amp amp lt; = > &?

47 "#

2 % &'( ) 1396 . /01 430 - 411

! "# $ % "

& ' "

) 1395 - 1382 (

1

&

4 56

( 7(

8 9 ":

; <

=

>

&? @

# A

; < #

=

) :

5 / 11 / 94 – :

28 / 10 / 95 (

B

C' 6 A 5D 9 E FA5 5GA H I ?

?

= A5) J ; 1920 ( K( (

A5) : 6 B ?5( (

( C' J 5A

= A5) 5 4

J 5LJ

= K&

=

(5 ) 5A . ) D

>

;

= NF % @ A K ) :

A5) : O LH

J 5A

= J;5 9?

4

&L >

( L' ( / 5(

A J 5

= 5 4

#5<

&

# . ; 4

?5B J # % ; 8

# 5LJ A5) . P5<

QD " ( 4

P5

KH J 5A

=

?

"I ; A5 (

= R

=

@

;

=

"&I

&'J S .

J 5A

= %@

= A5) & J;5 6

. T ? : 5 % & 5A

A5) D 4 5LJ 7(

= H ( 9( ( % & 5A S

A J 5

= 4

&

&

5A U V) .

5#

4 7 -

&H

=

? 5LJ . W X Y=

4 A 8

&

= 4 ZJ R

= A5) . ( [ B QD 45

= ' 5 5LJ O /)

C' ( L' 5H 5A

. ( I ) ( 4

5\ >J ZD S] 8 D

5( ) %@

=

U > 5D 4 L ^ D 9 (

( :

: NF %

A5) 5LJ K ) ( L'

J 5A

= 5 O "#

4 : /) B 4

5( ` &

= > 5D ( ^ D 4

# 4 >J ZD 8

\5 > ( 5\

Q6 :

K ) : NF %

( : 9

"

= . W X ;

&

&H

=

? A5) :

"J 5LJ

= Z) 5&

4 ( a

H

# ( b J ( 5 % & 5A S >L I %

A J 5

= 4 NQI J 5A

= A5)

U V) 5A .

A % 6c

=

A5) 5LJ 4

5GA 5 .

.١ ! "

: 8338361370

Email: sh.sadeghi1971@gmail.com

412

47

"#

2 % &'( ) 1396

&'( ) *+ ), -.

/ 0 123 0 / . , 4 " 5" 67 8 9

7:

;

<! " : /2= "

>

- ,/?

@ A, B,

1

7 / C A 1D E23 . , '8 , 8 9 .

" &

@ F G . G / H 0 G 8 0 2G 7 7

/I JK :

=8? F C .L

@ G / 0 / &M, .

" 7

@ - 6 ( .

2E" / 0

", .=

@

; F N :

@ D

O 7G . P Q , , G / ' , F I"R, O /

: N . O G 0 M, . : / 7 SF/( : T M

,HG

" A O . U 0 : 73 6 G / "F 5" 7:

7:

F NV 1W :

X =O / X,/- YHZ

G ),2

>

1970 '8 F E: 7:

.

<B, =Q" M " 'Z &

. X =O / [ / \F 6],/K 3

. , 7: 7

= 9 . 7^

O . O 7 . (F 6 ' , F I"R, O

@ ,/: 7 , 2( G 0

_QO ?

@

<! " 7:

>

/ . : F

?

@ N,

&Z O . O

@ : O ="

,/(

3 ` :

. , 7: 73 : 6[1" 9

<a, b G

@ , 9

L cGFV?

..

9 O I C .

O

@ 6 E

@ / /LG, F b, G, I .

7: L 7 G /

0 / . 67

O F ],/K O, 7

. , 7: 73 : /d Z cGFV? 6[1" 9

?

@ ,/: O, X+

0 cO/?

LO " O ? 6/d Z

@ : . : : F \, K YHZ " 'Z X, F / /LG, 67EO

. 7: L 7

G / 0 O F ],/K 2(

\ I 7D 7

@ e O, 7=

,/:

0 cO/? 7: O ? , 6N (

9

d/ 6cGFV?

.

>

c^ O 7: , /d Z

"

@ ,f- : 67EO F \, K YHZ " 'Z X, F

7:

\.

7K 2^" &

, 0

", 4 gZU" ), .=

@

=B, F 0

<M,

@ / \F 6 .

'2G /LG, 7 0

O, V ,/=

<B, : C . ( Z 7: b G : , ],/K X =O / [ .

G / cL 3 X , 7 0

O Yf3 F 7

G / 0 / . P Q , 7 /

. 5I hF .

, i L 6cGFV? 9 ..

j<RK 9

٤@ ,/: F O, 0

L ..

9

S d "

/g ),

>

kB,F ,/-

@ O . O

@

=B, F 0

O, N ( 7= /- N/1:

. F+ /- ,H:, 0

N , 6 G

7 Q: = , 0 F O /: &" (

@ 7 O D k: " F 4l 5" 6X ="

, 0

"

@ ( .

, 2G . cGFV? A ^ ,

:

7:

\.

A, B, 3F &

" D .<

.

@ G)/" , 3 F &M, / 0

,/m3 . 0 O . O

@ , :/* 2( F Y/* X,/

@ O 4l I 6 .

O

@ - K 2=3,

@ i; "

8 / . 69

21" Y ) :

@ /: , O . O G 0 75o "

, 0 G 8 0 , / / 6X, . O 67 /: ],/K F 7 3

0

"

@ ,f- . p2G . /G 9 / \F /LG, I 7 - .

: 7 7 . /=8 E23 "+ 9 .=

@ / A, B,

6 O, , , ( q+

X 13

@

<" k " /: ,

@

", F .=

@ , O F X,/

G 8 / 0

2G ?

@

(, G, M .

l &

B 73 4 F/d N ( .

O 4l I 7: i .

O

@ 8 / i; "

. 7: 9

;

<

@

`M a F 8"

@ G 0 /LG, 0

\F / . , , 7 T M 9

" F+

@ ( .

1. Diaspora

2. Partiya Karkeren Kurdistane (PKK) 3. Kurdistan Regional Government (KRG) 4. Explanation

4 d

= D ec f > 5A

&

A5) 5LJ O /) a J 5A ( L'

= ...

413

/g Y D D 0

L 3 F ), 7= /-/: cGFV?

>

G [1"

. kB,F ,/-

1@ 6 E

@ kB,F ,/-

@

O . O

@ kB,F F ,/-

@

=B, 0

= /"

.<

.

2[ ,H , F

=B, 4 B c 0

,

=O 0 ,H , c

O 4 B . O

@ O, .

\.

, Y Q= , &

/g 9 d X, 67 .

I

@ l :

@ ,/: 7 O, 0

L ..

&r " 9

, , N) Z 9 .

/g

kB,F ,/- OU X . C

\F s O, b G M 4 B 6

@ ,/:

kB,F

0

,/- X

=M O 0

OF 4 B .

b G F O, 7<

<a,

@ O 5:

.

? /: 4 B

>

/W . G 0

"

0 /E t

"

@ (

=\F /G 7

@

=M, . , . &u" 4 B X), .

GF/

0

" g

@ vUO F G 0 2 ,

@

:.

/ /_

0 , ),

@ G 0

" g

@ w I"

\F G O .

\F 7=L\,

"F S G

@ 4 B ),

, . , H ) X 1 ? 4 B (

. , K 2=3, /a K 7: 4 B 9

@ _ G/ F

@

\ ) : 7: 7 , N (, .

" g 4 B

@ /^ "

"

@ ( .

? /: X 1 ? 4 B

>

\F 4F/q E23 , 5" F G

. O 1 + .

4 B G 0

"/O 7: x H:

F 67 0 F . F/

0 ,

@ ,/:

0 5 , 0 ,

@

" g

@ M y 3

.

\F X 1 ? 4 B F , ) 7: G

,

@ G 0 N 5\ : , 0 7 \F C 7:

4 a &Ez\ :

"

@ F+

LB : : B c

6 , N (, )

Mearsheimer,2008:78-79

.(

&: 5"

kB,F

6

,/-

@

=M O

30 H=\,F L; 4

. , E

@ ,

" N

@ -.

{/ F /

"

@

" 7 . ( + X 13 5: 7: G 8 &

. d C .

| G G , F/:

0 O . : O . 9 &<2\,

O,

(Waltz,2000:5-41)

kB,F .

,/-

@ 23 1

5@ K ,

"

@ 7 4 B G 0

", x H:

. , M

: : . 8 . L 4 B X / 7

@ ,H , X (

" c

@ G . kB,F 6&: 5"

,/-

@ E ,

6@ , /:

5K 9 . N

) 4 B 7 O, 4 B F ( : }B =" O, 9'2"

G 0 1: x H:

kdF ), `5 7 O, /=

S 3 "

(Mearsheimer,2001; Wang,2004:176; Taliaferro,2000:128-161)

2G .

. 9

") . 7

OU

6

. C G

L "

..

O P Q , 9 .

3 M O

@ G 8 N -

k" 3 / 0 , .

OU ='"

. : C 7:

)F X / N -

G 0 a M

@ ), , 78 G 0 kB,F ,/-

@ OU . F /G 6C

z\~"

>

3 M

@

<M, F

@ M , .

" &

@ , . ,

" E(, ='" 9

@ GF) + F N) Z 7 , 0

O . 3 M O

@ <*, 8 C 7:

OF .<

>

3 O 8 X+ N _ .

[=

:.

9

&<2\, F 7:

F NV :

/W . G 0

" 4 B 0

L

@

" •Q8" X+

@ ( . kB,F ,/- OU X .

,/: C 7 F : 9

" 4 B 0

6 7z\~"

G 0 O O,

@ O M O .

3 M O

@ , G 8

? 7 ,f- 0

"

@ . K.

9

, 7: Z o:, 7 , 73 7=' 9

>

<"

@ : . /W 9 . G 0

"

0 O = F .

3 M O

@

1. Realism

2. Mercantilism 3. Structural Realism 4. Kenneth Waltz 5. Offensive Realism 6. Defensive Realism

414

47

"#

2 % &'( ) 1396

s , 3F G 8 Y Q= ,

G 0 O . 3 M O

@

`O O X _LQ F X,/LG .

O

@ A ^ ,

"

@ -.

/ , F

= Y Q= , 9 .

^

>

L 4 B ), 1 + (, /:

@

= 7 F M .

^

>

L , 5"

@ k: "

. H '

@ 1 + O . ,/: : G 8 9

<*,

?

@ ,H ,

", F 4 B c .

: . O /=8 .

[=

:.

9 : F = G &<2\, /; 9

7: O i ,

7" /: F 2K G

@

"

@ F 4 B 7: 73 : 7 )

,/(

<M, `

@ 3 M F

@

<E k: "

@ g M .

[ N ( , . ,

? 9 G 8 6c 7:

F NV

. 0 : X/B . F 6[' 7" /:

H 0 E" 3

@

? , .

" c

@ 2G <*, 7 /:

>

") . 7 G 0 O . O

@

<M,

@ 3 M F

@

" &" ( ,

@

=O, 7 ( 0

,H , a/K \F 4 B c

>

( + . C

:.

9

<<2\,

@ O,

) Rose,1998: 146- 147

.(

N -/g ), O =B,

. O

@ : . 9

&<2\,

= /"

.<

.

=

@ 6

<a,

@ / 9

\F b G G

4 B 3

@ F

, ,H ,H , F &M, 4F/q c P z c

€ M O,

) Rankin,2011:1

= /" .(

.<

.

• [ .

"

@ 7 B \F C 0

=\F 6

@ 85 7 O,

@ I"

0 EO

>

<" =B,

@ , z

) Holslag,2006:13

; Uzunidis, 2011:5-6

= /" .(

.<

. ‚ L , 7: [ /;F

>

", .

<"

@

\ F . 4F/q

=B, 0

• . O &5q H /" F , .

\F, , O

\F -

"

<

=B, EL F

. 4F/q

,/:

0 : . 8 .

" 4 B X / 7

@ :.

,H , F

<a, b G 4F/q c

@

<M, "

>

F =B, \F

: 4 ^ . 9 O, &<2\, .

/G 7" /: 7 - H

0 2Z F

=

@

\F 7 &M, =B, ), G

7: € M &2K

"

@ 6 F+

1 ,/:

0

<a, b G X F+/:

@ : . 8 . 7 ) O 0

<" 4 B

@ 7 O,

/g w O, 7

G 0 kB,F ,/-

@ . H , O

) Falkner,2011:21

^ + ), .(

O = 7 .

3 M O

@

/ . G D 7

>

M, . /: 6/

'I .

? [ 7 G 0 O F &M, 4 B .

N/o 3

@ O . O

@

=B, F 0

€ M G)/" ),

=L" c

@ ( , N ,/: : 6 O / 9

.L

@ /g ),

>

kB,F ,/-

@ O . O

@ F

=B, 0 , 7:

X, K : D D

@ O "

7:

g "

L ..

<! " 9

>

<a,

@ , 6cGFV? 9 E

@ ,/D

@

/ /LG, I .

G / 7: L 7 0

O F ],/K F Z 4l I /? 7

G C

>

M, . /

/ . 7EO F \, K YHZ " 'Z X, F 7 )

1395 - 1382 (

= /- /g .

[ .

/ \F . ,/( 7: 73 : 7 O `

. O

@

=B, – 0

<M,

@ 3 M F

@ m 7: A, B, M ..

/

O .

<! " &Z O

>

/ 8 € M F &M, /ƒ .

6„/ X _LQ 7:

F NV YHZ X _LQ

, 7: 7EO F \, K

= 9 . O 7^

.

" 7

<!

>

G / 0

<M,

@ , 8 9 N,

&Z

" g

@ F

", .=

@ 3 4l I : O =" F , 5o "

>

" F M . : 7 N,

&Z O "

/_

0 ,

Y Q= , s

7 ,/D , AF, EdF 9 . 21" O 6

@ GF) + /:,/: , 0

/LG, 0 O . O

@ F

4 d

= D ec f > 5A

&

A5) 5LJ O /) a J 5A ( L'

= ...

415

=B, 0 75o "

, 0 / . , 7 ^

"

@ . / /LG, I .

7

" ,

@ m X, ..

, 4 " 5" N _ / 9

\ 5" 7: L 8

>

", . 3 7EO F F

/ 3 .

O E…:

. O

@

", F .=

@ / \F 6 .

7 x H:

/ 9

? c\ D . c F 0

<! " , M

>

[G G /

<M, E…:

@ 3 M [G F

@ "

@ , . 7 7EO F \, K YHZ F) +

0 O . X 7:

K

@

/ /:

0 75o "

, 0 ,H , F 2G, c . 13 E:, P z F

@ m 6 O, ..

,/

@ 7=(f- /LG, ,

? 7 F+

"

@ X, m 7: X+ ), ..

O / . /…: O - M : ) „/

`M 8"

@

= O

@ ,/-,FH , F 7

713, "

"+

. H ( O 7:

. /: O -

", : /:

. 8- 7:

c : . /=8 ,/:

0 †Z E / 13 ",

@

z=O, F :

. /=8 A/ 4 B ), 7:

X, K . F/

0

<a,

@ O . 3 M O

@ / . 7 /

) Gorener,2008:5

, .(

9

") . 7 , 7: &M, 7EO F \, K YHZ 12 ^

. ,

@ D/G

7: / =Q"

g "

<! " &Z

>

A 2=G, / ) F

F E:

3 M

@ 2K cQ: 7 7: ‚ :/" X+

<B, " 'Z .

" ],/K X =O / [

@ ( 6 : ,/B/:

0 `:,F 2<‡

. : C . : , F , ' + 9 .

&

O

2007 A V ,/=O, `:,F h/= - F O C

. O

@

=B, F 0

O 2012 6A

= 7:

ˆ

5 "

.

"+

. H 0 &r ( . O X,/I: ",

? 1W F 7 cK,

cQ: b/ F 1

( X 13

@

, „ M ), X+ ), k " 6 8 9

( B, 7: 7EO F \, K YHZ 7 1: 8" A,

@

<B, X p2G .

[

O ],/K X =O / O 7

,/: : s : / 9

. P z , = 7 0

F 0 G / 0 O 7

/q~" C2 F ( : 7=(, 0

,/:

0 F 0 E " 4,/ " YHZ : 2G / Y,HZ, X "+

,) :

@ G A ^ , .

,/: : ,/( 9 2a Q `

@ / . ,/ " I , YHZ : 7 .

C

2 / O 7

) M (

>

O

‰

0

.

„ .

„

( AF, X p2G .

,/:

0 , &Z )F <*, F, 2Z, 6 2E" 9 F 73 M ", /

Q )F /

\ K F 8" F i: O

@

O X *F , .

3 M O

@ 6 , N G

@ + " ,

? . F c 0 / .

? F v/o" 7 .

F G 1 8

N,

&Z G

@ /= ,

", 9 .

<"

@ / . X, K : 7

i2K

V ,/=O,

3

C

7r, , / . , H /" 6/q, 9

O &5q . 3 M O

@ 2 G, F 0

<

@ O .

<M, O

@ / . 2 Z X, F 7 .

F \, K YHZ

:/K 1: ), &LB , 7EO

@ L ..

9

"

@ . V ,/=O, i2K A 1z"

/=

C

<*, F, 9

D

. 9

/E

" t

@ ( :

» / . L 7 7: , M

" &…? X, K .

i; " X

? . M X ",/

7:

F NV

" &…?

. X

G 8 0

"UO,

@ L F v/o" Y/* F , M

7:

X, K 75o " 4 B C ,

0 .

/ . 7: 73 : 7 ,/m3 F

. 0 M H /" \F C 0

: F O, D

. 6 &2K 9

8 0 D P z F k " : 75o " 9

)

" F M . F ) 5zB 6X '\ : 67 0

O . N

X *F ,

.(

F

<*ƒ,

K ,

"

@

=B, /g ), 7 0

/ /LG, .

O 7 O, X+ 7 2023

"

. 8 N X

1. The Islamic State of Iraq and Syria (ISIS)

2. The Kurdish Democratic Union Party (PYD) 3. Strategic Depth

416

47

"#

2 % &'( ) 1396

=E a x H:

@ ,/B X 13 -.

\ O 6 /

@ / 7 . 983 7 _\ O a

@ 123 0 ,H-/: , M

"

@ «

) Soleri Lecha,2011: 2

. (

<*ƒ, F,

7:

X, K O 2E"

. 3 M O

@ YHZ /: 7EO F \, K ,

/ 7 : F : 9 .

7

" F M 8 C .

7, 0 '\ : 6

@ ) 5zB 6 0 O+ 6 . 0 H /"

0 6 0 HM 0

" 6 7 ,/=

, 0 6

<M . ˆ O

@ F 0 O . G

@

" 7 O,

@ , X "H2G , K , F 7=(, P z i; " 9

0

, z 0 c5 /LG, 0 13

@ ( : 7=(, .

" N (, F,

@ / 7 . : 7 ,/:

0 N 5\ : A/ 4 B -

? /: 7 h,

>

4 ; L , Q

@ _ G/ F

@ , : O, i; " 9 6

7:

g "

EO

>

k "

=B, 0

"/O h, 7

,f- 0 . ,/:

0 , i5I 6/", 9 . H- X 1 ")

>

" g

@ F M

B c , \ z 0

O F 7E" 3 /:

. O, O .

&: 5"

: ,/

G 0 &Z

=O, c 0

'2G 0

=B, 0 75o "

, 0 ,

? . c /-

) Grigoriadis,2010:4-5

.(

/ . , O 7 0 7 , X+

7:

X, K B

@ 13

@ ,/: 6 ( 7=M ( 0

O . , 7: X g " 9

/LG, 0 7O l O, N / P Q , , 7 :

/ c5 7: Q .

7 7:

X, K 75o " 4 B C ,

0

I"

0

• . , s F , A

\F, 7' G

0 O . 3 M O

@ m , M ..

A O s O, N , /

, O `:,F 7' .

O

@

=B, F 0

: , M 4 B

G 0 ,H , 1W Z ,/: s O, N , c

0

O u"

2008 A OF . 7 x H:

/ 9 /(

^ C 0 / . D " F ( 7 .

9 ?

@ X+

^ `:,F [^Z O, 0

O , 2015

A :

" N ^ ? 7 .<

. O F 2020

A 7:

'

".

<.

O/: l

) Soleri Lecha,2011:3

, .(

GF) + 9 0

/ . 7z\~" ), 7=

G 0 O . O

@ F

=B, 0 X 8 N G F) + 0 / . ,/: 7 0 L 13 x H: 4 B 7: X ( &

@ G z" : 7 O, .

[

,H , : , 4 B c .

kB,F 4 ,/-

@ , Q2G

@ , . v,/; F 7EO F \, K YHZ ",

V ,/=O, 0 O . 3 M O

@ X+

E

<*, F,

@ ,

" 9 . F I" / G

@ ,

"

@ :.

/ 7 . 7

, 7:

4 (

" ,/B tEd kd "

@

†E: 7 G

@ 1 + ), 8

>

<M,

@ : F M/

@ 8

>

3 M

@

,

") /G F

@

"

@ + , O . O

@

=B, F 0

/ . /oM : , 7 ) O 73, "

.

,/:

0 , &Z 6 2E" 9

<*ƒ, F,

,/:

0 5 "

. GF) + i5I F 0

G /LG, 0 13

@ / . F 7

" / P ‚/(

@ :

O 7: Q

. O G 0

<M,

@ 2G : `:,F 7: AF F , N (, X _

.

) Z

<M,

@ / 6 . 7 .

<! " &Z ")

>

p2G F / .

: X ) &? 9 .

h/= - Z b '( 9

:.

9 AUO, ,/- l 'O F X G

0 7 O, 7E" 3 N,

&Z , ), N z=O, , 7<! " F 9

,/ " a, .

" C

@ :.

. , ), /W 6/g " 9 .

/LG, 0 / . EB " 7

@

" ,)+

@ " 7 (

<! "

>

N, 7: /

<B, ] 5Z 7 4 " <: F 7 l K &Z .

2† , / .

9 6 O s :

7 ,/D /1D / . 7 7:

X, K , , X 2< " 8 C 0

O,/ "

@ 75o "

6 7:

\.

&

K

X /' , ] 5Z

@ G / 7:

4 ( O, N ( hF Q"

. I ,

>

, ), ?F , 7<! " 9

7:

X, K

4 d

= D ec f > 5A

&

A5) 5LJ O /) a J 5A ( L'

= ...

417

\.

<

@ - 7 1 7 1:

- ,/:

0 f? A K / h/

. I , 7 - <3 7

. / 0

"

@ G 8 F

@ &u"

OF . 67 w/LB F X

<K G / 4 ), G : .

/ 7 . N / N z=O, 7 [1" F ,

, / , 7' 9

/ `:,F 7<! "

. 2G 8 7O : 7 7

, , [G X + 7 , h, 0

<B, .

= G /ƒ 6

q• I . /

O, N , ,/B .

: / 9 . EdF AF, .

G / 0 / &M, .

7 '

@ ), [1"

/ 9 k , "

O . / X . b, G, 7: 7 G,

/L 0 , O, 8 9

) Phillips,2009:2; Bengio,2013:1

" .(

<! "

>

l 'O [

. 7EO F \, K YHZ H ?

@ : 7 O, X+

. 9 cQ:

G 0 E" 3 t<=Q"

>

/ .

\ [G z 7: 7 .

O ,/L :

) Grigoriadis,2010:4-5 .(

! "# $

%

&

'

( ) * + ,

1 . + "# $ +

&

/ X, /2=\F .

=O, 7 0

b, G, F k "

4 " <:

5o " M

>

" F M . ŒM 7: 73 : 7

7:

3F EO 6A, a ‚ 5O ), N "+

@ ],/K P z 7:

X, K '

@ G 8 ), 0

I i: O

2uK /=

@ F . 2G,/? H . O /g ), .

O

@

=B, F 0

N "+/:

, F

?

@ '2G 0

<B, : . [

=O / k " w O,/: X 4 " <:

O . O

@

=B, F 0

= G m 7 ,/D s ..

<? r• 4,/

.=

. '

@ 7

Iza

>

O ˆ /o(

. O

@ F 75o "

0 , 6 / 7 ( LO .

7: 7 F [*

i: O /' L" M

@ /:

f? A K Z h/

.

>

<B, =Q" M .

, : , co:,F 6X =O / [ ) *+ " 'Z 9

. /g ),

/LG, 0 /"+ €F/M 6 '

B ŒM ],/K ),

@ , ,

" ^

@ / 7 / .

7 w O,/:

4 gZU"

/LG, 0 M :

" /? , X+

@ / . [8D ), ,

;,/ , F Y (+ C<1"

@ /- 0 H '

@

G)/"

0 / . D I 7 .

F 9 /' 0 : /q~"

. O ),

@ / . 7: 7

\.

O P z &

. O

@ F

_ G/

@ , /- 6 , m: X,/

H 0 H3 -.

/ 0 :

<B, . (, X =O / [ .

G / 0 ,) :

@ . H

" 1W,

@ / 7 , .

/( F I=" 7 L; C

.E

@ ) 6 O 1 + 5= " , N, 1 ,/

. 7: 1 + [

, F ?F ,

*.

5= "/

. [ /"+ 7:

O ' . ,/:

0 G / 0

\F, kL " 6Y/* 6],/K .

>

B

@ X :

( F 1 + 2† 1

. 5: 9 0 O 1 + . / . 7 7:

K X, F †K

†K I ,

>

12 6 ?F , .

4, /LG, 0

=B, F 0

O "

/ 0 , 7: L , ,/: X,/

0

<B, . „ , X =O / [

O, N . _= :,F

@ G / 0 / 7: ],/K .

7 LO / 7 N ( .

7 ] 8"

G 0 : . /=8 0 ,/:

0

, ( : 7=(, `:,F ^ .

: 9 X O 2KR, O . O G 0

<LB

@ G / LB 0

8 XF

N D ) O . 7 ,/D 6 2 /_

@

" g ,H:, ), ,

@ ,/:

0

&Z

<! "

>

<M,

@ N z=O,

,/:

0 A, B, G

\ E F . G 0

<B, " 'Z .

F I" X =O / [ ,

^

) Barkey,2010:4-7

.(

/ . 7 7:

;

= O

@ ,H , F ŽzZ X G, M N ( 73 =" , ' + F O, 75o " M P z c

7:

), F : 0 B 2

@ kL " ],/K X =O / 7 :

@ Lq

@ `:,F 6 O, 4 Lq :

<B, " 'Z : .

[

/ kz 7:

. O, 7 . O ),

@ . -/

@ / `:,F .

G 8 : 7 0

75o " x H:

/O /:

X,/I:

418

47

"#

2 % &'( ) 1396

O

<B, 67 . O /g ), , X =O / [ .

O

@ : 7:

<

@

"

L O O, N / &

. p2G . 4 B : 9

9= /-

‰ .

„ .

„ .

? O X,/I: S BF ), 2G, 67

.

<B, . X =O / [ 7:

X, K I=" C

75o "

, 0 /"+

: ' .

? ), c . ,H , c c O, 7=

. `:,F . / / . r,/O, : 7 . O F &

`:,F F 7

: B

"+

. , : H X,/

7:

T M O /O /:

\F, ), 67 G

0 [1"

O . 3 M O

@ / . 7

7:

T M ( bU=r, &: 5"

.E

@ O, 75o "

) Charountaki:2012:201

NFUK .(

, " /:

75o ",/ &", K 6N ( ,

0 X p2G K

0 ) O 0 /"+ : `:,F 7: 7 '

\.

'2G A K &

0 / . 7

/"+ : /O 7: ],/K ' 0

,/- . F : N . K H

?F , H"/B ‚ oM .

X ,/:

0

? . 7: 9=O

I ,

>

D I 6 ?F , .

/LG, 9 0 s O, N : /q~"

7 ,/D /"+ F ?F , '

7:

X, K

" Z . X

<B, " 'Z .

M I=" ), X =O / [ )

/ . 7 ( , g= , 6

@

<B, " 'Z &: 5"

. , [

) Gorener,2008:3

.(

0 / / b G 9 .

8- ), 7 O `:,F c

. O

@

<B, " 'Z : .

=O / [

<! " &Z 6X

>

G / 0 X, K : X+ ), 7 O, M 8 &M,

8- v/;

,/ " c .

C

"

@ ( .

7:

LK

@

<B, " 'Z : `:,F .

7" 5" 6[

, 0 ,/:

0

<! " &Z

>

G / 0

<M,

@ / . O, 7 . ),

/ b, G, /_

. ,/: 7 0 ,

<B, " 'Z : `:,F ^ .

N/1: 6[

-.

/ 0 O P z ), .

O

@ E" F 0

E "

,) :

@

"

. /3 & X G / X

0 75o "

7:

F NV / . O F 7 O, 7

. : / 9 .

/ . 4 " <: 4 gZU" 7: 73 : 7 /LG,

0 F M . ) H G 8 / 0

<M,

@ 3 M F

@ ,/:

0

<! " &Z

>

G / 0

<M,

@ 8- 7: A, B, O c

. O

@

<B, : M 4 LO "

. X =O / [ /

.

p2G . G 8" 9 ta

: 0 G 0 3 75o "

, 0 F .

<M, H

@ F ],/K 9= /- ,/B

/:,/:

2G

<" K 6x H: X _

@ / /LG, I [1"

.

<B, \F F ],/K 2( 7 .

X =O / [

O,

) Barkey,2010:3 .(

2 . 0 ' "# $

l I

@ Iza 7

>

O ˆ /o(

. O

@ 5o "

>

" F M . F 7 7:

F NV 1W ), ? ],/K cK,

F 0 6 , . -/

@ , , ' + F , m: `:,F ?

@ X+ /: , ],/K \F F (, (,

,/:

0

2 8 ), € M 7: M ) - F z 5= ,

<

@

" ), N z=O, 7:

. / / . G X 8 7 .

* ) - F z k: " 6&: 5"

@

<B, . F X =O / [ .

O 4 Lq H .

O

@ , / 7 ( LO 75o " 9 .

7 7:

<B, " 'Z .

X =O / [ 7:

X, K : C V ,/=O, &

=B, C 0

7:

T M ) Z

•/ , 0

N _ F NV , 0 , b oE"

) 1 (

.

4 d

= D ec f > 5A

&

A5) 5LJ O /) a J 5A ( L'

= ...

419

5 % & 5A S H ; 6 0 f( ? 54; .1 Source:Iraq Petroleum(2014).

/ ( Z =B, .

( : 7 6

8 : O a .

.

•/ , k: " ") 0

O, .

•/ , 4, ,F 0

7 1 _QO ? 0 . G) 0

<M,

@ . , 7'<: 6 S d " 9 LO

_= :,F

@ : . /=8

/ . OF 8 F 7: 7 .

, F 7 , X,/

7a/K 9 (

O, N . , 7: 73 : 6[1" 9

<*, F, 2Z,

?

@ ,/3, 0 O =O .

c

O

1/za : 2G 1: 7 : M X _ :/K

@ ,/3, 0 , 9

5K , =O .

O X,/I: 7 ,/D s (,f- [ G 8 7

0 / . I , 67

>

/"+ 6 ?F , F '

, ( 0 '2G 0

<M . ˆ w , &: 5" , OF F X,/

. , ,/B 7 .

, 7: 73 : k " 6[1" 9

<? r•

.=

. 4 gZU" F C /LG,

0 , ' + 6 , 7:

O 0 , X - a 9=M O S ="

•/

0 , 7:

9

/ X 2 G 8 .

,

" 9 .

=z k " X

@ ) - F 0 5" 7 ],/K /

( X 13

@ X+ ),

<B, . 6N ( kB,F X =O / [ ,/:

0 / . 7 Y Q= , C /LG,

0 O,

) Tocci,2013:3

), .(

7 ^ +

/ . , : : B 7 OF F X,/

. 7

?

@ 7: 7 O, X+

•/ , 5= , Xl,

20 75o "

: I , 7

>

L ?F , 6 ( &

?

@ : . 8 . 7 ) O 0

=B, k "

0 M , 9 2G 7: s O, 75o "

.

\ 9 . &

/ . 2 7

@

=z k: " ,

@ ],/K 2(

, N _:

. /

) Barkey,2010:6

.(

1. The Policy Tension on Zero

2. Energy Corridor

420

47

"#

2 % &'( ) 1396

/ . EO ), 7

>

<B, : c LO "

. ],/K X =O / [ ?

@

=B, b, G, 7: 7 O, X+

0

4 " <:

7:

M T

"•

.

", 9 .

•/ , 0

"

. O h) k: " /5 7 ,/D s :

M O G 0 .<

@ F . ,H ( H

•/ , b/ "

0 "

. a ) , k / \F 6 8 9 .

7

H- , ), / 9=

N,

<Z

@ ,/:

0

"•

.

", 9 .

•/ , 0 , 8 9 /

O, N . Z /d Z

:.

/=8

•/ , 4, ,F 9 0

/ . ), 7 OF . , F 7 O, X,/

)

"

1

k(

G 8

@ X,/I: /O /: 7

O /", s , k " † 67 0

4 " <: 7

"

@ ,

?

@ G 0

=B, 0 75o "

, 0 / . 7

O+ , . f?

/ ) O . ,/: : / 9 . ,/: 7 0

"•

. 9 . G) 0

•/ , 0 ,H N / cG 6h, 0

),/

- ) :

@

^ 0 h,

= :,F cG F _

@

•/ , k: " 7: h, 0

OF . , F 7 X,/

(Babali, 2012:1-10) 6

:

<

@

<B, 7: L M /LG, I H3 .

8- F X =O / [ O 4 LO " c

. O

@ -

=B, 0 , : , 75o " 9

) (Villellas,2014 .

=c5 f( . ( A5) <&'( % F _{.1 "}

https://www.stratfor.com/image/turkeys-natural-gas-imports-2011

G , ,/B 0

=z

@ : . / 9 .

<B, " 'Z F 7 .

2 [ m /_

..

- H: /

@ /LG, 4 LO "

0

/ . G)F N)F/", s O, 7

@ G / 7 0

=2 B ],/K

@

&'8" ),

", .=

@ / .

" N /2( 7

@ 6 (

/‡O 0 3 & F N ( 0

" 4 LO "

. /; X . O, N ( N 8- 9 .

G / 0 ],/K 2(

8Q: X ,

@ ), N,

&Z

= G . / (, 28D .

=z k: " 7: 7

@

<B, . I LO X =O / [

/ \F /LG, .

E† ), 7 . 5 7: t EB "

. G / 0 O, N ( ],/K .

: , ,)

@ ),

/':

7 8 , 0 2E ), . / `:,F i .

<B, " 'Z F 7 .

O, [ . , 9 ,) : ,

@ F

,/ " X *F , |<a

/ X =O / .

/g L 7 /

. , 7: F /Z 4 BU" 9

N) <3 , 0 2E . /LG, `:,F i 0

/;

. : 9 . NFUK

=B, k " /:

0 H 6 '

@ / . 7 7:

<B, " 'Z .

= 6[

<? r• ˆ .=

. '

@ '(+

0 . , /: H .

, UM 9 / 6 , . 7 7 1 C

"• 9!2o" kL "

.

•/ , 9 0

? . : |oO 7'<: 6N / ,

@ 5: O

>

'2G 0 , . &: 5" H

‰ .

„ .

„

8Q: 5 , .

O, N

) Taşpinar & Tol,2014:7

.(

: , F , ' + `:,F AF, .

&

X+), F O, [1"

7

/ . 7 7:

F NV ? - ), . O X,/I: X ( / H- 7

7 G 0 ) 0 , . O '( : .

O

4 d

= D ec f > 5A

&

A5) 5LJ O /) a J 5A ( L'

= ...

421

2G : c X O /za 7: <*, F, F X _

. 75o " X =OF ), X ( , 3 H ,

0 &u"

,/O, . O 6&

, F 7 G F X,/

@ O ),

>

_ O . /"+ 9 O /: ' . 3 M O

@ / 6h, . B 7

: G, M

<B, 4 ), .

X =O / [ 7:

X, K

<" K

@ [1"

,

^ 75o " 4 B X),

N/1:

, /:

0

) Charountaki:2012:196 .(

12 '

( ) * + ,

/ \F . X ") ), 7

&'(

-.

/ 0 5o "

>

<B, =Q" M .

],/K X =O / [ O

1991 A 1D

, `:,F ), 7<Z/"

O, N / 7:/^

:

<Z/"

>

" EoB F a : F,

>

688 , ( 0

", . L" /: 7 0

/G ), , ],/K \F X+

7 -

5o " 7: )F ^

>

" k " X =O /

@ '2G F / 0

\F

,)F, 4 -

,/3, , 1

0 X+

) F+

&

1991 ( ?

@ (, . / . , ), 7 f_G 9 7

1

"F ), . / X - ,F+ X,/I: 9

G)/"

0 / . , F 7 - <3 X,/

. / 0 / ) 3, , 7'<: 6 /"+

,/: , ' 0

<2K . 2( 4

,/: ],/K 0 5E

‰

.

.

„ .

„ .

7:

O F+

. ,/3, 0 , 7" EoB 9 3 "

'8 . \F &

=Q" M ],/K X =O /

( / F .

") 7 .

>

O . O

@

=B, F 0

, LB '2G 9

0 :

/"+

G F =O 7: '

@ O .

) Charountaki,2012:186

.(

<Z/"

>

/ `:,F AF .

<B, " 'Z : 7 .

( SF/( A, a ‚ 5O : X =O / [ .

, N F 9

X,/I: : , =:, :

@ 2=K, 0 4 B :

@

<B, " 'Z .

O ( F X =O / [

@ B

2@ N,/2G X+

: .

=", . ) G 0 ,F,/

@ , B ), =Q" M \F 7 .

<M, 9

@ /- ],/K ,/_ 6

@ / \F .

7

<B, " 'Z ), .

, X =O / [ ?

@ ^" 1W F (,

‰ .

„ .

„ .

" 'Z X : X g" F

<B, .

=8? 7: [ .L

@ LO 1 + 7: X , N ? F 7 (

/ . ,/: 7 0 5E .

†K, 0 , U2Z 6NF/- 9

@

, 7: , „ , 75o " 9 :L.

, s / 4 LO " kdF 9 .

" 'Z : 7 / / : ,

) Gorener,2008:2

.(

<Z/"

>

4 LO " A O O

2008 A O ( :

@ `O X =O / =Q" M " 'Z

/ 4 " 5"

. ) *+ 67 ( . / `:,F .

<B, " 'Z : 7 .

, [ 67<Z/" 9 N F

, 0 2G, : . ,/:

0

, /LG, 4 LO " ^ 0

„/

- : /ƒ . , 9

\F, 67<Z/"

. 9 , N l : 0 5= "

. : [ . 9

Q )F /

<B, . X =O / [

.

,) : X,F/p

3

@

=O/ F F

V / . ],/K 7: 7 , m:

4 a

/- .

? X+ ),

<*, F,

2 . bU=M, 7 /- [ G

0 : .

" ), , b/; F 9 .

, /: X .

1. Turgut Ozal

2. Defacto

3. Nechirvan Barzani

422

47

"#

2 % &'( ) 1396

/;

.

") 9 .

>

EO

>

O 4 LO "

. O

@

=B, F 0

z- ,F F

<! " 7 ( -

‰

>

.

„ .

„ .

+ [G, ),

" Y I" X

@ (

) Charountaki:2012:192 .(

<Z/"

>

/ `:,F A 1D .

<B, F 7 . G , M S BF : X =O / [

@ 3 O . 3 M O

@

/ . H : 7 '

@ : , 7: , ' + .

1: 7: &

0 6 , m: ), , ' + X ( F 7:

F NV ? €F/M ),

. GF/

0 /"+

/L" O ],/K ), ' 2011

\ I

@ O O,

@ . , 9 X ( F 7<Z/"

^

@ / . H /" \F ), 7 0

l 7: ],/K /LG, &

0 E="

0 /- 4 a :

1 . 2K . i

( b '( X ( .E

@ - O

@ : . , m: F , ' + 9 )

, E:

• \ r C (s 2 .

<M, 4 Lq

@ EO F

>

=B, 0

<B, . I" 7 [ . : <o" `

@ ,/: , 0

"/O 7 ,f- 0 / . cQ: 7: L 7 G

0 :/K

@ ],/K

" [G,/

@ / )

=B, E:

0 ( s 3 . ],/K \F

&2K 2 Z . 5o " /: , M

>

), X =O /

/ F : N , O .

, ), 7

<B, " 'Z X ") 9 .

z- b/; , [ F

,/: - 0

", . G)/"

0 M

"

@ , ) V ,/=O, E:

C (s 4 . / .

", 7 .

<B, " 'Z : M Y M `:,F ), 7 : ,F .

[

,/:

0 1"

‰ .

„ .

„ .

N z=O, )

O E:

. O

@ .(

NFUK , " /:

O 4l I 6N ( 7

. H

H"

<K /:

( / kd " AUK, F .

&M, =" &'8" 1D 6 O, \F /:,/: 7 3

0

, 4 " 5" &: 5"

, 8 9 ^

/ : 1 . '8 . 5o " &

>

=Q" M 0

O / O ), 7

0

,/ " I , YHZ .

C

7: 7

‰ .

„ .

„

H 1L3 X ( ) : LO 6 O, C

>

3 / X,) L"

"

@ ( s 2 . , _ ,/: JK : 7EB,F 9 .

G / cL 3 9=Q 0

/ . 7EO F \, K YHZ /: 8 F 7

"

@ ( s 3 . m ..

O / . / O . O &: 5" 7 7

3 "

: ), . I" 9= 9 7G C

'2G 0

, X,/

- O 7 - / .

" 7

@ ( s 4 . / `:,F . , m: F 7 .

O 4l I X,/I: ), H O+ 7

.

"

@ . 4U'8"

F N ( . H 75o " 4l I /_

, 0 LO F , m: ), , ' + 7D/G 7 (

"

@ ( 6 : , 7:

. &

H C / (

) Bengio,2013:4-5 .(

+ + '

+ 3

2Q .

" N ) 9

@ F Z 7 ( 3

"

.<

. / X O

7 ,/?

( : N ( N s

, [B 9 13 a

3 2 E.

23

"

.<

.

@ O '8 , 7 .

" &

@ G . O 2( 2 B 1 + - ) 7

@

"

@ 7

75o "

, 0 [G / : F Y/* ],/K X =O / : )/"

. O, Y/* F 2( 7 .

p2G . 5; " 9

@

= G / X+ X O <*, 7 , 3F i8" F <Z .

<*, 1 +

^1\ 7:

>

/ 0

^ "/

@ 9QO

"

@ -

^1\ 7

>

O, X =O / i; " \ * .

O / cL 3 7: 7

G /M,F,

>

1950 A

"/:

@ /- s

" _ G

@ 7

\F, . O YHZ 9 .

O

@ E

@ ,/ " YHZ .

/ C

O 0

`O GF/-

@ G / ), 0 ,/

0 / ), . 7 '8 . ( &

. O 4,/ " YHZ F) : 7

0

/ 4,/ " YHZ ],/K X =O

.

" Y I" H

@ ‡O 7 (

`O / 18" /LG

zo "

@

,) :

@

,/:

0

" cL 3 7: X , X ") O

<

@ ) / c( ? / B cL 3 C

0 , G /q~" F (

.

4 d

= D ec f > 5A

&

A5) 5LJ O /) a J 5A ( L'

= ...

423

O X+

,) : hU G

@ ,/:

0 X / I="

: i " G / .

\.

<a, &

@ ,

" 9

@ 6

O . 8M O

"+

. O F ],/K JE: " 'Z H A, B, &: 5" 7

†Z &2I A K F /

O G / p2G F 7

. /LG " bU=M, 9 0

: YHZ .

F X ") ), 0

YHZ X "+

y 3 JE:

<M,

@ O Y,HZ, 67

\ E / . )

")/

.

@ X, ) X+ X,/LG F =(,

EL . :

) Hevian,2013 :1-2

.(

7:

< ;

@ O / Y,HZ, 0

5 N 2K NF/- F 7:

.

" [

@ ( : 1 . YHZ

I ,

,/ "

. C

<"

@ ,/-

M ( 7

>

O 0 YHZ

‰ .

„ .

„

/ . O, 7 s 2

, (

.

0

<"

@ /

7

") O

@

"/G

@ O ), F O, 0

<B, \F .

2Z ],/K X =O / [

"

@ ( . O &M, 67

YHZ

,/ " I , .

C

: . B 0 / O /g ), F .

O

@ O, / F .

, p2G YHZ 9 .

9

?.

G 0 2K . O i . O

@

" g F

@

‰

:

.

„ .

„

O, N / ŽzZ ,

‰

.

.

„ .

„

I , YHZ 7:

,/ "

. /W C . G 0

" g

@

<M, A ^ , F

@

"

@ , ), 8Q:

/; 9 ,/: i 0 /: `<

7L(

" g . X

1 /

? F .

G =O /L8

0

*.

" g /

@ h, N z=O, .

,

? 9 . YHZ 6

I ,

,/ "

. C

NF/- ), , G

0 t\ Q"

O 0 G 8 F 0

2G 7 7:

F NV / .

" , 3 7

@ .

,/ " I ,

YHZ

.

C

p2G . , ( ), 9 0

<"

@ , s O, 3 / B/z 3F : , ( 9

>

<M,

@

2Z ), :

. 9

<<2\,

@ ) 0

" N/1:

@ /:

. , NF/- 9

>

2012

`O ), 7 / Y,HZ,

NF/- X ") O G

0 Q"

O t\

0 7:

\.

&

\, " JI: ), 1 + S =", .

[

=Q" M 0

F G / 6 ( , 3 O, ), E:

7:

3F

"+

. NFUK , /:

†K, 69 0

<'8="

>

, NF/- 9

7:

\.

z\ Q" &

NF/- G 0 /(

, : X+

• \ r 0

;,/ ,

@ ,/ " I , YHZ .

[G 7: C

H C , . , ( 0

"

<

@ p2G / . 2Z 9 O

. O

@

" g F

@

<B, " 'Z .

6 , , X =O / [

,"

- . / 0 G 0 O . O

@

<M,

@

? F . G , 6, ' + : c

@ ,/: , X+

0 YHZ : /q~" &: 5

,/ " I , .

C a/K

>

O /L O, N / F I" 7

(Abramowitz & Edelman, 2013:

.11)

&'( : -.

/ 0 O X,/I:

F 7 5K 8 .

@ O c , 8 / i; " ), 7

. O 2( 9 67

3 F 0

? c ), .

F c 0 G / 0 O 7 /- ,/B 7 '

@ c'28 AF, 1 + ),

/ : . O, 7 .

/ . 3, " 7 1

O X,/I: : 7 F , =:, 7

7 ; =I" /' ,

0 ,

? . /- c 6

^ + ), 7

,/3, O, M O, 8:

0 m ..

/

", s / v/o" , 8 &M, 4, F X,/I: 9= /- 4 ( :

O /M,F, 6X z\ Q" Y /O 2011

A

? O, X z\ Q" NF/- 7:

. O . / \F . 92d 7

2Z O X - ,F+ ), 0

,H , F 8 c 2<‡

. C :.

9

<<2\,

@ : c5 6 O, " 'Z /:

.

1. People's Defense Units (YPG)

424

47

"#

2 % &'( ) 1396

\ E

@ [G,/

=M O

") O 4 '", 9

@ ,/:

0 Q"

O X z\

0 (, . 6&: 5" O, 8:

=", . ) G 0 ) 0 F G / 7: , 7:

F

‰

NV

.

„ .

„

/ &: 5"

. oK, 7 / . 7: F,

6[< " |\ a

,/ " I , YHZ /LG .

C O 7 / X = G G

B

&

- )

@

"

@ / 6 7: , N) 3,

O €F/M : F /-) : 7 .

GF/

0 i; " ), c , 8 /

. 2( , N) 3, X + 7: 9

O ]/(

, 75o " /= 7 , ,)+ 7 7:

O - . /

) Hevian,2013 :2

.(

/ \F . ,/: 7 0 c\ D : 713, "

G 0 , N ( ^ F hP z ), N z=O, a 0

,) :

@

NF/- F G 0 , ( 0

"

<

@ O ( Z 7: b G : 7 .

YHZ X , 7

,/ " I ,

. / C

"+/:

.

,/3, 0 , / 6 /LG, 9 .

2Z 7: 7 , ( ),

0

"

<

@ O ), 7 / 0

,) :

@ 2Z

"

@ 6 ( 0

"

@ O . / . p2G 7 . F /: , c28D 9 0

NF/- 7: h 8 ), vUO 5= ,

AUO, ,/- 0 ,

1L3

'

>

N/ \,

", : . , 7:

O X z\ Q" 7: 7' 0

O, &: 5"

0 F G

I ,

YHZ

,/ "

. / C

E† , . O, 7= : 6 t

(Taşpinar & Tol,2014:7)

3F : .

D . m 9 ..

F / /' 0 O / Y,HZ, 6 0

<M, " 7:

>

/ . BF 7 O k

9W• O : 7

"

@ 3F : F /_

,/- c G 0 - 64F z="

. / 0 / . O , 7

" 7

@ . ,/:

0 u"

, ( 0

"

<

@ /: G / ,

: 9 2 , ' + 7 F

@

• G, M G / 6 O, 8: ), E: [

, ( 0

<"

@ O 7 ) :

< /_

. 0 ( :

(Hossino & Tanir,2012:14)

.

<a, &'8"

@ / . YHZ : 7

,/ " I ,

. / C

o:, 6

>

,

‰ : YHZ 9 .

„ . hU F „

,/: 1 + 0

=Q" M 0

i; "

8 / . O 9 O, 7 . , 7 S d " 9 G /

0 O 2G 7

<B, .

=Q" M 7: , =: ],/K X =O / [ 0

5o " F O/:

>

O XF , M 6 N , , 7

O 0 : <o"

@ ,/:

0 / . O, 7 . 5o " F

>

8 / =Q" M .

O F ],/K 9 /: 8 67

/ . : 7 , 7 . ), c 15

"

.<

. , / X 6

8 G, M /

oK, 7:

0 : ] 5Z . /=8 0 ,/:

0

X, F/1(

4 L" / ) F

ibid)

p2G .(

. / 9 . 7 O, X,/_ 7

?.

, c

<B, C . X =O / [

3 O

? F 7 . : X+

‰ .

„ .

„ .

D

\

", c .=

@ 3 0 , 7: , 2I 8 9 .

&

) Villellas,2014:2

.(

/?

D . ,/( 9 o

@ / /LG, I .

G / &: 5" 7 0

O : ) : 67

@ ,/( ),

", ` .=

@

O F . O

@

<M,

@ F 7:

F

‰

NV

.

„ .

„

F . -,/ X,/I: H .

O / 8Q: 7 O, 7

@

", ) ? ), .=

@

, X,/I:

'8 , 8 9 .

" &

@ G . K 2^"

>

, ,/( 9 ` LO N ( O, / 7 . G / : 7 0

O

= 7 0 L(

.

= 7: 7 :

G / 0 ( : 7=(, ],/K .

b/; ), /_

6 G / X ( € M 0

O O \F X z\ Q" bU=r, ), 7 7: 7

\.

LB &

X /' ,/(

7 bU=r, b/; ), X + `

2Z "

/ . 6 O, 7 3 "

/ 7 N ( .

7 O G 0 M, . G / 7: L / 0

O 7

4 d

= D ec f > 5A

&

A5) 5LJ O /) a J 5A ( L'

= ...

425

", N - .=

@ ( / 0 7=(, ( : ), F '8 .

=Q" M &

0 O G / 7

7:

4 ( X,/_

( : . O X,/I: AF, / 67

. 7=(, ,F , 7 O,

M i: O I=" : , M `:,F )

O 7 (

, F koB 4 LO I" S d " 9

/LG, 0 / . m , 7 ..

G / . ,/I: :

@ ,/( X (

", ` .=

@

O 2Z : N,/2G 67

\ 2=Z,

@ O

‰

), 7

.

„ . 6„

<! "

>

<a, I" 7: /

@ O . O

O 0 - / . L 7 O, N ( &

. G / 0 O , 7: 73 : 7 / 7'

. 7: L 7 /_

NF/- G 0 O t\ Q"

0 2 P z 6

@ F 0 , 1 + 6

), X z\ Q" /_

4F z="

, . ,/:

0 7<: 5"

D : . EdF 9 .=

@ / 6 . ,) : P z ), N z=O, a 7

@ ,/:

0 ( Z 7:

. YHZ X , 7

I ,

,/ "

. / C

&M, NF/-

G 0 O t\ Q"

0 F G / 0 O O, 7 . ,/: : , 9 ^

H `:,F

<B, \F : C .

8Q: 7: ],/K X =O / [

@ 4 LO I" ), /LG,

0 / . O 7 7

L O, N ( &

) Tol,2014:4 .(

+

3

/ /LG, . LB 7 G /

0 O : , 7 - 7: 73 : .

/ 0 O X,/I: 8 X+

F 7

p2G . 7G 1D y 3 9 ,

0 : X+

‰ .

„ .

„

<I . &

/ /L s 0 : 7 . F 7=8 ,HG &1D ), c

O F Z .

"

.<

. HG l (, /: 7

. / . 85 7

@

<

. 0 C2 O X z\ Q" 7:

0

:7 T M 2Z

, ( ), 0

<"

@ O '8 L =O, 7 7 .

p2G F N ( &

. , 9 c , ^

O ,)+

O, 7=(, 7 .

, 7D/-,

? 8 9

@ 9=(,f- /q, O • , Z /:

, 6 O, 7 9

/ &M, 7: • , Z .

7 . ,/O H O, 7=

s

<! "

>

,H , 7: F F LK &r " 6X,/3 1" c

)/" F/"

0 ,/_ F

@ , ),

‰

7'

.

„ .

„

, ), 9 1 7:

X, K

=a/

@ ,/:

0 8

\ E . G 0

, M 8 9

N/1:

, /:

0

) International Crisis Group,2013:21

.(

YHZ , ' + N _

,/ " I ,

. C /

O : 7 . ), c

‰ .

„ .

„

" hU

@

? G _

@ ,/:

0 EO

>

O M P z , 7

= s ^ .

7 O, X,/_ 7^

4 B :

@

G / 0 O 67 cL 3 G 0 , 3

@ , 7 L<;

/ . 1 7 ..

5 F ˆ .

,/_

@ O O,

@

/ . ,/ " I , YHZ 7 O, X+ 7 .

O / C 7

7:

N), , , 0 B 0 , =: 7 (

? N _ G 0

<2K .

@ B 7: 8"

O &

O• 7 . ^ + ), 7

‰ .

„ .

„

U2Z

@

<K , . 7

/ . A ^ , 7 G

G ") O

@ . / c , ,/5=O, .

l 3 7 0

2012 " A ^ , F

O : )/"

), 7

2B .

<8

@ :

@

7:

LO ,/ " I , YHZ 9= /- 4 B .

`< F / C

: 75o " /: X+

. _ , 7: 73 XF : .

NH G 0 7=z-

\F, b G 6N ( .

>

/ . N/a I" F F I" 7

/ YHZ X

,

,/ " I .

/ C

G)/" Y 3 c

7:

X, K

=2 B

@

", /LG,

),

.=

@

<"

@

O, 8 X+

. / 7D/-, .

7 ?

@ YHZ 7 O, X+

,/ " I , .

/ C

O /g ), , .

O

@