١
12 3 !
4 156 7
) :
16 / 3 / 95 : –
11 / 7 / 95 (
8 9 : 3; <= > 1? > @ A : B "A ">
C D &E : F
4 1,: + G
B F A F
. IJ:
4 & # 4 1& K1L 4 5M F A N6 G 5M 6
O F A A 1990 Q 6 " R: : 6 ,6
S 3=A > R 1 T 3 & U13=2 3 12 D # 4 1& F
. > 9&
9 ?6 : G V F 1?A I C F 3; F A 1 4 1& : : &1
&
3=A " W&
12 F A C 4 1& F 1
+ 5 > 1? > @ F 3; F Z73 [ 1:
<&G 1' . + 1C Z 4 & ' 14
FE M 2015 1: 3 ]13 ; ^ M
4 6
> 1? > @ A 1: C [ R G
! 3; F Z73
; <&1,6 F F A
4 1& D: 3
= <&1,6 G Z2 O13 C F 1:
.
+ 1C Z .
1:
3=A F 4 6
15:
9 : 3; > 1? > @ A F A C G G F1 2 ">
1C 1C_
. 3 A 9 8
G ]13 F "A : D F A
& 56 IA C F 1:
C A G A C F 1 +
1 .
+ ; : : 3 F 1: 4 17&G : F "A O 1? > @ F 3; F Z73 A 4 1&Z' G . 1 9&
`> ; &
3; ,6 F A B:
9 : a 2 ->b
F A
9 : 9 : 3; D ">
1: D ">
1;
C . 1A F 1 & 9 8 [ 1:
D 2 D
1 3=A + c F + 1c G R: 6 F
: A d 5M 3; F A
. F G
3=A + 1C Z 17&
F "M G & A 7> `> ; 4 6
» F 1?A FG "3 «
1 =-6 %
1C . 3=A " W&
4 1& F
12 F A C
1 + 5 ->b C 4V 17 : 3; F A
D : " 3= g ?6 h F 5"M F 1?A F AG :
> R D 3=A F A 4 1& F .
C 4V > . I 1'
» 3; > 1? > @ A <&1,6 O13 C F Z73 ?
9 : = 8 D ">
3=A + 1C Z & 1 4V G 78 4 1&
12 : F 1
+ 5
i 1C -3
«
c1 6 j c 9& 1: >
S + 1c C C F A C F 1?A 4 1& 3; F A
1 + 5 1 9 8 : F &
V M .
F 3; F Z73 A G > 9& < k 6
# -3 O 1? > @ .
F C 4 2l
3;
<&1,6 3;
" W&
3=A F 3;
<&1,6 F Z73
3;
9 :
">
&1&
4 1,:
.
.۱ : 02166409595 Email: [email protected]
792
47
! "#
3
% & ' 1396
!" # ! $% !&' ( )' " * + ' ,! -./ 012(!
3 -' 4 56' # 78 9
.
!%9 : - ; . < ; ", = ,! ,! >"%? <!% @7A ! !%8 < B8!
C!%6 D%B5E < ;
-' $%F -112(!
7A% E . !"
* + ' ! 012(!
G)H' !
-' 7H IHJ : :KLH' < ; " <!
-112(!
L ! 3 M KB5'
»
< B8!
« HP2; "
: - B= <!% C!%Q , "76'
» -A FJ < ; !, «
! . :R(S' -= = B8! 7HA 2; - ;
0G9 % -112(!
< Q(! " # 78 <7H 0T
C!%6 0 "
,! < %U;! < ; C!%6 :12J
:B5;
C!% ! <!
-' % VW
!&E .
-B H'! " -= = 1L' -L !%9 < %U;! # X + ' Y Z 21[ #!% !&' \ ! -' !%9 : 7H <!%
»
< %U;! <, =7X KB' «
79 :B9! J"
. " C!% ! :]%E!
$"%E < ; . 1
+ 5 _ = < ; 2003 D` 7) : C 9
: C!%6 ,! !&E <!% -FJ
: %'! ! aK6 @7A7A = b \A!
:R(S' 0 ( - %c < ; . dH < Q(! " -B ; @-G HG < ;
:
\ BA 3 %\H' 4 1L' A
. 7 .
!&' b \A!
b!e(! dH !e ! : :J C"7 #!%
f ; "g : $ E
0T %\H' Z 21[ a %h ,! -A!%6 # X + ' 0 "
-2A 9 .
:B5; -= 21[
$"%E < ; . " C!% ! <!
1 + 5 :A .A ,! -G C!%6 % 7' -1i! < ;
-' -K1 -A FJ = = " B8!
9 .
%; 0T ' :A E -' < %U;! " -B H'! 0j)' " 2) 7A!
; k =!%
% E !%8 :J ' -R1B/' < ; .
: %lA -?%
: 7A KBX! ! % C!,! %m
GB ! b \A!
B %E : ( 8
» :6( ' «
=! :B %E 0G9 % n % <, b FR' : .
%Q -?%
GB ! : 7A ! KBX! " :B9! - " RB' o`' D%QA :B5;
< Q(! : p L)' <!
» D, = «
!"
012(!
=!
.
)8!"
:B5; -= 21[ < ; -' C .A <!
,! " " C!, ( @ Aq a ! C!%Q , : 7;
-= = B8! < !&QB= = 7HB %E $%F _!%U ( rA -112(!
. D` b FR' : < %G " H]
: - B= <!%
» s%B.' " <,! ' = «
=!
. 0 16 -?%
t BA : 7A KBX! ! % C!%E
:B5; -= 21[ ,! 0i T
=! $ UA C,! B' <!
. < !&QB= = " -= = B8! ;
f ; -(!%U ( rA
% C,! B' t BA " p!7;! : - B= lBA! C!%Q , ,! Z
!
< G2; 7H < ;
9! 7H;! /A -112(!
.
:B5; -= 21[
< ; . " C!% ! <!
1 + 5 1T%' :=
3
=! :B %E b \A! -/
. 1T%' 3
:B5; -= 21[ _"!
: u %' C!% ! <!
_ = < ; 2004 - 2003
=! $ .
1T%' 3 b"
_ = < ; 2013 - 2005
=! :B b"!7 .
C! " ! 3\ BA
" < %U;! p!7;! <!% - /.'
0i T C!% ! -= = B8!
.A $7
=!
. 31T%' : u %' b = 2016
- 2013
$ : :
' A%
3 s%B.' b!78! w' J ' \A!
7 . " -= = p!7;! @#!% !&' ,! :1T%' !
C!% ! < B8! p!7;! ,! -./ #!,! ' : 4%c C FJ < %U;!
W ' 9 $7
=!
.
# "%+ s :B5; -= 21[ < ;
!%9 C!% ! <!
2;! -L -'
7 : 3L !
# "%+
:B5; -= 21[ < ; ' _!%U ( rA -= = B8! < !&QB= = ; " C!% ! <!
% E !%8 :J .
: =! Cg :( K' -1i! d=%m :
»
; M %6 _%BH < !&QB= = -A U'
-= = B8! -(!%U ( rA Cg ,! :A Q] C!% ! " 5 ] 012(!
:B5; #!% !&' 7H !%
<!
$"%E 1 + 5 x =! $ % $ RB=!
« +%
3 * + ' ! % :( K' W
# "%+ : ! 7 B8! < ;
< ; . < %U;! H'! " C!% ! -= = 1
+ 5
% H]
! : ! <7H
=! $ "g J"
.
:B5; -= 21[ 7H !% " M %6 _%BH < B8! < !&QB= = a 8 s <!%
! C!% ! <
@
7 d=%m
! !%8 :J ' e A ! -X% < ; .
%; : = m ,! Z
d=%m
< ; " -X%
-' !%8 :J ' :( K' 0i! d;"ym -1i!
% E . -1i!
d=%m % ! : -X% < ;
: ! $ 9! * + ' :
» M %6 _ 2X! -A U' < ;
x 5 ] C!% ! : 1X -112(!
« @
» :A .A < ;
B8!
x =! b!7 M %6 -= = «
"
» :B5; #!% !&' !%]
<!
2013 - 2005
\ BA : 3 4 1L'
%\H' M %6 _%BH < B8! < !&QB= = aK6 <!%
7.A x «
:B5; -= 21[ b \A! < B=! M %6 _%BH < B8! < !&QB= = " <!
% !&' Y
$"%E :UA J7H]
1 + 5
=! $ .
; @7H !% ! :]%E!
W Z 21[ # g
dKA - G %'
)
$7HH
"76' _ 2X! 7A" <!
C!% ! : 1X < %U;! _%BH _ 2X! " < B8! < ;
=! :B9!
@ :B5; -= 21[
:UA J7H] ; ' <!
! $"%E < ; . : 1
+ 5 -1i! 6'
-' 4 56' C!% ! Z 21[ 0' ) 9
. C!% ! 7H !% ! :
$%F < J
; ,! <% E
=! :B9! d !%E -(!%U ( rA ; : u %' < ; ", = 2= : -B5 ( z .
! "
:B5; -= 21[ 7H !% U M %6 _%BH < B8! < !&QB= = < ; ", = aK6 <!% <!
! ,!
%lA : ! 2;!
LKA 3 56' C!% ! < %U;! " -J ? = = -RLX -' 4
9 .
% w H' %E!
! 1L' !%9 Cg @79 :B9! !%8 < %U;! " < B8! - 52; 7H < ;
-= = B8! -(!%U ( rA < !&QB= = ,! -9 A
$, T Cg -./ %V! " -112(!
< ;
794
47
! "#
3
% & ' 1396
-' M;!% < %U;!
9 . : -' -1 h * + ' ! % C!
W
% 7' < ; Q(! : 9! 7
<, =7X KB' < ;7H !% a %h ,! C!%6 0i T -L !%9 < %U;!
-' 9 . @7A" !
% E C!%Q , -' D`
!7;! 7HH C .
7A, = C KB' 0 K' p%h #" RB' p!7;! !
) Art, 2014: 41
.(
=! d;"ym # 1 : u %' :( K' _"! d/
{ :A .A @b" d/
< !&QB= = < ;
B8!
_!%U ( rA <
: d;"ym <%lA ; C! HX U
=! $79 {
* + ' b = d/
-= % _!%U ( rA -= = B8! M %6 $79
=!
. -' ! M %6 C!
%', Y < ; ", =
= = 7HH "76' Y
5A! :A 2 ? " -' lA% c !e ! a %h ,! ; . {
u %' b F] d/
%6 -= = B8! : C!% ! M
W
=! C!% ! -1 5 <q%A! #! i <, = "76' % 7 .
,!
d/ C!% ! : \Ag C 9
<q%A! #! i a %h ,! ! ? -1?! |( ? A 7 ( ,! -FJ
: -' = <q%A! M %6 @ "g W
% V
<% Q2.]
: C!% ! -= = B8! % 9!&E J
{ d/
? =% , : u %' M\Hm
# "%+ " ;
< G2; dH A J
3 :B5; -= 21[ C!% ! <!
=!
. :B5; -= 21[ -1i! 6' : =! Cg b FR' : < %G " H]
7 ! <!
Cg ,! 4%c C FJ : 5A! - ; ", = :
=! $ % b A /= # 2 2 C! HX .
d/
( 8 C!% ! M %6 _%BH < B8! < !&QB= = p7; : u %' M.9
» 08!7T <, =
_!%U ( rA < B8! < !&QB= = ( 8 C!% ! < B8! #!7 7F «
!
= . : < %G " H]
#!7 7F d; <!% :H ', @ ; . _!%U ( rA dH < ; ", = k =!% : =! Cg < H)' : C!%Q , % = < %U;! 1 8 d; <!,! < B8!
-' J"
7 g .
! #!
$
% & '() ! * *) + , ! $) -%. $* /0%
$
:B5; #!% !&' b \A!
<!
@ ,! =! # UX Z 21[ D`
: lH'
< %U;! -X + ' 0T .
$"%E < ; . " C!% ! 1
+ 5 _ = ! <% E!% #!% !&' @-( ) 3\ BA : 0 A <!%
< ;
2015 - 2007 7A7A = b \A! : .
s! ! : \Ag ,!
("
Y 1 8 " < B8! < ;
:KLH' 6' C!% ! < %U;!
< G2; : p L)' <!
D` @ =! 0 KB' < ;
%
:H ',
"76' ,! !&E < ; M %6 : u %' < ;
< ; _ 2X!
:' H)L8 $79 <! 9 < ;
:B5; -= 21[ a %h ,! ! C!% ! : 1X 01' C ', = H'!
<% Q m <!
H 7 .
$y " 2;! * + ' ! @_!%U ( rA -= = B8! < !&QB= = <!
! C!%Q , :
-' :A Q]
" < G2; : p L)' < ; ", = a %h ,! ! ? < %U;! p!7;! 7HA!
<% Q m .' H
7H .
"76' @D%QA ! = = <!%J! 4 ] ] < B8! < ;
' H)L8 ( 8 M %6 3
1929 M %6 HP2; "
-' ! :UA \G < ; -1 } Y%', C!
:H ', : 5A!
<!% b,} Z 21[ < ; 0T
p`B?! 0 "
; :B5; C!%6 % 7' "
! <!
C G'!
-' % &m , = .
: %lA -= = B8! C!,! %m % ~ ! -B H'! # X + ' 7A ! D` -112(!
7H;
"
(! ,! <7 7J 0G9 o BU5A w H' " p!7;! : 0 A <!% ! < %U;! dH < Q
<% Q m s%B.'
H 7H . : %lA 0 ( 2; : * + ' ! % tA%B=! C!, = 7HA 2; -A!,! %m
W : 7A ! 7
$%F ,! <% E
»
< B8! 0 KB' -QB5 !" ; «
-' ' t BA " p!7;! 7A!
S ; . <!% <%V
% 7' " 7 7F _%BH : C!%6
"g J"
. " -B H'! @-= = * + ' %; @ ; !
-112(!
! -' -K1 ; . -A FJ B8! < ;, A ,! -) C!
%
) @ (%UH8 1389 : 155
.(
_!%U ( rA -= = B8! < !&QB= = %
* + ' ! W
7 -' 9 = = C!%Q , :
! ? dH < ; Q(! -A FJ -' M lH < B8! p!7;! k =!%
7HH . %; @-L !%9 H]
# "%+ ,! -) -= = dH :A E 7;! ? < B8! < ;
.
%Q < = ,!
@ k =!%
: %lA ; 7HA 2; -A!,! %m
» tA%B=! C!, = «
-' < B8! 0 KB' -QB5 !" < ;7H !%
7A!
:KLH' C!%Q , b c ! 3H ', " = = <!
, = M;!% ! -A FJ B8!
.
H ', @ 9 -;7A ', = < %U;! p!7;! Z 21[ #!% !&' %E!
3 0G9 <% E
: -B .' dH < ; ", = -' J"
7 g . : -B .' dH %Q , : =! Cg b FR'
: 9 T = = %VS' C!%Q , p!7;! : FA <!
-' Z eA 012(!
9 .
: %lA 7HA 2; -A!,! %m
»
;
« "
»
%E%U(7H « : %lA H] 7A 7i dKA k =!% ! <!
# 78 -B= !%
U € e < ; H
7H . 7H', A -A FJ B8! # UV : 7A KBX! ! % C Ag
# UV J"
=! $7H;
@
# UV Z ,! %B. : 7 UA :BU(!
7 D%B5E $7H;
) Elkin, 2006: 45
.(
' GT % " dKA : :J : =! :B %E 0G9 k =! ! % %E%U(7H 0 16 ;
FAg w H' " -A FJ = =
@ FJ -1i! wJ%' < ; FA % = : $7H;
! !
$ B8! Y7HH
5 A b 1)' -A FJ .
? C!%Q , w 2\
-' 2X )RH' Y7A ! % 3\ BA : o "%+ wRA
7 = . -' H X -' 2X < ;} ( 8 : -' 2X )RH' -A \' < ! = 0G.' @7
=! :J! ' .
@-9%QA H] k =!%
: %lA
%; : 7A KBX! ! % $79 C!,! %m ", = :A E
-' < %U;!
:A .A k =!% 5 %E 0i T Z A 'y; <%U; ,! - ;
) @%QH e( 9 1379 : 617
.(
= 21[ :]%E!
:B5; - FJ H % ~ : <!
C!% ! -J ? = = <% E %\H'
=! $7.A
@ :A .A
# "%+ k =!% % ~ < ; -' < %U;! " < B8! < ;
$, T : 7A!
< ;
7 D%B5E •1B/' .
; < Q(! H % ~ : p L)' -= = B8! -(!%U ( rA < ;
-2A 4 56' ; . !"
9 . (" @-9%QA H]
" w H' @ 2 T ,! ;
! ! Y b,}
796
47
! "#
3
% & ' 1396
dKA <!%
7A ! ?% < %U;! -
@
!7;! -' 2 7H;! /A 8 '!
C . a %h ,! !
-= 21[
W ' H 7H .
( )' 3 C 2; : # 78 :A E
@ =! !&E%V! IHJ " :X, H' : <!
W
% ! ? % V
! 7H
( U' 3 B8!
:B5; -= 21[ " <
e A <!
: 9!&E 7;! ? J .
_!%U ( rA D%QA * + ' ;
* + ' : p L)' ; . Z 21[ dH -1i!
» -U5A # 78 «
7;! ? .
Vg # 78
G)H' Z 21[ dH :A E %; -U5A -'
9 . :]%E!
, T Y $76B' #} ! @< B8!
€ e
! ! C FJ < \ <%5 %
‚%A "
< ; A!%=
3 7A !7 m A #7'7H1 Cg p% '
@
$, T Cg -./ %V!
-A FJ B8! " = = : u %' < ; :
b%;! 0 ( - ; !e ! " ;
%9 7HA 2;
ƒRT -B 1'7H] < ; 9
$7 =!
) " 2=!
C! G2;
@ 1392 : 36
.(
< ; . " C!% ! < %U;! p!7;! aK6 1
+ 5 B8! ; k =!%
-(!%U ( rA -= =
-' !
% C!
< Q(! < HU'
» 1B/' %Q.H 0 16
1« U
% . Cg b FR' : < %G " H]
-' <% Q m ! -i ? < B8! p!7;! C!%Q.H ,! Z %; : =!
7HH
@ -U5A e' C Ag '!
7H;! ? C!%Q , % = : U5A - " RB' 9!
.
; . ,! Z %; -L !%9 H]
( 8
»
< %U;! -U5A e' «
-' dKA < R ! : 7A,! %m
. 8 @C!%Q , dH 7A"
< %U;! < ;
1 8 < HU' % # 78 <, =%„ !7T : p L)' < % " < B? = < ;
=!
.
_!%U ( rA < B8! < !&QB= = ; :
:A E
% " -J ? = = #!% !&' <!
! 7H
:B5; -= 21[
-' dKA < R ! <!
:151= : 7H -' ! !" < Q(! # 78 !%'
% &m .
o %i D%QA ! # 78 !"
-2A G)H' IHJ 9
. 0G9 -' ! # 78 < ; C!
:A .A 0 16 -h U ! " -QH;% # 78 @< B8! # 78 @-G e # 78 < ;
% . ,! Z %;
1 8 ! -' ;
#!% !&' 7HA!
Cg ,! 0i T t BA "
7H; !%8 % VW 6 ! .
: %. #} 6 % = :A! " H # F' " ? H9 # 78 :]%E!
$y "
3H ', )=
3
IHJ ,! -j) " MF' $ ! 2; ; ! !%8 " ; !e !
' S %V
$ 7A!
@ ! e A %i )' < A
1 8 ,! -) )+"
! " # X`h! < " H : u %' < ;
=! # h U .
$%F ! ,! <% E
1 8 : ;
» s! ! % 7' «
6' C!%Q , -' 012(!
' \A!
7 . @-L !%9 H]
f ; : C!%Q , ,! Z
» a1L' " B=
2« -2A 0 A 7A 9
. ; . ,! Z %;
K ,! -./
! w H' :
-' = C Ag " B= C!e ' :]%E! @7A "g 3L !
-2 KB5' # 78 " 1 8
! C!%Q , < %U;!
) Fierk, 2013: 45
. (
1. Mixed actor Analysis
2. Absolute Gains
-= = B8! C!%Q , 0 KB' -QB5 !" : p L)' D%QA * + ' @-112(!
2;! M %6
! < 5 .
% !
! ,! ! ? < B8! < ;, A ! D` C!% ! 7H
M %6 _%BH a %h : C ! C m " ;
M %6 <% Q m ; H
7 . (" !% H 7
7H 2j
% :] " :A Q] C!%Q , •1B/' w H'
! -' 0i T <7H 9
. < ; . :]%E!
1 + 5 ! F…
:B5; -= 21[ 7A" : 7HB9!
<!
< %U;! p!7;!
! ! : =! Cg )8!" @7A
:H . 7i e A C!%Q , a %h ,! < B8! = <, =
:( U' : p L)' < ; ", =
7H;! ? .
%; -L !%9 H]
FJ % ~ :A E
# "%+ " C!% ! Z 21[ <% E B8! < ;
-= = :H ', @-112(!
<!% b,} < ; 0T
2( 5' 0 "
:B5; -= 21[ e 'g ! <!
C G'!
-' % &m , = . : M;
K ! : -A FJ B8! -QB= m
<
2;!
-BRA w H' 7H !%
< ;
< B8! " 79 %\H'
-' 9 . D%B5E ah H' C!%6 RA
2 8 % :1i ` @e ?
<q%A! -A FJ W
-' % V 6' - ;7' m " !&E 012(!
9! 7;! ? .
-( ' < ; !, C"7 -A FJ B8!
:KLH' < \ e !%' @012(!
-B)Hi <q ( HG " <!
" -A FJ B8! -) Uh w H' dKA @C ' ! { 9! 7;! /A -A!7H] 79 @C 7'
= = (" -' 2X < ;
$y " 2;! -B)Hi < ; <!
! . -A FJ B8! 79
$"`X
%
K !
<
B8! -B)Hi < ; . )8 ' @012(!
H ', 3 < ; . C79 7H2 78
!%Q , % !% %Q.( ] ' C
S = = %V : e A ! 012(!
-' J"
"g
) @C .A 1393 : 75
.(
%!
:B5; -= 21[ < ;7H -= = B8! < !&QB= = ( 8 <!
-' C .A -112(!
7;
$7X 8 : b A : <!
»
† )B' < ;"% A 7A m «
0G9 _ T @-A FJ 7A"
=! <% E
@ !% ,
-BRA < ;7'g : - ; . -' 5
"76' % !% @7HH = = < ;
C! 012(!
<%B. <%Q.( ] -' !7 m
{7HH :1r5' : <!
M;
$, T e A C H ! " = = •1B/' < ;
-' :lT`' -A FJ H'!
9 .
:A .A H] < ; 7H !%
$, T <
$7; .' - !%~J •1B/' < ; -'
9
@ : :A E : <!
d( ] 1i! < ;
= = % !% - < %U;! " -B H'! < ;
g < ; . : =! -Kh H' G %'
7HH i
Y 7A ! !%8 RA .
_ = -h <q%A! w H' D"% a %h ,! ; . ! < ;
m ,!
w H' : %= IHJ C 9
:B = -FJ 7A!
. K -A FJ B8! 79 @7A" !
:KLH' %Q.( ] < ;"% A <!
"
=! $ ? 7A m -112(!
.
-Ey " ,! -G -' ! _!%U ( rA B8! < !&QB= = -1i! < ;
u U ! C!
C A 8 " - !%E FA @- !%E -112(!
U - !%E
% . s A -A!%H/= -A T"
) %U' B[=
2013 ( K <!% :PAg %; b \A! : C!% ! : 9! $ 9! * + ' ! : C A 8 ' GT
798
47
! "#
3
% & ' 1396
" -1' ‡L=
@ =! b,} -112(!
7F)B' 7;! ? .
‡L= C A 8 2 T -112(!
d m
=! -A FJ ‡1i <`BX! " ƒRT u%9 .
d( ] : ' = m < 2H;! 7 < J < ;
79 •1B/' ˆ L= C A 8 2 T
) @- =!% ! " BA!
1395 : 67
. (
< ; . :)=
B 3 " -= = !7B8! @-B)Hi
< %U;!
IH; 2; a %h ,! ! ? <, =
: } " # KUh w H' •1B/' < ;
W
$ % ' 7A!
. : @-1' w H' " H'! * + ' @7A" !
: } w H' #!,! ' •1B/' - KUh < ;
W -' ' 9 .
!,!
H= @"
- Q/= m % -HBU' < ;
, T Y
! ? Vg @-1?!
$, T < ;
-' C!% ! -'`=! < F2J % e A -112(!
!&E .
K ! a %h ,! ! -1' H'! " w H' C Ag
<
1 8 -' <% Q m Z q ( HG " < B8! < ; 7HH
.
$, T 7A 8 C Ag :L ! @-1' H'! •1B/' < ;
IH; 2; " Z A E ! <!
: 7A "g J"
) " 2=!
C! G2;
@ 1392 : 75
.(
: %lA
%; : 7A KBX! ! % _!%U ( rA -= = C!,! %m B - Q/= m " dH :A E
K ! : -= =
<
» Z y !%B=! A`KX «
$, T ; . •1B/' < ;
%\H' -' 9 .
0G9 ' <% E S
$"%E " -.;"ym •1B/' # 5=
-' ! -B(" !&QB= = •1B/' < ; D` C!
C ', = B 3 GT ' :H F <!% ;
$, T _ ) \ ! a %h ,! -1' H'! <, = < ;
5A! < B8! w H' •1B/' .
-= = B8! -L !%9 H]
-' -112(!
1 8 7A!
< ;
:H F <!% b,}
:B5; -= 21[ 7A" <, = $"%E < ; . " C!% ! <!
1 + 5 p!7;! aK6 <!%
: ! < %U;!
g J"
"
) -1 ' @ !yA 1390 : 245
.(
+ , ! $) -%. $* /0% *) 1( 2 !
M %6 ,! $ RB=!
< B8! < ; :
5 A <7 7J D" -= = 7i K' <!%J! lH' .
("
;
M %6 : _ h •1B/' 0 } : 0= B' < B8! < ;
9
$7 7A!
. M %6 _ „' <!%
< ;
< \ " < B8!
' !e ! ,! -G : J 8 C! "
RB=!
Y k"
C!% ! : 1X ; .
,!
|? 9 :12J
p7; . < B8! # 78 <, = "76' M %6 = = < ;
!
= . 1QA!
e A _ = ! - Q(! H]
< ; 1953 - 1950 1T%' : ‰7 ' %B (" : 1X 3
"g !%J!
.
#} ! " : =" @ 1QA! H %GR
$%F 7 ! M %6 = = % $76B' ,! <% E
5A! -= = p!7;! : - B= <!% < B8! !e ! {
-( T K ! ' M lH : :' A
< ;
# "%+ ,! -) < %U;! " < B8!
-' 4 56' <7 7J < ; -= = < ;7T!" : 9
:H ', 7A ! D`
C K <!% b,} < ; :R(S'
8! < ; ! < B8! = = " -= = B
<% Q m H
7H .
"76' @w8! ' ,! < 5 _ 2X! < ;
k =!% p7; < ; . : 1X $79
# "%+
M lH < %U;! < ; 9
$7
@
% H] '!
!
|? 9 : :J C"7 <7H B8! < ;
-= = -A} h
#7' -./ %V!
' S <%V \ ! A -2 H 7 . _ ) " 0' ) = = ?%
= = -A FJ B8! < ;, A ,! -?% : =! -L !%9 : u %' C!% ! 7HA 2; - ; . 7H 7A m %Q 7G < %U;! " -B H'!
) -1 ' @ !yA 1390 : 185
.(
$, T ,! -G _!%U ( rA -= = B8! -1i! < ;
@ " _%BH ; . -U5A e' dKA
C!%6 % 7'
!
= .
!% ! C
%', Y B8! a %h ,! ! ? -U5A e' : =! - ; .
RA D"% ,! -9 A < ;7'g " -A FJ W
-' ' 7H { -= 21[ ,! -./ 0 ( 2; :
:B5;
=! <q%A! -= = B8! < ; ", = : p L)' <!
. t BA : -A!%Q , @7H !% !
0 A %VS' < %U;!
-' 9 7A C G'! : 79 :B9! J" -A FJ B8! C Ag < !&E%V!
. ,!
(" @%lH' ! •1B/' < ; ", = % a %h ,! ! ? w H' : 7A7H' %? -A!%Q , ;
C,! B' <!%
-' <% Q m w H' " p!7;! <, = 7HH
(Trevor, 2013: 155)
.
M %6 _ 2X!
< = ,! C!% ! : 1X < B8! < ; g
@ G %' 6 ! 3 : =" " ] @ m" !
@ -./
-' 4 56' _!%U ( rA - !%E FA ,!
9 .
$"%E p!7;! < %G " H]
: C!% ! _ G ! < ;
$ e 'g /B ! a ! : - B= B=! ? 9! #% ~' @7A!
. = = @ Aq a ! C ', ,!
- !% ~ C!% ! -1?!
: "
79 "
. ˆ HJ C!% ! B/' < ;
•1 Y
-= 21[ % 5'
:B5;
- " RB' %G " <!
B9!
: 7A!
.
$"%E
< G2; ,! 0i T t BA : _ G ! < ; " C!% ! < ;
g 7A C!%QA C!% ! < B8! w H' <!% G %' .
-( T : g - G %' -= 21[ # "%+ % ;
:H e; _ 2X! " UJ!
/= < ; :A!% E
C!% ! % !% <%
W 7 7HB9!
(Rubin, 2014: 87)
.
!" _!%U ( rA -= = B8! < !&QB= =
:lT`' ; . ,! < 5 012(!
-' 9 . 08!7T : u %' < j C!%Q , -' 2 : =! Cg < H)' : -K ! * 2J!
< ;
0 A - 1L' < B8! t BA : < %U;!
-' 9 7A . :]%E!
# 21[
; - 7A" 7A ! D` :
< X 7 7F ,! !&E " <, =
< ; <% Q m ! < B8! " -= = HH
7
@ -= = B8! -= 21[
_!%U ( rA
! <% Q m
$ %
@7A!
C ', = < G2; C"7 <7H !% H] aK6 -1i! C!%Q , 3B
= = 7;! ? < ! 9 012(!
.
"76' !%9 < ;
C G'! < B? =
% % -HBU' t BA : - B=
:2;
<%Q , f ; <!% :UA J C G'!
7;! /A % &m
) Baldwin,
1979: 63
.(
: C!% ! < B8! " -X 2BJ! < ;, A :A E
M !%B' <!
9 $7 d/ : C 9
-FJ ,!
7H !% a %h ,! ! Cg 'W @ . - !%J! C! !eE " C!7A"%F9 -J ? = = < ;
C G'!
-' % &m 7HA!
.
# "%+ -L !%9 H]
< ;, A ,! -) C!% ! -J ? = = < ;
# "%+ 'W : p L)' < ;7H !% " < B8!
7;! ? C!7A"%F9 -E7A, -' 2X < ; .
7 C!% ! -J ? = = < ;7A" - !%J! C! !eE , =, : 7H9 •8!" %'! ! %
<
800
47
! "#
3
% & ' 1396
< %U;! < ;, A )' J
3 ( 8 C!% !
»
$ « "
» H'!
« 0i T -L !%9 -'
9 #!% ~ :
(" < ; Q(! " - !%J! = = < GB ! < ;7A" " -G B 0i T . < !
9 .
-' ! C!% ! ?% G %'g dH < Q(!
( )' ( 8 C!
3
»
"76' < ;
-A 'y;
« U
% .
#} !
"76' ! D` $76B' C!%Q , : 1X < %U;! < ;
:KLH' < %U;! dH < Q(! -' lA b!78! 7HA 2; - ; ", = a %h ,! ! :A ' " ? <!
<% Q m 7H
. -' D` $ ! 2; C 'y; # 78 - A! 7H
U8 % = : U5A ! ? < ;
d !e ! 7;
: a %h ! ,! "
' # 78 S :KLH' 6' %V 0 7U <!
9 . U %2 9%'
# 78 -= = dH < ; Q(!
* + ' ! % € e < ; W
: ! 7 :
» -A 'y; b FR' :
eJ # i -
Z <!% % KLH'
3 Š ? - !%~J :
-'
"
. o`„'
-' -' FR' H]
$, T <!% 7A!
9 @ m" ! 7HA 2; - !%~J < ;
%G2 A @ =g ‰%9 _ 2 Y
- %c
9 $ RB=! :A ' " ? .
%G2 A € e # 78 FH . ! Y
$, T " - %c :KLH' < ;
<!
-' 4 56' :A ' " ? :12J ,!
9 . -' € e # 78 Z : -B )8 ' %BF : !"7 '! 7A!
:KLH' -A 'y; : C79 0 7U @79 Cg 5
%BH C G'! # i " <!
:KLH' _ ! \2; <!
=! -H ', a %h ,! k%B= 0 8 ...
@ 9 !7 7m :KLH' $ K( C 'y; Z %E!
%Q
# 78 :KLH' € e < ; :]
C 'y; Z2 C"7 7HA! B 5 7HH :1 K' "! %Q ah H' < ;
...
$7 ! !%9 :KLH' C 'y; FH : =! ! -E e # 78 %; <!% _g
FJ <!
79 C . H]
#7' " $ J ' w+" !7 %h -B("
; 6A Y
=! $ % ƒRT ! # 78 w , «
) @%2 9%'
1390 : 47
.(
#} ! @- !7;! H] : :J :H e; $76B'
-A 'y; 5 <!% ! ? -' lA < ;
:KLH'
=! $ ! d !e ! <!
. + ' ! % •1B/' -A ', wh K' ' "! s! %E!
* W ! 7
: :
» H eE 3
! !%8 e ' <" C!% ! ?% -' lA
« -' lA B? = : =! Cg b FR' : @
1m zq D%B5E ,! . ! - 12X "
:B %E $%F -' lA # '!78! b \A! <!% -G B 7A!
. H]
:KLH' C!%Q , : =! Cg b FR' : < %G "
" <!
:H F <!% -112(!
= ? )8 ' <,
:UA J7H] : p L)' < Q(! ,!
* HB' " - !%E -' $%F # 78 <, =
7A% E .
,! d | / Z
J 0 b = 3
:H e; : _! 7 ("
: ! C G'! ! -' lA < ;
, = ? Cg ,! ! :B5 !" " ! ! ; !7) %B. . %=!%= =! $ ! C E BHm .
$ ;
@ %9 !e;
C 1 ' :H e; : 06' " %F9 C! !e; @0~9 ;
$79 :B5 !" -' lA < ; 7A!
.
-( T :H e; MlX! d/ @$72X C! GA 2 m ,! -B.' : -' J : ! -' lA < ;
@7HA,
C 1 '
$79 :B5 !" Cg : ? D )' !%'! wUH' %lA ,! %RA ; 7A!
. C 2;
:A E b 1 " H= :
!%U(
35 _ = :BRE d m :
» C 1 ' w H' ;
g 8`X :A!7H'"% g -E7A, Z B9! : FH : - G %' :
B8! @7A7H'
: -B8" ! w H' ! " =! $ ? $%E -QHJ :
-2A %Q 7'g = C!
: = ,! -A =g
! . <! ! -A FJ B8! 7 7J b lA %;
X 2\' 3 -' -' T
! D` : 79 :H ',
< ;
, = M;!% ! -QHJ B8! "% m $"%E \ ! <!% b,}
. -' D` $"%E ! a %h ,! 7H
)=
3 :KLH' C!%6 : Cg D%B5E " <!
i%X 3 112(!
- \ ! ! #!7 7F ,! <7 7J ‡L= @
7 2A «
) 5T @$ !, 89 : 254
.(
( $3 ! 1( 2 ) -%.
%;
76' :A E -' < B8! "
:H ', 7A!
:UA J7H] <!% b,} < ; M;!% ! < %U;! - !%E
"g .
%lA 3 0 KB' -QB5 !"
7 P m Y * + ' ! % tA%B=! C!, = MA ? W
=! $79 7
"76' : < ;
_ 2X!
$,!7A! : 7 UA . Z : 1X $79 :H ', : 7 D%B5E <!
b,} < ;
7H] \ ! <!%
:UA J
"g M;!% ! - !%E .
M %6 : -L !%9 C!% ! : 1X < B8! < ;
_ 2X!
9 7 :H ', @ :UA J7H] F… <!% b,} < ; b!78! HP2; " - !%E
< ; UX <!% -UA J
M %6 ,!
%E !%8 B= ; .
%;
-' < B8! M %6 :A E
<7 7J < ; ", = 7A!
! A,! ' <!%
3 LH' :K C G'! #!7 7F ,! UX <!
, = % &m
) Ashly, 1995: 171
.(
:UA J7H]
dH !" 7 ! - !%E :A,! '
7HH Y M %6 % !% -= = B8!
< ; _ 2X!
79 Y
5A! C!% ! : 1X - %c < ; . % = " G %'g .
: :PAg 3(eH'
# "%+
-= = B8! < ;
-' -K1 ' M lH 7A" @ 9 K !
-' $7; .' s%B.' b!78! ˆ%h " :' A 9
. <q%A! H'!
M %6 7A" X%= = Z ,! -BRA < ; )=
3 < = ,! " $ ! d; ! C!% ! <q%A! w H'
%Q
@ <!% ! C!% ! <q%A! w H' : -=%B=
p% ' 0G.' C E7HH
=! $ % % .
!% H
-) Uh : -' %lA b,} !%9 : 7=
4%c C FJ " C!% ! !" -( ) a ! : 0 A <!%
M;!%
9
) Buzan & Waver, 1998: 145
.(
-' D` C B5 %X :]%E!
'! ! : , = 7X KB' ! 4%c C FJ 7H 3
C!% ! M %6 W
<% V
RA 2 8 % :
-2A J )8!" @ !&E A,! ' # "%+ k =!% -A FJ < ;
3 -A} h " #7'
C m
=! :B %E 0G9 C!%Q , -?% 6A! : C ! .
<q%A! - 2 _7' k =!%
» " :H '!
IH (" ; « 2F' %Q , -) Uh , E " RA M lX % ?‹ : :J C!% ! -
<q%A! < ; !,
-' C!% ! -BRA M %6 Π6( ! ,! " =!
7H 7 7F ! C FJ <q%A! H'! 7A!
. ,! $ RB=!
2 _7'
<q%A! - » IH (" ; " :H '!
« -'
%; : % V C!
?%] _`B?! :A E 3
:+%X
-' <q%A! < + K "
7.G d( ] : ! :?%] ! 0 <q%A! H'! 7A!
.
802
47
! "#
3
% & ' 1396
M %6 < B8! < ; :
-= = p!7;! <!%J! lH' :
-'
"
. M %6 < B8! < ;
o} 2)' :
= K) < !e ! C! HX -J ? =
: -' ! < B8! IHJ p7; " 7A"
9 !" # 5? M %6 ' . B8! : C G'! 7T : =!
. k =! ! %
M %6 e A C!% ! -BRA < ; :
C!% ! -'`=! < F2J B % ~ -= = p7; : 0 A lH'
=! :B %E # i .
%;
%9 b!78! :A E
= -B 1'7H] < ; 7 ! -A FJ B8! B?
( )' - " RB' !e ! " ; ", = ,! : 5A! - ;"% A % :U1c <!% -B 8 D`
3 # 78
-' $ RB=!
7HH .
Fit of the Verhulst function to U.S. crude oil extraction. Note that the peak occurred 1975-8:
7 7m <q%A! H'! %+ d !e ! # "%+ @IH (" ; " :H '! _7' k =!%
Y d !e !
<7J C FJ <q%A! d/ <q%A! w H' - 2
=! $79 % .
" $7HH 7 ( < ; .
p% ' 7HH Y -' -A FJ < ; !, ! ? @ RA
# \ <!% : 7H + K " :+%X RA
7 b \A! :A R H' -B2 8 k =!%
% E . p% ' " C E7HH 7 ( k =! ! % C E7HH
" C!%Q , -1'!% ‡L= ! <79 : " #`' ) F… D" -1) -112(!
-' M;!% 7)B' " C E A E -X 2BJ! < ;"% A HH
7
) " C ' C! G2;
@ 1393 : 245
.(
% _7' < HU'
» IH (" ; " :H '!
« " $7HH 7 ( < ; . 0' ) p% '
-' 2 " $7HH
Z Cg 0 ? -1'!% " -1' C!%Q , H ',
3 -' b \A! -G B 1m zq
% E . <!% _7' !
< Q(! := <q%A! - 2 \ !
» 6' + K - 2
« @
» - 2 :+%X 6' « "
» - 2
< B? = « |/.'
=! $79 .
%;
$79 _7' := ,! Z
! -' 0'! X ,! -G C!
W !&E% V
:B5; ( ) ' _ ) a ! < Q(! : 0 A <!% 4%c C FJ < %U;! = = % <!
5A! s%B.' b!78! ˆ%h 4 ] ] " C!% ! .
: -' %lA :A .A 7=
,! - ; : M;
C FJ , E " RA < ; !, -QB= m
= 3 -A FJ
ah H' w H' ! e %2 " <q%A! w H' - 2 " C % &m A7 7\ HP2; " B8! C79 _ 29 " :A ' " ? 0„' C FJ '! A 1c!
g
! J" K % .
%Q , Z : 1X -BRA M %6
7HA 2; $72X g
76B' " G %'
! C!% ! 7HA 2; - ; . RA < ; !, @ . Cg - %c C H'! @
1 <q%A!
3 -' 7 7F ! + K d/ :] " :+%X d/ :] C!%Q , 7H
. -= 21[
:B5;
< ; ", = ,! -G 7 ! <!
M
$"%E 7 7F <, =%V!
B8! % : 5A! - ;
-' lA <%E W 7A ! 7 .
%9 ,! -?%
_ = -B 1'7H] < ; < ;
15 - 2007 D`
% 7A
"76' < ;
:'7K' ! C!% ! : 1X < B8!
<!
<!%
-K1 -' lA b!78!
7HH . -( T 0G9 :
<7H H'! < ;
:KLH' <!
t 1?
|? 9 ,! -G 7 ! :A ' " ? " k - ;
:
"g 29 -' :
% 7A!
:KLH' H'! < ; ", = HP2; " <q%A! B8! !, 7A"
<!
W % V
!&Q . -?%
,!
$"%E < %U;! " < B8! < ; g
:H ', 7A ! D` G %' C G'! < ;
7X " :X, H' <% &m
7A "g M;!% ! C!%6 .
$"%E H]
-' ! - ; ( )' ,! -./ C!
3 7A m < B8! # 78
-' lA : p L)' < ;7H !%
<%E :
"g 29 .
_ = 2030 . <q%A! p% ' C!e ' < ;
-B)Hi 79 Y _ )' =g ‰%9 69
7i
_ = ,! %B.
2010 " 7;! ? :
79 = B' h 7
/ 2 9! 7;! ? <7i .
C!e ' !
65 : 79 7;! ? 0' 9 ! C FJ <q%A! p% ' 7i 54
_ = 7i 2010
0 8
=! :5 K' .
< G2; C ', = jX < ; . <q%A! p% ' C!e ' B8! < ;
:)= <
o U %K % ~ '! @ 7;! ? V C 9
79 7;! ? \ ! <q%A! % -FJ .
<q%A!
< ;
RA eQ J % &m7 7\
02T " -) Uh , E " $79 0KA"
, 7 ( <%B. IH= _ c
79 7;! ? $ RB=! ‰%
. @ ? = 2 8 :12J ,! -1 } : <q%A! 7U= % ~ !
< "g A
< ;
< !&QB= = " <q ( HG
%E 7;! ? # i = H' < ; .
" p% ' d !e !
804
47
! "#
3
% & ' 1396
< ; . #! !" d !e ! + K p% '
o} 2)' " =! $!%2; $7HH MF= ; . !
:H e;
-' d !e ! RA #! !" : u %' < ; 7
. " 7 ( 79 C!e ' : =! -( T !
+%X 3 ,! < 5 b ? RA " :B -("eA 7A" C FJ ah H'
-?%
$7A ' 7 ! ah H'
=!
) Baldwin, 2002: 68
.(
%lA -1i! C A * + ' 2;
3 b"
-H)
» 6' :+%X C KB' A _ )
«
=!
. 0' ) ,!
2 8 @ RA -A FJ < ; !, + K " :+%X -' 0G9 RA < ;
* + ' ! : % E
' ! + K FA BW
-' %V , = . : < ; . @ !, ;"% A ! J" 1X p% '
7HH Y RA
: : :B5 !" RA #! !" : #79 !
-' D` @7A -BRA ah H' " % ?‹ _%BH a %h ,! 7HH
%
$7HH 7 ( < ; . W
7A !&Q % V .
_ = 2030 Zm"! < jX!
70 79 7i +%X
3 RA
? Š B?! ? : ! b ? "7T -A FJ < ; !, $"%E ! MF= " ! 7H;!
45 7i
7;! ? .
Zm"! < jX! RA 7 ( C!e ' 12
"7T <, E # ) ' " :G. C 1 ' 4
:G. C 1 '
7;! ? d !e ! ,"
. Zm"! % c 7 ( 5
@ 7;! ? d !e ! ," :G. C 1 '
!% ,
d; @7 ( d !e ! ,! -./
% 7H;! ? C!%UJ ! -2 78 ' 7 ( .
0G9 H] <% E
- ; ", = ,! -./ 7 ! - !% ~
% -K1 :H ', :
b!78! C G'! <, = "76' < ;
C G'! ! C!% ! 7HA 2; - ; . ?% -' lA -' % &m
, = . :]%E!
» C ', = -112(!
<q%A!
« < %U;! % ?‹ <! !
@ =!
] IHJ : u %' Vg <7H !% H :KLH' < ;
! <!
C ' M '% #7' A
-2 H 7 .
\ BA 3 0G9 7A" !
# "%+ aK6 " <% E -(!%U ( rA -= = B8! < !&QB= = < ;
!
= .
< %G " H]
Z r " -1 16 ? =% ,
%lA 3 C G'! <, = "76' 12T
3 -' lA
79 7;! ? -A!%6 % c !%9 .
-G
•6 ,!
$"%E " ' "! s! -1i! < ; :l 6' < ;
%QH Y -' ! G %'g
# "%+ : u %' * + ' C!
C!%6 !%9 G %'g < %U;! < ;
5A!
.
$"%E ,! -?% :]%E!
< ;
<‹
:H ', ‹ RA ! < %U;! C \ ; \ ! < ;
: J"
$ "g
% H] : =! Cg )8!" @7A!
! 2A <7H - 7A!
W < %U;! < !&QB= = -A!7H] % V
G %'g : !&E J
) @C .A 1393 : 75
.(
\ BA 3 :A .A <7H !% H]
RE @b!%BT! k =!% - ;
"
s%B.' w H' " 0 KB' s @ E
=! $ $!%2; C!% ! .
# "%+
4 \ ! _!%U ( rA -= = B8! < !&QB= = ; < ;
-' : 7H
# 78 : € e < ; Ž ! T _%BH " C!%Q , _%BH @w H' _%BH -1i! wJ%' C! HX
$%F -A FJ B8! % 7' <!% b,} < ; ", = ,!
7A% Q .
% H]
! ( 8 @<7H
%lA 3
: b = '
»
< B? = - 2 «
-' U
9 . : %lA U < ; Q(! -B ; H] C!,! %m
=!% ! Ž ! T k
3L ! @ !, -' U < %U;! !eE " <%B.' 7HH
(Barzegar, 2014: 2)
.
H]
< %G "
e %2
@ 1 8 " :+%X 7) % p L)A!
p7; . <% &m W
! 7 .
( ) Zm"! < ; H ',
3 2 8 _%BH p7; -G e < ; !, _%BH e A RA < ;
2;
:H ', -' - , ! 9
. :PAg k =!%
@M BRE 79 C!e ' +%X
3 < + K 79 b ? RA
- i " !7A K L' Cg :
< " H " + K " :+%X % 7' Z2 : )=
3
<q%A!
< ;
d m k =!% eQ J -H
<q%A! - 2 @7 A :'! ! ; U=
2 8 7 79 d !e ! " RA < ;
W
< B8! 79 % Cg k G)' % V 79 7;! ?
.
-' + K " :+%X < j -QH; 2; b7X !%9 ! : C!
w2J : 7 = <7H
1 8 C!% ! 7HA 2; < . < B? = < ; :
:A E d !e ! <!
:B " C!e ' : =!
J 3
C G'!
<% &m 12T 3 -' "76' ! < !%L+!% c !%9 b lA , =
. : < !%~J % ~ ,! % c
" :+%X : <q%A! < + K
W -G B 1m zq #!% V C 9
!" " = = " :B9! -FJ
1 8 -1) !%9 @ =! $ ! % ~ ! ; . -J ? w H' _%BH < B? = < ;
" <q%A!
:H F p7; < ; . 1 8 <, = :
:A E #!7 7F b \A! C G'! : :B %E 0G9 <!
=! $ ! d; ! -' lA
) @ (%UH8 1389 : 124
.(
% !
! " :B d !e ! RA D"% ,! -9 A < B8! < ;7'g : C!% ! < ;, A @7H
:H ', :\ BA
$ 1J aK6 < ; M;!% < %U;! M5 2E!%m ,! - ;
9 7
=! $ . -= 21[ K '
:B5;
%; : =! -L !%9 : p L)' -= = B8! -(!%U ( rA D%QA <!
C!%Q , ,! Z
-' D`
0 A < B8! !, ' %„ !7T : 7HH A 9
7 . 7H', A -A FJ B8! : \Ag ,!
" C!% ! RA #! i W
% C!% ! -1?! !, < \ < ;, A '
! -A FJ # \ 7H
=!
<!% e A C!% ! @%Q < = ,! "
W -X 2BJ! -E7A, ' < B8! w H' :
! , A :H ', @ < ;
- FA "
:B5; -= 21[ <, = 4 HBJ! <!
7;! ? % &m A .
* 45 ("
$* 6& 78 $
% & '() *) ( ! ( 9
$
-= = B8!
:A .A -112(!
-' G)H' ! C!%6 % 7' -1i! < ; , =
. C!%6 % 7'
< G2; < Q(! " -= 21[ ,! -1G9 )8!" ! -A FJ = = -B .'
: u %' < ;
-' 0G9 w H' <!% 8 7;
. 7 R= ‚ w' J 7H=
@ -H)
%U;!
#} ! -1' H'!
76B' Y M lH C BH 1 C! " : G %'g 9
7 -A FJ B8! < ; ", = % "
7 W @ 9!
C HP2;
% UV @ ; !, d .E ,! G %'g 2T
$ %B5E b!78! " -( ' # -A FJ B8! %
7 W
$79
(World Bank, 2015)
.
806
47
! "#
3
% & ' 1396
% : =! -) Uh
! :B5; #!% !&' : p L)' 7H -' Cg ,! 0i T t BA " <!
t BA 5A!
% %VS'
<
! , T Y B8! < !&QB= = % -HBU' D%QA '! @7H \ ! C!% ! < B8!
: _!%U ( rA -= = :A .A <! !
-= = B8! < ; -112(!
=!
- !7;! H] aK6 @
$%h /'%m " ! 9 7;! ? <!
. : h % _!%U ( rA -= = B8! < !&QB= = @-1
< B8! Z5 ,! 4 HBJ! # "%+
W
! 7 . : 7A KBX! ! % - G %'g # ' K' :]%E!
f ; G %'g
! - `Bz! :A E :B5; a ! ,! 0i T t BA @ 9! 7;! /A C!%
D%QA <!
< G2; d !e ! : p L)' _!%U ( rA -= = B8! < !&QB= = < ; FA C!% ! < ;
79 7;! ? -112(!
) Cooper, 2005: 74
.(
0 16 -1i! 6' _!%U ( rA -= = B8! < !&QB= =
@
|? 9 % J" -1i! < ;
= C 5A!
B8! " =
=! 012(!
. lBA! @-9%QA H] k =!%
; ; . # U( L' "
#!% !&' 7A" : -A!%Q , -' 2 :12J ,!
1 + 5 @7HB9! .' 1c!
" #! lBA!
:B=! ? , T ! $79 \ ! a ! ,! <%B. < ; Y
<% Q m $ ! !%8 ? Z 21[ < ; .
QB= = : \Ag ,!
LKA % -HBU' _!%U ( rA -= = B8! < !&
3 :A ] -( ) - B= <!% -A,
%„ !7T : H eE
3 -) Uh @ =! G2' :
-' %lA 1L' -' 2 : C!%Q , : 7=
-H;‹ < ;
7A .A 0 A ? .
%; @< B8! < !&QB= = D%QA " $ E7 :6( ' :A E
! <!
-' C!
: (eH' 3
$!
0T
:H F " a 8 <% Q m <!% <!
1r5' 3 -K1 "76' w H' | /
% . :A E C 2; : : <!
-' !, !,g # \ C G'!
: C!
$!
w H' <, =%„ !7T <!% :( U' " :6( ' 0T
7 7F ,! !&E " < B8!
< ; 0 A Z 9 Ag 9
7 : =! -) Uh @ , T
Y = = 012(!
Q , e A -' C!%
C G'! w H' %„ !7T : 7HA!
0 A :6( ' < j % &m 9
7A . H]
, T : =! Cg < H)' : < %G "
Y 7A" < %U;! H'! " = = ,! -./ B8!
:B5; #!% !&' -' 4 56' <!
9 .
# !
$ RB=! ' ,!
7 ! < F2J = " -J ? = = C! !eE < =
-./
C!% ! -= = C , 7 7J )8!" ,!
% -K1 . @-J ? = = " -= = C ,
% 7;! ? \ ! ! ? Š ? < ' k G)A!
. 7 ! -J ? = = " -= = C ,
# "%+ " -12X = = @-'`X! = = k G)A!
w H' 'W <!% . Z < %U;! < ;
5A! -1' .
:B5; C!%6 : -L !%9 $"%E < ; . " C!% ! !" <!
1 + 5 $79 \ !
-' @ =!
:B5; ‰ KT * + ' C!
K ! ' <!
,! -./ ! s%B.' 02X 3' A% " Aq 3' A
$y ! -A T" (" -J ? = = < ; :
"g 29 .
< %G " H]
dG2.
< ;
= = b =%' :lT`' 012(!
-' 9 . dG2.
; J"
: % 6H' ; '
% C 9 @
e A -F .' -' 2X # i ?
! 7A . 7HH 7 ( < ; . Y
<% E!% -= = !7B8! ,! : RA
7A ! ?%
@ 1c!
% E!% _%BH " :L1= : 0 2
7A ! . ,! -./ ; . ! 0 ( 2; :
<!% ! ? 7'g )=
3 , T Y @-J ? = = ‹ RA :
-' 7A% E . :
%Q # UX
@
H]
7H !%
$%F p7; <
- A! ,! <% E
= = <!%J! <!% ; < ;
' S %V < j
< %U;!
-' b \A!
% E
) Bech, 2012: 73
.(
» -A ', -1?! B? = (" : : 2BX! ,! D!
% !% - Q/= m b7X " !7B8! @ RA
: } # U( L' H @79 ! ?% * 2BJ! < ;
: p L)' e A -J ? = = B " d
$%F <% E " _ G ! < ; Q(! ,!
:1 K' -' :A J 9
. RB=! - A! : =! G2' :L1=
Y
b!78! ,! :H F
; 79 -GB' k%B= !e ! "
. b!78! !
; -' ! G2 <!% -9` C!
5A! = "% C!%Q , {
? < K <!% : -A!%Q , -' :B5 !" = !% p%h :
7A 9 .
$"`X -' -J ? = = _%BH Cg %
$ 9 " M ; R' k =!% 7A!
9 _ 2X! <% 5R < ; .
:KLH' # 78 ,! :A ' " ? : -A!%Q , -' ! ?% <!
7A 9
@ " :L1= _ G9! -' 2 ,!
-' $%F 6' _%BH 7A% E
«
) Dahl, 1997: 36
.(
% H]
! <7H : =! Cg %QA
» * 2J! C!7K Y
@4 1L' %'! Z :]
F… : 5
dG2.
%\H' 9 . -' <" -A ', %'! ! %Q p%h : 7H < . m p%h Z : 7;
("! 7 -E7A, %Q p%h : =! " ! % p%h Z :GH ! @7H K ! ' "! < ;
-' 7 7F ! "!
7H . dG2. H]
; <
$%J .' @ ;!&' C ' # `B?! ,! :B= ?% <e 'g
IH;%
C FJ @ ; -H
D, ! @ ;
$ 9 " ;
=! -E7A, < ; .
$7 7m H] 1c!
0 ( " : m - ;
dG2. -1i!
7HB5; ; .
$7 7m ! B? =% ;
3 -X 2BJ!
!
$"%E @ !% ! : 7A (" " ;
,! @ ;
b lA < ;
! 2A " • %) <!% 2A : %\ : C
-' $ RB=! C . ; 7HH
«
) Bennett, 2014:
(115
. C!% ! 7HA 2; - ; . < %U;! < !&QB= = _!%U ( rA B8! 2;!
: :A E <!
%; : =! F.'
< %U;! < !&QB= = @< B8! M %6 :A E -' !%8 % VW 6 !
7;
.
A% -1i! 6' : C!% ! 7HA 2; - ; . :'
! ? < %U;! < !&QB= = " < B8! <e
-' M lH RA < ;7'g k =!%
7'g : -L !%9 @7HH C 9
:A .A @7 d;
,! - ;
" < B8! 7'g U2 " w H' U2 :
-' "
7A 9 . < !&QB= = < ; Q(! % ~
-' ! ; . ! -B H'! " < %U;!
,! -) C!
( )' 3 -(!%U ( rA ; < B8!
5A!
. :6( ' '
=! G2 _!%U ( rA < B8! < !&QB= = : u %' < ; ", = a %h ,!
9 0i T .
:B5; -= 21[
<!
H ', 3 ! :6( ' :
"g J"
. : - ! " M ; R' ,! < 5
808
47
! "#
3
% & ' 1396
:B5; -= 21[ 7A" _ r5' # ' K' ˆ%L' <!
-' HH 7
@ :A .A : u %' < ;
» * 2J!
-K ! «
! -QH; 2; -' 2X < !&QB= = .
" -= = $ E7 :
!%Q12X $ E7 $y "
/.' 3 = = :
-= 21[ 7A" a ! * 2J! < , F .' @# HG2' %H; C! HX
:B5;
$"%E < ; . " C!% ! <!
1 + 5
! . 2B= = %H; -9%QA H] k =!%
" C! !7
'
=! :BRFA :
$"%E !7; 7H', A C! !72B= = :GAg _"!
w+ ' ,! !&E <!% ;
<% E < ;
0 RH' : :6( ' < = o BU5A <!
7A !7 m . < !% ! H] @%Q < = ,!
7 # X!7 ! 7HA! B
: - !7;! <!% ! -= = o!%; …
-B9g % &m A
@ =!
: 7A "g J"
(Khajehpour, 2014: 4)
.
< B8! " -J ? = = C! !eE @-' 2X < !&QB= = 7A"
@ 02X < !,g
:2;
? < %U;! p!7;! aK6 <!% :UA J 7A !7A
. : -J ? = = #! GB ! <% E
< ;7H !% : p L)' X
<
, =
<
-L !%9 !"
C G'!
: 7;! ? % &m
$"`X
! ! % Y
= C! !eE :A .A @-1?! =
:H ', " ; = = < j < %U;! 0' ) < Q(! ,! - ;
79 :B9! J" e A 012(!
. D`
:2;
UA J 3 :KLH' %Q , Z : :J C"7 <!
0G9
<7H 6' # 78 < ; :KLH'
1L' t BA : -A FJ C!%Q , dH < ;7H !% " <!
-
%\H' 9 7;! /A 7
) " C ' 2;
C! G @ 1393 : 275
.(
:. ; + , ! ) -%. $* /0% *) ( < $"
08!7T # "%+ % _!%U ( rA -= = B8!
#!7 7F <, = W
! 7 . <%Q , %;
1c!
-' D`
:H ', 7H :H F < ;
78 <, = d
: < %U;! 0' ) a %h ,! !
"g J"
.
B8! < !&QB= = , B'! ,! -?% _!%U ( rA -= =
< ; -' 4%c C FJ : $79 LX!
7A!
:H ', ! $7H g #!7 7F d; <!% b,} < ; :
"g J"
.
$"%E -L !%9 H]
< ;
:l 6' :X 2\' " G %'g
< ; 0 z!%=!
,! 9! 7H;! ? <%B2 D` 6'
b!78! " -2J F < ; ", =
< ; H'! %m 3
$%F C!% ! : 1X -' lA 7A 9 7H'
) Ackerman, 2012:
(75
. -' 4 56' - `KX C!%Q , ; . : \Ag ,!
: u %' < ; ", = ,! @7A 9
» :H e;
$7 "
« -' $%F 7A% E . -' ! $7 " :H e; %G "
%', C!
Y : 5A! - ; Q(!
L)' _!%U ( rA -= = B8! < !&QB= = 7;! ? :\ BA : p
.
% !
! @7H
_!%U ( rA -= = B8! < !&QB= = H ',
3 0G9 dH <% E : ! - ;
-' J"
: "g
: p L)'
»
$ F dH < ; Q(!
1« 7;! ? .
b!78! b \A! C G'! -L !%9 H]
< ;
7;! ? d; C!% ! : 1X -2J F .
1. Pump-priming model
= B8! < !&QB= = _7'
$e QA! : =! Cg : p L)' _!%U ( rA -=
-2J F < ;
% - +!
! -K ! 7H
! -' :B? H9 _ K)'% c !7B ! : 9
@ -' : J 7H
. < ; Q(!
$%F 7H', A < %U;! dH < B=! Z 21[ dH < ; Q(! " Z !% " 7X! 8 ,! <% E
7;! ? 8 C!%Q , <, =7X KB' .
C!% ! -J ? = = < ;7A" -L !%9 H]
< G2; dH 7H', A :UA J7H] a %h ,! :A J
7;! ? < %U;! - !%E .
: -A! !eE
< %U;! " -B H'! @-J ? = = p!7;! aK6 Z !% " < Q(! ,!
-' $%F D` @7A% E
7H;! ?
% ! -'`=! < F2J Z 21[ < ;7A"
$7X 8 @-A A 8 M ; R' k =!%
" !%E
:A} r5' !%J! " U 7HH
) Aronoff, 2014: 74
.(
MF' ,! -G -' ! _!%U ( rA -= = B8! < !&QB= = : u %' # X + ' %
C!
" -./ %V! : u %' # X + ' u U !
! 0 16 <7'
% . -= = B8! < !&QB= =
_!%U ( rA
%
! 0 "g " a ! 7H 2015
: .'
»
% } -H6H' «
< B8! < !&QB= =
08!7T 5 <!% : ‹ J \ ! < H)' : : =!
-' -A} h C ', -\ 7 < ; 79
.
$ 1J < %G " H]
-' C .A ! < B8! < !&QB= = ,! - ; 0' X ! 08!7T = : 7;
C!%6 -1i!
; - 7HA 2;
-' b "
7A!
. -K ! * 2J! -L !%9 H]
:H ', @_!%U ( rA -= = B8! < !&QB= = 7 7F d; < ;
< ; 4 HBJ!
$7H g ! % &m A
:
"g 7;! ? J"
.
|? 9 :B5; -= 21[ 7A" _!%U ( rA -= = B8! < !&QB= = -1i! < ; C!% ! <!
# "%+ ,! -./
U;! < ; 6' -'`=! < F2J < % .8 H'%m
3 -' -K1 -B H'!
9 . ,!
7 ! -J ? = = - , ! : \Ag
! -J ? = = @ 5A! 02X _`KB=! " <7'
$, T : - ; . < ;
! : " < %U;! - !%J! #`G.' 02X _`KB=! " <7' "
B5;
7H @ 1c!
.E% )+"
!%8 <% &m -'
7A% E . :B5; a ! < !&QB= = k =!% <!
.E% < ;7A" : =! - ; ", = : p L)' _!%U ( rA -= = B8!
_%BH ! % &m H
7 .
-Ey " ,! -G ,! >"%? 7 ! C!% ! M %6 _%BH < B8! < !&QB= = -1i! < ;
5A! < %U;! <!"eA!
. :B5; -= 21[
L)' 7H !% " <!
: p ' A%
3 s%B.' b!78! w' J
! -B )+" H]
:
"g J"
. $!%2; % ~ -L !%9 C!% ! -J ? = = < ;7A"
9 $7 d/ : =!
C 9 % G %'g < %U;! C! !7' ', " - !%J! C! !eE ,! -FJ
M %6 " F' = = b"!7 # "%+
7A ! 7 W < B8! < ; .
H]
M %6
; - ! -2A C!
A .A 3 C!%Q , D%QA -BU„' '
S %V #! GB ! " , cg < ;7A" : U5A -A FJ = =
-K1 -A T" 5T < %U;!
%
(Juneau & Razavi, 2014: 18)
.
