F F F - ThaiScience

<=>?@A B^*

"# $

"DEF" #B!GHI?JKL"MENB"@<MO?PEQM>"BG "EQ"RM R"?S"RTUJKLQ?O VQGWXTEG"UQTGBGO?M>"BGEQJKL"MENB"S"@<MO?P UO OYMEF""MENB"S"R"Q? RM"MENB"S"R" Y"D"YI?UQTB!GHI?UZSLTEQ"MENB"

XRO?P VQGTBXB?="O?PS"BBRM>"BGB!GOQTGE>NBUOSLTEQJKL

"MENB" QTGWXTEG"UQTB!GHI?!"GS#TS"RTJKL"MENB"B?M>"BGM![>

RMUQT"ZUMGAS#TRT"V ?T?M>"

#%%# : M>"BG "MENB" "MENB" R?EQYEQ"

* BYGA [ #VG! LGGB"RO" Y?LQB"RO" 40002 BEA: natthapg@kku.ac.th

Vibration Serviceability of Footbridges and Its Mitigations Natthapong Areemit ^*

Abstract

This article presents the vibration serviceability problems of footbridges and its mitigations. There are several newly designed and constructed footbridges over the world known to have vibration problems and some of them are presented herein, both vertical and horizontal vibration. Then, the mechanisms of vibration generation due to pedestrians are explained. The guidelines for bridge designers are subsequently given in order to prevent, as well as mitigate the excessive vibration problems. Finally, vibration mitigation measures are also given.

Keywords: footbridge, pedestrian bridge, vibration serviceability, vibration control

* Lecturer, Department of Civil Engineering, Khon Kaen University, Khon Kaen 40002, E-mail: natthapg@kku.ac.th

1. "%

LS"BBRM>"BGZL "EQ""D"

RO?YLS"BBRM>"E>NBB?

YYB?G">L"M E"NB?Y"DZL"

MZ"M>"BG"D" OB"T?"TBGRMX?B?

M>"BGrYM"Q OB"T?Er E"NB?Y WXTBBRYM Z"I?HI?X@<AB?M>"BGEF"

L (Yang and Huang 1997) RMQTGE V"VG GSLO#OGSLTHT?M>""Q Er?UQT RM""rO?WSLTM>"BGGSLO BOB"ULRMVBEQ"MENB"UQT?OGG?ID"

JKL"MENB"B?M>"BG"D"D?RO S"BQ G?"OS"#O?""B?L"D"

EQ"EF"Y?LMBGO?>TBE>G?"E GZSLTM>"

EQRT Y"[GL?TB?BB Z?LT L"""M>"E>NBuB?"JKLQ?O (Hearn and Metcalfe 1995) "MENB"@<M"D ELYZB"B"E"NB?YY?LMT EQ" HBQ>TB? H!#B?M>"

"BY"DG?EF"WYV ?T?M>"BG OBO" L"O? (Damping ratio) OB"T?Z

"BEL"NBYJKL"MENB"S"R"Q?

E"NB?YY?LMEQ"UBQ>TB? H!#

B?M>"RT S"#O? 10 OWO"G?"HI?

JKL"MENB"B?M>"S"BXRL"I? NB

"S"R"?B?M>" wI?>OURM ELRO?Y"MENB"S"R"Q? ?"YG LG#D"UQTRQ?SLTELr"OJKL"MENB"?QT"

T?"DEQYx>"!A"MLO?WXTS#TM>"RM

"MENB"B?M>"EB? RM"MENB"YM

@<ME>MQID"ENBGP BGO?QErLYZ""B?

WXTS#TE>G?>B (Fujino et al., 1993, Dallards et al., 2001a)

S" "DYM"ZE"BUB?"MENB"

EQID" BGO?B?M>"EQJKL HI?!S#TS"

RTUJKL"MENB"Q?O

2.

2.1 AB#

M>"BG"D#O?G 33.6 E RM T?

2.4 E (X 1) YYQ>O O H

!#B?M>"BGXO 2 Hz RM OBO"

L"O?BGXO 0.005 M>"BGRLO?"D I B?V ?T?M>""TBGZSLT O H!# O OB"T?ZENBEGM>"BGBN" WXTS#TM>"BG RLO?"DHXTHI?"MENB"UQTBGO?#QEY"RM ?OB BQ[GS"S#T?" ELB?

JKL"D"YY?LMEQ"B?WXTS#TEO" H

!#B?M>"BG "BY"DM>"G? O BO" L"O? OB"T?Z

C 1

(Poovarodom et al., 2003) 2.2 T-Bridge GBH

M>"BGRLO?"DE#NBOBH"HVQGUG?

"z"QSLKO S""LGQYI?YMWXT "YZ""

EQ"?#zRMTB?EQ"TM>"RLO?"D (X 2)

@<MV ?T?B?M>"EF"M>"I?RUO GD?LQ 180 E RM T?

5.25 E M>"RLO?"D O H!#B?"

S"R"Q?B?VLQ 1 RM 2 BGXO 0.73 Hz RM 2 Hz ZQRM O H!#S""R"

?B?VLQ 1 BGXO 0.90 Hz wI?L>Y<

@<MB?R?MZQ?UQTOT?T" M>"

"OYM" OB"T?"R?S"R"Q?E"NB?Y H

!#B?M>"BQ>TB? HB?TET

>BQ

XQT"T?

XL"TQB?M>"

C 2 T-bridge 12 (Fujino et al., 1993)

BGO?UrQYYQ"MENB"B?

M>">OM>"RLO?"DJKL"MENB"

?R"YMEQJKLY"S"R"Q?

JKL"MENB"?QT"T?"DYMUOEQID"BGO?

""SQ ROYMEQID"ENBYZ""B?WXTEQ"BGXO"

M>"E>ID"RMTB?EQ"BGXO"M>"RTEF"

MGMEL"I? UB?"BGO?"R?"DUQTHX B!GUTO ENBM>"E"WXTS#TM>"YM>GG Y?LMEQ"SLTETY?LM"B?M>"

E>NB@Q Y?LMEQ""DZSLTY?LM EQ"B?WXTS#THXETL" RMO?WZSLTMQ

"MENB"B?M>" "R?G?ID"

I@"DEF"?"#D"RPB!GHI?x>"!A

"MLO?WXTS#TM>"RM"MENB"B?M>"

2.3 Millennium Bridge G LM M>" Millennium Bridge RLO?"DBQTRO"DZ EAS"?B"QB" (X 3) M>" G D?D" 332 E RO?BBEF" G#O??M>"

144 E G#O?|J}?EL"NB 80 E RM

G#O?|J}?ST 108 E D?B?T?B?M>"

E EE>NB"DZL"M>"QT"M 4 ET" VQGMGM TB?#T? (Sag) S"#O?? 2.3 E RMEG?

B?E EBETLM>"S"#O?? 1.73 E

?EQ""M>" T? 4 E

C 3 Millennium Bridge ; 1<= (Dallard et al., 2001a)

C 4 ;?;@A@A

Millennium Bridge BCDEF@G@AHI J (Dallard et al., 2001a)

M>"RLO?"DEQS#T?"ENB 12 H"G" 2543 S""

"D"WXT "YZ""OEB?RMEQ"BGXO"

M>" G?"O<MWXT "EQ"BGXOErM>" >

EHXTUQTHI?"MENB"?QT"T?

MQX?WQ Y"WXTS#T?O"TB?YM>"LNB HI?LGQEQ"E>NB@QSLTEB? ENB EGEG H!#RMBO" L"O?

B?M>""D>O OD?B?rBGXOS"#O?>UQTS"

M>"BN"P JKL"MENB">"D@<M TG I?"MENB"?QT"T?B?M>" T- Bridge S"MEK€" NBENBYZ"" "EQ"BGXO"

M>"YZ""Y"HI?MQL"I?YMZSLTM>"EQ

"MENB"BGO?"R? (X 4)

3. MO P$Q$P"RP "MENB"B?M>"BGELLY EQ"B?WXTS#T EQ"YM ErEGS"

TETBGXO 2 TOB" R?EQYEQ""D HRGB? AMBUQTEF" 3 ? NBR"Q?

R"G RMR"?B??EQ" wI?

R?EQID"S"R"Q?"D"EQYYQX"GAHO?B?

O?GE NB"S"R"Q?Y?LMTET (X 5) VQG HEGS"TETBGXO 2 TOB

" O"R??"D"YMEQYE NB"B?

YQX"GAHO?E>NB@QB?O?G (X 6) wI?YM H I?L"I?B? HS"TET Y YQR?EQID">OR?S"R"Q?YMQO"X?

Q

C 5 KD;LAB;1F MNODA O AP;L (Fujino et al., 1993)

C 6 QADAB;1F MNODA O AP;L (Fujino et al., 1993)

RYZB?ENDB?T">GGB!GHI?GMEBGQ B?R?EQYEQ" NBRGB? AMBB?R?

QTGB"XEGA E"NB?YR?EQYEQ"

@<MEQwDZEF"?B B? AMBB?R?"DH B!GUQTQTG

) 2

sin(

)

( _{i p i}

p t G G if t

F = +Σ α π −φ (1)

VQG ^G NB"DZL"B? "EQ" (N) αi NBM!‚

B?B"XEGA fp NB HS"TETRM φi

NBEB?ƒAV" i VQG i NBLGEB?ƒAV

" >Y<YD?LQ n ƒAV"

Vertical components

21 45 62 69

216

0 50 100 150 200 250

2 Hz 4 Hz 6 Hz 8 Hz 10 Hz

Loading, N

C 7 M?AK;LL;B;L (Bachmann and Ammann, 1987)

Horizontal components

23 6 25 7 9

0 50 100 150 200 250

1 Hz 2 Hz 3 Hz 4 Hz 5 Hz

Loading, N

C 8 M?AKKD?L;B;L (Bachmann and Ammann, 1987)

YI@B? Bachmann and Ammann (1987) RQ?SLTELr"HI?RGB? AMBB?R?EQ YEQ"EF"ƒAV" O?P VQGYMELr"OZLR?

S"R"Q?"D" YMƒAV" >ND"="BGXO 2 Hz VQG QO"B?R?X?HI?TBGM 37 B?"DZL"B?WXTEQ"

(X 7) O"R?EQID"R"?"D"YM OE>G?

TBGM 10 B?R?EQID"S"R"Q? wI? OZO (X 8) RME"NB?YR?EQR"?"D"Y?LM E NB"?QT"T? H>ND"="B?R?

>YI? OE>G? I?L"I?B? ErT "" NB 1 Hz VQGY?LMTETB?WXTS#TEQ"BGO?BM YM O HEGS"TETM< 2 TOB

" ROHTLM>"WXTS#TL"R"O"BYYMZSLT UOHEQ"UQTBGO?BM O?WSLTY?LMS"T ETHX VQG ErB?|X?#"O"SLKO RMBY ZSLT HS"TETQ?ELNB 1.4 TOB"

LNBZO"D" (Fujino et al., 1993)

E"NB?YR?EQID"R"Q? OX?OR?

EQID"S"R"? S"BBRM>"BG WXTBBRO?E"T"U>GGLEG?UOSLT H

!#B?M>"XR"S"R"Q?UBQ

>TB? HB?EQ" D?"DE>NBLEG?ZB"

(Resonance) E>MS"BQE GEL<A"

"B?LEQ"EF"Y?LMBGO?>TBE>G?" UQT ZSLTM>"BGEQRT S"MEK€""D"

TBZL"QS"BBRO H!#B?

M>"BGYMTB?UOBGXOS"#O? 1.5-2.3 Hz

ZLR?EQID"S"??"D" L YZ""B?WXTS#TM>"UOL"R"O" YMUOZSLTEQ JKL"MENB"B?M>" ROHTLWXTS#T M>"YZ""RTZSLTEQ"B?WXTS#TROM "UO HEQ"UQTBGO?BM WXTS#TM>"YMHX? SLTEQ"

Y?LMB? "O"SLKO wI?BYYMZSLTR?MZ M>"MQ"GZ KRMZSLTEQ

"MENB"UQT

YHOG[>E NB"ULB?WXTS#TM>" T- bridge "D">O "MENB"S"R"YMUOEQID"

""SQWXTS#TEQ"BGXO"M>" ROYMEQID"L?Y OWXTS#TYZ""EEQ""M>"U#MGME L"I? VQGY[>E NB"ULUQTRQ?SLTELr"O WXTS#T M>"?O"YMY?LMEQ"B?"EB?SLTET

Y?LM"MENB"B?M>" RM""ZSLT

"MENB"MQID" JKL"MENB"

@<M"DG?>UQTS"BLGM>" E#O" M>"

Millennium Bridge (Dallard et al., 2001a) RMM>"

Clifton Suspension Bridge (Macdonald, 2008) wI?

UEQJKL@<M"DYMUQTB!GS"LTBHQU 4. MO P$Q$P"RP

#

R?EQYEQ"">ND"BGXO"? RO?

YR?EQYEQ"">ND"M>"E NB"

E"NB?YWXTEQ""M>"E NB"LNB

"MENB"YM>GG@QB?EB?SLT?

BGXOUQT @<MEQ"WB?E NB"B?>ND"

EGTB?R"DEGO Synchronization phenomenon (Bachmann and Ammann, 1987) LNB Lock-in effect (Dallard et al., 2001b) W NBWXTS#TM>"YM

>GG!EQ"QTG?T?ID" wI?""r O?WSLTO"B?ZE NB"?QT"T?ID"

RMZSLTEQR??QT"T?ID"UQTG S"I@B? Dallard et al. (2001b) O ENBWXTS#TM>"EQ"QTGY?LMBQ>TB?" RM x>"!A"MENB"B?M>" YMZSLTEQ R?"QEF"QO"VQG? ErS"

E NB"B?>ND"M>"

) ( ) (t kv t

F = (2)

ENB ^k NBM!B?R??EQYEQ"

RM ^v(t) NB ErB?"MENB"?QT"T?

B?M>" wI?LG OWXTS#TM>"EQ"BGXO"

M>"<MEQ>…R"D YMZL"TENB"

EF" Negative damping LNB#OGE"MENB"SLT MQ"R?ID" QTGWXTS#TM>"rYMTB?LGQEQ"E>NB BSLT"MENB""D"QMQ? "BY"D Dallard et al. (2001b) G?UQTSLTTBQTGO JKL"DYMEQ M>" H!#ZO 1.3 Hz RMYZ""

WXTS#TE>G?>B wI?YZ""WXTS#TYMOBSLTEQJKL"DYM HM<UQTY

k N_L 8πcfM

= (3)

ENB c NB OBO" L"O? f NB O H

!# M NB modal mass RM k NBM!‚

B?R??EQYEQ"

C 9 ;?D;KL;B;L?I

;@A@ (Nakamura et al., 2008)

C 10 K;@A@L;B;L?I

;@A@ (Nakamura et al., 2008) "BEL"NBYYQRM?E>…

"MENB"?B?M>"BGY?RT G?UQT >GGS"I@S"LTB?xHI?R?

EQID"E"NB?YEQ"">ND"E NB"UQT VQG Nakamura et al. (2008) UQTZI@E>EE>NB YQR??E"NB?YEQ"VQG>Y<W B?E NB"B?>ND"WEQ"ETUQTG VQGSLTO BGO?EQ"BGXO">ND"B?E NB?EGO (Shaking Table) HE NB"?QT"T?UQT (X 9) WQB?

RQ?SLTELr"OR??EQYEQ"">ND"

E NB"UL? YM"QE>ID"MQB?

"MENB" VQG>OR?"QT"T?YM"QBGXO

S"#O?TBGM 10 MQE NB"B?>ND" 10 E RMYM OE>ID"EF"TBGM 15 B?"DZL"MQ E NB"B?>ND" 70 E "BY"D HB?

"MENB"G?WOBR?EQID"QTG (X 10) HI?RTYM>GG Q<AWB?EQ"B?WXTS#T LGP " ROQB?rG?ZVQGSLTEQ""RWO">ND"

M " RT"ZW"[GL?

5. Y ""

R"?S"BBRJYY"BGXO 2 R"? NB Z"<LB"B?Y?B?M>"RT YBOBGXOS"E<†AGBUQTLNBUO B R"? NB>GGBBRSLTM>" O H

!#X?O HYMZSLTEQx>"!AMLO?

WXTS#TM>"RMM>"EB?

AASHTO (1997) UQTR"M"ZSLTZME"

M![>QT">AB?M>" L>O M>"BBR O H!#ZO 3 Hz BGO?UrQ E?NB"U"DYMUQTGET"LV ?T?B?

M>""DZL"OR"M"ZS"="

=" BS5400 (1978) UQTB!GHI?!

YB"MENB"B?M>""S"R"Q?

ZLM>" H!#ZO 5 Hz

"BY"DG?ZL"QQTGO LM>"SQ H

!#B?"?ZO 1.5 Hz YMTB?

ZE MLA"MENB"QTG!?>A BGO?MEBGQ

Ontario Highway Bridge Design Code (1983) ZL"QSLT>Y<M>" H!#B?

"MENB"S"R"Q?ZO 4 Hz wI?ZO OZL"Q UTS" BS5400 O EO?X?QB?M>">Y<

D? 2 =""DYMTB?ZOE<†AZL"Q

"BY"DE>NBuB?" Modal Coupling MLO?

"MENB"S"R"RMR"Q? YI?UQTZL"QUT S"="QTGO H!#B?M>"UO ZO 4 Hz RM 1.5 f ENB f NB H!#

ZQB?M>""D"

Pimentel (1997) UQTZEGEGQYZQB?

"MENB"ZL"QUTS"="O?P Q?RQ?S"

X 11

C 11 ;?KD;L ?Y;@

(Pimentel, 1997)

C 12 ;?KD? ?Y;@

Z; BQ@FPO 60 A@Y;@D (ISO, 1992)

TBZL"QEGMQ"MENB"O"SLKO YM>Y<E>M"MENB"S"R"Q? ISO 10137 UQTZL"QTBYZQ"MENB"S"R"Q?RQ?S"

X 12 wI?YM>O#O?WXTS#TM>"YMXTHI?

"MENB"S"R"UQT?OGQ NB"MENB"

S"#O? HID"UHI? 2 Hz

6.

R"?S"RTUJKL"MENB"B?

M>"BGR>ND"="QHZUQTVQG EG"XRB?V ?T?M>"E>NBEG"R?

O H!# !"DHM? AE>NBLEG?

UOSLT H>ND"="B?M>"U? H B? AMBB?R?EQYEQ" B"YMZSLTEQ ZB" "" NB LEG?UOSLTM>" H

!#S"#O? 1.6-2.4 Hz ZL"MENB"S"

R"Q? RMLEG? H!#S"#O? 0.8-1.2 Hz ZL"MENB"? BGO?RTJKL QTGR"?"D NBM>" Cragside Bridge wI?UQT E Rr?R?E>NBE>E"B?M>"E>NBZSLT H!#X?ID" (Wilkinson and Knapton, 2006) ROLUOHBBRLNBEG"R?SLT H!#BGXO"B#O?Q?OUQT !"GS#T S"RTJKL"MENB"B?M>"BG NB E> OBO" L"O?SLTX?>BYM

"MENB"B?M>"SLTBGXOS"MQBQ[G D?S"R?O XTIB?WXTS#TRM BQ[GB?V ?T?

M>" BGO?B?!S#TS"E>BO"

L"O? NB L"O? O Tuned Mass Damper (TMD) wI?YMMBUQTG? (Spring) (Mass) RML"O? (Damper) LZ?"B?L"O?

O NBZSLTL"O? O H!#

EO O H!#B?M>"TB?

"MENB"QTGENBRM?ELM

"ZL"O? O <E#O""DUQD?UT"

V ?T?YM#O?Q"MENB""V ?T?UQT BGO?UrQ M![>B?L"O?YMQ?BGO?

L H!#B?L"O?UO? H

!#B?V ?T?TB? E>

L"O?ETUYM#OGZSLTM![>B?L"O?

OUOEG"R?U"RT H!#B?

L"O? OYMUOEO H!#B?V ?T?

>BQ BGO?B?M>"BG"ZL"O? O

#OGRTJKL"MENB" NB M>"BGS"

?E>L" (Poovarodom et al., 2003) M>"BG Millennium Bridge (Newland 2002) E>BO" L"O?SLTV ?T?G?

HZUQTB!QTG Tuned Liquid Damper (TLD)

!"DYMBGYB?ELS"<ELM

?S"[#"M VQG[#"M"D"YMGIQBGXOV ?T?

TB? "MENB" ENBV ?T?

E NB" ENBGYMZSLTB?ELS"[#"M E NB"S"??"T"MENB"B?

M>" RM#OGQMQ"MENB"B?M>"?UQT S"?<HTTB?E>BO" L"O?SLTX?ID"

YM"ZMR?LNBOGU?E NB"

B?PEL E>NBZSLTG>??"UQTG?ID"

M>"BG T-Bridge S"MEK€"rUQT"ZEB TLD US#TS" "MENB" (Fujino et al., 1992) 7. B

JKL"MENB"EQID"M>"BG LGXR WXTEG"UQTGBGO?JKLEQID"

M>"BGO?PG?" VQGUQTB!GHI?

>…XRO?PZSLTM>"BGEQ

"MENB"S"MQOBSLTEQ ?B?WXTS#T Y BGO?B?M>"BGGSLOYMELr"O @<M V ?T?M>"YM"Q OB"T?E>G? Z SLT EG?OBEQJKL"MENB"UQT?OG S"O"TGB? WXTEG"YI?UQTB!GHI?!

"GS#TS"RTJKL"MENB"B?V ?T?

M>"BGRO?P 8. P

American Association of State Highway and Transportation Officials (ASSHTO). 1997. Guide Specification for Design of Pedestrian Bridges.

Washington, D.C.

British Standards Institution (BSI). 1978. British Standard Specification for load; Steel, Concrete and Composite Bridges, Part 2. BS5400, London.

Bachmann, H. and Ammann, W. (1987). Vibrations in Structures Induced by Man and Machines.

IABSE-AIIPC-IVBH, Structural Engineering Documents, 3e.

Dallard, P., Fitzpatrick, T., Flint, A., Low, A., Smith, R.R., Willford, M. and Roche, M.. (2001a).

London Millennium Bridge: Pedestrian-induced Lateral Vibration. Journal of Bridge Engineering.

Vol. 6, No. 6, 412-417.

Dallard, P., Fitzpatrick, A.J., Flint, A., Bourva, S.L., Low, A., Smith, R.M. and Willford, M. (2001b).

The London Millennium Footbridge. The Structural Engineer. Vol. 79, No. 22, 17-33.

Fujino, Y., Sun, L., Pacheco, B.M. and Chaiseri, P.

(1992). Suppression of Horizontal Motion by Tuned Liquid Damper. Journal of Engineering Mechanics. Vol. 118, 2017-2030.

Fujino, Y., Pacheco, B.M., Nakamura, S.I. and Warnitchai, P. (1993). Synchronization of human walking observed during lateral vibration of a congested pedestrian bridge. Earthquake Engineering and Structural Dynamics. Vol. 22, No. 9, 741-758.

Hearn, G.E. and Metcalfe, A.V. (1995). Spectral Analysis in Engineering: Concepts and Cases.

Butterworth-Heinemann.

ISO. 1992. Bases for Design of Structures- Serviceability of Buildings Against Vibrations.

ISO 10137. International Standardization Organization. Geneva, Switzerland.

Macdonald, J.H.G. (2008). Pedestrian-induced vibrations of the Clifton Suspension Bridge, UK.

Proceedings of the ICE - Bridge Engineering.

Vol. 161, No. 2, 69-77.

Nakamura, S., Kawasaki, T., Katsuura, H. and Yokoyama, K. (2008). Experimental studies on lateral forces induced by pedestrians. Journal of Construction Steel Research. Vol. 64, 247-252.

Newland, D.E. (2002). Vibration of the London Millennium Footbridge: Part 2 - Cure.

Proceedings of the 9th International Congress on Sound and Vibration. Orlando, Florida, July 2002.

Ontario Highway Bridge Design Code. 1983.

Ministry of Transportation and Communications, Highway Engineering Division, Ontario.

Pimentel, R.L. (1997). Vibration Performance of Pedestrian Bridges Due to Human-Induced Loads. PhD Thesis, University of Sheffield, Sheffield, UK.

Poovarodom, N., Kanchanosot, S. and Warnitchai, P. (2003). Application of non-linear multiple tuned mass dampers to suppress man-induced vibrations of a pedestrian bridge. Earthquake Engineering and Structural Dynamics. Vol. 32, 1117-1131.

Wilkinson, S.M. and Knapton, J. (2006). Analysis and solution to human-induced lateral vibration on a historic footbridge. Journal of Bridge Engineering. Vol. 11, No. 1, 4-12.

Yang, S. and Huang, D. (1997). Aesthetic considerations for urban pedestrian bridge design. Journal of Architectural Engineering.

Vol. 3, No. 1, 3-8.