:
!"# $% &'( &)
* 1
, ,
. !"# / 0 12
* 2 ,
#$% $&
* #4 56 02
8 12 8 1432
;<=
#4 6.
15 8 02 8 1433
<=
,
?@
A B '( : )*
+, -.
/ 0 123 4$ 56 789 :,; ; ,<=> 4?@ A+B C;+ D$E FG H 4
I
5$ '=9J K?6 L6 D$E FG H 4/ M?N$ O?FPJ QJ +, R O?N<;S
526 FGS TFG ,
T?U86 ,?;V QJ #$% $& FG 5$
W, XY W, 4Z[ 0 \]
2009 2010 I _S D`$$ aBS ,T?=;$ ab FP H 4/ H;]$ aB -. +, cU;= D,dB
D%e;$ 5$ 4bS 4/ H;]$ \ fFJ,>
: ,_6. &SS ,W, 4?Z<; H;]$S ,W, H;]S ,?9 h=S , $ ij=S ,kKE
lP m(S ,5; H;]$S T>n. '=b
?UZo. > Dp qB >. r[CK$
α<0I05 I 0 5F; %][J 0 ?UZo. > p $s+. s?n 'js+BS
4/ H;]$
t;F]= $ ?9 4$6 uv( N( I 6I5
t;F]= $ $ ij= 4$6 uv( \o 0 ,T$s+. L6x abS % 0I9
% T$s+. 4_x S I
S 0
,? yP/ ,<=> 4?@ $ !`C;+ QJ zp {|
, D$E FG H 4/ H;]j 3FK; s;P+ 59j y;
I
C?! 'D
?=,x D$E FG ,?ZC8 D}] ,4?Z<; , $ f}=B ,4/ : I
________________________________
_________________________________________
________
Factors Influencing Shyness among Jordanian University Students: A Field Study
Nedal Kamal Al- Shraifin(1), and Ahmad Abd Allah Al- Shraifin(2)
Yarmouk University
(Received 29/10/2011; accepted 09/01/2012)
Abstract: This study aimed at exploring the influencing factors of shyness among Jordanian university students using stepwise multiple regression procedures. To achieve the objective of the study, the shyness scale for university students was administered to a random sample consisted of 526 students from Yarmouk university students, enrolled in the second semester of the academic year 2009/2010. The results revealed that the shyness level among students was low. Furthermore, the Correlation Coefficients between shyness and each of: Gender, parenting styles, Faculty, academic level, academic achievement, physical handicap, religiosity and height were generally low, but statistically significant. All predictors Contributed significantly in explaining the variance in shyness. Faculty factor explained 6.5% of variance, which was the highest contribution, where the parenting styles factor explained 0.9% which was the lowest contribution. Based on these findings, the standardized multiple linear regression equation was derived, which can be used for predicting shyness among university students.
Keyword: Shyness, parenting styles, Achievement, Personality traits, Jordanian University Students.
________________________________________________________________________
_ ________
1
#,8$ p;+B
~ S ~d, k[K Q6 Q]N ,
? ?b ,
#$% $&
,.
,
?jd ?=,x 9j ,
A ! 566 ~ $ ,
21163 (1) Associate Professor, Department of Psychology and Educational indicative,
Faculty of Education, University of Yarmouk Irbid, Jordan, p.o box: (566), Postal Code: (21163)
XS9 :
e-mail:
2 6]$ p;+B
~ S ~d, k[K Q6 Q]N ,
? ?b ,
#$% $&
(2) Assistant Professor, Department of Psychology and Educational indicative, Faculty of Education, University of Yarmouk
E : ']? 1 4/ 1 J E
N( ,1
5S, SKJ }b ,MS%$S f_F? sK6 @
&, z;j t= l/ [ T[S tJ ;b 0 5$ R t=BS ,k[K NY 5$ r[CK$
{ e
D[Z 5$ %S I
0 a$ 4 N( zp $S
5$ )SB $ L6 T+?_ ,4/ 1 ?][K A;b s ;o ,HVx ?][K };
S,F$
Zimbardo
6 4/ lo 1977
, S ~*
\YoF }; t?&J 0 |S ,S t ab
<=
)*
1
Fitts, Sebby & Zlokovich, 2009
I ?o
D+, 0 TP$ Tj= 1%Vx DK] Dsd T=S ,so|S ?;= ;1 )* ?sK
> (b 0 (x 1?o 0 %2J ;
(Hane,
Cheah, Rubin & Fox, 2008
I
7;V y; D<PZ 5$ T?,J 4/ S TYo ?Y<F sE '+ N( ,s[J lo aYoF
T@ YbB 498 4/ s[$ ?|;
TN + ab }6
Spere & Evans, 2009
, R&,$ R }b
7S,S
Margraf & Rudolf, 1999, 5
t= 4/
:
aB [ y; 7_ KS ,lFN % R/
[ s?( 46[;
5V $
I )`$S a]?= $B
Nelson et. al, 2008, 606
t= 4/ ( 6 N(
:
~3 498 ?6};&> 7_ 0 o ,8
T?b ?6};&> 7_ K -.
I ,S= %8S
Bandura
Q; ?j6 6 ,P; 4/ aB -.
F 5$ ( y6};&>
a]9,. N; }K? ,P?< m?
Erickson
,P; $x ?;= 4/ aB
y&9?]
Stranda, Cernab & Downs, 2008
I
'SKJ y; D[; 5FJ 5$ Q L6S yS ,TFNJ tJ=9$ L6 [J> QJ t=B >. 4/
:
&?][S ,?b]S ,?[=>S ,?(
? , S
-. aYoF V %S N ] D[; 4?@
t= 4/ 7J :
4[ S, L6 l PZ$
5jr;JS ,?6};&> 7_ 0 [ ?F]
)*
?F] S :
,8S ,R/S ,ONS ,J;
>
,J y6};&> #] 'FbS ,o 6S ,#F
S ,_;
,4; L6 1,N 6S ,<;
?;= R,>S ,Q[ R[&S ,N D 1S [ sj y; ?F] ,9(xS ,D* NY 6 5V $ 46[; L6 1,N 6S ,tJp 56 I
_S 3 AF+x +, aYoF lSKJ
5$ Yb l/ [ D[S 4C ,+,
<K L6 D+, zJ cU;= ?CJ 59jS :
[?d / N(
4C 3 AF+x 2008
:
,(x H 5$x 6 68$
S $ ?+B
:pjKS ,]E D_6S :S ,
~ I _S 4Y$ \?$E FP D+, 'j;
\]o +,
,2009
#K aB -. D,dB y;
; y; D[Z 5$
7Z a. p. ,l/ P ¡
K;S ,?6};& D_`6 59J 0 t O?r ,8S ,¢ ';8;S \ GC;
y6};&> 46[; {K2B 0 o 6S I
y$E P $9; ?ZC8 {K S T(
T?++B !@ * ,$ES y$E P
[ ?ZCd {K L6 D$E I
)* O?N<;S
4$ +, };> 5$ > ab ] ?ZC8 ,s;FP 4/ 0 23J y;
5$S Q2 R; a£(
L6
Ho. 498 O?_ 498 4/ PFJ 4$
@ 0 ?++x DP/
aB 59j 5* FP
¤J uN ?6};&> 1{[9 ?jK; ?][K 16] Q
Q¥
I
* s[$ +, ~ <F yK6 N(
D+, 5$ #KS ,D$E FP 4/
z?d +, cU;= D,dB N( ,zp lo '&B y;
,8$S
Cheek & Melchior, 1990
-.
_`6 &S
y D* N; B ]¦S 4/ \ t?GFJ, :
,y[? 4FN;]S ,]E 1,NS ,D* o
?jbx 1,NS ,X}]E sS I
MS%$b $B
Cramerus, 1998
H&B N( , ,?6};&> $C ?j+ $& FG L6 +,
6 &S -. sU;= D,dB y6};&> 4/ \ _`
* NKS D* yF] Q??N; 5$ 4bS ,s& 5$
4/ H;]$ aB -. z*b cU;K D,dBS ,R/S
= H tK$ L6B ab ,b* H I
+, 0S
D&,$S ,S,
Roeder & Margrat, 1999
L6
aB -. sU;= D,dB ,?=x D$E FG ¢
H T,8;= 4/ $ YbB 5$ ab FP $B F]K FP
%51
7_ aFK; 5* F]= '=bS ,
ON ?;= ?6};&>
%47
t;F]= $S , %18
aFK;
lS3]$ Cd $B ¢
I
S ~%F+ H&B HVB s& 5$
. k=[
(Spere
& Evans, 2009
-. sU;= D,dB +, B aB
\?$E FP 4V 1 0 Qs]J y; 4$
?Zo H;]$ XJS ,¢ D,s Qsb`;$ 6 Q¥ e D[
, Qs?Z@ XJ -. (|.
W, I 4/ H;]$ aB -. z*b cU;K D,dBS
Tr[CK$ ab ?9$x D$E FG H I
l;]b $B yF=KJS ybbSBS DS, S
Crystal, Parrott, Okazaki & Watanabe, 2001
4/ \ _` ($ -. '( +, S&B N(
D$E FG H HVx ?ZC8 D}+ § S
?= S ?9$B lB 5$ ?9$x ,
D,dB ?o
j 2; FP H 4/ H;]$ aB -. cU;K ¡ _ ¡8$ +, 0S ,P
(Hoyos,
( 2006
4/ \ / D+, cU;=
?9$x D$E FG H ?(NY lxS ,
iFJ D$E FG H 4/ aB sU;= D,dB ?(N2 4$
?(NY lx 1> a9jb FP
?[/S 4
N;
, &S -. D,dB }b
P ¨?Z<; H;]S 4/ \ ©96 fFJ, I
Kb 0 J%FB $& FG L6 +, 0S
University of Alberta Canda
=Sb$ &B
Macdonald, 1998
= aB -. sU;= D,dB
,b* 5$ T`V YbB I
, t|,J $ *S M +
Bas, 2010
+, cU;= D,dB ?o -.
aB
T`V YbB ,b*
a8 = aBS ,= 5$
&S -. (|. ,,b* 5$ YbB ?][K 1o _`6 .
?][K 1oS 4/ \ ? ª ,
H&BS
M>9?$S =`&
Hoglund & Mcholas, 1995
\ _` lo +, =* ,8S 4/
|J 5* ?9$x D$E FG H reS 5* FP aB -. sU;= D,dB ,m?+ «B D/
T`V YbB Q m?+ «B D/ |J FP 5$
4/ H;]$ abS ,D/ z; |; ¬ 5*
,b* H tK$ L6B = H I
loS H ?j?; Rx |S ?®B
4/ D;]j s;_`6S QsPPVS D$E FG D%dS a}+S =%J +, cU;= D,dB ,Q¥
Turner, Husman & Schallert, 2002
#`;$ aB -.
1[¯ 1_ N <| ?FN;] R FP ,Q; P8=B 0 fC=` FP T?(b k? tK9S
Q¥ 4/ 5$ §[CK$ H;]$ O?N<;
, Q 4
Q; D?+ 5$ #`;$ -. &<
* Q?K;S I
N ] D+, ;+ l`V 5$ °o`
y 1 +, 'SKJ y; D+, Q$ aB 4/ PFJ 4$ a T}6 ,?FK&B D+,
±
$ o -. (NY R`;V 7;
I ?®B 5$ Q L6S
~ aB >. ,P ?ZCd {K 0 1
² 56 <F 'j; y; D+, N;[
³; S ,yF] #] * 0 Qs]J y; 4$
,*& E$ s;E$S sK$ ¢ L6 4j I
_S
, )* D{&
R; R¡ + L6
§ ,S
D%e;
4$
FG H 4/ N;
´YoF o`$ ?;= z*bS ,?=,x D$E aB \
SB b,8j ;+ Q¥ k? FP 5$ T%Yb ,9(x G SB ,PJ y; D>]; 56 &
6 4/ 6B ,sS ,µNK 0 lVS 0 Qs?
yF] #] · ,QsU`$ $B QsYo {K2B ,Q¥
* 4/ h|j };> 5$ > ab
){,S 5j9J y; AF+x 56 <FS I
DF F]= 1 ?;= +, 98$ 'NYF=
'?o _S ,D$E FG \ ?b] D`98
;> D`98 )*
<FS } I
N(
§ D,dB
\?$E FP &$ 0 1 -. D+, #K aBS ,?][= ,8;+ D$V L6 lZ<
18 ?o 5$ FP D`98$ L6 DBG D%eJ hKS I D`98 5$ 4/ fFJ,> T=S
Z 0 T?++B T,¯ ),F;6S ?[=>S ?][K <
4C 59j 5j( ,?][K −
5$ %8J }b
aB D+,
©[K 7?9; 56 y$E P
$
?$E m?F ,
?J?¢ D> 0 N; 56S
R; e +, )* J * ,[;C L6
4/ 0 123 4$
, S q aYoF N; y;
iFJJ ,?FK&x D+, 0 sr lSKJ QJS ,4/
4Y$ ? D+, 0 SKJ Q; ¬S :
,kKE
, $ ij=S ,?9S ,y$E H;]S H;]S ,W, 4?Z<; H;]$S ,59] a9$S aS ,5; H;]$S ,D_6. &SS ,~Z;_>
;lP m(S ,1F )* ,S @ K]J $ p. t=x
c$ QNJ D$E a9$£ a9?+ D%e;
P ²ª ,S 4?[J 4&B 5$ ( d,
H;]$ \]@ ³; S ,4/ 5$ X ab lo 0 S ,FP H ?][K <Z Q2 5$
D$E 16]$
5$ 'm8=B ~* ,S O?N@ L6 {K S t&B
y$E P =;S $9; ?ZC8 I
@S T 6 &¸ '+ +, )* a£(
L
?J m+x :
1 D$E FG H 4/ H;]$ $ .
+, D%e;$ {| 0 ?=,x
ij=S ,kKE
,?9 h=S ,59] a9$S , $ W, H;]S ~Z;_> H;]S ,y$E
,$E 0 yjbx 4?Z<; H;]$S ,1«
aS ,_6 &SS ,P 5; H;]$S lP m(S ,1F
?
2 ?UZo. > Dp _`6 #K 4 .
α<0I05
D%e;$ 5$ %e;$ º4¤bS 4/ H;]$ \
??=,x D$E FG H +, 3
$ . ®]$ '®+ y; D%e; ?JJ
?UZo. > Dp
α<0I05
%e;$ 0 5F; %][J 0
??=,x D$E FG H 4/
G2
+, )* ?®B OYFKJ 5$
\F=&
~= lSx :
+, a£( K ?®x ?o 5j( ,yN?FPJ XYS S 56 789 0 Qs]J 4/ H;]$ \ _` _
aB 5$ T_`P= ,+, D%e;$S D$E FG H % lJ $ 4/ H;]$S D%e; )* \ _`
<|S I 1,K 1& (|. +, )* J }b
4$ 56 789J y; ?<S ? D+, E FG H 4/ 59J 0 ®]
D$
I 5$S
)* cU;= 789J aB 59j ?N?FP; ?®x ?o P 4V 0 Qs]J y; 4$ 56 +, ,D$E 0 a S a?K s[N;?( ,y$E {&.S ,?&`6 c$ S iPV |S L6 ajS a9? 1 )* 5$ ¢ L6 4jJ ?6n P8=B y$E P ,( Z;_ []( -. _ T;K$
R, 1S$ + ?ZCd ~p G cC;
46( 498 tFN;]$ 59J L6 )6]J y; D,sS I
5H! IJKL M"?
7_ 0 [ ?F] 4[ S,
?6};&>
,
?F] 4[ S, 5jr;JS :
,J;
S ,ONS
> ,8S R/
,J ,o 6S ,#F
,<; S ,_; y6};&> #] 'FbS N D 1S ,4; L6 1,N 6S ,D* NY 6 ?;= ;R,>S Q[ R[&S 6S ,tJp 56 [ sj y; ?F] ,9(xS 5V $ 46[; L6 1,N
I NS +, 0 M
M?N L6 ?;] s?6 4Z y; &, ?¢
\[ ),G ~* +, )* 0 C;]
\[S
I2011
% FG 5$ K?6 L6 +, K?6 D¼;_ -
1v?; NP ,?;V QJ #$% $&
I
y $C;] +, 1B - :
?N$
4/ M
\[S \[ 4F_ 5$ ,P
I2011
7; 0 ¯ C;] 4/ s[$ -
yU&
I
H?40. N$?O FG ?n 5$ +, j; a9J ?j+ ?=,x D$E 0 \?=,x M,9F
W, 5$ XY 4Z[
2009
½FS ,2010
Q6 1,S 56 ,Z yUZo N; %8 }b
yj <FS ³ Q?;
2010 165644
QsK$ ,FGS TFG
70181
S TFG
95463
FG
D$& 6 L6 \6$
I
40
#$% $& FG 5$ +, K?6 ,?;V QJ 1v?; NP
Available Sample
4j T= ;
§ ,?;V aYoF _ ?o ,$E 0 \YoF
NP ?=]=S ?j D?9 5$ 8 ,F8 y ,?;V> 1oS '=bS ,NK ?U8 +, K?6 (B 6 ½ p.
FGS TFG 526
I
2 +, )* 0 aYoF C;+
4/ M?N$
\[S \[ ),G ~*
C;+ 2011
a9J N( ,~ S ©[K M?N 0 Y¢ K 5$ ?UsK tJ,Z M?N
45
M?N ;¾S ,1N(
D`$$ D,_ ?o ,F+K$ $9?+ UZC
\;NP M?Nj DFY ,
®>SB : P C;+
?=YS ,M?N 0 ?N;
: = C;+
1N[ ;+>
I
?N; P F]K $B ,
QJ N(
C;+ ¨V ]J> DF2 4$$ :C;+
¿F=Sb $ )* C;+ t;j?_ 'e _S ,α
NP 0.95
1N[ ;+> = C;+ $B ,
N(
L6 lZ¢ QJ 5$ 49 1,<; Q?N
5$ \6= L6 lZ¢ QJS ,(x D,_S DN[
D`$
: (x !/ DFY 4$$
(Person
Reliability
DN[ !/ DFY 4$$S ,
(Item
Reliability
I 5$ 49 DFY D`$$ Q?_ 'e _S
(xS DN[
, 0.97
0.92
L6 a;j?_ ®S ,³;
a;[J$
a%8J ?; Àl6 DFY ;j; M?N aB -.
4/ %e;j _`6 Dp 7_$ 0 t$C;+ ?=9$.
I N( ,Z 1;$ D>> M?N ;¾ }b
,NG 5$ Yb M?N 5$ ON<; QJ
?o QJ
yNPK Z 5$ ON<;
Logical Validity
5$
s[$ 4?@ OG 56 zpS ,~K 4?<; l`V B 4Y¾ DN( ;b l`V 5$ ,tJ=9$S 4/
4/
tJ=9$
4F_ 5$ sj?9@S ,s;? NGS ,
DN( 4J QJ ?o ,\ZZC; 5$ 6j Q?9<; cU;= L6 T};6 M?N I
NG ¤J ?o
yNPK 4?<;
Logical Analysis
P Ho.
{K 5$ ON<; C;]J y; D{&S M?N DSB
Construct Validity
P 5$S ,
M?N 5$ ON<; '$C;+ y; HVx ?GFJ,> P
Correlational Techniques
,
¨$ 4?<; NGS
Factor Analysis
, _S
D,dBS UZC M?N ;¾ -. P )*
$9?+
FN$
I
PE QRST L6 M?N 4j;d
;+> Q;J ,1N( 45
b c,; W}/ D9? Q+ O(S sK6 :
1%Fb
M?N ?<ZJ K6 PJS ,T&
1%Fb ,D&, 5
PJS PJS P+;$ &, OFPKJ ,D&, 4
3
?_ &, S ,\;&, PJS ?_ &, ,D&, L6 OFPKJ D&, )*S ,1oS &, PJ &
c,; k9 \o 0 ,? ª. NP Z DN[
?F] DN[ 0 I
M?N D&, SJ z* S
\ 49b
− 45
225
ab $` '[J, }b ?< ,
L6 TÁ3$ zp FP H 4/ H;]$ 1
I _S
L6 Dm( k¦ -. K? (B D ;+ aYoF 7K
<K :
4Yj;JS ,T& r[CK 4/ H;]$ m(
&, L6 \¢ 0
4_( 1.49
S , H;]$ m(
SJ &, L6 \¢ 0 4Yj;JS ,§[CK 4/
\ −1.5
&, 2.49
S , ]$ m(
,i+; 4/ H;
\ SJ &, L6 \¢ 0 4Yj;JS
−2.5 3.49
&, S , \¢ 0 4Yj;JS ,[J 4/ H;]$ m(
\ SJ &, L6
−3.5
&, 4.49
T%VBS , m(
L6 \¢ 0 4Yj;JS ,T& [J 4/ H;]$
&, Yb( 4.5
I
UV?
:
QJ
$ 4$;
L6 +, )* 0 D%e;
<K :
W4 - ,T?UK2 T%e;$ ),F;6 t$ 4$; QJ :
j?NS ,b* [ j?N 'ZZVS
1
=¸
I
D X - T%e;$ ),F;6 t$ 4$; QJ :
j?NS ?j D?9 [ j?N 'ZZVS ,T?UK2 1
= D?9
?=]
I
I< Y ?@ - t$ 4$; QJ :
\ Q?_ t 'ZZVS ,T?F?JJ T%e;$ ),F;6
1
K]
-Sx S 4
Yb( K]
I
ZD@ X - t;+, {K2B 0 tK9+ a9$ ~B :
,T?F?JJ T%e;$ ),F;6 t$ 4$; QJ ?o ,?$E Q?N t ZVS
3
p.
1«x $ 59] ab ,
S 2
SB 4?$ $ 59S 1«x :,V 59] ab p.
{`$
, S 1
)[j 59] ab p.
I
I$"<<( S<<R? ?@<< - l ~B :
*K$ $E 0 P s+, y; j yjb t$ 4$; QJ _S ,+, '_S ;oS ¡ t_<;
J T%e;$ ),F;6 T?F?J
I 0 j; 7?KZ; j;6S
Q?N t ZV ?o ,FP 7?KZ; $E
1
p.
T;· N; ab
84-100
, S 2
T?& N; ab p.
T&
76-83.9
S , 3
T?& N; ab p.
68-75.9
,
S 4
T>FN$ N; ab p.
60-67.9
I
" [$ - ),F;6 t$ 4$; QJ :
Q?N t ZVS ,T?F?JJ T%e;$
1
$]; ijK
,
S 2
i]; ijK
S , 3
¢ ijK I
Z"? ?@ - T%e;$ ),F;6 t$ 4$; QJ :
j?NS ,\K; FP [ j?N 'ZZVS ,T?UK2 1
&; zpS ,\K; % FP ?;]j l3+ t?
6 . }
> ,5;$ % B TK;$ ab p ?;] aB }?+
zp % B TK;$ ab p. $ ($ L6 ,_x I
\S?6] ?@ - ),F;6 t$ 4$; QJ :
Q?N t ZVS ,T?F?JJ T%e;$
1
[J 4V
,
S 2
i+; 4V
S , 3
; 4V X
zpS ,
,tJ«B 4V M?N L6 ?;] NJ l`V 5$
4V S p£(
u¤6 ,K 800
SJ p.S ,T[J$
\
500-800
u¤6 ,K 56 4_ p.S ,TP+;$
500
FP 5$ K?6 {, L6 T};6 zpS ,T?=;$ ´¤6 ,K I
60^ K. - F;6 t$ 4$; QJ :
T%e;$ ),
Q?N t ZVS ,T?F?JJ
1
?ZCd _6.
S ,
2
1«x (B H _6.
S , 3
_6. & >
I
# _ - T%e;$ ),F;6 t$ 4$; QJ :
Q?N t ZVS ,T?F?JJ
1
{r?
S , 2
{j+
,
S 3
?PKo I
&` - J T%e;$ ),F;6 t$ 4$; QJ : ,T?F?J
Q?N t ZVS
1
Yb( Q+180
S , 2
−170 179
Q+
, S 3
4_( Q+169
I
JSCL . a$ST '( 3FKJ +, +, )* J -.
R;
L6 N;] D%e; ®]$
mFK;
, ,8 E P 4/ H;]j 3FK; 0 TN + s?.
y$
t FK; SB ; %e;
I 4?@ NG '$C;+ _S
Ybx D%e; \?; zpS ,; yP/ ,<=>
0 s$s+. ?o 5$ ?®B
; %e; 0 5F; %][J I
bJ?
¨?<; 7 +, 5$ {E * lSK;
?UZo DE cU;=
6 &¸ '&B y;
L
0 123 4$ 56 789 -. ( +, m+B }?(S ,?=,x D$E FG H 4/
¨ 6
m+x O(S cU;K )*
:
c].2 :
&. &@d E? bJ?4 H;]$ $ :
D%e;$ {| 0 ?=,x D$E FG H 4/
+,
a9$S , $ ij=S ,kKE
,y$E W, H;]S ,?9 h=S ,59]
4?Z<; H;]$S ,1« ~Z;_> H;]S H;]$S ,_6 &SS ,$E 0 yjbx
$N lG m(S ,1F aS ,5;
?
lSE \FS
1
DP+;
¢ ? ]
D(<=>S 49b 4/ M?N$ L6 ,?
I
&.K
* 1 , e UV? fg. PE h0 40 d?] " gR]. d@i `?
e
UV?
UV? "?@
j@i [?
\ kR]
?@
,bp 2.42
i+;$ .82
=.
2.22
§[CK$ .66 W4
¨9 2.28
§[CK$ .72
NdT &.K
* 1 e, UV?
UV? "?@
j@i [?
\ kR]
?@
$];$
2.22
§[CK$ .68
yP]J 2.81
[J$ .86
o 2.26
§[CK$ .65 " [$
¨9 2.28
§[CK$ .72
K$
2.27
§[CK$ .78
_ 2.24
§[CK$ .62
Q?Ã 2.60
i+;$ .87
2.77
[J$ .66
ZD@ _D
¨9 2.28
§[CK$ .72
?j6 2.46
i+;$ .78
?=]=.
2.08
§[CK$ .59 D X
¨9 2.28
§[CK$ .72
-SB 2.44
i+;$ .81
?=2 2.33
i+;$ .72
Y2 2.23
$ .68
§[CK
Yb( , 2.16
§[CK$ .67
Y ?@
¨9 2.28
§[CK$ .72
l6 2.53
i+;$ .82
i+;$
2.17
§[CK$ .66
a;$
2.83
i+;$ .61 lm \S?6] ?@
¨9 2.28
§[CK$ .72
;·
2.80
[J$ .91
& ?&
2.22
§[CK$ .68
?&
2.13
§[CK$ .61
lFN$
2.33 i+;$ .65
I$"( SR? ?@
¨9 2.28
§[CK$ .72
5;$
2.22
§[CK$ .68
5;$ %
2.49
i+;$ .84 Z"? ?@
¨9 2.28
§[CK$ .72
NdT &.K
* 1 e, UV?
UV? "?@
j@i [?
\ kR]
?@
?ZCd _6.
2.70
[J$ .96
1«x (B H _6.
2.66
[J$ .89
_6. & >
2.26
§[CK$ .70 60L K.
¨9 2.28
§[CK$ .72
{r?
2.20
§[CK$ .74
{j+
2.67
[J$ .74
?PKo 2.21
§[CK$ .65 # _
¨9 2.28
§[CK$ .72
Yb( Q+180 2.74
[J$ .78
− 170 +179 Q 2.22
§[CK$ .74
4_( Q+169 2.21
§[CK$ .65 &` ng
¨9 2.28
§[CK$ .72
lSE 5$ °o`
1
²]o i+;$ L6B aB
~Z;_> H;] %e;$ O(S ab 4/ M?N$ L6 ½ ?o ,X; ~Z;_> H;] DSp «
R<= 2.83
~,?$
I.61
=B ½ \o 0
;$
i+
,?9 h= %e; TN(S t][= M?N L6 ²]o
?=]= D?9 FP T@S ,
?o ½
2.08
~,?$ R<=
I.59
DP+;$ a °o` }b
= H sK$ L6B '=b M?N L6 ,b*
, Q,
Tr[CK$ ab }s?b 0 4/ H;]$ aB I
O(S $B
$ ij= %e;$
TJS[J #K aB °o`?(
\
DP+;
, ³o ,[ S
\ i+; 0 0.59
¤$ 5* FP i]; ijK Qs?6 M,
S ;¾ 5*
¤$ 5* FPS ,i+;$ 4V H;]j Qs?6 M,
$]; ijK S
§[CK$ 4V H;]j ;¾ 5*
I
`?( 59] a9$ %e;$ O(S $B \ TJS[J #K aB °o
DP+;
, ³o ,[ S
\ i+; 0 0.52
H;]j ;¾ 5*S ,F 0 aK9] 5* FP 5*S N 0 aK9] 5* FPS ,i+;$ 4V
§[CK$ 4V H;]j ;¾ I
h= %e;$ O(S $B
TJS[J #K aB °o`?( ?9 P+; \
D , ,[ S
³o ?j D?9 FG \ i+; 0 0.38
S D?9 FGS §[CK$ 4V H;]j ;¾ 5*
?=]=
S
§[CK$ 4V H;]j ;¾ 5*
I $B
\ TJS[J #K aB °o`?( W, H;] %e;$ O(S
DP+;
, ³o ,[ S
FG \ i+; 0 0.27
-Sx K]
S ,§[CK$ 4V H;]j ;¾ 5*
K] FGS S
4V H;]j ;¾ 5*
\ S[ zJ ']J }K? ,§[CK$
~Sp FP \ $ o -. M?N L6 DP+;
s& 5$ X; ~Z;_> H;]
, ~Sp FPS
s& 5$ i+; ~Z;_> H;]
FBS ,?=2
[
[ °o` \o 0 ,i+; 0 0.66
%e;$ O(S 4/ M?N$ L6 DP+; \ |
W, 4?Z<; H;]$
, ½ ,[ S
0.67
,
T_( #K aB °o`S FP H 4/ H;]$ \
s& 5$ \K;
, HVB s& 5$ \K; % FPS ,
,[ S 0.26
\ | [ °o` \o 0 ,
&S %e;$ O(S 4/ M?N$ L6 DP+;
O(S FP \ P+;$ S[ '=b }b ,_6
1F a %e;$
, ,[ S
I0.47
* °o` }b
4/ H;]$ ab N( ,lP m( %e;$ O(S [
lP ~Sp FP
P+;$ Yb( Q+ 180
tK$ L6BS T
lP m( ~Sp FP 5$ 49
−170
m(S ,Q+ 179
lP 4_( Q+ 169
, 4/ H;]$ ab 5*
Tr[CK$ Q¥
, ½ ,[ S
i+; 0 0.53
I
ab FP t ;¾ ~* 4/ H;]$ a£( 6 498 S Tr[CK$
I S[ )* & 5$ ON<; R¡S
. QJ ,
~ox 5F; 4?@S D ,F;V {&
%e;$ 4b +K $ O(S I
QJ N(
C;+
D ,F;V
´P+; \ [ ?UZo > ( L6 \
lSES kKE %e; 4/ M?N$
2
zp |
I
&.K
* 2 , e PE h0 oL. (p I`? d E$ ?q bJ?
D(
e
W4
j@i [?
\ kR]
$6 JSCL ]
,bp 159
2.4212 .82355
=.
367 2.2230
.65542 2.939
.003
lSE l`V 5$ °o`
2
( &S
~p
?UZo. >
α<0.01
tJ,Z 4/ H;]$ 0
?9 kK H
, FP ZS aB ~B ,,b*
= 5$ T`V YbB ,b*
I 1U] $ ij= 2B ($ R¡S
1«x 0 L6
,D$E FG H 4/ H;]$
lSE 0 \F$ }b ,~ox 5F; 4?@ {&. QJ I3
&.K
* 3 , e h0 ?@ \C Z"? r bJ?
" [$ UV? s@C D( PE e
0$
d X$O
"i K d [.
k $6 ] ?@
D6j \ 14.825
3 4.942
10.159 .000
D6j 4V 253.915
522
.486
−
−
¨9 268.741
525
−
−
−
lSE l`V 5$ °o`
3
p S( &S D
?UZo. >
α<0.01
4/ H;]$ DP+;$ 0
$ ij= R`;V> HJ I
,?UZo > Dp S[ _$ <;S t?[?d ,F;V C;+ QJ
Scheffe
D=,Nj
lSE 0 |$ }b ,F
4
I
&.K
* 4 , e [$4 " E bJ?
t!u ?q 5A?d D( PE h0 "
e
Q@? n!
j@i [?
= 2.2234 [@?
j@i [?
= 2.8169 5wi
j@i [?
= 2.2621
$];
²]¢ i+;
= 2.2234 ---
.59345*
-.03872
i];
²]¢ i+;
= 2.8169 ---
.55473*
¢
²]¢ i+;
= 2.2621 ---
lSE l`V 5$ °o`
4
~p ( &S
?UZo. >
α<0.01
ij= ab 5* FP m( \
$]; ijK Q«B 0 1U] $ ,
z*b ,i]; ijK ZS i]; ijK m(S Zo. > ~p ( &S ?U
α<0.01
ijK \
aB ~B ,i]; ijK ZS ¢ ijKS i];
Q«B 0 U] $ ij= 5* (x T`V YbB Q i]; ijK I
4/ H;]$ 0 ?9 h= 2B ($ R¡S lSES D ,F;V {&. QJ ,?9 tJ,Z
5
zp |
I
&.K
* 5 , : D UV? s@C D tTSd PE h0 ?@ ?q e
D
j@i [?
\ kR]
$6 JSCL ]
?j 275
2.4646 .77543
?=]=
248 2.0837
.58582 6.285
.000
lSE l`V 5$ °o`
5
( &S p
~
?UZo. >
α<0.01
tJ,Z 4/ H;]$ 0
D?9 FG ZS ?9 hK HJ ?9 5$ T`V YbB ?j D?9 FG aB ~B ,?j
?=]= D?9 FG I
4?Z<; H;] 2B #K ab p. }6 789S QJ ,D$E FG H 4/ H;]$ 0 W,
. lSE 0 \F$ }b ,~ox 5F; 4?@ {&
I6
&.K
* 6 , e Y SR? ?@ UV? s@C D( PE h0 ?@ \C Z"? r e
0$
d X$O
"i K d [.
k $6 JSCL ]
D6j \ 28.362
4 7.090
15.339 .000
D6j 4V 240.370
520 .462
−
−
¨9 268.732
525
−
−
−
lSE l`V 5$ °o`
6
Dp S( &S
?UZo. >
α<0.01
4/ H;]$ DP+;$ 0
W, 4?Z<; H;]$ R`;V> HJ I
?UZo > Dp S[ _$ <;S V C;+ QJ t?[?d ,F;
Scheffe
D=,Nj
lSE 0 |$ }b ,F
7
I
&.K
* 7 , e t!u ?q 5A?d D( PE h0 Y SR? ?@ " E e
z?{ n!
j@i [?
= 2.8043 K K
j@i [?
= 2.2223 K
j@i [?
= 2.1333 6|g [?
j@i [?
= 2.3313
;·
²]¢ i+;
= 2.8043 ---
.58195*
-.67093*
.47295*
T& ?&
²]¢ i+;
= 2.2223 ---
.08897 -.10901
?&
²]¢ i+;
= 2.1333 ---
-.19798
4_( i+;$
²]¢ i+;
= 2.3313 ---
o`
lSE l`V 5$ °
7
~p ( &S
?UZo. >
α<0.01
4?Z<; ~Sp FP \
;j , ?ES T& ?E 4?Z<; ~Sp 5$ 4bS m( 5$ 4?Z<; ~Sp FP ZS ,4_( i+;S
T`V YbB ³ 4?Z<; ~Sp FP aB ~B ,;j T`?Z@ 4_x FP 5$
I
R¡S H;]$ 0 W, H;] 2B ($
5F; 4?@ {&. QJ ,?9 tJ,Z 4/
lSE 0 \F$ }b ,~ox
I8
&.K
* 8 , e I ?@ UV? s@C D( PE h0 ?@ \C Z"? r e
0$
d X$O
"i K d [.
k $6 JSCL ]
D6j \ 4.836
4 1.209
2.387 .05
D6j 4V 263.905
521
− .507
−
¨9 268.741
− 525
−
−
lSE l`V 5$ °o`
8
Dp S( &S
?UZo. >
α<0.01
4/ H;]$ DP+;$ 0
y$E H;] R`;V> HJ I
$ <;S ?UZo > Dp S[ _
t?[?d ,F;V C;+ QJ
Scheffe
D=,Nj
lSE 0 |$ }b ,F
9
I
&.K
* 9 , e t!u ?q 5A?d D( PE h0 I ?@$ " E e
.2 4 n!
j@i [?
= 2.4401 4
j@i [?
= 2.3354
4 j@i [?
= 2.2372
(|g d j@i [?
= 2.1693
-SB K+
²]¢ i+;
= 2.4401 ---
.10466 .20284*
.27073*
?=2 K+
²]¢ i+;
= 2.3354 ---
.09817 .16607
Y2 K+
²]¢ i+;
= 2.2372 ---
.06789
Yb( ,
²]¢ i+;
= 2.1693 ---
lSE l`V 5$ °o`
9
Dp S( &S
?UZo. >
α<0.01
-Sx K] FG \ ,
4bS
,Yb( K] FGS YY K] FG 5$
H 4/ H;]$ aB ~B ,-Sx K] FG ZS -Sx K] FG FGS YY K] FG 5$ L6B
K]
I 4/ H;]$ 0 5; m( 2B ($ R¡S
lSES D ,F;V {&. QJ ,?9 tJ,Z
10
zp |
I
&.K
* 10 , e Z"? UV? s@C D tTSd PE h0 ?@ ?q e
Z"?
j@i [?
\ kR]
$6 JSCL ]
5;$
411 2.2286
.67805
5;$ %
102 2.4936
.83519 -3.365
.001
lSE l`V 5$ °o`
10
~p ( &S
?UZo. >
α<0.01
tJ,Z 4/ H;]$ 0
5; m( %e; HJ ?9 ,
% FP ZS
\K;
5$ T`V YbB Q \K; % FP aB ~B ,
\K; FP I
4/ H;]$ 0 lP m( 2B ($ R¡S }b ,~ox 5F; 4?@ {&. QJ ,?9 tJ,Z
lSE 0 \F$
I11
&.K
* 11 , e g UV? s@C D( PE h0 ?@ \C Z"? r
&` n e
0$
d X$O
"i K d [.
k $6 JSCL ]
D6j \ 17.224
3 5.741
11.915 .000
D6j 4V 251.517
522
.482
−
−
¨9 268.741
− 525
−
−
lSE l`V 5$ °o`
11
S( &S
?UZo. > Dp
α<0.01
H;]$ DP+;$ 0
lP m( R`;V> HJ 4/
I ?UZo > Dp S[ _$ <;S
t?[?d ,F;V C;+ QJ
Scheffe
D=,Nj
lSE 0 |$ }b ,F
12
I
&.K
* 12 , e
?q 5A?d D( PE h0 &` ng ?@$ " E t!u
e
180 n!
(|g
j@i [?
= 2.7414 170-179
j@i [?
= 2.2268 6|g 169
j@i [?
= 2.2112
Yb( 180
²]¢ i+;
= 2.7414 ---
.51458*
.53016*
170-179
²]¢ i+;
= 2.2268 ---
.01558
4_( 169
²]¢ i+;
= 2.2112 ---
lSE l`V 5$ °o`
12
~p ( &S
?UZo. >
α<0.01
lP m( ~Sp FP \
Yb( Q+ 180
, lP m( ~Sp FPS
−170 179
lP m( ~Sp ZS ,Q+
z*b ,Yb( Q+180
?UZo. > ~p ( &S
α<0.01
FP \
lP m( ~Sp b( Q+180
Y , m( ~Sp FPS lP
4_( Q+ 169
, lP m( ~Sp ZS
180
T`V YbB Q T>G Ybx FP aB ~B ,Yb( Q+
I
H;]$ 0 59] a9$ 2B ($ R¡S 5F; 4?@ {&. QJ ,?9 tJ,Z 4/
lSE 0 \F$ }b ,~ox
I13
&.K
* 13 , e r ZD@ _D UV? s@C D( PE h0 ?@ \C Z"?
e
0$
d X$O
"i K d [.
k $6 JSCL ]
D6j \ 6.471
4 1.618
3.214 .010
D6j 4V 262.270
521 .503
−
−
¨9 268.741
525
−
−
−
5$ °o`
lSE l`V
13
S( &S
?UZo. > Dp
α<0.01
H;]$ DP+;$ 0
59] a9$ R`;V> HJ 4/
I > Dp S[ |$ <;S
t?[?d ,F;V C;+ QJ ?UZo
Scheffe
lSE 0 |$ }b ,F D=,Nj
14
I
&.K
* 14 , e E t!u ?q 5A?d D( PE h0 ZD@ _D UV? "
e
4" n!
j@i [?
= 2.2743
"6 j@i [?
= 2.2426 a
j@i [?
= 2.6056
"d j@i [?
= 2.7711
K$
²]¢ i+;
= 2.2743 ---
.03162 -.33130
-.49686*
_
²]¢ i+;
= 2.2426 ---
-.36293 -.52848*
Q?Ã
²]¢ i+;
= 2.6056 ---
-.16556
²]¢ i+;
= 2.7711 ---
lSE l`V 5$ °o`
14
S( &S
?UZo. > Dp
α<0.05
5* FP \
K aK9]
, aK9] 5* FPS ,F
H;]$ aB ~B ,F aK9] 5* FP ZS L6B F FG H 4/
I Dp S( &S z*b
?UZo. >
α<0.05
aK9] 5* FP \ N
, F aK9] 5* FPS ,
FP ZS
F aK9] 5*
I
Z;_> H;] 2B ($ R¡S 0 ~
5F; 4?@ {&. QJ ,?9 tJ,Z 4/ H;]$
lSE 0 \F$ }b ,~ox
I15
&.K
* 15 , e
\S?6] ?@ UV? s@C D( PE h0 ?@ \C Z"? r e
0$
d X$O
"i K d [.
k $6 CL ]
JS
D6j \ 20.565
2 10.282
21.669 .000
D6j 4V 248.176
523
.475
−
−
¨9 268.741
525
−
−
−
lSE l`V 5$ °o`
15
S( &S
?UZo. > Dp
α<0.01
H;]$ DP+;$ 0
~Z;_> H;] R`;V> HJ 4/
I p S[ _$ <;S
?UZo > D
t?[?d ,F;V C;+ QJ
Scheffe
D=,Nj
lSE 0 |$ }b ,F
16
I
&.K
* 16 , e t!u ?q 5A?d D( PE h0 \S?6] ?@$ " E e
&0 n!
j@i [?
= 2.5329 [?
j@i [?
= 2.1743 _?
j@i [?
= 2.8380
l6
²]¢ i+;
= 2.5329 ---
.35862*
-.30512
i+;$
²]¢ i+;
= 2.1743 ---
-.66374*
a;$
²]¢ i+;
= 2.8380 ---
lSE l`V 5$ °o`
16
~p ( &S
?UZo. >
α<0.01
H;] ~Sp FP \
³ ~Z;_>
, ~Z;_> H;] ~Sp FPS
~B ,³ ~Z;_> H;] ~Sp ZS ,i+;
YbB Q ³ ~Z;_> H;] ~Sp FP aB T`V I ?UZo. > ~p ( &S z*b
α<0.01
i+; ~Z;_> H;] ~Sp FP \ ,
FPS
> H;] ~Sp m( ~Sp ZS ,X; ~Z;_
X; ~Z;_> H;]
I
H;]$ 0 _6 &S 2B ($ R¡S 5F; 4?@ {&. QJ ,?9 tJ,Z 4/
lSE 0 \F$ }b ,~ox
I17
&.K
* 17 , e K. UV? s@C D( PE h0 ?@ \C Z"? r 60^
e
0$
d X$O
"i K d [.
k $6 JSCL ]
D6j \ 6.029
2 2.010
3.993 .008
D6j 4V 262.712
523
− .503
−
¨9 268.741
− 525
−
−
lSE l`V 5$ °o`
17
S( &S
?UZo. > Dp
α<0.01
$ 0 H;]$ DP+;
_6 & HJ 4/
I ?UZo > Dp S[ _$ <;S
t?[?d ,F;V C;+ QJ
Scheffe
D=,Nj
lSE 0 |$ }b ,F
18
I
&.K
* 18 , e t!u ?q 5A?d D( PE h0 60^ K. UV? " E e
SAu 60^ n!
j@i [?
= 2.7000 l g2 60^
j@i [?
= 2.6628 60^ K" ]
j@i [?
= 2.2614
?ZCd _6.
²]¢ i+;
= 2.7000 ---
.03720 .43858
1«x (B H _6.
²]¢ i+;
= 2.6628 ---
.40138*
>
_6. &
²]¢ i+;
= 2.2614 ---
lSE l`V 5$ °o`
18
S( &S
?UZo. > Dp
α<0.01
a= 5* FP \
1«x (B H _6 &S 5$
, > 5* FPS
FP ZS ,_6. ~B 1«x H SB Q¥ &
_6. &S 5$ a= 5*
1«x (B H I
4/ H;]$ 0 1F a 2B ($ R¡S }b ,~ox 5F; 4?@ {&. QJ ,?9 tJ,Z
lSE 0 \F$
I19
&.K
* 19 , e
# _ UV? s@C D( PE h0 ?@ \C Z"? r e
0$
d X$O i K
"
d [.
k $6 JSCL ]
D6j \ 15.080
3 5.027
10.344 .000
D6j 4V 253.661
522
− .486
−
¨9 268.741
525
−
−
−
lSE l`V 5$ °o`
19
S( &S
?UZo. > Dp
α<0.01
H;]$ DP+;$ 0
F a R`;V> HJ 4/
1
I > Dp S[ |$ <;S
t?[?d ,F;V C;+ QJ ?UZo
Scheffe
lSE 0 |$ }b ,F D=,Nj
20
I
&.K
* 20 , e t!u ?q 5A?d D( PE h0 # _ ?@ " E e
)d n!
j@i [?
= 2.2043
$
j@i [?
= 2.6759
`4C j@i [?
= 2.2130
{r?
²]¢ i+;
= 2.2043 ---
-.47160*
-.00872
{j+
²]¢ i+;
= 2.6759 ---
.46288*
?PKo
²]¢ i+;
= 2.2130 ---
lSE l`V 5$ °o`
20
~p ( &S
UZo. >
?
α<0.01
FP \ 4/ H;]$ 0
{r?F 1F ~Sp ,
{j] 1F ~Sp FPS ,
{j] 1F ~Sp ZS I
~p ( &S z*b
?UZo. >
α<0.01
FP \ 4/ H;]$ 0
{j] 1F ~Sp ,
?PK¢ 1F ~Sp FPS ,
{j] 1F ~Sp ZS I
c :
< &@d E? bJ?4 #K 4 :
?UZo. > Dp _`6
α<0.05
H;]$ \
4/
,
?J D%e; 5$ %e;$ 4bS :
ij=S ,kKE
,?9 h=S ,59] a9$S , $ ~Z;_> H;]S ,y$E W, H;]S x 4?Z<; H;]$S ,1«
,$E 0 yjb
aS ,_6 &SS ,P 5; H;]$S
??=,x D$E FG H lP m(S ,1F 6 &¸
L D`$$ A]o QJ l3] *
5$ ?F?JS ?[?KZ; D%e; \ i?]F fFJ,>
s&
, HVB s& 5$ 4/ M?N$ L6 D&,S ,
$ C;+
SJ lKb fFJ, 4$
Kendall's Tau
I lSE 4YjS
21
fFJ,> D`$ ?9 cU;K
D%e; ?jE I
&.K
* 21 , e UV? Z UV? (. ?@ d [@ T]
e
UV?
T]
UV?
T]
W4 -.127*
? ?@
Y SR -.214*
" [$
.084*
60^ K.
-.076*
ZD@ _D Z"? ?@ .036
.135*
D X -.254*
# _ -.010
Y ?@
-.114*
&` ng -.171*
\S?6] ?@
-.046
40 JSC^ ] . T] ٭
* α<0.05 ,
lSE 5$ °o`
D`$$ Q?_ aB 21
\ 'oSJ _ fFJ,>
-.010
S .254
aBS ,
D%e;$
: ,W, 4?Z<; H;]$S ,?9 h=
lP m(S ,
5; H;]$S ,
DS kKES
0.12
,zp aS '=b D%e; ?N aB \o 0 , D`$ )* ?UZo > <( K6S qB \FJ
?UZo. > Dp
α<0.05
%e;$ 5$ 4b 6 $
1F aS ,~Z;_> H;]S ,59] a9$
I aBS
TGFJ, _B \ #8 5F; F]=
?9 h=
5$
s&
, HVB s& 5$ 4/ H;]$S
0.0645
5$
a %e; s][= F]K 'e }K? ,}sK$ ~B 5FJ 1F
0.0001
I c
:
&@d E? bJ?4 ?JJ $:
?UZo. > Dp ®]$ 'js+B y; D%e;
α<0.05
FG H 4/ %e;$ 0 5F; %][J 0
??=,x D$E 4?@ C;+ QJ l3] * L6 &¸
]$ ,F;6 :,; ; ,<=>
T%e;$ 4/ H;
T J z<
L6 mFK;$ D%e;$ N ] D%e;S ,
lSES ,49b +, K?6
22
4?@ cU;= \F
y; D%e; ?JJ \FS ,:,; ; ,<=>
FG H 4/ %e;$ 0 5F; %][J 0 'js+B
?=,x D$E I
&.K
* 22 , e
?
? ? R] r bJ :
Nd? UV? d T] d "w
*
R , U@<!T $H<2 I<? <n4? UV?. ,
D( 4 Nd? UV? Z"T e
" U
$4
\ |` R]
"
T ?d P
Nd T]
? UV?
T]
? ]
F I6 UV?
R2 |`
\
; Y j?N 2.806
.092 ---
30.474 .000
?9 -.357
.059 -.254
-6.018 .000
.065 .065
.000 .69322
; Y j?N 3.184
.120 ---
26.579 .000
?9 -.340
.058 -.242
-5.842 .000
4?Z<; H;]$
-.158 W, .033
-.199 -4.797
.000 .104
.039 .000
.67908
; Y j?N 2.938
.147 ---
19.970 .000
?9 -.335
.058 -.239
-5.795 .000
4?Z<; H;]$
, -.152 W
.033 -.192
-4.641 .000
5; H;]$
.191 .067
.118 2.851
.005 .118
.014 .005
.67449
; Y j?N 2.851
.151 ---
18.831 .000
?9 -.351
.058 -.251
-6.054 .000
4?Z<; H;]$
-.151 W, .033
-.191 -4.634
.000
5; H;]$
.177 .067
.109 2.647
.008
$ ij=
.088 .039
.094 2.260
.024 .127
.009 .024
.67185
lSE 5$ °o`
22
?9 %e;$ aB
%e;
L6x -Sx o 0 4VB * ,TGFJ, ,
QJS
0 W, 4?Z<; H;]$S ?9 %e;$ lV.
j?_ '=bS ,?=Y o ?9 %e; ;?
-.254
,
W, 4?Z<; H;] ;? j?_S
-.199
I 0S
T`r( 4VB YY o 6
L %e;$ \N ] 5%e;
o 0 $B ,5; H;]$
, (|. 4VB N(
$ ij= %e;$ N ] `Y D%e; -.
I D%e; $B ,kKE ys( F;+ QJ y;
H;]S ,y$E H;]S ,59] a9$S m(S ,1F aS ,_6 &SS ,~Z;_>
lP I Q?_ '=b _S * T?UZo. F
H;]$ K6
?UZo >
0.05 α<
· , ,x 4o 0
v[ 5F; aB -. %8 0
; %e;
H;]$
4/
T?UZo. T> ab I
lSE l`V 5$ °o` z*b
23
aB
VB y; D%e;
' y ,<=> :pjK :
?9 ,
W, 4?Z<; H;]$S ,
5; H;]$S ,
ij=S
-. ]];$ DPC 'VB _ , $ 3$ % FZJ y; D%e; F;+ :pjK 12
D%e; ?N &
I 6 'FYJ y; D%e; ~B
HVx D%e; & ?UZo s;>
I _S
-. V D%e; lSB ?9 %e;$ a °o D%e; $ i?] fFJ, 4$$ bB t ax ;:pjK yUZo ,F;V` j?_ bB ³; S , ; t?6S t
<K L6 -Sx 1P/ 0 :pjK FZ :
* D ,
0.357
–
2.851
=
Y
H;]$ %e;$ lV. QJ ?=Y o 0S W, 4?Z<;
, yU& fFJ, 4$$ L6B t ~*
j?_ '=bS ,?9 %e;$ DFY ; %e; $
Dp t
?UZo. >
, L6 :pjK FZ z*S <K
:
* Y SR? ?@
, –.158
* D , –0.34
3.184
=
Y
0S o H;]$ %e;$ lV. QJ YY
5;
, %e; $ yU& fFJ, 4$$ L6B t ~*
H;]$ %e;$S ?9 %e;$ 5$ 4b DFY ; j?_ '=bS ,W, 4?Z<;
?UZo. > Dp t
,
*S <K L6 :pjK FZ z :
* Z"? ?@
,
* + .191
Y SR? ?@
,
-.151
* + D ,
.355
–
2.938
=
Y
$ ij= %e;$ lV. QJ o 0S , %e; $ yU& fFJ, 4$$ L6B t ~*
$ %e;$S ,?9 %e;$ 5$ 4b DFY ; H;]
'=bS ,5; H;]$ %e;$S ,W, 4?Z<;
Q?_
:pjK FB z* S ,?UZo. > Dp t
<K L6 yUsK :
*
" [$
,
* + .088
Z"? ?@
, + .177
* Y SR? ?@
, –.151
* D , –.351
2.851
=
Y
:pjK * S :pj= 4r(B
<=
, >S ,
D%e; 5jr;
a9$S ,kKE H;]S ,59]
0 yjbx 4?Z<; H;]$S ,1« ~Z;_>
lP m(S ,1F aS ,_6 &SS ,$E
,
y; D%e; ?jE ,<=> 4$$ Q?_ '=bS
;T?UZo. 4o 4b 0 'VB ?n aB yK ·
; 5FJ 0 T?UZo. T> T$s+. Qs]J V D%e
4/ %e;$
I <; 4$$ j?_ °o`S
4o 0 '=b p. ,V D%e; 6 ,x .065
.104
.118
³; L6 .127
I K6S
