<

: ! ! ' " 7 O(

)

< !

F7 ! ( (

9 <

.

567 # 7 )! ") ! @ ] 9@7! 7 ' ( )9 W6[P <

) 046 / 0

= (P

)

"

)! 6[P

L)! ! 9 ( 5 ! )

039 / 0

= (P

)9 W6[P

) 04 / 0

= (P

)!

) 034 / 0

= (P

( 5 ! )!

! 9 6N

) D7 6< ) < < 7 ' ( E( 9 ! < L)!

1388 ) 21 ( y [L )!

( 5 ! 567 # 7 @6< ;6

) Z6' ! " 7 6w n <

"

6[P m R )

D7 & ! 567 # 7 < ") ! @

<

@ 9 .

!

567 # 7 E6< ! ! b(

! 9 ( 5 !

!) 9 ! : ) ! @ ] L)!! 9 6N L)!

9@7! ( 5 ! ! < L)! ! 9

"

c <

6N ( 5 ! < &R % 567 # 7 ! <

! R L)!! 9 )!

E(

)! F@

! L ]

( 5 ! E6< ) ! @ ] ( ' L)! ! 9

< 9 9(! L)! ! 9 6N K

! L ] 9 )

(10)

< BF ( ' ( 5 ! 6[P &6A' )! (

9 < ! L)! ! 9 .

< k6AP E( < : <

6N L)! ! 9 ( 5 ! 567 # 7 n 6g L)! ! 9

! @ !$ ! )! ) ) )

) y [L E(

( b( 9

"

E6 e ^

) _ )! #) b( & 96 9 <

) 0 6 (9 < R @ l !) L $ < 9 <

y L 6^ E( )! 7 % % 979< #$ % )!

9 ) ! <

.

7 &6D7 < : <

" 7 ] 7) 6 )! 567 #

# 7 " 7) 6 < GA' L)! ! 9 ( 5 ! ( @ 567 # 7 < GR " 7) 6 !! ] L @ $ ;6<

80 ! ? ) : )! ! ' &6A' $ 9I)!

! ' K )!

. !

$ ( : O(

"

)!

#)

# 7 567

<

@ ] >

6=

) 0 )!

9 )

? R@:

" 7 6[P

D : ( 5 !

) !) L <

&

E( < @<. ) e

!) !

)!

<

" 7 D ) 6N

D ) ! ( : O(

"

" <

#)

" F ) F 567 ( 5 ! )!

K '

! .

" 6 6 ( ?I ^ A E(

#$ ) 9 ) @ )

) D < ( !

168 ‚()

12 / 9 / 1393 l [ A6AP ~ X E6@rD7 ") @' A6AP & #$ %

!

<

~ X 9 930528094 ‚()

j( [ 28 / 5 / 1393 9 <

.

References

1- Bar-on R. The Bar-On model of emotional- social intelligence (ESI). Psicothema 2006: 18, supl., 13-25.

2- Mayer JD, Salovey P. Emotional Development and Emotional Intelligence. Chapter 1: What is emotional intelligexce?. New York, Basic Books;

1997:3-30

3- Jalali SA. Moral intelligence. The journal of pedagogy research center. Education ministry, 2002: 18, 1- 2, pp. 89- 103. [Persian]

4- Saarni C. Issues of cultural meaning fullness in emotional development. Developmental psychology. 1998; 34:647-82

5- Mayer JD, Cobb CD. Educational policy on emotional intelligence: Dose it make sense?.

Educational psychology Review. 2000; 12: 163-

83.

6- Sanchez Ruiz M J, Mavroveli S, Poullis J..

Trait emotional intelligence and its links to university performance. An examination Personality and Individual Differences.

2013;5(54): 658-62

7- Jafari M, Ahmadzade F. Investigate the association between the components ofemotional intelligence and academic achievement in students: Razi Journal of Medical Sciences.

2014;21:85-93

8- VanTassel-Baska J. The on-going dilemma of effective identification practices in gifted education. Originally published in The Communicator, 2000: (3). Retrived from:

http://education.wm.edu/centers/cfge/_documents/

resources/articles/ongoingdilemma. pdf (Access

(11)

date: Jan 2016)

9- Codd M. Why do we need to define giftedness?

Rhode Island Advocates for Gifted Education.

Available from:http://www.riage.org/articles/why- do-we-need-to-define-giftedness (Access Date:

Jan 2016).

10- Csikszentmihalyi M. Creativity: Flow and the psychology of discovery and invention. NY:

Harper Collins. 1996.

11- Marland S P. Education of the Gifted and Talented. Report to the Congress of the United States by the U.S. Commissioner of Education.

Washington, DC: U.S. Government Printing Office, 1972.

12- Golman D. Emotional intelligence.New York:

Bantam Books;1995

13- Robert VH. The role of emotional intelligence in the academic achievement of first year coloege students. [Dissertation], A & M university. 2003.

14-Woitasze wski SA, Aalsama MC. The contribution of emotional intelligence to social and academic success of gifted adolescence as measured by the multifactor emotional intelligence scale. Roper Rebiew. 2004, 27: 30-45.

15- Shoja Haydari M. Relationship between emotional intelligence and its components with the motivational strategies for learning and academic performance of students at the University of Isfahan, [Dissertation] Isfahan University. 2009. [Persian].

16- Zhyraldyn AR, Dibajnia P, Gheidar Z.

Evaluation of emotional intelligence among students of 4th grade in different medical majors

in Shahid Beheshti University of Medical Sciences. Pajoohandeh Journal. 2010; 15 (5):

204-207 [Persian].

17- Rostami N. Examine the relationship between the religious and emotional intelligence in students of Tehran during the academic year 2005-2004. Educational Innovation. 2004; 3 (10):

116-128.

18-Dehshir Gh. Relationship between emotional intelligence, academic achievement. News and Business Research, 2006;18:97-106.

19- Khaliliazar H. Comparison emotional intelligence between normal and gifted students and it's relationship with academic achievement.

Research in Curriculum Planning. 2007; 1 (14) :107-124

20- Yousefi H. Emotional intelligence:

Knowledge of individual and social success, Tehran. Ghatreh publishing 2009. [Persian].

21- Bayrami M. Forecast emotional intelligence based on demographic variables, Journal of Thought and Behavior. 2009;14:57-64

22- Boyatzis R, Goleman D, Rhee K. Clustering competence in emotional intelligence: insights from the emotional competence inventory (ECI).

In R. Bar-On & J.D.A. Parker (eds.): Handbook of emotional intelligence. 2000: San Francisco:

Jossey-Bass.

23- Khalil Arjmand F. Comparing the emotional intelligence, social skills and academic achievement in gifted and normal students.Thesis.

2004. Central library and document center - Tank 6 (Record: 29535 Recovery: 39P) - faculty library

(12)

Psychology and Educational Sciences (record:

1088 AS Recovery: 1088 AS) [Persian]

24- Dehshir Gh. Standardization of emotional quotient inventory-one (EQ-I) among university students in Tehran and its factor structure.

[Master's thesis]. Allameh Tabatabai University;2003.

25- Hakim Javadi M. "Comparison of emotional intelligence, social skills (in terms of age) and academic achievement of students in bright and normal", doctoral dissertation Psychology, Tehran University;2004.

26- Asadi B. Relationship between emotional intelligence, intelligence conventional and social

health of college students Kamyaran city, [MS Thesis] ,Tehran University;2005

27- Lepfge- Less P. Exploring patterns of achievement and intellectual development among academically successful woman fram disadvantaged backgrounds. Journal of college student Development.1997; 38(5): 468-78.

28- Mansouri B. Translation and standardization sybrya shrink test in state University. [Master's thesis], Allameh Tabatabai University, Tehran;

2001. [Persian]

(13)

Comparing Emotional Intelligence in Bright Students and Normal Students in Golestan University of Medical Sciences in 2013-2014

Safar Nejad Z¹, Jouybari L², Fata L³, Sanagoo A⁴, Vakili MA

1 Iran University of Medical Sciences, Tehran Iran.

2 Education Development Center, Goletsan University of Medical Sciences, Gorgan Iran

3 Iran University of Medical Sciences and Health Services. Tehran. Iran.

4 Nursing Research Center, Goletsan University of Medical Sciences, Gorgan Iran

5 Dept. of Health and Social Medicine, School of Medicine, Goletsan University of Medical Sciences, Gorgan, Iran Corresponding Author: Education Development Center, Golestan University of Medical Sciences, Gorgan , Iran

Email: [email protected]

Received: 13 Mar 2015 Accepted: 18 Oct 2015

Background and Objective: Emotional Intelligence provides a new perspective to anticipate effective factors on people's success in a society. Cognitive Intelligence, in its best context, is the cause of 20 percent of people's success in their life. 80 percent of success depends on other factors like Emotional Intelligence.In our educational system there is more emphasis on cognitive intelligence than emotional intelligence.

Therefore, as EQ is of paramount importance in people's future, this study investigated a comparison between talented and normal students regarding Emotional Intelligence.

Materials and Methods: This sectional descriptive study had an analytical approach between two groups and was conducted in 1392 on students of Golestan University of Medical Sciences. 152 students, including 41talented and 111 normal students participated in this study. Instrument of collecting data included a questionnaire with 133 Questions about Emotional Intelligence with N-bar normalization and demographic and educational specification. Analysis of data was performed by ANOVA, T-test and Kruskal Wallis.

Results: Findings showed that an average EQ of talented students was 77.103 and that of normal ones was 41.98. Comparison test and T-test showed that there was no significant difference in EQ of students between the two groups (P= 00085). In self-actualization component, there was a meaningful significance between talented and normal students (P=0.004). As a whole, it was worth to note that there was a meaningful difference regarding EQ among talented students with educated fathers (P=0.046). It was also shown that there was a meaningful difference regarding EQ among normal students with educated fathers (P=0.04).

Conclusion: Results showed that there was no significant difference regarding EQ between talented and normal students. So it can be said that being talented could not be the only factor to have higher abilities. It is proposed that in measuring talented students' abilities, not only cognitive intelligence but also EQ which causes more than 80 percent of peoples' success in a society should be considered.

Keywords: Emotional intelligence, Talent , Students, Cognition