• Tidak ada hasil yang ditemukan

A sociological study investigating the interface between the governance of democracy and traditional leadership in rural development : a case study of Emaqadini tribal authority.

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2023

Membagikan "A sociological study investigating the interface between the governance of democracy and traditional leadership in rural development : a case study of Emaqadini tribal authority."

Copied!
120
0
0

Teks penuh

The main conclusion of the study relates to whether there is any role for traditional leadership in rural development in the new democratic dispensation. The study's recommendations focus on the link between government and traditional leaders in rural development.

Introduction

Now local authorities must ensure that all communities have access to basic services, that all can participate in decision-making and planning, that the local economy grows, that job opportunities increase and that local resources are used wisely to improve the quality of life for all, now and in the future. The White Paper, which deals with the relationship between local government and traditional leadership and not other aspects of traditional leadership.

Background to the present study

Sections of the traditional leadership (TLs), particularly in KwaZulu Natal, strongly opposed the redrawing of municipal boundaries and the establishment of primary municipalities in traditional authority (TA) areas. South Africa's policy towards rural development and rural poverty reduction has undergone a significant transformation between the first and second terms of the ANC-led government.

The field of study

This requires building the confidence, skills and assets and freedom in the people needed to achieve this goal.

Motivation for the investigation

During this part of the survey, 5 (10%) of the respondents answered much better, and 40 (80%) still answered the same, and the remaining 5 (10%) answered slightly worse. When asked about access to the police, two (4%) of the respondents answered that it is much better, and 40 (80%) of the respondents answered that it is still the same, and 5 (10%) of those.

Table one
Table one

Aims and objectives of the study

Literature review

This framework endeavors to create a provincial context to ensure the effective implementation of rural development and poverty alleviation. Ethekwini Municipality has established a Rural Development Framework that guides the future development of the recent significant expansion of the metro area and newly incorporated areas that are essentially rural and semi-rural.

Theoretical perspective

Development Plan (lOP) is a legal requirement under the Municipal System Act and it replaces all other municipal plans. The strategic nature of the IDP is such that it must result in facilitating political and constitutional changes to ensure that the principle of integration is not lost.

Study area

Research methodology

It will be necessary to communicate with many practitioners and advisors in the field of municipal governance and administration as well as with the general public to ascertain their views on the impact of changes that municipal government is experiencing on Rural Development. It will be a simple random survey where households will be selected based on probability.

Limitations

When asked about respondents with the highest educational qualifications, 10 (20%) had no education, 15 (30%) respondents had education up to standard 6 and a further 15 (30%) respondents had education between standard 6 and matric and 5 (10%) respondents had a matric. Under this section, 45 (90%) of the respondents responded for Metro Council, and the 3 (6%) respondents responded for the Provincial Government and the remaining 2 (6%) of the respondents responded for Traditional Leaders.

Definitions of concepts

Integrated Development Planning (lDP)

OJ. Isilo Samabandla (King)

Inkosi

Rural areas

Rural Development Framework

Semi Rural areas

Sustainable livelihood

Tribal Authority

Summary

The subject of the interface between the democratic government and traditional leadership in rural development in South Africa has wide potential for scholarly investigation. Moreover, rural residents were largely excluded from the administration and management of the land, which was rooted in the Tribal Authorities, dominated by hereditary traditional authorities.

The debate about democracy

Post colonial Africa

The role of traditional authorities in South Africa's democracy remains unresolved, and a key challenge in service delivery and rural development.

Common citizenship

According to Sklar (1994:2), the constitutional powers of traditional authorities in most African countries are currently severely limited, as is their role. In Botswana, traditional authorities perform government functions authorized by prescribed constitutional arrangements, while in Swaziland; traditional authorities are incorporated into the state's constitutional system.

The debate in South Africa

Ismail put forward a model that he sees as effective and realistic, and which would incorporate traditional authorities 'and aspects of indigenous governance into liberal democratic governance' (Ismail, 1999:2). Given the central role and dominance of the ANC during the negotiations and beyond, it is important to view the ANC's position vis-à-vis traditional authorities in historical perspective.

The ANC and traditional leadership in historical perspective

On Robben Island and Exile

The role of traditional authorities in the liberation struggle received renewed attention from the ANC and its alliance partner, the South African Communist Party (SACP) when traditional authorities such as Chief Mangosuthu Buthelezi accepted Tribal Authorities in the 1950s, and the debate continued after political organizations banned in 1960 (Mbeki: 1996). The exiled members forced Mbeki to make the following powerful observation: “It seems that the ANC leadership in exile seriously underestimated the capacity of government-founded institutions to fulfill their intended role.

The Congress of Traditional Leaders of South Africa

The creation of Contralesa was clearly motivated by the ANC's ambiguous and targeted policies towards traditional authorities. That it was the UDF that played a leading role can only testify to the ANC's influence.

The present co- existence approach

The chief's powers must always be exercised subject to the provisions of the constitution and other laws. In summary, the guidelines were clearly based on the notion of the coexistence of democratic and traditional authority structures.

The Constitutional negotiations

The ANC and the NP woo the Traditional Authorities

Under this section of the survey, 10 (20%) of the respondents responded much better, and 25 (50%) respondents still responded the same, and 10 (20%) responded slightly worse, and the remaining 5 (10%) respondents reacted much worse. In this section of the survey, 5 (10%) respondents responded slightly better, and 45 (90%) respondents responded much better.

Local Government and land reform

Government's position

Act on Municipal Structures (1998), Act on Municipal Divisions (1998), Act on Municipal Systems (2000) and Act on Municipal Financial Management (2000) form the basis for the future municipal system. Respondents were asked if they are aware of EThekwini Metropolitan Council (or Durban Metro).

Legislation and policy developmental local Government

Government's approach to rural development

The main aim and purpose of developing local government is the improvement of service delivery and poverty reduction. The success of developing local government to ensure sustainable livelihoods and poverty reduction is heavily dependent on local government as the main entity in rural development.

The challenges

Powers and functions

It is one thing to say that the 'values' associated with 'indigenous institutions' are included in the post-colonial democratization project, but another to say that the institution of traditional authority is the sole bearer of these values. It is one thing to say that the "values" associated with "indigenous institutions" are included in the project of postcolonial democratization, but another to say that the institution of traditional authority is the sole bearer of these values.

The theoretical origins of modernization theory

Max Weber

As suggested earlier, supporting evidence is always a matter of selection and so there have been those who have challenged Weber's particular selection of data and interpretation of the history of capitalism. In their different ways, Durkheim and Weber have provided many of the basic themes of today's modernization theory, especially their contrast between traditional and modern societies.

Tradition versus modernity

Summary

This chapter also tried to take the discussion further by giving Max Weber's approach to modern society and this included some views on Parson's approach which finally draws a clear distinction between traditional society and modern society. This gave a clear elaboration of why modern society is good for the development of rural areas.

Methods of data collection

This chapter focuses on the methodological procedures that will be used in the realization of this study. According to Bless and Smith in their argument about the accuracy and skills required in data collection for any research project, (Bless and Smith, 1995:99) reveals that "a research stands or falls on the quality of the facts on which it based ".

The questionnaires

The purpose of filling the questionnaires is to avoid mistakes as the age group will be between 20 and 70 years and above and most of the people from rural areas cannot read or write.

The interview schedule

In this study, the interview schedule, as pointed out at the beginning, is aimed at obtaining a profile of the leadership structure of these two communities. Also by using the interview schedule, the researcher will be able to discover the fundamental obstacles hindering the development in these communities with the unsettled position of the traditional leaders of rural development.

Summary

The results from the sample indicate that 5 (10%) of the respondents responded that Inkosi should be responsible for the allocation of housing. Under the general improvement of the situation, 10 (20%) respondents answered that it is a little better, and 30 (60%) of the respondents answered that it is much better, and 5 (10%) of the respondents answered that it is still the same and the remaining 5 (10%) respondents answered that it is slightly worse.

Background Infonnation

Race

The literature survey shows that in South Africa most rural areas are predominantly owned by blacks due to the bantustan apartheid government system that pushed blacks into rural areas. During colonial occupation in the 1800s, the African population was pushed, violently and not without resistance, into small areas of the country.

Highest educational qualifications

The infamous forced removals, especially from the 1960s onwards, aimed to move the entire African population, surplus to the needs of the white economy, into these areas. Although the apartheid state never quite succeeded in achieving this goal, it caused enormous unrest and disruption for many millions of people across the country.

First languages

Occupation

Five (10%) respondents felt that the female head of the house is responsible for selling the house. The analyzes of the above table on the issue of land allocation indicate that 5 (10%) responded that the Inkosi should be responsible and 10 (20%) responded that the Induna should be responsible for the allocation of land.

Table Six
Table Six

House hold average monthly income

Ownership of fields for cultivation

Regarding the ownership of fields for cultivation, the results from the sample show that 2 (4%) did not have a field and 40 (80%) respondents had a field on which they produce, while 8 (16%) respondents had more than one field. on which they grow.

Questions about land

  • How long they have been living in this land
  • How the land was obtained
  • The respondents' opinions as to who has the right to sell their houses or land or
  • The question on the responsibility for the allocation of

The other 35 (70%) answered that the local municipal council should be responsible for allocating land. The other 5 (10%) respondents revealed that Induna should be responsible for housing allocation.

Table Ten
Table Ten

Questions about local government

Most of the responses from the community members show that they have lived on these lands for a long time. On the question of the council members' reaction, there was apparently no clear understanding as they follow the guidelines of the Metro Council which is part of the national strategy on District Municipalities.

On the responsibility of certain functions

To ensure the provision of services to the communities

To promote social and economic development

To promote a safe and secure environment free of violence

Other important findings relate to the assessment of development in some important areas in these communities in the last five years or since they became part of the Metro Council. According to the findings and discussions in the literature, which reveal that South Africa still faces the problem of defining the role of traditional leaders in rural development in the context of local government development, much remains to be done.

To the provision ofthe assessment in the development of the following fields in

Access to schools

Access to clinics

Access to electricity

Access to jobs

Access to transport

Access to policing

How is their financial situation

How is their general situation

Interview schedule

The general situation about Councillorship

Intervention in administration

A councilor shall not, except in cases provided by law, interfere in the management or direction of any department of the municipal council, unless authorized by the council. A councilor may not use, take, acquire any property or assets owned, controlled or managed by the municipality to which that councilor has no right.

To the general questions as far as rural development is concerned

When asked what role amakhosi play or should play in local government, the councilor highlighted the current situation that they are working with amakhosi or inkosi in dealing with issues related to their community since the role and functions of amakhosi have not been clarified. The councilor also mentioned the construction of the municipality which is part of the Durban metro in the development of rural communities, the installation of electricity for all the families of his community, which is a great contribution to the development of rural areas.

Summary

In the next chapter, a general summary, conclusions and recommendations will be mainly based on the current chapter. The research objectives will be reformulated and the recommendations and conclusions will be based on objectives.

Major findings

On the literature

On the community members

Recommendations

With the municipal elections coming up next year and still facing this problem of defining the role of the institution of traditional leaders, from the results of the two communities where the survey was conducted, it is recommended that the government conduct a comprehensive survey to all traditional authorities to obtain people's views from the ground on the role of the institution of traditional leaders in rural development. As a final note, the presence of the institution of traditional leaders should not wipe out rural development, as most of these institutions are found in rural areas.

Summary

Isiko lokukhuluma: Isikhundla kanye nesithombe sabaholi bendabuko eNingizimu Afrika yangaleso sikhathi. Amaqembu ezepolitiki 2. Uhulumeni wesifundazwe 3. Izinhlangano zomphakathi 5. Uhulumeni wezwe 6.

Gambar

Table one
Table Six
Table Ten
Table Eleven
+2

Referensi

Dokumen terkait

Governance was described in this article as "the way authority is applied in the administration of a country's economic and social resources for development."5 “Governance is

Sample Flowchart Example 4C Start contd… Count = 0 Read input data Add marks of all subjects giving Total Percentage = Total/10 Write output data Flowchart for the solution of