Neutron-activated theranostic radionuclides for nuclear medicine
Hun Yee Tan
a, Chai Hong Yeong
b, Yin How Wong
b, Molly McKenzie
c, Azahari Kasbollah
d, Mohamad Nazri Md. Shah
e, Alan Christopher Perkins
f,⁎
aSchool of Biosciences, Faculty of Health and Medical Sciences, Taylor's University, 47500 Subang Jaya, Selangor, Malaysia
bSchool of Medicine, Faculty of Health and Medical Sciences, Taylor's University, 47500 Subang Jaya, Selangor, Malaysia
cSchool of Life Sciences, University of Dundee, DD1 4HN, United Kingdom
dMedical Technology Division, Malaysian Nuclear Agency, Bangi, 43000 Kajang, Selangor, Malaysia
eDepartment of Biomedical Imaging, University of Malaya Medical Centre, 59100 Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia
fRadiological Sciences, School of Medicine, University of Nottingham, Nottingham NG7 2UH, United Kingdom
a b s t r a c t a r t i c l e i n f o
Article history:
Received 10 July 2020
Received in revised form 8 September 2020 Accepted 22 September 2020
Available online xxxx Keywords:
Theranostics Neutron activation Radionuclide Nuclear medicine
Theranostics in nuclear medicine refers to personalized patient management that involves targeted therapy and diagnostic imaging using a single or combination of radionuclide (s). The radionuclides emit both alpha (α) or beta (β−) particles and gamma (γ) rays which possess therapeutic and diagnostic capabilities, respectively. How- ever, the production of these radionuclides often faces difficulties due to high cost, complexity of preparation methods and that the products are often sourced far from the healthcare facilities, hence losing activity due to ra- dioactive decay during transportation. Subject to the availability of a nuclear reactor within an accessible distance from healthcare facilities, neutron activation is the most practical and cost-effective route to produce radionu- clides suitable for theranostic purposes. Holmium-166 (166Ho), Lutetium-177 (177Lu), Rhenium-186 (186Re), Rhenium-188 (188Re) and Samarium-153 (153Sm) are some of the most promising neutron-activated radionu- clides that are currently in clinical practice and undergoing clinical research for theranostic applications. The aim of this paper is to review the physical characteristics, current clinical applications and future prospects of these neutron activated radionuclides in theranostics. The production, physical properties, validated clinical ap- plications and clinical studies for each neutron-activated radionuclide suitable for theranostic use in nuclear med- icine are reviewed in this paper.
© 2020 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
Contents
1. Introduction . . . 56
2. Neutron activation . . . 56
3. Theranostics . . . 56
4. Commonly used neutron-activated radionuclides for nuclear medicine theranostics . . . 57
4.1. Holmium-166 . . . 57
4.2. Lutetium-177 . . . 60
4.3. Rhenium-186 . . . 61
4.4. Rhenium-188 . . . 62
4.5. Samarium-153 . . . 62
5. Recent developments of neutron-activated theranostics radionuclides for clinical applications . . . 63
5.1. Gastroenteropancreatic neuroendocrine tumors . . . 63
5.2. Bone metastasis . . . 63
5.3. Radiosynovectomy . . . 63
5.4. Head and neck cancer . . . 63
5.5. Non-melanoma skin cancer. . . 64
5.6. Liver cancer. . . 64
5.7. Malignant airway blockage and malignant biliary stricture. . . 64
5.8. Spinal cancer . . . 64
⁎ Corresponding author at: Radiological Sciences, School of Medicine, University of Nottingham, Nottingham NG7 2UH, United Kingdom.
E-mail address:[email protected](A.C. Perkins).
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.nucmedbio.2020.09.005 0969-8051/© 2020 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
Contents lists available atScienceDirect
Nuclear Medicine and Biology
j o u r n a l h o m e p a g e :w w w . e l s e v i e r . c o m / l o c a t e / n u c m e d b i o
6. Conclusions . . . 64
Abbreviations . . . 65
Acknowledgements . . . 65
References . . . 11
1. Introduction
The scope of nuclear medicine has expanded over the last decade due its capabilities in providing a wide range of both diagnostic imaging and targeted therapy. Recent advances in radiopharmaceuticals and nanotechnology has led to the evolution of a newfield of nuclear med- icine, known as theranostics. Theranostics provides a transition from conventional nuclear medicine to contemporary personalized or preci- sion medicine. It uses molecular targeting vectors (such as receptor binding peptides and monoclonal antibodies (mAbs)) labeled with di- agnostic and therapeutic radionuclide(s), to acquire diagnostic images as well as to deliver a therapeutic radiation dose to the target tissues.
This can be achieved by either using a theranostics radionuclide that emits both therapeutic (e.g.αorβ−) and diagnostic (e.g.γor positron) radiations, such as131I,153Sm,166Ho,177Lu,186Re and188Re; or incorpo- rating two radionuclides (one for imaging and another for therapy) into the same theranostics radiopharmaceutical formulation. The diagnostic imaging enables determination of the subtype of the disease, its pro- gression, and the specific characteristics of a patient. This information al- lows decisions to be made on the quantity, timing, type of drugs and choice of therapy procedures for personalized patient treatment, as well as to monitor early response to treatment and predict efficacy.
There are several methods for producing medical radionuclides. The most common ones include neutron activation in a nuclear reactor or by particle acceleration via a cyclotron, synchrotron, or linear accelerator.
In the case of radionuclides produced by using a radionuclide generator one of the previously mentioned methods is used to produce the parent radionuclide [1]. This review only focuses on theranostic radionuclides that are produced via the method of neutron activation in a nuclear re- actor. One of the classic examples of such a radionuclide is131I which has been used for more than 6 decades in the form of sodium iodide for the diagnosis and treatment of thyroid cancer [2].131I emits both therapeuticβ−particles and diagnosticγ-rays and it primarily targets the thyroid cells, with little uptake or effect on the rest of the body. In this way iodine is a radionuclide that serves a benchmark that other ra- dionuclides can be compared to in terms of both functionality and cost effectiveness. The aim of this paper is to review the physical character- istics, current applications, and future prospects of neutron-activated theranostic radionuclides.
2. Neutron activation
Neutron activation is a preferred method for radionuclide produc- tion due to its cost-effectiveness, availability, and capability in produc- ing a wide range of radionuclides. Currently, there are 220 operational research reactors in the world according to the International Atomic En- ergy Agency (IAEA) research reactor database [3]. However, the number of reactors capable of producing medical radionuclides is far less than thisfigure (96 nuclear research reactors [3]) and some have faced severe operational difficulties and production outages in recent years. Neutron activation describes the process in which a stable nuclide becomes ra- dioactive after bombardment by a neutronflux. This occurs when atomic nuclei capture free neutrons, becoming heavier and entering ex- cited states. The excited nucleus often decays immediately by emitting gamma radiation or particles such asα,β−,fission products and neu- trons. The reaction is usually written as (n,γ) or (n,x) reaction, where x indicates the emitted particles [4].Fig. 1shows the basic structures of a nuclear research reactor and an example of a (n,γ) reaction.
Due to its inherent accuracy, sensitivity and simplicity, neutron acti- vation has been extensively used in many applications including medi- cal radionuclide production [5]. Two important factors in choosing a suitable radionuclide for medical applications are cost and availability.
The costs of the elemental targets, radiochemical processing, and reactor operation, including volume and time of irradiation, are among the fac- tors that determine the radionuclide production cost. The radionuclide decay characteristics such as the physical half-life, abundance percent- age, types and energies of radiation emissions also play a vital role in the effectiveness of the diagnostic/therapeutic application [6]. The activ- ity, A in Becquerel (Bq) of a radionuclide produced via neutron activa- tion can be calculated using Eq.(1)[6].
A¼Nσϕ1–e–λt
ð1Þ
where:
N = number of target atoms
σ= cross-section (1 b = 10−28m2or 10−24cm2) ϕ= neutronflux
λ= decay constant = 0.693/T1/2
T1/2= half-life t = time of irradiation
Most of the radionuclides produced in a research reactor are irradi- ated by thermal neutronflux (at levels between 1011and 1014n/
cm2/s−1) due to its simple production process and high yield [7]. In ad- dition, many elemental targets do not require further chemical separa- tion of the target and product after activation.Table 1shows a list of medical radionuclides produced from stable targets by direct (n,γ) neu- tron activation, their physical characteristics, and current clinical appli- cations. The wide availability of nuclear research reactors has encouraged many countries to produce radiopharmaceuticals locally so that they can be supplied to nearby healthcare facilities with more af- fordable price.
Although many radionuclides can be produced via neutron activa- tion as listed inTable 1, factors such as short (less than few hours) or long (more than several days) physical half-lives, unstable decay prod- ucts, absence ofγor positron emission for diagnostic imaging, too highγ-rays energy (unnecessary high dose to patient and personnel) and very low cross-section value (producing radionuclides with a spe- cific activity that are too low to be useful for therapy) eventually make those radionuclides unsuitable for theranostic applications [8]. There- fore, after considering all the factors above,166Ho,177Lu,186Re,188Re and153Sm are the radionuclides that fulfill the criteria for theranostics use.
3. Theranostics
The term“theranostics”was introduced by John Funkhouser in 2002 [9] to describe developments in science to establish more specific and individualized therapies for various pathologies uniting the applications of diagnosis and therapy into a single agent. This approach has led to a promising therapeutic paradigm involving diagnosis, drug delivery and monitoring of treatment response [10]. Nevertheless, the fundamental principle of theranostics can be traced back to 1940's after
131I wasfirst used by Glenn Seaborg and John Livingood at the Univer- sity of California, Berkeley for the diagnosis and treatment of thyroid cancer [2,11].131I emits both therapeuticβ−particles and diagnostic γ-rays, which is a classic example of theranostics agent.131I targets
primarily to the thyroid cells, whereby the radiation can destroy the thyroid glands and any other thyroid cells (including cancer cells) that uptake the iodine, with little effect on the rest of the body [12]. The usage of theranostics agent has been constantly expanding, and subse- quently playing an important role in nuclear targeted therapies, specifically in patients with advanced neuroendocrine tumours (for example gastroenteropancreatic tumours), pheochromocytoma, bronchopulmonary neuroendocrine tumours and neuroblastomas [13–20]. Additionally, radioligand therapies in metastatic melanoma and metastatic prostate cancer have presented encouraging results [21–25].
Theranostic radionuclides can be used as a diagnostic agent when administered at a lower activity to determine the location and state of disease prior to treatment. Hybrid single photon emission computed to- mography/computed tomography (SPECT/CT) or positron emission to- mography/computed tomography (PET/CT) imaging can be performed to assess the biodistribution and uptake to determine the optimum therapeutic activity required and to predict treatment outcome [26,27]
. As stated by Qaim [8], an ideal theranostic radionuclide should have ap- propriate biochemical reactivity and decay properties. He further elabo- rated that the radionuclide should have a physical half-life between 6 h to 7 d, medium to high linear energy transfer (LET) and sufficient range in tissue for the treatment purpose. In addition, the ratio of non- penetrating to penetrating radiation must be high, and the radionuclide must decay into a short-lived or stable daughter. Furthermore, the ra- dionuclide should provide an optimal and selective concentration along with prolonged retention in the tumours with minimum or no up- take in normal tissues [8]. A summary of the characteristics of neutron- activated theranostic radionuclides which are commercially available or currently undergoing clinical trials is presented inTable 2. WhileFig. 2 illustrates the clinical applications of currently available neutron- activated theranostic radiopharmaceuticals in different organs.
4. Commonly used neutron-activated radionuclides for nuclear medicine theranostics
4.1. Holmium-166
166Ho can be produced by neutron activation of165Ho (100% natural abundance) which has a neutron cross-section of 64.7 b [28]; hence a large amount of166Ho can be produced with relatively high specific activ- ity of 2.28 GBq/mg following neutron activation at 4.2 × 1013n/cm2/s for 60 h [29]. It has a physical half-life of 26.8 h [30] and166Ho is aβ−emitter (Eβmean= 0.66 MeV) that also emits 81 keVγ-rays suitable for gamma scintigraphy [31]. It is used for therapeutic applications such as radiosynovectomy and bone marrow ablation [6]. The penetration range of theβ−emissions from166Ho in soft tissues is 2.2 mm on average, reaching a maximum depth of 10.2 mm [31]. The166Ho is highly paramag- netic and has been used for both scintigraphy and magnetic resonance im- aging (MRI) [32], which allowed biodistribution assessment and quantitative dosimetry analysis in patient post-procedural [33].
166Ho is a promising radionuclide for theranostics use due to its rel- atively high specific activity and short physical half-life, examples of therapeutic use include 166Ho-1,4,7,10-tetraazacyclododecane- 1,4,7,10-tetramethyl phosphonic acid (DOTMP) for bone marrow treatment in patients with multiple myelomas and166Ho-ethylene di- amine tetra(methylene phosphonate) (EDTMP) for metastatic bone pain palliation [34,35]. It has been reported that the toxicity profile of
166Ho-DOTMP is acceptable although it results in higher marrow suppression compared with153Sm-EDTMP due to the long range of
166Ho β- particles [36,37]. 166Ho-1,2-propylene di-amino tetra (methy1enephosphonic acid) (PDTMP) is recommended as an alternative to166Ho-DOTMP as there is very little accumulation in the kidney, liver or spleen, which is an important parameter for bone mar- row ablation, as suggested from animal studies by Zolghadri et al. [38].
Fig. 1.(a) Schematic diagram of the basic structure of a nuclear research reactor and (b) an example of152Sm(n,γ)153Sm neutron activation reaction.
A study by Cho et al. showed that166Ho-chitosan complex used as a radiosynovectomy agent resulted in good clinical outcomes for the treatment of haemophilic arthropathy due to simpler and safer proto- cols which provide satisfactory and promising results without any seri- ous complication [39]. Observed on the target joints have shown excellent control of bleeding reducing the requirement for coagulation treatment [39]. The post-procedural biodistribution and pharmacoki- netic of166Ho-chitosan complex for patient with knee synovitis can be evaluated using a gamma camera [40]. Due to the relatively short phys- ical half-life, the166Ho-chitosan complex has also been used for treating outpatients with skin cancer. Chung et al. reported that a study of 8 pa- tients treated with166Ho-chitosan patches showed excellent functional and cosmetic outcomes without any complications [41]. In addition, a pilot study that involved 22 patients with cystic brain tumour treated with 166Ho-chitosan complex resulted in a radiological response of
70% and tumour control was prolonged in both low grade astrocytomas and benign tumours with clinical improvement [42]. Kim et al. also showed that a166Ho-chitosan complex can be used for the treatment of renal cysts where 90% of the cysts regressed completely with no sig- nificant complications [43].166Ho-chitosan complex has also been used in patients with single and large HCC as reported by Sohn et al. in a phase II study that involved 54 patients [44]. This study showed remark- able results with a response rate of 78% and tolerable toxicities, for pa- tients with tumour sizes of 3–5 cm.
166Ho-labeled poly-L-lactic acid (PLLA) microspheres have been used widely in Europe (Trade name QuiremSpheres®, Quirem, The Netherlands) for the treatment of liver malignancies. Following intra- arterial injection, the microspheres lodge in the microvasculature sur- rounding the tumour. Due to the average microsphere having a diame- ter of 30μm, the tumouricidal effects is maximised and the negative Table 1
List of medical radionuclides produced from stable targets by direct (n,γ) neutron activation [1,6,29].
Radionuclide Half-life, T1/2
Nuclear reaction
Decay product (stable)
Natural abundance (%)
Cross-section, σ(barns)
Energy of β−particles (keV)
Imaging γ-rays (keV)
Current clinical applications
Dysprosium-165 (165Dy)
2.3 h 164Dy (n,γ)165Dy
Holmium-165 (165Ho)
28.2 2650 1287
(83%) 1192 (15%)
94.7 (4%)
Relief pain in the synovial joints [164]
Erbium-169 (169Er)
9.4 d 168Er (n,γ)169Er
Thulium-169 (169Tm)
26.8 2.7 351(55%)
343 (45%) 110 (0.001%) 8 (0.2%)
Relief pain in the synovial joints [165,166]
Gold-198 (198Au)
2.7 d 197Au (n,γ)198Au
Mercury-198 (198Hg)
100 98.7 960 (99%)
285 (1%) 1088 (0.2%) 412 (96%) 676 (1%)
Therapy of bladder, cervix and prostate cancer, reduce fluid accumulation secondary to a cancer, relief pain in the synovial joints [167–169]
Holmium-166 (166Ho)
26.8 h 165Ho (n,γ)166Ho
Erbium-166 (166Er)
100 64.7 1854
(50%) 1774 (49%)
81 (6%) Therapy and diagnosis of liver and skin cancer, head, neck and brain tumours, renal cysts, relief pain in synovial joints and bone cancer [151]
Lutetium-177 (177Lu)
6.7 d 176Lu (n,γ)177Lu
Hafnium-177 (177Hf)
2.6 2065 498 (79%)
385 (9%) 176 (12%)
208 (11%) 113 (6%)
Therapy and diagnosis of neuroendocrine and prostate cancer, relief pain from bone cancer [81,170]
Phosphorus-32 (32P)
14.3 d 31P(n,γ)32P Sulfur-32 (32S) 100 0.18 1709 (100%)
Noγ-ray Therapy of polycythemia vera, essential thrombocythemia and leukemia, relief pain from bone cancer and in the synovial joints [111,171]
Rhenium-186 (186Re)
3.7 d 185Re (n,γ)186Re
Osmium-186 (186Os)a
37.4 112 1069
(80%) 932 (22%) 581 (6%)
137 (9%) Relief pain from bone cancer [133]
Rhenium-188 (188Re)
17.0 h 187Re (n,γ)188Re
Osmium-188 (188Os)
62.6 76.4 2120
(71%) 1965 (26%)
155 (15%)
Therapy and diagnosis of liver and skin cancer, relief pain in synovial joints and bone cancer [122]
Samarium-153 (153Sm)
46.3 h 152Sm (n,γ)153Sm
Europium-153 (153Eu)
26.7 206 808 (18%)
705 (50%) 635 (32%)
103 (28%) 70 (5%)
Relief pain from bone cancer [134]
Tin-117 m (117mSn)
13.6 d 116Sn (n,γ)117mSn
Tin-177 m (117mSn)
14.5 6 152 (26%)b
129 (12%)b 127 (65%)b
159 (86%) 156 (2%)
Relief pain from bone cancer [172]
Strontium-89 (89Sr)
50.5 d 88Sr (n,γ)89Sr
Yttrium-89 (89Y)
82.6 0.058 1497
(100%)
Noγ-ray Relief pain from bone cancer [165]
Tantalum-182 (182Ta)
114.4 d 181Ta (n,γ)182Ta
Tungsten-182 (182W)a
100 20.5 524 (40%)
439 (21%) 260 (29%)
1231 (12%) 1189 (16%) 1121 (35%) 222 (8%) 100 (14%) 68 (41%)
Therapy of bladder cancer [173]
Thulium-170 (170Tm)
128.6 d 169Tm (n,γ)170Tm
Ytterbium-170 (170Yb)
100 105 968 (82%)
884 (18%)
84 (3%) Therapy of prostate cancer and relief pain from bone cancer [174,175]
Yttrium-90 (90Y) 64.0 h 89Y(n,γ)90Y Zirconium-90 (90Zr)
100 1.3 2282
(100%)
Noγ-ray Therapy of liver cancer and non-Hodgkin's lymphoma, relief pain in synovial joints [111,176,177]
a Decay product is not stable.
b Conversion electrons.
effects on healthy liver parenchyma are reduced [34]. The166Ho-labeled PLLA microspheres achieved sufficiently high activity of ~15 GBq de- pending on the neutron activation parameters which could result in a maximum specific activity of 450 Bq/microsphere [45]. The holmium embolization particles for arterial radiotherapy 1 study (HEPAR1)
showed that166Ho radioembolization is practicable and safe for deliver- ing a dose of 60 Gy to the whole liver (this being known as the maxi- mum tolerated dose). The distribution of the microspheres was visualized in-vivo by MRI or SPECT imaging post-administration [45,46]. A further study, HEPAR 2, showed that166Ho microspheres in- Table 2
Summary of neutron-activated theranostics radionuclides which are commercially available or currently under clinical trials.
Radionuclide Maximum tissue range (mm) [31]
Radiopharmaceuticals (commercially available/under clinical trials)
Diseases References
166Ho 10.2 166Ho-chitosan complex HCC, skin cancer, cystic brain tumour, renal cysts, rheumatoid arthritis and hemophilic arthropathy
[36,37,39,42,44,51,53,151]
166Ho-DOTMP Bone metastases
166Ho-EDTMP
166Ho-PLLA microspheres Liver malignancies, head, and neck squamous cell carcinoma
177Lu 2.0 177Lu-DOTATATE Somatostatin receptor–positive gastroenteropancreatic
neuroendocrine tumours
[13,25,62,63,70,71,74,78,79,81,170]
177Lu-DOTMP Bone metastases
177Lu-EDTMP
177Lu-PSMA Metastatic castration-resistant prostate cancer (mCRPC)
186Re 4.5 186Re-HEDP Bone metastases [92,96,150,166]
186R-sulfide-colloid Rheumatoid arthritis
188Re 11.0 188Re-DMSA Bone metastases [115,120–122]
188Re-HEDP
188Re-HDD-iodized oil HCC
188Re-HDD-lipiodol
188Re-HSA microspheres
188Re-SCT Skin cancer
188Re‑tin-colloid Rheumatoid arthritis
153Sm 4.0 153Sm-EDTMP Bone metastases [134,140,178]
153Sm-HA Rheumatoid arthritis and haemophilic arthropathy
DMSA = dimercaptosuccinic acid; DOTATATE = dodecanetetraacetic acid coupled-tyr3-octreotate; DOTMP = 1,4,7,10-tetraazacyclododecane-1,4,7,10-tetramethyl phosphonic acid;
EDTMP = ethylene diamine tetra(methylene phosphonate); HA = hydroxyapatite; HCC = hepatocellular carcinoma; HDD = 4-hexadecyl-1, 2, 9, 9-tetramethyl-4, 7-diaza-1,10- decanethiol; HEDP = 1-hydroxyethylene-1, 1-diphosphonic acid; HSA = human serum albumin; PLLA = poly(L-lactic acid); PSMA = prostate specific membrane antigen; SCT = skin cancer therapy.
Fig. 2.Clinical applications of currently available neutron-activated theranostics radiopharmaceuticals in different organs.
duced a tumour response with an acceptable toxicity profile, resulting in the effective treatment of liver metastases (73% of the patients showed control of disease after 3 months). In addition the use of SPECT/CT, dem- onstrated that personalized dosimetry could be performed with high precision [47]. Some recent studies [48–50] suggested that a tracer amount of166Ho microspheres (± 250 MBq) can be used as a scout dose to optimize the therapeutic dose and select patients for advance treatment planning. This has been made commercially available as QuiremScout® (Quirem, The Netherlands) and has been proven safe in clinical settings as a better predictor of lung shunts and intrahepatic distribution than Technetium-99m macroaggregated albumin (99mTc- MAA) which was originally developed for lung perfusion imaging [48–50]. Furthermore, a study by Bakker et al. showed that direct intratumoural injection of166Ho-PLLA microspheres in three patients with head and neck squamous cell carcinoma (HNSCC) was a promising and negligibly invasive method of treatment [51].
Several studies have been carried out in the Netherlands using166Ho microspheres. Surefire infusion system versus standard microcatheter use during 166Ho radioembolization (SIM) is a study that explores whether the use of an anti-reflux catheter increases the tumour to non-tumour activity concentration ratio compared to a standard end- hole microcatheter [49,52]. The HEPAR PLUS study (HEPAR plus177Lu- dodecanetetraacetic acid coupled-tyr3-octreotate (DOTATATE) in sal- vage neuroendocrine tumour patients) is another clinical trial that fo- cuses on using an additional radiation boost on liver metastases to further decrease hepatic tumour burden as well as evaluating the safety of combine treatments, dosimetry, biodistribution, quality of life (QoL) and adverse events [53]. While the multicentre HEPAR primary phase II trial is to establish the safety and toxicity profile of 166Ho radioembolization in unresectable advanced HCC patients, the study also includes efficacy, tumour marker response, QoL (through question- naires), biodistribution or dosimetry based on SPECT/CT as well as MRI and hepatobiliary scintigraphy for the assessment of hepatic function pre- and post-treatment [53,54]. In the HORA EST study (holmium radioembolization as adjuvant treatment to radiofrequency ablation for early stage HCC: a dose-finding study), patients with early stage HCC receive166Ho radioembolization as adjuvant treatment after radio- frequency ablation. This is used to determine the therapeutic dose that will result in the delivery of a radiation-absorbed dose≥120 Gy to the target area in at least 90% of patients, toxicity profile, local tumour recur- rence and QoL [53,55].
4.2. Lutetium-177
The nuclear reactor product,177Lu decays by emitting moderate en- ergyβ−particles (shorter tissue penetration range of 0.2–0.3 mm) and low-energy γ-rays which allows scintigraphy assessment of biodistribution and dosimetry [56]. Enriched176Lu target can be used to produce high specific activity of177Lu at 740 GBq/mg via neutron ac- tivation (176Lu(n,γ)177Lu) for the application of radiolabeled peptides and antibodies [57].176Lu has the highest neutron activation cross- section of 2065 b compared to other currently used theranostic radionu- clides in targeted therapy [6]. Therefore, production of large amounts of
177Lu can be easily achieved via neutron activation which is the most significant advantage of this radionuclide [58]. The emission of low- energyγ-rays enables scintigraphy imaging of the biodistribution and allows personalized dosimetry before and during treatment [59,60]. As a moderate energyβ−emitter,177Lu is more favorable than90Y which is an energeticβ−emitter ideal for treatment of small tumours [60,61]
.177Lu has a physical half-life of 6.7 d, which is comparable to131I with a half-life of 8 d. The relatively long half-life offers logistical advan- tage for supplying177Lu to places that are far from the nuclear reactor with minimum loss due to radioactive decay [58]. Production of large amounts of177Lu can be easily achieved, this being a significant advan- tage for a radionuclide to be used for targeted therapy [58].
177Lu-prostate specific membrane antigen (PSMA) therapy employs a molecule that binds with high affinity to PSMA a transmembrane pro- tein expressed in all types of prostatic tissue.177Lu emitsβ−particles that can penetrate 1 mm in soft tissue, allowing effective delivery of ra- diation to tumour cells while sparing the nearby healthy tissues [62].
Currently only a few published trials that involved about 245 patients had been carried out using177Lu-PSMA targeted therapy to treat meta- static castration resistant prostate cancer (mCRPC) and the outcomes have shown significant treatment response, well-tolerated and low- grade toxicities [24,63–68]. Thesefindings were supported by a study [62] showing that177Lu-PSMA treatment had high response rates, low toxicities and lessen pain in men with mCRPC who have progressed after conventional therapies. A systematic review and meta-analysis by Yadav et al. also concluded that treatment for advanced stage mCRPC patients using177Lu-PSMA had low toxicity profile as well as is an effective method for cases that does not response to standard treat- ments [69]. A recent prospective study on 14 patients by Aghdam et al. [70] in Iran showed the same results hence, treatment with
177Lu-PSMA can be considered the best options for end-stage mCRPC patients.Fig. 3shows an example of177Lu-PSMA being an excellent theranostics radiopharmaceutical for the treatment of mCRPC. The co- emission ofγ-rays enables post-therapeutic imaging to monitor treat- ment response [63].
A phase II clinical trial carried out by Agarwal et al. showed that
177Lu-EDTMP is an effective and safe radiopharmaceutical for bone pain palliation in patients with metastatic prostate and breast carcino- mas [71]. Another importantfinding from this study was that, no signif- icant difference was found in toxicity or efficacy for patients who received low-dose and high-dose of177Lu-EDTMP [71]. In addition to the therapeutic usage, the of177Lu-EDTMP at a dose of 185 MBq has been used as diagnostic agent where tumours were visibly indicated in the whole-body images post-administration. Furthermore, the post- therapy monitoring of the patients were accessible from the images ob- tained after 4 weeks post-injection of the therapeutic doses of177Lu- EDTMP [72]. In an animal study using healthy mice, it was observed that 16% of177Lu-DOTMP was uptake in skeletal muscle and almost all the remaining activity being eliminated through urine, thus causing less myelosuppression than153Sm-EDTMP with an equivalent dose [73]. Chakraborty et al. [74] and Chang et al. [75] have both done a com- parison study between177Lu-EDTMP and177Lu-DOTMP using animal models. Both studies showed that177Lu-EDTMP had marginally higher bone uptake and slower bone clearance than177Lu-DOTMP and these radiopharmaceuticals were found to have great potential as bone pain palliation agents [74,75].
177Lu-DOTATATE is commercially available as Lutathera® (Ad- vanced Accelerator Applications SA, France, Paris) that had been widely used in many countries for the treatment of somatostatin receptor– positive gastroenteropancreatic neuroendocrine tumours (GEP-NETs) after it was approved by the United States (US) Food and Drug Admin- istration (FDA) in January 2018 [76,77]. From the phase 3 neuroendo- crine tumours therapy (NETTER)-1 trial, patients with somatostatin receptor–positive midgut neuroendocrine tumours treated with177Lu- DOTATATE showed markedly longer progression-free survival and a sig- nificantly higher response rate than the patients treated with high-dose octreotide long-acting repeatable dose (control group) [14]. In nonrandomized trials,177Lu-DOTATATE was found to be effective in treating patients with other gastrointestinal and pancreatic neuroendo- crine tumours [78]. Patients who were active on a daily basis also expe- rienced benefits in functional health-related QoL [79]. The pre-therapy imaging of neuroendocrine tumours can be achieved using the whole- body scanning with177Lu-DOTATATE. The image quality was found comparable to 111In-octreotide and 68Ga-dodecanetetraacetic acid coupled-tyr3-octreotide (68Ga-DOTATOC) PET scans. In addition, dose estimation and treatment response monitoring after therapy to deter- mine the dose delivery for the next fraction can be accurately calculated from the177Lu-DOTATATE whole-body scans [80].
Interest in the further development of177Lu-based radiopharmaceu- ticals has been growing over the last decade due to the high theranostic potential and convenient production logistics of this radionuclide [74,81–86]. There has been an increasing number of published studies on the in vivo and in vitro applications of improved and new177Lu- labeled compounds [34]. Hence,177Lu is undeniably an extremely valu- able reactor produced radionuclide for theranostic applications and the usage is predicted to increase further in the future [81].
4.3. Rhenium-186
186Re is produced via185Re(n,γ)186Re reaction with185Re having a neutron cross-section of 112 b and isotope abundance of 37.4% [6]. It has an averageβ−energy of 0.35 MeV andγ-rays energy of 137 keV that is suitable for imaging purposes [31]. The meanβ−particle ranges in soft-tissue and bone are 1.1 and 0.5 mm, respectively [87].186Re can also be produced in a cyclotron by a (p,n) reaction on186W. However, production of high purity186Re can be achieved in large quantities at lower cost using nuclear reactors [6]. Neutron activation of natural rhe- nium target will produce both186Re and188Re, as185Re (37.4%,σ= 112 b) and187Re (62.6%,σ= 72 b) are both present in natural rhenium. The percentage of each radionuclide produced relies on the irradiation and post-irradiation period (cooling time) because188Re (T1/2= 17.01 h) has a physical half-life much lower than186Re (T1/2= 3.72 d). Hence, longer irradiation and cooling time will produce more186Re and fewer
188Re, but the specific activity is low. The proportion of188Re can be made to be less than 5% by irradiating the target for more than 7 d and a cooling period of 4 d [6]. Although the specific activity is low when using natural rhenium target (e.g. 1.3 GBq/mg from thermal neu- tronflux of 3 × 1013n/cm2/s irradiated for 7 d [88]), it is adequate for bone pain palliation and radiosynovectomy but may not be sufficiently high enough for clinical antibody and peptide radiolabelings [6]. While enriched185Re will provide a higher specific activity of 18.5 GBq/mg for an irradiation period of 2 d with thermal neutronflux of 1014n/
cm2/s [89].
186Re-sulfide-colloid is an effective treatment for inflammatory joint diseases such as rheumatoid arthritis and synovial joints [90].186Re-sul- fide-colloid is routinely applied for cases involving middle sized joints where good to excellent results are reported in 50–60% of the cases, in ankle, elbow, hand, hip and shoulder joints. Another study reported good to very good results in 83% of elbow joints [91]. In Europe,186Re- sulfide-colloid has been used for more than 25 years in Europe due to its effectiveness in rheumatoid arthritis whereby its adverse effects are negligible and intermittent [92–94]. The dosimetry assessment post- administration can be performed using the external imaging with gamma camera or SPECT/CT [95].
As a surface bone-seeking agent,186Re-1-hydroxyethylene-1, 1- diphosphonic acid (HEDP) has been popular for bone palliative treat- ments. The recommended amount of activity for bone metastases is 1285 MBq and the maximum tolerable dose is considered to be 2960 MBq from data originating from prostate and breast cancer pa- tients [96–100]. Following intravenous administration, the peak uptake of186Re-HEDP in skeletal bone can be seen within 3 h [101,102]. The low energyγ-rays, which is similar toγ-ray energy (140 keV) of the most commonly used99mTc diagnostic radionuclide, has enables SPECT imag- ing to estimate the radiation dose delivered to the bone metastatic sites [89,95]. Studies showed that overall pain relief was seen in 80% of hor- mone refractory prostate cancer patients after treatment using 1285 MBq of186Re-HEDP with an average period of 7 weeks [97,103].
It was also reported that after administration of a single dose of186Re- HEDP, signs of improvement were seen in 80–90% patient, which typi- cally occur between 24 and 48 h. The efficacy of186Re-HEDP has been proven in placebo-controlled, randomized studies [97,104]. An average of 26 Gy absorbed dose in bone metastases and 1.73 Gy in red marrow were reported when using the standard activity of 1285 MBq [97]. A high therapeutic index was observed with a mean ratio of tumour to marrow dose of 34:1 (mean value) [103]. In addition, the radioactivity was cleared in the urine and blood rapidly. Toxicity was limited to tem- porary myelosuppression, with platelet and neutrophil nadir at 4 weeks after therapy, and the treatment was generally completed in 8 weeks, marked by patient's recovery [105].
Fig. 3.Clinical example of177Lu-PSMA theranostics treatment for mCRPC. (a) Pre-treatment PET/CT scan was done using68Ga-PSMA11. (b) Co-emission ofγ-rays from177Lu enables gamma imaging during therapy to monitor treatment response. (c)99mTc-PSMA scintigraphy was done as follow-up imaging after the177Lu-PSMA treatment. GM = geometric mean;
MIP = maximum-intensity projections; p.i. = post-injection. (Reproduced with permission from [63]).
4.4. Rhenium-188
188Re has an averageβ−energy of 0.76 MeV associated with 155 keV ofγ-rays and a relatively short physical half-life of 17.0 h [31]. The maxi- mum tissue penetration range of its beta particle is about 10 mm and the mean range is 3.5 mm [106]. By using a highly enriched187Re target,188Re can be produced in a reactor via187Re(n,γ)188Re with neutron cross- section of 76.4 b. Specific activity of 22.2 GBq/mg can be achieved from 2 h irradiation in a thermal neutronflux of 1014n/cm2/s [89]. Similar to
186Re, large amounts of188Re can be produced via neutron activation that are appropriate for medical applications such as treatment of HCC, bone pain palliation and radiosynovectomy [6]. One of the limitations of
188Re is its short physical half-life which causes logistic challenge for transportation to locations which are far away from the reactor [58].
Hence, the188W/188Re alumina-based generator has been developed to solve this problem [89].188W has a physical half-life of 69.4d and it can be produced in a nuclear reactor with thermal and high energy neutrons by irradiation of tungsten oxide of 96.07% enrichment in188W [107].
The use of188Re‑tin-colloid in radiosynovectomy is particularly bene- ficial for treating large joints due to its high energeticβ−particles [108]. In a study by Shukla et al.,188Re‑tin-colloids microparticles showed greater retention as there was no leakage from the side of the knee joints and pa- tients received good therapeutic outcomes with lower whole-body absorbed dose [109]. Shamim et al. further confirmed that188Re‑tin-col- loid in radiosynovectomy is an effective treatment for patients with chronic inflammatory knee joint conditions, where a significant decline in pain scores were observed at 3, 6 and 12 months [110]. The authors also suggested that ideal candidates for this treatment are those with tiny or no swelling, shorter duration of disease, slight tenderness, ability to move, and normal/minor radiographicfinding. A multicenter study that compared the therapeutic efficacy between90Y, 32P and 188Re radiocolloids on 99 rheumatoid arthritis patients revealed that most pa- tients experienced pain relief at 1-month follow-up, achieved greater im- provement after 3 months and persisted up to 12 months [111]. The pain relief score (based on a 10-step visual analogue scale) between these three radiocolloids did not differ significantly from each other (p > 0.10). The distribution of the administered188Re‑tin-colloid and leaking of the radioactivity post-administration at different time points can be studied using gamma camera [112].
The reason of rapid symptom response after188Re administration is due to its highβ−particles energies and short physical half-life. Exten- sion of response interval and progression free survival are observed in fractionated bone palliative treatment. A study by Palmedo et al. in pros- tate cancer patients treated with188Re-HEDP for osseous metastases showed low toxicity with moderate leukopenia and thrombopenia [106]. It was also reported that repeated188Re-HEDP therapies were more effective than single dose therapies for pain palliation, having ob- tained a response rate of 92% and time of response was 5.66 months.
Liepe et al. found no indication of either systemic or local intolerance to188Re-HEDP therapy, however 16% of patients had aflare reaction with an increase in pain within 14 d after treatment [111]. Biersack et al. also documented a positive outcome of repeated therapy on overall survival with the highest mean survival rate of 15.7 months after the ini- tial therapy. It was reported that all patients had bone pain with more thanfive lesions [113]. Nevertheless, Lange et al. reported that single in- jection and repeated therapy of188Re-HEDP had similar pain response with an overall QoL response rate of 68% [114]. A recent study by Shinto et al. that investigated patients with painful bone metastases due to bladder, breast, lung, prostate and renal cancers, treated with188Re- HEDP showed that 90% of them experienced relief from bone pain [115]. It has been evident that188Re-HEDP showed clinical benefits and can be practiced in routine clinics due to its low toxicity and adverse effects, and the outcome is equivalent to external beam radiotherapy.
188Re-dimercaptosuccinic acid (DMSA) has also been utilized for bone metastases originate from breast and prostate cancers, whereby this ra- dionuclide biodistribution is similar to99mTc analogue. The uptakes by
normal bone and nearby healthy tissues are low, with significantly high uptake in bone metastases and kidney [116].
188Re-4-hexadecyl-1, 2, 9, 9-tetramethyl-4, 7-diaza-1,10-decanethiol (HDD)-lipiodol has been used for HCC treatment [117]. This radiopharma- ceutical was administered intraarterially to the liver via femoral and he- patic artery [118].188Re has a number of advantages over131I, due to its lowerβ−energy emission, shorter physical half-life, on-site generator availability and low toxicity. Treatment with188Re-HDD-lipiodol is a sim- pler process when compared to90Y microspheres and is suitable for the majority of referred patients diagnosed with HCC [107]. In an impressive multination study of 185 patients sponsored by the IAEA, it was docu- mented that the overall tolerance of intra-arterial188Re-HDD-lipiodol treatment for inoperable HCC was outstanding, resulting in three com- plete responses and 19 partial responses with 1- and 2-year survival rates of 46% and 23%, respectively [119]. The low gamma energy (155 keV, 15%) emission from188Re is ideal for pre-treatment imaging using a scout dose (~150 MBq) to determine the maximum tolerated dose to the bone marrow, lungs and normal liver as well as to calculate the desired therapeutic radioactivity to the tumour [119]. Liepe et al. re- ported that patients with colorectal liver metastases or HCC treated using
188Re-human serum albumin (HSA) microspheres with high activity above 10 GBq was well tolerated in 30% of patients and it was concluded that patients should obtain earlier and repetitive therapy to improve treatment efficacy [120]. In a study by Kumar et al., 93 patients were ad- ministered with 185 MBq of188Re-HDD-iodized oil via hepatic artery and this resulted in tumour response rates of 100%, 95%, 90%, 58% and 30% between patients with survival rates at 6, 9, 12, 24 and 36 months re- spectively, with a median survival of 980 d [121].
188Re is also ideal for targeted therapy of superficial skin cancers, such as non-melanoma skin cancer, due to the short penetration range of itsβ− particles. Currently,188Re-skin cancer therapy (SCT) epidermal radioiso- tope is commercially available by OncoBeta® GmbH, Germany where it is regularly applied for the treatment of basal cell carcinomas (BCC) and squamous cell carcinomas (SCC) [122]. A recent study by Cipriani et al.
showed a remarkable result of 36 patients (24 BCC and 12 SCC) success- fully treated with only one session of188Re-SCT and no side effects were observed [123].
4.5. Samarium-153
Neutron activation of stable152Sm will result in the production of
153Sm, a beta emitter that also emitsγ-rays at a physical half-life of 46.3 h [136].153Sm emits mediumβ−energies with an average of 0.23 MeV [31] and the mean penetration range in soft tissue is 0.8 mm [56]. In addition, it emitsγ-radiation at the energy of 103 keV, which is well suited for gamma imaging using a low energy collimator. The im- ages with high spatial resolution and low noise can be acquired after every treatment which can be utilized for evaluation of radioactive leak- age to other organs [95]. A large quantity of high specific activity153Sm can be produced via152Sm(n,γ)153Sm reaction due to the high thermal neutron capture cross-section of 206 b. The specific activity is high enough for bone palliation and radiosynovectomy treatments [6,58].
Sometimes enriched form of152Sm target is used to produce153Sm with even higher specific activity for targeted radionuclide therapy [58]. In a study reported by Ramamoorthy et al. [124], specific activity of 11 GBq/mg and 44 GBq/mg were obtained using natural152Sm and enriched152Sm, respectively. Being a low-cost nuclear reactor product,
153Sm possess many benefits for theranostic cancer management. The imaging capability of153Sm enables baseline imaging and restaging scans using the same radiopharmaceutical formulation but with lower activity to enhance efficacy and safety of the overall treatment.
153Sm has been an excellent radionuclide for bone pain palliation since153Sm-EDTMP (Quadramet®, Lantheus Medical Imaging, Inc., USA) was approved by the US FDA in 1997 [6]. The recommended dose of153Sm-EDTMP of 37 MBq/kg [125] resulted in pain reduction in 55–70% of evaluated patients [126,127]. Quadramet® is mainly
utilized to treat the pain associated with osteoblastic and mixed bone metastases, which are confirmed on a radionuclide bone scan, and has reported efficient in patients with breast, prostate and other primary cancers [128–130]. Bone metastases happens in more than 50% of differ- ent cancer types and has 80% possibility of being very painful in breast, lung and prostate cancer patients. Therefore, this treatment is highly fa- vorable for a wide group of patients in reducing bone pain [34].153Sm has several advantages over89Sr due to its lower beta energy, shorter physical half-life, faster radiation delivery, rapid clearance from the body and relatively lower myelotoxicity [6,131,132]. Pain relief by
153Sm-EDTMP generally starts after 2–7 d post-administration and can retain for as long as 2–17 weeks [127,133]. Mild myelotoxicity may hap- pen with approximately 10–40% decrease in platelet and leukocyte counts, but full recovery is expected within 6–8 weeks [127].
Kolesnikov-Gauthier et al. reported that an effective and helpful treat- ment (besides improving QoL) in patients who suffer from bone metas- tases,particularly with breast or prostate cancer, is 153Sm-EDTMP therapy [134]. Evaluation of biodistribution and dosimetry estimation of153Sm-EDTMP at 24 h post-administration can be performed using a gamma camera or SPECT/CT scanner with low energy, high-resolution collimators. The images were found similar to the commonly used
99mTc-methylenediphosphonate (MDP) bone scan [135–137]. In a re- cent study, Taheri et al. reported that153Sm-EDTMP and177Lu-EDTMP achieved similar safety and effectiveness in pain palliation treatment of skeletal metastases, whereby significant reduction in pain levels were observed after 2 weeks for both treatment groups, and continuing to last for 12 weeks after treatment [138]. Elzahry et al. mentioned that a single therapeutic dose of153Sm-EDTMP offers an effective and safe op- tion for patients with painful bone disseminations, in which 67% of the patients showed overall therapeutic bone regression/stabilization and 33% showed bone progression [139].
153Sm can also be utilized for radiosynovectomy or radiosynoviorthesis of intermediate size joints (ankles and elbows) [6]
. For example,153Sm-hydroxyapatite (HA) has been used in the treat- ment of haemophilic arthropathy and the treatment is proven to be ef- fective, safe and affordable. By injecting higher dose of 153Sm-HA, radionecrosis effect can be improved due to the optimum penetration range of the medium energy beta radiations [140]. Calegaro et al. stud- ied the effectiveness of153Sm-HA in the treatment of hemophilic ar- thropathy in ankles and elbows [140]. The study showed an observed substantial improvement in both ankles and elbows following153Sm- HA radiosynovectomy, in which the grade of pain relief measured was greater for ankles (improvement of 71% and 61%) than elbows (im- provement of 46% and 37%), after 12 and 42 months, respectively. The distribution of 153Sm-HA and incident of joint effusion at different time points post-administration has been performed using gamma cam- era scans. The results obtained from this study corresponded with those reported in the previous literatures [141,142]. Calegaro et al. also de- scribed the153Sm-HA treatment as cost-effective, minimally invasive and highly safe in managing pain and bleeding [140].
In an experimental study carried out by Hashikin et al.,153Sm-labeled ion-exchange resin microparticles (Amberlite® IR120, Rohm and Haas Company, USA) demonstrated superior characteristics compared to other radionuclides for potential use in hepatic radioembolization [143].
However, a comprehensive dosimetry studies to estimate total153Sm ac- tivity to deliver equivalent tumour dose from commercially available 3 GBq90Y microspheres, as well as animal studies for in-vivo distributions and biochemical stability prior to clinical studies are needed.
5. Recent developments of neutron-activated theranostics radionu- clides for clinical applications
5.1. Gastroenteropancreatic neuroendocrine tumors
GEP-NETs are among the most complicated tumours to detect and treat owing to their specific properties, thus patient' survival is highly
reliant on histology and stage [144]. Among all the theranostic radionu- clides,177Lu has become the most widely used radionuclide in the last decade for the treatment of somatostatin receptor-positive GEP-NETs.
In 2018,177Lu-oxodotreotide has been approved in Europe for the treat- ment of GEP-NETs as an alternative therapy opportunity [146]. IAEA has also been supporting the development of low cost and easily available
177Lu-labeled antibodies and peptides for the treatment of other pri- mary cancers such as prostate, liver, mCRPC, etc.177Lu has low toxicity, promising anti-tumour activity and improves QoL in patient, hence, the clinical application of177Lu is expected to continue to grow in the com- ing decade for a wide range of targeted radionuclide therapies.
5.2. Bone metastasis
Bone metastasis is the advanced stage of various cancers and it causes variable symptoms such as severe pain, pathologic fractures, hy- percalcemia and metastatic spinal cord compression [147]. Bone metas- tasis requires treatment that can relief pain in patient and eventually improving the QoL. In bone pain palliative treatment, radionuclides pro- ducingβ−particles with high energy are essential for the therapy, it would be beneficial however if the associatedγ-rays were of low energy for diagnostic imaging. Thus,153Sm and89Sr are the most suitable can- didates for this option since32P is no longer used due to its severe bone marrow toxicity [148,149].153Sm has more advantages than89Sr as it also emitsγ-rays that is useful for imaging. Meanwhile,177Lu,
186Re and188Re were found to be as efficient and safe as153Sm for bone palliative treatments. Other features such as capability to produce in high specific activity, suitable half-life, minimum radioactivity to the bone marrow, sufficientβ−particles energy for therapeutic andγ-rays energy for diagnostic as well as provide an extensive outcome with a single administration are taken into consideration for this procedure [147].
5.3. Radiosynovectomy
Radiosynovectomy has been applied as an option minimally invasive local treatment for refractory joint inflammations or complications. It uses ionizing radiation to irradiate the inflamed synovial membrane by intra-articular injection of the unsealedβ−emitting radionuclide coupled with a suitable particle or colloid [95]. Radiosynovectomy for the treatment of joint pain caused by arthropathies currently utilizes
186Re and90Y, as both radionuclides are commercially available in the colloidal form [150]. This treatment is easy to perform, cost-effective, re- liable and it does not cause any adverse effects, as documented so far.
Both radionuclides are applied to different types of joints;186Re is suit- able for ankle, elbow, hip, shoulder, subtalar and wrist joints, while90Y is suitable for the knee joint only. Studies using166Ho (on ankle, elbow and knee joints) [39],153Sm (ankle and elbow joints) [140] and188Re (knee joint) [110] have been carried out and promising results such as significant pain relief have been observed. Some researchers have been exploring new formulations for radiosynovectomy, such as
166Ho-labeled ferric hydroxide macroaggregates (FHMA) complex, chi- tosan complex, PLLA-microspheres and PLLA-macroaggregates. Results to date show that these formulations have good retention on the admin- istration site and no significant leakage of radionuclides was observed in animal studies [151]. Eventually, other radionuclides can also be labeled with these formulations for similar applications in the future.
5.4. Head and neck cancer
Patients with locoregional recurrences of HNSCC have limited treat- ment choices, hence a single session, relatively safe and minimally inva- sive procedure has been preferred for palliative management of this disease [51]. For treating small tumours in the HNSCC and cystic brain tumour, direct intratumoural injection can be used as a minimally inva- sive and targeted therapy whereby the radionuclide is injected directly