1
"
/ 01 / 2
! 034
5 6 70"8 7 9 :
/ 2
! 034
) :
2 / 4 / –93 :
19 / 9 / 93 (
/ ;
!
"
#
$
%
&
' ( )
*+
,
" - ./
0
% + . 1 23 * 3 4!5
6 7
*+
" , 8 69 0 : 8
; .
= ) 8
>3!1
?@
A B CD
=
(= - 3 (= ,
%@
@ + 7 7 E
"
% F
" - ./
0 3
= *+
1
"G H 8%
69 0 :
? 7 :;G :/ 1 3 3 I 5 C
)FJ
%
" 1
*+
" ,
>
K
" L 1 ( .M
=
>
% . )
@ 8 3
/NF )FJ
% 3 O
"G /
% 1
.M
= 5
; .
7 8 ! 1<
8 CD (= - 3 (= ,
%@
@ 8 )FJ
% 8 1 .M 8
%@
@
. !
: 66409595 - Email: [email protected] 021
!
" #
$
%&
' ()
* + , .
. / #
0 ) 1 2 34 5 ,+56
! 7 0 8
.
" 5 9
9 .
"
: . , / .
%
;
<
=
" #
$
>%&
? 2 2 .
@ A
B/
$
%&
/ .
%
;
%0 .
% C
>
. D 4
%
>
5
$!
" #
$
%&
E / F # 0 C
. FG
%&
; H.5 5
%I . E
$4 5 / /
. F J . / 5 +5 5!
.
,
@ 45 C H4 !
" E
>
. . FG
*%&
$H
#
>*5A ! K ! (
% L
>"D F # 0 C
>"D L
M
!
<
N 7 0 .
!
%
>
O/
# / .
%
; . ) J P .
" 5 Q C H.5
%R .
F # 0 C
H.5 G .
$ , / 0#
/
*#
? !5 5) . ST
M C 5 5A !
; . FG
%&
; H.5 5! 8
!
"D
%
;
%7) .
%
"
, !
" E R
*%
, .
I +8 .
" 5 .
% . FG
;%&
H.5 U . 5 F %7 ) V W
. ! 5 5
@ !
" #
$
%&
8 5!
XT E/
! 5
" #
$
%&
Y5W ,C .
; F %7 ) .
FG
;%&
H.5
" #
$
%&
V4 Z %
,3+
/ 53
! 4 34 5I . [ H/
5.\9 / 5
,
@ .
] ^ ,
>
0
@ _ / 6 HR , T/
3/
%7 ) 5
# ! E /
\6 .
>* 8 . .
*%R ` R /
# ,3+
/ 53
"
" #
$
%&
. FG
%&
; H.5
# / .
" 6%
. ) J P
@ !
>
@
@
" H Y5
%
;
$9
" % 3/
@ !
" E , .
. 3
>
a 5 /
34 !
" E .
>" 5
L SB/
. 34
$
%&
' 34
$ 0 5 S !
.
» «
. FG
%&
; H.5
% / a5U 5
b8C F %7 ) C
. 1 LH)5
*%R ,
!
* A/
,Tc/
3/
14 + ,3+
/ 53 , .
d/
5I . [ ,3+
/ 53
" #
$
%&
. FG
;%&
H.5 / 65@
%
%I . E 5 / .
" 6%
. ) J P
@ !
#
"
* / C
@ .
"
/ 7 ) O
* 5!
H 5 , 5
$ Oa
" 5H/
" / C U . 5 ,3+
/ ):
!
%
* / , .
9 1
# .
@
# 1c . S@ # ,3+
/ R R , :
» ,
%+
&
V4
@ c/
% ,R
@ _ / 6 / , T/
5) 53
" #
$
%&
#
"D ) 53 ( W :
i ( / .
" 6%
. F 3
" #
$
%&
N/ jD
@ .
* / C
@
"D
@
&)
$
% ! ...
« l @ m .
$
" @ 1c + a
% ! :
» H.5 i H S@ 5+
D
"
7 ) F % B
7T)
$ 5) , ...
(General «
Assembly Resolution 162(II), 1947,Section 11 (
.
SH4
! V W n MC H)
i , . FG
;%&
H.5 , T/
%I
. E o5 ,
% M) . L
" / C U . 5 1c S@ E ,3+
/ Z %
, . 1c S@ E ,3+
/
" m R , :
» / F 53 . FG
*%&
, T/
" A/ A Q C
. ! 5+
Z % 1c
. S@ # /
R !
" E i H
%I . E 5+
.
*%R
1c . S@ #
(General Assembly Resolution 162(II), 1947, Section 13),
.
" @ / 6
!
@%
p 5 c
1
@ . S@ # S@ E
,3+
/ 53 5!m
>%R
!
" E . . FG
;%&
H.5
%7 ) C . 1 , T/
%I . E
" % W
O/
R 5) 0#
% M) . L
" / U . 5 C
$
* 5H/
, . .
%7 ) / 7 )
O(/
" #
$ H 0 )
@ , b%@
,3+
/
%7 ) O(/
/ .
" 6%
@ ! E /
, .
@
>
8 34
" #
$
%&
? WC
! T
"
S R O `
0 ) ,
!
"
R I
%
%@
; 1946
/ 70
. + , . .
% c
# ' 34
$ S! 4 5
"
" # ,
@
%
* 5!
,
) (T +
>
1391 : 991 - 992
.(
l @
>
V o a ' 3&
McR , 34
" #
! 5B/
. )
;
" 5 0 F TC
*
" ! !
" #
$
%&
1949 5
"D
&I R \6
%R
Reparation For Injuries, 1947)
>(
,3+
/
*%3
" # . FG
*%&
. 6x
%@
;
! 34
5 ] ^
.
$
%&
,
, .
5 .
>
5 y
; 36 T/ !
"
. ' 34 F %@
d/
*%R5!m 1c
@
. S@ # S@ E
,3+
/ 53 . ,3+
/
# W 5 . O . E
/ .
%
; . ) J P .
" 5
% M) . L
" / U . 5 C 3/
HRD 5 +56
, XT , !
" E 5 5
.
" 5
" # ) z
"
$ Y5 ,
(Commentary on Draft Articles on Responsibilty of States, 2001: 49)
.
" . R 5!m ,
! .
/E 1 ! 5
$!
$
%&
, T/
i c)
5 .
. FG
;%&
H.5 T S7 ,
! : / (
* ! 6 5
%
"
Oa 5I . [ F 3
" # 0
*%R ,
!
5 .
>
7 0 8
.
" 5 5 y V4 .
*%R ` (
,3+
/ 53 .
, ^
|) ,
%R
; N9
#
"D )
! T ' C
* / .
>%
34 S T
, T/
\9 .
=5 / .
%
; . ) J P C . 1 E/
" #
$
%&
/
` 2 34
%
"
PR ,
%
;
$9 5 5 , . FG
;%&
H.5 , .
! "#
$
%
&
' (
1)* #
. FG
;%&
H.5
#
%
%I . E 5 / .
%
; . ) J P .
" 5 M) . L
" /
U . 5 C
>
H/ 2 G
" %
* R
%R
>
/ 7 ) 5 F %7 )
C . 1
$ 3
" #
$
%&
. P !
>
. 7 0 8
.
" 5
>
3/
* 5!
H
$I
T4 / , +
%7 / E
= %c
* 5!
, . .
" % ,
! . FG
*%&
. R
! V T4 / ,
$I +
%7 , H/
! 5
* , . .
%
;
$9
; + !
" E 0 )
R .
4
#G ,
%
$I T4 / ,
%
;
$9
! +565
#
"D , 5
! S NJ .
. FG
;%&
H.5 S ` T
.
)+
,- . /
» T4 / ,
" ) 5@ 0 H
>
E .
, F 53 34 +
%7 9
"
,T/
D'Amato, 1992: 599-601)
!(
7(
C C
#
4
>
(}
H/ 7 9 34
,
«
) (T +
>
1391 : 561 (.
1. Estoppel Rule.
T4 / ,
" l @ I c
# ' 34
$
$ R R
1.
>$I T4
/ ,
$
% ! %&
;
! 4 , , @ ! 5
S
? 0
\9 / . 5
,
Reinhold, 2013: 1-2)
.(
>O SB/
34 o /
I M , :
>
I
@
!
F ,
# / 0
% /
$I +
%7
! 56 . , /
*%@
) .
%7 ) ( 50 / R
>
I [&M
!
*%
" # 5 y 3 , %
T() 5 50
% ! a SB/
0 ,
!
$I T4 / ,
&)
$ ,Tc/
L I [&M ' 34
$ / . 5A/
,
) (T +
>
1392
.(
$I T4 / , 5 ) 34
>
*x.
34
" #
@
,
@ .
34 ,
@ .
%H .
>5A
*5W O
H
%! 9 +
%7
" ) ' 34 ,
) (T +
>
1391 : 453
.(
5|!
' 34
(Annuare de I'nstitut de driot international, 1956, t. 46, pp. $
333, 338, 340
• (T +
>
1391 : 561 (
. >
.
Lancing, 1911: 1-31)
>(
O 0
|!
5
# ,
@
@ , 34 .
$I ) .:
%
* 5!
%/
) (T +
>
1391 : 561
.(
l @ O `
" #
$
%&
8 I ' 34
$
; /
H @
"
,
@ 5 y
>
.
$I 5 #
; ' 34
$ 5
*
(General ,
(Assembly Resolution 3314,1974 .
` /
>
$I T4 / ,
" @
*# %/
! 5 T() 5
"
! 5
@ ,
>
T() 5
; b5
@
"D / E 7
€ 5^
.
% . )5)
>L .
>$I S@
•+ 4
0 ,
S@
a 5+
) (T +
>
1390 : 420 ( .
%
;
$9
"
$I T4 / , 0
! 4
# . Y5M b (R 5
y T4 / , 3 ,
!
" ! 5`
"D
* 53
"D H/
5!
* , . 0
>
; W
%
;
$9
$I T4 / ,
" )
"
,R
! :
»
%R /
%
;
$9 / +5 B ) . V ƒ 5
•ƒ(4 ƒR :
"
Tƒ4 / ƒ ,
V 3) ) % 5
•(4 F ^ ƒ34 ƒ
"
ƒ!
, @
(McGibbon, 1958: «
(513
. ' ( )* # 0
/ 1 2
>O
;
$9 , &I
# 1 ! . 34 ,
!
$ # 5I
. [ . a .
#
1.As a ‘general principle’, good faith forms part of the sources of international law.
!
# 5
*%R , ! . 5A a +56
"D V4
"D H)
* 5!
/ ,
# 5 C . 1 W
!
*% !# 5
$<
(Kaczorowska, ,
2010: 274-275 (.
.
"
5 T6 V4
> 5a
$I
$9 . / A 5 ) . i
% ! :
» )
$9 ( . +5
! a n C a
\9 .
=5 . ):
.
% 5!
*
>, V4
%@ c/
,R
"D ) 5 5 m V4 (
# = %c
«
Shaw, 2008: 102) (.
3 SH R
$9 S@
2 3+
@ !
" #
@ ,
%/
>
H n cR
34 3 / E
&I
$ Y5
(Ibid, ,
2008: 261
.(
* 8
>
F
>
# . 5A
" 5H(
' 34
$
>
/ E
"
R , :
»
$9 H) H 34 ,
"D a
,
! ! , T/
% U) 5
a , )
|) ,
*%R (
; ! . 5A a . ,
*
%R «
Ibid, 2008: 261)
.(
5@
4
>
, H/
%
# 5 )
$9 ( 5
$I T4 / , - 0
% D
* ,
) (T +
>
1390 : 424 ( .
%
$9
>
% / . 5 I
% ' 34
$ .
*# 4
>
70 ) /
*%
,
Mc Nair, 1924: 17)
•(
7 5 . 0 ) , T/
%
%
;
$9
" #
R\6 +5
.
"
@ S! &
) .
*%
* , .
.
> 4 N9
#
@ 7/
E
>
# 5 0 ) / .
%
;
$9 S@ 5+
*%R ,
McGibbon, 2014: 1) (.
. 5
>
$9
" % PR
*%
p 5 ' 34
$ ,
!
b W /
\9 . 5
% ) % B/
. .
"
<
5 T6 .
"
5 T6 ,
Ovcar ,2009: 1)
.(
.
*%
0#
%
Preah Viear Temple Case, 2013)
>(
#D . 1
@ )
Nuclear Tests case, 1974: 253)
F +8 C (
%&) .
%
%4 2
Y5W
*%R ,
Territorial Dispute, 1994: 78)
.(
O
>
5I H )
$
% @
;
%
;
$9 ' 34
$
% )
# : 5I . [
[a
>"
" %
% p5R
"
)
$ .
%7 ) V (
>
5 y . T4
/ ,
*%R# 5
$ , T/
b5 . +5
%7 )
Wagner, 1996: 1779-1880) (
.
%
;
$9 (/
. H/
. b (R
# .
FG
;%&
H.5
T [a / .
"
,
D'amato, 2010:8)
.(
.
" % ,
! !
" E
@ N9
# H )
$
" #
$
%&
)
" !
E65@
R %/
,
!
# / .
%
; !
" #
$
%&
6 0 5
% !
4 / / C U . 5
%7 ) Z % ,3+
/ 53 M) . L / .
% .
o a ' + )
%4
% . O R / / ,
!
<
N
! 0 HR . , .
" 5
#
%
. FG
;%&
H.5 / E T 0 5 HR . , .
" 5 .
$ H.5
!54
%0 .
%
" % 3
"
" # . P ! !
" E
%
* 5!
7„
5B/
} /G XT 5 o a
/ 0 .
" 5 H.5 4
* , .
. ,T
$
# 5 ' W/
.
% ' W/
$ H.5
%
;
$9 F
H.5 W
%
%I . E 5 D 0
5 R .
5 y M K
8 D .
$ 2014 R
S.2195 ; 5A !
; . FG
;%&
H.5
!
) )
T/ / .
" TH B ) S
%R
* ,
Nancy Ericsson, 2014)
>(
<
N 7 0
. FG
;%&
H.5 i„
*%R , )
# 5 . V F # 0 C
. ! 5+
S7
0 +
,
@ 5) . T
! 5 , . FG
;%&
H.5
%7) .
% R
D.
% Q C . !
*
%@%/
1.
† +
# } / / 5
"
. M 70
,3+
/ 53
! !
" E
%7
"D
>, '8 0 M
! 4 / .
" 6%
. ) J P
" #
$
%&
,
@
"D 5a
%/#
/ E T 1 2 A/ 5 E / .
% .
5 .
>y . FG
;%&
H.5 .
H D 4
% /
.
%
; +5
%R
;
7 0 8
.
" 5
" #
$
%&
A/ 6 56 5 F ( ! H.5
1979 4 R
,
>
N9
# ,R\6 ˆ 9
# @ S@
+ 5) . T
O+
. ,
;%&
H.5
`/
* , 5 .
? 2 2 M
C 5 / )5
%a 5) . T . P / 0 . !
>
D
%7) .
% 5 , ,
" E
* , V4 Q C
! E
%@ c/
,R .
S@
. , `
! . P / 0 56 . . FG
;%&
H.5 70
H) i 1) %7 )
, T/
" #
$
%&
. 5A
@ ! /
.
"
R .
* 8
>
. T X
%9 .
*%
,
! 4 Z
"
‰ 0 5
%M R %/
,
%/ ) /G 5
, C
@ HRD
" 7 9 5
$
%&
%R .
1. To deny admission to the United States to any representative to the United Nations who has been found to have been engaged in espionage activities or a terrorist activity against the United States and poses a threat to United States national security interests.
Š5+
0 V4
*% ! %&
5 . FG
;%&
H.5 W
,
!
> E D.
$ . FG
;%&
H.5 5)
. T
"%/ C + ,
@ D
n M 9 1
#
? H) 50 /
‹,T D.
%!
* 6 /G C .
5 y
%!
/ (M D
5) . ,T , V4
%@ c/
,R
/ . 6%
= ! 5
*%7 A
‹ 5
. Oa 3W XT
. FG
;%&
H.5 5 HRD R
*
R F ^
@ . 1
# 5B/
\6 .
. iI
" ! 0
5
$
!\
H.5 ' W/
.
1) %7 )
# 59 . S .
. FG
;%&
H.5 M) . L
" /
? M 5A !
; . !
! Y5R
"D
>,R\6
T() 5 O
# + ,
@ 5) . T O+
H.5 W
/ .
%
; . ) J P
7 0 8
.
" 5 Y a
L0 3/
F %7 ) Y5M
,3+
/ 53
" #
$
%&
@ ! 0#
.
" 5
*%R , .
l @
>
5 y
$I T4
/ ,
%
; ]
#
"D .
%
;
$9 0 )
%7 ) 5 .
0 .
FG
;%&
H.5
% , /
# / .
%
; . P ,
$
%&
LH)5 H/
. 3/
$
&I [ 5 5
%7 )
V C R
*%
! 5 y
$I T4 / , +
%7
* , . 5 .
>
. FG
;%&
H.5 5 y
%
;
$9
! , T/
%7 ) .
b (R 4
/ ^
>
/
%/ ) 5
i c)
# / .
%
; . ) J P .
" 5
" #
$
%&
%@
XT ,
"D
! .
*x 5+
.
@%
. B/
$
%&
$ Y5
, .
% . 7 , + ) V .
# Oa
" #
$
%&
5I
"D o +
#
I ,/
# 1 83 A T T
# . .
%/ ) / #D S7
,R /5
# 5H
" #
$
%&
B 6 0 5
# .
$ F %
. P / 0 56
%R .
# / 3
"
5B/
5
% ,3+
/ 53 M } 3W 5 5A !
; . FG
;%&
H.5
@ . !
;
%
%I . E 5 / .
%
; .
" 5
" #
$
>%&
>
i c) ,
" E
# ,3+
/ , T/
" #
$
%&
!
O(
] ^ ,3+
/ E . 7 0 8
.
" 5 [a W , .
# . . . FG
;%&
H.5 .
!
"
,
" E
" #
$
%&
4
; T y T4
‰ 0 5 5 5 ) F %7 53 . !
* ,
% C 5 . ! M)
. L M Š
/ ,3+
/ 53 .
&I [
3
"D Y a i c
$I T4 / , +
%7 ,
! )5) L
# I [&M
@ SB/
34
, *%R +56
.
S@
. , `
!
%
;
$9 . FG
;%&
H.5
$ ,
a ,
9
%
% ! .
> . 5 R . T , 7 0 8
.
" 5 , 7
# . H/
%
) +5„
,
@ 34 B
C5 .
P / 0 56 . C %
C
" #
$
%&
@ H . O05 0 )
%0
% ! .
* 8
>
T
? T4
*%R V
34 [W
#
7 0 8
.
" 5
!
# S@
" ! . , 1 0
%
%7 ) 5
*%7
>
%/ ) 6 .
%
;
@
† 5+59 F5
D E 5
@ !
$3 T 5 H T
%R
>
5B/
% , 7 0 8
" 5.
$.G /
34
? M / D
, ,/
7/
, . 7 0 E
D 5R C 6% . /
" 5.
" #
$
%&
) 5@
% 2 /
a 5
#
" 5.
* 5 @ (
&. )
#
. V4 C Š 5 5!
* S M) FG .
;%&
H.5
& M
* / , . . T X
H , F% %
F ) A
5) R
%R
@ C5
} 5 34 b8C
b5 O+
" 5.
%.% )
!
% .
456 7 8 9
(
.
% &
' ( ) * +) ) 1391 ( ( , -.
/01 2&34) (5) * 6 7)89 : : *8 8;
.
2 .
% &
' ( ) * +) ) 1392 ( ( 8- 5)8 , -.
10 / 2&34) (5) * 6 7)89 :
<; ) , -.
= >; ) 9?
0
@;91 ' ( A
B 0&
' .
3 .
% &
' ( ) * +) ) 1390 ( ( C&D E F 7) E
<.
(7 G 7)89 : 8;
( AH 0 I .
; (
< 5
4. General Assembly Resolution 162(II) (1947), "Agreement Between United Nations and United States of America Regarding the Head Quarters of the United Nations".
5. Annuare de I'nstitut de driot international (1956), t. 46, pp. 333 (:Alfaro), 338 (:Sir G.
Fitzmaurice), 430-341 (: Ripert), 344 (: Basdevant).
6. Case Concerning The Temple Of Preah Vihear (1962), (Cambodia V. Thailand) Merits.
7. D'Amato, Anthony (1992), "Good Faith", in: Encyclopedia of public international law.
8. D'Amato, Anthony.(2010), "Consent, Estoppel, and Reasonableness: Three Challenges to Universal International Law, Faculty". Working Papers. p.102.
9. General Assembly Resolution 3314(1974), "Declaration on the Principles of International Law Concerning Friendly Relations and Cooperation among States in Accordance with the Charter of the United Nations".UN Doc. GA/RES/2625(XXV) 1970.
10. Kaczorowska, Alina (2010), Public International law, Fourth edition, London: Rutledge Publications.
11. Lansing, R. (1911), "The North Atlantic Coast Fishers Arbitration", The American Journal Of International Law, 4(1).
12. MC Gibbon, ‘Estoppel in International Law’ (1958), International and Comparative Law Quarterly,7(3), 468-513.
13. MC Nair, (1924), "The Legality of the Occupation of the Ruhr," British Year Book of International Law.
14. Nancy Ericsson (2014), 113th Congress 2d Session, S.2195, In The House Of Representatives April 8, 2014 Referred To The Committee On The Judiciary, Passed The Senate.
15. Nuclear Tests (1974), (Australia v France) (Judgment) ICJ Rep 253.
16. Ovchar, Alexander. (2009), "Estoppel in the Jurisprudence of the ICJ A principle promoting stability threatens to undermine it", Bond Law Review, Volume 21(1) . 17. Reinhold, Steven (2013), Good Faith In International Law, Bonn Research Papers On
Public International Law Paper No 2/2013.
18. Reparation For Injuries Suffered In The Service Of The United Nations, Reports Of Judgments, Advisory Opinions And Orders (1949), ICJ Rep, 174-205.
19. Request For Interpretation Of The Judgment Of 15 June 1962 In The Case Concerning The Temple Of Preah Vihear (Cambodia V. Thailand) ,(Cambodia V. Thailand), (2013).
20. Shaw Qc, Malcolm N (2008), International Law, Sixth edition, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
21. Territorial Dispute (1994), (Libyan Arab Jamahiriya v Chad) (Merits) ICJ Rep 6, 78 (Separate Opinion of Judge Ajibola) .
22. The Draft Articles on Responsibility of States for International Wrongful Acts with Commentaries (2001), in Year book of International Law Commission of United Nations, Vol.2, 34-180 .
23. Wagner, Megan L. (1996), "Jurisdiction by Estoppel in the International Court of Justice", California Law Review, 74(5).
