48 ! "#
2 % &'( ) 1397 . /01 -369 347
!
"
1
45
!
% 46) 7
8
&9 : 4&;
<
!
% 46) 7
) :
21 / 4 / 95 : –
26 / 10 / 95
(
=
> ?
# 4 0)
@ 4
<
? A &B'
@
>C D (
@ E 6F ;
G
&/
<
@
>C D H 4( I J
I
<
"&?
K ) 6 : L
I .
@ ( C N
I 7C J 0&
<
/)
> ? J N)
% # 41 >
)
C ; E .4(
G ( QR)
7C #
<
B;4 4(
<
/)
> ? S
&9 # 4 0) 6F
@ I N I
<
T J 8
U 4 VR
@ 4U % 4
; W . J 0& ( XY
@ QR) 7C N # % #
6F 7= ;
@
?
@
@ 1 > % 4 T # AZ "> = 4
@
<
) ( J T X 4( ( I &9 6F (
<
"&?
&[
<
\B)4
@ ( WI J %4[ % 4 .
EZ &
4] 4( ; #
@
&9 .Z /) N
<
> ?
@ % 4
"
WI J %4[
@
> ? 47
<
K
>
^
@
> ? ( B 40& &'
<
") [
T
@ J )
<
C T
&'
" % ; (
@ J J I
<
6
<
? . 4 0)
@ WI 4
4;
.
< ; % 5_
T
@ 7 I
<
J
&9 .Z /)
<
4 E /)
<
> ?
#
"&? &9 4 0) 6F
4 0 #
<
.
1 . ! "
: 02166409595
Email: [email protected]
348
48
! "#
2 % &'( ) 1397
# $ % &'() ' $ * " +,#
-" . / . 0 1 2 $#1 3
# 4-" . # 5& 6 $10 $#1
# 7 -8 9 /:
#
" 1; <1=>" ' ?@ " / >
A
%9
>" BC 4 1 A
4>D# #10 $E 6#1 1F G 1?>" ' H> "
I#
1.
>
9
@ 3 JK "
A L 9 M 7 1B NO P 4 I# $E 7
>C ' A I 9 I A ) 9 J # 6# Q RS
) # T#
7
# #' +,#
A F / A
"6 9 . $ U. F *1F VW C X 1W ' #G '1F /4 R1,
"
A
# .
#
" $ Y 4Z J" M A
&
9 -" . 4 5 3
# [ \>I 5& 6 $10 $#1
?2 P ] 9
^
>* I 7
& >* I 7
>0#
7 - 2 ?>.#
A I X -H ' 9
I A I#
.
#
>* I P M 7
F 9 $
>0#
7 -#
2 ?>.
A 1B P 7
) 1 2 9
" 50 # 4`'1Y" ' 4`'1Y" Y A
6 .
# $10 $#1
" 5& 6 9 S 7 ) I 9 1@& 5& G 7
?D A ( 4F / ' T(
9
? 3
# a'
" # $10 M A
$10 $#
# $#1B= D'
#1 A
# .
# 1B= D'
#1 A ) #
# $ 0 ' b = $10 M A
D 4 F
=% $# >F G%1& 1c
# 1 Y #1B $#
.
`'1Y" RSJ # 3
# $#1 ) 1906 /a 1285 [ (
4F
>I#
A 1B= D' RSJ # 7
#1F F / F
# M Y 3 I 9 I A I ' 5& 6 $10 Z ,
&
7
U> "
A F $10 4F 9 4F # 5>
>I#
A F
# Y 3 e 99
# RSJ # ' 1 .
>=cD A
"E 9
# 4 I# G M
# Y 3 e 99 10 /RSJ # ' 1 A
f'# 4F I
9 I N Hg $10 4 9
I A 9 F G . F 1%#
J"
4#
7 V 4F
# T c $#1 9
I Q"# E ' N Hg 1; 6# 5& 6 $10 /5 9
I A -
" ; A 10 A
F A
; 9 I# 1 . I N Hg 9 I A
# 7 2 ?>.# P 4F 4 A
-
>0#
7 6 F1 7
" @ # 4-" . 9
'
4F H2 A e 99
>* I 1 7
1I
?2 ' h 9 $' ^ ]
1& i N Hg 7
#1F F j 6 50 # /M
# k 8 "
F 4Z J" M 9 L 1& 6# Q 9
4-" . /G I D A I 1B $ "E1F 9
I A . 4-" .
# 7 I#
I 1; 6# 4 9
I A Hg L A
T#1?%
2 ?>.# 1; 6# "# /T A
-
>0#
7 O P R# 1%
A
>* I 7 I#
.
# " l &
I 1F 4Z J" M A
O P 6# 4>I $E A
2 ?>.# >* I A
-
>0#
7 - I 9 I A
# ) Ui . " 4 I# 5& 6 $10 $#1 T c
&
7
"6 I A
"6 9 4
&
7 U 7 I 1B=
9 I A
. 4F '
# E6 F $E hH A
4BHD
&
7 1B 7 ) 9
# $ "#1 ) M T c
&
7
"6 I A
"
A 1%
. h0#'
"
A
&# * 9
& $ Y 5 9
I 1B= 4 cL 4 5 9
I A /4`'1Y" 1 2
>C A 4?YL1I 1; 6# 1%#
&
1 . U"
7 1H&
7 R > /
`'1Y"
3 a Ui# / * 1;
7 1W L m 9
" M A :
»"
9
# $
>IE $#1 3
4F ' ' 9 7
# F $ "
& VH0 I #G&' $#1 9
' = o A
& " p PZ 6#
7 e 1%# U /4>D# .' 99
1 7
" T & Y"
A
" / D A # $E $#
+BD A , ' 9
>* I1 7
# « ) 1H&
7 / 1387 : 19 .(
4F
" 1;
A
#1% I J+ 4F Q A -" . 3
# $#1 4F 5& 6 $10 $# 2
4-" .
# 7
#
> ' / >
9
# #' 4@
A - ' A J+
A I 1B $ 1 9
I A
" /4`'1Y"
9 +*# $ % &'() $ A
# '
#1 A . 0 1 2
t 1) . * $ % &'() 6# 1 A
D F . F 9 7 1c 9 1B= D' Ui G 7
# 1W -"
F XS" # $#1 A
"6 F u H # 9
4 ' &
1B NO @"
7 ) 9 1B= D' Y 7
#
" $#1 A
# .
#1 # 7
# .E v# w D " / ?C# E S. $ L A
+2 / A
"
9 I xI1 A I / 9 # .
H` H`
A I ' 9 C 9 ' .' F 4?& /1 M
& 1B 7
# / y>"
M ?& T % )
#1F 7
# J M T % z# # ' &
3 ]
F T % V . { : D 81"S, A
?i ' A 1U"6 /1 1393 .(
> ?
# 4 0) 6F
?
@
& : U 4 VR
@ % 4
349
$' H" $' / D H #6 A
>0#
7 - 2 ?>.#
A
#
"6 ' 4`'1Y" 1 2 $#1 9
4
&
7 U 7
# 6# T "E1F H" M
A
?C ' Ui /|1` $ B"#
"
A F .
#
# 4F 4Z J" M Y
3 1= " $#1B=>"
&# \ 9 4F 4B+F / *# 1) 5 .
7
" [S $E A
9
& $ Y 5 9
cL 4 5 >* I u H # 4
2 ?>.#
A - I 9 I A
#
% % V"# 2 1g# 1F $#1 A
&# * |1D 4 9
#6 4F / # 5
"6 Q 9 4
&
7 U 7
Z ' 1}B>"
9 ) '1
~ ( I 1B B"
9 I A 0 9
" 1@ "
A D .
#1F F 1B NO P /M 7
'
>C A F # A
• T # 9
? 3 4 /5& 6 $10 a' 8 2 ]
3
# #' A F ' A /4Y 2 4B+F A
&b < HK # 9
#
#1 A O P F A
) 4 F 9 2 $E 6# Q 9
9 -" . 3
# F T # • $#1
1.
:
#1F 7 '
& c>I M A
+P 9+
A 4F -Z K" ; "
3 4-" .
>* D A I 1B= Ui 9
I A .
# 6# /5& 6 $10 $#1 4>
&
7
! 4-" . ' ]
€ D
> .1F 3 T 1 T =>I# 1W -"
# 5 .
> \ 9 I'' N1F' U E M 4-" . >I# /2
I D A 1) T cY # 1"E $ >
+,# 4 I B
4F 4-" . $# 2
" 4>* D &•" € D A
D . 5U"
1
" $E 6# 4 '# 1g# M A
2 $#
A +P 9 V
4-" .
>* D A R > / 1 f#1\>I# # 1B=
2 ?.
&
7
$ ?>=%
:
#
‚ Z z 7 >* I '
2 ?>.#
A |SW# QH . A
1c D' / 7
' / I I 9Z 9 )' # 5
٣A ) 1989 ( I#
. 1c 7
Z # 9
4G 4-" . >I# / I D
A ) T cY # 9
# + 9 I . Z ƒ GF 1g#
9 $# 2 F G
4-" . I D A 4= +
&
: 1;
4#
7 U.
A
#1F 7 e 99 1B 1
57 ) 1998 ( 4F # '#
T1UL $# 2
# 7
4>* D 6 C 4Y0 "1) ' T D 4-" .
I D A I# T 1 |1K" 4= + ' 1B .
$ #
I I#
A 1 M 4>
&
7 1;
7
#
& 4F # ' M A
1Y
" m A 9 F L L 5 A
+P 9+
A
#1F 7
'E 5 18 C Q&'() 5
.
R > I'' 2 ?.
&
7 $ ?>=%
1F 4F I A
#1D 2 ?>.# „ A
a'# ' [1> % / Ui
QH .
&
7 1B 7
> > '1) 9
1c D' /aG 7
I I ' 9 Z9 e F V" - 5 99
>0# N#1 7
/
2 ?>.# N JH`
A
& >* I ' 7
I 9 I A
"
A 6# 1) . I 1F I'' A
#1D 2 ?>.# „ A
# Ui M
QH .
&
7 1B 7 4I F /4 % 9
#1D M P" „ 9 K A
"6 / 9 4
&
7 U 7
@ 6 ' 9 T1
&
7 B= Q 9
]
"
A
#•%
:
1 .
#1F 7 +P 9+
A 0 9
^ 2 ' M&b < HK # 6# 1 9
W12 M 3 R # ' 1-D .
{ : JZ * A ' 9 ] /a .1 1395 . 2. Robert Wuthnow
3. Communities of Discourse: Ideology and Social Structure in The Reformation, The Enlightenment and European Socialism
4. Randall Collins
5. The Sociology of Philosophies: A Global Theory of Intellectual Change
350
48
! "#
2 % &'( ) 1397
:Z#
(
#1D P" „ 9 K
1A : 1- 1F F / I'' :
»
#1D P" „ 9 K A 4F + A 1 2 ?>.# BD# M A
/
c &1 A I / 9 I A
>0# ' 7
'
"6 A I 1F "
A
# T D#
« .
# I# J>-" I'' 4B
-" . ] 3
\Y" $ "6 … * A
#G # †1-"
Q -?. Q&
9 E >0# / I#
$
[1> % C
#1D / I# † HJ # I „
9 I A
#1D $S t . „
# ' / I# m+W $E 4B
H&•" p PZ 4F 4-" . A
4 c KJ XO ?-" / I# T ) L 3
+P 6 ,E 9
I# V .
#1F 7 Ui 5U
a ;
&
7
#
‚ Z z . ] F
9 c cL 4 I# 5U"
A e 99
# 1
#1D M P" „ 9 K A 1; " #
& #10 9 5 . e 99 N#1
» P"
9 2 ?>.# „ A
« XO ?>C#
» a6O hF "
«
#1F # 7
# @ QH . ]
c &1 A .
" 5 A
) Wuthnow, 1989: 6-7
.(
# 6#
e M 99 I' N#1 9 h e /1 99 N#1
… *
"6 1 9 4
&
7 U 7
#
" @ A 'E 4 D 7
&
7 c &1 A
" MB?" # A
.
R (
"6 9 4
&
7 U
27 :
"6 9 4
&
7 U 7 1 / 9 4KI#'SF N H 1
7 5 hF " 4 > &
T D
1` 6#
#1D ^ P" „ 9 K A $E Z 0
" 4>\
A D . -8' U E 9
&
7
"6 I A
# 7 4 > &
#
‚ Z z 7 )
" ' A
#9
# \F 9 t &1 ' /5+2 /Q # /1B (
1 E U E
" Q\) ' T A
D .
+?. 6#
3
#
"6 M 9 4
&
7 U 7
"
A
$#
T cY # ' € # " 4F + / &
9 h"# . / . " / &
-Z K"
A
" E / A
&
7
?+2 A 4" 6' /
#‚E / &
&
7
#1?BC A I R#GC# ' 9
I A 1 T D#
.
Z9
# $' /t &1 $ %
"6 M 9 4 I1>I a6O hF " 4F / &
A
"
A * $ H` \" F / F
" #101F u H # A
' P" F '
&
7
?P 9 V I 6# T D 7
0 9 4+F J" N 0 $ HC W ' $ H
"
A
) Wuthnow, 1989: 7
.(
f (
@ 6 9 T1
&
7
3Q :
@ 6 9 T1
&
7
"6 $' 4 Q 9
4
&
7 U 7
" • A 4F / &
Z >
9 l1 " ' $ %
? ' t &1 $ % 9
5
&
7
" C 9
L I /$
A $#1H& / &
I 9 I A '
#1c A
> 1F 4 Z
9 g‡ U E $ H` \" ' t &1 $ % 9
" 1 A T D# / #•%
# .
# Q M +,# &
c 7
" 5+0 6# &
A
& " ' > # 9
W * A .#G" ' A U E
" $E 6# h "
A 4F # U E $# >F 4 D a ; N W
I 1F "
A 1 .
# .' F 0 a U=" /M
9 ^
@ 6 9 T1
&
7
?U" QJ Q A
#
" = A :#
?&# a U=" M 9
#G%
7
# A " 4F # 'E
7
"
A
>C / A
# 1%#
#G% M 7
' P" $'
&
7
& >* I 7
U 7 V?2
) Wuthnow, 1989: 7
.(
# / I'' 1; 6#
Z J" 4I M 3
" U="
A 4F 5& F 4ˆ L
" / ' A +P 4F # 9
QH . V
2 ?>.#
A
&1 Q 4 c
A
" • $E A
]? / &
.
#1D P" „ 9 K A T 1> % a F /
# 7 I#
" ‰-H " $E 6# hF " 4 A
"6 $E 6# -F / D 9
4
&
7 U 7
" #10 4KI#'SF A
%9
# 4 1 M
1. Environmental conditions
2. Institutional contexts 3. Action sequences
> ?
# 4 0) 6F
?
@
& : U 4 VR
@ % 4
351
; $E hF "
9 6 ' 5
" h A Q a I mKI T1*O F ' D
&
7 W * A
" #10 A
%9 4 1
Z 1"#
9 T(F#
&
7 1 c &
A
% 9
" 1 A D .
#1F F
# /M F @
#1 ] 4I
4+C1"
# 7
U.# "
9 5 . '
%(
A
&
7 P"
9 2 ?>.# „ A
"6 1F /a 2 9
4
&
7 U 7 g‡ … * 9
" 1 A 4 #•%
#
‚ Z z 7 Z $E 9
"
A
@ 6 xI / D 9
T1
&
7 Z 1"# Q 9
#
‚ Z z
# $' ] M
"6 9 4
% &
9
" 1 A D .
4F
>*' # $ F €1>I I'' 1;
3 I hF "
9 I A
>0# ' 7
5U" / 1 Ui u1D M
#
‚ Z z 7
&
7 . I# T F .
" $ Y '#
A 4 &
» 1&
# 6# ] 'E VC#1" M 7
c &1 A /
T ' `
# 7
>0# D 6#
7 }>I#
A )' # 7 F1, A
# • .
T'S2
# 1F $E /M
J` "
A 1 O F 4 M
c &1 NO P +,# / 1 4F1@ # D A
9 ) G 9 F 6 >Y
«
) Wuthnow, 1989: 8-9 .(
# I'' O >I# 5U" Q\F |SW# yU 4 I# M
A /
1c D' 7 I I ' 9 Z9 )' # 5 A QH . /
&
7 2 ?>.#
A -I 4 F 3
U E ) p PZ 4F 5&
"6 A
#1e. 5& ' 9
A (
"G?& 4F A F # ' 9
' M
>0# ^ 7 :W ' F 7
" @"
9 $
Z#9
&
7 5 C F 4> F#' .
F 4F 9 A 2 /1c A
#1D HK0 L „ A
?C 6'1F $ B"# 4 T D
# 4Y
&
7 0 9 F '
" 5 # V A
.
"
A 1; =% $#
3 1; / I'' 3
26 "
3 lS>z#
I &
. 4 ? a ?
&
7 4I
% 3 /'#
I hF "
9 I A
#
>0 7 .
>Z' Q\F / A
J #
"
A 1%# xI j -8' ]
9 ' 7
6# "
3 O ` N 0 A
N "
) :W # $E '# 4 F
7
"
A
"
( F9
>Z' $#1cY M A
'
4; P"
#1F y / D F 4>D# .' ƒ GF {S" $#
7
»
" I RGC A
« 1 E 6#
c &1 $ A
" 6 F A
# 6# 4 D
" I 1H M A
1F .
#1D I „ 9 I A -
>0#
7 $S ) I# N H2 +,# 4
6# " 6#
3 9 F &'1 9 2 @ # Q\F ' Z' M A
4-" . (1
" C / A 1I ] 7 R L L
&
7 U 7
"
A
?C F $#1B= D' 4 D 1B U E
7 ) # * 9
" Q A 1F .
>
9 4@
%9 1 7 + A
" I'' ‰C H" 6#
A +P =% $#
9 , , '# V 3
H"
A
"
7 Z 9
c &1 A ' 9 ) G 9 T1B F 7
&
7 I 9 I A /
>0#
7
# 7
#1F 4 D# # 7
2 $#1B= D' A
y 7
" 5 = A
1 .
#1D '#
I „ 9 I A - 2 ?>.#
A
>0# ' 7
"6 4F # $S 9
4
&
7 U 7
" „H 1"
A g‡ xI ' 9
# V 1 Z 1F 4" ; " M 9
G% / U ' Q c
A QH .
&
7 1B 7 -
c &1 A 4I
% 3 I 1F "
A
" $ Y # * A
&
. 2#
39 U A
" c & 4 I# $E A
#1D 4 „
"
7
>* I ' 7
> / D F 2 "
9 Z $# 4@
9 1B 7 I#
.
# H>2# "
2# M 9 +` # 4 9-
3
1B= D' Ui 7
# $ "
&# * $ "6E 4F $#1 9
D#•% 5 .
1 .
# "
>IE $#1 3
&# * 4`'1Y"
9 5
# 4 F 4 6# " M 9 4F Z' M
? $# 2 2 @ # Q\F
A . @ ' /
) 1*
T 6#'‚ F 7 . ) 9 U. >0# F A
( ' 9 . $ S" G 4F
? $# 2 ) Q\F
9 I# '1Y .
352
48
! "#
2 % &'( ) 1397
!
"
1
1g#
Z # 9
$# 2 F G 4-" .
I D A 4= +
&
:
! 7 U.
A e 99 1B 1
27 ) 1998 ( 6#
5&#
1 gE M 7 -Z K" $ 4 I#
3 4-" .
>* D A 4= + I# T "E [ c 4F &
.
! 7 Z 9 UL F =Z \" G T %
H 1c 99
# M T
" |1K" &
A D . Z9 1. G $
# UL M 4F /T %
?8 ` A
?2 Q\F +W# 1W 2
A
! 7 4-" .
>* D A # * 9
G
" |1K"
A . 4F
" 1;
A
# F =Z \" I UL M
T6# # /T %
# 7
&61"
7 4-" . I D A
I 6# # 1B=
T6 C 1
&
7 -Z K"
3 1B=
9
" MD' G A
: 1 .
# T
# &
T
" # &
A 1 E j
2 .
#
# #1 T
" # &
A 1 E j 3 .
# # * t &1
" @ A j 4 . L 4?&
9 I G 9 , ' 9 VF 01
H 99 I# M . Z9 UL 1& G 1; VF J" ' T 1 # T %
3 4-" .
>* D A F *
Z ' 4= + 9
-Z K" VW C 4 # 1B 3
3 I #G&
1B 7
$ ? ' #' # 1YF
&
7
:+>\"
" |1K" I#
A . Z 1; 6#
9 Z /G 9
#'G # 4L1%# 1B 7
" • 1 A
/ &
U P"
A y2
& cZ# 1 7
2 ?>.#
A I#
. 0S*
9 0S* a 2 / 9
' 9 G
0S* $ F 9
1B 7
>
9
@ 3
#1D
>* I „ 7
#1D 4 ' I#
1 „ 7
) Collins, 1998: 54
.(
4F
F9 Z $ 9 /G
» "
9 E "6 9 I $E 4F 4 5 7
\D 9 1c F &
# >F /5 9
BHD # U E 5 3
#1
&
A 4F # U E 4 T1UL $# 2
&
7
\ A T # #10 " 4. †1-"
VC / # 9
5 «
) Collins, 1998: 4 .(
#1 # 7
# 4 T
&
7 5U"
T 1 |1K" #
& cZ# $' / # 7
2 ?>.#
A 2 A 4> 1% #10
#
& cZ# j A T'1% $ ˆ?&
4BHD / &
F 0 ' &
&
7 1B= D' 7
.
# $' 1 M
» 4BHD >* I
# 7 «
" 1B=>" 4 I#
A D . L 9 G 7 'G " 1B=>" $# 2 F 7
'
V 4B+F / # .' 1= "
cZ# 4I $' 4= + ' 1B 7
2 ?>.#
A 6
" • 1 A
&
:
^C ( 45 I
<
4
3<
: T % Z9 6# # 4= + /G
U. VF 0 A
T'1%
I &
. T'1% 6# '# ; "
& &
9 L o 9 2#G> # G A 9 T'1% 4B+F /
&
7 1D /$ >I' 7
4J+C ' ‰PF
&
7 4 >I'
" ; " # A
' +,# 4
%(
A
&
7 QH .
&
7 2 ?>.#
A j # #
1 . Z "
9 U.' L G A ) ' 9 ˆ 9 4F / I# T P 7 4F $E |1D 4 N W
) M>" ] 9 # $E 5U 5& ' I# VBY" 5& 4>I
" VBY"
A .
# ) M 9 ˆ 9
% A 4F '
$E6# T(
4-" . 4 I' I D
A +
= 3 Z 9 G ] 1 T % 9H A -F L 7
! 6# 1"
7
SJ2 R \> # A
/
? V" - T % 1; /M
3
* I1F /426 "
#1%
A 2 ?>.#
A 4-" . ' I D A
&
9 I# N @ .
Z9
#1F G 7
# f#1\>I#
I #G& 4I ' C " M $ ? QD # 1B
A
" / 9 P A /aSI# / U L ' 9
& ' M T 1 H
F ' I#
1 M 9 2 # 7 Z ?Y U.
A
# T #G% M H " ' &
99 A
*
# # Q .
# Y\F 1F @ A
# 6#
4 / " M
8 9 m
&
P Ui 1. ' B" u JI
$
&
7 1B 7
#1F F / I#
" M A cZ# /$E ]? F $#
7 / I''
I 1B= Ui 9
I A . ) 1 2 9 Y 8 # 4`'1Y"
9
" G 1? / # m A
9 5 .
2. The Sociology of Philosophies: A Global Theory of Intellectual Change 3. intellectual groups
> ?
# 4 0) 6F
?
@
& : U 4 VR
@ % 4
353
QH .
&
A 5& 4
» ' >* I A
« 5& '
»
#1D „ F9 '1 A «
# . . '#
A 8 1c 9
m
1B T'1%
7
"
A
% :
» 6# " ; " 4ˆ E 1B T'1% ]
7 y2# 42 ?@" „J / I#
A I#
4% 4 4F T %
" 5& 1% ' ' N W A
E E V" - 5 #1>" NO H 9
A
# ' 6 F T
-
& / & ?
‚1 # ' &
7
&
7
&
9
@ A
# 7 Z 9
# 4
" a' A
& % ' F A
1F $#1c
" „+ "
A D «
) Collins, 1998: 21
.(
V ( B#
I
<
4
<
: cZ# ] 7 0S*
9 4BHD 1c
&
7 F 9 M +
1A / I#
- A
@ 6 9 T1
&
7
> .1F $# 1% D ' $ ?+-"
3 U E . Z9
# >Y) 4F G 3
N -Z K"
\ A 1> % *
"
A
% L $ 1 BDE 9
4BHD M
@ 6 ' &
9 T1
&
A
?&
3 T '
&
7
\ A 7 $ IE
I#
. 2 # 7 Z 9 0S* 4 I# $E G 9
4F N W A
"
9
? • #1 # $ A
4B+F / &
@ 6 9 T1
&
7 F 9 M + A
" 4>* I A D
) ibid: 6
.(
c ( ( [ I
<
4
<
:
" I 9 ' M
%(
A T6 C
&
7 1B= D' 7
>* I F 0 /
27 I#
.
1B 7 1J / H
?& X 9
" G 1?>" C#' $ "6 4Y A
D .
=IS 3 4F ƒ GF ' N W
4I A
" 1& i A 0 h8# " ' D 9
F $ "G?&
B
" 4-I 1c A
F ) + $# ' ] A
C#'
1J X H 35 - 4Z I
# .(
cZ#
7 0S*
9
$ "G?&
H0 „I /3
7
# # 7 /4F Y" ZG " ' $‡D
1J 1I#1I X H cZ#
A I# ?Y U.
) (ibid
.
#
& cZ 7 4I
% 3 ' >* I $' O F A
1B 2 ?.
7
" • A
?& "# / &
3 U E
#1F 7
?C ' JF ) 4F
T c
&
7
"6 I A
#1D '
>* I $S „ 7
#1F 7
?C
# 6#
M
) T c 4> F#' &
# .
#1F F ' >* I 1B+?2 /M A
1B 2 ?.
7 1%# / ) 4L 9 ˆ 9 ' T
+P / I# >\" * 9
U V A
& >* I 4F 7
>0# $S 7
2 ?>.#
A I# 4> F#' .
"#
Z Š4 cL 9
#1F # 4>B ' G 7
#101F 7
# 1Y u H # M
" m A :
>B 3
# '#
€ I#1F 4B
4>
&
7 Z 9 I 1F 6# G A
I #G& 4I /1YF 1B
d)
@ e H 4(
<
T
@ 7 I
<
J 6F % #
@ (
@ f
; . 4= +
# 4F &
Z M 9 h8# " 4 V
1B O >I# # 1c 7
T # BD #
T * BD U E 6#
Ui / # u JI
? A . 4F
" 1;
A -8 " 1& I A
# # 4 7
?C 2 ?>.#
A A # * I# 0 / D F
1B p PZ 4F 7
#1F 7 T '
# 7 ‹=C ' P"
.
# p PZ 4F ' BDE NS?C .' F 1"# M
JK "
A 0 7 +2 9
" • $E 4 A
&
) Collins, 1989:124-125
.(
H B"
A
# # 4 7 ) 0 T c 7 / > &
?&
9 T# 4Y
&
A
#1F 7 1B k 7
) * 6#
9
" # A
#1F F / O >I# 1g# 1F G%1& M
&
7
1. intergenerational networks
2. structural rivalry
3. contemporaneous creativity
354
48
! "#
2 % &'( ) 1397
h 0 $ Y =Z \"
? A D .
#1F 4ˆ E ) 7
u JI
# # ) ] 5
9 M& 4B L / I# 6
"
A
%
@ & D H # / 7
# >P" 4F H &
7
# # ) $E 5
9 e 4B+F / 99
?C 1
&
7
F9 '1 A I#
.
# +W# /VW# M A
F 9
#1F 5U"
7 H 99 Ui M a'# ' u JI
B" %
1B 7 I# $ "6 ` .
#
&# * [S @ 9
& $ Y 1 5 9
" 4 cL 5 A
1B ^ ' $#
7
) 1 2 9 I 1B= Ui ' 4`'1Y" Y 9
I A .
# Ui € I#1F # $#1 ) u JI
T c
&
7
"6 I A 8 U E 9
# m .
>B 3
# a' 4 I# M 4#
@ \ -
"&?
4U J %R;
@ g
@ 4 h
@ 4
<
C ) 4(
&/ 4
<
]i) %:
4 j5 . F 4F 9 Z $ 9 /G
») T c
&
7
"6 I A « ) F 4F 9 / I'' $
»
"6 9 4
&
7 U 7
« ( F „I#' 9
# M ' $S mKI ' M
> & 1*
.
# 6# ; "
) M T c
&
7
"6 I A ) T c
&
7 F 9 '1 ŒA
= + h8# "
A
$E
$ "6 I
&
A
" #1?>I# 4 > &
7 Z - 9 1B 7 #
" 5 A .
# U 9 , * G 7
*
" #
#1D $ I „ 9 I A -
>0#
7 -"
7 I' 9
> & h .
e \
99 I N#1 9 I A
>0# ' 7
>I# . " $S 9
S
& U # 7
"
7 ) T c
&
7
"6 I A
# 7
"
A $#1B= D' 6# 4 D
?C
"
A 4-" W / &#•" j
& #6 F / B" / &
7 1Y )
" 4 8# " ' A
9 5 : T cY # / &
T6 C
&
7
?+2 9 Y&'() G #1" /4 A
H&•" € # " / A
$ /NS@" /N 2 HK" /
&
7 1B= D' 7
, ' 9 T1 (
# 1g# 1F F $S NO P M 9
'1 A Ui
" u JI A
) Collins, 1998: 380
.(
xI
1. ' B"
1B N 7
# $' ) M
T c
&
7
"6 I A
# € I#1F /
& cZ 7 4I
% 3
T'1%
&
7 1B 7 4BHD /$ "G?&
&
7 1B 7 F 9 M + A F 0 ' /
&
7 1B 7 D ' Ui $ B"#
"
A F .
#1F F
# M @ 9 +C1" 4I F / I'' " $ ˆ?& G 3
2 ?>.# >* I A
) / T c
&
7
"6 I A 4BHD ' /
&
7 1B 7
# '1I ) 4F O F 6# U E ' ^ ' 4 5
9 - M 99
" M A D .
! #
!
"
D1F F A
# 4
! 6# @ 7
Z $S 9
# a @ # G 1 /5
9 cZ#
7 4-" . I D A 1B=
Z ' I'' 9
# D G 7
9 . 4-" . ' 1&
+2 1F € D 9
‡ 4KI#' F 9
# $E ' #
"
A
•) 1 .
# 6# a# 1&
1; /' M 3
+2 9 F KI#' 3
& =" F # * 9
W * 5 A
" |1K"
A . 6#
#1D / I'' 1;
P" „ 9 K A e . " / 99
"6 1 9 4
&
7 U 7
" C A
" $#1B=>"
A Z ' D 9
1B
# $'
"6 M 9 4 g‡ P # &
9
" #10 1 A
&
. ' 7
?& 4F Y"
9 Z 1; 6# /M 9
e G 99 N#1
I 9 I A
>0# ' 7
>I# HI 9
S U #
&
7
"
7 ) T c
&
7
"6 I A
"
A 6# 4 D
?C $#1B= D'
"
A .
# $' $#1B=>"
) M T c
&
7
"6 I A
& cZ# € I#1F ' 7
2 ?>.#
A 4I Z 4F 4 % 9
" 1B A 6# 1) .
#1D I „ 9 I A
>0# ' 7
)
# 4 # $E Q&'() M
2 ?>.# >* I A
"
A
"9 5 ( H" / A
"
7
" C A C 9 1B N 7 e # 99
" 1 A
#1F F / &
. " /M
> ?
# 4 0) 6F
?
@
& : U 4 VR
@ % 4
355
Ui 1. u JI 1B N
7
= + ' A
"
A D . cZ#
7 e 5& I'' 99
#1D 1
>0# „ 7
# 4F ' 1 M 9 e 99 4UH. 1
&
7 1& 4 $S mKI N 0 4F ]
F }"
3
" C A UH. ] 3
1B 7
" V?2 A L $ ?& h0#' / 9
G 7 e # 99
" 1 A 4 &
Z9 H" # $E G A
"
7 C 9 N
1B 7
"
A
"
.
#
# M 0S* /4Y 9
1B 7 4F 4>HZ# / 4 %
# 7 F A 4KI#' Z 4ˆ E 6# 1 9
|1K" G
"
A g‡ P / 9
e 1 99 ) 1 T c
&
7
"
7
" C A I# 1B=>"
.
#1F F
& =" /M 9 4I 5
% 3
#1D P" „ 9 K A
"6 / 9 4
&
7 U 7
@ 6 ' 9 T1
&
7 cZ# Q 7
& =" F / I'' 9
VC#1" ' 5
4I
% 3
>0# >* I 7
- 2 ?>.#
A ) /$S T c
&
7
"6 I A ' >* I ' / A
2 ?.
1B 7 ) 4BHD
&
7 1B 7 ( cZ#
7 Z 9 6# # ' 1i >" G 6
7 I# $ D x?&
.
# cZ# M
" # A 6 VBD 4F $#
I1 1 9 1 5 :
GC ; B;4) < 7C @ ? 4 0) 6F < 6 <I J "&? &9 D( .1 S #
# 2 ?>.# >* I / cZ# M A
#1D P" „ 9 K A 5 ' P" ' hF "
I &
. 1&
2 ?>.# >* I A
W * k A
1 6#
9
"6 N H 9 4
&
7 U 7 ) T c
&
7
"6 I A
" 50 # A 6 .
"
A $#
)9 T1B F 7
# 2 ?>.# >* I M A
"6 ' 9 4
&
7 U 7 W1 >* I # $E F I >"
1B= D' 2 ?. V 7
4F 'E R C .
y A u H # 4
" $E † HJ # A
VBD 1F #
4BHD ' >* I U E # - ' &
A 1B 2 ?.
7 g‡
9
#•cF 1 . 4BHD
&
7 1B 7 $'
#
"6 M 9 4
&
7 U 7
" #10 A
%9 5 ' 1 'E
‚1 # 7
&
9
@ A
"1I ' 3 c &1 A 4 #
4F J> " N W 9
0S* ' F 5 9
1B 7 I# u H # 1 .
2 ?>.# >* I 1%#
A >* I /
1B 2 ?. V W1 7
% #10 VP" ' 4BHD >* I / I#
9 1 7 W1 >* I /$E 1
k(
/
@ I J@
&9 4
<
356
48
! "#
2 % &'( ) 1397
BY # 1 9
" V A
&
. e 99 >* I 1 2 ?>.#
A e 4F 99
# V 1
" 4" ; " M A
#1F F / " @ # M
e 99 1B N#1 7 4F g‡ P 4KI#' F N W 9
e 1 99 2 ?>.# >* I N#1 A
# . 4F /$#1B= D' F }"
3
Z9
# $ % T gE / &
7 Z 9
"
A ' 4
%(
A I I#
A F U E A
"6 9 c A 6# M> 1 #1 '
#1 "# / I# $ B" ' $ "6 Z9
# 4F gE M
#1 N D 7
"6 9 4 I# " >* I ' "
.
# 6# T =>I# F 4"# #
" [S / cZ# M A
9
#1L 5 A c cL ' A
I 1B= Ui 9
I A .
# ) € I#1F # $#1 9
c 9 1 7
>* I NO P 7
#1D $S
>0# „ 7
2 ?>.# / A I ' 9 I A '
P g‡
9
#•%1 7
# e M 99
>* I N#1 7
e 1F 99
"6 1 9 4
&
7 U 7
#1F F ' /1B=
Ui M
1.
. N 1B 7 8 9
& m 9 5 .
$ %& &' ( ) * +,
- . /
! -
#
>* I P 4I & D /5& 6 $10 $#1 7
I I#
A I# T F a# E ' T G* "# / :
:Z#
( P
-?. >* I 9>
A R j ( JH` >* I P A
j f ( I >* I P 9
I A .
>9
@ 3
# 4I M
6# " P 7
5&1F ' g‡
9 J / #•%1 4-" .
) JH` Ui 1g# 1F +,#
A 9
"'1 ( 6#
/ I ]
-y ' 9 4F " BC : F }"
3 +W# h "
A 1B P 7
I ' 9 I A I 6# 4-" . 7
I# T F 1c .
# 4"# #
>* I P 4I M 7
I I#
A 5& ' / g‡
9
#•%1 7 +P U E VF J>"
9
" V A D
BDE 9 J 4 cL 4 5
" / " BC VF J" 4-" . 9
/ I'' |SKW# 4F ' /426 " $#
:W F 7 9 e # &'1 99
y # 1 7
#1F = 7
. $#1B=>" Ui P '
D 6 F T# * .
0 (
% &' ( *
!
&
: . +
!
-?.
9
#
` $#1 A 0
# "# /T 1 D 5& 6 $1 D M
I# T H $ F >D ' *# B .
D
-?.
9>
A D A T ' 6#
&
7 T ' /m+W ' ^ '
&
7 KP0 A F ' 9
? 7 -
" V A / I# T D
4F "#
" 1;
A 4F I KP0 hKJ" G.
A I 1864 -?. D k ?@"
9 I# T F H}"
.
*1F € I#1F A
-?. / & 'E1F 9
# V ' C 6# $#1 5
"
9+
9 I 1= $
&
7 6 ,E $10 M
" 5& 6 9 S 7 ) I 9 T 5& G .
<
( ' C 4F 9
- 8
"
9+
9 ) 1= $
# $ I $10 M 9
.
*1F A
6 # $ * "
F A
&
7 [ * F9 4
*1F ' 1 A F F 9 4 1 7 2 ?>.# >* I p PZ 6# "# j # A
+ NO P 6# 4ˆ E /1B=
A -?.
9
?&#
9 F 9 1>Y 7 -?. P / # 9
1UD 7 4 I#
1>? lS>*# $E "
7
# .' .
-?.
9 1UD 7
# ' C 6# $#1 8
10 V W
-?.
9 ' C 4F 5& 6 $10 6 ,E Y 20
I W
&
7 6 ,E F $10 M 9 I 5>
9 .
?& 4>HZ#
9
# # 1UD 4I „J 5& $ "6 M 7
-?.
9 F 9 1= #G& W 6# Q
# .' $#1
D#
) ' C /$#1U 280
1H j1= #G&
' C /G 200
' C /$ U=W# j1= #G&
100 #G&
1=
(
) /$ >?Z 1379 : 138
.(
-?. D 1; 6#
9
&1UD 7 c?YL / 1= "
9 1 1 -?. D M 9
` A
> ?
# 4 0) 6F
?
@
& : U 4 VR
@ % 4
357
$#1U 4F u F1" 5& 6 $10 )
6#
60 4F #G&
200 300 1= #G&
( 1H ' G ) 6#
30 60 G&
#
4F 200 300 1= #G&
( I# T F
) /$#
1371 R : 102
.(
F A u H # 9
" 4 A F9 9 F 5 9 7 6#
1B NO P 7
I ' 9 I A ) ' 4`'1Y" 4F u F1"
9 1H $E 6# ) ' Q
" • $#1U ' G A
&
.
#
#1D $#1 K
A F $10 #' 9
-?. H 4 D 5>
9 Y2 1 7 6# # D
U. $ A
Q&
-?. H /4>
9 1UD 7 1J -?. ' T D 1F#1F ' X H 9
J&
A ) F9 4F 1>Y Z9 V
-?. H Q&
9 Y2 1 7 ( 1} # H} XS" # * 9
F T 1
) /$#
1371 f : 95
.(
# 4F M
1 9 -?. >* I 5& 6 $10 / 9>
A
# D T ?2 P 4I [ \>I $#1 :
#G # Q
@ A
-?.
9 -?. D / 9>
A D
&1UD 4. $ A
1H ' $#1U $ L -?. H Q& ' G
9
Y2 ' C 4F : 6# Y 1 ]
-?. a UL 9
Y V
) 2 9 7 / 1388 : 30
.(
1UD 7 $ D
-?.
9 -" 4F 7
#G #
"1I D H # ' 4Z H" Q J /4
JH`
3 6#'‚ F 7
@ 7 Ui ' /
JH`
3 1UD „I >"
7
#G # 1g# 1F
>" V, Y" Q 1UD „I
7 ' 9 [1> % G O #
7
>Z' A
F .
(
JH` >* I P A
# ) /5& 6 $10 $#1 9
G
>0# P ' F ] 7
- 2 ?>.#
A
F 1c :
#G # . * N @ ' N @ Q A
6#
BZ " a ; P ' / I ] 9
"6 ' 9
# 7
I 6#
7 1c .
# 4"# #
" H # P ' M A
9 5 :
1 . G
@ 8 . )
? 9 6F
J _ (
<
)
<
+"# 2 A I N Hg $ L 9
I A 1I X >H D / )' # N @ ' - W D / 6 ' Y Q\F h
7
> ' 9
&O N# W D 4@
7 Z'#
9
# 6# 4
#G # ' $#1 QU. . " / )' # 6# N# #' Q
. * N @ 5@C A
# $#1
#'# ' 5& 6 $10 1*#'#
F $10 V 9 D 5>
. N @ V 50
# 6# $#1 1800 ) 1179 [ ( 1860 ) 1239 [ ( F xI ' 1F#1F ' 9
I M
&
7 1860 1914
) 1293 [ (
# 4F jT D 1F#1F UL X# @"
` 4 -" M A
114 I 12 I# T D 1F#1F
) /$#
1371 :Z#
: 38
.(
I' 5UI 9
+c # ' 4 9
# QU. M I F
N 0 1 J" VF 0 &
H 4 . 5@C V
# F $ > +c # N @
` $#1 A F 9 I 6# I 1875
) 1254 [ ( 1895 ) 1274 [ ( 1J X H
6# ' D 1F#1F ' 7
/ 1
"
9+
9 Z $ 9 Z1>I# T1 9 4F t 3
"
9+
9 Z $ 9 I T1 9 .
#
@ $ > F ' T F M 7
1F N# W
>
9
# 4F $#1 20 F W 9
#' 6# 1>Y
# 6# Y $E N#
F $#1
) /$#
1371 :Z#
: 36
.(
I' N @ 5@C 9
# F 4 $#1 9 6# G 9 4?
&
7 5& @& $10 9
? 3 F 5& 6 $10 9
1F#1F T 6# Q
6# ' D 554 4F VF' #G&
2 / 6
"
9+
9 I VF' $ 9
.
# N# W 5UI # >F#
I' 4F $#1 9
1F 4
# 6# N# #' ) Y M
9 Y A
# "# / D#
M 4F 4 6# "
6# ~ 9 4?
&
7 I' 4 5& 6 $10 9
4
358
48
! "#
2 % &'( ) 1397
5
" 5 9
>- W 1 A e / D#•% a % $ D 99
1 1 .
» 1x"#
Z9 VF' 5 « [1> % 21I F
>"# ' 9
&6 7
?U"
A D 9 T# •# C# /NS D •*# ] F ' l#1c+ /T . ' M&E
. I
1914 ) 1293 [ (
"1I 4
#•%
7 I' V 9
# 4 Z F $#1 1F Ž 164
"
9+
9 4 F VF' $ 127
"9 +9 D# #10 €' ] F 1> $E $ .
?&
9 / I M 56
# N# #' W I' 6# $#1
9 4
' 72
# N# W W I' 4F $#1
9 Z C / F 4 A
1F 5UI 4
>
9
# 6#
4F 50 ' M 1
9 28 '
13
& Y ' F W A
?}2 $ L A
T $ ?ZE '
&
7 F - 7
>D# #10 .
#1D „
4F 4 %
# 7 U. t . 6 ,E 4 F A
I a' 1914
# 6# # $#1 6
7
>0# # "
I' 9 G. 4F ' 4> 1% #10 4 A
1 7
# >0# 6#
H Y M F T D V
) /$#
1371 :Z#
: 37
.(
# 6# " BC 5UI
;2 5@C M 9
N# #' VBD 4F +,# 4 N @ 5
>- W NO P"
A
6 ' Y NO P" N# W ' R1, M 7
1 "
L / F 4H ) ' { 9
G 7 1 G.
7
~+
*# 1)
&
7 . * A
#G # '
& F 5@C Q A
# 1g# 1F j H Z' 1 M
7
@ 7 /
& "E 7
# 6# VW C
;2 5@C M 9
# L ]? Z' ^ ' 4F 4 /N @ 5 A
4F 4 ' 1
-"
9 T Y
&
7 a 1"
7
% 6 F "E +,# 4B+F j I A
. * N @ 4 # A
#G # / >D# I
^ " 4 @ E / # Q 1
. C " /$ E M A
"#
9 M ]+" ' R1yZ#
/ @>Z#
?&# ' N'1g 9
F 9 1>Y 7
>
. F )' # F N @ 9
F ' F ƒ GF $#1. h= 4F 1& 6# Q
#G #
\D N'1g Q A
1F / I N 0 9
I A JZ F 'G # " BC VF J" $ E
) 6 /$
1393 :
188
.(
#1F F 'E1F 1I N 0 K0 VF J" N @ K0 /5& 6 $10 1*#'# M .
4F
F %' E [ #G%
9 4 9
? 3 Y " 5& 6 $10 A
=I xI ' 9
$#1U 4 #1 N =I 1
@ / F 9
? 3 4F 5& 6 $10 C
7 S 0' 4F ' T # a#' Z' 4F 4 F ? #
Z "
A
" N @ # $E A
# . ˆ?& U E 9
" M 9 a1>P" 6# a 1" $ 1
Y0# M )
6# ) XO ?>C#
?+2 7 M ( F
) 2 9 7 / 1388 : 53
.(
D 5U" . 0 " BC # 1
J +2 M #6 F
I >* I 9
I A
>0#– 7 F &1UD .
#1D 4F „ 4 %
# 7 4 F
» I 1*E $10 hF
I 9 N 0 $6# /5& G F T D #6 F h= 4F V" 1c
.
# * $ D * l W#
7 # $ D *
" R \> # A
?&# 1> S / 1 9
4F # Q>
+ A
* ' F T # I 6#
9+
A &1UD 1c
4F
&
9 o 1H* 4.' 7 H >P" 6#
«
)
" FE 9 /$
1394 : 13
.(
"1I h0#' @ 4
5& 6 $10 $# #
# l W# "# j F $#1 9
H ' P" @ l W# 4F X 1W "'1 .
/l W# N 0 ' k
# $#1 9
? 3 F -F 4F 5& 6 $10 A
; 9
>C 4 @ E / I# 1 A
5 ' T I V, Y"
"E 7 $ L
$ D'1=>I ' $#1% /$#1F F 9
# # G 7 ' : W BY
9
4F 4L1%# 4 F * … * NS
4 1" l1C $ HC W " 0 ' a BP>I#
BY C 1& 4F / H 1 9
S A
# # ' •\Y"
7 1
F
)
" FE 9 /$
1387 : 32 - 30
.(
> ?
# 4 0) 6F
?
@
& : U 4 VR
@ % 4
359
& 6#
3 1870
;2 G 1? / -F 4F 9
T 2 I N'1g 5
# 7
" UY" ? '1g @ A
4 D
>=% 4F 3 D $#
A
#G # 6#
# #' Q 6 ' Y NO P" N# W ' N 2 " N 7
F .
# 4F M
1 9 Z C / A
" # - 4 9+
9 " ' &1 ) ? '1g $# #
9 6# Q 1880 F 9 / F { #
I 1900
" 1= & W 4F $ E # - A
I 9
) /$#
1371 R : 103
% $ % 6 F (
9
#'# $S $10 V
F9 1F# I1) N @ 4F 4 5>
Y" 5Y '1g $ L 6# / F e A
@ F 4 D # *1F
)' # 7 F1, A I' ' 9
" F 0 4 A
1 .
@ N'1g 7
. C $ L A
"# M C ?P"
9 M /R1yZ#
. C A 2 ?I# ?P"
9 1H V G 7 . C / A -" ?P" 0E 9
M . C / @>Z#
A J ?P"
A '1& D 7 /
Y?. R F # 9
. C ' A ]+"
F G F6 @>Z#
. ˆ?&
9 4& M
&
7 1880 ' 1890 & D
VBD
%9 1 7
" J"
A T c F
&
7
@ 7 B F ' A
% GF A # ƒ GF 1. L 4 F ]
" P>" 4 I•"
A 1 . 4F U. #6 F N @ [1> % N#6# "
A
& 6# / 3 1880 4F -F ~
1D
&
7 +"
A 9 'E1F 1I G .
I 1882
"# 1D 9
A / 1886
% 6 F 1D A
# 1 /$#
1890 U. 1D 9
/$
1892 Y " 1D 7
/ 1896 /€ 1D 1897
/ P # 1D 1898
- " 1D 7
' 1899
" ?2 1D A
1& / ] B A 6#
&1UD 7
# I‡ $#1 9
% 6 F 1F U E +,# G 1? 4 D A
#1W ' A F .
# 4F 1 M 9
#1D 4F „ 4 %
# 7 ) 9
4F 4 Q
>D 3 v# H2 /:
» +2 A Z# ! „+ 5, 9
#1D /5 2 „ 9 A /
[1> % +*# #6 F ]
A
" ?2 / A +" ' A 1 # 1 h «
) 2 6# VJ 4F 9 7 / 1388 : 65
#6 F j(
7 4
:W F F F
7 ) # 426 "
e 5& 6 $10 $ 99
4F ' & 1 F }"
3 F 9
?C $
"
7
# Y 3 I 9 I A . V?2 .
2 . l) 4
&9 C C ) m C n
BZ " U $# J 9
W * A )
> ' # 9
' / " BC 6# VJ> " N JH` $# J 4@
%(
A
I I#
A V
# I# T F $#1 .
# -8' M 9
>C A 9 4?
&
7 / D# 4"# # 5& 6 $10
I 4B L 1861
"6 9 M
&
7 BZ " P 9
' C T D ]
a I
"6 V : 9
M
&
7 VF 0
# Y
" V" D # $#1 A
6# "# j D 9
4?
&
7 ' /5& 6 $10 7
>I# € B-"
7
W * A 6 I 7 BZ "
9
"6 9 1% VBD M .
# 1g# 1F I ' C 6# / ' M 1850
-F 4F
BZ "
9
"6 9 4F M P 7
#G ' " BC 1> 6# T 9
?+2 / @ I 4F ' D f * $# #
?I N " J" ' A
#
> # NO .
# N' =
#•%#' k M 7
) 4ˆ E F 9
# / D# .' $E 6# Q M
" #•%#' $ 4ˆ E 4 F A
U / D
»
>"#
9 6 « T1UF
# 1F 7
"6 6#
9
#1F M 7
"
A -"
9 "# / F M
# F M
» BZ " ^C 9 «
"6 9 F 4> ['1 4F M .
F $# $ .
# W * ' M A
6 I 7 '
*1F A
>
4F $E ~ ' JH` >* I T(
A
" 4-" . A :
