!
1
* +, - . / 0 & 12 3
-+
& 12 3 4 "0
* 5 4 +"6
) :
10 / 2 / 92 :
20 / 11 / 92 (
* 7 :
9: ;
<=# + > :# ? @
* +.A,
? /+ 4 "0 B
# C ? # +D E6 FD# FDG
H 6 4 I @ - @ G G
J K 2 + -+
D L /+M / 0 N -
4 , , &C B ? -L+#
5 @+
.0
? .O FD.("
4 ND-
P 0
# FG HQ B F 1 4 O+0 N-
"
R
? @ D + D#
F +D FD#
D # D G
- + +G S
B F#
Q + N-
? @
@ Q F , + D .
U D;
<K 0 N- B +#
J + V W ? @ 1. X-Y -+
?
* +GZ D 6 FD# +D. G D2
X X-Y X
@ R"
? @
* -
* F.; +Q .
F2 N-
*+D"# D#
B ?+D ,
[ ) 6 X '6 9
&Y D'6 D -L+ +D# \,+ ] 6 +5 G ) X * 9C6
C ? # F#
)
#+ "#
( +#
, + .
-L B - : 4 - Q
N-
; 9:
@
?
+.A, + V +6
* .
? G 4 ,`
:
? #
C
; 9:
@
? +.A, + J -+
W
? @ a 6 + + M
.
: 88630196 [email protected] 021
Email:
1 .
2011 !"
# $ %& ' (
) * + , !# * - . # * ' * % $
/ . 0 1 2 . + 3, 45 #
6# / 7 2 8"
/ 9 : /
! * ;+ /
/
< # (# * 2 8" + " 2
9 : / 7 + * 6# /
. 4 >?*
. 0 #
* ;+ ' !"
!+
@ 7-
! ! /
!+ A.' B 4 !" !C- D CE+B !%F' 2 8"
+ G C#
! H I+ J G' +
. .
@ 7- . 0
) 1 2 . + 45 #
% $ / 4 A.) !K LMCN O P
+ !"
!
< # (# %CE Q * %CE R S
RP ; G * !%F' 2
O+ T
%F' 2 8" ( !3 1 U
A + VW D + , !# * - .#
.
%L-
*
.9C X
4 * ; / B !MS R >9 * 2 7CT 3, R1 8 / 9E# 2
+ / , C * 2 7CT
" 'C,
4 / 1 # T !+
2 E$
/
* !> + 1 4 " * M RI, ' $B + 2 + Y1 G#
Z 3# 6 2
[
\ ,
O . 0
!C$ W 3# 1 2 . + 45 # .# )
.
2 . A + A. .0 C + !] 2* " * * O M; !+ /J ' 2 3# 2 (: 2 W _ 2
, C A. G#
!K 7N8 ^ C# * 4 A #
.
!+ ! + [ ! '
T
.# W + _ 3, 4 >
.9C A -
#P & : !+ + C - *
0 ` % .)
_ a - + ( 2 * b " + 8" 3#
/
!+
R.)
* !" c ? C$ W 3# + * /4) - 4 dL >
4 * ;
/ 2
(' $ 2 7CT * , C _
Y* - 2 + !' 2 *.
A " $ +
3# / U
» 9E# 4 * ;
« W R + . /1
.'M A (8# C /
!: % 2 3# b ] ] ', !+
4$ W 3#
.
3 . 3#
U W R + . 9E# 4 * ; /
! 3#
'] * X 2 .
2.>+
!" 4 A W.
2 LMCN
!K , C RP ; b +
.
) / W 1377
@ / 35 - 20
.(
CE+ * mC U
3#
U W
»
#. 4# 8-
«
!> nF o . ! M, * 4# 8- J: T !" 4
1. Ted Robert Gurr.
M9C ) . W 3#
/
, C ; ', !+ 4# 8- L
- ' '+
. MT
& !" ) 5>+ * !C$ 4 ' , 4# 8- p
XT q' !+
/ ] 2
m& / "
Y ) * G'
)
) / W 1377
@ / (24
W R + . .
4 .%C>
!+ 9E# 4 * ; S , 4# 8- c T* !+ /O%CE 2 mC ',
U , C . G#
+ *
o1C- * ( + s 9'C 2 '9 2.' # * ) R 3C#
#B ) 2
\ >
) . 2*
) R 3C#
t
!L:
- !" !C$ W 3# F ) *
* I B .'#
. C ? # u E 4 R 9, W . 3# 9E# 4 * ; L
G C# !" # * U
o )
) R 3C#
) R 7 ' v ( 4 M+ T *
) 2
)
#* + 4 >T * (
!+
* . B
) / W 1377
@ / 56 - 53
.(
*I$
W R + . B + Z
. "
, C 2 C 0 p & * # 0 x ; + xME 2 G' u + R 3C#
*
> (' $ )
.
;C u E $ R 3C# 2 '9 2*
T %
$ !" .#
O ) !>
!" .) + C >?* ) # 4 C ` %;C u E * W
A + B $ ' 8 0 A + .'
.#
+ 2* 2 + * !C) !C)VW * - !" C >?*
! :I' U
!C$ W 3# 4' 4 A.)
) / W 1377
@ / 54 - 53
.(
) + C) #
!' !+ A (' $ * 2 7CT / b " 2
- , C
) # ME y % $
2 mC (' $
- , C
T 2 7CT * /
2
) A.) 2* " * % $ 4
.
*I$
4 A " Y1 A.'E # B + a 0
!"
2 8" 9E# 4 * ; B )
O ) J % $
2 . + 45 # 2 W
1
!%F' 4 A.) /
. # 9 .
A.'E # ' ) "
A.
W 2.' B $ 4
W !+
? $ U MS 3# * " m !+ O , ! #B + 'C9
2
8"
G' .#.) / R 9D !+
+ .#
.
% p %; Y*
!# N+ C" !:
2
* pF' + 'C9
4 O M; * \ S .
!C$
R ,1& . . + p+ F I # a *z0 2
4 A.) !K !%F' nF .
1 2 . + 45 # * + O , * OM, 9 2 + Y1
) A W. 2 '9 + % $
! 3# 2
{ F 0
/ T * 4 >
' , 2
!C * O , 2.'+
A.) b E; !: % 2 *B # 0 I # W
.
1.3 . ( YI - * + 2 7CT O , .']
| a|%# 8" 2 4|)
/
|
O M; - + o1- +
# E+ # !" + Q W 7|CT 2 |
| 2
| * |+ O| , |
B # 3#
.|# W
http://read and comment.com/2011) /(
. .|) |%L- 4|LW .| +
! 8" + "
2 1990 * 2000
!7- ) A !+
|, G 2 |
U
B / YI| - * + MS O ,
!|+ |
| |)
(Montalsr, Garica: 2011, 32-3).|#*
.
Y IW u +
2011 t E U
Freedom House»
« / ) !%F' 3# % $
2 B 2 |
2010 } # + 78 .S 2 .S
4 $
!C|) T %L-
4 . t
!E / b I 4 : >$ 4 *.;
9#
6|MG R + NC# # # T 4 ,* 8
*
2 4
/ S , . .) 2 '(' * U
|+ | + 2 B * R |, 9F
!7- )
|) 2 8|" ( * 6# / 9 : / 7 2 8" %L- 2
|% $
4 A ) +
www.freedom House. org/2011) (.
R !+
/c ? /R ? C, b "
G' ) * 2 (C U
/ 9
69
& 2
#P
!+ * R.
|L: N |- + .# | O|CT /
( t
!L:
2 9#
2 B 2
!|+ 8"
|)
|
(www.Geopolicity .| B
Com/2011)
. A |+ u | ~ % , !> 2 5$ 8W C:* X /
* + + .#
!"
P R 1S
!
|+ J 8" , C \MCN 2
! R .|T
A.) ( 1 & $ 2 * # . /
a: |] |+ 8" 4 ' * R 9D ' ('| 2 |
*
!+
Foreign policy,2011:55-6) *
(.
(
!
!+ . .) .9C * A (C| Y CE|W * !> + " E M0 2 5$ A
2 | ' |C
8" C:* . .) C ? # O P ( +
4| A .
4| ' | .|)
7 A (C A !+
|+ |9 : * 6# | o N C ' 2
!
| a|%# %CE| Q |&
O ) 4|) 8|" | | | R |? C, 2 | W
Diplomatique, March 2011) Le
Monde
(.
u +
| Y I|W 8|+ ` |% X$ .| 2 |
/ 69| * O|CT * !G' |)
| 2
&
#P 8|" | A W 2 IW + *.+ 9 R.
2 |"
!|+ | >
|)
4$
. R.) 9 : 4 >?*
2 C8 + + - + y
!+
!|# W
|- + * |+ |+ !|" 2
!# 8#
C ? # 2
! 2
1980
* 1990 / + $ VT b " | !|+ !|#
4- 0 L: N
*
4:* \: N b I 6 Z
/
| '+ H | |+ 2* E|
B V|W
1,
(The Middle East Quarterly, 2011:69-70).) .
+ u 8|+ ` |% | Y I|W
• * / ' 2009
/ 1200
* .#. OCT !+ 9 : # .#
$ V|T !|" + :
8+ ` % X$ . 2 $ -
www.Human Rights Watch.org/2011)4E|#
!G' |) .(
*
4 7N) .,
7 2
U 2000 . , R ? C, I # _
X$ .| 2
+ 8+ ` % y
!+
!# W + L, !" 2 Y IW OM :
2007
|-
!|+ 7|
G' ) O : U
|+ I|" !|+ | |L: N
|+ A |" \ |S | !G' |) |MM :
(www.Amensty International.org/2009)
.
| I # 6# 4 >?*
4|:* * |+ | $
+
* M, _
4E +
*
! : U
| ., P >$ 2 E+ .> - 4
9 !+
6
& 2
#P
4- ; R.
.(Pollak, 2011: p.2)
2.3 .
"!#
(
$%
& '(
)
"!#
YI - € ; O ,
7| * 6# | | 2 | )
|9 : 2 *.| | * (
|+ 8" 2 7CT R1 8 .
|S !|+ 7| * 6# | 8|" * !| #B |+ X|T * U
8"
| & u + * + Q 2
|# |+
» H I|+ !|# * -
«
~ C9E|# 2 7|CT R 1|S
A CEW 2 O * U
2000 8" 2 7CT C-
|? * A |" |QB |- 2 |
R | : } |# * !C| " 7CT 4:* 4: - / M •: - # . : 9 +
!|$ > * | 2 |
.# a " " W /
!+ K ^ C# 2 7CT R 1S
|- !|" *B |+
/ R1 8|
4- *I$ 8" * 2 7CT
(Zakaria, 2011:25-6)
. 2 7|CT R 1S XT *
A CEW R m M9 + !" 7 * 6#
+ A 2 /
* +
% 2 7 7| 2 7CT 2.S
2 2006 2008 .|) } |# * 6
.|S 8|" | 2
| 2010
.|) } |# *
7 6# 2.S 2
2008 -
(www.cia.gov/2011) 2010 /
2 + + |#
| 2 |
4- )B C8 + !] X .
,
!| #B C8| + 2 7|CT R 1S
!7- ) + 'C9 .) + 8" + 2
/ b ] ] + p+ F
| & 2 | A.|)
2 |
+ `*.'S * # [# + .|'] | !" + 0 MM :
|" |QB 2 |‚ R |S !|+ *
aN+ $ )
*B $ 8" 7CT /
R* |D G B R !+ :*
a I$ !>
.
"
A + J !"
R* D €.# * W ' 2.' .| W
/
!+
+ # U
4 T , a I$ J9 -
.) W.|''". : | !|> | %$ R |%9& *
C * / * 8" /ƒI
• |" \| & / W |" / # |+ + p& ' A |- * 8|#
9| "
!+
T DZ 4; R.)
www.Irinnews.org/2011)
.(
. /c |?
J| ' C|) .#
) # 2 7CT .)
2 7CT 2 B
| 2 5$ R 1S G# *.+_
!>
T + *_ 9#
# U aN+ %F' J9| 4| # !|" 2 7|CT * | 2 |
. W " (9N# E$ C8 + !] Y CEW /
4 >|?* 6# | * 7| | C ? #
4- . .8
(Dunne Jan 31 2011)
.
* O , I # 9 : 2 7CT R1 8
T + 8"
.
|
R1 8| | |
/
|+
!|+ 4|:* |
$ 4 >?*
aN+
9 : T ) 2 +
. , aN+ !"
_
„ NC| p& |' 8" 4L#
.(www.economist .com/ 2011).)
*I$
B + /
* + - * 4-
# U 4
|W I+ |
"
! A + bB !+ + C H I+ 2 ) .'
4- / 2 |) |'+ R E| Z
) .'] ' b1? $ # "
. H I+
A.|)
|+
| !|"
c |?
/
!|+
Az| *
C) .#
b1? $ /
4E R1 8
O+ T F ;
!+ p& ' 2 + A *B | *
(Times, 3 march 2011:40) + .
0 + $ VT !C9:
!# 8|# * |+ !|+ |+
C |? # p| , 2 |
# ,
U * U 2000 / * .'" .# 8" 1S " Y1
2008 4L# OS . B 2 * !+ ! ' 1, + .| - E|% |9 : |
"
/
"Z
*. !# : …M9 !" # . 22
+ . - P I .
+ A.,*
.# T + >) . 2* s %
(www.aljazeera.com/ 30 oct.2011)
.
(
* + !$, )
- (
O M; - + !" 6# * 7 8" * 2 7CT R 1S R >9 !M W
YI| - O| , |CW I+ B + Q
|3# 8|" | | H I|+ 2 |
.# W / + !> + " , %$ Y CEW
: 19-20) (Attia, 2012
.
Y IW u +
2011 /
# + U
>
U 4| v |N O| : !+ .;C OM
2 7|CT J| ' # 2 |
* - 2 8"
# U + , / 50 4 > .S 25
8"
2010
%$
| W.# 4%8 * .|# "
www.UNDP.Org/Arab Human Development Report/2010)
.(
|
CEW R 1S * + 7 4 >?*
_ [| *.| 2 7CT
|+ | G'|0
| C|| * p& |' |%$ | , } |# * 4|$ W
| 40
||+ !|C$ a I|$ I| # .|S
www.worldbank.org/2010)
.(
, 40 44 2.| B 2 I| # 8|" | .S
||C "
2
*.||; C$ ||W T 2 ||'> !||+ !||" .||# + * P _
||+ O|| " ||%$
www.Imf.org/2010) .(
> + " , %$
U 6#
2010 * 3, YI - QB +
*.| 6# | , | C | R * | B u + 8"
25 (# | # !|" |+ .|S
4|| * ; 2 7||CT . .||) 2 ||
||
[ [|| || || ]
||+ 8||" || || 8||)
(www. Tunisia.com/ Social Affairs Ministry/2010)
.
| .0 I| # 9 : , %$
A.
| W $ 2
+
! )
# !" 2 ) R* D * + * 4$
U 4:* . , 4L# Y* $ .)
/ 2 E+
+ 8"
!
!T $ * %$ 4 # T ) p& ' Az * +
! .# +
| > R # *
W.#
* ;
(http://www.indexmundi.com).# +
.
. ( / 0 %
+ )B 2 +
! 8" C ? # O P ( 6# * 7 Az * +
4| A .
!8 !" 4 >?*
# E+ #
!| 8|" | 2 7CT 2 2 |
1990
* 2000
4) /
# 0 2 U
2000 . - „* !+
y
!+
!# W
!" 2
| Y IW u +
2010
# + U
>
U OM
/ ) # 2 + } # % $
2 2009
| 2005 2P + E+ T !+
23 .S . !|"
*.|
# | } |# |+ + * )
13 .|S (
b E;
.|)
| # |# * U
| * U 2000
*.|
83
| | + .|S
O 8 8"
(www.UNDP.org/2010:108).#
. 9E|# .|) O|+ % 4 >?*
# 8" 2 7CT U
| * U 2000 / .|' B $ p| , R1 8| | * (# | #
+ !C$ W R S 2 7CT R 1S y
+
!
| 6# 2 + } # !" 2 &
2 | 2005
* 2006
!+
27
*.| .> !" + !C$ a I$ .S 65
.|S
O 8| |#
(8|# : , R1 7; !" # 2 E+ * .#
/.'C|) MQ 8| !|+ ~ |9
* * 4E0 .# + A *B 2* !
(Ibid: 109)
. a + " I # 7 x )
R |S | !+
C:* 2 B u + .'] * + /
8" 2 + } # 2010
A *.|
+ .S
www.Imf. Org/ Egypt/2010) /(
|+ …: |+ 2 B * Q X+ ' 15
.|S
!> nF + )
a# #B 2 E+ !"
O 8 A (8# (C- B .#
( 4
.'C|)
(www.Alahram Enghlish.org/2010)
.
| I| # |9 : 2 | + U
2000 2 1 |
+ R1 8 b E; 8" , C H I
R # * + * .)
_ CEW /4|:* : |
*.
13
* Om) *.+ 9 : .#* ) .S 16
A # - .S I #
*.+
. B
.# + C+ D
Africa .org/ March 2009) (www.Reuters
.
3.3 . -!1
(
!$, $(
) /
: , A CEW E$
A | + * " | A (C| { F 2 |+ | , R |# 2 |+
LC _
" .# - 7N) /
CEW R ? C, ( _
/ |9 : 2 8|" , | C 8|T
YI - !" + 7 * 6#
#B MS 2 >) !+ 2 .9
A.|)
. (29 th International system Dynamics conference, July 2011: pp 17-18) |+
O5|> |
! , C H I+
2 1990
* 2000 4|:* * . - „* !+
| |+ " | 2 |
!+ 8"
!# W -v R Q !+ !CN EW E$ 2
!C- 0 a - 2 8" 2 /
b E 2
# + B .|# W + 6 K _
|+ |G# |T
(Hibou & Hulsey, 2006:202)
E|$.
4) * # E R S !+ ~ 9 % 8" ! C .
| 6#
.|+ >:
|+
EM+ & M : Y E A !+ M, /
[# + 2 E+ 4 "
C|) | C- | .'
* 50
1 > .S B b E !+ ~ %CE 8" # + R
* I .) 6# | .
E$ # 4 $
2010 _
59
|+ !|C$ W 2
(www.corruption perception
index.com/2011)
# - 2 .
_ + M, 5
# (# 60 * A.) *B + P M
+
" 48W )B M, 2* !
*I$
b E +
[|# + 2 | M # |+ 2
* 6 K | 2 |
A 4" ) * !# - "
/ O|MG 21| * * | 0B .|']
!E|# $ * 6 K | / |# "
I| #
!C|) 4|
(http://www.telegraph.co.uk June 2011)
E|$.
|9 : C | A CE|W |
+ y
!+
!# W
|3# 8|" !" 2
|%9& : | E|$
U } |# |+ " | 2
/ 2
| .|S
2010 A ||(
146 E||$ # || 4|| $ )
178
|| 8||"
( 4||) ||T
(Perception index.com/2010)
. . , aN+
_
* |9 : 8|" 2 |G R1 >
_ 4| "
41
: U A # - * 2* %CE R 3# 4; $ VT R S Y
% * 4$ W ~ 9
2
$ VT C'" 8"
+ .
* H 60 $ VT 2 85
!|" .|) 1|, * | M
4 7N) .' * D \ 2*
+ A 2 2
. .
O+ T aN+ I * b E !+ 8" CL# 2 . B
# |- * * 7|N) 2 A
Y
! * \MCN 2 8"
4" ) 2 VW /o 2 * / C| B !|M C M .|'] 2
+ R $ 2 * - 4" ) *
.(The Economist, 1 April/2011)
I| # 7| 2 E$
'E * 4) 6# * 9 : !+ 8 a + " C >?*
* € 9 A # - Y 3, aN+ +
[# +
!C- .# q'] 7 > * X 'S / .# +
! *
| ' 8|" - 2 VW
) 4- 0 + 1" _
6 K •N) !+
|+ V0 .
|
|+ …: |+ € |9 2 |
M P .) *B + [# + !"
2 . (# CEM(# * 6 K 2
| | ' * .)
b E
# + 2 + …: + 6 K *
472 + P M
:12) Al malky, 2010
.(
u | +
4 $
2010 7 /
| 178
| 8|"
_ 89
4|) 2 | *.| |
perception index.com) (www.corruption
.
CEW E$
_ nF : * 2
% 2 |
|, :
!|9
|) 2 8|"
|% $
! 2 1990
* 2000
* | # 4 I # 8" R* 5T A (C !+ X * %
: , R 5T 2 E+
A ) 4$ + !9
|C:* R % XL# !+ (' 2
|S
||
.||# "
) www.washingtonpost.com/Middle east turmoil/March 11,2011 (
* || E
4: .,
| 8|" | | 2 >|) | 5|T A (C| 4 1| * |- YI - 3, 2 2011
+ .
( 2% #/
# # 3
J7> * 2
M 9T T
! + * 2 O 9T - + !+
/ O P a . 0
YI - 2
_ CEW
!" + 9 : 8"
G#
M- q' !+
I # 2 , .| G#
. ' 8| 0 U
c ? 9 : , C C- !8 !"
/
* !+
_
| |+ : C * # ‡, 4 "
+ W . M" + /
8" O 9T
* T |) O| 9T A* |W *
4 7- , # + !" 2 + Q O 9T 4| !C|) | * A* |W *
.
* T ) O 9T XT * _
6 FM
/ 9 : A ) 0 /
!+ 4:* MS )
.'C$
2 " 60 * 1969
4|) p|M> #B !+ I # $ VT !" + Q O 9T / $ VT >
/
!|+
.'C- 0 * 4 .
R.
+ $ VT !" T ) O 9T
\ p+ | | < |
b E;
.#.) 4$ W 8-
) /2.| b |, 1390
@ / 9
|+ O|+ % *(
|%F' O| 9T ! U
b |Q /
!+
M 9T * Az * U
P $ * / - MS ( *1
/2
*B 2*
.
* _
$ V|T #P |& 4| "
/
O 9T 4 4 2*
!+ - 0
o L|S CE| ) | 2 + Y1 R
4$ W a 0 - \: N O 9T .
* $ VT !" + : _
- #P & 4 "
+
||" ||9 : || O|| 9T v ||L# * a||%# || ||+ A ||" Y1|| || + ||9 : q||#
||
t) ne . outernationalist ://
(http
. 2 W 2 M 9T T
!
!|+ 2 + Y1 * 2
! |) O| 9T .|#
4:* \: N /
| H I|+ | T O| P | !|+ !|" |+ |9 : 8|"
# - q'
M- 2 ) ˆ &
48|W .9 % $
* G# | s %| !|+
$ VT . G#
.
. (
&45/ 6 7
8 9% : ; <( 3=
- +
Ngo2 4 *.|; * |+ I| # 6# * 7 2 8"
. .|) 2 | /
.' B $ c1& * , 2 (')*
#
@ 7|- a|%# |- X| |+ " | |%L-
O+ T .'C)
!M !"
A. A* W !+
` |% * 6# +
" A ) 7 8+
.
! 2 1980 * 1990 Y IW &
# : | 2 U
|-
b " * 4# 8- 2
|C ' 2 | * # * 4:*
!|+
A |" | + |- /
|9#
2 B 2 *. 8" 2 )B
.'C-
www.Egyption)
organization
for Human right .org
!" + : (.
9 :
‰ | !|+ 8|+ ` |% O%CE| 2
', _
* .'C) .# 4 : >$
9 : C ' 2 * #
$
".|#
!|+ * * .|S !|"
|
1. Tripolitania.
2. Magarha.
!S , .# + /
# .# * (C
"
.#
www. Human Rights watch.com)
.(
(
>
8 % -!1 > 1 ?!4
+ A. # * # !+ 9E#
# |+ , | C A ( C) (#
8|" | /
|(
|+ 9 : * 7 /6# 2 8" # ~ 9 % C ? # O , .
| c |?
| !|"
+ !# P X M" R S 7- !+ 2 *.
W y
* 7| !|+ C8 + .']
# , C 4 >?* 9 + ? 6# 4:* * 4) @ 7C- 9 : /
2 B E| 2 | 2*
2 E+ +
OK E + A " F, #B !+
/ + 8|" !| # ,
A.) !C) (# A. # #B ` % 2 E+ ! ' 4
* B
| .#* ) ', !+
U
*
.# ) %M /
~ % ,
!+ * ? #
|(' $ x |) |9 + * 4 >|?* m - R.) *
.# + - , C
(Juan and Shahin Cole, 2011)
.
2 C E# * 2 7 #
+ C
CEW R 3 - ` % _
!|S , Y* !+ Y*
| 2 |
!+ #B >) * .'C$ 5
% ` % * 4$ ) /RI, *B 4 U
+ - .
R !+
B /
2 E|+
.'C||) %CE|| 5|| 8||" || |M- q||' I|| # || 9 : || ||#
www.Mehrkhane.com/Islamic Awakening /2012)
(.
4.3 .
& ( ( / / $ 5 ,
!S , %L-
* , 9F 2 E#
CEW _
!#
|( 8|" | | * W 2
YI - O P
7| 8" ! 2
/
|+ 6# | * |9 : 4| A
.
|
* /
* |+
+ 2 B dL + 6# * 7 2 8" # T n 7 /
| M"
U
!# |
| * W 2 |
% . .) R 3# 4;
2 ) 2 E+ * .'C) T C ' 4 7N
2
\: |N , 9F
! 2 1980 / 1990 * 2000 .#.|) # .|# * (C| 2 1
(Des Medias, 2007 :11) .
!S , + " %L- ) 2 8" , 9F 2
% $
!+
!# W C " !" + 2 U
+ MM :
!| # * 4
|(#
/ 8|" .|'] * 6# | / |9 : / 7| 2 8|"
|3# |(
# .#
! # * "
H1+* / (#
| # | 4E| : .|S |C# C' P |>$ * E| #
2010 + A T
(http://outernationalist.net)
.
|+ 4|:* O| , R.|) b " | |M,
|| ~ S 7||- R ||, 9F 2 B U
2000
||
||C " !||" 4||$ W „* ||G#B U
4||
! # * (#
1988 : | 6#
!
| R |, 9F H I|+ |) A |
$ >
"
www.committee to protectjournalist.com/2011)
*.|+ |(# 9- | *(
+ I #
|+ A |) + | R |, 9F 2 B b " | . | | |M,
www. Reporters without Borders.com/2011)
4 | |" CM $ /R |, 9F E|# R.) (.
2 |
H1+* 2 (C „ * O%CE
| 7 4:* \: N E #
# | * 4E|N# 2 |
U 2000
!+
!# W
| 7| R |,1& * !" + 2 2005
7|, . | $ ~ |
!#
EN# !" " 1, O%CE * o L) * W 2
|% o C, C
2 |
0.'M+
U
!# ! M, . .) E# , 7 8|" | 2 G 2 5$ * * W 2
!+
) B
The Role of media in Egypt,2010:9).
(
2 B b " .
I| # 9 : 2 $ 2
! 2 1980 / 1990 * 2000 , 2 C8 + !] R.) +
| * .)
|"
!|+
Az| *
' U H1+* 2 (C * R , 9F E#
4:* \: N E # 2
2009 * 2010
!+
A .#
.) 2 R W
$ R , 9F 2 B 4 $ !" 4 9 :
2 E|# ', !+
|
) * !# * - 8"
$ > % $
"
http: // freedom house.org/2011) (.
(
0 / A
B!
0(
) H I+ RP ; * + O ,
2.| B " # | C ? # % $
2< : K.
E + , 0 * E : / E P / E : # # , \MCN 2 +
)
# |%
2 +B * $ / 1391 /
@ 3
.(
+ G XT * U
3# p$ # 2
* CE : 9 : * CE:
#
| 2. B "
JC 2
|9 : * 6# | / 7| 2 8" o . p%; 2 $ /
* 8|- R |9
4:* W -
!" + A *B $ G#
YI| - J|: T 2 |
_ CE|W
4$ MG
.
# # U
•- ) / B
E : JC 7 4:* 4 >9
* _
! 3# 4 !+ a- ] 6Š * S ': .9,
'E| 6Š| * R | # | 2
+ 8" ~1 , !" + € 9 U
A W*
|+ !C- | b |Q * ` ) 2 .
4 >|?*
* 6#
_ + * !9 T + J 9 4 "
!+ a + " I # M,
|
|3# * |+ R |S
!9) [
4|) .# !+ C 9) ‰ O , 8" + "
.
|9 : 8|"
T !" I # V R * E| G !+ ‰ / + @ - + , E : , # 0 + ,. $
|M 9T |3# 4: ~1 , " < * + A.8#
!
!|+ I|M |( !|" 4|) 2
I+ 6 K R C $ Y V0
.# + !M 9T H
)
2. b ,
@ / 9 (.
. ( C DE % 29, %
4 0 + * O S 1 !+ 48W +
!C| - ( 1 # T + 'C9 2 |
||+ 6# || * ||9 : / 7|| 2 8||" || ||
. 8||" || ||9 2 * X||T *
1||| : |||>
* 2*
|||3# !|||+ C8||| + !|||] *B
* CE||| P 2 |||
I||| #
+ 'C,
1 R C !+
) 6# | |) B I|" 1| b |G X|'
* _
||+
.|| W E||# ||C- 2 E||+ O 7||; € || J|| !||" ||M, (
www.mehrkhane.com/Islamic Awakening /2012)
€ ; (
| ME , 2
3# + 4L: N + 8"
+ "
.
|
* / R |3 | 2 >|) |
9 : M- q' „* * 6# * 7 \MCN 2 ) A CEW /
4 6 Z
2 |
H I|+ R |, C * + 1
* !|> 2 | * C| | I| # |
4$ W O ) !> 2 # 2 IW + 2
Feddlers, 2011:4-5)
c ? (.
!|+ B !"
I # 1 2 . + ', A.)
4 / 1| A |W C + / 7| 2 8|" | |-
O M; - + !" 4 9 : * 6#
', !+ B W A |" | 1| 2 P |
.|#
.
) 2 8" 2 8$ 0 * S A 0 *I: + % $
| m 6|0 1 .)
<
I # 8" 2 4 !C$ * . " "
y
!+
!# W
|9 : 4|T 4|:* 6 |K !|" 2
! I QB 60 O MG: .9, LF7 . 2* 0 + '9
! " 1 )
|+
Z
|+ .| "
- + t
!L:
E P 2
(
!+
4 S
2 .|' B 4|:* MS o. 1 4> ) _
4E# 9 : .
‹ 2
& I # 6# * 7
* R * ? !+ 8 ‚ !C)VW
. Z 1 2
"
(Diplomatic citizen, No.54).#
. !C9:
. 9#
| ZD
8" # ME + 1 b1%# R.
I # y4|$ W A. #
!|+
!|# W 2
!|"
- + 4 7N) 8" +1%# 2
!+
')*
b1|%# 2 |(: |- 2 V|0 DZ
* 7 YI - 1 b1%# 2 * 0 * !CLW N 1
6#
!CE#
.#
)
* 9M : "
2 1#B 9- / 6
/ 12 / 1389
.(
( 4 F 3 /5 G 8 4 /
) 2 8" N 4 + .) * ! F: * M * Q %; 6
|% $
YI - .# !" + O , ( 2
_ CEW V|W DZ !|%F'
+ . XT * + 4 >+
4|:* 8|" | |9 2 |] * |]
2 | * |+ Q 2 |
4 + A.;C RP 2
!
* 4N (# + 8" 8- R.)
!+
# @ 7-
A M 7;
+ M ,
!: 9# € 9 'E * M, + b Q 2*
!
|%C# R.)
"
.|#
.
*I$
B + /
* 6# * 7
| 0 !|+ - C:
|"
* b |, | B * |;
[ " 4$ 9T ' FEM$ 4) # A.;C RP 9C, * : 2
|0* * |
C .'C-
www.washing)
ton post.com
(.
2 C8| + R.) 7 4 >?*
4|) *
2 E+
# : [ " 4$ 2 7 9 # U
2
P M
8|" 2
|
*
4: - 8" M- A.;C RP # * )B 2 /
|9T : |>L# 4|
M O K 8- R .T
U 2006 + .E# * '9: b ' !+
U AIQ # n$
2009
| 2008 +
!
; R.)
"
.#
*
!|" 4 >|?* | 7| # C| + 8|"
!C$ I' !# W
*
! # C:* !+ S ': .9, * 8 0 2 8" b ,
4 4 A.) O .9 A.# 8#
/ M , ) #
4| #
| € |9 .'CE|#
. x|+ * | *
O K + 7 %CE
!|+ 8|" | 8- O , (
| |)
4|$
y
* / W 2 7 W.''" 3 CEW 2
_ R L| O|+ % | + -
A " R 3 O K /
F+ XFT C - 2. & !+
U .|# + O K + 7
) /2 |) 1390 /
@ 11
.(
S a + " 4 >?* I # 9 : b |Q 4 | !+ $ VT # W # a- ] * + `
x * U 2000 4 * + 2 >) C) +
! * FEM$ 9T - +1%# ‚
1 / C |? # 2 .| | #B * *B |$ 8|" | p , C ? # R 9
4 !'
a 0 * %> # 2 ' +
.8#
_ 2*
/
!|+ 4|# - , # $ VT . . 4
B 0 * 8" 2 - M # T - .)
.'CE#
.
3 . 5 . 0 4 + !$, I J/ ?
! 9) X .)
! 9) !M & 9 . . 2
!|%F' | A | LM * 4# C' 2
+
!
$ O P ( 6# * 7 2 8" Az *
|+ | | , R ,1& nF a I
! Az| *
. . R ,1& 4$
@ 7-
|+ " | .# - E$
.
| | B u | |+
2009
! 9|) !+ 8" C
& |9 .| . 2 |
|+
!
@ 7|-
| | 4|# C'
!+
!# W
~ 9 % !" + 2
[ * 6# #
!+ 7 ]
4: | !|+ + C|
. . 2 * '$
A + Y I|W | 3, |G p| & * .# + .' 2 |
!|+ s |+
| |T C- 8" , C * 4 >?*
4|$ W .
| /@ 7|-
| 7 C# C' + " .>
2010
!|+
22 .|> * |L# I| .7| * | M
LM " C8 a + !+ A
60 A CE|W a|N+ !" + !C8W …: + L# M
|# 2
T - a) 0 4; 8"
) /! # 1390 @ / 118
|9 : .|'] 4 >?* .(
0 nF 6# * 7 + !E % + 2
/ +
2010 / 232
|L# I I| #
8"
ƒI C# C' + "
!+
) . B
|Wz * C$ |W 3# + !" .#
|> 2 | U
| C# C' + " L# I A C " I ] # T * 9 : C' * !CE+ ~1 "
4E|N# 2 |
U 2000 O+ T C$ 8 0 4
4|) 8|" | & |9 # 2 * '$ !3 1
www.cia.gov/2011) (.
2 I+
& 9 # 2 /
# (')* a%# . U
- / I+ ', !+
A M I # \MCN 8T GE#
W .#.)
! 9) *
»
€ |+ 6 $
« /
» C |
«
*
» b
«
!+
H1+* A 9# A
! 9) * 0 2
# /
G 9 +
A CEW 2 R ,1&
& C# C' + "
2 2008 2010
!+
CE+ , # YI| - |
H I|+ 2 |
.# +
Matilda: 11)
> (.
U
! 9) A 6# * 7 & 9 2
a 0 2
YI - QB 2
/
!+
!# W + !" 4$ R.) 2
! 9|) | - 4|: |C# C' 2 |
!C$ W - !+ 2 G b I /
A 2 + , - $ p &
!|' 4|:* !| M, 0
$ 2 + .'C- | A B 7 T . B
www.washington post.com)
!|+ (.
2 5|$ R |
2 G /
! 9) ' 2 9- 2
!%F E|$ @ 7|- 2 ('|)* * R |,1& |9 I| # 2
) 2 8" + " %L- * , C O M; * .# + a%# W L % $
Y IW *
! 9) 2 9- 2 : |>: * A IG: 2
@ 7|-
* , | C | 4 >|?*
!CN (# + 6# * 7 / 9 : 2 7CT
R E .)
8|" | |9 ! M, ,
!" + VW DZ 2 *. I #
!MŒE YI - c T* 60 . | - „* !+ 2
(www.Aljazeera.org)
.
!+
! 9) R C# C' 2 /
!#
|# " * : C G 2 A | 2 |
2 / '| 8|C#
6 : * !# ;
_ +
* 2 E$
: _ CEW I| # !|%F' | 2 8|" |+ "
+
! O+ T a%# @ - &
+
!
| *
!|' *B
2 8|" | YI| - 2 |
2 C8 + R.) 6# 4 >?* !" # L 9 : * 7 /6#
4) .
| * !E| t
b* G + 6 :
Az * C _ +
8"
/
; ~1 " R ,1&
!#
E$ @ 7- 2
# - _
!" 4- 8C' M, +
*I$
%9& ! M, 2 W 8$ + U
"
/ .# W + _ J: F
_ +
|+ 6# 4 >?*
. I| # | '| * J|: F 6 |: | *
@ 7|-
9 : * 7 .
" 8C' 2 (')* G !"
# 8|" , 8T I|
a%# 2 *.
+ $B
http: www. Helium .com / 2011)
.(
Z
& |9 # 2 I+ D
) YI -
!+ % $
!|# W O| M; |- + !|" |+ 2
|W /
! 9|)
* |C# C' 2 |
# "
A 2 a9' a . 0 O , 2
!CE# ? C, 2 .#
.
K ! c ? .']
~ . , !: %
@ 7|- O| P
.| 0 YI| -
| H I|+ 2 |
aN+
)
% $ y4 +
* 6# / 7 2 8" 4 •N8 ! #B
!+ ' 9 : B
* .#* * !C$ # 4 - o . *
*
!|+ I # !C)VW
!|# W 2
8# !" A + Q .
+ * b
! A.;C RP Az * 4 >|?* d|L .|S |' |
2* * !%F'
"
- !+ !CE+ * # 9 . B .') +
. OT . *
!" !: % Y (#
* YI| - QB 2 Š| !|%F' | | 2 |
/A.|)
| '
R S 8" ;F m MS * !C$ W
C - U
|) |
!|" |% $
A + " %C /
2* +
"
| . B
E| |#< 2 | " 6Š| *
* 7|
!" 6# T* : \7' : (M
!+
5 , # .''"
_
| b |Q R.| X$ '
+ !%F'
! ) .#*
/ 4 A.# R E .
" 4 :
% 2 E+ ! 2
0.'M+
U
<
4E0 ' M, + * € 9 2
!C) 5 C . 2
/ 4 : ŒE
|- 2 |
A " dL .#
. .T .'] !" 4 B (# # I # 9 : .#* ( 2
2 + 2.
Z
!C$ W R S 8" #. 2 # 6 /
+ : |S %$ '
@ 7-
A.' B 3#
A.8# G#
4 * I # +
! B |# - + O :
| 2 |
8" \MCN p& ' /
.' B $ Z 2 # 6
# |T *.| * |M 6|MG | #.|
a 0 2.'" !+ I #
* .
2 7CT R1 8 ( 2 /
!+
Az * + / 2P + } #
|0 * A.|' I$ 2 |
|+
+ * * ' 8" , A $ nF
!
# 3#
| .|'] OT . .
V0 R S R1 8 a " 2 + 2. .T ( y
*.| | R1 8 !" ]
2 8" 2 7CT C- !+ 2 A.|)
|+
!| # + |3' R |S * |W 2 |
2 7CT # R 1S
/
^ C#
!+
4 A. B + _ O+ T #
!3 1 4$ . - MG 2 .
,
* 7| 2 8|" | * N | A |( I' W - * 8-
+ nF 9 : * 6#
* |) | |+ ' b Q O+ % 9 W Š * MM :
R YI -
|# # * !| |M 2 | U
* R |3 .|'] 2 I|W + I| # B |+
4 !+ • C, 9 : * 6# * 7 3, W 4:* : >L# 2
|9T
!%F' * # OK E R |3 9 : 8- „* !" + 2
@ 7|- M |$
9 0 u.% 4 !+ I B )
@ ( / 2 (: E'" !+ !M !+
L OCT * 2 m'+
8"
! * /
!9)
!CE8# + #< 2 "
CL !L M-
„ * + * 2 m'+
„ *
%F' U 8" > * G'
.) .
!+
R / B CEW R ? C, _
6# | * 7
@ 7- F+ * .
U O K +
* Z ' FEM$ c ? 2 (# + *I: + . "
! . R .T # (#
1 C$ W 8|" | & $ W
)
|+
! A* |W Az| * 2 |
& $ + E a, & $
( + *
!
|# (# |( !|> , 4 ' C$ F- 2 |
+ !%F'
! )
* . aN+ ' E| |#< 2 " 7 3,
/
.# $ _
7 a 8 0
/ A. IW + * .|T $ 8|" | | 6 |K |', !+ 2* .)
# # T 4 * 4| 2* *
.# 8|#
_ X$ |'
%CE|
A.|;C RP |
|
!| * .|' _
4
€ 9 'E 2 8"
.'#
.
- ) (# !C9:
Y YI - 4LW . + !# ' + 2
_ CEW aN+
|) |
2 * C % $
~ C9E#
+ -
* + !C)VW
!
!C) 9#
4|
|"
| !
| #B |
|" / 8|- 2 |C 4| .'] CE+ + 4- a|%# .|) q|#
| /!|%F' O K
O ) . C$ W G
# #. 2 # /
$ P 2 CE|+ .) |3# |G 2 |+
2 |
' & /[
/ 1| b I 4 : >$ QB / - GE# * R. * R .T C$
aN+ 1 : > G . 4 "
|) 2 8|" , C * (' $ \MCN 2
" / % $
!# + " E# * %L- „ .) q#
/ * W 2 A (8|# * *
!|+ |
!> nF L * !8 .# +
~ 'ΠF !" 4 A + 4 >?* * . R S
/
. ) !%F' Z
3# 6
| " + 'C9 )
|+ |:*
!
!9|) R |S [|
(
+ .' - - 2 8"
.
<% &
LFM 5 :
( / (
% 5 :
1 . E / . )
1389 ( /
!%F' 2 . 0 * 6# - RP ; / B 2
'M7$
U 1 / ) _ 44 / .
2 . 1
? . / 0 )
1381 ( /
!>
a9' ')
S > 2
# { & / / .
3 . T +. ; / 8 - )
1390 ( / 2 . + „ ) /[ MŠ 2 8 /
_ 54 .
4 . 2 ) / . ) 1390 ( / . 0 * O P y % $B ) 1 2 . + [ MŠ C: + /
.
5 .
# Ž';: \ F: .9, /
v # !9 T + J G: /U & % .: !: E : * J m : 1%C P U9N#
« /! E: M>M: ! + >: UMG :
.>:
29 ƒ C) / 2011 .
6 . . . / %D )
1390 ( / 2< : K. q' /
' U
* | /!| # / # E|# |M, /
|) _ 10 Az| * /
| # U
* |#
/
@ 118 .
7 . OK / C(' C#
) 1370 ( /
# W W Y NC X /
U M, 8# / D1D E;
/
* 9M : "
2 /
1#B 9- 6 / 12 / 1389 .
8 . + /2. b , )
1391 ( /
+ 2 '
9 : A.' B 2 ) / CL / /
_ 6900 .
( 1/ F :
9. “The Arab Spring Is 2011, Not 1989 “The New York Times. Retrieved from.
http://www.nytimes.com/2011”.
10. “The 'Arab Spring” The Middle East Quarterly.april 2011. Retrieved from: Http://
www.meforum.org/2011.
11. “The national council for Human Rights” Law No 94, 2004. Retrieved from:
http://www.anhri.net
12. “Tunisia orders investigation into £5bn fortune of Ben Ali “The Telegraph, 2 June 2011.
Retrieved from. http://www.telegraph.co.uk
13. “Why Benghazi Rebelled". Time magazine. 3 March 2011 .Retrieved from:
http://www.time.com
14. Alhannani, Mohamed (2010), The Role of media in Egypt, Cairo.
15. Arabahmadi, Amirbahram (September 2011),” Probable Scenarios for Libya in near future” Iran newspaper, no.9833.
16. Attia, Sayed (6-12 November 2008),”Poverty eradication in Egypt, The goal of poverty reduction should be a stable, loyal and productive society”, Retrieved from:
http:/weekly.ahram.org.eg/, Issue No. 921.
17. B. Hibou and J. Hulsey (2006), “Domination & Control in Tunisia: Economic Levers for the Exercise of Authoritarian Power.” Review of African Political Economy. Retrieved from: www.victoria.ac.nz
18. Dehghani firooz abadi (2012), sayed jalal ud din”a comment on the future of North Africa”Quds news agency.
19. Feddlers, john (11 Feb 2011), "Libyan Muslims” Guardian, Retrieved from:
www.guardian.co.uk
20. Http: // freedom house.org/2011
21. Http: www. Helium .com / knowledge/ Top item/ causes of Tunisia 2011 jasmine Revolution.
22. Http: www.bashgah.net/Islamic Awakening/2011
23. http:// fcohrdrefort. Readand comment.com/the Arab spring / the causes of the Arab spring/2011.
24. http://outernationalist.net/Revolt Checklist: 10 Reasons the Masses Seek to Overthrow the Rulers of the Middle East/2011
25. http://read and comment.com/2011 26. http://www.indexmundi.com
27. Juan Cole and Shahin Cole (March 2011), “An Arab spring for women “Le Monde Diplomatique.
28. Khalid, wahba (July 24-28 2011),”The Egyptian Revolution The fall of the virtual wall The Revolution systems Thinking Archetype” 29th International System Dynamics Conference, Washington, DC, USA.
29. Matilda willows, Causes of Tunisian 2011 jasmine Revolution, Retrieved from:
http://www.helium.com
30. McGrath, cam “Egypt: population Growth overtakes Literacy Rise” Retrieved from:
http://www.populationconnection.org
31. Michele Dunne “Too Late for Reform Now”Retrived from; Carnegie Endowment for International peace Jan 31, 2011. Retrieved from: http://carnegieendowmwnt.org
32. Montalsr, Garcia (2011), Topics in Middle East and African economies.Retrived from;
www.New Generation in north Africa.com
33. Pollak, Kenneth m: understanding the Arab Awakening .Retrieved from:
http://www.brookings.edu/2011.
34. Rania Al Malky”, Too Late to Save Egypt's Revolution?” Retrieved from:
Egypttoday.com/2010.
35. Transparency International “corruption perception Index” 2010, Retrieved from http://www. Transparency. Org/2010.
36. UNDP, Arab Human Development Report: challenges in Human security in the Arab Countries, New York: Regional Bureau for Arab states 2009. Retrieved from http://www.undp.org
37. Www. Atlantic-club.org/acb events/the new Arab spring: what happened, what it means and what comes next / Nov 8 th-9th 2011.
38. Www. Human Rights watch.com/North Africa/2010 39. Www. Reporters without Borders.com/2011 40. Www. Tunisia.com/ Social Affairs Ministry/2010 41. www.aljazeera.com/Africa/ 30 oct.2011
42. www.Amensty International.org/2009
43. www.cia.gov/2011/worldfact book/north Africa/Tunisia 44. www.committee to protect journalist.com/2011 45. www.corruption perception index.com
46. www.economist .com:”Building a new Libya” march 2011 47. www.Egyption organization for Human right .org 48. www.freedom House. Org/201
49. www.Geopolicity. Com 50. www.Human Rights. Watch.org 51. www.Imf. Org/ Egypt/2010
52. www.Imf.org/North Africa/Tunisia/ 2010 53. www.Irinnews.org/2011
54. www.Mehrkhane.com/Islamic Awakening /2012 55. www.Reuters Africa .org/ March 2009
56. www.washingtonpost.com/Middle east turmoil/March 11, 2011 57. www.washingtonpost.com/Middle east turmoil/March 11, 2011 58. www.worldbank.org/2011
59. Zakaria, farid “A Region at War with Its History”, Retrieved from: http://www.time.com
