vm^mj^^j^AT^ij^p^
H A U PHIEN T O A P H U C T H A M V U A N VIFON:
Ong td cua my ii/liiiicet va Phd an iien nhan nai iceu oan
NGUYEN T A N B C T U
Tgp chi Phdp ly dd cd nhiiu bdi phdn dnh vi vu dn vd cdc phiin tda xet xd Nguyin Thanh Huyin vd cdc dong phgm trong vu dn "Tham d tdi sdn"xdy ra tgi Cdng ty Ky nghi thdc phdm Viet Nam (VIFON). Bin nay, bf dn Nguyen Bi, culf Chu tjch HDQT, Tdng Gidm ddc doanh nghiep ndy, dng td cda my Miliket vd Phd dn liin ndi tieng trong vd ngodi nddc vdn khdc khodi, nhdn ngi gCd dcfn den cdc cdquan chdc ndng, cd thdm quyin vd bdo chi di keu oan.
V) SAO Kiu OAN?
dng Nguyen Bi, nguyen Chu tjch HDQT - Tong Giam flSc Cong ^ Ky nghe thi/c pham Viet Nam (VIFON); la bi cao trong vu i n "Tham 5 tai Sein", "Co y lam trai quy dmh cua nha niidc ve quan ly kinh te, gay hau qua nghiem trpng" va "Lam dung tin nhiem chiem doat tai san" xay ratal VIFON
B^n an hinh sii phuc tham so 26?/2014/HSPT ngay 19/5/2014 cua Toa phuc tham TANDTC tai TP Ho Chi Mmh da ket an va xijl phat ong 8i 15 nam tiJ ve tpi
"Oh ^ lam trai quy dinh v^ quan ly kinh t^
cua Nha nifdc gay hau qua nghiem trpng"
ve cac hanh vi tiJ y chia thufing 290,000 USD (tUdng difdng 4.705,295.680d} va chi thi/dng khong so tien 3.507.990.667d, T^ng c^ng hai khoan la 8,213.268.347d.
dng 6i keu oan vi cho rang ket luan cua Toa an cap phuc tham la khong khach quan, khong diing quy djnh cua phap luat va khong dung suthat dien ra xung quanh hanh vi chi thiicing,
ThiJ nhat, khoin tien 290.000 USD, cac cd quan tien hanh to tung ket tpi ong Bi thucing s3 tien nay cho 7 can b6 cua CSng ty ma khong thong qua to chfic Cfing doan, la vi pham Dieu 32 Nghj djnh 27/1999/ND-CR Tuy nhien, ong Bl ky quyet djnh khen thiicing vao ngay 4/6/2004, thSi diem nay Cong ty VIFON la C6ngty Co phan, do do mpi hoat dong cua Cfing ty C^ phan do Dai hpi cd dfing quy^t djnh, ngn viec khen thiicing nay khong b i t buoc phai co y kien cua to chi^c Cfing doan. Do do, trong thdi gian dieu tra vu an cung nhu tai phifin t5a, 66 chu quan cila Cong ty VIFON la Bp Cfing Thuong deu xac djnh la 86 khong bj thiet hai ve tai san.
Ml cOa Vifon chiem 75% thi phdn d th trudng Slovakia. Ndm 2011, trong chuyen di thdm quae gia ndy, dng Nguyen 8i (bia phdi} duac Tong thong Slovakia Rudolt Schuster ti4p ddn.
m'^ khac, Nghi djnh 27/1999/ND-CP khong CO Dieu 32 Vi la cfing ty co phan nen hanh vi cua ong Bi cung khong vi pham Oieu 6 Luat Ke toan nam 2003,
Nhu vay, cac cfl quan tien hanh to tung da can cti' vao dieu khong c6 trong van ban phap luat de kgt toi, la da lam oan cho fing Nguyen Bi.
Thif hai la khoan tien 3.507.990.667d.
Cac cfl quan tien hanh to tung va Hpi dong xet XLf tai phien toa xet xii phuc tham deu k§t luan ong Bi la ky chi thufing va viec chi thuflng sfi tifin tren 3,5 ti dong nay vi pham Difiu 6 Luat Ke toan nam 2003.
Su that la sfi tifin 80.000USD {tUdng duong 1.241.280.000d) dUflc ong Bi ky duyet Giay dfi nghi thanh toan va Phiiu chi so 348/08 ngay 27/08/2003 mang ten Nguyen Thi Nghiem de thufing cho can bo cong nhan vien, Nhung Phieu chi nay khong dUdc dUa cho ba Nguyin Thi Nghiem (Tri/dng Phong To chiic - Bao vfi)
(Je chi thuflng cho can bp, cong nh§n vifin, ma h\ cao Huyen da lpi dung viec Thii quy true tifip giao tien cho minh de chiem doat la ngoai y mu6n cua fing Bi va fing Bi hoan toan khfing biet viec nay,
C6nsotien2,226,710.667diasotien thuflng con lai trong Quy khen thudng cua Cong ty dupc ban giao cho Tong Giam doc mfli khi ong Bi da nghi chu'c vu Tong Giam doc, Khi do bj cao Huyfin la ngufli trUc tiep thi/c hifin, nhung bj cao Huyen da thuc hifin khfing dung. Ngay 26/4/2005, bj cao Huyen chi dao BS phan K§ toan lap Phieu chi sfi 205/4 vfli so tien 2.226,710.667d mang ten Nguyen Thj Nghiem, Den ngay 28/10/2005, b! cao Huyfin rut so tifin 1.118.800.000d va ngay 24/11/2005 , bi cao Huyen lai ky vfli tu each Pho Tong Giam dfic, Thu truflng ddn vj de lay so tien l,210,800.000d va bj cao Huyen da ky nhan tai Thu quy ca 2 chiing tCltffin, Nhu vay, day hoan toan thupc trach nhiem cua So cuoi thang 10/2014 TAP C H l P H A P LY 2 3
_ BEN KHUNG CU'A TU PHAP
bj cao Huyen, nhung bupc tpi fing Bi la khong khach quan
KHdNG LAM OAN NGU'dl VO
TOITrong ddn giii den Tap chi Phap ly, ong Nguyfin Bi tha thiet de ngh| Chanh an TANDTC, Vifin truflng VKSNDTC khang nghi doi vfli ban an phiic tham so 267/2014/
HSPT ngay 19/5/2014 ciia Toa phiic tham TANDTC tai TR H6 Chi Mmh de giai quyet lai vu an theo thii tuc giam doc tham, de ong sflm duoc tuyen bo khfing pham tpi Co y lam trai quy dmh ve quan ly kmh te Ciia Nha nuflc gay hau qua nghifim trpng.
Niem tin c h k chin cfla ong dua vao hai diem, do la khoan tien 7,9 ty dong fing k^ cac quyet dinh khen thuflng do khfing phii ti^n cfla Nha nuflc va ngay tU ban an sd tham d i khang djnh hiu qua da dupc khac phuc hoan toan. Nhu vay nhan thu'e Clia ong Bi la ong khong c5 y lam trai va cung khfing co hau qua nghiem trong xay ra sau khi ky ba quyet dmh khen tfiuflng.
Khfing bo Ipt tpi pham va khong lam oan ngufli khong pham tfii la muc tieu cao nhat ciia cong cupc c i i cich tU phap hifin nay, nfin dfln khieu nai de ngh[ khang nghj Clia fing Nguyen Bi (k can dUflc quan tam, Hon nQa, nhUng ngufli theo doi vu an con biet ro fing Nguyen Bi l i ngufli co dflng gflp to Ifln trong qua trinh Ifln manh cua Cong ty Vifon noi neng v i cong nghiep che bien cua Vifit Nam noi chung trong may chuc nam qua.
Sinh ra tif vung d i t gian kho Quang Binh, nam 1974, sau khi hoc xong Dai hpc nganh cfl khi fl Tiep Khac, ong Bi v§ nuflc va dupc de bat lam Truflng nginh Cfl khf sfla chOa fl Nha may duflng 19/5 Sfln lay.
Nam 1986, fing dUflc difiu ve lam Giam doc Nhi may Bpt ngpt lan Binh (tien than Clia Vifon ngay nay), kifim Pho Tong Giam doc XNLH Bpt ngpt - Mi an lien. Nam 2003, ong la Tong Giam dfic kiem lufin VI tri Chu tjch Cong ty Co phan Vifon nhfl nhUng dong gop xuit sac cua ong
Tronggiai doan doi mfli dat nuflc, ong Bl manh dan lien doanh va nhap cong nghe nuflc ngoai, Diu tien, fing to chUc hen ket vfli Xi nghifip LUflng thuc Quin 5 TR Ho Chi Minh sin xuat mi an lifin, Tfl day mfli co mi Miliket, nguQn goc tii chii 2 4 TAP C H l P H A P LV SO cu6i thang 10/2014
Ong Nguyen Bl (thd hai tif trdi sang), dgi dien Vifon nhdn Huy chUang vdng "Doanh nghiip hoat dong kmh doanh xudt sdc dnUdc ngodi" do to chdc Foundation For Excellence In Business Practice (FEBP) Thuy SI trao tdng cho doanh nghiep VN duy nhdt, ndm 2001
mi "lien ket" ma ra. Mi Miliket sau khi ra dfll da thong trj thj truflng trong nuflc trong thfli gian dai, truflc khi co cac san pham ngoai nhap nhiing nam d i u the ki 21,
Sau do, fing lifin doanh vfli nhi^u ddn vj khac nhu vfli Cfing ty luong thyc H i Nfii, mfl rpng lien doanh ra Vmh. Roi lifin doanh Ajmomoto, Acecook (Nhat) hay Orsan lan luot ra dfll CO luc lUflng lao dpng Ifin den hang nghin ngufll
Giai doan tU khi fing ve tiep quan nam 1986 cho den nam 2000 dUflc danh gia la thfli ki rUc rfl nhat cua Vifon. Hoat dpng lien doanh l i sang kien tao bao va dem lai thanh cong Ifln cho mpt doanh nghifip nha nuflc dl dau nhU Vifon. Bfli y tuflng nay khong chi giiip Vifon ning cao cong nghfi san xuit (tU Nhat Ban), cho ra dfli nhieu loai san pham tifin tifin, ma con co tac dung huy dpng von ho trfl san xuat trong giai doan kinh te nuflc ntia con kho khan nhieu mat.
Tfl mpt XI nghiep nhfl chi cfl vfin 24 ti dong chuyfin san xuat axit, mi an lien va banh phfing tfim, fing Bi da cung vfli can bp, cong nhan vifin dua Vifon trfl thanh mpt flfln vi dan dau ca nuflc fl Unh vyc thuc pham an lien, Giai doan hoang kim, thj phan Vifon luon chiem khoang 60- 70% toan thi truflng.
Khong chi vay, sau khi thoai vfin fl cac lien doanh, Vifon cfln tao Ifli nhuan r i t Ifln cho nha nuflc, den 127 ti dong. Neu so vfli con so diu tu thi hieu qua thu ve kha
cao. Hai lien doanh Ajinomoto va Acecook VN ma Vifon tifin phong hflp tic, hien tai da trfl thanh doanh nghiep "khflng", hang nam dflng gop ngin sach tren 1,000 ti d^ng/doanh nghifip, vfli hfln 10.000 lao dpng l i m viec on djnh tai c i c n\\i may khip ca nuflc va tifiu thy mot sin lil^ng Ifln hang nfing s i n trong nUflc.
Nhung thinh cfing ^n tifdng nhat cila fing Bi la tao tieng vang trfin th^ gifli vfi s i n ph^m "Phfl an lien". Vifon da nh|p cong nghfi tii Trung Quoc mang ve sang tao thiet k^ cho hoan thien vfli gia thanh re va tiep tuc phat trien cho den ngiy hfim nay. Sau nhieu nam khong ngiing cSi ti^n, Vifon da dUa mon quoc hon quoc tHy ciia Viet Nam la Phfl Ipt vao danh sach top 10 giai thuflng thyc pham toan cau, Trong do, Phfl Vifon dflng hang 5 cua Giii thuflng Thuc pham Toan cau (Global Food Award). Cic thi truflng chau Au, DongAu, My deu co dau an cua Vifon hay noi each khac la cua Nguyen Bi. Vifon da trfl thanti thuflng hifiu Ifln dUdc nhieu khach hSng chl can nhin qua ho sd, gifli thieu da dii hang.
Vi the, Nha nuflc trao tang ong Nguyin Bi Huan chUflng Lao dpng hang 3 cflng nhieu bang khen cua Thfl tuflng Chinh phli.
Hien nay fing Nguyfin Bi dang dieu tri benh tim va nhieu bfinh tuoi gia trong khi khac khoai chfl dUflc minh oan.
