CIPP
!"#$%&'() $!*
! "+
! "!#$ %&!'!
()&!#'!!## '!()&!#*!!%+%'
!%&!,- #*!#*!!#$!&!
'#,!+) '!#$.-+!-- !/0% -%&!+!
(# 1#! !*!+!,*!/0 %&!0*!
2 1$0' '#,!32$
*! 4 -!'+ '/,
3, 5 +# *!'+667,(Stufflebeam) ,C1'#D#
!*!!!EF EF %! %&!
EF % ,'''2EF 'EF
*0, ,/, --+' %G *!
!#$G !.!#+
+0 CIPP Model ! 4 O - (Context Evaluation) U%%* ( Input Evaluation) ( Process Evaluation) , /,/, + (Product Evaluation)
,, , 'O*! 3 3#! 5&!%Z+' # 1#*!.,/,,4$
'% %1%#%+! 3#! 5&!)&!%,*!
.,%,. +,%#'*!.
3#!,(UD*!3#! #% !*&
-%%.' -!, 3 %1)&!#- -*!3#! #' ,#!*!% 3#!
!1 / #, 5&!)&!,,/
,! ! %,! %-
*0," -* ! ,!!# ! +-' 4 O*& !!')(,Z#% ,
%3#!- %&! 3$!+
#% % *(! (Stengths) ,% (Weakness) *!3//!/3#! 5&!
%-')2&C-O,!%' ' 3#!,
$ #, /,,4$ ! *&+) '!#$*!
3#!+Z- ! %1(*! , * ,3#! + /, -#'%+!/,(Impact) , /,,4$ (Outcomes) *!3//!,3#!
! CIPP %+,*! %!- 2 OD G # # (formative evaluation) , ' (Summative Evaluation) ,#
/!! ! +3#!#
/,-/,!- UD '#-! 5&!%*0,, /0/ - !-*/! , ' 4 O !*&
#%&!,C1*!!% % /- ! %/3#!
-! *' #0# # !55 /, 5&!+!,!# , !1 +) %1)&!3#!, , /,0#3$## 3#!
-!' 4 O !%&!#/0 /,3#! G 3+!
/0*%,*!3#! ! 3 ,C1% !+
#)!+-
- #%-+!
- #+/-
- /!-- - - #'#'(%-
#+! /,*! -' ' ,!, ' /, -/,!-! '#'(%++) '!#$!- - /,0%*# ',!,!# , ,!1 +*'# 3#!UD '# -, +) '!#$ /0 %-') -* !3#!-!%3#!- '(%' -, 5&!,- ' +%'' 4 O (Efficiency) *!3#! G %&!#/0 /,%
O #!+! /, 0% +
#)!+-
- -,)&!#%,G - - /'+ '/,--
- /- %!
- #'(%!
/!' 0 0
0
0 (internal evaluation) # /, !*!
!3 #,!/0*!!+! -*0, !" !, .+ )+%'
!*!+! (self-evaluation) ,# %&!*+e + !!
+! ! ,C1'#D*! /,O*!')2&C # ')2&C +!!+!-*0,-'0" !+! ,%-+%'
% O
/!#./1 %.2'$
1. % % *(!*!+!
2. *0, ! !*!+!
3. '!#/ +O %-%
4. !/, '41 ,-*0,!/"
!+-
0
/,O (external evaluation) # +%'# 1O !*!!5&!3, ##, 3 -*0,
# 1#*!! 5&!3$+ !!,,# 1O !*!!-+Z- !
&'
1. -*0, ! !- 2!+!
2. /,e + !, /,+.!-!
3. -*0,!/" ! !# 1O + . !*&
4. -*0,+' #+*!3#! ! ! %+!G *!')2&C
$)
+Z )&!,+,!*! ##,e + ! # 1## 1O*!
$)' #., ,, CIPP 4 $)
/,%+! !-+Z 5&!/0 +!
-# 1O+1g$ !+-
1. +Z)3$ (Utility Standard) % %- ''2%,+!/0+! ,#/, +!*0,+!+/0/, 0 ( /0 #0%$ /0#! !*! i,i) ,- 3$" ! !-% ! 3j)')*0, !+!- ##, (2&C #0 /0 ) (% !3$*&
2. +Z#-- (Feasibility Standard) % %' ! *&% !## 2 , ! -6 F6l ! 4 %+!
#--!e + % ! # #,'
3. +Z#'(Propriety Standard) % %
!)0+!+m %1,#&!)&!'' O*!/0*! ! , #-/,
4. +Z#)0+!(Accuracy Standard)) % % '!(,-''2 !# #!,C1'#DG
# 1##*!3#! ! 4 %&!+!#)0+!
*0,)- #! +!')+!+!-% !
##)'01$++!+! ,!/0*0,)- *0,+#% ! 4 #$,'/, )0+! ,/, #
' +0 CIPP Model %-!
')+%'- 3 0 CIPP (.
0 G # % ! 3!'+%'- ,'!'!!## ! %+! !+!++Z
#
' /,*6U! +!,$ 4 "!%
! "5( : !% ! #7&"8 #! 16 1 3!,3, O! %! C1 3, ! 17-18 # 2551 3 % , /,2&C*!3, 2 #2'+%$
, '+667, (Prof. Daniel Stufflebeam) ,2'+%$ , ,, #' (Prof. Allen Gullickson) %2'Z
