Policy Analysis of Intended Nationally Determined Contribution (INDC) Under the Paris Agreement for
the Electricity Industry
Reza Akhbari
PhD candidate of international economics, University of Shahid Bahonar, Kerman, Iran
Alireza Shakibaei1
Associate Professor, Department of Economy, University of Shahid Bahonar, Kerman, Iran
Mehdi Nejati
Assistant Professor, Department of Economy, University of Shahid Bahonar, Kerman, Iran
(Received: 2021/04/23 -Accepted: 2021/09/22)
Abstract
The lack of a comprehensive model in the electricity industry for the quantitative analysis of the policy consequences adopted in the superior documents of this industry has made it difficult to evaluate policies. In this study, a dynamic general equilibrium model designed with the focus on the electricity industry & considering the Intended Nationally Determined Contribution (INDC) program as an superior document, the efficiency of strategies such as Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) & energy price increment - as an alternative strategy- to achieve the targeted amount of carbon were measured. The results showed that although FDI & rising energy prices can not achieve the goals, but it has positive effects on the output value of the industrial sector & the electricity industry particularly. Finally, in order to achieve the goal of emissions reduction & reducing the rebound effects of improving energy efficiency in the electricity sector, it is recommended that electricity prices be increased significantly for the private household.
Keywords
Policy Analysis, Dynamic General Equilibrium, Paris Agreement, Electricity Industry, Rebound ffect.
Copyright © 2022 The Authors. Published by Faculty of Law & Political Science, University of Tehran.
This Work Is licensed under a CreativeCommons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International (CC BY-NC 4.0)
1- Corresponding Author’s Email: [email protected]
) + B ! "
7 ) 4 B 4 B 7 , 1400 # DJK B 70 - 49
, - .*/ ) 0 12 $ ,)3 4 & (5
# () 6(5
O0 R
" 6 &C 0 8 W T 8 6 8 H
7 " 6
1 O (4 R
1
0 W T
7 " 6 " 6 &C
. 8* 2-
" 6 &C 0 W T 7 " 6
: )
3 / 2 / 1400 - :
31 / 6 / 1400 (
,; 1; $ 1# – ) A1 , { ,\ G -& b ! ;&M & ; -& % „ 0 $
,; 1; 4- 5 % h ,\ G
& % - %& $ , - # @& \ \ * -&.
,)- 2 ' J s { ,\ G
) r! , -& ) ;&M ; (INDC
,; 1; T- ) % h / a - #
; A1QW 4 $ E , 1W : (! ' - B `1 < - "O
- :1# ) - 2 … *; 1 ;& - i - ( ,; 1;
% bW ' : ; &- -& % 1
ˆ .,;
; C O & & 2 :1# (1 - B `1 < - "O
E , 1W : (! ' -& % 1
# -& { ,\ G [ B - s ' ,\ G :0 ; ]4- QX F d &4 ; r - ~ $ 1G # -& .&- &
' - 2 :$ ) ~ $ 1 ;& & % - ) & Q 4 % 2O4 F d A1
.& % & & : (! G /B - B - & \ F- G { , 1W $ O' 1 :0 -& E
:
,; 1; A1 . 2O4 d { ,\ G a - # r! # @& \
1- Email: [email protected]
,) &
h6
& / W $ 1# 4- , ! ,; 1;
{ ,\ G ?Q $
$ R52 - ;&M & ; ?; % 11\ 1< -& ,) J & Q21# I ' &4 ;
@R B ,\ G ;&M & ; -& v- ~ $ 1 ;& % ' $ r! .& % 2) E b … s ' a - #
- 2 ,\ G ;&M & ; 4
f < { % & / W $ 1# ;- , b J s F-' + ) & %
,; 1; 4
1 - & ; 4 P ) $ A „ $ - " ; 1; F 1 & -& . )
% 4 5 ) &- & & ' ,; 1; B C ,
% B
]'- ,; 1; ;- -& $ f < $
hJ G ?; .& % & \ i
,; % bW ' & ; &- - " ; 1; T ! t 2 (Malek Mohammadi,
2015) 4- ,; 1; ,; 1; ' - ) - ;& J :% ,; 1; B C @ -& .
; 1;
g \ ,; 1; # ' ,; 1; 11y , - ) - ;& @ X O .& %
-& =& % g \ a - # r! ; - -& ,)- 2 1 - " ; 1;
T ! 4 P- C J -& `$ ' ' J -& `$ ,; 1; A1 ' 4- B C F- G ' .& "#
q + - )" B C 4 J '& -& ,; 1; A1 1 (
4 $ 1# ,! -&
]'- 4 ' J -& .&& O % & ; 4 ; 1Q% A % $
4 a# ' P- C J -& ) J -& & % 1 ; J $ 1# ,; 1; 4 :1#
,; 1; 4- % F- G 1 $ 1# S ;
\ * ~ $ .& "#
,; 1; 4-
) ,)- 2 $
g \ { ,\ G a - # r! A „ (INDC
4' ,m1$ -& h / 4 4 ) ,; )„ P4M ' % @ ; :% &' J1
2 T % 1# Rs &-"O ; > 4 5 .,; 2
,; 1;
T $ 1# 4 $ & ; 4 ' %"O ' J 4 -& & $ \ * -& ! O F- G ,; 1; A1 2 2 b!- , -& - " ; 1;
. ;- - % ' ,; 1; -& & J F &
, ! ' ,<1 -& a - #
A 4 ; `1 W F 11y 1< ) SR 1 5 ) 2
UNFCCC 1€ a - # -& (
- 2) 1 '
- 2 ;- G r! F ~ $ . 1;- 4 + J $
4 O 0 O $
<
E b ~ / ;- G r s 4 ,B ; 4 O ' ,
-& - 1# .,; % g \ 22
@ ; A -'T 2016
E @' .& ) k &R1
@ ; 2020 4 cT @ ; &R1 ' 1# -& f / $
) ,)- 2 INDC3
(
1 - < -&
20 / 8 / 1394 - % . 1;- h / 4' Fn1$
112411 / F 52513
2 - United Nation Framework Convention on Climate Change 3 - Intended Nationally Determined Contribution
a - # ! k 4 :1# . % 11\ - 2) $ f / j - -&INDC
15 1394
@& \ ) 7 Q ) 2015 4 ; `1 W 11y 1< ) ' h / 4' ,m1$ ?; ( &R1
@ ; 4 4' ,m1$ / S ; . % @ ;- A 2020
&R1
Q ;& # ' 4 cT 2030
& &R1 -& R; - .
A
0 O $4 O A) - 2 :$ ) -& ,)- 2 - & B - 2 (1 ) 5% % & 4
4 # -&
4 ) # @ ; ,Q< G-&
2010 : (! -& . :$ ) (
:0 -& - )
~ / g 0 $
,B ; ( 1 x $ ' )
@ \ $ ) #
M ` ; ) % )„ 4' ,m1$ f / ; -& .,; % 1)n \1Qs 4 O 4 :1 ) - 2 -& E :0 90
:$ ) -& :0 M A1< # T bQ ' ( G-&
-& .,; - 2) $ O' 1 5Q% - : (! ~ *\ -' ! $4 1 - 2 :$ ) ~ $ @ /J
4 &' J 4 1 - 2 -& G-&
5 / 17 -M& &- 1 1
; :1# - "O :$ ) \ z' 2 :$ )) A) [ /B -& `W- .,; % 1
8 “ (z' 2 1c :$ ) $ - 2 G-&
5 / 52 -& .,; % &-'T -M& &- 1 1
C > 1 ) - 2 :$ ) -& E - ) & Q ‚ - # : .&- & & ' :
) &- & - W (1 F \ * 1 n &- Sharekian & Lotfalipour, 2016
-& ( & Q INDC
2 11\ T 1 - % … * - 2 :$ ) - i { 1 -& E - ) Q .,;
2O4 d & ' < - ) : (! -&
) C & % bW ' &- 1
) &4 ; X B - 2 :$ ) -& - - ) & Q 4 AG J ,QX d Wei & Liu, 2017; Koesler
et al, 2016; Lu et al, 2017 1Q% > ) .(
# @& \ f C- C -& 4 ;
1#
,; 1;
; : (! *; ' { 1 -& - ) : (! $ - "O
,\ G g 0 & \ ) b J s F-' + .& ) 4- 4 :1# - :0 F s Q - ' { 1Q% ' % A % - & / W g 0 $
-& - " ; 1; 4 ;
@ ; @ s -& ' ,\ G $
1 &4 ; 5 – ) F- G - &
J s .& %
@ 4 a# @& \ ' 1 ' @& \ 1 $ 1y ,) J 1< ; % 5 # F- G `$ ! - ‡ % T &- ' h W -& ' ,; 1;
& , , -& ' ) ( -
,\ G -& - " ; 1; ' ~ $ 1 ;& '- ;- . % $ B {
) - 2 :$ ) 4 (INDC
15 % J s $ - ; ˆ % ! O i -& ;
F 4 4 -& - 2 :$ ) , { ! F 1+ .& % A1
j; # @ Q & r1 4 @ ƒ; '& O
:,;
1 - Rebound Effect
0 1 -
; T :1# - "O
; h W -& ' ;&M & ; -& % 1 - "O
) - B `1 <
% % & $ (1 - E - ) & Q & B @ Q &
:$ ) 4 8 ) - 2 G-&
p& %
0 2 -
; # -&
B `1 < - "O :1# (1 @& \ -
; -& % 1 ' &
11y C E - ) & Q ( ; 1; E , 1W : (!
-&
|- { ~ / (1 ' { ,\ G ' A) - s ,\ G :0 &'(! ]4- GDP p $&
E - ) 1dn 1# i Q € - 4 a# & -&
2O4 d P ' - 2
,< 4 ' & / W $ 1# ;- 1 4 -& ! O F- G F \ * -' & Q *1
]'- :0 -& .,; % B & # - ) @& \ ' 2O4 d Q; ; %
- ; ˆ # J s , -& ' % ! \ { ,\ G , - # :0 -&
1G ' ˆ
j; # ' A1 ,\ G -& E - ) & Q $ 1# ; 1; $
€ - r1 FM ƒ;
.& %
E
@ ) 4 ) E - ) : (! r1 -&
; $ ' - B `1 < - "O
'- E , 1W : (!
) - 2 ,1\+' $&
& / W h0 $ 1y B '
-& % )„ ~ $ , ; ,) J 1< 4- - i A1 INDC
- i .& %
; T z Q - ' E - ) z i Q * - aŒ; ' % € - - "O
& & t1+ E - ) ' E , 1W 1 * @ \ - s E - ) .& %
{Rs E & J ' > 4 & ; % 1 ; - ' & %
.B %
4 $
& % 1O )
Patterson, 1996: 377
E - ) & / W ` -& .(
IM \ 4 E -'
1O .& % -' ,<1 < ' E & E
& ; 5 ' ; ' - ) ' 1 A1QW 4 $
T -' $ - "O 1dn E -'
.,;
> 4 % 1 ! + ; E - ) -'
F Qd Ž ! % ! + E & J ' g \ &- ;
& % )
Wei & Liu, 2017: 2 .(
; [ B - s 1% ' FMT- ( h W -& ' T - - i E - ) -& - "O
-
M - ) FMT 1 # E ~ / %"O 2 1 t*;
; 1 x $ .& %
! - "O ' A J &M ! A1QW 4 F B ' $M ) & + {
: (! $ %' ! F B ' A & / W '
; *; ' -& - "O
%- E - ) )
Wu et al, 2019
4 - ) & Q 1# 2O4 d .(
) & % : (! J ' - ) : (! - 4 ) 2$ ) E - ) & Q
F (1 1O- 5 F \!& : (! ,1! ‰ : (! *; ' E r * - ~ / -&
) & % $ ! / Giraudet et al, 2012: 426-427
1 - ) : (! .( E )
T ! -& ) :$ ) E F B 1 A) ($ ) \ &- & 4 1 1
.
& F B - 21 + - 2! ' ! :$ ) E F B , 1W 1 -&
; % 2O4 d + -& : (! . ) ' & %
F d 4 B
- ) & Q E ~ / :$ ) ' ) - 2 :$ ) A1QW 4 –
- ) X B - Lee et al,
(2020 .
) :bQ . & / W 2O4 d `<1 5 -1 A5%
Wei & Liu, 2017: 4
(.
O & 4 2O4 d >15 F' … *; g 0 $
QW F \ * -' .& %
4 ) Broberg et al, 2015
2 ( ;& ) $&
( ;- & \ $
) 1 ' ' .&- & & ' d ' `1 < 1c ' `1 < F d 2O4 d >15 (2017
T d '& 4 \ € - :0 $ z E ~ / -& F 11y - $
(- B :0 [ B - s ) :0 ; 1dn u1$ ) & ) ?Q
, 1W ' $ $
& / W R) 2O4 d 1 x $ .&- $- 4 &
& ) ! \ d -1
-& )
* t*;
, 1W -& F 11y ' 20 1 $ 1# A1 &
*; ' - 4 $
'- E - ) & Q ) @'M ' ‚ E g \ .,; & &
R) 2O4 d (2017
% A \ $- 4 5 T 4 a# ' A) E + E - ) -& : (! d & / W @& \ I & ' 4 - ;-
1O -& % g \ $ - ; . )
d x T r1 - W - % &- 2O4
) 1 ' ' g \ & 1O ‚ E ' (2017
) @'M '
> &( (2017 $M ) 1 :0 ' $ O' 1 :0 t*; -& d 4 ,;
1 - Macroeconomic Rebound Effect
A1 & / W A) ' & Q A W a5 &- -& .& %
-& F 11y E - ) A \
& \ F \ * E , 1W T 4 ) ! O F- G
$ 1O ' O- &
) ) 1 $ ' 1O (1995 ) 1 $ (2002
) - 5 $ ' &T ' (2006 .& ) - % (2010
2 ' & & - W i E + - E , 1W F d F \ * -& $&
-'&
,;M E , 1W ) $ E 5 h/ *; ' E - )
4' E $
E - ) ' E , 1W 1 , `$ z Q - .,; ! : (! - (O- ) - !- 11y ' ($ :$ ) A1 &
) 1 ; 4 `$ $ & E 4 )
- &
)
-& `$ ' ,; $ 2 A W ) ~ / , ;
E F B 4 ) .&
- i S ; . : (! E - ) E , 1W ,QX ‡ % &'-
G *+ = 7
2 B & F \ * -' @& \ u1$ ) ) $&
C ' < C–
# - ,; 1; - dT 4- ~ $ $
,\ G , - 1 -& ' { ,\ G ?Q
$ q & - ) - B F \ * ;- ) J -& 2 J s # ' < CGE
1#
,; 1; @ $ 1# 4- ' ( - - 5%T - { ,\ G ?Q $
w ) B & F \ * & -& .&4 ; h W -& - T $ 1# ' E - ) & Q
:0 -& ' 2O4 d
& & - W ;- &- & / W g 0 $ -'
aŒ; ' & %
€ - r1 q + ?Q - B F \ * 4 % .&& O
`1$ ' ) O& 4 (2011
5 E - ) : (! 5 - % Q 4
$- ( 4 E 5 ,! 21# $
- % ) - 2 :$ ) ' E ~ / :$ ) G ?Q 2O4 d &'-
-& . & & - W &-'T &- - ) - 2 ' - B ~ / E - ) & Q ' E 5 ,! 21# % Ž ! \ * ,; 4
1Q% 4 & ; ' - ; ; s ' 4 ;
(1 ) E - ) : (!
20 30 ' 40 I Q + b ' ( G-&
2O4 d @T
2 ˆ .,; % &-'T I Q 2O4 d $&
98 & Q ) \ ,; G-&
- 2 :$ ) €( - 1< d - ) - ) : (! ) 4 ' &- & E + '
! { M - 1< $ | ' 1 1 ; .,% & - 2O4 d % >C ) - i
) - 5 $ & Q F d 4- 4 1 # @& \ 4 & ; (2017
,B ; - ) G -& 1<! $
E b B & #
1Q% . -'& 4 ;
60 ' ;
(1 - ) & Q - ; '& -&
1 / 3 E b G G-&
:0 '
$
2 ˆ .,; % P ,B ; - ) & Q ) $&
E b G -& 1<! $
:$ ) ' 2O4 F d &
@' - ; -& 1<! ,B ; + J -& & %
,B ; - ) & Q )
@ ; -& 2O4 F d & P'& - ; -& 1<! $ $
,<0 ,B ; + ' & %
: (! F -& 1<! $ ' 1 1 ; .
) - 5 $ A W @& \ @ > ) (2018
- ) & Q F d 4- Q;
,B ; E b G -& E & ' { 1<! $ T . B & #
1Q% $ '& 4 ;
:0 - ) & Q - ; E b G ' $
- ) & Q # -& ) & & 2
,B ; { 2O4 F d E & ' 1<! $
iJR A W AX E b G -&
; ; F ( ! ' 1 1% FM / - ) & Q 4 a# F d ) - s & %
E b G h1
63 84 ' 72 &- -& & ' & G-&
:0 4 ,; F- Q h1 $ 79
94 ' 92 . G-&
) - 5 $ ' \1!- € - (2019
,1 \! -& T Q; ' 2O4 F d ( i 4 & ; g 0 $
& & ' Q; A W @& \ @ ; - <J a $
1390 d & & 2
,B ; ' { - ) G-& > : (! 2O4 $
h1 1<!
1 / 90 ' 8 / 72
& & A152 - - B v- 0 4 1 # ` ; E ($ 5 1 x $ .,; G-&
2O4 F d &- @ Q & - B ; 4 - & 4 : ) ' - ) : (! 1 -& ' 1 I .,; % &-'T &' J 1 $ -& (1 ; ; 1O
& M , ) %
&' E ~ / :$ ) - ) : (! ,; 1; - "O d 2O4 F d .& %
) - 5 $ ' ‘ ' & / W 4 ,\ G :0 -& A) 2O4 d 4 4- - i (2015
: (! A % - ; ; ' J s Q; A W @& \ > € ; 5
-& G-&
: (! F B ' $M ) ) 1 b G P -& E - ) 5
E - ) -& G-&
: (! ' - J $ O' 1 ' 4 O { b G ( b G -&
5 - ) -& G-&
% b G "c ) ,\ G \ $ &-'T ! \ A1QW 4 E b G -& E 1 1
1Q% - F ( ! ' &M ! $T & Q # -& ) & & 2 ˆ . & ) 4 ;
5 - ) G-&
&' -& 2O4 d € ; b G -& E 40
70 & Q W' .& $ B 1y G-&
'- E b G :0 -& - ) $ 2 2O4 d M $&
' .& % 1 '
) > ) - T z MT - 2 ' 2O4 d (2017 &- t*; -&CGE
T . & & - W \ * E - ) T S ; ) - ; J s ' > ) $
: (!
) & '- & , 1\+' - ˆ BAU1
< &- ( - W
d ) - s & ‘-( - 1< 2O4 d 4 ) J ˆ . & &
70 ~ / G-&
d ' E 90 @ ; -& MT - 2 G-&
2040 .,; % & @ Q & t*; -& '
) - 5 $ ' > ) - 1C -& E g 0 q z 2O4 d (2017
T . & ) ; % < CGE ) - < q '& $
‡ Ž ! )) F ' F
:0 , ; ;
4 E - ) & Q ' ( % M $&4 $ 5
' 10
1 - Business As Usual
t*; -& `$ ' 1 t*; -& `$ - 2O4 d E M ) q ˆ # 4 > $ G-&
4 E q $ A) { 4 & ; -& E - ) & Q & & 2 ˆ . & ) 1O
E & < -&
- ,QX d O-( $ - 5 $ ' ;- .,; % &GDP
) > 4 A52 Q1$ > > ) (2019 M 1 # > 'CGE
1) -& E - ) & Q . B & # ‡- & -& E - ) ?Q ,; 1; A1 (BU
0 O $4 O - 2 :$ ) -& G ‡ ,\ G ,B ; ) & ; @ ) 4
-
! \ 1<! $ E - ) & Q ) .& %
:$ ) h 5
G-&
~ / -&
@ ; -& \ G E 2030
) - 5 $ ' .& % # @ ; ,Q<
(2020
,; 1; F d 4- 2O4 F d ) ,\ G :0 -& $ ' fT $
5 E 5 - ) & Q # -& 2O4 d ' ) & & 2 \ * ˆ . B & # (1 4 ) - 2 8
/ 23 `W- 2O4 F d Q ' ! :$ ) 1 1
7 / 12 .,; 1;- 1 1
! 9 =I
& ; &- # @& \ - B ; ' 2O4 d Q; :0 -&
,; 1; A1 - i -& % 1 :1# $
h W -&INDC t 2 - ; ˆ # AJ .& %
# @& \ Rundynam 1.36
< 4 5 ) % P P $
- (!
-& &
GEMPACK
2.,;
$7 B 5 J E9 * *
- h0 & / W $ 1y B ' ) - 2 ,1\+' + J r1 5
# -&
q W' *; ' - ) & Q $ O' 1 :0 -& E $ A J , 1W : (! 'FDI
- W @ ƒ; &- & Q A W $M ) 1 :0 ! / { ' d Q; $&
) - 5 $ ' 'E 2 %'- 4 2O4 ) - 5 $ ' \ * -& ) (2018
(1 (2017
% ! O - ) & ;
T .& % > 4 $ R) 2O4 d ( CGE
& / W t*; -&3
136 - dT . & 1C -& + o( ˆ # ' 1 :0
E q ˆ # ~ / -& - ) & Q 1# z $ T \ * -& ;- &- 2O4 ) $ T - ) ,;
4 q ˆ # 4 P T .,; % 1O
R) 2O4 d $
( ; ; ) & / W - ) & Q Ž ! - R
،ɣ g \ 4 F- G . )
1 - Bottom-up
2 - .,; € - A W % & - (! P -& # @& \ AJ z < ) 3 - Economy-Wide Rebound Effect
1 E 100
R γ
= + ×
&
(1) ) E&
E - ) & Q : ) ' -& E ~ / -& 11y G-&
O .,; ɣ R=0
O @ X ' &- & ' 2O4 d T % R=20%
T % 20
4 G-&
! G X B 2O4 d `<1 5 E - i
.& % ) 4 R>1
d ,;
& ! ‚ >1 % d -& % &- ' 2O4 & Q ,QX F d T # -& ) % 1Q21
- h - ) O .& %
! G E ~ / -& ) ,; \ & % R
.,; & ! {
O :0 IRX ' & / W 4 G B :0 z ɣ
\ % 1 $ & Q )
4 F- G < & / W R) 2O4 d & & |- 1 , ; -& - ) Q;
:& %
1 E 100
R αγ
= + ×
&
(2) α )
` ; ' % bW ' - ) & Q 1dn , ) ,; E ~ / ` ; 1 '
& / W -& E ~ / A) 4 \ G :0 -& E ~ / Ep
4 E 1O .& %
a 2 p - 5 $ ' 'E \ * -& ' ,; 1 :0 O )
2018 A % ( j=1,…,135
1 :0 -& - ) & Q *; ' ; ; 2O4 d 2 - s .& %
:0 >
g \ 4 F- G .& %
1 Ej 100
R γ
= + ×
&
(3) ) E&j
:0 -& E ~ / -& 11y bW ' -& .,; j
E&j
: ) ' $ -& $
:0 -& E ~ / &- 2 - Pj
4 ,; F- Q - . $&
2O4 d
@& \ B % 20 2O4 d ' % g \ :0 t*; -& )
.& %
6?
$7 B 5 , CGE
GTAP-E-Power 4 1 \
GTAP-E f <
MT - 2 ) & %
E 5 A % ' & & :% # - ) ! 21# $
-& ) ,; 1< 5 1 ,
1 ,; 1; A 1dn E ' $ ' fT F 11y ?Q $
- "O ) ‚ . % (2020
GTAP-E-PowerS 4 1 \ ))
GTAP-E-Power f <
! \ - (& % )
r1W& 4- - i ) - 4 - B ; T -& ) ,; 1;
$ ' fT 11y ?Q $ 1 - Backfire
J s4 1 @ /J .,; % r1W&
MT & - 2 … *;
'R $
F d \W ' J 4 ) &-'T …RG hQ; & B ) % &'(! ) 1<) &
,; 1;
$ ' fT 11y ?Q $ MT & ) &- ' *; ' .& %
'R & $
:0 )
$ ($ & / W g 0 % $ B A %- 2 … *; , M $
($ A1 % ) - 2 ) J < -& )
M $
& / W .& % GTAP-E-PowerS
2 ~ / ' 1 - B ; ' & < q 4
GTAP-E-Power (1 F' ' &- &
GTAP-E [ B J s -&
) / -& ) ,; 1< 5 :0 1
P ! r1 -& & ; &- . % € - (
) ‚ 4 #
2020 f < ( .,; # 1 $ -& T ( ' ' & %
1< 5 :0 f C- C 4 A5%
t 2 -& - . )
A5%
2 - -& { 1 - B ; GTAP-E-PowerS
.
1 # - v' - '
& 4 & ; P ) $2
1 g 0 $ ) A5% r * .& %
2 (
O' 1 -& # -
& 4 & ; ; ' & W - J $ $ [ B $
1 1 ... ' b ,B ; 4 O 1%- B- O' -& v' - & ; -& .& %
O' 1 1 1%- B ' W - J $ T 4 .& %
>1# - ' # - )
~ / [ B /! 4'- Q% 4 G B F ; A1QW 4 ' ~ $ 12 & %
1 2 , '& ' - B :0 z FM& \ .&- & ' h) M ) '&
GTAP-E ) - 5 $ ' - QB \ * -& ) ,;
- i ' % € - F 1€( (2019
T & )„ 4 w .10 - && B $
F' .& % '& -& + J -& & $
GRB &-
% ) =&
1
; h) M ) ' 1 ,B-& ( -
) ' E 2
. # (
) / ) ,% & @' F' 1#
1 4 -& 1< 5 B % 12 (
1 - Base Load (BL) 2 - Peak Load (PL)
; h) M ) -
z E E
- ,; %GTAP P4M F' 1 '& &- -& .1
2O4 # P ,;
& % t 2 % ! O - ) \ * -& ) -& .2
Q; 2O4 # f C- C
& ' 4 -'& > 4 @ \ - s "#
1Q% P .,; A/ T Ž' & & # > ' &- &
ˆ > ) - & & # 4 ;
1Q%
1 ' -'& 1 F 11y ) 4 ; 2 - \ -'& '
\ 4 -'& $&
.&
& & # C- C 1 C -&
$ \! -'& -& & / W 4 2 A %
& & 4 B
& & . % \ -'& z ! + $ (1 ! + $
-'& @ s
@ X % % Q &
& % A % - \ -'& 4 cT -& 1y C 4
) Ianchovichina & Walmsley, 2012 2O4 # % J s P ! .(
GTAP-E-
powerS &- ;
)GTAP Hertel,1997
; 1 ‡ - i - (
1Q* F - i i ' ; ,% Q
; &- -&
-& .,; & & `1 \ - "O
&- ;
`1 \ 'GTAP 4 T # 1c $ GTAP-E
' GTAP-E-powerS
;
? ! 1 P .rs 1 -& ' & % * > -& b G 1
‡ % A1 4 b rs $
) & % (1
; $ , - g 0 rs -& - "O
- W 1dn ) - 5 $ ' 51 g \ . $&
F 1 / 2O4 # -& (2009
; ' ~ / 1 &- -&
, 1W Q - "O
`1 / -'& $ „ 0 1O
.& %
; - "O P 5% $
% ($ O ) &
, 1W ' & $ T -& & ; $
a# # 4 P ! -& . $ B 11y '
` ; A) ~ / ' $4 T-& 4 d $
~ / ' <$
a# )
$&4 4 F - i Q - & B ~ / ' 4 T $
; Q - "O 11y T -& ! / F B ' $M ) , 1W -& F 11y 4 F - i
> < @ > I Q ' @ Q & 4 1< > 2O4 # P ! -& . $&
-'&
-&
AJ 4 s ' % AJ < @ ‡ % 4 a# -'& > @ .& %
% AJ $ 1y P aŒ;
- '& @ ' ! O - ) \ -'& 1 ' $ 1y
AJ a# 11y A1 & 4 @ s -& ; 1B„ . BT ' & % %- -'& > -& $4
; 1B„ ‡R ; <) 4 a# ' ) - &
\ -'& -& -'
Ž ! .& % O ) 1 & %
~ / ' ) F 1 / O )
F T . 1O -& $
($ - -'&
X) J - ,1 * AW J - $ Ž ! ' )
- ? % ) & %
-'& P & / W f .,; ? < T $
$ 1y ‡ % & ) &- ' -& $
$ ; 1B„ AX ,% Q T @ ; @ ; F 11y ' 11\ -'& > -& ,1\ '3
$
1 - E 5 ,B-& &- -& 21 \ * GTAP-E
) - 5 $ ' - QB 1398
.& % \ (
2 -
@& \ # :0 + - ? '- iJR
Ianchovichina & Walmsley (2012)
F G .& % \ 54 20
3 - Debt
,;
1Q% T ! . T ,) J - 4 ;
B %1
& & O .& %
z $
# , J & ' P , M& ( @ ; $ ) # @ ; T % % & & / W -&2
T ! ,) J 1< &-'T ,;
& 1O - W & ; &- $ 1y 3
) Pant, 2002 .(
5 F+ K, $
; : (! @ ) '& 4 - ) & Q i Q r * ' - B - "O
, 1W 11y
A J E $ ‡ % z & & -& S ; .& % AG J
; '
,; 1; rQ* $ - ; &- $ -& aŒ; ' % g \ E , 1W : (!
$ &
€ - % 11\ ~ $ 1 ;& - i ;&M & ; -&
:1# .& % 1
& %
‡ %
! $ O' 1 :0 -& E - ) & Q *; ' E :0 -&FDI : (
t*;
IM J 2O4 F d & ' , & ; 4 ' & % :0 -& 1 : (!
A J , 1W : (! 1 x $ . ! { (1 ) - 2 1< 5 1c) E $
{ ' (
O' 1 -& 1 - J $
:0 -& E - ) & Q h1 O' 1
$
- J ; 1 & { 4 ) & Q A W $M ) 1 :0 ' &
(1 )
2 - i 2O4 F d & ' *; ' `$ 4 Q ' & & : (! - ; :$ ) $
i $„ 4 -'& ) - 2 -& - & \ . ;-
5 L 5 , =9 , 9 M I N ;+
(
:$ )) z' 2 1c ~ $ 1 ;& 4' ,m1$ f / ; -&
4 - 2 -& G-&
:$ )) z' 2 ' ( ) 8
; 4 1 h1 (z' 2 1c ~ $ 'R G-&
- "O
(1 5 / 17 ' 5 / 52 1# ;- - T ! .,; % )„ -M& &- 1 1
; - "O
& & ‡ % 4 Q; $ O' 1 :0 -& - B `1 <
$
@ ; -& F Q; r * .,; % \ # - ; 4 v 0 <
2020 v- 0
; ) - "O A J :0 -& (EVFA
&-'T ! , A % E $ { ' 4 O $
I &' J ( 1 :0 ) 8
/ 131 ‡ % g \ .,; & -M& &- 1 1 T bQ 'FDI
€ - - ; ; s E 5 $( - ; h W -& E - ) : (!
) & %
$ - ; A1
P A3
% - "O ) @' - ; -& .
Ž ! (A1 ` J & %
; (1 - "O 5
/ 17
& , -M& &- 1 1 @ ; $ -& z' 2 1c ~ $ 1 ;
2020 @ ) 4 1€ WT & l ' ) \ * 1 r * .& % 1 n FDI
) ]' 1# (2017
1 - Momentum Simulation 2 - Stationary State 3 - Trajectories
,Q< E - ) ,1; <J Ž ! FDI
& -& : (! G-& > $ 4 & %
4 E - ) FDI 07
/ 0 . : (! G-&
z ;- - T - 2 P
;
; ,Q< 4 E :0 -& - B - "O 1 ;& , 4 1 &- - "O
; A) E :0 -& z' 2 1c ~ $ `W- \ ) :0 -& % P - "O
8 / 131 ‡ % - Q; (-M& &- 1 1 E - ) 'FDI
& ; Q; .& %
‡ % { ! ,Q<
13 G-&
O' 1 A %) E -&FDI ( E $ A J ' $
‡ % h; ' 91
/ 0 g \ $ O' 1 :0 -& E - ) & Q G-&
-& .& %
) - ; 1 '&
; (A2 1c ~ $ 'R z' 2 ~ $ 1 ;& , - "O z' 2
“ Q \ 5 / 52 @ ; -& -M& &- 1 1 2020
@ - ; 2 (1 , J -& .& %
; v- 0 (1 `W- ,Q< Q; > ) 121#
:0 -& ! O F- G - "O
) E 8 / 131 ‡ % (-M& &- 1 1 h1 E - ) 'FDI
8 / 39 ' G-&
786 / 2
) P ; - ; -& .,; % g \ G-&
) ,; Ž ! 1 $ (A3
; h W -& z' 2 ~ $ r - i % 1 :1# - "O ' 2 r FDI
“ Q 5 / 17
@ ; @ s -& ' 4 -' z' 2 1c ~ $ z -M& &- 1 1 4 a# $
! % r -( & / W a - # r
(1 , J -& ) ,; .& %
; h; E - ) S ; .,! $ B & Q @ ; $ -& ! r - "O
‡ %
; z $
g \ 4 4 @' r * E - ) ' - "O & %
; q )
- "O ;) ! O F- G 5
`W- ( 5 / 17 . ; -M& &- 1 1
' @ 1 - - ; -& M ; - "O ; &
A3
@ ; -& - "O ; v- 0
E :0 (-M& &- 1 1 ) ‡ % -
( G-&) ; - "O ; -
; ‡ % *; ' (-M& &- 1 1 ) - "O ; q
F- G ‡ % h W -&
\ - ) ‡ % -
( G-&) E
2020 8 / 131 1
318
/ 1 318
/ 1 07
/ 0
2021 5 / 132 1
325
/ 1 643
/ 2 07
/ 0
2022 9 / 132 1
329
/ 1 972
/ 3 07
/ 0
2023 2 / 133 1
332
/ 1 304
/ 5 07
/ 0
2024 6 / 133 1
336
/ 1 64
/ 6 07
/ 0
2025 3 / 134 1
343
/ 1 983
/ 7 07
/ 0
2026 1 / 135 1
351
/ 1 334
/ 9 07
/ 0
2027 136 1
36
/ 1 694
/ 10 07
/ 0
2028 9 / 136 1
369
/ 1 063
/ 12 07
/ 0
2029 8 / 137 1
378
/ 1 441
/ 13 07
/ 0
2030 8 / 138 1
388
/ 1 829
/ 14 07
/ 0
2031 8 / 139 1
398
/ 1 227
/ 16 07
/ 0
2032 6 / 140 1
406
/ 1 633
/ 17 07
/ 0
r F Q; :bQ
{ ! @' -& P'& ; &
) # - ; z EVFA 2 - (BAU
. $&
; & P ; ; -& % g \ ‡ % (P- C ;) - B - "O
; 4 G-&
&'(! ; & ) @ ; $ -& (P'& ;) A) - "O
' r * h1 .,; % Q; & %
; ‡ % { ! @ (P ; ;) - "O
g \ -& (`2% ;) E - ) ' 4' O ) ,; )„ P4M .& %
1' 1 -&
8 @ ; @ ; 1400
; (1 { ,\ G -& % P M ; - "O
:0 A %) 4 <W ' @ ' b 4 1 $
@& \ (- 2) E :0 6
/ 1
v- 0 &- ' M ; ‡ % % 11\ & S ; .,; & -M& &- 1 1
; 1 E :0 -& - "O i "#
. ;-
( 5 L 5 , =9 8& / M I N ;+
A J , 1W : (!
& … % i Q r * E $ AQW :0 -& % &
- >
) ~ / 1 -& ' E - ) & Q - i ( AJ - 2 ' T
1 # … *;
M & ; -& & ~ $ 1 ;& , -& ) & % … * ) - ;&
l ' ) \ * r * (1 :0 -& .& ) $ B A1 <
) ]' 1€ WT &
(2017
! Ž
4 E - ) (1 E , 1W : (! G-& > $ 4 % 23
/ 0 G-&
: (!
g \ - ; '& S ; . A J , 1W 11y F d ) & %
E $
- W 4- &- t*; '& -& ) - 2 ) @' t*; -& .& 1O
, 1W (B1 J
A $
- 2) $ O' 1 :0 & ; &- E -
) & T 4 ‡ - B
& % - QX ‡ %
4 1
@ ; 4 4 -& M ; F- G ' G-&
$ 2020 2035
&R1 g \
O' 1 :0 -& (1 E - ) ,QX ‡ % 1W ‡ % h; .& % $
4
23 / 0 ) P'& t*; -& .,; % g \ G-&
&' J 5 (B2 60
1! ‰ G-&
,
O' 1 z - 2) $ O' 1 { ,B ; ' 4 O O' 1 A %) - J $
,; (b
Ministry of Energy, 2019: 40).
Ž ! ( (1 QX ‡ % & %
10 ' @ ; $ G-&
&
O' 1 ?; % 1 { , 1W QW 4 4 $ - &- ' - J $
' h;
~ / , ; -& ) & Q A W $M ) 1 :0 -& E - ) ‡ % T )
- W {
4 - &
3 / 2 g \ G-&
.& %
O*5
; 1; T- ) 4- - i \ * -&
, -& % € - $ r! A „INDC
T- ) (1 @' @ ƒ; . % … s @ ƒ; '& ) - 2 … *; :$ ) 1# a - # FDI
1 - S-&T iraneconomist.com/fa/news/360620/
.& % \
~ $ - 2 :$ ) - i { ,\ G -&
-& % - "O - W : ; &- -INDC
. $&
,; 1; F d P'& @ ƒ; -&
:1# $ % 1
\–
! 'FDI A J , 1W : ( E $
( ,; 1; – -
4 & / W $ 1y ,\ G :0 &'(! ]4- GDP
@ ƒ; j; # ! . % bW ' :; # &- { ~ / - ' { ,\ G ' A) - s ) $- & < @' 1
) ( 7 $ - ; -& $ % rQs .& ) ( A1
A3 FDI
$ - ; -& J .&-'T # ) - 2 ` J -& - & \ :$ ) 'B1
)B2
,; 1; h1 A J , 1W : (! $
O' 1 & ; &- E $ ' - J $
- W ;- &- - 1 $ J ' & ; &- { , 1W : (!
:$ ) $&
$ 2 ) - 2 (1 -& - & \ - ; -& IRX 5 & %
,Q< ) - 2 B2
-& - 2 - %- # @ ; - C -& @ J 1 -& % & : (! # - ; - ; 1 # … *; B2
5 T 1 .,; 1;- # - ; -& - 2 %- 4 ` J
; :1# - "O -& % 1
' z' 2 ~ $ 1 ;& - i T- ) W !INDC
i 1 x $ .,; z' 2 1c A J , 1W : (! ,; 1; ;-
E $
. % % & ) - 2 :$ ) 21 1dn
< P'& @ ƒ; &- -&
) $- & rQs .& ) q - 4 $- &
8 ) ( 12 (
$ - ; -&
'A1 t*; -& 11y $ %A2 4 Q ) `1 <$ # - ; ,Q< GDP
1 4 ~R B (1 \ P ; @ ; 1 & 2 F' ' &'-
@ 4 AG JGDP
& # - ; ' $ - ; .& %
- i ,\ G :0 ; ]4- '- ;-
1+ ! 4- a - # ! # -& :0 % 12) & )- Q ,;
]- (O B -& ) .,; % € - $
) $- & rQs 13
) ( 17 $ - ; -& \ G ; ]4- '- ( 'A1
4 a#A2
X) J ‡ % q W' 4 @ ; ;
$ # - ; z '- FDI - ; -& .& %
$ - ; -& ? ! ' ,; # - ; rQ* '- A3 'B1
& ,QX F 11y B2
- ; -& F' .,; # - ; 4 ! \ G F 1 ]4- -& % -& 'B2
! F : ( 2 ,<1 - i r * (1 - ; -& - 2 (1 C O '
, 1W : (! 1 $ J ' ! / { , 1W : (! 21 ,QX 1dn $&
A J O' 1 & ; &- E $ .,; \ G :0 ; ]4- - J $
) P ! / { , 1W : (! ,\ G :0 -& ) - 2 :$
' 1 $
- $ J ' -& E - ) & Q ) $- & -& ) & & ,Q< 2O4 d
18 (
) 22 ,; 1; @ 5 T 1 .,; % € - ( -& % )„ $
(O $ INDC
)- ' 1*\
(1 { ,\ G &- -& q + . % $ 0 ,\ G :0 % 12) &
.&- & { / - 2) ,\ G 4 20
) $- & -&
23 ) ( 27 ) % € - { ,\ G ; ]4- -& F 11y '- (
$ - ; S ; 'A1
,\ G ; ]4- -& ,QX F 11y A2 - C 4 a# X) J {
$ # - ; s $ '- ' % X B @ ; ; ]4- F 11y .& %
- ; -& { ,\ G $ - ; -& .,; rQ* 5 # - ; 'A3
'B1
- ; [ B - s (! F- G F -& ,\ G ; ]4- -& F 11y B2
%- # - ; ,Q<
{ ,\ G % & )- P (1 $- & 1 . )
.&- & , M& a - # r! # -&
r * ;- &- $ - ; s G /B - B ?; { ~ / -& F 11y '- ) - &
28
; -& ' & & \G - $ ( 4 M @ ; $ -& ~ / - $ -
- ; S ; { ~ / F 11y 1 ~R B .,; ! O - W # - ; 'B1
F -& $ - ; & ,Q< ) - s ! : (! 4 -' # - ;
; .,; & & 2 # - ; - F' 21 S
*; ' ,! O 1
) & ) A M F % 2O4 d $ O' 1 :0 -& E - ) : (!
, -& ' ,; % & # -& - - B ~ / : (! F Q { , 1W :$ ) .,; % - 2) -& ) - 2 :$ ) P
(-M& 1 1 ) G /B - B { + ]4- F 11y -28 - &
2 $ % % J s $ - ; 4 P ) u1$ q -& $&
- 2 t*;
@ ; - ) 2030
' 2035 ; 4 . $& :$ ) a - # r! -& % 1 :1# … *;
r! ; 1# h W -& O J &
; a - # Q1;T `$ 4 & % r $ -
- 2 … *; :$ ) -& - &4 : ) , -& .& $ 0 ,\ G :0 2O4 d $ &- &
.,; & 1 4 - ) - 2 :$ ) 5 ) & %
@ +
$9 9
b 4 1G { ! ˆ
0 < 4 - W ; 1; $ v
:& %
- ,Q< E - ) ,1; <J - " ; 1; &- & F-' + & …RG FDI
:1#
; % 1 . P W ,)- 2 ; -& - B `1 < - "O
- -& E - ) & Q 4 % 2O4 d M F- W - " ; 1; ,; P4M
' 1 :0 - 5%T G /B - B { ~ / : (! ) $ O
~ / : (! =& %
. @ ) G /B - B T , 1W : (! r s 4 - {
- - B & ) ($ Q; -& 1 # - 1< ` ; { , 1W + J @ J -& 5
; 1G -& - " ; 1; ,; P4M &- & G /B J - { , 1W 121# ; 1
. ! { - 2 :$ ) , -& ' % @ ) { ~ / $& : (! - & \
-
`1 / - " ; 1;
~ $ ) E - ) : (! &- -& r1W& 1O
1# F \ * ˆ 4 & ; 4 1 r ,)- 2 - ) "# 1dn
4 E .& % , J 1 4 -& F 1 4 ,; P4M S ; 1 $ ' ,; FDI
References:
1 - Adeyemi, O. I., D. C. Broadstock, M. Chitnis, L. C. Hunt & G. Judge. (2010). Asymmetric price responses & the underlying energy dem& trend: are they substitutes or complements? Evidence from modelling OECD aggregate energy dem&. Energy Economics, 32(5), 1157–1164.
2 - Akbari, Reza; Jalai Esfandabadi, Seyyed Abd-alMajid; Nejati, Mehdi & Mina Javadinia, (2019), Investigating the impact of international agreements on the quality of the environment through the foreign direct investment channel with the CGE model approach: a case study of the JCPOA. Economic Research, 54(4), pp. 787-819 [in Persian].
3 - anderson, K. S., S. Dockweiler & H. K. Jacobsen. (2019). Squaring the energy efficiency circle:
evaluating industry energy efficiency policy in a hybrid model setting. MPRA Paper, No. 96546.
4 - Babiker, M., A. Gurgel, S. Paltsev & J. Reilly. (2009). Forward-looking versus recursive-dynamic modeling in climate policy analysis: a comparision. Economic modeling, 26, 1341-1354.
5 - Broberg, T., C. Berg & E. Samakovlis. (2015). The economy-wide rebound effect from improved energy efficiency in Swedish industries- A general equilibrium analysis. Energy policy, 83, 26-37.
6 - Dargay, J. M. & D. Gately. (1995). The imperfect price-reversibility of non-transport oil demand in the OECD. Energy Economics, 17(1), 59–71.
7 - Eftekhari, Shervin; Mousavi, Seyed Mostafa & Abtin Ataei, (2015). Investigation of the reduction of greenhouse gas emissions due to solar electricity production in solar electricity development programs. The second national conference on energy & sustainable development, 29 & 30 February 2015, Islamic Azad University, Takistan Unit [in Persian].
8 - Gately, D. & H. G. Huntington. (2002). The asymmetric effects of changes in price & income of energy
& oil demand. Energy journal, 23(1), 19–55.
9 - Giraudet, L-G., C. Guivarch & P. Quirion. (2012). Exploring the potential for energy conservation in french households through hybrid modeling, Energy economics, 34, 426-445.
10- Huntington, H. G. (2006). A note on price asymmetry as induced technical change. Energy journal, 27(3), 1–7.
11 - Ianchovichina, E. I. & T. L. Walmsley. (2012). Dynamic modeling & applications for global economic analysis. Cambridge university press.
12 - Kafaei, Seyyed Mohammad Ali & Priya Nejad Aghaian-Vosh, (2017), Identifying factors affecting energy efficiency in Iran's economy, Quarterly Journal of Energy Economics Studies, 13(52), pp. 1-34.
13 - Koesler, S., K. Swales & K. Turner. (2016). International spillover & rebound effects from increased energy efficiency in Germany. Energy economics, 54, 444-452.
14- Lee, H., S. W. Kang & Y. Koo. (2020). A hybrid energy system model to evaluate the impact of climate policy on the manufacturing sector: adoption of energy-efficient technologies & rebound effects. Energy, 212, 118718.
15 - Lu, Y., Y. Liu & M. Zhou. (2017). Rebound effect of improved energy efficiency for different energy types: a general equilibrium analysis for China. Energy economics, 62, 248-256.
16 - Malek Mohammadi, Hamid Reza, (2015). Basics & principles of public policy, Tehran, Samit, first edition [in Persian].
17 - Ministry of Energy, (2019). Energy balance sheet for 2017. Tehran, Iran [in Persian].
18 - Nong, D. (2020). Development of electricity-environmental policy CGE model (GTAP-E-PowerS): A case of the carbon tax in South Africa. Energy policy, 140, 111375.
19 - Pant, H. M. (2002). Solving an intertemporal CGE model without an intertemporal database using GEMPACK – in the GTEM way. 5th annual conference on global economic analysis.
20 - Patterson, M. G. (1996). What is energy efficiency?: concepts, indicators & methodological issues.
Energy policy, 24(5), 377-390.
21 - Rafiei, Fatemeh; Asgari, Manouchehr & Hamidreza Arbab, (2019), Analyzing the rebound effects caused by increasing in energy efficiency in Iran: Computable general equilibrium model approach, Economics & Modeling Quarterly, 39, pp. 87-111 [in Persian].
22 - Sharekian, Atiyeh & Mohammad Reza Lotfalipour, (2016), the role of energy efficiency in improving the environment in selected oil exporting countries (using panel data), Journal of Regional Economy &
Development, 23(11), pp. 106- 130 [in Persian].
23 - Sharzei, Gholam Ali & He-Zhar Ebrahimzadegan, (2011), estimation of the return effect of increasing energy efficiency in relation to household consumption & carbon dioxide emissions in Iran, Journal of Energy Economics Studies, 8(30), pp. 33-61 [in Persian].
24 - Suleimanian, Zohreh; Bazazan, Fatemeh & Mirhossein Mousavi, (2018), Reciprocal effects resulting from improving the efficiency of electricity, fossil fuels & energy input in energy-intensive industries: a computable general equilibrium approach. Economic Research, 53(4), pp. 855-880 [in Persian].
25 - Suleimanian, Zohreh; Bazazan, Fatemeh & Mirhossein Mousavi, (2017), The effects of improving the efficiency of fossil fuels in energy-intensive industries: an inter-temporal dynamic computable general equilibrium model, Iran Energy Economics Research Journal, 6(21), pp. 163-200 [in Persian].
26 - Wei, T. & Y. Liu. (2017). Estimation of global rebound effect caused by energy efficiency improvement. Energy economics, 66, 27-34.
27 - Wu, Y-H., C-H. Liu, M-L. Hung, T-Y. Liu & T. Masui. (2019). Sectoral energy efficiency improvements in Taiwan: Evaluations using a hybrid of top-down & bottom-up models. Energy policy, 132, 1241-1255.
28 - Zhang, J. S. & C. Y. Lawell. (2017). The macroeconomic rebound effect in China. Energy economics, 67, 202-212.
