: *
! " #
$% &' .
!" # $ % & '( )
1
* 2
!"# $% & 3 4
1 - !"#$ %
& ' ( )
* (
2 - , !"#$ %
*& ' ( ) (
3 -
".
/ 0 &
, (1 23 %
4 - , !"#$ %
*& ' ( ) (
! / #
$ # %&'(
! /
2 /
&( * 98
-& & / 80
: 17 / 1 / 98 :
11 / 3 / 98
:$ )
*+&, ! - . / 0 1 2-, 3 .5-, 6 7
8 9 :, ;,
<
* = $ ! , / / > , +& 7 /
? =
1 2=-, , = > : = . $@0 ? &, 0 A ) ? > +& 7 , . > B9> ;, ! C. D E , F . - @ $>
0
./ > ! 1
G /, :
< D H I > B < $ J , D E -
L > < M 7
N =7 $=CO / = $C ./ >
$=
> N +B ! 1 0 1 2-, , >
30 / >
> $ $ L / / Q & / ? R* S -, > 0/ . I 15
, =L ? D = <
+0 L , U .
D < L 15
/ < ?, > + 7 , . > $"
/ 50 / .
$+0 :
/,/ B V +
$ &, , M +& 7 , . >
:,
? , 7 $@0
: ? &, 0 > $@0 /
L D = <
/
) 50 D ,10, , L L > $" ) 05
/ 0 p<
( O +& 7 , . >
0 / ? ; . ? &,
: . $@0 2=-, , > /, Z,
! 1= = 1
.57,
$% + [#>
? L :
V + ? &, 0 > ? , 7 $@0 ? ). , / +& 7 , . > $ /,/ B $CO .5=-, ; :
, 3 C +& B , ,/ :*&, > *Z / 7 / \ B ! , > >
> ! , / +& 7 , . > > +] :*&, +=-, 1 ,
/
/ 7 .
^,
? ?
:
! 1 0 1 2-, , > : . $@0 ? &, 0 +& 7 , . >
.
/
9498
$ )
,
;
$ & ,<, '=1 ) 2 >#
? " ( @"AB( ? ,(2 ? C ? ,0
1
: ( D ,8E FB *G F,H9G 2 I )
1 .(
, L"
&
, 9 ,
; 9$ M"N 1
5 / 1 ( I
. &
Q ( FRS( TU1$ & "9: 9,& V ?C : T:" "<9:
W BX ?QN $ Q '=1 )
F,9: & ,) ' H0 X( ( Y ( 6 ( Z ( 67 &2 ?G" ?[; \ '1 ( ( ) :
, E )
2 ) #9$ " ,( .(
1 ) V * 3 ], V,,H ,0 & TU1$ 2 *&
M
.F 8^(
: ]: _
? : ( H (
'1 (
) ?[; \ M1 )
,
; . "G
X( 2 ,A&
_ ?[; \ 67 ' H0 #I
; , M1 )
( .
&
?H0 X( M S(
*[(
?[; \ "( 9:
& ? , 9 " ) * 3
?[; \ )E
,
H` #9$
, a 2 :
(2 ( ,
?
?[; \ )
, &
, V &
, 9 Q T: % A&
'
H(
) F "G 3
.(
/ 2 ]: _
9:
b ?[; \ '1 ( ?
! 9
; , 9,& ,& 3 : F9AD (
"
) 4 9: "U 2 .(
,
\ '1 ( & ?X&
?[;
9,& ? , ?., V ?&
; , 3 Z,
( : ( ?[; \ ? ,(2 H(
V
] & ,& : Z, 3 -
c;
( "
N ? *d V, C T: * 3 . (1 ?[; \ M"
. ,)E ' (
L "
0, a ,& ? "(23 &
e & W ( ,8E ' $1N W 2 & ,)
&
* 3 ) 5 .(
b
; \ 67 ? & 1$ ! . ' H0 X(
?[
( , E ; , 9,& ' ( "
f "$ 2 Z, 3 V ? F 3 :
'1 ( F "R 9,& A&
g R 9,& V h(
Q ( ]:
V,& g R ] &
F#$ " ( h( D a# ( :
; , 9,& > ( V &
) 6 ( [ ?& .(
3 , Z ( ' ( " ?X; \
"
&
1$
T
,
? W .
3 : , . & 8^(
9
& @ $ !"#$
( ( "
3 , Z
" ; j h(
, F & >& D I
k1 ( F
3 " ] :
) ) M C ,
FI ;
: G
&
( k1I ,
T
"7 F
: #9$
h(
. : ( .F "9 Q# (
g R
&
7 ]: "R*&
6 ?G"
! . ") M1 ) ? ;
( F
( ") l ) '= ! :
. &
9 & '1) ( m V
:
? V ? F
) 6U 7 ?&
,
?#
3 T: ; n
?& 9; :
9 V : ?R G
"R*& F*G ?G" a# ( ( ! .
, 9 >( ( . V
: & ( o
2
0, Q ? F , (2 G"
.F a# ( k"X & ?
& f ; V
F
?
B ( M H;
o ! (
, T A : h p$ & ?G"
,,
; d , F ) ;
( ? "
V h : [ ?& ") ,,
' 2
&
: "
F M"qA(
) 7-9 Vt 2 .(
?tG" t&
M1 ) 2 Z, 3 : ?tR G ?t&
,
; ' t8
t,Q(
t(
" 2 &
) ]: _t Vt ! .
' t`
F;
.
G /,
& ` \ ]: _ (23 L" 2
' "I ?& )
, ]
"(23 - ?H( G . "& (M & "(23 u
(3
# ,
? &
, 9 ,
;
& ( V( ( ,
9
...6 7 & ) " 2 & & 8
"
9:
* L"#N V( (
& >9 ( 30
"& Q 2 ?
R( & o n " >RD H(
, :
DSM5
0 & ?R\ ( ,
, 6 ,
;
o
) ( , : , w h ,, :
&
, 9 x
"&
.
&, 9 &
?
; "N
: (23 ]
" 2 &) )
) ( 15 Q : 15 Q (23 ] D (
* 1( . ;
& ?& "& 1 R( :]: _ ?&
, 9
,
; zRN ,
6 o
B( t
&, V 25 60 M - A&
( ( "&
' ( ?&
6 (
` = & ?&
F
* 1( .? : 3 R$ 2 { )
& :2 , 9 9AG
" T :e
M1 ) RXD
.
: "(23 ! . F*G )
` F R ?(
( 9 2
9 . ? ; k N F
(
m2"(3 / n " : "(23 W ! .
F;
.
?X; \ u ,
) ;
$ ?X; \
) ;
#A "(23 n " ' 9#
)
WMS-III
( ? ;
3 . (2
]
" 2 & m2"(3 FB )
?&
,
?#
; ! /1
)
Cogni plus
>( (
15
" 2 & ?A#G 3
&
' ( ?& & : ? Q:
40
D ,
?7 &
"(23 : F; D "&
:
2"(3 F;
2"(3 ' A#G 2 u . : .(
?& "(23 u "(
,
?#
?[; \ *& "(23
. ; D = A & #A
<
) _ "L 1> " $@0 WMS-III
(
n "
"
M #A 1939
( .
!" ? A 3
G / &
V [ '
& ?[; \ ,
A& F ,
: ? A '1 ( 2
#RD
.F |Q (
V
& "(23 (1 ]
j , (1
#9$)
\ N ( 7( .F
, / (1 :
("9$ ' $1N L"`"(
} : F: R
0 " : ' Q
& ! D (
"
7(
, /
#9$
9 : ,
>
! 9
\ N : ZH ( &
[ , T &
&
, o
"G ( F)
G C "
, V . ... (M2 ) ,
(
& #A . "
&
2 R $ 7(
, / : *& :
":
m 2
,
?9 2 (32 &
` .F Q
Z R $
*&
":
# 97 / 0
C T: .F m
, V
: *& "(
":
% &
, V
` Z g"& ( R $
m": *& ?&
(1 94
/ 0 T V ?& g"& (
": *&
m2 F$
88 / 0 "( .F
2 7(
, / &
, V
` Z } ?& R $ 92
/ 0
9 V (1 ?&
81 / 0 "( . l )
: m ?&
% AR9: ?#9G 2 a# ( &
, V
2 7(
, / : : *&
":
#B ,
>
#( $ : ?
"( m 7( Z (
, / F ) 10 11 .(
` , . > ,10, +& 7
) Cogni plus
$9"
04 / 1 (
o
R( ( m
" 2 & &
) (
&
H >( ?
# ?( &
, a
& a# ( k"X
7 :
)
( Z (
9 . &
'
A#G : G
9 >( ( ? '
?& g"& (
2 & 9 A( ?G"
: ?[; \ ?& g"& ( 2 &
: (2 ?& g"& ( ]
:>( ? 9 A( ?G"
":
,
% 2 ?& m"
?[; \ ?[; \ :>( ?
7 A( ' ( "
, T ?[; \ /" H(
c;
. "& ] (2
1 -
":
,
"%0 : V
9 V R("
,
# ? F
G (
, w ( F \ T) ?& | ( FQ:
"(23 (
( % : "
& | ( ?
( G
"(23 ; ( ; ?9
. :
2 -
% 2 ?& m"
%0 :
"
V 9 V R("
,
# ? F
( F \ G (
( % : ( ?
,
( F7R ,
( V ] ( D • C
"
"(23 V
( ; ?9 ! % : . :
3 - ?[; \ 7 A( ' ( " ?[; \ :>(
, T
?[; \ /" H(
c;
3-1 - ' ( " ?[; \ 7 A(
, T
"%0 :/" H(
V
9 V o
"(23 ? F T: F
/
9698
: d ! % : ?9 T: F ?& (
( ;
. :
3-2 - ?[; \ c;
"%0 : V
9 V ( , V
: & ? F ?& >
, Z C , .
"(23 &
, Z C , ( V ( , V V:e ?& :
C "B H& ?#\ ( A&
, ( ( , V ?& :
. F : 3 3
4 -
( 9 :] (2
9 V >( . "G :
(2
"(23 ? F : B( ?U ! % :
9 € : V
( ") 2 : (2 >S( . :
?U ] 9
V : . 9 A( ?G" ?& g"& (
!2=
N ? F e ?&
9 ! . '
&
:
"(2 (23 "(
] .F F ?& 3 ?#\ ( 2
? < 1 O <
; ! 2 Q & : >,#B ? . SPSS
} 23 H( •X 05
/ 0
& "(
D
.F;
$+0
M G 1 "t(23 ], € B V,% ,(
: 9 "(23 u
$ ) ; , ?[; \
] t(23 t: ' 9# ) ; ,& ?[; \ : .F (3 o, Q ?&
M G ? ? " 9:
1 ?[; \ V,% ,( F (3
?[; \ $ ) ; ,
' 9# ) ; ,&
?& ] (23 Z,
2 46 / 4 7 66 / 3 8 ],t
?tt& "tt(23 06
/ 9 13 / 8 60 / 7 76 / 12 "tt(23 utt
tt € ttB V,tt <9: .Ftt; ] tt;
?tt[; \
, ,& ?[; \ $ ) ; ' t9# ) ;
2 Zt, ?t& ] t(23 76
/ 4 22 / 1 66 / 2 78 / 5
"(23 ],
?&
05 / 5 80 / 1 79 / 2 37 / 4 ,,h
.F M tG ?& ?G" &
1 &
, t V ( t7(
t,
% , V ?t&
' t9# ?[; \ 76
/ 12 t 9 "t(23 ut V
t7(
( ,
% , V
& ?[; \ ?&
, t t , ] "t(23 66 / 3 zt#H
.F;
M ttG 1 . 6) tt 9 Q,ttI" : ?tt[; \ tt:
; , tt
tt ) ; tt ,& ?tt[; \ tt$ tt )
' 9#
: (23 .
G ?& ?G" &
M 2 , ] f ; :
#B ,
>
"
u ?
"& M ( f ; 2 F ' R$
A u
:
& &
, Z n) ,
"
& ? F h (
, : D &
.F •X : "(23 ? : ( b )
05 / 0
p<
(
$ ) ; , ?[; \ : ,h ( "(
: V,& ,& ?[; \
(23
: H(
. A:
M G 2 . ], b f ; u " >,#B :
a+
/ > 3
! O <
K-S
p F
p
, ?[; \ 854
/ 0 460 / 0 993 / 15 227 / 0
$ ) ; 997
/ 0 273 / 0 489 / 0 490 / 0
,& ?[; \ 963
/ 0 311 / 0 206 / 0 653 / 0
' 9# ) ; 788
/ 0 564 / 0 506 / 0 483 / 0
M ttG b tt 3
( tt tt:
?tt[; \ "tt( ?tt
, FRA ) ?R B(F 354
/ 23
F H( (
.
: ,h (
],
"(23 u
"(23
V,% ,(
? ,(
€ B
V,% ,(
? ,(
€ B
: ?[; \
, 90 / 5 7 84 / 3 16
/ 5 5 43 / 5
) ;
$ 33 / 4 4 19 / 4 70
/ 5 5 57 / 3
?[; \ ,&
20 / 3 3 67 / 2 26
/ 3 3 81 / 2
) ; ' 9#
100 / 6 6 51 / 7 16
/ 6 6 41 / 6
] (23 ?[; \
, 46 / 4 50 / 4 76 / 4 06
/ 9 8,5 05 / 5
) ;
$ 7 8 22 / 1 13
/ 8 8 80 / 1
?[; \ ,&
66 / 3 3 66 / 2 60
/ 7 7 79 / 2
) ; ' 9#
8 10 78 / 5 76
/ 12 11 37 / 4
...6 7 & ) " 2 & & 8
"
9:
( ,& b R$ ?&
9 : 8 €W\ & ? t:
], , tt ?tt[; \ tt,h ( tt,h ( "tt $ ?tt& "tt(23
u , ?[; \ & m2"(3 #I 8 m 9:
3 "(2
H(
( Z ` .F
m2"t(3 ,8E ? :
95 I , t ?t[; \ t,h ( u 2 V,t,H
( . tt tt$ tt ) ; "tt( V,tt <9:
FRttA F
) tt ?Rtt B(
173 / 1 "tt( tt( FttA, tt H( (
,& ?[; \ FRA
) t ?R B(F 793
/ 42 t H( (
F . R$ ?&
( ,& b 8 €Wt\ t& ?t
t:
9 ,& ?[; \ ,h ( : ],
t,h ( " $ ?& "(23
u t ,& ?t[; \ & m2"(3 #I 8 m 9:
"t(23
H(
( Z ` .F
m2"t(3 ,8E ? :
61 ttI V,tt,H tt ,& ?tt[; \ tt,h ( u tt 2
( . tt tt( tt)3 ' tt9# tt ) ; "
FRttA F
) ?R B(
341 / 10
F H( (
. b t tR$ ?t&
( ,&
9 : 8 €W\ & ? ' t9# t,h ( t:
], t& m2"(3 #I 8 m 9: ,h ( " $ ?& "(23
u ' 9#
H( "(23
( Z ` .F
: m2"(3 ,8E ?
61 tI t 2 ' t9# t,h ( u
( V,,H .
M G 3 . t& ?t#) ( t: 8 u t " >,#B ?I1)
t ,& ?t[; \ t$ ) ; , ?[; \ ,h ( ,h ( M & ' 9# ) ; .
b M G 4 ( : ?[; \ ,h ( V,% ,(
' 9# ) ; ,& ?[; \ , ,8E % ,& ? F M 2 ,& (23 ?[; \ ,h ( ] ; " 2 & '1) ( m2"(3
.F ' 9# ) ; ,& ?[; \ , M G 4 . 2 u > H V,% ,(
" 2 & m2"(3
) .
a+
L
! b / , +-, ? &
, ?[; \
"
10
/ 4 27
/ 4
(23 06 / 9 05
/ 5
,& ?[; \ M
93 / 1 01
/ 2
(23 60 / 7 79
/ 2
' 9# ) ;
M 83 / 5 62
/ 6
(23 76 / 12 37
/ 4
[#>
$% +
? L
: ]: _ "& ?& ?G" &
" 2 &
) t
"
? 7
: #9$
) t "tR*&
1$
tt T tt7 tt: ' tt*(
) tt tt: ]tt7
$ 9 G &
, 9 ,
; F 8"(
t& ` \ ]: _
& € :
" 2 &
) ?[; \ &
V &
, 9 ! .
tt ?tt " tt9: . tt
? 6 tt ( tt
tt b
#B tt,
>
"
tt u tt ?tt[; \ ' tt9 ?tt tt ,
&, 9 ,
;
" 2 t& m2"t(3 FB ? ) t
H( "N ?& ; D 2 = &
: "t&
) F 05 / 0
<
(.p
V b &
? ; : t ]: _ ,
9:
: ) "& "A9 12
(.
R ,, V V
? ; ( : "
?[; \ FQ ,
T*(
V
? Ft &2 &
; tA& ]7 ") t m2 t .
,
(1 t( ?t ; ?& ") ? ot9 t& "t
: ] W ( ' ( #& ' ( " ?[; \ (
a+
6]
:, a.
J % :, c%
$ /
/, <
? ! b :, c%
F d p
+ ,
?[; \ , m 9:
937 / 373 1 937 / 373
#I 8 240 / 207 1 240 / 207 354 / 23 0001 / 0 464 / 0
X)
D &
( M ( 81 / 11 58 204 / 0
) ;
$ m 9:
851 / 50 1 851 / 50
#I 8 63 / 4 1 63 / 4 173 / 1 288 / 0 042 / 0
X)
D &
( M ( 215 / 98 27 638 / 3
?[; \ ,&
m 9:
371 / 37 1 37371 / 37
#I 8 711 / 204 1 711 / 204 793 / 42 0001 / 0 613 / 0
X)
D &
( M ( 16 / 129 27 784 / 4
) ; ' 9#
m 9:
310 / 312 1 310 / 312
#I 8 476 / 218 1 476 / 218 341 / 10 003 / 0 277 / 0
X)
D &
( M ( 456 / 570 27 128 / 21
/
9898
"
) 13 ( .(
, 7 6
#9$
)
&
, 9
,
; ( [ ?&
3 ? , Z ' ( " ?[; \
( & "
8E TU1$
,
& W%&
, 9 t ,
;
! t$ Ft#$ ?&
Ft;
t
|
" t tI $ V t
A
<9: > ( ,
V A&
, 6t7 ' tH0 X( 2
?[; \ ,
_
#I M1 ) ,
; t(
) 14 [ 2 .(
t: R:
) t t: ;
;
; t& ?t tA:
t )e t, 2 t 2 &
Ft;
8E ?[; \ ' $1N 8^(
, (
. W
V t: R:
( o9 ; ?&
& 2 ' $1N t,
Z t&
)e ? )"(3 1RD ' $1N ,
2
?[; \ t #&
( (3 ' ( )
14 .(
, 2 &
, t : _
& 8 "(
) t m2"(3 ?t ( t&
t 3
?& ' $1N m2 F$
V ,
?t.
t , ?t t V
" F "& 8^( m2"(3 )e
, (1 ' $1N
" ttt ttt ?ttt[; \
ttt;
] ' ttt9
(
; ") F$
] ( ?t& . t:
( [
" 2 & ? )
& ?&
, 9 t ,
;
$ m ?& 3 o9 : (2 t
?t[; \
, ?G" FD ,
"7 F 0 "
,
"7 F : ?#9G (
t /" H( ?G"
,
"
U G ?& ?G ,
' 2 &
?t[; \ '1 ( & ") &
, : R: 2
& Z ( Q t > ( >\
) 12 .(
?(
b
#B ,
>
"
u ' t9 ?
) ;
$
&
, 9 ,
; m2"t(3 FtB ?
" 2 &
) t H( ' tQ ; D t t&
: F ) 05 / 0
>
.(p
V b &
? ; : ]: _
t9D D t&
"t& "tA9:
) 15-17 .(
t
: _ t R " ?
) t 2
t
&
8E ' ( " ?[; \ ( ,
RS(
) ?: . t,
R "
) 1 R( "(
t t =1 ) ?t&
?t
: ) ?[; \ 2"\
t ?G"
& "(
8Et t: ]: _ S .F ? ; D ,
t V 1 ) m2"(3
= 03 "t<9:
t9 t 3 , Z th(
Q) , a / "
,
;
&
, ] 0 H;
t &
t
t & 8 t
V t: m2"t(3 ) t
?G" ?[; \ ( F*G
&
V E '=1 ) ,
) 17 R .(
,, V ! $ V ' Q
% : 9:
( "
2 H ?&
: ?A#G (3
2"
( , m2"t(3 F$ t
9: ! $
% tA) &
, t9
t ' t[
,
% , ?t : m2"(3 ' *( ' ( #&
V t: >( $ ]: _ e
? t "tG t t t
<9: .F "& B(
, V 9*( L"`"(
t( ?t
&, 9 ,
; 9:
, F : ' Q "G t;
& ( , 9
"
#B ,
>
% 7; ") ,
;
% ( 3 ( ? &
& "
,
?.
(
. & 8"(
b
#B ,
>
"
u ' t9 ?t t
& ?[; \ ,
9 ,
;
" 2 t& m2"t(3 FB ?
) t H( "tN ?& ; D t 2 = t&
Ft "tt& "t )
05 / 0
<
.(p
tt V tt b t&
?tt ; tt:
]: _
"& "A9:
) 18 R .(
,, V V
?t ; t( t:
t: 2"t\ ?t#9G 2 ?t FQ "
t& nR t(
M1 t)
: G
" 2 t& ?( & YF ?[; \ '1 (
)
?
*G"t >& D "N ?&
m2 t F$ t
R) ?[; \ ' 9 t(1
&
, t t;
]
<9:
, V
; ] u "
M t ; t
]t7
*G"t >& D )
19 ( .(
,
"t # t : _ "t $ t&
8E , ' ?( &
? t& m2"t(3 ?t[; \ ?tG"
2"(3 ]
! . b ? V !
& 2 ; t ?t[; \ ?tG"
8Et ,
*G"t >t& D
( [ ?& .F ?
" 2 & m2"(3 )
?t&
"
k N t[
, T € t: ?t& €"tXH( t ;
9
$ ?G"
, 2 € tXH t& ! "t Q t (
& ' tt$1N ,
tt ttA& ]tt7
& ?tt& ? tt ,
tt9
tt ,
; tt & ?tt[; \ "ttR*& Ftt*G tt #9$
"tN ?t& o9 ' $1N m2 F$ ")
*G" >& D Wt € tXH m2 t F$
) t
...6 7 & ) " 2 & & 8
"
9:
?[; \ ' 9 R)
&
,
; ] t&
; ] u "
M ;
*G"t >t& D ]t7
<9: . & ? ,
V V t( m2"t(3 ?t[; \ t& t "
% : t9: ?G" ƒQ\
t \ aHt` ! t$
?[; \ / "\
8Et , t <9: . t & Wt ,
V
b
#B ,
>
"
t u t ) ; ' t9 ?t t
& ' 9#
, 9 ,
;
" 2 t& m2"t(3 FB ?
) t H( "tN ?& ; D t 2 = t&
: Ft "t&
) 05 / 0
<
.(p
t V t b t&
?t ; t:
: 0 V# ]: _
"t& "tA9:
) 21 20 R .(
,t, V
V
? ; ( : t FQ "
,
; t " t 2
V ) t '=1
"
, o !"#H( t Ft#$ t& ?t Ft
A\ Q " " ' : [ '
#ht t #9$
; ( ? )
) t t M1 t) . "
tG
M (
V :e @ . 0 >\ (
t,
? t ,
;
( @"AB(
?& 1 R( ; . "
,
;
& Z#j , ] 2
o t: ? 2 "(
Rt $ - ) t ' "tI ?t&
: : 9 ?G" ?[; \ G
t
\ (
) : 22 7B 9: V# .(
, 7
tt " ! tt$
&
, tt9 tt
,
;
tt$
(1 ' $1N tA& ?t
, TtU1$ t& nR t(
Q ( F * 3 ) 20 t( [ ?& .(
t
" 2 t& m2"t(3
) : (2 t "tR*& Ft*G t ( M"tN
]7 ' 9#
8^(
& ?& ? , t9 t
,
; ?t
*%
2 H& ' $1N o
)E , > t ( C "
) ' $1N m2 ?#\ ( ?& $1N A:
,
<
tt, tt9 tt <9: . tt ott9 tt ,
V m2"tt(3
: R:
t , t(
t; ZtG"( t "
] ( t,
, : ? )"(3 9 ƒQ\
:e t&
") F$
3
& Z#X(
, 9 "t (
: _ . o9 a# (
: 0 ?
t 9:
" 2 & ]7 " $ &
) ) 6U 7 ]:
Q ( TU1$
&
, 9 ,
; t ! . b
t
) 6U 7 ? &
, 9 ,
; &
t R "
) ( ]:
&
) 21
& & .(
V ( ?t FQ "
: R: m2"(3 2 ; ! )
t N ) ?&
; ' 9#
: M= t Tt*; ?G" "C
]7 Q
t(
t( t "tR*& ]t & t "
G #9$
&
, 9 ,
; . " |D 8^(
B( ` \ ]: _ ! . F
: ?t "9 >( t
, ?& B(
o
A G o (
,
\ *t t,
g
9H , T b
?t "9 T T.\ ?& ?G" &
' t
&, 9
& t(2 ' t(
, t9 FtRS( Ft(1$
tQ (
&, 9
: ?
` t( Q
t
.F "G
,/ U 2B.
V 2 ? ; & ?0 7(
t ?(
t( t
. tt &
tt
tt tt F tt ?tt9: 2
0"qA(
, V ?% ( &
, 9 ,
; L"#N V( (
! . ? *
V ]: _t t "9 "t9:
D (
9 , T .
/
10098 References
1. Lee J, Park S. Working memory impairments in schizophrenia: a meta- analysis. Journal of abnormal psychology.
2005; 114(4):599.
2. Lesh TA, Niendam TA, Minzenberg MJ, Carter CS. Cognitive control deficits in schizophrenia: mechanisms and meaning.
Neuropsychopharmacology.2011; 36(1):
310.
3. Mazhari S, Haghshenas H, Firooz-abadi A.
Verbal Memory, Visual Memory and Working Memory in Patients with Schizophrenia and their First-degree Relatives. Iranian Journal of Psychiatry and Clinical Psychology. 2007; 12(4):359-64.
4. Zarshenas S, Houshvar P, Chehrehnegar N.
Working memory in schizophrenia its methods of evalution. Journal of research in rehabilitiation of science.2011; 7 (5):739- 749.(In Persian)
5. Zhao YL, Tan SP, De Yang F, Wang LL, Feng WF, Chan RC, Gao X, Zhou DF, Li BB, Song CS, Fan FM. Dysfunction in different phases of working memory in schizophrenia: Evidence from ERP recordings. Schizophrenia research. 2011;
133(1-3):112-9.
6. Barch DM, Csernansky JG, Conturo T, Snyder AZ. Working and long-term memory deficits in schizophrenia: is there a common prefrontal mechanism?. Journal of abnormal psychology. 2002; 111(3):478.
7. Boutla M, Supalla T, Newport EL, Bavelier D. Short-term memory span: insights from sign language. Nature neuroscience. 2004;
7(9): 997.
8. Grieve J, Maskill L. Neuropsychology for occupational therapists: cognition in
occupational performance. John Wiley &
Sons; 2013:148-69.
9. Abdi A, Arabani DA, Hatami J, Parand A. The Effect of Cognitive Computer Games on Working Memory, Attention and Cognitive Flexibility in Students with Attention Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder . JOEC. 2014; 14 (1):19-34.
10.Groth-Marnat G. Handbook of psychological assessment. John Wiley &
Sons; 2009:119-206.
11. Sadeghi A, Rabiee M, Abedi M.Validation and reliability of the wechsler intelligence scale for children-IV. 2011; 7(28):377-386 .(In Persian)
12.Shiran A, Breznitz Z. The effect of cognitive training on recall range and speed of information processing in the working memory of dyslexic and skilled readers.
Journal of Neurolinguistics. 2011;
24(5):524-37.
13.Tijms J, Hoeks J. A computerized treatment of dyslexia: Benefits from treating lexico‐phonological processing problems.
Dyslexia. 2005; 11(1): 22-40.
14.Thomas ML, Green MF, Hellemann G, et al. Modeling Deficits From Early Auditory Information Processing to Psychosocial Functioning in Schizophrenia. JAMA Psychiatry. 2017; 74(1):37–46.
15.Wykes T, Reeder C, Landau S, Everitt B, Knapp M, Patel A, Romeo R. Cognitive remediation therapy in schizophrenia:
randomised controlled trial. The British journal of psychiatry. 2007; 190(5) 421-7.
16.Ghamari H,Maghsoud N,Dehghani F. The Effectiveness of Cognitive rehabilitation therapy on the Reconstruction of Executive Functions of Obsessive- Compulsive
...6 7 & ) " 2 & & 8
"
9:
Patients.Clinical psychology studies.2015;
16(4):102-110.
17.Bagheri E,Forouzandeh E The application of rehabilitation of disorder.Journal of New Advances in Behavioral Sciences.2017;
10(2):13-26.
18.Dehn MJ. Working memory and academic learning: Assessment and intervention. John Wiley & Sons; 2011: 1-408.
19.Stern A, Malik E, Pollak Y, Bonne O, Maeir A. The efficacy of computerized cognitive training in adults with ADHD: A randomized controlled trial. Journal of attention disorders. 2016; 20(12): 991-1003.
20.Glahn DC, Cannon TD, Gur RE, Ragland JD, Gur RC. Working memory constrains abstraction in schizophrenia. Biological psychiatry. 2000; 47(1):34-42.
21.Doulatshahi S.Jazayeri S. The role of cognitive rehabilitation in reducing cognitive deficits and negative symptoms of schizophrenia patients.Tehran.:University of social welfare and rehabilitation sciencess; 2005.(In Persian)
22.Sadock BJ, Sadock VA. Kaplan and Sadock's synopsis of psychiatry: Behavioral sciences/clinical psychiatry. Lippincott Williams & Wilkins; 2015:300-346.
/
10298
The effectiveness of cognitive rehabilitation on short - term memory deficits of chronic schizophrenic patients
Nokani M*1, Jamilian HR2, Zohrevand M3, Mohsenpourian Kh4
1.Assistant professor,Department of Psychiatry, School of Medicine, Arak University of Medical Sciences, Arak, [email protected]
2. Associate Professor. Department of Psychiatry, School of Medicine, Arak University of Medical Sciences, Arak, Iran.
3.Student of clinical psychology.Department of psychology,college of psychology,Arak Branch,Islamic Azad University,Arak,Iran.
4.Resident of psychiatry. Department of Psychiatry, School of Medicine, Arak University of Medical Sciences, Arak Iran.
,
Received: 6 April 2019 Accepted: 1 Jun 2019
Abstract
Background: schizophrenia is common in all ages. It affects cognitive abilities, and assessment and treatment is necessary. The purpose of this study was to investigate the effectiveness of cognitive rehabilitation on short-term memory deficits in chronic schizophrenic patients.
Materials and Methods: this semi-experimental research used a pre-test and post-test with control a group. The study population included all the patients with chronic schizophrenic disorders in the center for chronic psychiatric patients in the city of Arak, totalling 30 patients. They were randomly assigned to control and experimental groups (each group was 15). The experimental group received 15 rehabilitation sessions.
Results: results showed cognitive rehabilitation increased the overall scores of auditory and visual memory, and the vocabulary span of the participants in the experimental group, but cognitive rehabilitation had no effect on the digit span with chronic schizophrenia.
Conclusion: The result of the present study showed that cognitive rehabilitation is effective in improving auditory, visual and vocabulary short term memory. Therefore, it is recommended that psychological intervention should be combined with pharmacological treatment.
Keywords: cognitive rehabilitation, short-term memory, chronic schizophrenic patients.
*Citation: Nokani M, Jamilian HR, Zohrevand M, Mohsenpourian Kh. The effectiveness of cognitive rehabilitation on short - term memory deficits of chronic schizophrenic patients. Yafte. 2019; 21(2):93-102.
